The only time a person will enter hellfire forever is when he or she die in the state of shirk but if you ask Allah for forgiveness before you die he will forgive you indeed Allah is the most merciful and the most forgiving
That is fair because Allah has created everything in balance and humans have two choices to believe or disbelief but whoever believes in Allah and worship him alone will have great rewards and whoever disbelief in Allah he will have hell
@@turboturbo780 you know what’s unfair ? That you disbelievers want to live this life exactly as you wish, full pleasure, no restriction AND call God unjust when he says he will punish you. You guys are unfair, not God. What is unfair is you want full pleasure and no hardship or worship in this life AND enjoy all the next life … God just proves he is just.
Didnt Ask you nothing never said god is unjust you need to see differences never he is that just hes decisions is unjust not the same and never claimed i know whats unfair dont put words in my mouth
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
@@williampz244 Yes, hellfire is not eternal if someone preserves faith in Almighty Allah and in the last Prophet Muhammad (S.) as Allah's Messenger which is minimum! Because of the wrong deeds that are forbidden by Islam which were done by him, he'll enter into hellfire but because of beliefs in Almighty Allah and Allah's Messenger he'll be brought back to Jannah for his beliefs, Inn Sh'a Allah.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.105/ 106/ 107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. The verse 40 (Al-araf) and also When it says that Allah has forbidden paradise to the associates speaks of the day of judgment where Allah will never let the infidels enter paradise, but after having suffered centuries in hell they will come out. the verse where Allah says that they will not come out of the fire it is only for one day (1000 years) as in the verse V.35 (Al-Jaathiya) and he says "kharijina" not "yukhraju" which is not the same thing. "yukhraju" means that they will never go out and this is said only for those in heaven. V.68 (At-tawba) "permanent" means that it will be continuous without pause, not eternal God wrote in a book that mercy precedes my anger
Jahannam is eternal for disbelievers Surah Baqarah 2/81, . Surah A’raf 7/36, Surah Jinn 72/23 all those verses say hellfire is eternal for nonbelievers. The prophet(SAW) was talking about the last muslim to enter jannah from Jahannam, but the disbelievers would eternal live in hellfire.
@@warkaahmed8035 Yes but there is exception in v128 to 130 (an naam) and v.103 to 10u (Hud), v35 (al jathiya) and the prophet Mohammed talked about the last men who left hellfire and go in paradise
@Mohammed-ks9wf the person dies I the state of shirk will go to hell or the person who has committed major crimes e g murder theft and he had not ask forgiveness will go to hell and the person who commits suicide
@@kowtobtwBut wouldn't those be technically considered as temporarily in Hellfire, and then after serving a certain amount of time there, they can then enter Paradise?
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
I my opinion my answer is If a person in hell Asked same que to Allah the answer will be that if Allah again send back in to the world by erasing the memory again he will do Shirk If he would live for eternity still he'll do Shrik so the punishment of eternal life is totally logical ! It's just my opinion !
But how about those kafirs who reject islam simply because they're not convinced enough to embrace islam? They worship the wrong God because they don't know the truth, not because they want to. Will it be fair if they remain in hell forever?
Assalaamualykum my dear brothers and sisters, we find this question in Quran (2_80)(They say, ‘The Fire will only touch us for a few days.’ Say to them, ‘Have you received a promise from God- for God never breaks His promise- or are you saying things about Him of which you have no real knowledge?’ ), and answer is given in next verse(2_81)(Truly those who do evil and are surrounded by their sins will be the inhabitants of the Fire, there to remain), It depends on what sin's we earn. If we get context of these verses, it will be helpful, may God save us from hell and sin's which leads to hell aameean.
The Supreme God does not care whether the person is a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, Sikh, Parsi, etc. What matters to the Supreme God most is devotion in whichever path one chooses in the pursuit of the Supreme God and how the person has led a life of piety along with carrying out his/her obligatory duties like treating his/her old parents/grandparents well, not cheating & hurting anyone, helping people in times of need, etc. Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, etc are just different paths which lead to the Supreme God. One can follow any path according to one's nature. There is no True Path or False path. Jai Shri Krishna
Islam, Christendom are a shame for teaching non truths about God’s greatest attribute of love. A “hell-fire” is incompatible with such godly attribute.
Absolutely. If any God says that he will give special treatment to persons of only a certain religion and put others into hell fire then he cannot be a God, forget being a true god.
@@AbdulRehman-j6q9h No Dr Shabbir Ali Says Hell is not forever of all, including non Muslims. Because all Humans is a Creation of Allah/God.and God is not slaughter who punished his creations for eternity.He is most merciful/ Rahman Al Rahim. Hell maybe long duration for non believers but not forever. If Allah punished Non believers for eternity than why he is called Al Rahman Al Rahim.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
@@AbdulRehman-j6q9h Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
No one is free my friend if they do unjust you cant be behind prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) in the Qur'an allah says you are a messenger and a human and you are not responsible about the deeds of the people it is upon oneself that decide the either paths of eternal life i.e heaven/hell even if you are the prophets wife you cant be forgiven by the relationship it is the deeds which defines you destiny but in Christianity alll are forgiven if you just love jesus but cant able to follow the path of Jesus (peace and blessings upon him)
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
I am surprised that Dr Naik can give such an illogical answer, he gave all examples that does not match with the qualities of our Creator Allah. Allah is full of mercy and His mercy encompasses everything including those people who even failed to recognise Him. Hell is a temporary place for correction and purification after which all human being will be with their Creator and there will be no hell.
This is your opinion and your opinion only brother. In the Quran, Allah mentiones 3 times, “they will abide therein forever.” In all cases he refers to people that comitted shirk and were disbelievers. Of course, the punishment will vary but only sinful muslims that, believed in Allah, but weren’t the best muslims, only they get to be taken out of hell after a period of time when Allah wills!
@@edisluka5053 my opinion is based on the clear guidance of the holy Quran, this forever mean as long as the hell exist, after it will be shut, there will be none there, it will be empty. Nowhere in the holy Quran, it was mentioned that none will be expelled from hell but for jannah it was mentioned that none will be expelled from there.
How can you say that hell will be finished khallas in sometime majority of muslim ummah. Is satisfied in the eternal hell punishment and we can't comprehend the intellect and knowledge of allah swt he created the hell eternal for a reason he created us and he has every right to punish us eternally may allah gives hidayat and distance us from hell as long as the whole universe ameen @@mdsaifurrahman9462
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
@@TarMezoIf a messenger was sent in native America then why are their traditions so different than Arab Muslims? Not even a single niche of them have similar traditions as Islam. Can you blame the whole population for it, or would you blame that messenger who was unable to send the right message to them ?
@@nikhilsaharanAllah says he will only punish those who heard about the Truth and rejected it the one who doesn't get the message will not be punished and also some scholars says if a person Heard about Islam in a wrong way he would not goto hell hope that answers your question and Allah knows best my brother ❤
Quran says that all his deeds will be void if he does not believe in allah and allah will punish him very severely, and that such people are worst of human beings (doesnt matter what their deeds were). So for allah it matters more that you believe in him rather than doing good things. Seems like he is so insecure
For example I say u have a friend he/she helps u to read, guides u and helps u to do homework but even after he/she does so much to u, u just go to other friends and completely ignore that helping friend and saying to him/her iam being so much good student u don't appreciate that rather u r being insecure of me being with others. U can't do that to one right it's betrayel. This is the small level comparison for understanding Allah clothes u feeds u gave life here and u are totally neglecting him and also insulting him.. just go and try to read Qur'an open heartedly and u will understand islam inshallah And sorry if I was ignorent or something and don't mind my if English was bad everyone are learners here. :)
@@shifa9457 I don't know if Allah helped me what's the proof of that? I've seen written that Muhammad made split the moon in half to make people believe. I've seen some passages in Qur'an which give a wrong prespective of the world for example one passage said that sun sets in a lake. I know that Muhammad when he was 54 he married Ayesha aged 5 and consummated marriage when she was 9 and it seemed really disgusting that such a thing is still allowed in Islam.
God won't forgive shirk in Day of jugement Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises. No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population. Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated. What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god? You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same. Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works. If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
@@williampz244 sorry my boy, nice try saving your religion. fi-abadan means forever. Many scholars have tried to justify eternal hell too. It's funny how many muslims interpret as they wish/ want and bring up different meanings and the quran itself claims it's a clear book and it's in arabic for people to understand. And yet even scholars have different approaches in defining the real meaning. Looks like god failed ✌️. And the surah (hud) 107 108, look at the context bro, it's for sinful believers and not non believers. I can show you as many as verses in quran that God says non-believer will be in hell forever. What ever good they do, it will be only for this world. Wake up to the reality, it's just the mind of primitive men let it be bible torah quran bagavat gita etc.. there's no god, humans are incapable of understanding this universe that doesn't mean there's a god with all these attributes.
@@atheistexmuslimindian adding "indian" to your name automatically makes you lose any bit of credibility, drop the ego and humble yourself. Secondly, moral arguments don't disprove the existence of God whether you like it or not. Quite frankly it doesn't matter what you feel is right or wrong because at the end of the day, its just your subjective interpretations, you can't even prove that your views are objectively true or false, because you cannot prove morality to exist in the first place, so no, try again if you think you seriously "won" here. Lastly, it is a simple concept where actions have consequences. It's a paradigm shift from a finite life to an infinite life, and each and every single human's goal is to find out why they exist and what their purpose is in this finite life. At the same time, it is an innate intuition to believe in the afterlife, so its not like you are completely unaware either, you can look at the studies and the science behind it. Therefore, It is on you if you fail to draw the right conclusion and continue living your life as if its purposeless and happened for no reason, you chose to live in ignorance for as long as you live, and if you had lived for eternity, it is evident that you would disbelieve for eternity, so the punishment matches that exact intention. a random atheist from india isn't disproving thousands of years of philosophy because his feelings were hurt about the afterlife, despite actively accepting "eternal nothingness" of this life.
@@shark7698 first of all bro is butthurt that i added indian to my user name. Why though, was it a problem for you. I wanted to add because people should know the countries where exmuslims exists too. I think it's my freedom to add or not, if you don't like deal with it rather being offensive Asking me to humble myself. What kind of stupid justice is that, if i continue to live i would disbelieve for eternity , you're damning someone to eternal torture for something didn't happen , maybe ask god to wait for eternity before putting me in hell 😂. You guys boast about hard-core christians converting to islam at some point in their life, would you have thought that person would believe in your version of god if you've spoken to him when he was a christian? No right, same applies here, you never know what happens over a period of time. Is this your concept of law and justice, lol! , imagine punishing a thief by death saying if he continues to live he will be stealing stuff forever in life! Every punishment should be a step to learn how we can stop someone harming anyone. Your god's law and justice is just ridiculous. ! And finally, disprove god? Where did anyone prove god in the first place? 😂 Don't you know who has the burden of proof? If you have proven god then go get a noble prize for the greatest discovery in the history of humanity. Every group has their own brainwashed version of god, so does yours. Allah is real for you, while it's not for 75% of the human population. ☺️
Eternal hell is 100% illogical concept. God will not punish millions of people who have less intellect for eternal time just because Allah has angry on them because they were hindus or other religions. My intelligence prefer samsara or karma concept rather than eternal hell. And real God knows we are true or false.
It is logical if you understand the reward on the other side, it is not that hard to get eternal heaven, the very phrase la ilaha illalah can grant you eternal heaven, someone on their deathbed can say this, on get eternal heaven if he was sincere. Dont blind yourself and reject religion purely based on this 1 thing you have doubt about. Research islam and it will be so clear to you it is truth
True. The Supreme God does not care whether the person is a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, Sikh, Parsi, etc. What matters to the Supreme God most is devotion in whichever path one chooses in the pursuit of the Supreme God and how the person has led a life of piety along with carrying out his/her obligatory duties like treating his/her old parents/grandparents well, not cheating & hurting anyone, helping people in times of need, etc. Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, etc are just different paths which lead to the Supreme God. There is no True Path and False path. Jai Shri Krishna
@@MBP1073 i don’t agree with your belief. Yes it is important being dutiful and respectful to your parents, helping people etc, but you also have to be dutiful to God almighty, which is more important than anything else in this world. If God said to you, you cant worship false Gods, multiple Gods etc, you have to follow it. And if you follow true religion (like islam), God will also tell you to be dutiful and respectful to your parents, help people, be kind etc. So it is indeed really important to follow the true religion, especially if God himself said so
@@MBP1073 i am interested why tho? If God himself said that people should only worship him, and you deny that, it means you deny the religion that says it completely. You either fabricate your own new religion, or there is an already existing religion with your belief (i dont know such), so at the end of the day, you do follow a religion. You cant deny fundamentals of Abrahamic religions (like islam, christianity, judaism), then say you believe in them all
But wouldnt it be way more unfair if babies (or minors in general) were not granted heaven? I mean how could you justufy holding them accountable for something they did if they are too young and not smart enough to know whats right or wrong?
There are specific tests in the hereafter for those babies or those who didn't get the message of islam ...it's in the hadiths. You can search up on the RUclips for further clarification. Do some research first before coming to a conclusion.
So if I don't believe Allah is real God then Allah will torture me trillions and trillions of year with most possible way of torturing...does it make sense ...what a cult it is
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time. read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell) also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing v23 (an-naba) the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise. there is other evidence too
One of the worst answers I have ever heard. He never justified why shirk is a sin. And if it is a sin, then why is it the greatest sin in Islam? So, according to Islam shirk is worse than rape or murder? Okay, even if shirk is the greatest sin, why eternal punishment for it? Burning someone eternally is the most cruel thing anyone can do, and Allah claims himself to be the most merciful being.
Shirk is the biggest sin. Imagine if you break the things at your house, your parents can forgive you but if you leave your parents and adopt some new parents, your parents will never forgive you.
@@danishakram9540 Comparing parents to God is a bad analogy. We humans know out parents, so why would we adopt others as our parents? And even if I adopted others as my parents, that doesn't give my orignal parents any right to give me eternal painful punishments.
@@zipzap6783when you get to know who God is and understand his 99 names and attributes, and the advice he gives to us mankind in the Quran you realise what is forbidden is protection and what he has granted is only good for us, Allah the almighty and merciful has made us, created us , know us better than ourselves and our parents, is a constant guardian over us, every heartbeat lies in his permission, the gifts he has given us that we would never sell like our sight or limbs. Now imagine knowing all of us and accepting this truth but choosing not to worship, worship as in a lifestyle and worshipping him as one, how ungrateful does that make us to not acknowledge him. Yes God is far above any apology to that of human analogy but in order to understand you apply this concept, your mother you has looked after you and cared for you, only to not acknowledge everything she’s done for you and you disobey her constantly and serve new parents. This mother calls you back loving many times with reminders and gentle warnings but there’s only so much
Eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises. No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population. Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated. What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god? You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same. Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works. If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
His answer is correct, it is not the duration to be considered when it's a sin, it's the intensity/ crime that should be considered. But first of all, eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises. No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population. Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated. What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god? You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same. Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works. If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
@@kevalkishan3824My dear brother I see that you have an open mind and are willing to study about religions to choose one for yourself,if you are a man who believes in scientific evidence then I can write here some scientific evidence from the Quran that no one could have known 1400 years ago
The only time a person will enter hellfire forever is when he or she die in the state of shirk but if you ask Allah for forgiveness before you die he will forgive you indeed Allah is the most merciful and the most forgiving
Unjust not fair of god
That is fair because Allah has created everything in balance and humans have two choices to believe or disbelief but whoever believes in Allah and worship him alone will have great rewards and whoever disbelief in Allah he will have hell
@@turboturbo780 you know what’s unfair ? That you disbelievers want to live this life exactly as you wish, full pleasure, no restriction AND call God unjust when he says he will punish you. You guys are unfair, not God. What is unfair is you want full pleasure and no hardship or worship in this life AND enjoy all the next life … God just proves he is just.
@@r.a.8002 didnt Ask you nothing and never said god is unjust just said it is unjust of him not the same that maybe hes not unjust but his decisions
Didnt Ask you nothing never said god is unjust you need to see differences never he is that just hes decisions is unjust not the same and never claimed i know whats unfair dont put words in my mouth
This speech back me Islam again alhamdulillah
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
@@williampz244
Yes, hellfire is not eternal if someone preserves faith in Almighty Allah and in the last Prophet Muhammad (S.) as Allah's Messenger which is minimum! Because of the wrong deeds that are forbidden by Islam which were done by him, he'll enter into hellfire but because of beliefs in Almighty Allah and Allah's Messenger he'll be brought back to Jannah for his beliefs, Inn Sh'a Allah.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.105/ 106/ 107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
The verse 40 (Al-araf) and also When it says that Allah has forbidden paradise to the associates speaks of the day of judgment where Allah will never let the infidels enter paradise, but after having suffered centuries in hell they will come out.
the verse where Allah says that they will not come out of the fire it is only for one day (1000 years) as in the verse V.35 (Al-Jaathiya) and he says "kharijina" not "yukhraju" which is not the same thing. "yukhraju" means that they will never go out and this is said only for those in heaven.
V.68 (At-tawba) "permanent" means that it will be continuous without pause, not eternal
God wrote in a book that mercy precedes my anger
Jahannam is eternal for disbelievers Surah Baqarah 2/81, . Surah A’raf 7/36, Surah Jinn 72/23 all those verses say hellfire is eternal for nonbelievers. The prophet(SAW) was talking about the last muslim to enter jannah from Jahannam, but the disbelievers would eternal live in hellfire.
@@warkaahmed8035 Yes but there is exception in v128 to 130 (an naam) and v.103 to 10u (Hud), v35 (al jathiya) and the prophet Mohammed talked about the last men who left hellfire and go in paradise
@Mohammed-ks9wf the person dies I the state of shirk will go to hell or the person who has committed major crimes e g murder theft and he had not ask forgiveness will go to hell and the person who commits suicide
@@kowtobtwBut wouldn't those be technically considered as temporarily in Hellfire, and then after serving a certain amount of time there, they can then enter Paradise?
@retroman5432 yes all Muslims who believed in God and committed major sins will spend temporarily time in hell and eventually will be in heaven
Perfect reply. InshaaAllah
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
I my opinion my answer is If a person in hell Asked same que to Allah the answer will be that if Allah again send back in to the world by erasing the memory again he will do Shirk If he would live for eternity still he'll do Shrik so the punishment of eternal life is totally logical !
It's just my opinion !
You are so right because this is in the quran
@@emilyhill4488 can you mention me the verse?
But how about those kafirs who reject islam simply because they're not convinced enough to embrace islam? They worship the wrong God because they don't know the truth, not because they want to. Will it be fair if they remain in hell forever?
@@sohailshaikhhh what about those who dont believe in him due to less evidence
@@Anxh007ALLAH says . Agar in logon tk sachaee pohnch Gai phir b inhon ne mun phera to ALLAH will punish them
Assalaamualykum my dear brothers and sisters, we find this question in Quran (2_80)(They say, ‘The Fire will only touch us for a few days.’ Say to them, ‘Have you received a promise from God- for God never breaks His promise- or are you saying things about Him of which you have no real knowledge?’ ), and answer is given in next verse(2_81)(Truly those who do evil and are surrounded by their sins will be the inhabitants of the Fire, there to remain), It depends on what sin's we earn. If we get context of these verses, it will be helpful, may God save us from hell and sin's which leads to hell aameean.
The Supreme God does not care whether the person is a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, Sikh, Parsi, etc. What matters to the Supreme God most is devotion in whichever path one chooses in the pursuit of the Supreme God and how the person has led a life of piety along with carrying out his/her obligatory duties like treating his/her old parents/grandparents well, not cheating & hurting anyone, helping people in times of need, etc.
Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, etc are just different paths which lead to the Supreme God. One can follow any path according to one's nature. There is no True Path or False path.
Jai Shri Krishna
Islam, Christendom are a shame for teaching non truths about God’s greatest attribute of love. A “hell-fire” is incompatible with such godly attribute.
Absolutely. If any God says that he will give special treatment to persons of only a certain religion and put others into hell fire then he cannot be a God, forget being a true god.
Maashaallaah! Amazing Example By Dr Zakir Naik Saab! We 💙L💙O💙V💙E💙 You Sir!
Dr Shabbir Ali Says Hell us not forever.because Allah is most Merciful
Not for Muslims that's only for those who committed shirk.
@@AbdulRehman-j6q9h No Dr Shabbir Ali Says Hell is not forever of all, including non Muslims.
Because all Humans is a Creation of Allah/God.and God is not slaughter who punished his creations for eternity.He is most merciful/ Rahman Al Rahim.
Hell maybe long duration for non believers but not forever.
If Allah punished Non believers for eternity than why he is called Al Rahman Al Rahim.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
@@AbdulRehman-j6q9h Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
@@williampz244 are u a muslim?
hell is temporary in Hinduism Sikhism and in many other relgions accept islam and Christianity
Is it true our Prophet pbuh will save all his umma from Hell fire ????if yes it is as same as Christian say they will be saved by Jesus pbuh
No one is free my friend if they do unjust you cant be behind prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) in the Qur'an allah says you are a messenger and a human and you are not responsible about the deeds of the people it is upon oneself that decide the either paths of eternal life i.e heaven/hell even if you are the prophets wife you cant be forgiven by the relationship it is the deeds which defines you destiny but in Christianity alll are forgiven if you just love jesus but cant able to follow the path of Jesus (peace and blessings upon him)
Masha allah
Maa Sha Allah
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
Allah😢😢 hell forever forgive us😢 6:03 6:05
Love u sir ♥️🇵🇰
I am surprised that Dr Naik can give such an illogical answer, he gave all examples that does not match with the qualities of our Creator Allah. Allah is full of mercy and His mercy encompasses everything including those people who even failed to recognise Him. Hell is a temporary place for correction and purification after which all human being will be with their Creator and there will be no hell.
This is your opinion and your opinion only brother. In the Quran, Allah mentiones 3 times, “they will abide therein forever.”
In all cases he refers to people that comitted shirk and were disbelievers.
Of course, the punishment will vary but only sinful muslims that, believed in Allah, but weren’t the best muslims, only they get to be taken out of hell after a period of time when Allah wills!
@@edisluka5053 my opinion is based on the clear guidance of the holy Quran, this forever mean as long as the hell exist, after it will be shut, there will be none there, it will be empty. Nowhere in the holy Quran, it was mentioned that none will be expelled from hell but for jannah it was mentioned that none will be expelled from there.
How can you say that hell will be finished khallas in sometime majority of muslim ummah. Is satisfied in the eternal hell punishment and we can't comprehend the intellect and knowledge of allah swt he created the hell eternal for a reason he created us and he has every right to punish us eternally may allah gives hidayat and distance us from hell as long as the whole universe ameen @@mdsaifurrahman9462
what about native americans who died before Islam even became known to them.. they went in hell?! 😂😂
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
@@williampz244 ok so keeping them in hellfire for "some days" is "not so bad" so its "okay" right?
( No burdened soul carries the burdens of another, nor do We ever punish until We have sent a messenger ) Surah al-Isra':15
@@TarMezoIf a messenger was sent in native America then why are their traditions so different than Arab Muslims? Not even a single niche of them have similar traditions as Islam. Can you blame the whole population for it, or would you blame that messenger who was unable to send the right message to them ?
@@nikhilsaharanAllah says he will only punish those who heard about the Truth and rejected it the one who doesn't get the message will not be punished and also some scholars says if a person Heard about Islam in a wrong way he would not goto hell hope that answers your question and Allah knows best my brother ❤
Quran says that all his deeds will be void if he does not believe in allah and allah will punish him very severely, and that such people are worst of human beings (doesnt matter what their deeds were). So for allah it matters more that you believe in him rather than doing good things. Seems like he is so insecure
For example I say u have a friend he/she helps u to read, guides u and helps u to do homework but even after he/she does so much to u, u just go to other friends and completely ignore that helping friend and saying to him/her iam being so much good student u don't appreciate that rather u r being insecure of me being with others. U can't do that to one right it's betrayel.
This is the small level comparison for understanding Allah clothes u feeds u gave life here and u are totally neglecting him and also insulting him.. just go and try to read Qur'an open heartedly and u will understand islam inshallah
And sorry if I was ignorent or something and don't mind my if English was bad everyone are learners here. :)
@@shifa9457 I don't know if Allah helped me what's the proof of that? I've seen written that Muhammad made split the moon in half to make people believe. I've seen some passages in Qur'an which give a wrong prespective of the world for example one passage said that sun sets in a lake. I know that Muhammad when he was 54 he married Ayesha aged 5 and consummated marriage when she was 9 and it seemed really disgusting that such a thing is still allowed in Islam.
About Shirk is written in Quraan. God won't forgive that. Wen you set up a partner with God.
God won't forgive shirk in Day of jugement
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises.
No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population.
Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated.
What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god?
You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same.
Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works.
If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
@@williampz244 sorry my boy, nice try saving your religion. fi-abadan means forever. Many scholars have tried to justify eternal hell too. It's funny how many muslims interpret as they wish/ want and bring up different meanings and the quran itself claims it's a clear book and it's in arabic for people to understand. And yet even scholars have different approaches in defining the real meaning. Looks like god failed ✌️.
And the surah (hud) 107 108, look at the context bro, it's for sinful believers and not non believers. I can show you as many as verses in quran that God says non-believer will be in hell forever. What ever good they do, it will be only for this world.
Wake up to the reality, it's just the mind of primitive men let it be bible torah quran bagavat gita etc.. there's no god, humans are incapable of understanding this universe that doesn't mean there's a god with all these attributes.
@@atheistexmuslimindian adding "indian" to your name automatically makes you lose any bit of credibility, drop the ego and humble yourself. Secondly, moral arguments don't disprove the existence of God whether you like it or not. Quite frankly it doesn't matter what you feel is right or wrong because at the end of the day, its just your subjective interpretations, you can't even prove that your views are objectively true or false, because you cannot prove morality to exist in the first place, so no, try again if you think you seriously "won" here.
Lastly, it is a simple concept where actions have consequences. It's a paradigm shift from a finite life to an infinite life, and each and every single human's goal is to find out why they exist and what their purpose is in this finite life. At the same time, it is an innate intuition to believe in the afterlife, so its not like you are completely unaware either, you can look at the studies and the science behind it. Therefore, It is on you if you fail to draw the right conclusion and continue living your life as if its purposeless and happened for no reason, you chose to live in ignorance for as long as you live, and if you had lived for eternity, it is evident that you would disbelieve for eternity, so the punishment matches that exact intention. a random atheist from india isn't disproving thousands of years of philosophy because his feelings were hurt about the afterlife, despite actively accepting "eternal nothingness" of this life.
@@shark7698 first of all bro is butthurt that i added indian to my user name. Why though, was it a problem for you. I wanted to add because people should know the countries where exmuslims exists too. I think it's my freedom to add or not, if you don't like deal with it rather being offensive Asking me to humble myself.
What kind of stupid justice is that, if i continue to live i would disbelieve for eternity , you're damning someone to eternal torture for something didn't happen , maybe ask god to wait for eternity before putting me in hell 😂. You guys boast about hard-core christians converting to islam at some point in their life, would you have thought that person would believe in your version of god if you've spoken to him when he was a christian? No right, same applies here, you never know what happens over a period of time. Is this your concept of law and justice, lol! , imagine punishing a thief by death saying if he continues to live he will be stealing stuff forever in life! Every punishment should be a step to learn how we can stop someone harming anyone. Your god's law and justice is just ridiculous. !
And finally, disprove god? Where did anyone prove god in the first place? 😂 Don't you know who has the burden of proof? If you have proven god then go get a noble prize for the greatest discovery in the history of humanity. Every group has their own brainwashed version of god, so does yours. Allah is real for you, while it's not for 75% of the human population. ☺️
Eternal hell is 100% illogical concept. God will not punish millions of people who have less intellect for eternal time just because Allah has angry on them because they were hindus or other religions.
My intelligence prefer samsara or karma concept rather than eternal hell. And real God knows we are true or false.
It is logical if you understand the reward on the other side, it is not that hard to get eternal heaven, the very phrase la ilaha illalah can grant you eternal heaven, someone on their deathbed can say this, on get eternal heaven if he was sincere. Dont blind yourself and reject religion purely based on this 1 thing you have doubt about. Research islam and it will be so clear to you it is truth
True.
The Supreme God does not care whether the person is a Muslim, Christian, Hindu, Jew, Buddhist, Sikh, Parsi, etc. What matters to the Supreme God most is devotion in whichever path one chooses in the pursuit of the Supreme God and how the person has led a life of piety along with carrying out his/her obligatory duties like treating his/her old parents/grandparents well, not cheating & hurting anyone, helping people in times of need, etc.
Islam, Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, etc are just different paths which lead to the Supreme God. There is no True Path and False path.
Jai Shri Krishna
@@MBP1073 i don’t agree with your belief. Yes it is important being dutiful and respectful to your parents, helping people etc, but you also have to be dutiful to God almighty, which is more important than anything else in this world. If God said to you, you cant worship false Gods, multiple Gods etc, you have to follow it. And if you follow true religion (like islam), God will also tell you to be dutiful and respectful to your parents, help people, be kind etc. So it is indeed really important to follow the true religion, especially if God himself said so
@@Pesimesi I respect your opinion but I humbly disagree with your opinion too.
@@MBP1073 i am interested why tho? If God himself said that people should only worship him, and you deny that, it means you deny the religion that says it completely. You either fabricate your own new religion, or there is an already existing religion with your belief (i dont know such), so at the end of the day, you do follow a religion. You cant deny fundamentals of Abrahamic religions (like islam, christianity, judaism), then say you believe in them all
❤❤❤
Is it not unfair to everyone else if babies who have passed away (peace be upon them) have heaven and we’re not put to the test like the rest of us?
But wouldnt it be way more unfair if babies (or minors in general) were not granted heaven? I mean how could you justufy holding them accountable for something they did if they are too young and not smart enough to know whats right or wrong?
@@krm.073 it would be worse. But why is this in existence and not something else in it’s place?
i thought they will be tested in afterlife.
How are you feeling unjust by a baby who have done nothing wrong? You have all this worldy enjoyment, they didn’t 🤦🏻♂️
There are specific tests in the hereafter for those babies or those who didn't get the message of islam ...it's in the hadiths.
You can search up on the RUclips for further clarification. Do some research first before coming to a conclusion.
Not just biggest crime in islam also its biggest sin in the world
So if I don't believe Allah is real God then Allah will torture me trillions and trillions of year with most possible way of torturing...does it make sense ...what a cult it is
May allah bless dr naik with the most beautiful virgins of jannah
lol 😂
Hellfire is not eternal, the word "khalidina" and "abad" it also means for a long time.
read also V.128 An-naam in arabic: ila macha allahu which means "except what God wants" (speaking of the length of stay in hell)
also in v.107 and 108 (Hud) he says the same thing
v23 (an-naba)
the prophet mohamed talked about the last men in the hellfire who after he go in paradise.
there is other evidence too
One of the worst answers I have ever heard. He never justified why shirk is a sin. And if it is a sin, then why is it the greatest sin in Islam? So, according to Islam shirk is worse than rape or murder? Okay, even if shirk is the greatest sin, why eternal punishment for it? Burning someone eternally is the most cruel thing anyone can do, and Allah claims himself to be the most merciful being.
Shirk is the biggest sin. Imagine if you break the things at your house, your parents can forgive you but if you leave your parents and adopt some new parents, your parents will never forgive you.
@@danishakram9540 Comparing parents to God is a bad analogy. We humans know out parents, so why would we adopt others as our parents? And even if I adopted others as my parents, that doesn't give my orignal parents any right to give me eternal painful punishments.
@@zipzap6783when you get to know who God is and understand his 99 names and attributes, and the advice he gives to us mankind in the Quran you realise what is forbidden is protection and what he has granted is only good for us, Allah the almighty and merciful has made us, created us , know us better than ourselves and our parents, is a constant guardian over us, every heartbeat lies in his permission, the gifts he has given us that we would never sell like our sight or limbs. Now imagine knowing all of us and accepting this truth but choosing not to worship, worship as in a lifestyle and worshipping him as one, how ungrateful does that make us to not acknowledge him. Yes God is far above any apology to that of human analogy but in order to understand you apply this concept, your mother you has looked after you and cared for you, only to not acknowledge everything she’s done for you and you disobey her constantly and serve new parents. This mother calls you back loving many times with reminders and gentle warnings but there’s only so much
Also there is a paper by Yaqeen institute about why shirk is so grave, it’s a good paper pls read
Eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises.
No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population.
Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated.
What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god?
You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same.
Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works.
If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
Is Jannat and Jahannam life endless obviously?
For beleivers jahanam is not infinite but jannah is infinite
@@BloxGMS But is it finite for ONLY for Muslims though?
@@ElJefeQ1 those who beleive in allah and only allah and worship only him and eccept the prophet mohammoud as the rassule
@@ElJefeQ1 but we dont know only allah knows 60 100 1000 years we dont know
yea the people who will stay in jannah will be the ones who did shirk, and disbelief@@ElJefeQ1
Worst answer i saw..😂
Just like your comment…worst comment I ever saw is yours 😂😂😂😂
@@MuhammadIkram-kb3pu same for it is the worst replies as well 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
His answer is correct, it is not the duration to be considered when it's a sin, it's the intensity/ crime that should be considered.
But first of all, eternity of burning hell for any crime is injustice. Especially if you give such attributes like all-loving to a god who has love of 70 mothers together, that's when the problem arises.
No one in this world is so arrogant to reject Allah if he/she knew that Allah is the god / real God. Everyone is biased to their own birth religion, there's so much emotions attached to it that they will leave their religion to another, even if, it's very rare like 1% of human population.
Everyone is convinced their version of god is the true one, just like a muslim too. You'll not realize or accept it because you're born into it and indoctrinated.
What if maybe Christianity is the true religion and you end up denying that Jesus is god?
You'll end up in Christian hell for eternity, but does that make you arrogant? You'll then think you deserve that punishment, no right? It's the same.
Think deep, every religion is made up by MEN when they didn't know how this world works and how nature works.
If there's a god with all these characteristics, he would have found a better way to communicate rather through flawed human beings and books that's open to interpretation.
@@atheistexmuslimindian what a beautiful answer...and what I think btw that God exists ...but not what Muslims says or anyone yet ..
@@kevalkishan3824My dear brother I see that you have an open mind and are willing to study about religions to choose one for yourself,if you are a man who believes in scientific evidence then I can write here some scientific evidence from the Quran that no one could have known 1400 years ago