When Karnataka joins jobs-for-locals-in-pvt-sector madness with new ‘law’ & why it’s dead on arrival
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 окт 2024
- #cuttheclutter
Siddaramaiah Tuesday first approved and then held back a draft law reserving 50% of managerial jobs and 70% of non-managerial jobs in the private sector for Kannadigas, with clauses for nodal officers to verify their language skills. In Episode 1483 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief @Shekhar Gupta discusses its drawbacks and why it can be challenged like a similar law in Haryana.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To Watch Episode 1482 of #CutTheClutter: • Understanding ‘Rs4000 ...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Congress may be a national party but it is still a divisive party. They have sown the seeds of discord with this - Now, a new party will emerge promoting this idea & Congress will become their ally to hold on to power. This is exactly what they did in TN!
This comes as a warning to the whole Nation on not to elect Congress into any position of power. I know Chacha jan will delete this comment. But a dare if he didnt.
Sir baaki sab hota rahega pehle ye reservation ka zeher humare desh se hataiye. Save our country from this poison. Today the biggest sin is to be an honest hard-working general category student in India.
😊0@@Sam2-jr9bu
Lot of kannadigas are not getting permanent jobs in Government sectors in central and state past Ten years. Regional railway ( south west railway) was provided lot of jobs to kannadigas Ten years before. Now all were closed.
Reality of Karnataka
Lot of ITI studied youths are not getting jobs in south west railway and ksrtc.past 10 years.
I think Rahul's constitutional saviour book is not distrubed to karnataka 😂
Rahul, Mohabbat ka dukan with his Lal book to distribute to kanadigas magar logo ne bhaga diya aur bol rhe the ki Kannada mea translate kar ke lao 😂
Read the hindu newspaper, about how rss had written 3 letters praising Indira gandhi emergency.
It's hypocrisy to use PLMA law to target opponents without evidence, & talking about sins of emergency while trying to divert from their own sins today.
Modis Gujarat has passed same act in 1998,up has passed same law, haryana did it recently. Naklis should comment on this.
@@RajashekarBs-e6c none of them have been enforced
Are you living in different dimension and different India ? @@RajashekarBs-e6c
"Liberal" Kiran Mazumder Shaw got a taste of what a "Fascist" government Actually looks like 😂
Your govt is weak at heart
😂😂😂
Its a gift from congress for UP and Rajasthan castiests who voted for INDI alliance in 2024.
😂😂😂
And she is critical and vocal about it. That's how a liberal should be.
CM siddu expert in diverting issues and he knows how to control the media. Whenever he is on Blackfoot he brings Nandini,Kannada,Kaveri issue , his backward caste (I am also belongs to same caste) .his 4000cr scam in MUDA and 187 cr ST board scam .
Remember he had tried to categorize Lingayats as a separate religion in 2018
Very true
North vs south tax also right that was used by him this election?
So basically he is like Lalu yadav of Karnataka.....Lalu perfected this art in Bihar......and basically has made a template there which others like Nitish,JeetanRam also use.
The one advantage with Karnataka is it is industrialized.....and people have already developed in that cognitive way......at least in cities... hoping this causes hurdles in stopping the downward spiral of a great state.
@@NoOne-kx7zs nothing will happen, state votes on caste base, Congress has 40% solid vote bank of SC,ST,KURUBA, Muslims , only Upper OBCs, general castes, lingayat,vakkaliga are divided between the congress,BJP,JDS
Main reason why the Country will never become a powerhouse..
For the country to become a power house all the states should develope not a few cities.
@@jeanpierre-st7rlYes , indeed .
The slow transition away from agricultural employment has witnessed a reversal after 2019, with a decline in manufacturing.
8 crore employment RBI data, includes the rise in "unpaid" workers like housewives & the people going back to agriculture.
India's manufacturing sector has shrunk from 17% in 2010 to 11% in 2023 due to rising cost of inflation. Firms are not seeing domestic demand to increase their capacity.
Meanwhile, Company 'A' hides black money in shell companies in the Cayman Islands. India's unemployment data is from CMIE:
2024 (6 months) = 9.2 percent
2023 = 8 percent
2022 = 7.33 percent
2021 = 6 percent
Our latest infrastructure, often fails within months. When you have connections with ruling party politicians, corrupt people commit crimes, without fear of any laws.
@@jeanpierre-st7rlgrowth is always uneven and urban. For every Shenzhen there is a Xihaigu.
@@jeanpierre-st7rl it won't because of politicians like Mamta Banerjee will chase industries out .... and idiots will support them.... and let them rule for 20-30 years
If reservations based on regionalism and language are possible in the private sector, reservations based on caste and religion could also arise in the future. This is not a good sign for a developing country even after 75 years of independence.
Oh that will also come when m will become 30 percent.
Than this secularism will also be gone like it did in Pakistan and bangladesh.
Exactly. This election only clearly showed that private sector reservation is not far behind. Irrespective of any party, "Jitne abadi uttna hakk" would be done in every sector to win elections. Eventually, when political parties run out of ideas to win elections, caste based reservation will seep into the private sector. It's just the question of when this will happen.
This is the sum and substance of bharat jodo abyan by rahul
This anti national program was actually started by BJP in Haryana, that time techies here in Gurgaon said, if south started the same thing, would be a big issue, that fear now come true....
How exactly regionalism or language? Do you know what domicile is?
this Karnataka CM is caught in corruption, hence he try to create different news headline, our news channel are stupid, ,they have to do publish more news about this CM's corruption.
I am a hard core kannadiga. i oppose this law. This would do more damage to us than good. Really substandard thinking. When will we go beyond vote bank politics. Govt should stay away from private sector.
Then Perhaps Kannadigas should not vote for Congress or the left cause thats what the Congress is capable of doing ..Their major play is Division based on Caste / Regional and social grounds
@@innigaaduyes bjp doesn't do caste based politics😂😂😂😂
U from RSS bjp
@@innigaadusince karnataka congress is doing this doesn’t mean BJP is good…they are worse than that
good chance that rahul gandhi will say that we have no association with the congress party in karnataka😂😂
I am from Karnataka. The only purpose of this bill is to divert the attention of people away from the multiple scams Siddu is involved in. Goal achieved when the entire national media talks only about this. Also, now BJP in Karnataka has to wait for some more time before bringing up the scams as they can not be seen to be opposing Kannadiga interests. Siddu wins even though this bill will never become the law.
But Sir, the damage is done , now new investors will hesitate to invest in entire karanataka, not only Bengaluru
Absolutely
@@johnsmith-qz4hf True😢
@@johnsmith-qz4hfit doesn't work like that, still companies get land and tax subsidy, companies also know government politics
Bangalore has tough competition now with other cities also attracting IT companies like Pune and Hyderabad and now these kind of bills coming up..
Why government is interfering in private sector? First, government has to do it's job properly. Are government services like health, education, infrastructure etc good in Karnataka ?
Instead of distributing companies across Karnataka, encourage growth of smaller cities, they do these gimmicks.
😅 it’s business choice where they want to be
@@80siddIt states choice..what to do be
@@TheGreatVivek7divide and rule wala Pappu ah gaya😂
@@TheGreatVivek7divide and rule wala Pappu ag gaya
@@TheGreatVivek7 What nonsense. Bangalore L's biggest problem is corruption. And this is done by locals only.
Next CONgress should introduce a law that 50% of tax revenues go into gandi family bank accounts and Indians need visas and passports to enter CONgress ruled States!
Only 18 percent India are able have savings while 40 percent of working families currently in India are surviving on loans.
UP gets Rs. 4 from Central Govt. in return for every Rs. 1 it gives in taxes. Whereas, for every Rs. 1, Tamil Nadu gets 30 paisa, Kerala gets back 20 paisa, Karnataka gets 13 paisa back.
8 crore employment RBI data released recently, actually includes the rise in "unpaid" workers like housewives & the people going back to agriculture.
The slow transition away from agricultural employment has witnessed a reversal after 2019, with a decline in manufacturing.
India's manufacturing sector has shrunk from 17% in 2010 to 11% in 2023 due to rising cost of inflation. Firms are not seeing domestic demand to increase their capacity.
Meanwhile, Company 'A' hides black money in shell companies in the Cayman Islands. India's unemployment data is from CMIE:
2024 (6 months) = 9.2 percent
2023 = 8 percent
2022 = 7.33 percent
2021 = 6 percent
@@xxyz2023complete cowshit from madarsa
Every country has unequal states. Look at the US- CA contributes more than AL or AK. Or even in the EU, Germany is richer than Greece. Doesn’t mean that you ban free movement of people. Also while north India is poorer than south India, it also saves south India from China and Pakistan. Look at it like that. Point is the whole country sticks together. These same politicians want to hand out nothing but freebies and unproductive subsidies- hence why states like Bihar aren’t as well off as say TN.
@@xxyz2023u forgot to mention how tax filing is determined by which city 'HQ' is in...so TCS which has centers all iver india files all its taxes from Mumbai which gets added in Maharashtra tax payment........that doesn't mean it is only making money from MH.
Most companies have HQ in Mumbai,pune,bngalore,chennai,Gurgaon which is why these states have higher tax filing.
Not to mention states like jharkhand, chattisgarh,Orissa produce over 80% of critical minerals of india which are sent to industrialized states at dirt cheap prices...and without cheap farming of UP,bihar,MP, haryana....food prices would be wayyy higher in india.
I am kannadiga & against this law it is just brought to distract public from Scams Cong has done
But A request to all other language people to respect Kannada & it's culture when you are staying here 🙏
Removing hindi/english Signs from shops are done in good faith? This hostility towards north indian will only further alienate people from south
@@river. You must respect the Culture & language of place u stay if I am in North & I force people to only use my own language will it be fine
And rule is 60% kannada & 40% u can keep any language
@@ab20037 removing english is less about respecting kannada and more about disrespect rest of India. It actually looses our respect for the state
Not linguistic chauvinism
No one has anything against kannada bro. Pretty sure this whole fiasco can be solved by keeping the yearly side course on language in work places and universities.
This is their version of Bharat Jodo!
😂😂😂😂
Bharat Jodo ❌ Bharat todo ✔️ 🤡 🤧
Haryana initiated it and met with disaster …..
Years ago Bal Thackeray demanded too .. disaster them days !
Such laws in Bharat never pass the supreme court’s judgment .
Why not Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities be infrastructure developed in Bharat ?
Supreme court is bunch of clown they support where it suit them seen many bill they remained quet
It is India you shmuck
Modi has to do something about the corruption in bureaucracy and improve the overall system. Second is as you said development of tier 2 and 3 cities because quality of living is deteriorating and more expensive in tier 1.
Leave karnataka, LOVE your STATES ❣️
@@Mithilesh_R Who are you asking to leave ... companies ?
Something that amaze me these politician even knowing these such bills never stand in court of law but still try to fool people, bihar quota struck down by patna high court, haryana reservation struck down by court before that maratha quota, prestigious industry body like nasscim has to openly raise concern about it shows u how our politician are failing our economy for their self political interest
Indeed - Well said 👍
That's the whole point. Show to the world that we brought a bill but it was struck down - we tried.
They will do anything to hide their incompetence.
Politicians know it but sadly most people don't. The guy is successful in conveying - I care for locals while reality is far from it.
Every time I want to encourage my daughter to stay in India ,grow in India..something like this happens.Why are we selecting our political leaders like this?
Me too.Everything I will think good about my country.Something like this happens.No future here .Only caste and vote bank politics.I will definently send my son outside because he wo'nt have bright future here.
India wo;nt survive for long.
@@mammuonline7671India will survive, but at what cost
@@eliteraisingstars8195 all of India is not like this. North Indians are so patriotic and so talented and etc etc etc. Why not educate your children there and set up industries there and prove to others?
And it was this same party that was talking about “Saving the constitution”
@kevindsz It's hypocrisy to use PLMA law to target opponents without evidence, & talking about sins of emergency while trying to divert from their own sins today.
@@xxyz2023why are you writing geography answers in a maths exam?😂😂😂
Why are you spaming@@xxyz2023
@@xxyz2023even I can write a letter quoting muslims were the pioneers of LGBTQ and post it in a pro-liberal newspaper agency citing some bullshit dhruv Rathee logic.
Shame
Udupi, Dakshina Kannada and Kodagu should ask for a separate state called Karavali Karnataka
Kannada is not the majority language in those districts. They also don't usually vote for the current ruling party anyway.
Exactly.. I was also thinking the same.... 3 coastal districts plus Kodagu.... as KODAVALI state
Some mallu talking for coastal
@@manju2793 eh yaako gaamdu, tuluva here
They could have put mandatory learning Kannada clause in companies and avoided such discriminatory law. Private sector shouldn't be touched, that's it. As a businessman, we want one who can do the job. No one should direct is whom to hire.
The way the demography is changing in this region, don't be surprised if it becomes a part of caliphate.
I thought Rahul Gandhi is the ultimate PAPPU in khangress... Sidda proved me wrong
They are not pappus.They are smart enough to understand what strategies to adopt to further divide hindus.
@@akshaymattoo4456true. Pappus are innocent. These are sinister people. After British they took over in divide and rule policy
@@akshaymattoo4456I'm sorry. I understand your sarcasm but that was a dumb move.
@@bharatraut3234 RaGa: Pappu Jr
Sidda: Pappu Sr.
I am expecting honarable karanataka govt to Put this local bill
So that 70% telugu people will find difficlty and companies also find difficulty
This will help AP to pull companies from Benagaluru
@kothamasusambasivarao1687 how AP will pull companies? Even in AP there is 75% reservation for locals. Ap and haryana together brought this system in 2018. However haryana bill is challenged in Punjab-haryana high court. Now also companies show interest in Telangana instead of AP.
@@josejoseph8725Bill is passed in AP? I thought it too got revoked.
Is TDP considering revoking this law if the bill is passed?
If all the states pass this kind of bill, I will become stateless
Same 😂 Many communities in India dont have individual states.
😂
I am in the same boat. Plus i am in Bangalore only.
Yea that's why the constitution disallows this sh*t
Many army kids will become the same
Madness. Rahul Gandhi demonstrating his understanding of "India is a union of states". BJP ruled Haryana tried the same under pressure from JJP. It yielded neither political nor economic benefits. All eyes on CBN now, if he manages to replicate his Hyderabad success with Amravati, he'll become a role model CM for all states.
In haryana also bjp tried implement same bill.. Why blame Rahul gandhi blame modi also😂
@@nirmal886devide and rule
This will break apart our country india
If someone is doing stupidity and you are doing the same you are call stupid
@@nirmal886Modi doesn't get blamed because that was a state unit making it a poll plank while Rahul is running his dukaan on redistribution.
@sankalp6872 lol amravati. Andhrapradesh and Haryana are thr States which brought these reservation for locals. Andhrapradesh too has this 75% reservation for locals, then how will Amaravati will develop like hyderabad?
@@josejoseph8725 Do you live under a rock? Both Haryana and AP legislations were struck down by the courts. Also, in AP the law was brought by Jagan. In any case it did not matter because Jagan had already destroyed AP to the extent that there were not jobs either for domiciles or non-natives.
Kannada is NOT the language of all residents of Karmataka. The coastal konkan region has its own languages. Northern Karnataka speaks Marathi / Hindi. Areas bordering Andhra or Telangana speak Telugu! Muslims don't speak local languages and tend to speak urdu at home.
But they are born in karnataka and they would have studied kannada..
Not necessarily Muslims study urdu, aren't we alienating them through this@@nirmal886
You forgot Tulu
@@nirmal886 your ooga booga tribal language is not spoken beyond Karnataka, Hindi is spoken worldwide and has 600 million speakers. You are imposing your mother tongue on North Indians and cry when Hindi is taught 😂
@@kushalrow The first comment is clearly against the bill and was talking about kannadigas itself. No one brought up north indians. How about you refine your reading comprehension skills first before spouting such nonsense.
Please pass the law Mr Sidhharamiah Plzzzzzzzzzzzz
We need jobs in Maharashtra
Plz do so at the earliest
However ONLY kannadigas will have to learn Marathi for jobs here 😉😉😉
Companies and Skilled employees... please Just shift to Hyderabad which is much more inviting and you get better quality of life too. No one bothers you.
❤❤❤
Thanks.. BJP taking its data centre to HYD.... Are you happy , anything more to do
Cities like Chennai, Hyderabad, Pune kochi, Amaravati going to benefit From this law....
@Vihari9 amravati? Andhra also has this local reservation system. First let andhra remove this reservation for locals then they can think about companies.
@@niceguy3099Data centre?
I have lived in Bengaluru for the last 17 years. Graduated from here, got a job here, contributed to the economy by paying high rent, paid my taxes to this state, was considering buying a flat here. N very stupidly voted for the current govt. I love Bengaluru and its weather and people, however, if it comes to this, I will consider moving out. My biggest regret is to vote for this govt.
Stop this nonsense
I think if they want to put quota in private sector they should 1st put quota for students in educational institutions. 100% kannadigas till 12th, 75% for graduation & 50% for PG, then no ll come to Karnataka & u can give ur 50-100% job quota. So pathatic are these politicians, I don't think we can ever become a developed 1st world country.
So impose hindi and purohithashahi
@@ssv.dlook at this ebrehemik inf iltrator
I am getting college and have paid 3 lakhs to them😢
@@VforVikramm your loss. sorry for you.
@@d1p70 Should I proceed studying or let the money sink in??
Such a draconian law by the self-proclaimed “saviours of the Constitution”. India deserves better! 🤦🏻♂️
Since this Siddaramiyah became CM hes been trying to divide people. Earlier he tried to divide lingayat community. North/South divisive sentiment also took root during his rule.
Closing an IT company in Bangalore and open one in AP or TN is a matter of 6 months max to max
To get the people to work there - it'll take forever. Hyderabad has been catching up to Bangalore since before the time I moved to bangalore over 20 years ago. Nothing has happened - at all.
If companies decide to move then will the people... It's in hands of sidda
It's the two Congress leaders ... CM and his deputy outstanding each other 😂... Khata khat... Khata khat...
One changing name of a city and other changing job eligibility 😂
Minorities will anyway vote for them even if they lose employment for not being kannadigas
This is the party who wants to rule the country….they don’t know how to run a state with inclusiveness “mohbat ki dukan” , such a shame party and shame to the people who voted them to rule.
as a kannnadiga we wont support as ppl of karnataka we need competition higher competition higher advancement of techonologies
Mostly tamage Inna experience aagilla anta kaaNatte.
Yella aache inda bandu namma kelasagalannu kittukoLLutiddaare. Idu hege yendare, aache inda namma manege bandu idu nann Mane anta heLkoLluvudu, idu allade avara janarannu namma manege karedukondu bandu nammannu acche haakodu nischaya.
Ee rule taruvidarinda yenenu tappilla.
Tappu madirodu naavu achekade avarannu bittu kondu. Ivattu heLtaare 'Bengaluru kannadigaru beLasilvante' naaLe Karnataka Kannadigaradu alla anta heLtaare, yelru kaige chombu kodtaare.
Sumne idannu taam taam hodiuo badilu nishabdavaagi namma nammalle, namma janarige bembala needabeku.
Yaaro hindi tunne ge huttiro kalaberake irbeku 😂
Traitor you are.
Higer advancement in D level workers 😂
Exactly, plus the bill is excludes out a majority of kannadigas itself 😂
They also would have made a law where investments also should from local Kannadiga only 😂
This is typical congress mentality. Seems that Congress do not think of India as a whole unit. This tendency will create animosity between peoples of different state and thus an insecure India. Shame on you Congress!!!
It's is better to divide a country on the basis of states and linguistic difference (bc it's been that way for thousands of years as empires) than to divide a secular country based on religion and caste.
Vishwaguru apparently seems to be unable to even take care of its own family members, by discriminating based on language and domicile! Shame on those who voted in favor. Shame on us, that we selected such people who are doing this! Sorry for those "outsiders" who work in the state for ensuring the survival and wellbeing of their family back home! I hope that investors are positively spooked by this move and adequately punish the state government by shifting base somewhere else!
Why does every one in India needs quota from IAS to common people?
Reservation or quota doesn't change anything...it complicates things..
Why not publish how much extra jobs , industries they can bring.... That will solve the local problem... won't it ?
Kyonki bharat ek gareeb desh hain
So true
@@jaishree701exactly
Politicians play the zero sum game and the public eats it up.
@@jaishree701 India is among top 5 most richest countries
India is not poor....mentality is poor...if you really want to make money in india you can make it...there are many examples....but none of them got rich through reservation
IT company needs to leave banglore
For one political party stupidity, industry shouldn't follow their stupidity, congress govt is complete storm with one scam after another, bill is paused right now, even if they pass high court will stuck it down, Bengaluru it sector is critical for india's growth
Yess they can leave banglore, none of the IT companies are running charity here, they are getting tax exemptions cheap land, peaceful law & order, so they are coming to karnataka. Even if they leave, we will be more happy to live in Bangalore
Yayyy @@naveenbkgowda_malenadu I really hope your wishes come true 😂
@@naveenbkgowda_malenadudoes that mean a government can bring any stupid law to curb that instead karnataka should harvest such a good business environment.
Auto driver comment 😅
This is it. We are the new Argentina....
We need Javier Milei 😂. Modi is too crony of a capitalist
@@MARKCRASTO you forget that Milei got elected only and only because people grew tired of 75 years of redistribution and debased currency.
This government should be fined for wasting time and for the financial loss of the state.
Company's money, company wants employees. Govt wants to decide who should work. What a joke.
But company is not doing charity.. Power, land in subsidy rate.. And maintain safety they do.. They bring industry for tax and local employment improvement... If people start doing manawadu business then this issue occurs..
@@cricketclassics5490 but Andhra minister is handing out red carpet welcome to companies to move out to Vaizag to get all facilities without any restriction...so govt. isn't doing any charity either ! Everybody is doing business !....and if you are not competitive you will lose businesses to other states !
@@divyanshukumar6120 tats true but andhra as a state has larger issue of Inclusiveness than karnataka.. Here u can easily survive without learning local things but can't expect the same in andhra.. There is a reason why mostly locals work in andhra and tamil nadu... They never became a cosmopolitan society.. If u think kannadigas have extreme language chauvinism u need to multiply by 3 for other southern states 😂.. It's like jumping from a hole to hellfire..
Please do some development work Congress. And I want to thank all people of Karnataka please keep voting Congress to power. You all will have great future. Jai Hind
Private firms will shift from Karnataka.... They are working for making profit not to uplift unskilled locals
The CM will be appreciated ifnhe had passed law like this : A person can become chief minister or finance or law minister if has served 15 years in public life without any criminal charges and might have passed IIM, national law school and Delhi University economics tests etc ... Laughable law.
They forgot to write Nodal Agency’s report should also be written in legible Kannada 😂😅
An interview at Bangalore.
Interviewer: Do you know C++
Candidate: No
Interviewer: Do you know Java
Candidate: No
Interviewer: Do you know Python
Candidate: No
Interviewer: Then which language do you know
Candidate: KANNADA
Interviewer: Sir, CEO banoge hamari company me.
Hahaha bad joke, Karnataka especially Bengaluru has many good tech colleges and the students will know C++ to Python including Kannada, so stop these bad jokes...
What about ur bloody hindi North beggers 😅
I can see the start of the downfall of Bengaluru and Karnataka if this law gets passed.
The law passes or it doesnt, the city is already in a downfall. There are a lot of elements in the city that are riled up by just hearing about this. Civilian life is already a nuisance.
This bill is directly violating the article 15
Now bjp rss understood constitution
@@ssv.dnikka is blaming BJP here too .wow
@@ssv.d
No madrasa chap, read constitution specially art 44 and article 368
@@ssv.dDarbari Doormats at it again with their bot profiles.
Mr.Gupta also make Cut the Clutter on unemployment problem in this country.State Governments to solve the problem.
Like SG says - No one can stop a bad idea whose time has come 😂
It is toxic when viewed from 1000 ft feet. I have spent 30yrs in industrty. I have seen the nepotism from close distance. A manager from x place comes and goes to campus interview for his/her native and floods the people from
their place. If everyone is playing fair then we do not need such draconian laws. Sometime I wonder, man Yogi must have built much better education institutions in UP, so we have floor full of people from UP. Good job Yogi :-)
Nepotism is in Indian dna and that is toxic. They take it where ever they go. I have worked in US for 18yrs, and same story there. Indian from x place comes and she/he tends to hire their own people. These companies had fair hiring proces. We just corrupted it with our nepotism.
I agree, Karnataka is for Kannadigas, thats why we have state borders. But I don't know how this kind of law help mitigate nepotism as this policy would not be good a global company. There should some other creative ways to prioritize local people's needs..
Companies will shift out of Bangalore. They won’t compromise on talent
Such practices could not have been a policy decision by the companies but practiced by corrupt hiring managers. Is this good for the company? Companies where nepotism is prevalent would eventually cease to exist. Same effect would be observed with such laws. The difference is that companies who want to survive can take active measures against nepotism but won't be able to do anything if it is the law of the land.
@@shashank.c that's an ideal world. But we are not in ideal world. So what to do about that?
Outsiders come and pay rent to local land lords
Pay at grocery stores
Pay at local convience
Pay to locals for all other utilities 😂
They are indirectly giving employment to locals.
But think if all they would leave the karnatka!
This law is bringing mafia raaj and will enhance corruption😮
Congress and their divisive politics. Caste, religion, language, north-south and what not. 😢
@sauravbharti2709 It is a fact that southern states are more successful, however, the point is not why south are doing well, but why isn't the north?
UP gets Rs. 4 from Central Govt. in return for every Rs. 1 it gives in taxes. Whereas, for every Rs. 1, Tamil Nadu gets 30 paisa, Kerala gets back 20 paisa, Karnataka gets 13 paisa back.
If India has to grow more than China, we should make India's largest State more like Karnataka, rather than turning the rest of India into U.P.
8 crore employment RBI data, includes the rise in "unpaid" workers like housewives & the people going back to agriculture.
The slow transition away from agricultural employment has witnessed a reversal after 2019, with a decline in manufacturing.
India's manufacturing sector has shrunk from 17% in 2010 to 11% in 2023 due to rising cost of inflation. Firms are not seeing domestic demand to increase their capacity.
Meanwhile, Company 'A' hides black money in shell companies in the Cayman Islands. India's unemployment data is from CMIE:
2024 (6 months) = 9.2 percent
2023 = 8 percent
2022 = 7.33 percent
2021 = 6 percent
Based on what research did the Congress bring this bill?
1. How many people are required to fill 70% positions and are there so many Kannada speaking skilled workers in Karnataka who can fill in the 70% quota (Kannada may not be the mother-tongue of people from some districts in Karnataka)?
2. The bill proposes training local Kannadigas to fill those positions within the next three years. Do they have any data on how many openings are there and how did they decide that 3 years would be sufficient for this?
3. For perspective, an engineering degree takes 4 years to complete but the real training starts after the graduate joins the industry.
4. What would be the impact on non-Kannadiga workforce already in those companies? Would the industries have to force them out? Answer seems obvious, but do they have any data on how many people would lose their jobs and how the Karnataka government would compensate them?
5. Most important of all, what are the governement's plans to encourage industrial growth in Karnataka? Any state has limited population of skilled workers. If the state encourages industries, then it attracts people from other states as well. Limiting participation of people from outside the state severely limits the number of companies that can be built in the state unless the state has a way to keep producing skilled workers that can sustain the growth rate.
6. Lastly, how much is this going to cost Karnataka? What would be the consequences if these companies decide to move out of the state? Is any study done on that?
Probably, this is just a gimmick to divert people's attention from the corruption allegations on the CM, but if they are serious then the seriousness should reflect in the bill.
MNCs are pure money minded. Train the locals well, they will give jobs to localities only.
Then they will become big and turn into a MNC 😂
No when you have money, you will also do same.
Job of govt not companies.
They will make CA, Developer, tester within 3 years
Anyone watching local channels and following assembly proceedings - kind of guessed that it was a distraction tactic!!
There should be a court case filed against this unconstitutional bill.
Indian politics summary: one party trying to consolidate Hindu votes , polarizes by being anti Muslim and plays caste politics . The other party tries to break the Hindu consolidation to stop party 1 through caste, language, class and also minority appeasement . Smaller parties have their own rules
Shudder to think of a “inspector Raj”. But Shekar Ji, today in national public sector companies they have a Hindi Implementation cell? That their inspectors go all over the country to inspect Hindi implementation? That they check things like - if names of employees in attendance register is written in Hindi, count the number of official circulars written in Hindi and this list is endless. And in order to keep these “inspectors” happy, local officers go out of their way to keep them in good humor? You should do a talk on such existing practices too!! God save my country!!!
This move can be revivable of IT in Chennai, Hyderabad, Pune , Kolkata.
Keep it up Karnataka. Best of Luck. This happens when you vote for Freebies 😅
Karnataka is bearing the brunt of Congress retrograde policies starting with freebies that are hurting already. Tax payers are at mercy. Now this is a blow to industry and competitiveness that brings healthy candidates to workforce
Instead of focusing on whatever happened to that abuser Prajwal Revanna, this is all Karnataka wants to focus on! Brilliant!
"Creative Destruction"
Nothing creative about this. This is the average output of our leaders. Siddu the litigator, DKS the real estate goon and a 12th fail for an IT minister.
We don’t want any Indian companies in Karnataka. We have enough MNC’s in Karnataka. All other Indian investors please go to Bihar,UP, Rajastan,West Bengal ,Madyapradesh,Orissa and north east states. We don’t want to loose Kannada culture in Karnataka anymore.
Exactly, move out and take all these intellectuals...These people come from a state where if a girl shows a bit of skin she gets molested, their language is incomplete without badmouthing their own mothers and sisters ...Let them all get the hell out of our state
Peak "bharat jodo" move by congress.....
As a Kanndiga. Who VOTED BJP. Im completly against this. Im so done with Congress. Wish I could clean them up.
Sir, please make a #cuttheclutter for the Pooja Khedkar case, there have been instances of mass forgery and misuse of Disability/EWS/OBC Certificates. What Govt is doing about it, what steps should be taken. The Watchdog of Merit System is under scrutiny, as Aspirants loose trust in the organisation.
1. This will be the death knell for Karnataka. Industry, particularly the IT industry will leave.
2. It makes sense for this law be applied to workers in the service sector including bankers posted in rural areas, Tier 2/3 ….towns.
3. Certificate of proficiency can be conducted as a state wide exam.
4. A big problem is students of English Medium schools are not proficient in reading and writing Kannada. This has a detrimental cultural impact. This is so in other states as well. Students are not proficient in reading and writing in their regional language. The solution to this problem is to establish a dual stream of education. Quantitative subjects are taught in English. Social Science subjects are taught in the regional language.
Like people take IELTS English test, people going to work in Karnataka will take IKLTS Kannadiga test. 😂 Will be funny if every state in India passes such law.
This is the ‘inclusiveness‘, of Congress....
If politicians knows the final result of the law then why they are doing it again and again.
Because they can show locals "we tried" and get votes
I support Karnataka government decision - Jai Telangana, Jai Jai Telangana 🙏
This is a great decision by Karnataka government. Now these high paying MNCs will move out of Bangalore. And people who had to come to Bangalore because all jobs are here can move to better cities having good roads, police and lower cost of living
If there are was better city with good roads, law and order and lower cost of living, where companies can be more profits, why wouldn't the companies gone there first?
Pune and Mumbai will expand further@@sunilkb
@@millennialmind9507 yeah and they are already overburdened cities and time is not far away for them also get frustrated and implement such (bad) policies. And again this is the problem. Everyone here will only name a existing urban metro will take companies from Blr, no one, even the native people want to develop their own states like Bihar or UP. When criticizing the place where they work, they voice is loudest. When it comes to questioning thier native state govt for lack of jobs, everyone keeps mum.
@@sunilkb Excellent question. Indian government invested heavily in 1970s and 80s strategically making Bangalore a magnet for foreign investment and talent from all over India. Foreign companies have invested heavily over the time since then to tap in the best talent of India. To be honest, now Indian government should invest in other parts of India. It is very sad that talented Indians have to leave home and come so far to pursue a job in a place where people don’t like them. I can tell you it’s not a fun experience to leave one’s elderly parents, friends and relatives and come to Bangalore for work.
@@sunilkb California is the best example how companies ran away from the silicon Valley
How long you all depend on Karnataka? Come on, work towards developing your states. Migration has been the biggest problem in Karnataka now, it's high time to address it and control.
Groupism and nepotism among kannadigas is the least of all regions. Historical city Bengaluru City became cosmopolitan with it boom in the late 90s and always encouraging talent pool. Private companies are not here to do charity work and are here to make profits. Government bargains at the class 3 and 4 should not be more than 1/3 with the private organizations for the locals representation. Atleast 1/10 at the class 1 and 2.
This Law is Good for Future of India . companies will think about starting industries in other states
Cheap labor is what businesses look for irrespective of cities.
Why USA companies operate from Bengaluru ? People here work for 1/10th the cost
Why Bengaluru restos have north east or eastern Indian waiters? Same logic!
As a Kannadiga. we can proudly say that, We have selected a government which can proudly take back our state to 20 years
It was a distraction to divert focus from corruption charges 😅
Its classic politics
Thanks ❤❤❤ and was WORTH listening in for me too❤ my mangalorean bangalore Karnataka
Love my childhood day's Journalism Editorial full of information and not tired of giving more information.. in those days of newspaper boy's days ❤❤❤
I still buy TOI but i rarely touch it...
For some reason..
That bengali Bihari BOY Dutifully 'DROPS' the newspaper at my door...
And for that ..
Am grateful ❤ to my .. KA St
bangalore INDIA
This bill was needed cause of the people who are in the managements of all firms who have taken up their state people more for their benifit even in the small scale industries factories they hire their state/city/ village keeping their cuts and to overrule. In this job politics locals are suffering. This bill must be implicated so that this job politics would come to an end. And locals gets benefited by the investments which is done in their state and city.
Other state people are making a fuss on this bill when this kind of bills are already passed and applied in other part of the country.
And this is not just about speaking kannada this is about creating jobs in private sectors for locals.
Bengalurens are talented but the opportunities for them are coming to an end due to state fellowship politics.
This action will reduce the presige of. Bangalore and act against Karnataka development. If they believe in it, they should not send the locals to other states and countriesike UDA, Canada, Australia etc.
I think this is very good law. Karnataka govt should continue and make all necessary arrengement to impement this law.
There is job mafia in Tamil Nadu and Andhra where they directly prefer locals but this is not true in Karnataka so they tried to influence directly, media People can’t understand local knowledge Kerala Tamil and Andhra people prefer people from their language. It is a problem people from outside can’t understand
Pretty sure you're unemployed
Oh wow!,Really?
How localites will get the job,if you are then make jobs for all in your state,kannadigas never went begged in other states for jobs
Rahul Before election:- samvidhan bachao
Rahul after election:- samvidhaan mere l@wd£ pe😂😂😂
Not a matter of joke, they can go to any extent for votes.
Now they will say these industrialist friends of modi are against kannadigas. And looking at the way of thinking of Karnataka locals , its a master move from election point of view.
😂
Typical Congress govt
BJP in haryana passed something similar last year, theres even an episode or two of CTC on that.
Haryana govt did the same under Khattar. koshish kro, ek din neutral ho jaoge beta
I has been scrapped off by hc@@kushalsaitia971
Haryana government had brought this bill in pressure of jjp.BJP never do such type of politics.It also got cancelled by supreme court.These all discriminative work is done by Congress only.
@@Mjjjyyy chote vo jjp ki pressure me aake karna pada tha Bjp ko.
Karnataka gives only 30 percent jobs to non kannadigas
All other 35 states and union Territories should bring a law that states that people of kannada can have only less than 1 percent of jobs in other states.
1x35 = 35
I'm born in Maharashtra but I'm more than happy to take TOEFL- style Kannada language test and i can pass it successfully i would be happy to migrate to Bangalore...I appreciate recognition based on merit!!...Nothing wrong in it....I'm willing to work hard to secure a high paying, white collar job in Bangalore.....uncontrolled migration also need to be regulated otherwise Quality of Life is affected for everyone (seeing Mumbai of 2024) 😢....South is moderately populated than High populated Northern belt!!...
This is stupid logic, you have not seen video. The test result would be very subjective plus if each state does this then work growth and opportunities significantly decreased and migration becomes more toxic. I am also from Maharashtra I pray my state doesn't do such stupidity
But even if after all your hard work you are told you are not local?
For the economic development there will always be places that will become a "hub" and an ecosystem is built there to attract talents and investments easily.
That's how Silicon Valley (US) was built.
Places like Tokyo and Seoul are made Japanese and Koreans respectively, but look at their education level and talent pool.
Can the people of Karnataka claim that Karnataka's talent pool is strong enough to build a silicon valley? Ask your government to educate your people and schools first, maybe then you'll have a chance, otherwise you or any place in India will need talented people from the whole of India to build a silicon valley or any kind of "hub" for that matter, whether it's arts, music, fashion, education and so on.
Jharkhand and Bihar are waiting for such entrepreneurs....
Shekuuu Barking against master don't you know *British used Divide & Rule & Congress follows the same* ?
Siddharamaiah seems to be running for the post of PM of Telangana or Andhra. He is giving impetus to Industries to go to these states.
i was waiting this video
Hey The Print, I am getting a seat in Banglore Enginnering College should I pay 20 Lakhs???? I am thinking of avoiding to be on a safer side(Delhi seems better for placements)
Please share your thoughts everyone
India is becoming Lebanon. Only your own Caste and community matters, not India.
You are being far too charitable. Lebanon was largely run by the private sector not government largesse. We are like Argentina where one or two profitable sectors are sucked out to fund a large population.
@@rutvikrs and Indians like to say Diversity is a good thing?
It is the exact feeling of locals of Karnataka
Typical congress style to divide country basis caste and regionalism . Its shameful
Why should North Indians come to.South India for jobs? Is South India? Let North India States also provide jobs for their own.citzen...All media pouncing why?
For north cow is more important.
Why should Bhavish create Ola in BLR? He should go back to North India. Microsoft, Amazon, Boeing and other foreigners too.