dude your channel is amazing. like you’re so dedicated to it and run it so professionally and the production value on EVERYTHING is so good?? how do u not have way more clout ??
I haven't done a very good job of appeasing the RUclips deities. I'm supposed to feed the algorithm every week, but I don't post nearly that frequently ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
My question is because the Julian calendar lost a day every 128 years, then by 1582 the calendar would be off by 12 days. But the Gregorian only moved up 10 days. So aren’t we technically 2 days off from the Solar calendar?
I just moved and went from attending an Antiochian Orthodox Church that uses the Julian calendar for all the movable feasts and the Gregorian calendar for everything else to a Serbian Orthodox Church that uses the Julian calendar for everything.
The Julian calender was based on the ancient Kemet (Egyptian) Calender which was more organised. 12 months of 30 days + 5 days at the end of the year. The Julian calender messed up the number of the days of the month!!! How come February is 28 days?!!! Some months are 30 days and the others are 31, for no specific reason!!! The year start from mid Winter!!! Why???
When I was a child I observed xmas on the 25th December in the gregorian calendar but also the 25th December in the julian calendar which is currently (until 2099) 13 days behind the gregorian calendar so from the years 1901 to 2099 January 7th in the gregorian calendar is December 25th julian calendar. So I got gifts on two days 13 days apart.
Thanks for the detailed explanation on this inter-calendar anomaly! By the way, this also explains why the two Russian revolutions of 1917 are called the "February Revolution" and the "October Revolution" (based on the Julian months), despite taking place in March and November on the Gregorian calendar. Also, I find it particularly strange that the Russian Orthodox Church is still holding on to the Julian calendar, even when all of the civil authorities (except maybe a few stragglers with completely different calendars), including in Russia itself, adopted the Gregorian calendar! At least you can have Christmas twice!
I'll take this as a serious question. It's a matter of degree. As something roughly TWENTY-SIX times better than the Julian for adhering to the Solstices and Equinoxes, it only requires a further adjustment by one day every THIRTY-TWO centuries, plus about one half! It so happens that the skipping of leap year days is in the same direction as Julian to current Gregorian. Take a leap year day out over a period of time, rather than add any.
@@ForwardMan3001 And the million dollar question that no one has answered is, *"How long is the true solar year exactly?"* _Solar Calendars_ 365 days (Egyptians) 365.25 days (Julian) 365.2422 days (Gregorian) _Lunar Calendars_ 354 days All of the above fall behind the true solar year yet we aren't told exactly how long the true solar year is. When you do the math: *7 days × 52 weeks = 364 days* This is the only reasonable answer I can come to. A historical study on the Gregorian calendar shows you that it was only created to keep Catholics from celebrating Easter at the same time Jews observed Passover...it never corrected any real issues with observances of equinoxes and solstices.
I gave made some fictional characters that are of a fictional nation celebrate some holidays twice a year due to their country not having a preference between the two calendars. They use both and specify similarly to how the United States is familiar with both the Fahrenheit and Celsius scales (even if Fahrenheit is used more outside of Science classes and experiments) and specify which is one is being used and learn at some point how to convert the two. One character said the Catholics primary prefer one calendar and the Orthodox's primarily prefer another, but the country doesn't feel like playing favorites, so they teach both and those who don't think it matters so much will sometimes use it as an excuse to celebrate twice and visit with one side of the family or group of people for one and the other or another for the other. When the the two Easter dates line up, they make a huge deal out of it and treat it like its extra special. Yeah I might have created a bunch of craziness based around the calendar debate. 😂
Wait. So if a year is exactly 365 days, why did they have to add a day every leap year? That would push it in the other direction. That's rhetorical btw, I already know the real calendar.
Just The Russians and the Serbs. Plus the orthodox church of Jerusalem. The Greeks, the Romanians, the Bulgarians, the Georgians celebrate Christmas by the Gregorian calendar.
The majority of Orthodox Christians celebrates Christmas on January 7th.....The Georgians are on the Julian Calendar too......By the way not all Greeks, Romanians and Bulgarians celebrate Christmas on the Gregorian Calendar
It would have made more sense to eliminate a leap year day every 128 years. This would have been very smooth because 128 is evenly divisible by 4. More to the point is that matching the solstices and exuinoxes is closer with such a system than skipping 3 such days every 400 years.
That’s why we do that for centuries that aren’t divisible by 400. The leap year is removed. That way in the Gregorian calendar we lose a day every 3226 years
F the deities and their Eyetalian counterparts, keep up the amazing standards and do what you do for the right reasons, i just binged a few of your vid's and am SO impressed with the content and presentation, ima subscribe and make my first comment ever, so be gentle, never done this before
Serbia,macedonia,montenegro,belarus,Georgia and ethiopia all celebrate on 7th January Because that is the orthodox real calendar 25 December is catholic papal paganism Real date is on 7 January
You might have been just joking about the East and West splitting over using yeast in the Eucharist but to people who are uninformed it paints a very silly picture of the schism which was about much more serious issues like the primacy of the pope, the filioque etc
здравствуйте! Great video! :-) There are so many bad, uninformed RUclips videos on this subject, but this is excellent. Great graphics too! The only major problem I have is that you're so beautiful that I found it hard to concentrate on what you were saying :D I'm a devout Christian, but neither Catholic nor Protestant. I go with what the Bible says. I don't celebrate Christmas - the Bible tells us to boycott pagan festivals and idolatry (eg Jer 10:3). It also tells us that the Lord Jesus was born in October/September (you have to do some digging, but it's there). I LOVE Russia! One of the greatest, most moral countries in the world! Sadly, my own country (the UK) has become the most evil, sinister and godless country on the planet within the past few decades. I no longer associate with the hell hole that is UK, I support Israel and the Jews - they may not be living right, but the Bible says those people are beloved to God, so they're beloved to me too! Well honey, I hope your channel gets more views. It deserves to. I've subscribed! :-) I'll check out some of your other videos. I'll try to pay attention to what you're saying but no promises! :/
12/02/1996 And The name is Julian, wow to see that the 21st century would have had a big climate issue haha. And yet I do believe in Jesus the christ we see as today's date, oh yeah leap year 2024 Feb 29th not 28th or 365 it will be 366 days as An leap year of 1996s Hell yeah how you like me now lol
Actually, all bodies in the Solar System revolve around the center of mass. This would happen to be inside the surface of the Sun. I would take the time to explain it to you, but I'll leave it to your mommy and daddy, youngster. I might not be careful enough in delivery. The risk is that I would short out your brain.
Why are you even on the web? GPS would not even work as it does with your pancake delusion. Engineers would have noticed this and notified everybody. Trust me, adults do not care what you "think"!
dude your channel is amazing. like you’re so dedicated to it and run it so professionally and the production value on EVERYTHING is so good?? how do u not have way more clout ??
glad i stumbled upon this gonna binge lmao
I haven't done a very good job of appeasing the RUclips deities. I'm supposed to feed the algorithm every week, but I don't post nearly that frequently ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Yeah, This sis is so professional yet simple and clear with her explanation.. really appreciate it👍❤️❤️❤️
2:35 Pope Gregory the 13th should be written as Gregory XIII, not Gregory XVIII which is 18.
Fantastic video. Really well explained, in a fun charming way :) Got yourself another subscriber!
You explained this very well
Come back to RUclips
My question is because the Julian calendar lost a day every 128 years, then by 1582 the calendar would be off by 12 days. But the Gregorian only moved up 10 days. So aren’t we technically 2 days off from the Solar calendar?
This videos' quality is amazing! Underrated channel for sure.
Absolutely brilliant 👏 thanks for the explanation you lovely lady
So 😎 cool ! I've been doing the double Christmas for years. Is there a relationship between the 12 days of Christmas and the calendar?
Beautiful information
I just moved and went from attending an Antiochian Orthodox Church that uses the Julian calendar for all the movable feasts and the Gregorian calendar for everything else to a Serbian Orthodox Church that uses the Julian calendar for everything.
thank you very much, now I know why my parents celebrated both Christmas dates
The Julian calender was based on the ancient Kemet (Egyptian) Calender which was more organised. 12 months of 30 days + 5 days at the end of the year.
The Julian calender messed up the number of the days of the month!!!
How come February is 28 days?!!!
Some months are 30 days and the others are 31, for no specific reason!!!
The year start from mid Winter!!! Why???
When I was a child I observed xmas on the 25th December in the gregorian calendar but also the 25th December in the julian calendar which is currently (until 2099) 13 days behind the gregorian calendar so from the years 1901 to 2099 January 7th in the gregorian calendar is December 25th julian calendar. So I got gifts on two days 13 days apart.
Concise and accurate explanation. Thank you!
Calendar can be fully in touch and you can still get snow in April. 😂
Fantastic video!
Beautifully explained! Thanks.
You're welcome! Thanks for watching 😊
Awesome, Having 2 Christmas days in a year.
Subscribed :)
Great video
Thanks for the detailed explanation on this inter-calendar anomaly! By the way, this also explains why the two Russian revolutions of 1917 are called the "February Revolution" and the "October Revolution" (based on the Julian months), despite taking place in March and November on the Gregorian calendar.
Also, I find it particularly strange that the Russian Orthodox Church is still holding on to the Julian calendar, even when all of the civil authorities (except maybe a few stragglers with completely different calendars), including in Russia itself, adopted the Gregorian calendar! At least you can have Christmas twice!
Let me get this straight...after the Gregorian reform we still fall behind the solar year? What actually was corrected if it still falls behind?
I'll take this as a serious question.
It's a matter of degree.
As something roughly TWENTY-SIX times better than the Julian for adhering to the Solstices and Equinoxes, it only requires a further adjustment by one day every THIRTY-TWO centuries, plus about one half!
It so happens that the skipping of leap year days is in the same direction as Julian to current Gregorian. Take a leap year day out over a period of time, rather than add any.
@@ForwardMan3001 And the million dollar question that no one has answered is, *"How long is the true solar year exactly?"*
_Solar Calendars_
365 days (Egyptians)
365.25 days (Julian)
365.2422 days (Gregorian)
_Lunar Calendars_
354 days
All of the above fall behind the true solar year yet we aren't told exactly how long the true solar year is. When you do the math:
*7 days × 52 weeks = 364 days*
This is the only reasonable answer I can come to. A historical study on the Gregorian calendar shows you that it was only created to keep Catholics from celebrating Easter at the same time Jews observed Passover...it never corrected any real issues with observances of equinoxes and solstices.
I gave made some fictional characters that are of a fictional nation celebrate some holidays twice a year due to their country not having a preference between the two calendars. They use both and specify similarly to how the United States is familiar with both the Fahrenheit and Celsius scales (even if Fahrenheit is used more outside of Science classes and experiments) and specify which is one is being used and learn at some point how to convert the two. One character said the Catholics primary prefer one calendar and the Orthodox's primarily prefer another, but the country doesn't feel like playing favorites, so they teach both and those who don't think it matters so much will sometimes use it as an excuse to celebrate twice and visit with one side of the family or group of people for one and the other or another for the other. When the the two Easter dates line up, they make a huge deal out of it and treat it like its extra special. Yeah I might have created a bunch of craziness based around the calendar debate. 😂
nice!
Where did you get the idea that the Roman Calendar was 355 days long? Just curious. Couldn't find anything on it.
С Рождеством
С Рождеством 2.0!
Okay you are perfect
Because the year 2100 will never be a leap year in Gregorian calendar but it is a leap year in Julian calendar
So technically i was born on Christmas. I'M JESUS
Wait. So if a year is exactly 365 days, why did they have to add a day every leap year? That would push it in the other direction. That's rhetorical btw, I already know the real calendar.
Just The Russians and the Serbs. Plus the orthodox church of Jerusalem. The Greeks, the Romanians, the Bulgarians, the Georgians celebrate Christmas by the Gregorian calendar.
Georgians???
The Macedonians celebrate on the 7th
The majority of Orthodox Christians celebrates Christmas on January 7th.....The Georgians are on the Julian Calendar too......By the way not all Greeks, Romanians and Bulgarians celebrate Christmas on the Gregorian Calendar
It would have made more sense to eliminate a leap year day every 128 years. This would have been very smooth because 128 is evenly divisible by 4. More to the point is that matching the solstices and exuinoxes is closer with such a system than skipping 3 such days every 400 years.
That’s why we do that for centuries that aren’t divisible by 400. The leap year is removed. That way in the Gregorian calendar we lose a day every 3226 years
Actually, these two guys were not Italians.
F the deities and their Eyetalian counterparts, keep up the amazing standards and do what you do for the right reasons, i just binged a few of your vid's and am SO impressed with the content and presentation, ima subscribe and make my first comment ever, so be gentle, never done this before
Why Russia only have january 7 Christmas?
Serbia,macedonia,montenegro,belarus,Georgia and ethiopia all celebrate on 7th January
Because that is the orthodox real calendar
25 December is catholic papal paganism
Real date is on 7 January
I'm playing Escape from Tarkov and wanted to know how long the christmas tree/santa/frost would be ingame :D ty
You might have been just joking about the East and West splitting over using yeast in the Eucharist but to people who are uninformed it paints a very silly picture of the schism which was about much more serious issues like the primacy of the pope, the filioque etc
as 200% atheist i is just not a celebrating any crhistmas, but only the New Year (31 Dec-1 Jan) :)
Chances are Jesus Christ wasn't born in the Winter at all. We just celebrate Him around that time of year.
Would you please remove the "EFF YOU" from the video? It would be a decent video to show kids without that.
здравствуйте! Great video! :-) There are so many bad, uninformed RUclips videos on this subject, but this is excellent. Great graphics too! The only major problem I have is that you're so beautiful that I found it hard to concentrate on what you were saying :D
I'm a devout Christian, but neither Catholic nor Protestant. I go with what the Bible says. I don't celebrate Christmas - the Bible tells us to boycott pagan festivals and idolatry (eg Jer 10:3). It also tells us that the Lord Jesus was born in October/September (you have to do some digging, but it's there).
I LOVE Russia! One of the greatest, most moral countries in the world! Sadly, my own country (the UK) has become the most evil, sinister and godless country on the planet within the past few decades. I no longer associate with the hell hole that is UK, I support Israel and the Jews - they may not be living right, but the Bible says those people are beloved to God, so they're beloved to me too!
Well honey, I hope your channel gets more views. It deserves to. I've subscribed! :-) I'll check out some of your other videos. I'll try to pay attention to what you're saying but no promises! :/
FYI. Christmas Easter are not pagan holidays
Happy Russian Christmas! I didn’t even realize until I watched this video lol
12/02/1996 And The name is Julian, wow to see that the 21st century would have had a big climate issue haha. And yet I do believe in Jesus the christ we see as today's date, oh yeah leap year 2024 Feb 29th not 28th or 365 it will be 366 days as An leap year of 1996s Hell yeah how you like me now lol
Det Moroz and Snegurichka! C Prozdneekom C Noviym Godiym!
Armenians make great slamtoys
What makes you believe our earth goes around the sun?
Actually, all bodies in the Solar System revolve around the center of mass. This would happen to be inside the surface of the Sun.
I would take the time to explain it to you, but I'll leave it to your mommy and daddy, youngster. I might not be careful enough in delivery. The risk is that I would short out your brain.
The earth is flat and earth was created by God
Why are you even on the web? GPS would not even work as it does with your pancake delusion. Engineers would have noticed this and notified everybody.
Trust me, adults do not care what you "think"!
Yeshua still was not a white skinned man....on either calendar. lol
Hey, I just used what popped up in Google image search. What Google giveth, I shalt use-eth.
Seethe loser