No SOLDIER Knows The NUMBER of Men He's KILLED

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 май 2024
  • #history #avc #military #army #ww2 #wwii #militaryhistory
    ----------------------------------------------------------------
    Support the American Veterans Center's mission to preserve the legacy and history of our heroes by making a tax-deductible donation today: americanveteranscenter.org/do...
    Learn more about the American Veterans Center: www.americanveteranscenter.org/
    Like us on Facebook: / americanveteranscenter
    Follow us on Twitter: / avcupdate
    Follow us on Instagram: / americanveteranscenter
    Subscribe to the Veterans Chronicles podcast: link.chtbl.com/americanvetera...
    ----------------------------------------------------------------

Комментарии • 2,4 тыс.

  • @americanveteranscenter
    @americanveteranscenter  Месяц назад +441

    HISTORY LOVERS - before you comment, be sure to subscribe to this RUclips channel and ring the notification bell so you never miss a future upload!

    • @bronxmosthated1
      @bronxmosthated1 Месяц назад

      A world without money, also known as a non-monetary economy, is a system where goods and services are allocated without the use of money. In this system, all products and services are free, and everyone must work for free to get what they want. This means that any work that a society needs is considered legitimate All drugs and prostitutions should be legal people should watch the ted talk About a world without money by Colin R. Turner

    • @Mollyisadog
      @Mollyisadog 25 дней назад +1

      Jesus loves you

    • @fhsjdjskkshi
      @fhsjdjskkshi 9 дней назад

      Jesus loves you 💖🙏✝️💓

    • @PaulFalk-pf8zf
      @PaulFalk-pf8zf 8 дней назад

      To hear the hell is real

  • @gitsomemoto
    @gitsomemoto Месяц назад +3151

    As a combat veteran there was an instance where I kept thinking my gun was jammed after pulling the trigger. Turns out I had emptied all my magazines and swear I had only shot 4 bullets. That 6 hour post felt less than 15 minutes. We started receiving fire 10 minutes after we arrived.

    • @31446963048
      @31446963048 Месяц назад +206

      Glad you made it home.

    • @-AyeYallThereGoLaFlare-
      @-AyeYallThereGoLaFlare- Месяц назад +33

      Is that you in your pfp ?

    • @WorthlessDeadEnd
      @WorthlessDeadEnd Месяц назад +130

      Dude, that is wild. It's kind of scary what the mind can achieve and endure when you're fighting to stay alive. You probably weren't even remotely aware that you may have had to pee during those six hours.

    • @Mordant.Melodys
      @Mordant.Melodys Месяц назад +32

      Glad you’re here to tell the story, brother. IRQ or AFG? Much love.

    • @kaymartinez3443
      @kaymartinez3443 Месяц назад +21

      Thank you for your service. God bless you 🙏

  • @stalinbeballin9711
    @stalinbeballin9711 Месяц назад +7104

    And that is part of the reason why "confirmed kills" are only those that a third party witnesses
    Edit: War is hell, just like these comments. I get it. Shush please

    • @Exxar-Kuun
      @Exxar-Kuun Месяц назад +158

      We lost chuck mawhinny out of my community this year. Couldn’t be more true. We’ll never know what he did, but especially cause his grandson is suffering from being an incurable prick. Tales lost to time. Interview your vets!!

    • @lemonator8813
      @lemonator8813 Месяц назад +9

      Yup.

    • @bjorndanielsen4680
      @bjorndanielsen4680 Месяц назад +26

      I can maybe talk to his grandson. I can be a massively overbearing prick.​@@Exxar-Kuun

    • @bruhism173
      @bruhism173 Месяц назад

      This is why Indians took scalps

    • @jamiewalker8772
      @jamiewalker8772 Месяц назад +47

      @@Exxar-Kuundamn that’s a real shame. Have an epic grandfather only to get a brat 😔
      Downfall of the west and we watch 🤦‍♂️

  • @jamesgornall5731
    @jamesgornall5731 Месяц назад +1943

    My Granddad told us that all he did was paint tanks during the war, as a Royal Engineer sapper in the Far East. After he died, Gran said he'd been shot and wounded in action 3 times that he'd told her of, so we know that he did a good deal more than that, but a more gentle man you'd never meet. Died at 92 in 2017.

    • @AnthonySforza
      @AnthonySforza Месяц назад +100

      Sounds like my Grandfather. He basically told my dad "Yea, I was in the Army and went to Korea" but never really said anything about it. Turns out decades after his death, not only was he in post occupation Germany, but in Korea, he was one of the Chosin Few... and didnt have any Purple Hearts.

    • @AnthonySforza
      @AnthonySforza Месяц назад +9

      Sounds like my Grandfather. He basically told my dad "Yea, I was in the Army and went to Korea" but never really said anything about it. Turns out decades after his death, not only was he in post occupation Germany, but in Korea, he was one of the Chosin Few... and didnt have any Purple Hearts.

    • @kristoferprovencal3608
      @kristoferprovencal3608 Месяц назад +37

      Honestly, it’s entirely possible all he did was work on tanks… he just did it while under enemy fire, which probably takes as much if not more nerves than being in involved in the firefight itself.

    • @hamby2232
      @hamby2232 Месяц назад +37

      I've heard many times that the people who say they did simple boring jobs during a war often have some of the most fascinating yet also horrifying stories of all

    • @DB-yj3qc
      @DB-yj3qc Месяц назад +28

      ​@@AnthonySforza
      The same with my uncle he served in Germany and Korea. He didn't talk about it to really anyone other than his father who was in WW1 and me after Desert Storm. That was the only time I ever saw him drink any alcohol beverage, it was one of my decompressions from one of many deployments. Very few in the family knew, as far as most knew he was just a tank mechanic. The line of military service on my father's side of the family will come to an end with me after over 150 years.

  • @jarredbadillo
    @jarredbadillo Месяц назад +667

    He still has the stare when he talks about it.

    • @michaelwolfe5775
      @michaelwolfe5775 Месяц назад +13

      Very true.

    • @WorthlessDeadEnd
      @WorthlessDeadEnd Месяц назад +20

      The thousand yard stare

    • @brickson98m
      @brickson98m 28 дней назад +19

      Yeah, taking a life is never easy. Not that I would know, but from what I’ve heard from soldiers. Even when your life is on the line, those shots you take come back to haunt you.

    • @doomturtle7579
      @doomturtle7579 28 дней назад +9

      it never goes away, you just learn to move forward with it

    • @mkay1957
      @mkay1957 28 дней назад +6

      They can see a lot of what they went through vividly in their mind.

  • @danielhaigler556
    @danielhaigler556 Месяц назад +708

    I knew a WW2 veteran when i was a child. He showed us his medal display. There were so many i couldnt begin to identify. He had European and pacific medals. He told us about his bronze star, he got it when his squad rushed a bunker and blew up only to find it empty. But the officer who recommended the medal didnt know it. He laughed and we laughed. I asked him about his silver star.
    His face changed, he quietly asked me never to ask how he earned it again. He was a BAR Gunner. I cannot imagine what he went through. The things he saw and did to survive the war. He was a kind and caring man.
    Rest in peace Richard Kastel. You earned it

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +22

      Rest in peace ❤and God bless you and him ❤

    • @Mollyisadog
      @Mollyisadog 25 дней назад +9

      Jesus loves u

    • @FinesseKidd_22
      @FinesseKidd_22 25 дней назад +2

      🫡🙏🕊️

    • @charleswestbrooks1257
      @charleswestbrooks1257 25 дней назад +39

      My father was a BAR gunner. He passed away when I was only 20. He never spoke about his service or being a POW and I was always taught not to ask. His Bronze Star, Purple Heart and other medals he kept in a cigar box at the bottom of his sock drawer.

    • @Tomc8030
      @Tomc8030 24 дня назад +21

      @@charleswestbrooks1257 my dad was a Air Born Medical Ranger he never talked about the war. He’s dead and gone but my uncle told me before he died that the Air Born Medical Rangers where know as bad asses and he was very proud of my dad! Wish I had known that before dad died.

  • @blitzwolfe7875
    @blitzwolfe7875 Месяц назад +1620

    Crazy to think they can talk about this like an everyday experience. Hats off to you, sir.

    • @HK_PNW
      @HK_PNW Месяц назад +110

      Look into his eyes. It definitely wasnt an every day experience for him. He just happens to be very good at emotional control.

    • @aedes947
      @aedes947 Месяц назад +54

      The way he talks you can clearly see that although he may have come at peace with a lot of things he did, it still is something pretty heavy for him.

    • @wandery2k
      @wandery2k Месяц назад +44

      watch the pause. Watch the eyes. He went back for a split second. And it’s heartbreaking.

    • @Rick-np9vz
      @Rick-np9vz Месяц назад +26

      Just because you learn to live with your demons doesn't mean they're going to let you sleep well!

    • @tadspencer4852
      @tadspencer4852 Месяц назад +14

      Probably took him half his life and to watch most his generation dying of old age without telling their stories before he realized that those stories needed to be told...

  • @gauthierrigaux56
    @gauthierrigaux56 Месяц назад +442

    Frenchman here, even after all this time, we'll never forget how courageous those veterans were. God Bless you America,

    • @DarkMatterX1
      @DarkMatterX1 28 дней назад +40

      And thank you for Lafayette, and the French Navy.

    • @NicWoyS_
      @NicWoyS_ 27 дней назад

      France is certainly doing well now, certainly not infested with migrants, certainly not. But hey, at least we don't speak German, right?

    • @randydover3370
      @randydover3370 27 дней назад +17

      Thoughtful Frenchman!!

    • @liamwhitlock3353
      @liamwhitlock3353 26 дней назад +15

      Blessings to you to Mr French man 🇦🇺

    • @zteaxon7787
      @zteaxon7787 26 дней назад +1

      No the Germans liberated France.
      Americans enforced the current rulers.

  • @williamstokely9589
    @williamstokely9589 Месяц назад +316

    This mans interview is incredible because he doesn't sugar coat anything and he tells it in some detail too.

    • @cloviswater4870
      @cloviswater4870 29 дней назад

      Most older troops who’ve been in combat don’t lie. It’s the politicians that don’t have to go to war that lie

  • @isawit9722
    @isawit9722 Месяц назад +842

    I asked a Vietnam vet,how many kills he got....he said " as many as were trying to kill me at the time.... that's why I'm here.....he said he didn't take ears like others did, they only started doing that when they found thier wounded on the field butchered.

    • @Krilium
      @Krilium 29 дней назад +10

      take ears?!

    • @isaiahcampbell488
      @isaiahcampbell488 29 дней назад +57

      ​@@Krilium
      Trophies

    • @Aden_III
      @Aden_III 29 дней назад +146

      @@Krilium”get-back” trophies.
      My grandpa was army, 4th ID, but he said one time that they came upon a marine that had been skinned alive and nailed to a stake in the middle of a clearing - still alive.
      He begged to be shot. When the sergeant left to go take a report, my grandpa said he just shot him.

    • @MoonmanSpacejam
      @MoonmanSpacejam 29 дней назад +29

      That's a terrible question to ask a vet

    • @svefnhnuturthorgeirsson
      @svefnhnuturthorgeirsson 29 дней назад +41

      ​@@Aden_IIIAll I can say to that is jesus christ

  • @josephschuster7181
    @josephschuster7181 Месяц назад +401

    It’s a tragedy that war happens. You never know, those two men could’ve been friends if they had met under different circumstances.

    • @Billy-je6mq
      @Billy-je6mq Месяц назад +29

      That's what shifty powers said in his interview at the end of the band of brothers series.

    • @gawdzalien2811
      @gawdzalien2811 Месяц назад

      War is the natural state of man, peace is the oddity. America has been spared due to CIA clandestine intervention agency, toppling threats before they gain ground

    • @Chris-qg6kc
      @Chris-qg6kc 29 дней назад

      Then one finds out the other was banging his wife and they go back to being enemies.

    • @Corrello88
      @Corrello88 29 дней назад +18

      Theres a docu that I re watch religiously every now and then by Ken burns on the Nam, there was one old NVA soldier talking about how after an ambush he saw the Americans were just like them, they held each other and cried when one died, they got their wounded off the field, he said "it really made me think" very eye opening in the ways of a soldiers thinking.

    • @Qthunderchicken
      @Qthunderchicken 28 дней назад +7

      rich men north of Richmond

  • @gustavedelior3683
    @gustavedelior3683 Месяц назад +76

    My great grandfather said he didn't know how many he killed, but could count the ones he could remember.

    • @Ineeadifferentusernamelol
      @Ineeadifferentusernamelol 29 дней назад +3

      Of course even then this is a guess. No hit markers , no “confirmed kills”, unless someone else sees you shoot someone pretty much right next to you, you didn’t confirm anything. Like you all use the same ammo. What are you gonna do, guess whose rounds are who’s on the dudes body? Imagine grenade use or just the spray and pray nature that is the real life firefights.

    • @gustavedelior3683
      @gustavedelior3683 29 дней назад +5

      @@Ineeadifferentusernamelol let's back track here, why are you stating obvious? Yes he had no idea how many he killed no one is denying this. Or maybe I'm rude, seems a lot of information in response to a common triviality among WW2 vets.

  • @Eastwing74
    @Eastwing74 Месяц назад +102

    When I was a kid, my neighbor was a down pilot rescuer in Nam. This is a man that would jump out of the helicopter, hovering a few feet off the ground to run across an open rice patty under fire to throw a pilot over his shoulder and get him back to that chopper and back to safety. He was missing a part of his nose and some of his knuckles from where bullets almost took him out. He was one of the lucky ones that managed to push down all the stuff that he saw in Nam. He had medals, but I never asked him about them. I could tell he wanted to move on from all that.

  • @alisonwalter2698
    @alisonwalter2698 Месяц назад +39

    Thank you for your service, Sir. No one knows the trauma you have endured.

  • @cubixzz831
    @cubixzz831 Месяц назад +62

    That stare tells a thousand stories

    • @mkay1957
      @mkay1957 28 дней назад +2

      Because he can see everything as clear as day in his mind.

  • @user-zq4zi3dy3c
    @user-zq4zi3dy3c Месяц назад +47

    Thank you for your service!

    • @unsignedmusic
      @unsignedmusic 26 дней назад +1

      🤮

    • @AfiSM
      @AfiSM 25 дней назад

      ​@@unsignedmusic bro was 6💀

  • @gragglenotz
    @gragglenotz Месяц назад +47

    This man sharing his experience of war is absolutely needed. We don’t teach this in school. People who have seen that kind of violence have a certain depth to their eyes. Gives it away.
    I’m thankful for the men and women who put work and effort into any war effort on our behalf. Justified or otherwise. They are truly salt of the earth.
    Don’t say happy Memorial Day. It does not do justice to what is or what was done. Thanking people for their service is more real. We have a semblance of a nation with their effort and blood that was given.
    Always faithful.

    • @Simpson17866
      @Simpson17866 Месяц назад +1

      "Thanking people for their service is more real"
      Don't most vets not like that either?

    • @PaladinThizz
      @PaladinThizz Месяц назад

      Not everyone who’s seen that kind of violence has that look and some people have that look and have never been to war

    • @aloysiusdevanderabercrombi470
      @aloysiusdevanderabercrombi470 29 дней назад +1

      ​@@PaladinThizz it's a trauma reaction

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад

      God bless you ❤wise advice ❤

  • @TwilightHusky115
    @TwilightHusky115 Месяц назад +232

    You can see him reliving it in his mind as he talks.
    Thank you for your service sir.
    Truly, the greatest generation.

  • @xnavyro
    @xnavyro Месяц назад +103

    I realized real early the asking Dad about his “kills” was a verboten subject. Every now & then after him & his fellow Marines would have a “session”, tongues would loosen & I’d hear things that to this day send shivers down my spine! Dad, I’m sorry you had to be exposed to this madness but thank you for doing what I know you had to do!
    Love you, RIP, God bless you & hopefully your nights are no longer filled with nightmares of that time?

    • @user-kn4bd5ci4v
      @user-kn4bd5ci4v 29 дней назад +1

      Wow. thankyou for sharing. I’m hoping this doesn’t cause offense if it’s inappropriate to ask I apologize and you do not have to answer obviously but I was curious and thought you can’t receive if you don’t ask so I better just ask so I’m wondering if you would share any of the stories you overheard?

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад

      That's so moving 😢bless you and yes I pray he is resting in peace ❤

    • @roderickstockdale1678
      @roderickstockdale1678 27 дней назад

      The pacific?

  • @afrikasmith1049
    @afrikasmith1049 Месяц назад +80

    WW2 was a great example of ending evil regimes, but sadly we are now seen as bad guys after Vietnam and Iraq. But it isn't our boy's and girl's fault who we sent overseas to fight. It's our politicians who's to blame.

    • @d4cto
      @d4cto Месяц назад

      Not really? Politicians are getting blamed, not people.

    • @afrikasmith1049
      @afrikasmith1049 Месяц назад +6

      @@d4cto But it's not to the point where we are ending the trend. Take a long look at Afghanistan and the soldiers we lost there.

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +2

      Bless you ❤

    • @dickartist
      @dickartist 26 дней назад

      Eh, in WW2, the US propped up one evil regime to stop another and both the US and USSR had a role in propping up more all around the world in the decades that followed. The European theater was more about saving Britain's ass and protecting trade interests than anything else. The Pacific theater was about revenge and also protecting trade interests in the region. Even in the most black and white parts of history, there are still shades of gray under the surface.

    • @rjberes333
      @rjberes333 24 дня назад +3

      ​@@afrikasmith104913 US uniform soldiers and alot of American backers after some idiot despite the warnings from his military advisors ordered the withdrawal of our forces in Afghanistan without proper cover. Is it any wonder military recruiters can't make their quota.

  • @ExiledPiasa
    @ExiledPiasa Месяц назад +21

    As a Tomahawk tech in the USN (‘97-‘03) this man speaks the truth

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад

      Bless ❤

    • @johnmcgowan1623
      @johnmcgowan1623 5 дней назад

      This is completely off toooc but I’m sure it got a little crazy and out of the norm after the 9/11 attack for you? Bc of us going over seas into the Middle East again? Idk just a thought

  • @kensurratt2729
    @kensurratt2729 Месяц назад +30

    I'm old enough to have had Uncles in WWII and Korea. They didn't want to talk about it, till much later in life. The stories of a young man in his late teens, early twenties and how he survived. There was no Hollywood glory. You're not watching stolen valor, but the
    recollections of someones time in the European Theater.
    Blessings to this man.

  • @ryanjohnson7017
    @ryanjohnson7017 Месяц назад +137

    Never ask a veteran how many people they've killed. It's disrespectful.

    • @Onix.556
      @Onix.556 Месяц назад

      I served from 1999-2014 until I got hurt. I was in 18th Airborne Corp then got moved to 82nd Airborne. I’ve deployed multiple times and in my 14 years I was always in a combat MOS. I never took it as disrespectful when someone asked. Maybe because the first person to ask me made me laugh hard and always think of him. My wife’s younger brother was about 8 years old when I came back from 1st deployment. He ran up to me and immediately gave me a hug and said “DID YA KILL ANY OF THOSE FUKERS?” in a young redneck voice.
      My wife smacked him and said his full name and “don’t ask him that” and I just died laughing and now always think of that moment when asked but yeah, I never take it as disrespectful, I know kids are kids and want to know that type of thing.

    • @michaeloliveri1907
      @michaeloliveri1907 Месяц назад +12

      Agreed!

    • @dominicthomas4111
      @dominicthomas4111 Месяц назад +13

      Yea people think life's a video game

    • @IceTTom
      @IceTTom Месяц назад

      Reeeallly tho?? Reealllyy??? 😐

    • @Lady-Carmakazi
      @Lady-Carmakazi 29 дней назад +4

      I asked my father in law & he just got real quiet & said wait here. He went in his room & retrieved some black & white photos from D-day WW2 that he'd taken himself, definitely authentic . Upon looking at them I realized there were piles of clothes, shoes, other items & bodies. He'd gone over D- day & clean up afterwards. He wanted me to know why before he answered my question. He didn't have to answer me & I understood right then that he probably had too. Also had an uncle who was a helicopter gunner in Vietnam. I didn't have to ask him, that was a position that didn't need any explanation. Said some of the guys were being rough with the captives & throwing them out before they'd land. The captain said cut that out be nicer & right after he said that one tried to attack & kill him , he changed his mind said get em out of here NOW so they began pushing them out before landing again.
      Hate war, but it's sometimes a necessary evil.

  • @Johnny.Mohawk
    @Johnny.Mohawk Месяц назад +29

    I’m glad I was never sent overseas while I was in the army. I served 4 years (CAF). Left nearly 2 years before 9/11 happened. After it happened I thought about re-joining, but am glad I didn’t. Every single person I know who went to Afghanistan and made it back home, came home fucked right up. Of the 20 or so who came back, 8 killed themselves, 5 are drug addicts, 2 are in prison serving serious sentences, 1 has been in and out of a psychiatric hospital for the last decade, 1 nobody has seen or heard from in years, and the remaining 3 have severe PTSD

  • @johno1544
    @johno1544 Месяц назад +26

    Snipers know better then most soldiers how many kills they had.

  • @johndemaria9408
    @johndemaria9408 Месяц назад +46

    Thank for you honesty and service

  • @JorgePerez-gj2iq
    @JorgePerez-gj2iq Месяц назад +20

    That is a true hero a man who fought for the right reasons and lived thank you for all you did and all you lost may god bless you with many more years.

    • @delltawnnorthri7459
      @delltawnnorthri7459 Месяц назад

      The right reasons are to secure the enslavement of western enslavement for the bankers and media powers that be, of a certain middle eastern tribe?
      Direct link to fighting in that war to the LGBT, debt ridden, degenerate world we now live.

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +1

      God bless you too❤

  • @idipped2521
    @idipped2521 Месяц назад +17

    You can see in his eyes he was at war

  • @preztruman-tv9zi
    @preztruman-tv9zi Месяц назад +12

    Semper Fi, that, Sir. So glad you made it back🇺🇸🫡🇺🇸

    • @albinodino343
      @albinodino343 Месяц назад

      You've come a long way, yet again you haven't met Frank horrigan

    • @archdornan8349
      @archdornan8349 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@albinodino343Ain't no way you think that Horrigan coined "semper fi" 😂 get off fallout 2 man

  • @MichaelGronski
    @MichaelGronski Месяц назад +11

    Thank you for your service young man!!😊

    • @yvonneplant9434
      @yvonneplant9434 Месяц назад

      He may have gotten drafted.

    • @adl_gamer2694
      @adl_gamer2694 Месяц назад

      @@yvonneplant9434prolly but it’s still your choice to come home alive or in a box, thank you for your service

    • @PaladinThizz
      @PaladinThizz Месяц назад +2

      @@adl_gamer2694it’s not your choice. No one chooses to die in a foreign land

  • @phillipkirby502
    @phillipkirby502 Месяц назад +29

    Thank you for your service Sir.

  • @patrickpatterson3356
    @patrickpatterson3356 Месяц назад +17

    I salute you sir thankyou for your service and god bless all veterans

  • @betsydonato6817
    @betsydonato6817 Месяц назад +12

    Some pretty far away eyes , but the voice is still humbling to hear. Thank you for your service.

  • @alfredoballesteros2764
    @alfredoballesteros2764 Месяц назад +32

    Thank you much for your service Sir!

  • @AKAKiddo
    @AKAKiddo Месяц назад +252

    When somebody asks a question like that, "how many men did you kill", you know they have no clue as to what they're talking about.

    • @samuelmmmk181
      @samuelmmmk181 Месяц назад +10

      Not what he meant, but ok

    • @Dendoi_
      @Dendoi_ Месяц назад +18

      yes they don't know, that's why they asked?

    • @RC_Engineering
      @RC_Engineering Месяц назад +14

      ​@@Dendoi_ no it's the worst part of a soldier's job, it's rude because it's a horrible thing they had to do.

    • @Dendoi_
      @Dendoi_ Месяц назад +14

      @@RC_Engineering Depends who you ask, some people loved their time in war

    • @WorthlessDeadEnd
      @WorthlessDeadEnd Месяц назад

      @@Dendoi_ Don't believe the propaganda and Hollywood movies.

  • @GavinAkers-mg4nd
    @GavinAkers-mg4nd Месяц назад +19

    My father had quite a few (26) confirmed in Iraq over two deployments. One thing he’ll say when civilians ask him is that he doesn’t know the true number, especially with night firefights as it’s shooting as flashes or small targets until you don’t see it.

    • @aesop2733
      @aesop2733 26 дней назад

      imo it's pretty disrespectful to ask a veteran that. The fact that he has to have a canned response for it is kind of sad. He might be fine with it but it just feels like responding to bad social etiquette

    • @LandMonster0311
      @LandMonster0311 20 дней назад

      There's no such thing as confirmed kills in the military, even for snipers. It's a Hollywood invention. Your dad is telling stories.

  • @TOGade-dj6jh
    @TOGade-dj6jh Месяц назад +85

    That’s what my dad told me once. He was a UN soldier in Congo in the sixties and saw plenty of action. He doesn’t like to talk about it but sometimes he does. He told me he only remembers his first kill, he used a grenade launcher, but he says that in a firefight there confusion and fear rolled into one and all he could think was: “I’m not going home in a coffin”.

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +1

      Bless 🙌 ❤

    • @NoriKassidy
      @NoriKassidy 25 дней назад +1

      Your father is a very brave man, then.

    • @TOGade-dj6jh
      @TOGade-dj6jh 24 дня назад

      @@NoriKassidy thank you, I agree. He’s been an awesome father as well. Even if he has never said he loves me or am proud of me he shows it in so many other ways. No matter what happens he’s right by my side. He’s 81 and more vital than most teenagers today.

  • @joelburgess3278
    @joelburgess3278 Месяц назад +38

    War is war, I hate being asked that question, it’s always ask by someone that hasn’t been there, like we would keep score, heaven forbid. Needless to say, after the first one, your soul becomes a little darker, the question those people need to ask in how many people did you save by taking the responsibility to fight and possibly die for their freedoms.

    • @brandip77
      @brandip77 Месяц назад +6

      Wow. This is deep. Something I never thought of. Thank you for your service.

    • @docdeadsailor7865
      @docdeadsailor7865 Месяц назад +5

      Truth bro. Believing I’m a good man is the only reason I haven’t “opted out” yet.

    • @macva553
      @macva553 Месяц назад +4

      Please tell us how many people you saved by killing people on the other side of the world so you can make your country richer.

    • @BudgetGunsandGearReviews
      @BudgetGunsandGearReviews Месяц назад

      ​@@macva553tell me you're an asshole without saying you're an asshole

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +1

      Infinite blessings and prayers your way ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @CWA69143
    @CWA69143 29 дней назад +1

    Thank you for your service sir!!!

  • @deloridwright3721
    @deloridwright3721 Месяц назад +10

    thank you for your service to America.

  • @audreywitko1445
    @audreywitko1445 Месяц назад +19

    Thank you, sir, for your service & bravery. I pray each day for a time where war will be no more.

    • @mucicafrajer9882
      @mucicafrajer9882 Месяц назад +1

      "Humans will not stop fighting until there is one human or less"

    • @audreywitko1445
      @audreywitko1445 Месяц назад +1

      @@mucicafrajer9882 I chose to believe that in the not too distant future Humanity will choose peace.

    • @Yue_Jin
      @Yue_Jin Месяц назад

      @@audreywitko1445 They're literally genociding those from Europe right now to replace them with people that are easier to enslave. There will never be peace lmao.

    • @redfog2010
      @redfog2010 Месяц назад +2

      ​@@audreywitko1445, war has and always be a part of the human condition. All we can truly hope for is for generations who know not of bloodshed. We must inspire our generation and the next to create that world. For borders cannot be distinguished from orbit, and earth the cradle of mankind.

    • @flatded
      @flatded Месяц назад

      humans will only stop killing each other, when there's a threat from the outside to the whole humanity

  • @darlatidwell6255
    @darlatidwell6255 Месяц назад +18

    Thank you for your service.

  • @thankgodimouttahere
    @thankgodimouttahere 29 дней назад +1

    Respect our Veterans

  • @holycrap0866
    @holycrap0866 Месяц назад +27

    When I was around 13 I asked my WWII dad if he killed a Nazi in the war.
    His face went contorted and he said “go help your mother”
    I was confused. I had never seen him so upset with me. I never knew why until my brothers were in Vietnam.

    • @PaladinThizz
      @PaladinThizz Месяц назад

      @Aesop123 they were all nazis, just not all of them believed in what they were fighting for

    • @seanharris8419
      @seanharris8419 9 дней назад +1

      @@PaladinThizzThey definitely were not all Nazis. The Nazis were a political party that took power in Germany. That’s it. Saying they were all Nazis is the modern day equivalent of saying “every soldier in the US army today is a republican (or democrat).”

  • @martinoregan3028
    @martinoregan3028 Месяц назад +21

    A real soldier here

  • @thefacesofsteven839
    @thefacesofsteven839 17 дней назад +1

    God Bless that mans service! I am able to live free in this great country because of your sacrifice.🙏🏻🇺🇲

  • @dirtmover6190
    @dirtmover6190 Месяц назад +15

    Exactly my friend there’s no way to know, and I would not want to know

  • @leemaresh6855
    @leemaresh6855 Месяц назад +15

    Thank you sir for your service..God bless you .

  • @littlemark01
    @littlemark01 Месяц назад +18

    Thank God for our awesome soldiers.

  • @laveos82
    @laveos82 Месяц назад +132

    YOU DONT EVER ASK A SOLDIER HOW MANY MEN YOUVE KILLED! EVER!

    • @mikerotch2654
      @mikerotch2654 Месяц назад +3

      Why

    • @iisthirsty1403
      @iisthirsty1403 Месяц назад +7

      Its quite traumatic ​@mikerotch2654

    • @duoblade332
      @duoblade332 Месяц назад +8

      You ask, How many men did you save?

    • @constantin240
      @constantin240 Месяц назад

      Why? You don’t want the kids to know what war is? So they don’t learn about why you don’t go to war? And the war cicle to go on? Yes, that’s why. It don’t go well for the Oligarchy and royals.

    • @hawjhawj5251
      @hawjhawj5251 Месяц назад

      Why

  • @roryrumpler6807
    @roryrumpler6807 8 дней назад +2

    A true American soldier

  • @chrisreidland
    @chrisreidland Месяц назад +16

    Sorry you had to go through that Sir.

  • @charliemoore4047
    @charliemoore4047 Месяц назад +98

    To busy trying to stay alive than count

    • @robertnault5865
      @robertnault5865 29 дней назад +2

      Yeah , its morbid to think about it so long like that.your there to do a job.get it done,survive,get outa there!!!

    • @philgiglio7922
      @philgiglio7922 29 дней назад +7

      It's a question that should NEVER be asked of ANY combat vet...it's insensitive and may trigger a flashback.

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад

      God bless ❤

    • @infiniteinspiration1628
      @infiniteinspiration1628 27 дней назад +1

      ​@@philgiglio7922truest truth ❤bless you ❤

  • @tracycobb9499
    @tracycobb9499 28 дней назад

    Thank you for your sacrifice and service.❤❤❤❤

  • @TonyMontana-en4qb
    @TonyMontana-en4qb 20 дней назад

    Thank you for your service young man

  • @theprancingprussian
    @theprancingprussian Месяц назад +22

    Best way to describe some firefights
    Unlike most vidsogames you have a sense of self preservation and so does the enemy, you get behind what cover you can and fire at each other with a 20 percent chance of a hit overall or less
    You try and pin them down while you flank or get an mg set up

    • @augustuscaeser5895
      @augustuscaeser5895 Месяц назад

      It’s estimated that WW2 and Vietnam the US fired around 50k rounds per kill. Point stands, but 20% is a massive estimate (probably even if you run it on a probability of actually killing someone per firefight instead of per shot, but less extreme of an overestimate and I don’t know those numbers lol)

    • @theprancingprussian
      @theprancingprussian Месяц назад +1

      @@augustuscaeser5895 i probably over estimated
      Pretty sure ww1 saw 1 in 50 shots hit and ww2 see 200 or similar with Vietnam having smaller hitrate

    • @axeguy3856
      @axeguy3856 29 дней назад +1

      I read in a book on combat psychology (long after service) that in WWII, only 26% of US soldiers pulled their triggers aiming directly at the enemy. In Vietnam it was close to 95%…it was the conditioning and the close proximity…and these vets paid the price.

  • @user-od1ob4gg9b
    @user-od1ob4gg9b Месяц назад +24

    Thanku Sir for serving our country with bravery '& courage

  • @decemberbaby9549
    @decemberbaby9549 Месяц назад

    God bless our Veterans❤

  • @Brometheus420
    @Brometheus420 Месяц назад +11

    Pretty sure this pointman got his ear pierced in the field. You don't see a lot of pointmen.

  • @nickengstrom1983
    @nickengstrom1983 Месяц назад +6

    The sadness and terror in this man’s eyes tell you everything you could possibly want to know. I can’t imagine the things he’s had to live with.

  • @cjsiatkowski5144
    @cjsiatkowski5144 Месяц назад +19

    Thank you for your service and bravery, sir. You are a true American hero.

  • @marykellerzacks9110
    @marykellerzacks9110 Месяц назад +1

    Pray for peace

  • @darreljoseph
    @darreljoseph 11 дней назад

    Truth is unbelievable for people who never lived this unfortunate life . God bless you brother.

  • @janetdoten4489
    @janetdoten4489 Месяц назад +6

    Don't ask. God bless you and thanks for your service

  • @mikedorava7961
    @mikedorava7961 Месяц назад +120

    I think it's kinda disrespectful to EVEN ASK a question like that. Many of our soldiers, Marines, sailors, and airmen, suffering from PTSD, have spent their lives trying to forget the answer to that question. I understand the morbid curiosity, but please, unless they volunteer such information, have the discipline to refrain from asking. 🇺🇸 To those of you who have served, thank you for your service!

    • @robertsanchez5652
      @robertsanchez5652 Месяц назад +2

      Yea but this was at a time when nearly ever US male had in some shape or form seen combat. 1 out of every 8 US soldiers killed or injured

    • @spencer1381
      @spencer1381 Месяц назад +9

      I agree but this isn’t just a civilian issue. My grandpa fought in the battle of hue he was invited to a marine corps ball and the other vets were bragging about how many kills they got, I wasn’t there with them but when they asked my grandpa my dad told me he didn’t answer the question and never went back to another ball… You’re 100% right, These men lived it they take pride in being marines and support their brothers but when you ask them such terrible questions regardless of your intent it puts them back in those dark times.

    • @mattmarzula
      @mattmarzula Месяц назад +1

      ​@@spencer1381everyone is different. People handle things differently. While I have an answer to the question, I tell people the same thing every time. It doesn't matter that you do your job. It matters how you do your job.

    • @kaladin4138
      @kaladin4138 Месяц назад

      very few airmen suffer from ptsd, and if they do its cause the internet ran out on their 'deployments'

    • @spencer1381
      @spencer1381 Месяц назад +3

      @@mattmarzula I’m sure the fact he fought in the deadliest battle of Vietnam played a part in this, If you saw a lot of ur buddies die you probably wouldn’t feel like sitting there and boasting about your kill count either🤷‍♂️

  • @jackavery7179
    @jackavery7179 Месяц назад

    Thank for your service, sir 🇺🇲

  • @robertphillips6296
    @robertphillips6296 Месяц назад +15

    In combat if you stop to count or keep score your gonna be on somebody else's Body Count.

  • @jasonhausenfluck1163
    @jasonhausenfluck1163 Месяц назад +7

    Thank you for your service

  • @karenfields-sb4cq
    @karenfields-sb4cq Месяц назад +12

    Thank you for your service sir😊

  • @AfiSM
    @AfiSM 25 дней назад

    For all veterans from out there I just want to say thank you for your service to your beautiful country

  • @keithbarnes4509
    @keithbarnes4509 9 дней назад

    Thank you, sir, for your sacrifice and service.

  • @DagNaggit
    @DagNaggit Месяц назад +121

    he looks you straight in the eyes while talking about killing someone

    • @boboh8209
      @boboh8209 Месяц назад +10

      He wasn't looking the man he was talking to in the eye he was looking at the man he killed fs

    • @brianfischer149
      @brianfischer149 Месяц назад +7

      And that man is part of the reason you have the Freedom's you have today !

    • @666Kaca
      @666Kaca Месяц назад

      He talks about not killing a human being tho. The enemy was a nvzi

    • @ejam4345
      @ejam4345 Месяц назад

      ​@@666Kacathat's the same logic that allowed the Nazis to kill so many Jews

    • @-_----__-_----_--
      @-_----__-_----_-- Месяц назад

      @@666Kaca Still human. No guarantee they were all SS either. He killed Germans, Germans are human.

  • @CapnCharlie
    @CapnCharlie Месяц назад +7

    Rip to this man, I've seen a couple videos of him and he always seemed to be in a good mood.

  • @alexanderstewart1885
    @alexanderstewart1885 15 дней назад

    You're a brave man. Thank you for your service 🙏

  • @cherylgartside2547
    @cherylgartside2547 21 день назад

    Thank you for your service and sacrifices. GOD BLESS YOU. 🙏

  • @pzkw6759
    @pzkw6759 Месяц назад +15

    Thank you, Mr. Manley, sir

  • @MarshallAnderson-if8yx
    @MarshallAnderson-if8yx Месяц назад +15

    Thank you sir for all you did and congratulations on making it back alive! Respect!!

  • @thekid4698
    @thekid4698 Месяц назад +4

    That poor man he is hurting inside thank you for your service the greatest generation 🇺🇸

    • @andrewk.7498
      @andrewk.7498 Месяц назад +1

      He knows we fought the wrong enemy

    • @bobcat24
      @bobcat24 Месяц назад

      @@andrewk.7498What are you talking about?

    • @ericolsen5592
      @ericolsen5592 Месяц назад

      ​@@andrewk.7498Patton would slap you and all the other sympathizers silly for misinterpreting that quote so much

  • @danalamb8398
    @danalamb8398 Месяц назад

    Thank-you, sir, for your service to our Country.

  • @rickfurey74
    @rickfurey74 8 дней назад

    Thank you Sir I salute you and I will stand beside you then and now to honor and to protect our country

  • @ronkohout676
    @ronkohout676 Месяц назад +60

    I would never ask a veteran if he killed anyone or how many. I personally think it is very disrespectful.

    • @spicyhummus6266
      @spicyhummus6266 Месяц назад +2

      Yeah the trauma they went through for all of the coming generations to be able to live a comfortable & free life, I think its totally unfair to them to bring up what could be very traumatic memories... I know if I killed another person, even in war & a kill or be killed situation, as much as I could justify it, in my head all I would be able to think about is that we the pawns were basically forced into this war & that's a human being I killed that no longer gets to experience life & it was my actions that caused it. That's a son (in this day & age it could also be a daughter) that doesn't get to go back to their Mum & Dad, or if they had kids the kids no longer have a parent, a lost sibling, uncle/aunty. I think it would crushed me to have been a war vet that killed people. This is what makes me sad about the current war in Ukraine, for both sides, even the possibility for Taiwan & China. Its not the Dictators that want the war that will be affected in any way shape or form but the pawns in their game. Evil.

    • @artg6700
      @artg6700 Месяц назад +3

      @@spicyhummus6266yeah for the WW2 veterans alive sure, they definitely risked it all and many many died for the betterment of the world but basically all the other wars we’ve been in have not been about protecting America it’s been about money

  • @warbosswurldsmasha5414
    @warbosswurldsmasha5414 Месяц назад +24

    "I killed fitty men!"
    -Cotton Hill

    • @garret47
      @garret47 Месяц назад +2

      I see the resemblance 😂👏🏼

  • @Bob-in1bc
    @Bob-in1bc Месяц назад +1

    All I have to say is thank you old timer for your service.

  • @keithnorrod6878
    @keithnorrod6878 Месяц назад +3

    The Greatest Generation !!
    May God Bless and Keep Him Always 🙏

  • @Jackmerius_Tacktheritrix5733
    @Jackmerius_Tacktheritrix5733 Месяц назад +15

    My grandfather died in a concentration camp. Poor guy had a heart attack in the guard tower.

    • @ironclad452
      @ironclad452 Месяц назад

      He was a guard in a concentration camp tower? Eek

  • @donaldchristian7556
    @donaldchristian7556 22 дня назад

    Thank-you Ed for your service and sacrifice ❤!

  • @marcmenton8063
    @marcmenton8063 Месяц назад

    Thank you sir for your service to our country

  • @michaelcollins2488
    @michaelcollins2488 Месяц назад +9

    God bless that generation..

  • @nostoneunturned7641
    @nostoneunturned7641 Месяц назад +29

    All except Cotton Hill. Everyone knows his score.

  • @advancedrescue4083
    @advancedrescue4083 28 дней назад +1

    Thank you, Sir! 🙏🏼

  • @jaynefinley
    @jaynefinley 29 дней назад

    Greatest Generation- Hats off to you sir. Thank you for protecting our democracy.
    Thanks for posting this video and honoring this veteran.

  • @Jordan-rb28
    @Jordan-rb28 Месяц назад +11

    I know for a fact my great grandpa had 2 killed from the ball turret of a B-17. That's all he truly 'knew.'

  • @volksdude1970
    @volksdude1970 Месяц назад +88

    That is a number few want to be proud of, and one that you should never ask a soldier.
    Chris Kyle, the American Sniper who was credited with the highest confirmed kill counts always loathed hearing his kill count. He would rather prefer to count the number of lives he saved in those situations.
    God Bless our troops, and those who fought for freedom and peace, anywhere and any time.

    • @Arthurian.
      @Arthurian. Месяц назад +5

      You never heard of the Reaper. Plenty do not care in the least. Believe it or not, humans are a vicious & violent animal that thrive in war.

    • @calebk1841
      @calebk1841 Месяц назад

      @Arthurian sounds cool but is basically stupid. Nobody thrives in war. Some people enjoy bloodshed but it’s to their own detriment. We can see how the Middle East and Africa is “thriving” while Europe is ‘suffering’ lol

    • @davechongle
      @davechongle Месяц назад +15

      he loathed it so much that he still kept count and told the world? chris kyle is a hack with a huge ego. he still served the country, but he is not someone to look up to.

    • @piyo744
      @piyo744 Месяц назад

      chris kyle was a child murderer and a liar lol

    • @dotesondots
      @dotesondots Месяц назад +2

      Amen

  • @ChristopherAguilera-ez7eq
    @ChristopherAguilera-ez7eq 19 дней назад

    All my respect sir. Thank you for your service and sacrifice.

  • @bdcinac
    @bdcinac 11 дней назад

    Thank you for your service, Sir.

  • @user-qc2mi5be1s
    @user-qc2mi5be1s Месяц назад +6

    Thank you ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @user-by4hz3cf1i
    @user-by4hz3cf1i Месяц назад

    Thank you for your service!! 🇺🇸

  • @badmonkey7001
    @badmonkey7001 8 дней назад +1

    Words are so profound.

  • @williamherold1776
    @williamherold1776 Месяц назад +7

    Knowing would haunt you until your last day.

  • @bullseyedixon5660
    @bullseyedixon5660 Месяц назад +6

    THANK YOU