'TERRIFYING' | Ireland's 'censorship bill' will control what us BRITS say on social media
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- ‘This could actually be one of the furthest reaching censorial bills that we’ve ever seen in Western Europe’
Lois McClatchie, Free speech commentator and campaigner, warns of Ireland's 'hate speech' bill which could soon become law.
#gbnews #ireland #x #twitter #elonmusk #hatespeech #freespeech
Keep up to date with the latest news at www.gbnews.com
Join us today and unlock your members-only benefits: gbnews.com/support
Twitter: / gbnews
Facebook: / gbnewsonline
Download the GB News app! You can watch GB News on all of your favourite devices and keep up to date with the latest news, analysis, opinion and more.
www.gbnews.com...
"Hate speech," of course, means anything you say that the political elites don't want to hear.
Everything will be made about race, or some 'underprivileged type' so that you cannot say "This bill destroys us".
the road towards the end of freedom of speech the end of democracy
Looks like that's what d government wants total control
1984 is not a novel, it's a blueprint.
Fabian blueprint
I'm on chapter 4.
And Animal Farm
Make Orwell fiction again……
@@lindalaw5466 Sara Gonzales actually has a sweatshirt with those words on it.
These hate laws only ever go one way.
Exactly 💯
Taxed on your morals and beliefs now
Of course, they’re pulling that card on them to keep them all quiet.
Anti-white Anti-Jewish Anti-Democratic Anti-Cristian and most importantly without consent of Irish Public.
It will lead IMO to civil war in many countries.
Its quite astonishing how quickly Governments can pass this sort of bullcrap into law at a drop of a hat but other stuff to address real injustice takes years.
Yes funny is it not and always the case. Nothing to meet your needs but no problems for the ongoing progressive agenda.
It's because our governments hate us, and most of the time they spend their time pretending to be working hard while they are living it up with your tax money
People aren't good business, even though generally speaking, we put them there....at least that's what they tell us.
Disagree with me = HATE SPEECH
So shut up
This is 100% Orwellian. Someone should go around town in those vehicles with ad screens and just show quotes from George Orwell’s 1984 warning book.
the road towards the end of freedom of speech the end of democracy
You can be certain that censorship will be applied to whatever secular left wing wokes object to rather than what normal right thinking moral people consider hateful.
the wef are flooding europe with migrants and at the same time they are cutting the food supply?
the wef are flooding europe with migrants and at the same time they are cutting the food supply?
Yes.
The bill itself is hate speech.
Protection for undocumented
Free speech should never be curtailed…this is horrifying
It doesn't exist already certainly not on utube
It's more the reintroduction of Old school "Heresy", rebranded as "Hate Speech"!
A huge backwards step, nonetheless though.
It’s all BS.
@@MissSmith-od7yk so hello miss Smith ☺️What happened to Mr Smith
It's more like the reintroduction of Old school "Heresy", rebranded as "Hate Speech"!
A huge backwards step, nonetheless though.
It's literally just a - "Don't you dare disagree with the woke elites" bill.
That's what "hate speech" has always meant.
We know right away what is it all about. Protecting woke. Supressing common sense.
*Elitists. Let's not call them the "elite" anymore, because they are not a class above us, they are literally garbage people.
Just agree with the racist and sexist ones
This is what is meant by being forced to bow to the Image of the Beast in Rev 13, and to mark yourself as a worshipper of it, or else face exclusion from normal commerce.
I think the arrests shall be disproportionate. Indigenous Irish are concerned about the demographics of their country. Is this to keep the population quiet?
Are Unionists "indigenous Irish"?
Yes that’s exactly it ! To kept us quiet,but that won’t stop us from.
I had the same thought - they want to criminalize the backlash to the replacement plan they've put in motion.
It's so they can control all media. The national station of Ireland has been under state control for years now RTE and it only allows a certain pro government opinion. Same goes for Radio stations. Now they want full control of the Internet. They recently told all NGO's that if they don't protest in the interest of the government they will cut all their funding so that's their little cronies army of bullies like LGBT+. All under the guise of diversity.
The Leader himself is under investigation for campaign funding coming from Estate agencys, Travel agents and Pharma companys from the US. So thats completly iilegal. It also speaks for whats happening. Jam a shit load of people into Ireland and give contracts to American businesses for your own profit.
@@incurableromantic4006 What "replacement plan"?
Children telling on their parents?? that happened in the 1930s.... Germany...
Worse in the U.S.S.R. & China for decades.
This is the global future, WEF/UN global governance.
Yes, this shows what it will be like.
only if we allow it, the power has always and always will reside with us
Government is the last group of individuals you want in charge of determining what you can/cant say
Especially one run by schoolteachers.
Didn't the Tories bring in legislation, curtailing freedom of speech rights based on perceived acts of terrorism?... Where was GBNews, when UK government introduced their form of speech control?
This censorship bill has a purpose. This censorship bill is laying the ground work for Islamisation of the UK . The main point of this bill is to stop criticism or debate about Islam, the Quran, the Hadith's or of Muhammad. This law is the first step towards bringing in Sharia law.
This is the view of an insane person... I would have said 20 years ago.
@@charlytaylor1748 The lunatics have taken over the asylum now unfortunately.
i think it is even more insidious than that!, it will be ANYTHING the government wants to push!, covid mandates for example!
@@charlytaylor1748 Agreed. Islamic rules etc have no place in Europe.
You are aware that Ireland is not part of the UK.
Who decides what qualifies as hate speech????
Exactly, it will be whatever the government decide is hate Speech.
Whatever government is in power at the time. Shocking.
Those in power, of course.
@RonP1
Racist nutcase alert!
The entire language - with the exception of leftist clichés.
Saying ‘men in dresses should stay out of women’s spaces’ isn’t hate speech, it’s love and respect speech for women.
It depends:
1. What is meant by "men in dresses" ?
2. What are "woman's spaces" ?
3. How many "men in dresses" are actually invading "women's spaces", is this actually a problem or something made up or exaggerated due to hate....
@@MKR5210
1. A man is an adult human male, and a dress is an open-bottomed garment traditionally worn by women 👗
2. Women’s spaces are places designed for the sole purpose of women in order to keep men out, eg. changing rooms, certain crisis centres, toilets, prisons, etc.
3. Yes, it’s a problem, not only for women and girls who are made to feel threatened and uncomfortable by the presence of men in women-only spaces, but for the increasing number of attacks that have been carried out by men on women in such spaces, and if you don’t know what I’m talking about, do some research.
I hope this clarifies things for you.
@@MKR5210Karl stop playing with mummy’s lipstick.
@@MrMarmalizerThen it is only logical that women who pretend to be men need to use the female toilets provided, I hope the women using those facilities are comfortable with butch "women" on Testosterone coming into their spaces. Sex is binary after all.
@@MKR5210 everyone will be spending the rest of their lives in court with all this nonsense!
Freedom of speech is for everyone. Not just those we agree with.
The answer is mass resistance. Everyone posts the same banned speech across their socials at once and overloads the system.
Yep. If people really care then they need to mass non-comply. They can't arrest everyone.
Brilliant idea
Civil disobedience. We are legion😊
Pure Communism.
Don't even think communism tried this
Creeping in
It's Fascism were facing...Communism means everything is state owned eg North Korea...Fascism means the government and big corporations are colluding together to rule citizens eg the rest of the world...there 's the difference mate!!!
They did but its not just communism its dictatoriship too@brianlaudrupchannel
The problem with this so called 'Hate Speech' is that ANY remark is classed as such.
guilty until proven innocent
Whatever happened to 'sticks and stones'?!
You still get them
out of the window if I not I personally FEEL offended and I report you you must PROVE that that was not your intention or get arrested it seems
Welcome back to the stazi. It looks like people will never learn from history.
Ireland already had a law that allows Islamists to not push any tax. All new houses behind purchased only by Muslims in Ireland and dare anyone speak out.
agreed..it seems people are enjoying their new 'brownshirt' status mate!!!
@@petercrane2560 look into Irish history and brown shirts and you'll learn they never went away!
indeed
They call Putin all sorts and then act just like him
Worse than Putin. Putin in general has the support of his people. The Irish people didn't vote for this.
Ohhh much worse than putin
@@docsavage8640correct putins a patriot and a moderate
I agree ,
At least Putin is trying to wipe out his own people and culture.
Hamza Yusuf in Scotland, when “Justice” minister there, wanted to criminalise certain speech IN PEOPLE’S HOMES!!!!! Legally, even if you were talking to yourself, Yusuk would come round and throw you into prison.
And when will everyone be required to have an "alexi"or "Seri" in your home to listen and report on every word you say.
They won’t control me. I’d get their leader out if I was the Irish voters.
No point, that leader will just be replaced with another of the same ilk, the days of thinking voting will change anything are long gone !
Varadker was never elected by the Irish people. He was selected. The majority of the political parties in Ireland 🇮🇪 are corrupt to the core.
I wonder if white people and biological women will be protected by this law
Doubt it VERY much
Poor white people go through so much persecution
Only "white men" are a "non protected class" under the Equality Act 2020.
👍
No they hate us
So sorry that Ireland is going this direction.😢
It hasn’t been passed yet and I can’t see us taking it lying down.
What utter BS!
👍💯
Is it?
Well if you live in Ireland or especially Scotland, I suggest you throw your Alexa or similar device in the bin. Or indeed any technology that can spy on you
@@alexedwards6509But but but alexa only starts to listen when you say it's name... right? Right? 😂😉
@@ScarsNotFresh Alexa is very sinister, I think it will used to arrest people in the future for speech made in the home, etc.
This has Blair’s influence written all over it.
I can’t express how important it is
@phillipcarter8045 - to himself, yes.
Absolutely, 👍👍👍
Talk about hate speech, i hate that war mongering bastard,
the devils child
We must leave the EU in my opinion 🇮🇪
Amen!
Yep i agree but remember ireland rejecting the lisbon treaty the EU said nope vote again its a cult
That won't make a difference. The bill needs to be scrapped completely.
@@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559 your name explains your response. Your NOT Irish!
we all also need to stop voting for Useless idiots that fill politics on all sides of the aisle
I very strongly suggest that the way to deal with this is with more speech, this is a time when we must peacefully but clearly disobey. We did not vote for this and we do not want or need this.
As long as people speak in truth then if offence is taken so be it, the taker made that choice, all the speaker did was speak the truth. Fight back with our free speech.
indeed
"X is headquartered in Ireland" - well that can be fixed right away if Elon moves that HQ out of Ireland
The problem there is that Corporation Tax in Ireland is 12.6% as opposed to 21% in USA, which is why Apple, Google, X, etc moved there - they save $billions annually.
Ah, now you support cancel culture!
@@barriejackson3294 and I might be out of date or downright wrong, but I believe UK is 25% 😮
@@noelpucarua2843 That's "moving culture", not cancel culture?!
@@noelpucarua2843 Yes I am in favour of cancelling people who want to put me in prison for not agreeing with them. In the same way that I am OK with people using force to defend themselves when attacked.
Clear enough?
How terrifying that us humans have such a short memory span!
Some humans I can't believe this is happening in my country Ireland. It's like we've been infiltrated in our government by mindless idiots.
Labour plan the same Hate bill in the UK 😮
Ever wef/woke colony will have it.
Be careful who you vote for.
Canada has the bill. Us is just ushering in the "restrict act". It's global. Well, at least in the west, the rest already had no free speech - which only underlines the importance of it. Free speech is the foundation of western civilization. And no, it has nothing to do with voting. They control the world, how dumb you need to be to think they would allow you to vote them out...
There is going to be a lot of Irish in Jail because if this goes through we will not abide with it.
There won't be any room 😅
You are delusional.
Complaining or criticizing these ‘hate speech’ laws will be defined itself as hate speech
George Orwell was not just a writer he was a prophet!
So was Enoch Powell.
indeed
Wake up 🌎
This is no game.
Fascism is here,this only ends 1 way.
@RonP1 how many wars are there going to be we’re in world war three now I hope we don’t have eleven wars
@RonP1you are an idiot if you truly believe that
@RonP1World War 3 comes first, even I know that.
Apologising on twitter for fifteen days is like writing lines at school! Wow just wow!
I continue to advocate and agree with free speech in Scotland despite my MSP dismissing me as she does not agree with me but I continue to be free!
Yes who decides what's hate speech. Free speech should always be respected .Leo Vardetc you have no right to impose your will on the people who benefits from this governments and those who think they know better, Be careful what you wish for Varderak.Remember Nicola Sturgeon thought she was infallible .
If she's an SNP MP, she may not be free for long!
Lock 'em up!
It's more and more steps to quietly quiet people and more control. It'll be put up and shut up or you're going to jail.
we must resist this and use political power to do this
Does this include the disgusting behavior of Irelands womens basketball team. A despicable display of ignorance and hatred.
I’m a Christian and I’m not going to stop denouncing sin!
like pslm
If you can be arrested for tweeting a bible verse, it’s only a matter of time they make the bible a hate book.
Nor should you have to. Of course the increasing censorship is happening in part because of your idiotic views and if you wanted to actually make a difference you would be better off keeping your mouth shut.
sin is man made , rightfully or wrongfully even when you believe in god , facetious you may offend an atheist the left know the answer call it hate speech
So basically, if you do not believe in their woke views, you will be punished?
It is not hateful to censor a persons freedom of speech?
You've just said it. No such as hate speech only speech you hate !
So any criticism would be classed as hate speech then
I cannot believe what I am listening to. For your own safety - avoid all public interactions.
SAY WHAT YOU WANT, WHEN YOU WANT
Quadri case is unbelievable. Like being back at school, made to "copy lines". Orwell was so, so right.
I just looked this case up. So he was trying to speak up for women because a man pretending to be a woman was claiming a woman's space. And he was convicted of violence against women because he made a man pretending to be a woman mad. Well now I'm just confused. No actual women were offended just a man with delusions.
It's time this country started getting rid of this distressing movement the government are a joke
Of course what Is "hate speech" is not defined. That's the essence of the (Orwellian) game: introduce a law nobody can be against, don't define (clearly) the subject of the law, than use it at will. You see it in every wef/woke colony.
Its basically 'wrong think'
well said
We MUST bring these politicians to justice ⚖️
When God is pushed out, EVIL is forced in😒
Vote Reform
Bet this Doesn't apply to the Free plastikote lot, to those waving an Irish or British flags 😊
Síol na hÉireann - Niall McConnell - show support. It’s all happening over there as well.
Such a caring man
@phillipcarter8045 That he is. We all need more like him, and so could the rest of Europe.
We all know the real reason for these laws is to eventually stop any criticism of political masters. It's just the thin edge of the wedge.
If I was a politician in Ireland I would not vote for this. I would not feel safe after doing so. People in Ireland are very angry right now for numerous reasons. Two thirds have said in surveys they do not want this.
I can’t believe there’s a third who are ok with it
@@mogznwaz Muppets
From an Irishman, the Irish government has gone insane!
Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Article 19
"Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers."
So, anything that censors beyond threats or inciting violence towards others, is breaking the law.
indeed, then again saying everything for germany by some AFD person is not hate speech it may be at most an unfortunate choice of words but comparing everything to the past and not be allowed to say things apart from inciting or threats should be allowed and think of Nigel Farage expected to leave an EU building for having an opinion , I mean how is Nigel Farage far right , I don't think he is a nazi
Just because you hate what someone says doesn't make it hate speech..
I wonder if that would apply to …”from the river to the sea..Pale.stine will be free”, since that is basically calling for the extermination of a people group.
Automatic free pass right there
Hate speech will not be applied to islamists who are above the law during the last 16 years.
Allah, the best deceiver Quran 3:54 . JESUS is God. Islam = submit no free will. That means everyone but Muslims they would kill kill after the Jews. "Fight those who won't believe in Allah" kill non believers " =Islam. GLOBALISTS Government goes along with a.i artificial intelligence. Cashless society
They will allow all the hate speech that is currently useful for their plans. Islamists are just pawns in the game too.
Next time they might support hate speech directed at someone else. You just never know with these puppetmasters.
Um, no. That phrase does no such thing. Nice try though.
Hate is an emotion, and therefore cannot be measured. We simply can't have laws based on feelings, it's ridiculous.
i HATE liver is that 5 years in prison?
Yes I love liver. Orf wiv yer ead
That's liverism you liverist 😂😂
I hate peas. I won’t give peas a chance. That’s gotta be worth 10 years in the woke re-education gulags
6 years and you have to eat warm raw liver every hour...
maybe if you would say like a Nigel Farage that multiculturalism has failed
I hate cancel-culture and everyone who backs it.
Shall I turn myself in?
P. S. I hate the Irish and Scottish governments just as much.
Protected characteristics - Have them, and you get power over those who don't.
Dan Wootton was the presenter that showed everyone the snp for what they really are and I believe he was right when he said that they are finished.
And what did he do to get ditched?
@@rockerjim8045 Tell the truth .
People invariably claim to hate these laws, and then they vote again and again for the same politicians who put these laws into place.
don't vote for the left
It's not just happening in Europe this is happening in Australia. Queensland has the exact same hate speech laws, the amendment was passed last year and was given royal assent although there still isn't a proclamation date. I have written to the Attorney General asking questions providing details of what our group of GC campaigners are doing and the Government refuses to respond. They refuse to even speak to me by phone when following up on when my correspondence from 26 October will be responded to.
Ireland, you got what you voted for!
Irish people didn't vote for Varadker. He was selected. The majority of the political parties in Ireland 🇮🇪 are corrupt to the core.
They sure did, it's going to be rolled out everywhere and the public will back it
I didn't vote for them
No one voted for them! They got in by default because sinn féin couldn't get anyone to form a party with them, do your fuukin homework!!
@@patti4785SF voted for approval of this bill on April 26th last year, so it’s a good job they weren’t in power then. They oppose it now though, which is good, but only after a lengthy and cynical climb down.
we are walking blindly into fascism
They are signing their own death sentence
Orwell warned us.
Already has. The censorship on this site is dystopian
Screw them. KEEP CALM AND CARRY ON REGARDLESS FOLKS. YOU GREAT BRITISH PEOPLE.
It's unnerving that people implementing this can't see themselves for what they are. Genuinely evil people.
We'll just have to get old school and send each other letters, meet in pubs, and build up resistance that way. Slow by modern standards, but does the trick...
Exactly as they say there is more than one way to skin a cat.
Under the Irish bill, people can be imprisoned for things they say in their own homes.
@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559
Kim Jong-un would be impressed
@@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559 really that is f**** insane the irish need reyot
It will only control what people say if people are afraid of the potential consequences. Personally I'd face charges rather than being told what I can or cannot say - of course everyone will make their own decisions about that. 'X' and Meta are not the only social media channels - shop around.
Who determined what hate speech is because what might offend one person might not and usually doesn't offend other people.
So who are they to say what people can and cannot say.
the left wing political elite , they show their true colours , don't vote for the left , they seem mild communists,
every person, every group, every religion has the right to be offended, we need to get rid of any 'hate laws'.
If someone murders someone because they are gay, is it worse than if they got murdered for their trainers. They are still dead
They haven't the guts to say what it is. CENSORSHIP CENSORSHIP. The text in all of this was drafted in Brussels
Hate speech laws are not necessary. There are already laws designed to protect people against harassment, intimidation and assault.
This opens the potential for one off mass arrests to frighten both the arrested and public at large.
It will chill conversations on whatever the government says that you should not dislike. It'll get mixed in with climate change, what foods you might be against. I'm not been hyperbolic here, but without an actual definition of hate, it's potential for absurdity is endless.
You can't enforce how someone feels.
The state will tell you what you can and can’t say. What could go wrong?
the end of freedom of speech and democracy
This is what we Ulster Unionists are walking into if we don't get our act together. I would urge nationalists to be wary of voting due to a hatred of Britishness.
Its a nut house. An absolute nut house.
This is hate speech
We need to push the boundary's on this new moronic ruling . If enough people ignored it then it would not be a viable rule. I say rule not law because this is lawless and undemocratic
indeed
i can't see Musk keeping his European HQ in Ireland much longer if this goes through
This bill is illegal from an internation human rights position. It's a fascist law that should be opposed in the courts.
Hey, it started ages ago. We all know, we only get called out, if we don't say the things the people in charge don't agree with. I don't have long to go, and I can't tell you how GLAD I am. Good luck people to Communism in every country now.
How many Irish citizens have actually asked for this law. Were there organized groups putting pressure on the govenment? Or this just a question of authoritarian rulers thinking they know best
Does this include white Christians as we are most hated but other groups feel its their right to insult us eg, white supremacy, white privileged, colonial, etc
Whats the difference between Dublins bill and the UK 'online 'safety' bill' ?
So, exactly WHO defines what constitutes "Hate Speech"? If you ask a dozen people what they'd consider a hateful statement, you'd get a dozen different answers. Anything that anyone doesn't agree with could be considered "Hate". It all depends on your viewpoint and the context in which it was said. For example, who except a rabid trans activist would consider the statement "Only biological Women have XX chromosomes" in any way "Hate"? That is NOT "Hate Speech", it is a biological fact, yet the more unhinged trans activists would label it thus. Passing Laws like this is a slippery slope into Fascism, make no mistake. Freedom of Speech is a basic human right and should be protected at all costs.🏴😎🏴
Its the Non crime ,Hate crime naughty list for you .
@@bigted1347 I've been on that list for awhile.😁
As someone who lives in Dublin I hope Elon Musk threatens our government to move his business out of Ireland if this continues.
Probably never meant to have conceptual clarity. All the more power for people that weald it.
She says, "Write to your leaders ?"
Who the hell you think is behind this in the first place ?
All those that have been bought off or on the wagon in favor of these policies to begin with.
What's needed is a show of force & mass protests at all the locations to where they are -For starters.
The head of the Irish online media regulator is Jeremy Godfrey, a Brit; the head of the Irish national TV is a Brit; the head of the Irish police is a Northern Irish Brit; the head of the Irish Refugee Council is a Brit. Ireland is West Britain, and England is Little India
Those that want the silence of their ideological opponents, will do anything and everything to stop them being challenged or debated.
well said