I don’t think they’re angry at him just because they’re projecting. They’re angry because he’s being rude. He’s overstepping boundaries and humiliating people in front of their friends. Like “hey everyone, Chandler has childhood trauma that has made him emotionally stunted.” Or the thing with Monica and the cookies? That’s so condescending. Just let her eat a cookie without it becoming some big comment on her psyche. Basically I think saying that they’re just mad at him because they’re projecting invalidates the legitimate anger they have at him for acting completely inappropriately.
Yeah like I feel like everything this guy does violetes several ethical codes. Like I'm pretty a psychiatrist should regulate what issues they open up so they have time to unpack everything with their patient and then repack before the end of the session. Not just open up major emotional issues and just leave to watch a movie. Also, what about this thing called informed consent. I'm training to become a personal trainer and if I want to train someone I have to have their informed consent on what that involves so my client knows what they're getting into. Here the guy just starts analysing people without their permission and then voicing his opinions out loud. Which is another thing, what's a patients right to privacy? I feel like if a genuine psychiatrist went around doing this stuff they could get in legitimate trouble. For similar reasons that doctors will get in trouble for providing unofficial diagnoses and treatment in their spare time.
Hes literally saying how the guy is basically lighting fire and walking away. He wasent helping them they werent angry at themselves and projecting there. Its all the things you said above i dont see how he didnt catch that.
*guy walks in a room, and completely unprompted, points out deep character and emotional flaw with everyone in there, gets them to open up about and be vulnerable, then leaves the room without offering them any kind of reassurance, compassion, or sympathy’ Same guy: they don’t like me, pfff whatever, clearly I did nothing wrong
Especially the former!! I mean his first divorce and his parents spoiling him senselessly really turned him into a neurotic, possessive man who cannot admit his mistakes, always thinking that he’s right! That’s why his relationship with Rachel didn’t work out!!
His points are valid, but he says those to appear smarter than them. He uses his knowledge to hurt and sneer, not to help them. They are angry because he mocks their insecurities.
I like how Phoebe later in the series jokes that she secretly manipulates the other characters. You kind of wonder whether she liked seeing all their reactions to the Doctor.
I don't think they're transferring their anger at all. They are a mess, but they had legitimate reasons to detest him. He comes into their circle, and as you pointed out, dropped mental health and emotional bombs. Even as a guest in their homes. Besides being a dick move, how can that be ethical?
There's always a chance that he himself suffers from a personality disorder or something of the like. Something that makes him tend to be blind to societal cues. It's not uncommon but also something you'd expect a doctor of his type would have some understanding of and hopefully at his age have strategies to help him pick up cues he may have missed. However like Dr Elliot said, he seems to enjoy pouring fuel on the flames and watching the explosion. Which would point to an entirely different area of mental health I guess.
Pickle Rick from Rick & Morty might be a good episode to react to. Also, Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas from Community. Or most Bojack episodes, really.
Came to your channel after watching the reaction to the Brooklyn99 episode. Your videos are really interesting and fun to watch! I would love to see more reaction videos
I would love if you’d do a video about personality disorders! They are so badly stigmatized and considered the “abusive person disorders” even though many of them can very in symptoms.
Great video. Somehow your channel was recommended by the RUclips algorithm. Glad that happened. Nice to meet you. I hope you keep making content like this. I am learning new things here while being entertained. Thank you. Take care!
This might be a US v. UK thing, but I'm a bit surprised that you didn't mention that Roger is essentially performing therapy on people who have not consented to it (or in the case of Ross and Rachel, who may have chosen to talk with him, they haven't done so with informed consent). In the US, that is a *MASSIVE* ethical violation of every professional ethics code out there (in Roger's case, likely either AMA or APA). He's also not done any proper intake, etc. (which, while not directly an ethical issue, could indirectly be since it leaves him unprepared to provide his highest standard of care, which *is* an ethical violation since it's not acting in the best interest of the client/patient). All those rules requiring therapeutic practice to be undertaken with informed consent, in a professional setting, and with professional boundaries in place exist specifically because the sort of 'off the cuff' analysis in the episode can be incredibly harmful (for any number of reasons - one clearly displayed in the episode being that the erstwhile client/patient is then left without the necessary support in follow up). It's obviously a sitcom, but his behavior is actually shockingly irresponsible.
It would be great to see you react to the 7x06 “Mystery vs. History” episode of How I Met Your Mother, where a therapist analyzes the main cast in a way somewhat reminiscent of this or the therapy episode of Its Always Sunny.
You should react to the psychiatrist boyfriend in "How I met your mother", I think he is nice one))) also its a good series and there is some interesting things about maturing, dealing with grief, finding your place in life.
I have always thought that the patient mentioned in the beginning was a reference to "The Man Who Mistook His Wife For a Hat" , which was popular just a few years before. Especially because it is phrased as the patient thinking that "things ARE other things" , rather than it being an OCD trigger of some sort.
8.31 It's the Dark Knight. Also a part of that is improvisation. There is apart when he walks away and the explosions stop and he turns around, shrugs and starts playing around with the button. That apparently it happened because there was a planned pause with the explosives that he did not seem to know about. Brilliant.
Another great video thank you. Also I haven't tried to clean the hook of your wall since I mentioned it :) If you can, have a look into Scrubs 'My Lunch'. I definitely believe it is a top 3 Scrubs episode. I always wondered how a Dr processes their mistakes and how others feel when someone you hold in high regard breaks a little. Edit (Sp)
I can see him as a therapist who can’t switch off but, particularly for the stage of the relationship he has with the bunch- think it, don’t say it! He’s so work focused he forgot his social skills
Great video, loved hearing about the early psychological history and theories! Is it a breach of confidentiality to talk about patients conditions if you don't give out any identifying personal information, like names, age, gender etc?
It can be. The rule all professions should stick to is that if the patient themselves heard it and recognised it as their story, then it's a breach of confidentiality. If in doubt, be cautious. Thanks for supporting the channel and really glad you liked the vid
1:50 that’s not necessarily true, since the fetuses brain starts to dream at around six months. And over time the baby starts laughing to form memories of the outside world and of their mother. Typically they form attachments to their mother’s heartbeat as it can be soothing when steady and their voice if they read and/or sing to them regularly. So they already have some form of emotional bind with their (birth) mother when they are born. So they know them more than just a pair of boobs that come and go Just take what I see with a grain of salt as I only get a little of bit of info from bits and pieces I’ve read. I am in no way an expert on any of this
One thing that always surprises me with scripted productions is the depth of knowledge that screenwriters seem to have across a seemingly never-ending variety of subjects which In this case is psychiatry. I am guessing that the treatment of the subject is cursory enough to not require the services of specialist consultant. What do you reckon? Have you ever thought of providing your services to a given industry as a specialist consult outside of the NHS?
Most TV shows will consult with people in the field on things like this. Medical dramas have resident doctors that help form the stories and scripts though that doesnt stop the tendency to embellish the truth (House would be a prime example of this)
@@DoctorElliottCarthy thanks doc. Would you ever considering becoming a consult and if so, what would be your favourite genre or media type and what would be your favourite production and why?
3:27 - I thought a breach of confidentiality happened when a patient's identity is revealed along with their medical history. Fisher Stevens didn't say anyone's name.
I just started watching his videos I feel like I watched a majority of them 🤗🤗🤗🤗 love the videos where he analyzes tv show/movies I watch or have watched all those tv shows
Год назад
Hahaha thanks for refering to us people as "nice things" :D
I like the content. Another nice Friend epizode for analyze would be S06E23 - "The One with the Ring" with my favourite quote from Rachel: "I cannot listen to any more of this. The only one who'd listen is a mental health professional. And that's only because they get $100 an hour."
I disagree with the "projection" analysis. Of course that can play a part, but if someone spoke to me about my problems like that it would make me extremely angry. Its belittling and minimises problems. I have a lot of trauma and if he spoke to me like that, I wouldn't feel angry at myself even subconsciously. It reminds me of Mrs. Hoffstater (idk spelling) from the big bang theory. She and Rodger know all the psychological backing but their relationships with others are not appropriate for the field. Love the video, just a difference of opinions❤️
Both are true. I think they definitely were upset because they were afraid of they’re feelings and the truth but i also think rodger was definitely wrong for talking to them like that in that setting, which mr reactor points out and recognizes too.
I remember watching this as a kid with some "curry" aunties and uncles as they call them and the bit where he says cups with nipples on them one of my aunties was like "oh my god, what bad language..." lol
crazy idea: maybe they are angry at him because... he is the fu*** worst. This character is what I call a glass-cannon: high offense, super delicate. I mean, he does make a ton of accurate but not-requested analysis in a very rude way. (with emphasis in NOT REQUESTED) And after that he gets aggressive with Phoebe at the end for a single comment about him. I actually know some glass-cannons in real life, and yes, they are generally the worst, people to avoid if possible.
At least in the US a psychiatrist can talk about cases as long as the patient remains confidential. Most psychiatrists in the US will barely even acknowledge one of their patients if they run into them somewhere to protect the patient’s ambiguity, unless the patient acknowledges the psychiatrist. But that’s true of most medical doctors, not just psychiatrists. A gynecologist can’t go around telling people that you have an STD.
I think they hate him because of the rudeness. I think they know that he was right to some extent but the condescending way he says it just comes out rude. That being said, what he said with Phoebe was spot on 😅
I hung out with someone who would just hate someone as soon as they see bad sides of them.He was a bed person himself and anything good was just an act
please react to the episode "stinson missile crisis" from How I Met Your Mother! in the episode, the character robin goes to therapy and it's a very new experience for her. the episode is mostly about relationship drama, but it was nice to see a therapist in a sitcom who wasn't portrayed as a creep.
i think they are mad because this guy is overstepping, it was one way to show a failed relationship from phoebe and this is why it didn't work out, like chandler doesn't need someone digging into his past sure he is right probably about everyone, but this should have gotten him fired tbh.
The thing I didn't get about Roj is he dating Phoebe and yet doesn't analyze her. Phoebe who has had a lot happen over her life and is estranged from her sister.
Ross and Monica were definitely screwed up by their parents, their dad seems sweet enough but the mom clearly screwed up Monica by making her feel like she was never good enough and they set up Ross for failure by treating him like the golden child who could do no wrong so he could not handle failure in adulthood. Then chandler had his parents divorce plus his father openly having sexual relationships with men while still married to his mother and then being a cross dresser and possibly trans in later episodes.
Chandler always has that thing , he's ducking over and over while he talks. ...I'm nearly as black out mode, took me allot to type in proper English. 😎
I really hated that guy in the show. They were just trying to chillout and have fun and instead the get psychoanalyzed. Why couldent that guy just mind his own business
There are a few more episodes that deal with mental illness in House MD which you should consider reacting to, Dr. Elliott. You should look them up if you are a fan of the series.
I get this is doctor reacts, but you gotta look at this not from a doctors perspective cause they didnt seek him out in professional setting, they’re in a cafe and their own home thinking they’re just gonna be hanging out with their friends new beau and suddenly he is drudging up issues they’ve managed in their own ways and than abandons them with no actual healthy coping mechanisms or even decent advice. “Dont eat your feelings Monica” yea like she hasnt already been told that by every bully in school. I think they truly do hate him and i believe they have every right to. He came in brought trauma to the surface, enjoyed the chaos he caused and left without actually helping them.
The boobies thing is funny because since this was season one the creators were still trying to decide if Chandler was going to turn out to be gay or not.
I loved friends as a kid lol and thought Roj was awful. I've always wanted to go to therapy but I'm not really sure how to go about it and I definitely can't afford private care. I have had full body chronic pain starting when I was 7 years old and have struggled with mental health issues relating to that since I was about 11. My GP basically just stuck me on sertraline which helps a bit but I still really struggle sometimes. Oh well I'll just have to cope.
Have you heard of the Curable app? My friend who has suffered with horrendous migraines for years uses the free version and says it has reduced her pain by 50% after using it for a month 🌻
Please react to exorcist. Plus I love your videos I have been watching them over and over again. You are one of the coolest psychiatrist I ever seen on youtube.
I think a really interesting film for Dr. Carthy to see and react to is "American Mary". A film about extreme body modification and objectification of women. I would call it stunning, as I was completely stunned multiple times during the movie. How far can revenge go? Pretty damn far.
I don’t think they’re angry at him just because they’re projecting. They’re angry because he’s being rude. He’s overstepping boundaries and humiliating people in front of their friends. Like “hey everyone, Chandler has childhood trauma that has made him emotionally stunted.” Or the thing with Monica and the cookies? That’s so condescending. Just let her eat a cookie without it becoming some big comment on her psyche. Basically I think saying that they’re just mad at him because they’re projecting invalidates the legitimate anger they have at him for acting completely inappropriately.
Yeah like I feel like everything this guy does violetes several ethical codes. Like I'm pretty a psychiatrist should regulate what issues they open up so they have time to unpack everything with their patient and then repack before the end of the session. Not just open up major emotional issues and just leave to watch a movie. Also, what about this thing called informed consent. I'm training to become a personal trainer and if I want to train someone I have to have their informed consent on what that involves so my client knows what they're getting into. Here the guy just starts analysing people without their permission and then voicing his opinions out loud. Which is another thing, what's a patients right to privacy?
I feel like if a genuine psychiatrist went around doing this stuff they could get in legitimate trouble. For similar reasons that doctors will get in trouble for providing unofficial diagnoses and treatment in their spare time.
Hes literally saying how the guy is basically lighting fire and walking away. He wasent helping them they werent angry at themselves and projecting there. Its all the things you said above i dont see how he didnt catch that.
yeah he is totally breaking all boundaries and anger is an reaction to that.
I think it’s both a combination of what you’re saying and what Elliott said!
*guy walks in a room, and completely unprompted, points out deep character and emotional flaw with everyone in there, gets them to open up about and be vulnerable, then leaves the room without offering them any kind of reassurance, compassion, or sympathy’
Same guy: they don’t like me, pfff whatever, clearly I did nothing wrong
My narcissism radar is beeping really loudly for this guy :')
I do strongly think that Ross and Monica are the main ones that need therapy.
Especially the former!! I mean his first divorce and his parents spoiling him senselessly really turned him into a neurotic, possessive man who cannot admit his mistakes, always thinking that he’s right! That’s why his relationship with Rachel didn’t work out!!
Yea but what about phoebe
@@InstruMentalbreakdown. Phoebe as well, considering the many traumatic situations she went through
omg, yes, but Chandler and then Phoebe need that a lot
I would say Chandler needs it the most!!
His points are valid, but he says those to appear smarter than them. He uses his knowledge to hurt and sneer, not to help them. They are angry because he mocks their insecurities.
No they're not. How can you know your wife the woman you sleep with is secretly a lesbian?
I hadn’t seen this episode in years! But everything Rog says about the group gets magnified throughout the series, especially in regards to Ross.
yes but its rude to break someone boundaries and trolling them with their trauma(
I like how Phoebe later in the series jokes that she secretly manipulates the other characters. You kind of wonder whether she liked seeing all their reactions to the Doctor.
Wait when does she say that?
@@desteny1393 In the hospital episodes, when Rachel gives birth.
@@desteny1393 she thinks of herself as the puppet master of the group
I don't think they're transferring their anger at all. They are a mess, but they had legitimate reasons to detest him. He comes into their circle, and as you pointed out, dropped mental health and emotional bombs. Even as a guest in their homes. Besides being a dick move, how can that be ethical?
There's always a chance that he himself suffers from a personality disorder or something of the like. Something that makes him tend to be blind to societal cues. It's not uncommon but also something you'd expect a doctor of his type would have some understanding of and hopefully at his age have strategies to help him pick up cues he may have missed.
However like Dr Elliot said, he seems to enjoy pouring fuel on the flames and watching the explosion. Which would point to an entirely different area of mental health I guess.
This is good 😀 . Would love to see the sandwich episode analysis.
*MY SANDWICH?!*
You mean the sandwich with the “moist maker”?
Lmao
The person who needs therapy the most is the boss who eats someone else's sandwich. Who does that?
Pickle Rick from Rick & Morty might be a good episode to react to. Also, Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas from Community. Or most Bojack episodes, really.
“Okay-rock, hard place, ME.” Is one of my favorite Chandler lines EVER 😂😂😂😂😂
Came to your channel after watching the reaction to the Brooklyn99 episode. Your videos are really interesting and fun to watch! I would love to see more reaction videos
I would love if you’d do a video about personality disorders! They are so badly stigmatized and considered the “abusive person disorders” even though many of them can very in symptoms.
Absolutely. I'm planning to do one on myths about borderline PD very soon
Great video. Somehow your channel was recommended by the RUclips algorithm. Glad that happened. Nice to meet you. I hope you keep making content like this. I am learning new things here while being entertained. Thank you. Take care!
There's some episodes of How I met your mother with a therapist. The first one is "The stinson missle crisis: S7E4
This might be a US v. UK thing, but I'm a bit surprised that you didn't mention that Roger is essentially performing therapy on people who have not consented to it (or in the case of Ross and Rachel, who may have chosen to talk with him, they haven't done so with informed consent). In the US, that is a *MASSIVE* ethical violation of every professional ethics code out there (in Roger's case, likely either AMA or APA). He's also not done any proper intake, etc. (which, while not directly an ethical issue, could indirectly be since it leaves him unprepared to provide his highest standard of care, which *is* an ethical violation since it's not acting in the best interest of the client/patient).
All those rules requiring therapeutic practice to be undertaken with informed consent, in a professional setting, and with professional boundaries in place exist specifically because the sort of 'off the cuff' analysis in the episode can be incredibly harmful (for any number of reasons - one clearly displayed in the episode being that the erstwhile client/patient is then left without the necessary support in follow up). It's obviously a sitcom, but his behavior is actually shockingly irresponsible.
Would love an episode on the Nanny especially the one about Grace and the imaginary friend. Or the ones where Fran go to therapy.
YEEESS!!! 👏👏👏👏🤩✨
This was so fun to watch. If you haven’t already, please react to the therapist from How I Met Your Mother
Dr Elliot, love the content. First time I’ve seen a video this early.
Also, are there any chances of doing more scrubs or BoJack episodes?
Absolutely. They're coming 😊
@@DoctorElliottCarthy another show that may be fun would be MASH. Some real horrors of war and had a very scrubs like feeling
@@johnmartin9846 yeessdd
Your voice and the way you speak feels like a hug somehow? Very sweet 💙
Such cute and relevant analysis (that cues into liking the "friends' archive" one has in her memory). Thanks for the insight and grounded comments. ♡
It would be great to see you react to the 7x06 “Mystery vs. History” episode of How I Met Your Mother, where a therapist analyzes the main cast in a way somewhat reminiscent of this or the therapy episode of Its Always Sunny.
I discover this channel only recently and I'm loving your content! You're such an interesting person !
Love from Italy ✨
Please react to a few clips from Frasier! I’d love an authentic lens on the show’s representation of psychiatry~
You should react to the psychiatrist boyfriend in "How I met your mother", I think he is nice one))) also its a good series and there is some interesting things about maturing, dealing with grief, finding your place in life.
I have always thought that the patient mentioned in the beginning was a reference to "The Man Who Mistook His Wife For a Hat" , which was popular just a few years before. Especially because it is phrased as the patient thinking that "things ARE other things" , rather than it being an OCD trigger of some sort.
I came down to the comments section to see if anyone else had said this-I thought the exact same thing.
Love the content. Have you thought of reacting to how PTSD is explored in the MCU?
Would love to see more reactions to friends!!
I love the analysis and commentary. Keep up the good work! :)
8.31 It's the Dark Knight. Also a part of that is improvisation. There is apart when he walks away and the explosions stop and he turns around, shrugs and starts playing around with the button. That apparently it happened because there was a planned pause with the explosives that he did not seem to know about. Brilliant.
The Gilmore Girls revival has some episodes with a (really awful) therapist. Might be interesting to see your analysis.
Another great video thank you. Also I haven't tried to clean the hook of your wall since I mentioned it :)
If you can, have a look into Scrubs 'My Lunch'. I definitely believe it is a top 3 Scrubs episode. I always wondered how a Dr processes their mistakes and how others feel when someone you hold in high regard breaks a little.
Edit (Sp)
I can see him as a therapist who can’t switch off but, particularly for the stage of the relationship he has with the bunch- think it, don’t say it! He’s so work focused he forgot his social skills
I enjoyed the video and also noticed the early psychoanalyst theories. Great explanation.
The psychoanalysis element was really interesting, but honestly I'd just watch you react to Friends 😅
I can't have empathy for people who hate friends. Such a nice, light tv show!
Great video, loved hearing about the early psychological history and theories! Is it a breach of confidentiality to talk about patients conditions if you don't give out any identifying personal information, like names, age, gender etc?
It can be. The rule all professions should stick to is that if the patient themselves heard it and recognised it as their story, then it's a breach of confidentiality. If in doubt, be cautious. Thanks for supporting the channel and really glad you liked the vid
1:50 that’s not necessarily true, since the fetuses brain starts to dream at around six months. And over time the baby starts laughing to form memories of the outside world and of their mother. Typically they form attachments to their mother’s heartbeat as it can be soothing when steady and their voice if they read and/or sing to them regularly.
So they already have some form of emotional bind with their (birth) mother when they are born. So they know them more than just a pair of boobs that come and go
Just take what I see with a grain of salt as I only get a little of bit of info from bits and pieces I’ve read. I am in no way an expert on any of this
I just started to study psychology and we are learning about Melanie Klein, omg I've never been able to already know what you are saying hahah
One thing that always surprises me with scripted productions is the depth of knowledge that screenwriters seem to have across a seemingly never-ending variety of subjects which In this case is psychiatry. I am guessing that the treatment of the subject is cursory enough to not require the services of specialist consultant. What do you reckon? Have you ever thought of providing your services to a given industry as a specialist consult outside of the NHS?
Most TV shows will consult with people in the field on things like this. Medical dramas have resident doctors that help form the stories and scripts though that doesnt stop the tendency to embellish the truth (House would be a prime example of this)
@@DoctorElliottCarthy thanks doc. Would you ever considering becoming a consult and if so, what would be your favourite genre or media type and what would be your favourite production and why?
Hmmm depends on the show. Maybe for a medical drama but not anything that fuels the harmful stereotypes that this channel aims to challenge
3:27 - I thought a breach of confidentiality happened when a patient's identity is revealed along with their medical history. Fisher Stevens didn't say anyone's name.
You should react to New Amsterdam. I love it and it's the only medical show I know of that has a physiatrist in the main cast
I would think most psychotherapists wouldn't WANT to analyze everyone. It's like you'd never get a break from your job. It would be exhausting.
I just started watching his videos I feel like I watched a majority of them 🤗🤗🤗🤗 love the videos where he analyzes tv show/movies I watch or have watched all those tv shows
Hahaha thanks for refering to us people as "nice things" :D
Thanks for reminding me how I cant stand comedy shows with laugh tracks
I like the content. Another nice Friend epizode for analyze would be S06E23 - "The One with the Ring"
with my favourite quote from Rachel: "I cannot listen to any more of this. The only one who'd listen is a mental health professional. And that's only because they get $100 an hour."
I disagree with the "projection" analysis. Of course that can play a part, but if someone spoke to me about my problems like that it would make me extremely angry. Its belittling and minimises problems. I have a lot of trauma and if he spoke to me like that, I wouldn't feel angry at myself even subconsciously. It reminds me of Mrs. Hoffstater (idk spelling) from the big bang theory. She and Rodger know all the psychological backing but their relationships with others are not appropriate for the field.
Love the video, just a difference of opinions❤️
Both are true. I think they definitely were upset because they were afraid of they’re feelings and the truth but i also think rodger was definitely wrong for talking to them like that in that setting, which mr reactor points out and recognizes too.
What the hell do you mean 25 years ago?? :Counts with fingers: Well, shoot me!
i’ve always been weirdly interested in analyzing the geller family dynamic
I remember watching this as a kid with some "curry" aunties and uncles as they call them and the bit where he says cups with nipples on them one of my aunties was like "oh my god, what bad language..." lol
crazy idea: maybe they are angry at him because... he is the fu*** worst.
This character is what I call a glass-cannon: high offense, super delicate.
I mean, he does make a ton of accurate but not-requested analysis in a very rude way. (with emphasis in NOT REQUESTED)
And after that he gets aggressive with Phoebe at the end for a single comment about him.
I actually know some glass-cannons in real life, and yes, they are generally the worst, people to avoid if possible.
Love (semi /s) that Friends just built a whole episode around outright stating the characters' motivations.
Has Dr Elliott Carthy reviewed the "Shutter Island" movie yet?
"Mum is just a pair of boobs" Well what if she doesn't HAVE any??
I had a feeling Rog was probably right about a lot of his analysis and that's why they got mad haha
Can you do a react to certain episodes of How I Met Your Mother, some of these episodes might be interesting for analizie.
At least in the US a psychiatrist can talk about cases as long as the patient remains confidential. Most psychiatrists in the US will barely even acknowledge one of their patients if they run into them somewhere to protect the patient’s ambiguity, unless the patient acknowledges the psychiatrist. But that’s true of most medical doctors, not just psychiatrists. A gynecologist can’t go around telling people that you have an STD.
I think they hate him because of the rudeness. I think they know that he was right to some extent but the condescending way he says it just comes out rude. That being said, what he said with Phoebe was spot on 😅
I have BPD so you saying about splitting was pretty relatable
I hung out with someone who would just hate someone as soon as they see bad sides of them.He was a bed person himself and anything good was just an act
Wasn’t Roger the bad guy on HACKERS?
This is the most 90’s thing in existence!
The term "shrink" is a term for a person working in the mental health professionals that is often intended to be rude...
i do think they were projecting a lot, but also they were just angry at how unprofessional and quite frankly douchey this guy was acting.
What he did should be classified as unethical. Dude caused more issues than he solved.
please react to the episode "stinson missile crisis" from How I Met Your Mother! in the episode, the character robin goes to therapy and it's a very new experience for her. the episode is mostly about relationship drama, but it was nice to see a therapist in a sitcom who wasn't portrayed as a creep.
This is good stuff....more friends and other shows too
i think they are mad because this guy is overstepping, it was one way to show a failed relationship from phoebe and this is why it didn't work out, like chandler doesn't need someone digging into his past sure he is right probably about everyone, but this should have gotten him fired tbh.
The thing I didn't get about Roj is he dating Phoebe and yet doesn't analyze her. Phoebe who has had a lot happen over her life and is estranged from her sister.
I guess he had so much restraint focused torwards not doing that, he couldn't bear not analyzing her friends.
do lucifer at therapy
Ross and Monica were definitely screwed up by their parents, their dad seems sweet enough but the mom clearly screwed up Monica by making her feel like she was never good enough and they set up Ross for failure by treating him like the golden child who could do no wrong so he could not handle failure in adulthood. Then chandler had his parents divorce plus his father openly having sexual relationships with men while still married to his mother and then being a cross dresser and possibly trans in later episodes.
l actually lie on a couch when seeing my psychologist. lt's relaxing and it turns less into a conversation because l can't see him.
Chandler always has that thing , he's ducking over and over while he talks.
...I'm nearly as black out mode, took me allot to type in proper English. 😎
Where is the episode w Ross’ sandwich???
I really hated that guy in the show. They were just trying to chillout and have fun and instead the get psychoanalyzed. Why couldent that guy just mind his own business
There are a few more episodes that deal with mental illness in House MD which you should consider reacting to, Dr. Elliott. You should look them up if you are a fan of the series.
I don't think they were projecting. He was being a jerk!
His voice is like Lee from Utopia (UK)
Can you do How i met your mother's episode where Robin's psycholog boyfriend analyzes their dysfunctional group dynamic?
Have you ever seen the Fawlty Towers "Psychiatrist" episode?
you should cover the similar how i met your mother episodes with robin's therapist love interest
I get this is doctor reacts, but you gotta look at this not from a doctors perspective cause they didnt seek him out in professional setting, they’re in a cafe and their own home thinking they’re just gonna be hanging out with their friends new beau and suddenly he is drudging up issues they’ve managed in their own ways and than abandons them with no actual healthy coping mechanisms or even decent advice. “Dont eat your feelings Monica” yea like she hasnt already been told that by every bully in school.
I think they truly do hate him and i believe they have every right to. He came in brought trauma to the surface, enjoyed the chaos he caused and left without actually helping them.
The boobies thing is funny because since this was season one the creators were still trying to decide if Chandler was going to turn out to be gay or not.
I loved friends as a kid lol and thought Roj was awful. I've always wanted to go to therapy but I'm not really sure how to go about it and I definitely can't afford private care. I have had full body chronic pain starting when I was 7 years old and have struggled with mental health issues relating to that since I was about 11. My GP basically just stuck me on sertraline which helps a bit but I still really struggle sometimes. Oh well I'll just have to cope.
Have you heard of the Curable app? My friend who has suffered with horrendous migraines for years uses the free version and says it has reduced her pain by 50% after using it for a month 🌻
Please react to exorcist. Plus I love your videos I have been watching them over and over again. You are one of the coolest psychiatrist I ever seen on youtube.
You should react to frasier and or cheers
I don’t know if it’s what you say or how you say it… but I definitely know that the sweater makes me trust you…
I wish you could be my therapist.
HEY Doctor or is that and honorary title lol. Try Fawlty Towers. "that's enough for and entire conference"
Love your videos! Can you do a video on schizophrenia please. Maybe some kind of reaction to a beautiful mind or something.
You should do the how I met your mother episode where robin dates a therapist
I dunno i think id be miffed as well. The point of friends is not to be picked apart and have your foibles shoved in your face🤷♀️
I guess analyzing a few episodes from " Mind Hunter'" could be a good idea but that would also be a bit uncomfortable to watch.
What do you make of Dexter?
React to Kevin the shrink in How I met your mother! He did break some rules.
please do the episode "the one where they're up all night". Does pheobe have schizophrenia or some delusions?
Probably not, a lot of lack of sleep can cause hallucinations
I think a really interesting film for Dr. Carthy to see and react to is "American Mary". A film about extreme body modification and objectification of women. I would call it stunning, as I was completely stunned multiple times during the movie. How far can revenge go? Pretty damn far.
What was that psychiatrist on???
Do the sandwich episode please
a psychiatry analysis of a comedy?... why?? why??'... this should title "how to wreck a comedy"
Hey, I think that guy also played a psychiatrist or psychologist on Frasier. He came over to test if Daphne had any sort of psychic abilities.