Southeast Asian Crossbow of the Hmong

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 окт 2024
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 122

  • @HistoricalWeapons
    @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +20

    thanks for watching

    • @jburdine1956
      @jburdine1956 2 года назад

      I assume that the Hmong crossbow already sold?

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      @@jburdine1956 yes but montrgaard avail

  • @markdennis254
    @markdennis254 2 года назад +34

    Hmong needs their own country

    • @andkonblack
      @andkonblack 2 года назад +16

      its called St. Paul, Minnesota

    • @azuaraikrezeul1677
      @azuaraikrezeul1677 2 года назад +2

      They already have one called america.

    • @boygonewhoopdataZZ
      @boygonewhoopdataZZ 2 года назад +2

      @@andkonblack LOLOLOL. My wife is hmong and yea we go there every other year, same with Cali.

    • @fongxiong1929
      @fongxiong1929 2 года назад +1

      No. We don't.

    • @DUDEfreestyle
      @DUDEfreestyle Год назад +1

      @@fongxiong1929 yes you do it's called Laos and America. Hmongs are the 3rd largest population in Laos. It's the 21st century stop saying you don't have a country when in reality you do. That's a slap in the face to the Hmongs who fight for the American flag and the one who fought against communism in your homeland of Laos.

  • @andkonblack
    @andkonblack 2 года назад +14

    met a lot of hmong in minnesota

  • @Leverguns50
    @Leverguns50 2 года назад +19

    Very interesting thank you for sharing, I hope you get all moved OK

  • @sergeib8840
    @sergeib8840 2 года назад +24

    Vietnam jungle whispers intensify

  • @theghosthero6173
    @theghosthero6173 2 года назад +16

    Wasn't the 3 man crossbow also Hmong? Would love to see a reproduction, although it's probably a logistical nightmare

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +1

      Making something similar for Song Dynasty

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      yes that 3 man crossbow pic popular online is Hmong potrayed by Qing artists. not a logistical nightmare if used like artillery

  • @gunbuckybucketman4578
    @gunbuckybucketman4578 2 года назад +18

    Are these things good for squirrel?

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +6

      yes, as long as you have the right projectile heads.

    • @gunbuckybucketman4578
      @gunbuckybucketman4578 2 года назад

      @@HistoricalWeapons Thanks, they always drills holes on my roof, and kinda see these kind of crossbow selling on the internet.

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +1

      @@gunbuckybucketman4578 mine is for sale too. how much you want it for? i recommend a slingshot if you want something cheap and effective and quiet

    • @gunbuckybucketman4578
      @gunbuckybucketman4578 2 года назад

      @@HistoricalWeapons I wish I could buy from you, but I've no way to pay out side my country, so.

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      @@gunbuckybucketman4578 which

  • @langdavid6852
    @langdavid6852 2 года назад +23

    Notice he was very careful not to call these Chinese

    • @zhangtony3372
      @zhangtony3372 2 года назад +10

      CHINESE is NOT a race. same logic applied to american. Are Mohawk, Commanche, and Cree people American? same debate

    • @daedalus5253
      @daedalus5253 2 года назад +1

      Why?

    • @MrShiromochi
      @MrShiromochi 2 года назад +9

      @@zhangtony3372 The Hmong people living in China is happy to identify as Chinese because that's their nationality. Ethnically they are not Han Chinese, they are part of the Miao minority group in China. Outside of China they do not identify as Chinese, they are Hmong of whatever country they happen to live in. Hmong means free people.

    • @DUDEfreestyle
      @DUDEfreestyle Месяц назад +1

      nationality and ethnicity are different langdavid

  • @janneplanman6433
    @janneplanman6433 2 года назад +7

    I am a crossbow fanatic. I have done some monsterous steelbow crossbows, but these small, light and firm models you show here take me over thirty years back to my childhood, when I started with fiberglass and pinewood😊 Even then when I was like 12 years old I made crossbows that shot very well with their minimalistic qualities and light draw weight 💜🇫🇮

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +4

      awesome yes its not just about power. these small light crossbows are the result of the environment of the natives of the jungles of SE asia. if you have poison tipped bolts, all you need is something to deliver the poison

  • @congaudeant
    @congaudeant 2 года назад +12

    I've been looking for details about the Montagnard crossbow and it's mechanism so a video would be greatly appreciated

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +2

      Noted! ill see how the views are on these crossbows before making a decision on that. it seems most my viewers want bow videos, not crossbow videos

    • @dydactic1112
      @dydactic1112 2 года назад +1

      @@HistoricalWeapons Would love to see Asian crossbows other than modern or European types. Other channels got it covered already

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      @@dydactic1112 most of Tods crossbows are Renaissance + because steel nuts are not historical and steel prods are 1450s+. Only Andreas make historical medical crossbows that reflect their true power

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +2

      Made a video about it for u

  • @phawang37
    @phawang37 2 года назад +22

    Welcome to the rice fields

  • @420pump9
    @420pump9 2 года назад +20

    🔥🔥🔥

  • @krausearchery8749
    @krausearchery8749 2 года назад +7

    Well I'm surprised you used your own content.
    You pretty accurate on your information.
    I'll buy everything you got.

  • @oackman9250
    @oackman9250 2 года назад +15

    isnt this a chinese crossbow

  • @gn2650
    @gn2650 2 года назад +3

    I learn a lot in your channel, no just about bows, but also history, geography and anthropology 👍🏻

  • @kenvang9237
    @kenvang9237 2 года назад +4

    Nice to see my hmong, Miao, hmu, people’s crossbow being talked about!

  • @TORREX-A.D.
    @TORREX-A.D. 2 года назад +3

    The area in California that I live has a the largest hmong population in US next to Minneapolis. They still held their culture in the eighties but that's a dying thing they've pretty much mixed in with everybody else now.

  • @apozki9773
    @apozki9773 2 года назад +6

    hmong us!!?!?!?!?!??!?

  • @gerxiong4830
    @gerxiong4830 2 года назад +5

    Nice to see my Hmong culture crossbow being showcased

  • @RV_Chef_Life
    @RV_Chef_Life 2 года назад +2

    Would love to see a Montegard video. I just purchased one myself and will be making a hemp string and possibly arrows for it in the future

  • @foxmulder7616
    @foxmulder7616 2 года назад +10

    Yes please do a video on the montrgard 🏹

    • @ianuser9650
      @ianuser9650 2 года назад +6

      considering the lows views he gets on these i doubt it. people just want to see warbows from him.

    • @foxmulder7616
      @foxmulder7616 2 года назад

      @@ianuser9650 ha pretty much! This was an awesome video!!! Didn't know about the Hmong crossbow, grew up with allot of them they're nice people! As for the Chinese idk lol

    • @Not-Just-Cars
      @Not-Just-Cars 2 года назад +1

      @@foxmulder7616 hmong people and han chinese get along in north america

    • @Not-Just-Cars
      @Not-Just-Cars 2 года назад +2

      @@foxmulder7616we are all immigrants in foreign country and theres no need to bring past beef in new land

    • @phawang37
      @phawang37 2 года назад +2

      @@ianuser9650 yeah people complain he just does warbows...but he does a lot of history vids. obviously he is passionate about history but most of the views are warbows for some reason

  • @j-adore-le-classique
    @j-adore-le-classique 2 года назад +8

    really interresting nice!

  • @mangcha2254
    @mangcha2254 2 года назад +5

    Appreciate you sharing our culture and weaponry 🙏

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      your welcome! any information on yue crossbows or bows? im interested to make them

  • @woutvanostaden1299
    @woutvanostaden1299 2 года назад +3

    So on (partially) on your recommandation I bought a 85 pound bow from Alibow. I would really like to (find a way to) buy the Chu Ko Nu bow version that you have for sale, if I'm still on time. While trying to buy the bow however from alibow I ran into some problems (I can't have a credit card or Paypal due to private issues) and I would like to know if there might still other avenues of payment that you would accept?

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      hi the chukunu is sold. i still have the hmong crossbow and african crosbsow

  • @VictorJavannn
    @VictorJavannn 2 года назад +19

    They should introduce these in rs2

  • @少年阳光
    @少年阳光 2 года назад +10

    its a miao crossbow

    • @MrShiromochi
      @MrShiromochi 2 года назад +4

      Miao is the Chinese word for Hmong. The Miao minority subgroup contains Hmong, Hmu, Qo-Xiong and A-Hmao. Hmong means free people and its what they call themselves outside China. If they want to be identified as Hmong then let them. Just like Meiguo is the Chinese word for Americans. Nobody outside China refers to Americans by the Chinese word except Chinese people.

    • @bugger6881
      @bugger6881 2 года назад +1

      @@MrShiromochi right on

    • @TeaSerpent
      @TeaSerpent 2 года назад

      @@MrShiromochi It's way more complicated than that.
      Various Miao ethnic groups as well as other minority ethnic groups in southern and western China were major supporters of Communism and fed and sheltered soldiers during the long march.
      One of the first thing the communists did after taking over was to create a minority ethnic group congress and give them the choice of what names they wanted to be officially known by.
      A number of representatives of various ethnic groups, after discussing it with their people, decided that the names they were historically referred to by Han people were offensive and the government officially changed their names to the ones they wanted to be called.
      The Miao ethnic groups however decided they wanted to be officially known as "Miao".
      They did not find the name offensive, they thought it fit with their agricultural lifestyle, and moreover Hmu, A-Hmao, Xiong, etc. did not want to be called Hmong as they did not consider themselves to be Hmong people.
      The name Miao is thought to be derived from an early endonym of a Miao language speaking group. Although in the last 1000 years both the Han languages as well as the Miao languages have evolved.
      The catch is that at some point Hmong people outside of China started to view the name Miao as being derogatory.
      Which is why the Miao -Yao language family is now starting to be called the Hmong - Mien language family in the west, ie because of claims that using "Miao" is offensive to Hmong people.
      But again the problem is that outside of China it's mainly Hmong and Mong people, or other closely related groups in the western branch of the Miao language family, living in southeast Asia and the US and very few members of other Miao language family groups.
      The groups in China made the choice to be listed under the name Miao as they did not consider it offensive and did not want to be called Hmong in the same way that Puerto Ricans or Nicaraguans wouldn't like being called Mexicans despite them all being Hispanic peoples.
      So yes I call Hmong people Hmong, but I'm not going to call other Miao language family speaking groups as a whole "Hmong" because they collectively decided that they would rather be called Miao when being referred to as a general grouping.

  • @kasiamoua8767
    @kasiamoua8767 Год назад

    Thank you

  • @topcatandgang
    @topcatandgang Год назад

    we gave the chieftan of the Montagnards of Pleiku Vietnam a crossbow that was made at Springfield Arms Company of Massachusetts in order to get the tribe to join the Special Forces.

  • @gn2650
    @gn2650 2 года назад +1

    What would you say is the weight of those light arrows you should in the video?

  • @Go4Broke247
    @Go4Broke247 Год назад

    You can find videos of Hmong people hunting small mammals in the Jungle of SouthEast Asia. Interesting.

  • @legntt3488
    @legntt3488 2 года назад +1

    yes

  • @spudgn
    @spudgn 2 года назад

    Thanks. Was a good watch.

  • @mariojeromechavez6663
    @mariojeromechavez6663 Год назад

    The design of that crossbow is probably an eagle head.

  • @gn2650
    @gn2650 2 года назад +1

    What would you say is the poundage of that crossbow?

  • @randomguy-dy3uy
    @randomguy-dy3uy 2 года назад

    Id love a very detailed vidoe on that montagaard T trigger.

  • @scottvaj4434
    @scottvaj4434 2 года назад +2

    Nice video! Jack, are you Hmong?

  • @netyr4554
    @netyr4554 2 года назад

    Much appreciated for doing this video, these crossbows are very interesting but not much information in English.

  • @terryscott9459
    @terryscott9459 2 года назад

    Does anyone have some details of how the trigger mechanism worked on the montengard crossbows.i have an original one but the trigger was missing when I required some 45 yrs ago. I have seen some were there was a trigger that had a wooden pin that went through the body of the bow through the trigger and it just would pivot on the pin but mine does not have a cross hole for a pin to go through I would like to restore it to as close to original as I can.
    Any help is much appreciated

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      i made a video on the montegard crossbow check my most recent vids

  • @aoe2_elo037
    @aoe2_elo037 2 года назад

    thx

  • @niamtxiv
    @niamtxiv 2 года назад

    Good video

  • @bugger6881
    @bugger6881 2 года назад

    nice bwork

  • @Dnahwjjwjejnenex
    @Dnahwjjwjejnenex 2 года назад +11

    China is not in south east Asia

    • @markdennis254
      @markdennis254 2 года назад +6

      you just offended the entire Hmong community for mentioning the word China

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +6

      this specific crossbow was brought back in Thailand.

    • @scottvaj4434
      @scottvaj4434 2 года назад +2

      Southern Yunnan is pretty much SE Asia.

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад

      @@scottvaj4434 agreed

  • @elshebactm6769
    @elshebactm6769 2 года назад +2

    👍🏿🤠👍🏿

  • @dsasd778
    @dsasd778 2 года назад +3

    wheres ur rice hat

  • @fatboy8420
    @fatboy8420 2 года назад

    Nice

  • @dingdong4156
    @dingdong4156 2 года назад +4

    Eat more rice

    • @ianuser9650
      @ianuser9650 2 года назад +1

      Too much

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +5

      just casually scroling down the comments and the more bottom you get the more troll the comment is

  • @CrossTactics
    @CrossTactics 2 года назад

    If you live in South Africa, pick up one of these lethal, easy to use, fast and reliable Tactical Repeating Crossbows;
    ruclips.net/video/a_wGDu-uFpw/видео.html

    • @HistoricalWeapons
      @HistoricalWeapons  2 года назад +1

      i only do historical

    • @CrossTactics
      @CrossTactics 2 года назад

      @@HistoricalWeapons no problem, someone else will see the comment too