Super Mario Sunshine is definitely one of the Mario best games to exist only do to it being unique and creative and it is really fun to master everything. The Dang Boat made my me rage in a game for the first time and every time now
Odyssey actually is a special game to me as well. I remember I brought it and hadn’t played it yet. My family actually had when on vacation for the weekend and I had the house to myself during that summer. I setup my front room just to chill and play Odyssey that weekend. It was just a great time. 2d will always be my favorite but Odyssey definitely is special to me
+ so, it makes sense that the levels are linear and the camera is fixed, with the entire game sharing many different similarities between it and previous 2d games.
I think what he means is 3d land is a intro to 3d in a less ambitious way that wont overwhelm people who have only played 2d games. @@andyspendlove1019
Mario Odyssey is my all time favorite and after 8 years I have beaten it countless times and every time finding more moons I've never seen and as the video said the music is great it is something else if I showed someone New Donk city they would not be able to tell (besides the Mario billboards). That game is phenomenal I don't care how much I have to say it Mario Odyssey is my favorite game ever.
I'm gonna be honest, I can't rank them. I just have too many emotional ties to each of these games that when thinking back to each of them, it's just happy memories. I try ranking them by using factors that each game has above the other, but then I remember how much fun I had with all of them. Even when there are times that they suck and become very frustrating, I can't help but just have joy in the experience. It's actually impossible for me to genuinely rank them. They are all amazing and just so much fun.
With a Mario game I want the core Mario vibe with some new things i prefer not to much drastic from what I love in the Mario franchise but new things like power ups and enemies I love to see I don’t really like straying off from the core of Mario that we know and love (Awesome video keep up the good work!!! 🔥😎)
Taking turns playing galaxy 1 and 2 with my brother will always be some of my favorite memories, and same with playing 3d world at my friends house, but when I finally got Mario odessy just last year, I was absolutely blown away, like I played it less than 6 months ago and I already have so much nostalgia for it + on the moon where all the different creatures from each kingdom stand next to each other looking at the earth still makes me tear up
Super Mario 3D Land or Super Mario Galaxy are my favorite 3D Mario games for the Wii and 3DS overall. Super Mario 3D World has a next level story in another world. Hats off to these 3 Mario games. 😄
I find Galaxy actually more fun and epic in feel. My issue with Odyssey is often there are parts of levels that are quite empty when you move off the beaten track. Galaxy was insane with it's creativity. Fun every second of play.
Well it definitely has flaws they are just very little. Galaxy was a more fun all the time Mario game. Odyssey has moments of repetitive moons and boring kingdoms. I love odyssey don't get me wrong but flawless it is not.
Most of the Minigames in Mario 64 DS are also on the NSMBDS game as well, and I love those Minigames, I have very high scores on them, and I'm always trying to beat my personal best, even though some may be impossible to beat since I have them so high.
3D Land is always a Nostalgic adventure for me, and it hurts to see it at the very bottom. None the less, this game screams simplicity and charm. And the Special 8 song just sounds so good.
I have over 500 hours in Mario 3d World (a lot for a story game) so this list is very heart breaking for me.. I have played most of these games, and I can say for certain that 3d world has a very interactive experience. The first time you play through with no spoilers, it is really fun. The bosses are exciting, the levels have variation, the ending boss is one of a kind, gave me chills the first run through as a kid, and also in my most recent run. I would argue that the quality of this game is better than all but Odyssey and Fury (graphics, story, gameplay) but I still understand and respect your list, even if it breaks my heart because we all know Odyssey belongs at the top for being an absolutely beautiful game. Glad you put it at the top!
My list is: 9. Super Mario 3D land 8. Super Mario 64 ds 7. Bowsers fury 6. Super Mario sunshine 5. Super Mario galaxy 2 (plz no hate, I don’t have too much experience with the game) 4. Super Mario 64 3. Super Mario 3D world 2. Super Mario galaxy 1. Super Mario odyssey
@@Aigle662frileux 64 is fucking phenomenal. If it was remastered today it would be peoples favorite mario game hands down its got great level design it just needs to be remade a little (which is completely normal for a almost 30 year old 3d game).
Sunshine might be my least favorite of the ones I played. Though I will admit, Sunshine's themes are distinct and unmistakable. They did a great job making that game look, sound and feel like the idea of being at the beach during summer. It's like Mario's trip to Florida. Like lets go to the beach, lets go to the theme parks, lets get thrown around by the locals, lets go see the ugly loading docks, lets fall to our deaths in the void. Just like it really.
I used to prefer Galaxy 1 to 2, but I like Galaxy 2 more because I think it has better power ups, better level design, and better bosses. Galaxy 1 is still phenomenal, but I just prefer Galaxy 2. Galaxy 1 and 2 are my two favorite games of all time
@@Mazrio_RenardioMFG Sunshine is not terrible. Yes, it has more frustrating levels than 64, but the controls are good and that music is bliss even if it’s all sequenced. You can also ride Yoshi.
@@palacioestrellacontrols are good but physics are terrible, the camera is almost as bad as 64 and about a third of the 120 shines made me want to rip out my pulmonary blood vessels. Also Yoshi is used for like 4 shines from what I can recall and all of them weren’t exactly fun
@notaurorahimmelwithlightystar Sorry to say. But Sunshine is like the only bad 3D Mario game. Even if it's not an terrible game or the worst game out there, it's still the only not so good 3D Mario game compared to others.
I’ve given up on it happening at this point, but I really think this series needs a sequel for Odyssey. Like, it doesn’t have to be as big. I don’t think we need another 800+ moon game, but it would be nice to have some kind of sequel to it.
I agree that super Mario odyssey belongs at number one. But I will say this. This doesn’t say anything about where the game I’m about to reference belongs on this list by the way, but I always thought the game that reminds me the most of odyssey that isn’t odyssey is sunshine. Biggest reason: the wide distribution of NPCs some of which even move in each, the realistic worlds with unique architecture, the fact that they are the only two games with a camera being fully controlled in all angles by a separate analogue stick, the travel companions that Mario uses to enhance his abilities, the designated secret linear platforming levels, how big each world is. I can go on and on with this list. But yes I think Super Mario Sunshine and Odyssey are the two 3D Mario games that closely resemble each other most.
@@Matty_Ice3955 The level with the electric goop would drive me nuts! I can remember losing so many lives on that level lol. My favourite was Pinna Park, I just liked the vibe
Insanely respectable list. I rate Galaxy and Galaxy 2 the highest but I love how high you rated Odyssey, it's such a spectacular game. I'm curious to see if my feelings for the game will grow even more one day and dethrones my two current favorites.
If you play Super Mario 3D Land emulated in Citra VR on a VR headset and use the emulator’s “immersive mode” - which expands the level to be visible all around you - it instantly becomes one of the best Mario games. I hope the next Switch does something with VR.
Nice list, as someone who has played all the games, mine would be 9. Bowser's Fury 8: 3d land 7: 3d world 6: Sm64 DS 5: Super mario Sunshine 4: Super mario oddysey 3: Super mario 64 2: Galaxy 2 1: Super Mario galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy is my favorite 3D Mario game overall because of its creativity and grand scope and pretty much everything else about it, but I still love the others too for different reasons. Super Mario 64 for its replayability and simplicity, Super Mario Sunshine for its uniqueness, style, FLUDD as a mechanic and Isle Delfino as a unique world and its interconnected nature and cohesion, Super Mario 64 DS because of its extra missions, minigames, having Luigi, Wario and Yoshi as playable characters, its new powerups and nostalgia as it was my first 3D Mario game and I love it because of that too, Super Mario 3D Land for its pick-up and play nature as a handheld 3D Mario and it's callbacks to Mario 3, and Super Mario 3D World for its playable characters, hybrid 2D & 3D nature and its great classic style linear platforming levels, it's new powerups like Cat Mario and the Double Cherry and its soundtrack as well, and Super Mario Galaxy 2 for its new powerups and how it uses Yoshi and has callbacks to past Mario games while having plenty of unique ideas of its own as well too, and Super Mario Odyssey for its fresh new kingdoms and how it honors the series's whole history in different ways, like with its 8-bit 2D sections, Cappy and the Capture mechanic and how abstract and unforgettable locations like New Donk City, the Luncheon Kingdom and Tosterena are, as well as its new characters like the Broodals, and the game's boss fights as well as its climatic ending sequence too, and Bowser's Fury for how much freedom it gives you, Plessis as a fast way to move around, being able to use 3D World's powerups in a more open game, and Fury Bowser's design and as a mechanic, the game's jazzy soundtrack and its loving and fun callbacks to Super Mario Sunshine as well.
It’s weird to think about now, but I actually played Super Mario Galaxy 2 before I knew it was a sequel or knew the original existed. So when I first played 1, I kept wondering why Yoshi wasn’t there and why I was on an observatory rather than Mario’s head.
So I almost totally agree with your list. I was totally happy to see Mario 64 DS over the original and Galaxy 1 over 2 as controversial as those pics are. But dude, I gotta switch your number 1 and 2. Don't get me wrong, it is VERY close between those two, but Galaxy is ICONIC! The music, the worlds, the hub, the introduction of Rosalina, and just the whole atmosphere go together so perfectly. Like it is one of my few 10/10 games for sure. And like Odessey is good but I did have a few problems with it. The moons just don't feel as satisfying to get when you collect so many of them. And some of the worlds just felt disjointed compared to each other. But it's still really good, just 2nd for me. Also yes bring Galaxy 2 to switch please!
You know what, the D-pad controls on 64 DS don't matter to me as much now as they used to because of the fact that I've gotten used to them over the years but also I genuinely love 64 DS and it is my favorite 3D Mario game because what other 3D Mario has Wario as a playable character and has given an entire generation of gamers a gambling addiction?
I've only played a handful, but my top three is probably Odyssey, 3D World, and Galaxy. Galaxy is in a solid third, the other two are tied for first, they both are great for different reasons.
My ranking 1. Super Mario Galaxy 2 2. Super Mario Odyssey 3. Super Mario Galaxy 4. Super Mario 3D World 5. Super Mario 64 6. Super Mario 64 DS 7. Super Mario Sunshine 8. Super Mario 3D Land 9. Bowser’s Fury (It’s way too short to be better than any of the other FULL games)
Ever since SMB2, when I hoped SMB3 would be 3D (which a lot of game franchises were getting into at the time) and would yet return to form of the original SMB, that was what I always wanted from a 3D Mario. SMB had a "flow" to it, with its linear format, and "open world" just doesn't have it. In SMB, you automatically knew what to do, where in Mario 64, I didn't know where to begin. So 3DW and 3DL were the "holy grail", for me. Odyssey is nice for the realistic NYC graphics, and luncheon kingdom looks nice as well. Bowser's Fury is open world, but it's small size is non-overwhelming. My first 3D was Galaxy 2, and the little worldlet concept was also nice, and easier to know what to do. (I would group those togther, since they are so similar). With 64, I just can't get over the crude polygon graphics, and I don't know why they didn't completely redo that when they redid it for 3D Allstars. Sunshine was a bg improvement, though.
1. SM64 DS is indeed better than the og. 2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a retelling of SM Galaxy 1. At the end of the game we find out that Rosalina was telling the story to some baby Lumas.
Is mario odyssey worth it? I literally just got a switch 2 weeks ago. I am mostly an rpg guy but love adventure games and 2d mario. Odyssey looks really fun because it seems more like an adventure game rather than a platformer where you just have to make it to the end of the level. It looks like there is a lot of replay value and post game content which is important to me. I'm curious on what people would choose between odyssey and kirby forgotten land?
Personally, I like odyssey better than Kirby and the forgotten land. However, the co-op is better in Kirby if you plan to play with someone. Kirby’s levels are also more linear, whereas odysseys are more of a sand box. They are both fantastic games however and you won’t be disappointed with either. If you’re interested in rpg and adventure games though, legend of Zelda botw and Totk are top tier, and I hear paper Mario thousand year door is supposed to be excellent as well.
I know a lot of people love the Galaxy games, but personally I really didn’t like any part where I had to run around on a small sphere. It often made me feel dizzy and would give me a headache after some time.
Super Mario sunshine is my personal favorite too!!!!loveeee that game so much but I’m in the exact same page as you, I know it different upon most Mario games but it’s sooo unique
before i even see the video its gonna be between mario galaxy and mario odyssey everything else was nice and all but these 2 just stand out more than any other 3d mario
Super Mario 64 for me. Nothing beats that Nostalgia. 64 DS is awesome too but I am from the school that burned down before the Old School. Super Mario RPG if included then Super Mario Galaxy then Odyssey then Bowsers Fury then 3D World and finally Sunshine thereafter. I have 3D Land but Can't stop Lulzing at the way it looks in 2024, never played it back when it released and thought I am not doing this right now when I got Mario Wonder. I will play through it soon since I do own it, I have too. All 3D Mario games kick arse.
Odyssey's controls really are the best. Galaxy has the best level design. Mario is just a tad slow in Galaxy. If 64 didn't have tank turning, I'd bump it up a bit. Good list
Them thinking there the best trilogy😕 1: super mario 3d land 2: super mario 3d world 3: Bowsers fury Did you forget about us? 😎 1 Super mario bros 2 Super mario bros 2 USA 3 Super Mario Bros 3
I loved Super Mario Odyssey when it was released; however, over time, I began to notice its flaws more and more. Today, I would rank *Odyssey* in fourth place, alongside 3D World + Bowser's Fury, and with Super Mario Galaxy 2, Super Mario Galaxy, and Super Mario 64 taking the lead. Now, I'd like to share my perspective on why it's not as high on my list. Firstly, its biggest flaw, in my opinion, is the excessive number of Power Moons. There seem to be around 10 Moons in every corner, easily obtained through ground pounding capturing or other little effort, with most lacking any real challenge. You can acquire 90% of the moons in less than a minute. In contrast, *Super Mario Galaxy* offered unique challenges with each Star, diverse environments, and captivating gameplay. With only a handful of Stars in each Galaxy, you completed it before it became monotonous. However, after collecting 50+ Moons in every Kingdom in *Odyssey*, the repetition became tiresome. While there are some more challenging Moons hidden behind Pipes or Doors, most environments feel artificial and lackluster, with the music becoming repetitive quickly. Another issue with the Kingdoms is their flat appearance. As they aimed for more realistic environments like New Donk City or the Sand Kingdom, there were fewer significant platforming areas. For instance, Tostarena Town and New Donk City lack depth in their Plattforming areas. Moreover, the Capture mechanic isn't as enjoyable in my opinion and can't replace traditional Mario items. Captures often feel like downgrades, restricting movement and only being necessary for specific events. Additionally, the lack of compelling bosses in Super Mario Odyssey is disappointing. Besides the Broodals, which I don't consider true bosses, there are only seven original bosses plus the final Bowser fight. While Super Mario Galaxy games felt like grand adventures, Odyssey feels more like a repetitive collection task, akin to gathering all 900 Korok Seeds in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. However some things i really like about odyssey are its graphics and movement. Even though you can cheese through many passages with the cappy mechanic
My favorite is Super Mario Galaxy 2, and my second favorite is Princess Peach: Showtime!. Super Mario Galaxy 2 has a much better camera than Super Mario Odyssey because the camera has smooth interpolation, and it is automatic, so you don't have to be controlling two analog sticks at once. The movement in Super Mario Galaxy 2 is more precise, so players cannot just speed through every level and skip past all the interesting mechanics and level design. In Super Mario Odyssey, moons are scattered everywhere and if you collect enough, you can skip the main story and boss fights.
![The HARDEST Boss Battle In Every Mario Game EVER! [55 Games!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vxuRUtJ31Rg/mqdefault.jpg)
![The HARDEST Boss Battle In Every Mario Game EVER! [55 Games!]](/img/tr.png)
Super Mario Sunshine is definitely one of the Mario best games to exist only do to it being unique and creative and it is really fun to master everything. The Dang Boat made my me rage in a game for the first time and every time now
I also love how the stages are all part of the island. Being able to see Pinna Park from Gelato made it feel more connected and believable.
Placing super mario 64 above sunshine is crazy, i will never understand the majority lol
Odyssey actually is a special game to me as well. I remember I brought it and hadn’t played it yet. My family actually had when on vacation for the weekend and I had the house to myself during that summer. I setup my front room just to chill and play Odyssey that weekend. It was just a great time. 2d will always be my favorite but Odyssey definitely is special to me
If I remember correctly, 3D Land was made because Nintendo wanted to introduce 2D Mario fans to the third dimension.
That's cool!
Crazy
+ so, it makes sense that the levels are linear and the camera is fixed, with the entire game sharing many different similarities between it and previous 2d games.
Super Mario 64 already did that 15 years earlier and way better
I think what he means is 3d land is a intro to 3d in a less ambitious way that wont overwhelm people who have only played 2d games. @@andyspendlove1019
"3d World is just lava, grass, desert, snow All stuff we've seen before" while playing footage of unique 3d world levels
Yeah so ? What did you expect that is what I love about it. Just simple unique levels to enjoy with your friends and alone.
Mario Odyssey is my all time favorite and after 8 years I have beaten it countless times and every time finding more moons I've never seen and as the video said the music is great it is something else if I showed someone New Donk city they would not be able to tell (besides the Mario billboards). That game is phenomenal I don't care how much I have to say it Mario Odyssey is my favorite game ever.
Mine too
I'm gonna be honest, I can't rank them. I just have too many emotional ties to each of these games that when thinking back to each of them, it's just happy memories. I try ranking them by using factors that each game has above the other, but then I remember how much fun I had with all of them. Even when there are times that they suck and become very frustrating, I can't help but just have joy in the experience. It's actually impossible for me to genuinely rank them. They are all amazing and just so much fun.
That's very well-said! They're all great and unique in too many ways, warranting giving them all a playthrough.
🤓
13:56 I love the respect you gave bouy base Galaxy, its probably has my favourite piece of music in any game ever
Happy to see 64ds get the respect it deserves!
Same
It deserves none
Even after 1 Month its still a Huge W Take.
@@Tyler-jp4vzit’s better than N64 Mario 64
@@Tyler-jp4vzagreed, it doesn't deserve to even to exists
3D Land gang assemble! My precious little masterpiece
A Mario 3D land enjoyer
@@bigman69617 Indeed my friend
*Y E S*
@@hichaelhyers 3D Land & 3D World should be higher. Above 64 & Sunshine at least.
I am here, brethren
With a Mario game I want the core Mario vibe with some new things i prefer not to much drastic from what I love in the Mario franchise but new things like power ups and enemies I love to see I don’t really like straying off from the core of Mario that we know and love (Awesome video keep up the good work!!! 🔥😎)
I like all 3D Mario games to be honestly none of them are bad
Yeah amazing how they’ve never messed up and made something unplayable even once on these
@@theeyeplaylists(cough) unlike Sonic (cough)
Not a Sonic hater by any means, but the first few 3D Sonic games are.... pretty broken
they are ALL great games not just ok or good but GREAT
Sunshine was terrible
Taking turns playing galaxy 1 and 2 with my brother will always be some of my favorite memories, and same with playing 3d world at my friends house, but when I finally got Mario odessy just last year, I was absolutely blown away, like I played it less than 6 months ago and I already have so much nostalgia for it + on the moon where all the different creatures from each kingdom stand next to each other looking at the earth still makes me tear up
I LOVE Mario 64 DS. So happy to see your ranking it as I felt I was on an island on this one
Same I still play it
I really enjoyed all the 3D Mario games but my personal favorites are Mario Galaxy 3D World and Mario Odyssey
Super Mario 3D Land or Super Mario Galaxy are my favorite 3D Mario games for the Wii and 3DS overall. Super Mario 3D World has a next level story in another world. Hats off to these 3 Mario games. 😄
Only correct opinion, aside from 3d worls
@@jheadley3667ratio
I love super Mario odyssey but the first 3D Mario game I’ve ever played was super Mario 64 DS and that would be my pick
Super Mario Odyssey is still head and shoulders above the rest in practically every way to me
@AmirLuckettain’t no way bro said it’s odysseys older brother💀 the games are nothing alike
I feel like its the game I feel the want to replay the least though.
I find Galaxy actually more fun and epic in feel. My issue with Odyssey is often there are parts of levels that are quite empty when you move off the beaten track. Galaxy was insane with it's creativity. Fun every second of play.
@AmirLuckett 3D World and Odyssey are THE most different 3D Mario games, they are almost nothing alike…
I agree 💯
Bowsers fury is phenomenal (for me at least) banger music, bosses, and levels, but SMO takes all that from fury to the extreme 👏
Bowsers fury and 3D world are the best
yes@@AdamKolbeck-gg9fn
@@AdamKolbeck-gg9fnagreed
Super Mario Odessy is easily the best imo and it'll be very hard to top
Mario Odyssey really might be the most flawless game on the Switch. One of the best games I’ve ever played
Well it definitely has flaws they are just very little. Galaxy was a more fun all the time Mario game. Odyssey has moments of repetitive moons and boring kingdoms. I love odyssey don't get me wrong but flawless it is not.
My favourite is super Mario 64 so many things to do and all of the soundtracks in it will remind me how great it is
odyssey was the reason i got into videogames, god, i cant imagine a life without it
Super mario 64 ds is my favorite game!
Mario sunshine is my favorite Mario game but I understand why people don't like it
People were promised 64, which got cancelled. 😢
Finally someone that remembers that 3D world and 3D land exists
Most of the Minigames in Mario 64 DS are also on the NSMBDS game as well, and I love those Minigames, I have very high scores on them, and I'm always trying to beat my personal best, even though some may be impossible to beat since I have them so high.
Super Mario Odyssey is one of my favorite and the best 3D Mario games ever! Yahoo!
Dead opinion
just because its got good graphics doesnt mean its yhe best, some games had graphical limitations man
@@jheadley3667your opinion is trash don’t hate
@@alan-tairoveverything about the game is what makes it the best not just graphics
3D Land is always a Nostalgic adventure for me, and it hurts to see it at the very bottom. None the less, this game screams simplicity and charm. And the Special 8 song just sounds so good.
I have over 500 hours in Mario 3d World (a lot for a story game) so this list is very heart breaking for me.. I have played most of these games, and I can say for certain that 3d world has a very interactive experience. The first time you play through with no spoilers, it is really fun. The bosses are exciting, the levels have variation, the ending boss is one of a kind, gave me chills the first run through as a kid, and also in my most recent run. I would argue that the quality of this game is better than all but Odyssey and Fury (graphics, story, gameplay) but I still understand and respect your list, even if it breaks my heart because we all know Odyssey belongs at the top for being an absolutely beautiful game. Glad you put it at the top!
Keanu Reeves is... Shadow the Hedgehog in... Sonic the Hedgehog 3!
Paramount Shadow: "Maria..."
What
What
Wrong video, dawg
My list is:
9. Super Mario 3D land
8. Super Mario 64 ds
7. Bowsers fury
6. Super Mario sunshine
5. Super Mario galaxy 2 (plz no hate, I don’t have too much experience with the game)
4. Super Mario 64
3. Super Mario 3D world
2. Super Mario galaxy
1. Super Mario odyssey
Dead list
Bro chill out
dead list
Can you explain your options or is that too much?
@@PearGoesIn it’s just that I haven’t got that much experience with galaxy 2 all of these are great games
9. 3D Land
8. 64 DS
7. 3D World
6. Bowser's Fury
5. 64
4. Odyssey
3. Sunshine
2. Galaxy 1
1. Galaxy 2
Deadest list itw
@@jheadley3667 Tell me your list then you prick. Let me guess, you love 3D Land
@@jheadley3667if you think this list is bad, make your own
@@alan-tairovodyssey at 1 and it isn’t close
@@OmarAlmuhaya.odyssey at 1 is crazy af, Mario galaxy is way better tbh
Playing Mario 64 ds on the 3ds where you dont have to use the d pad was fantastic.
I havent played very many mario games, but when i was a wee lad, mario sunshine on gamecube occupied a large portion of my childhood.
I don’t get why he thinks the 3D World is basic. It has some of the most unique Mario levels I’ve ever seen.
The soundtrack is a banger
My Top 5:
5. Sunshine
4. Galaxy 2
3. Oddysey
2. Galaxy
1. Mario 64
The nostalgia is talking
@@Aigle662frileux 64 is fucking phenomenal. If it was remastered today it would be peoples favorite mario game hands down its got great level design it just needs to be remade a little (which is completely normal for a almost 30 year old 3d game).
...OG 64
Galaxy
Oddyssey
ALRIGHT WE GET IT 0:18
My list
9-3D land
8-64 DS
7-64
6-Sunshine
5-Bowser Fury
4-Galaxy
3-Odyssey
2-Galaxy 2
1-3D world
3D World is at least top three IMO. It’s so good. Way too underrated.
It’s my favorite Mario game ever
Sunshine might be my least favorite of the ones I played. Though I will admit, Sunshine's themes are distinct and unmistakable. They did a great job making that game look, sound and feel like the idea of being at the beach during summer. It's like Mario's trip to Florida. Like lets go to the beach, lets go to the theme parks, lets get thrown around by the locals, lets go see the ugly loading docks, lets fall to our deaths in the void. Just like it really.
Super Mario Galaxy is way better than the others
I used to prefer Galaxy 1 to 2, but I like Galaxy 2 more because I think it has better power ups, better level design, and better bosses. Galaxy 1 is still phenomenal, but I just prefer Galaxy 2. Galaxy 1 and 2 are my two favorite games of all time
@@JGr2000bro gave every reason to like 2 over 1 lol
I have never played 2 so I am sticking with one
@@BluePikmin101same
agreed
My favorite is super Mario odyssey
To be perfectly honest here, I don’t think there’s a single bad 3D Mario. All of them are great.
Sunshine
@@Mazrio_RenardioMFG Sunshine is not terrible. Yes, it has more frustrating levels than 64, but the controls are good and that music is bliss even if it’s all sequenced. You can also ride Yoshi.
@@palacioestrella except you wanna keep Yoshi you have to feed him otherwise he dissolves.
@@palacioestrellacontrols are good but physics are terrible, the camera is almost as bad as 64 and about a third of the 120 shines made me want to rip out my pulmonary blood vessels. Also Yoshi is used for like 4 shines from what I can recall and all of them weren’t exactly fun
@notaurorahimmelwithlightystar Sorry to say. But Sunshine is like the only bad 3D Mario game. Even if it's not an terrible game or the worst game out there, it's still the only not so good 3D Mario game compared to others.
I’ve given up on it happening at this point, but I really think this series needs a sequel for Odyssey. Like, it doesn’t have to be as big. I don’t think we need another 800+ moon game, but it would be nice to have some kind of sequel to it.
Okay Nin10doland is my favorite RUclipsr but 3D world at 8th?! Come on man.
I first played SM64 for my first time last year and i love it 100% Nostalgia free
I agree that super Mario odyssey belongs at number one. But I will say this. This doesn’t say anything about where the game I’m about to reference belongs on this list by the way, but I always thought the game that reminds me the most of odyssey that isn’t odyssey is sunshine. Biggest reason: the wide distribution of NPCs some of which even move in each, the realistic worlds with unique architecture, the fact that they are the only two games with a camera being fully controlled in all angles by a separate analogue stick, the travel companions that Mario uses to enhance his abilities, the designated secret linear platforming levels, how big each world is. I can go on and on with this list. But yes I think Super Mario Sunshine and Odyssey are the two 3D Mario games that closely resemble each other most.
He really put my top 3 dead last😢
I wait for a future 3D Mario game: Mario Universe, a 3d open world platform-rpg and multiplayer game.
exactly what I want
Super Mario Sunshine is the best in my opinion. Not even a question!!!!!
What's your favorite level? Mine was Delfino hotel.
@@Matty_Ice3955 The level with the electric goop would drive me nuts! I can remember losing so many lives on that level lol. My favourite was Pinna Park, I just liked the vibe
@@Matty_Ice3955Ricco Harbor! First level i think of when talking about the game + makes me think about Metal Harbor in SA2. I also like the big squid
Insanely respectable list. I rate Galaxy and Galaxy 2 the highest but I love how high you rated Odyssey, it's such a spectacular game. I'm curious to see if my feelings for the game will grow even more one day and dethrones my two current favorites.
If you play Super Mario 3D Land emulated in Citra VR on a VR headset and use the emulator’s “immersive mode” - which expands the level to be visible all around you - it instantly becomes one of the best Mario games.
I hope the next Switch does something with VR.
Nice list, as someone who has played all the games, mine would be
9. Bowser's Fury
8: 3d land
7: 3d world
6: Sm64 DS
5: Super mario Sunshine
4: Super mario oddysey
3: Super mario 64
2: Galaxy 2
1: Super Mario galaxy
Didn't expect to agree with this list so much. Other than 3d World it's honestly perfect (though I do slightly prefer Galaxy 2 over Galaxy 1)
So idk if very many people know this, but in the beginning of Mario galaxy 2, it claims to be a retelling of the story of Mario galaxy 1
I can totally agree with the Top 3
Super Mario Galaxy is my favorite 3D Mario game overall because of its creativity and grand scope and pretty much everything else about it, but I still love the others too for different reasons. Super Mario 64 for its replayability and simplicity, Super Mario Sunshine for its uniqueness, style, FLUDD as a mechanic and Isle Delfino as a unique world and its interconnected nature and cohesion, Super Mario 64 DS because of its extra missions, minigames, having Luigi, Wario and Yoshi as playable characters, its new powerups and nostalgia as it was my first 3D Mario game and I love it because of that too, Super Mario 3D Land for its pick-up and play nature as a handheld 3D Mario and it's callbacks to Mario 3, and Super Mario 3D World for its playable characters, hybrid 2D & 3D nature and its great classic style linear platforming levels, it's new powerups like Cat Mario and the Double Cherry and its soundtrack as well, and Super Mario Galaxy 2 for its new powerups and how it uses Yoshi and has callbacks to past Mario games while having plenty of unique ideas of its own as well too, and Super Mario Odyssey for its fresh new kingdoms and how it honors the series's whole history in different ways, like with its 8-bit 2D sections, Cappy and the Capture mechanic and how abstract and unforgettable locations like New Donk City, the Luncheon Kingdom and Tosterena are, as well as its new characters like the Broodals, and the game's boss fights as well as its climatic ending sequence too, and Bowser's Fury for how much freedom it gives you, Plessis as a fast way to move around, being able to use 3D World's powerups in a more open game, and Fury Bowser's design and as a mechanic, the game's jazzy soundtrack and its loving and fun callbacks to Super Mario Sunshine as well.
Same Mario Galaxy 1 is my fave as well but I like the others for different reasons as well all the games have reason to like them
It’s weird to think about now, but I actually played Super Mario Galaxy 2 before I knew it was a sequel or knew the original existed. So when I first played 1, I kept wondering why Yoshi wasn’t there and why I was on an observatory rather than Mario’s head.
Sunshine will always be my favorite Mario 3d game.
Odyssey the goat in my top 5 all time game.
So I almost totally agree with your list. I was totally happy to see Mario 64 DS over the original and Galaxy 1 over 2 as controversial as those pics are. But dude, I gotta switch your number 1 and 2. Don't get me wrong, it is VERY close between those two, but Galaxy is ICONIC! The music, the worlds, the hub, the introduction of Rosalina, and just the whole atmosphere go together so perfectly. Like it is one of my few 10/10 games for sure. And like Odessey is good but I did have a few problems with it. The moons just don't feel as satisfying to get when you collect so many of them. And some of the worlds just felt disjointed compared to each other. But it's still really good, just 2nd for me. Also yes bring Galaxy 2 to switch please!
you have the correct opinion
While I 100% believe Galaxy is the best, I do respect this list. Well reasoned as well.
3D World would be in my Top 3 or 5
I kinda like the linear Mario games more, because you dont miss much
You know what, the D-pad controls on 64 DS don't matter to me as much now as they used to because of the fact that I've gotten used to them over the years but also I genuinely love 64 DS and it is my favorite 3D Mario game because what other 3D Mario has Wario as a playable character and has given an entire generation of gamers a gambling addiction?
Yea I love playing as Wario in 64 ds and he’s my fave character as well
Mario sunshine was basically the predecessor for Splatoon
The d-pad in M64 DS never phased me as a kid
I've only played a handful, but my top three is probably Odyssey, 3D World, and Galaxy. Galaxy is in a solid third, the other two are tied for first, they both are great for different reasons.
My ranking
1. Super Mario Galaxy 2
2. Super Mario Odyssey
3. Super Mario Galaxy
4. Super Mario 3D World
5. Super Mario 64
6. Super Mario 64 DS
7. Super Mario Sunshine
8. Super Mario 3D Land
9. Bowser’s Fury (It’s way too short to be better than any of the other FULL games)
Ever since SMB2, when I hoped SMB3 would be 3D (which a lot of game franchises were getting into at the time) and would yet return to form of the original SMB, that was what I always wanted from a 3D Mario. SMB had a "flow" to it, with its linear format, and "open world" just doesn't have it. In SMB, you automatically knew what to do, where in Mario 64, I didn't know where to begin. So 3DW and 3DL were the "holy grail", for me. Odyssey is nice for the realistic NYC graphics, and luncheon kingdom looks nice as well. Bowser's Fury is open world, but it's small size is non-overwhelming. My first 3D was Galaxy 2, and the little worldlet concept was also nice, and easier to know what to do. (I would group those togther, since they are so similar). With 64, I just can't get over the crude polygon graphics, and I don't know why they didn't completely redo that when they redid it for 3D Allstars. Sunshine was a bg improvement, though.
The polygon graphics just look so goofy 😂 half the time I’m like “what the heck is that” 😂
I think mario has the most robust and smoothest way to execute the moveset in odyssey. This, after going back to play galaxy and sunshine.
It felt like mario 64 and sunshine perfected the adventure exploration, Galaxy 1 and 2 perfected the platforming and Odyssey brought it all together ❤
My List:
1. Sunshine
2. 64
3. Galaxy
4. Galaxy 2
5. Odyssey
6. 64 DS
7. 3D World
8. Bowser's Fury
9. 3D Land
I agree. Sunshine deserves to be at the top.
Sunshine is my favorite Mario game.
1. SM64 DS is indeed better than the og.
2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a retelling of SM Galaxy 1. At the end of the game we find out that Rosalina was telling the story to some baby Lumas.
Is mario odyssey worth it? I literally just got a switch 2 weeks ago. I am mostly an rpg guy but love adventure games and 2d mario. Odyssey looks really fun because it seems more like an adventure game rather than a platformer where you just have to make it to the end of the level. It looks like there is a lot of replay value and post game content which is important to me. I'm curious on what people would choose between odyssey and kirby forgotten land?
If you have a history in Kirby, get Forgotten Land. Otherwise get Odyssey.
Personally, I like odyssey better than Kirby and the forgotten land. However, the co-op is better in Kirby if you plan to play with someone. Kirby’s levels are also more linear, whereas odysseys are more of a sand box. They are both fantastic games however and you won’t be disappointed with either.
If you’re interested in rpg and adventure games though, legend of Zelda botw and Totk are top tier, and I hear paper Mario thousand year door is supposed to be excellent as well.
3d land is #3 for me but at least he didnt forget about it
I think Mario odyssey is my favorite video game EVER not listening to the community also exactly agree with your ranking
I know a lot of people love the Galaxy games, but personally I really didn’t like any part where I had to run around on a small sphere. It often made me feel dizzy and would give me a headache after some time.
64 sunshine galaxy and odyssey all hit the mark, they all have their pros and cons but I loved going for all the stars/shines/moons on all of them
Super Mario sunshine is my personal favorite too!!!!loveeee that game so much but I’m in the exact same page as you, I know it different upon most Mario games but it’s sooo unique
Super Mario Galaxy is still the best 3D title in my opinion. The music, the levels, the visuals, the overall concept is just amazing.
They're all GREAT
before i even see the video its gonna be between mario galaxy and mario odyssey everything else was nice and all but these 2 just stand out more than any other 3d mario
I actually enjoy 3D Land more than 3D World. With the fixed isometric camera, I think the stereoscopic 3D really helps.
You forgot Mario rabbids if it counts
Technically that's a RPG yes there is 3D parts like the hub world but that's not the main part of the game.
Finally someone who realizes how good Mario 64 da really is
Super Mario 64 for me. Nothing beats that Nostalgia. 64 DS is awesome too but I am from the school that burned down before the Old School. Super Mario RPG if included then Super Mario Galaxy then Odyssey then Bowsers Fury then 3D World and finally Sunshine thereafter. I have 3D Land but Can't stop Lulzing at the way it looks in 2024, never played it back when it released and thought I am not doing this right now when I got Mario Wonder. I will play through it soon since I do own it, I have too. All 3D Mario games kick arse.
Top for me is Odyssey. Bottom will have to be Sunshine. Never really cared for that one.
Not a single day makes me forget Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Odyssey because I love these games
Odyssey's controls really are the best. Galaxy has the best level design. Mario is just a tad slow in Galaxy. If 64 didn't have tank turning, I'd bump it up a bit. Good list
Them thinking there the best trilogy😕
1: super mario 3d land
2: super mario 3d world
3: Bowsers fury
Did you forget about us? 😎
1 Super mario bros
2 Super mario bros 2 USA
3 Super Mario Bros 3
Thank you for making Mario odyssey my favorite game ever I’m subscribing
Nothin like soaring off the top of the tallest tower in Metro Land😂
3d land has always been so underrated to me
Bowser's Fury is my fav Mario game and I will stand by that
Quality over Quantity
I loved Super Mario Odyssey when it was released; however, over time, I began to notice its flaws more and more. Today, I would rank *Odyssey* in fourth place, alongside 3D World + Bowser's Fury, and with Super Mario Galaxy 2, Super Mario Galaxy, and Super Mario 64 taking the lead.
Now, I'd like to share my perspective on why it's not as high on my list.
Firstly, its biggest flaw, in my opinion, is the excessive number of Power Moons. There seem to be around 10 Moons in every corner, easily obtained through ground pounding capturing or other little effort, with most lacking any real challenge. You can acquire 90% of the moons in less than a minute. In contrast, *Super Mario Galaxy* offered unique challenges with each Star, diverse environments, and captivating gameplay. With only a handful of Stars in each Galaxy, you completed it before it became monotonous. However, after collecting 50+ Moons in every Kingdom in *Odyssey*, the repetition became tiresome. While there are some more challenging Moons hidden behind Pipes or Doors, most environments feel artificial and lackluster, with the music becoming repetitive quickly.
Another issue with the Kingdoms is their flat appearance. As they aimed for more realistic environments like New Donk City or the Sand Kingdom, there were fewer significant platforming areas. For instance, Tostarena Town and New Donk City lack depth in their Plattforming areas.
Moreover, the Capture mechanic isn't as enjoyable in my opinion and can't replace traditional Mario items. Captures often feel like downgrades, restricting movement and only being necessary for specific events.
Additionally, the lack of compelling bosses in Super Mario Odyssey is disappointing. Besides the Broodals, which I don't consider true bosses, there are only seven original bosses plus the final Bowser fight.
While Super Mario Galaxy games felt like grand adventures, Odyssey feels more like a repetitive collection task, akin to gathering all 900 Korok Seeds in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.
However some things i really like about odyssey are its graphics and movement. Even though you can cheese through many passages with the cappy mechanic
Dude, the dedication it took to type this all out...phenomenal
Completely agree, and I’m not sure galaxy could ever be topped tbh
My favorite is Super Mario Galaxy 2, and my second favorite is Princess Peach: Showtime!.
Super Mario Galaxy 2 has a much better camera than Super Mario Odyssey because the camera has smooth interpolation, and it is automatic, so you don't have to be controlling two analog sticks at once. The movement in Super Mario Galaxy 2 is more precise, so players cannot just speed through every level and skip past all the interesting mechanics and level design. In Super Mario Odyssey, moons are scattered everywhere and if you collect enough, you can skip the main story and boss fights.
princess peach showtime isnt even a mario game bro it doesnt even have mario in the game 🤦🤦🤦