Dizide fikret 27 yaşında, ailenin en büyük çocuğu fikretin doğum günü olduğu bölümde söylemişti. Sevketle aralarında bir yaş var, sonra Leyla leyladan bir iki yaş küçük Necla var en küçükte Ayşe, yani dizide böyle sıralama
Hi,hope you font mind Im writting on English. Im from Serbia and this telenovela was so popular in our country. And even the actors came in our country for some interviews❤ Fikrets mother in low was so popular,because thats Balkan typical mother in law.😂 And years later,we would say Cevrie mother in love(i dont know how to spell her name), and you would just know that someone is that type of in law😂 I am planning to find that book to read it now,I know that the book was also popular. Was the book fiction or done according to the real events? And which years? Past century but when exactly?
Hi! First of all thank you so much for your interest in my chanel. ♥️ Yess Cevriye was so iconic and I love how we laugh to similar things about her character. Book is taking place at last years of Ottoman Empire which is the same time writer lived(he also experienced times after ottomans and foundation of Turkey). but its not based on real events. At least as we know 😂 its actually a critical view on how people changing in those years. People trying to get modern to survive (politicaly). But the book says if we break away our traditions so much that we lost our moral values. But also cant survive in changing world without changing and without modernizing. So we can say characters are not real but the topics are. Theres so many books written at the same time about same issues. “Araba Sevdası” (Car Love) by Recaizade Mahmut Ekrem is one of my favorites. There is no popular series adaptation for this one ofc 😂. My question to you is the video is understandable even its not in English? I really want to add subtitles though. Thank you so much for your comment again ♥️
@@AsliBozlu Love your long answer❣️some words I can understand, but sentences not at all. sometimes I can tell what are you talking about but the exact sentence not that much. Subtitles would be great if you want to talk about Turkish literature. It would be interesting to many people,I am sure. Book was also popular, but at that time I got enoyed by Turkish telenovelas,coz they replaced Latinamerican telenovelas,wich i loved the most😂 And my grandparents have always been Ali Riza and Hajrije( I dont know how to write their names properly). Sheherezade was first Turskish telenovela appeared in Serbia in 21st century,before that I dont know if we had something to watch from your country. And I was like what a strange language. But my grandparents were like its Turkish. They are born in '43 and my grandfather remembers his grandmother speaking every second word as turkish word. You know Ottoman Empire ruled 4 centuries and few decades more in Serbia and other countries. So thats why our food is almost like yours,except for pig,we have to start eating pork instead of lamb so we would eat any meat at all. And there are so many Turkish words. Not to mention we are buying turkish music and make our commercial songs. We are so connected. 🤣🤣🤣 I think Paramparcha (we say paramparcad) is good quality telenovela but too dramatic with unnecessary things. One telenovela worth mentioning is Oyle bir gecer zaman ki. Interesting and really sad series,but worth watching. Sultan Sulejman was so popular but I dont like how historically inaccurate is. Feriha is amazing story very relatable for all Balkan countries,but i dont remember it ever ended and it should be shorter. Ezel was interesting,unusual. Unusual telenovela is Ask i memnu. But I dont like how violent your telenovelas are and how children are being used. So sad. My grandma sometimes cant sleep because of all violent scenes, and she wont stop watching them😂 But we are similar as people. And I also noticed that daughter in law is blamed for everything. Like they are such a harmonic family(not like everything us pushed under the rug) and than daughter in law comes and suddenly they are the most destructive and disfuncional family.
hatırladığım kadarıyla ilk 10 dakikada bahsedilen NAMUS meselesi: 1. Oğuz, Leyla'ya t*cvz ettikten sonra Leyla evlenmek istemediği halde NAMUS meselesi yüzünden zorla evlendirilmesi :( 2. Şevket evlenmeden Ferhunde ile ilişki yaşayınca Arıza istemediği halde NAMUS için kabul etmesi...(tam olarak bu muydu evlenmeleri çok hatırlamıyorum açıkçası) kitabı okurken ben de kendime sürekli yazıldığı dönemle ilgili sürekli kendime telkinde bulunmuştum :D
Evet evet. Hatta Leyla hiç istemiyordu, babasına yalvarır gibiydi evlendiklerinde. Sonra güyya bunun pişmanlığını çekiyor. Dizi de aslında çoook problematik. Zaten bu kadar gelenek görenekle elalem ne der’le, erkek adam evin reisi olur kafasıyla işlenen bi aileyi işleyip de günümüze kıyasla problematik olmaması mümkün değil
I will die to know the differences, you will do us international fans of the show such a favor if you translated this video into English, the auto-translation is not helpful.
Kitabın yazıldığı yılla şimdi ki yılları kıyaslamayın,șimdi namus kavramı farklı degil namus yok denecek kadar az.Evet namus önemli,yorumlamanız gördüğüm en kötü yorumlama.Çünkü feminist tavırlar var.
Oturup değerler üzerine uzuun bir tartışma yapsak da şu kitaba tepeden bakan tavrınızla benim videoyu izlerken aynı tavrı size almamın mantıksızlığı ortaya dökülse
Çok güzel içerik editlerine bayıldım. Kitap incelemelerinin devamı gelsin lütfen
Dizide fikret 27 yaşında, ailenin en büyük çocuğu fikretin doğum günü olduğu bölümde söylemişti. Sevketle aralarında bir yaş var, sonra Leyla leyladan bir iki yaş küçük Necla var en küçükte Ayşe, yani dizide böyle sıralama
dizide fikret en büyükleri kitapta şevket mi büyük
dizide necla leladan büyük diye hatirliyorum ben
@@user-wo3ok1ny6byok Leyla büyük 1 yaş
Bence yaprak dökümü dizisini başka kimse bu kadar mükemmel yapamazdı o kitabı gösterince finalde ki çalan şarkı burnum sızlar hala
Darmadağın hayat bitiyor ..
Kitabı yeni bitirdim. Diziyi annem sağolsun tekrar tekrar izliyorum :D yorumlarin komik ve eğlenceli takibe değer bir kanal 👍
Aşkı memnu videon anasayfama düştü izledim çok iyi geldi. Kanalını inceledim ve abone oldum. Umarım kanalın hızla büyür başarılar dilerim
Çok teşekkür ederim 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Normalde kitabı diziden güzel bulurum ama Yaprak Dökümünde tam tersi hikayeden çok özetini okumuş gibi hissettim
Gerçekten kitabı okuyunca insanın diziyi izleyeai geliyor
Hi,hope you font mind Im writting on English. Im from Serbia and this telenovela was so popular in our country. And even the actors came in our country for some interviews❤ Fikrets mother in low was so popular,because thats Balkan typical mother in law.😂 And years later,we would say Cevrie mother in love(i dont know how to spell her name), and you would just know that someone is that type of in law😂 I am planning to find that book to read it now,I know that the book was also popular. Was the book fiction or done according to the real events? And which years? Past century but when exactly?
Hi! First of all thank you so much for your interest in my chanel. ♥️ Yess Cevriye was so iconic and I love how we laugh to similar things about her character. Book is taking place at last years of Ottoman Empire which is the same time writer lived(he also experienced times after ottomans and foundation of Turkey). but its not based on real events. At least as we know 😂 its actually a critical view on how people changing in those years. People trying to get modern to survive (politicaly). But the book says if we break away our traditions so much that we lost our moral values. But also cant survive in changing world without changing and without modernizing. So we can say characters are not real but the topics are. Theres so many books written at the same time about same issues. “Araba Sevdası” (Car Love) by Recaizade Mahmut Ekrem is one of my favorites. There is no popular series adaptation for this one ofc 😂. My question to you is the video is understandable even its not in English? I really want to add subtitles though. Thank you so much for your comment again ♥️
@@AsliBozlu Love your long answer❣️some words I can understand, but sentences not at all. sometimes I can tell what are you talking about but the exact sentence not that much. Subtitles would be great if you want to talk about Turkish literature. It would be interesting to many people,I am sure.
Book was also popular, but at that time I got enoyed by Turkish telenovelas,coz they replaced Latinamerican telenovelas,wich i loved the most😂 And my grandparents have always been Ali Riza and Hajrije( I dont know how to write their names properly). Sheherezade was first Turskish telenovela appeared in Serbia in 21st century,before that I dont know if we had something to watch from your country. And I was like what a strange language. But my grandparents were like its Turkish. They are born in '43 and my grandfather remembers his grandmother speaking every second word as turkish word. You know Ottoman Empire ruled 4 centuries and few decades more in Serbia and other countries. So thats why our food is almost like yours,except for pig,we have to start eating pork instead of lamb so we would eat any meat at all.
And there are so many Turkish words. Not to mention we are buying turkish music and make our commercial songs. We are so connected. 🤣🤣🤣
I think Paramparcha (we say paramparcad) is good quality telenovela but too dramatic with unnecessary things. One telenovela worth mentioning is Oyle bir gecer zaman ki. Interesting and really sad series,but worth watching. Sultan Sulejman was so popular but I dont like how historically inaccurate is. Feriha is amazing story very relatable for all Balkan countries,but i dont remember it ever ended and it should be shorter. Ezel was interesting,unusual. Unusual telenovela is Ask i memnu.
But I dont like how violent your telenovelas are and how children are being used. So sad. My grandma sometimes cant sleep because of all violent scenes, and she wont stop watching them😂
But we are similar as people. And I also noticed that daughter in law is blamed for everything. Like they are such a harmonic family(not like everything us pushed under the rug) and than daughter in law comes and suddenly they are the most destructive and disfuncional family.
Yaprak dokumu iyi bir turk dizisi standartlarini asmis bi dizi, boyle bir dizi bi defa daha yapilamaz
hatırladığım kadarıyla ilk 10 dakikada bahsedilen NAMUS meselesi:
1. Oğuz, Leyla'ya t*cvz ettikten sonra Leyla evlenmek istemediği halde NAMUS meselesi yüzünden zorla evlendirilmesi :(
2. Şevket evlenmeden Ferhunde ile ilişki yaşayınca Arıza istemediği halde NAMUS için kabul etmesi...(tam olarak bu muydu evlenmeleri çok hatırlamıyorum açıkçası)
kitabı okurken ben de kendime sürekli yazıldığı dönemle ilgili sürekli kendime telkinde bulunmuştum :D
Evet evet. Hatta Leyla hiç istemiyordu, babasına yalvarır gibiydi evlendiklerinde. Sonra güyya bunun pişmanlığını çekiyor. Dizi de aslında çoook problematik. Zaten bu kadar gelenek görenekle elalem ne der’le, erkek adam evin reisi olur kafasıyla işlenen bi aileyi işleyip de günümüze kıyasla problematik olmaması mümkün değil
@@AsliBozlu evet, çok haklısın...
gördüğüm en güzel videolardan....
Çok güzel bir kızsınız 😇🥰
😂😂🤣 harika bir video olmus
Kaymakam ali rıza bey 174 bölümde vali oldu kendisi 😅😅
Kitap videolarını çoğaltmalısın çok iyi bir anlatımın var 🤎
I will die to know the differences, you will do us international fans of the show such a favor if you translated this video into English, the auto-translation is not helpful.
I didn’t know the auto-translation was unhelpful. Then I will consider this and try to add subs for those type of videos of mine. Thank you so much 🙏
O ZAMANIN KADINLARI 50 55 YASINDA DOGA BILIR
Harika bir inceleme
26:34
18:15 kuşku ne alaka?
Dizide Fikret Sevket ten daha büyük degilmiydi? Sanki bi ara 28 yas kutlamasini yapmislardi diye hatirliyorum.
Evet, doğru teşekkür ederimmm
Yanlış yorum yapıyorsun adam bu kitabı yazarken bile bu kadar kötü düşünmemiş
Domuzdan başka hayvan eşini paylașmaz,destekledikleri șey bu ...
Kitabın yazıldığı yılla şimdi ki yılları kıyaslamayın,șimdi namus kavramı farklı degil namus yok denecek kadar az.Evet namus önemli,yorumlamanız gördüğüm en kötü yorumlama.Çünkü feminist tavırlar var.
Oturup değerler üzerine uzuun bir tartışma yapsak da şu kitaba tepeden bakan tavrınızla benim videoyu izlerken aynı tavrı size almamın mantıksızlığı ortaya dökülse
❤️❤️
Binealeyh: Bu yüzden demekmiş
Abla lens'mi o
He ya yeşil lens var gözümde
yakışmış
😘
Canım sen o zaman para için kötü şeyler yapanları yani namussuzluk yapanları da savunuyorsun sanırım yani anlatımından bunu çıkardım kusura bakma
Herkesin anlama kapasitesi aynı değil tabii
@ hı hı tabi
Namus önemli birşeydir.
Hiç böle böle 💁💁💁yapma.
11:19
Anlatım tarzın kötü beğenmedim