Brian Greene - What Was There Before The Big Bang?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- The American theoretical physicist, Brian Greene explains various hypotheses about the causation of the big bang. Brian Greene is an excellent science communicator and he makes complex cosmological concepts more easy to understand.
The Big Bang explains the evolution of the universe from a starting density and temperature that is currently well beyond humanity's capability to replicate. Thus the most extreme conditions and earliest times of the universe are speculative and any explanation for what caused the big bang should be taken with a grain of salt. Nevertheless that shouldn't stop us to ask questions like what was there before the big bang.
Brian Greene mentions the possibility that time itself may have originated with the birth of the cosmos about 13.8 billion years ago.
To understand how the Universe came to be, scientists combine mathematical models with observations and develop workable theories which explain the evolution of the cosmos. The Big Bang theory, which is built upon the equations of classical general relativity, indicates a singularity at the origin of cosmic time.
However, the physical theories of general relativity and quantum mechanics as currently realized are not applicable before the Planck epoch, which is the earliest period of time in the history of the universe, and correcting this will require the development of a correct treatment of quantum gravity.
Certain quantum gravity treatments imply that time itself could be an emergent property. Which leads some physicists to conclude that time did not exist before the Big Bang. While others are open to the possibility of time preceding the big bang.
One of the common misconceptions about the Big Bang model is that it fully explains the origin of the universe. However, the Big Bang model does not describe how energy, time, and space were caused, but rather it describes the emergence of the present universe from an ultra-dense and high-temperature initial state. It is misleading to visualize the Big Bang by comparing its size to everyday objects. When the size of the universe at Big Bang is described, it refers to the size of the observable universe, and not the entire universe.
#bigbang #bgreene #science
SUBSCRIBE to our channel "Science Time": / sciencetime24
SUPPORT us on Patreon: / sciencetime
BUY Science Time Merch: teespring.com/...
Sources:
Briang Greene at JRE: • What Was Happening Bef...
NDT: • Neil DeGrasse Tyson: B...
science.nasa.g...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
"Brian Greene no Fronteiras do Pensamento Porto Alegre 2014" by fronteirasweb is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0
Shoutout to the universe for makng this video possible.
praises to The Creator no the creation praises to Allah
m.ruclips.net/video/69AmLbNeNf0/видео.html
@@wishuonmyjourney818 nah
@@wishuonmyjourney818 Schrodinger's allah. Was there a god before anybody was there to observe it?
Without it, you woudn´t exist
@@RoseInTheWeeds one question: who?
This really pulls you back into how overwhelming the thought is of the universe and space really is.
Too much to comprehend sensory overload
It's disappointing to know we're not equipped with the hardware to comprehend this stuff
@Mike Seork The thought that space could potentially be infinite is hard to grasp because humans are hardwired either by nature or nurture to think that everything is finite and has a beginning and an end. Every day use of infinite or it's synonyms are usually not true infinite, so the actual thought of something having no end is impossible to wrap my head around. How would something like that work? How could there never be an end to the size of something? How can something have no beginning, It just exists? Space can't just be "nothing" since we are able to exist in it, it has to be "something". So many questions we may never have answers to. I love learning about space but when we start talking about the starting point or the infinity of the universe, it boggles my mind to the point where I need to go observe some finite things, like my bag of chips coming to an end.
Yet somehow we’re here experiencing spacetime and I think somehow we are the manifestation of the universe asking itself wtf it is lol
@@shadoukingu3730 I don’t think space could be infinite since it’s expanding and something that which is infinite cannot increase or decrease in size.
I live in Russia and I am suffering from schizophrenia and anxiety on daily basis atmosphere here is always haunted rainy and snowy but when I listen to these type of videos I get a sense of relief and feels good ...that's why I wanna be a astrophysicist
There is an American Catholic priest who gives a great talk on the big bang called fr spitzer.
Always wanted to go to Russia, maybe one day when the world get back to normal🙂
Fr Spitzer God and science.
It is a good talk.
@@07nuahs Definitely gonna check out fr Spitzer
Stay away from priests. I haven't seen a priest who has a good understanding of evolution, abiogenesis or cosmology. They are average at best, but will try to sneak their religious doctrine at any opportunity. Stick to mainstream, well-known scientists.
I believe in you bro you can do it
And the most interesting part for me, is that we are the conscious part of the universe reflecting upon itself.
Omniscient entity could not have subjective experiences. For it to know everything it would probably want to experience everything first hand. We are just god experiencing itself
@@2010RSHACKS interesting perspective.
That's opinion though.
What we call consciousness is just an abstract term for our brains complex electro bio chemical processes. The universe never needed humanity to experience its self. It's just our interpretations of the universe
@@emiliospowerballer1441 the thing is, we are undeniably a part (possitive energy) of the universe, for it was from the universe we were derived, and with our specific case...consciousness. Now, consciousness cannot be directly defined...even to the sciences. Humans are not only contained within the universe...we are of the universe. This is not to be confused that we are the center of the universe; humans habitually catorgorize what he or she deems worthy. You can no more extract us from the universe, though, than you can a planet, a flower, or even a unicellular organism. Humans are probably no more essential than is an inanimate object. The universe is neither good nor bad, rather it is neutral. Admittedly, humans are extremely destruction, and in the grand scheme of the universe, it affects nothing. But if we want to see the earth in better condition, than we are certainly on the wrong path to success.
@@2010RSHACKS in order for the claim that we are god, we must meet the criteria. Are you applying that title metaphorically, like a representation of something greater, such as the universe?
Believe it or not watching these videos is the only way I can fall asleep.
Me too
I believe it . I save these videos to "daily sleep" playlists, and watch them in bed after everyone else is asleep.
Lol I always want to watch them but end up drifting off and keep having to go back to finish them...
I’m not surprised, I used to put headphones on and just lay down and listen to all the information being thrown at me. I love it, the universe is such an interesting place, I wish more people were curious about our own existence
Nowadays, I get Lovecraft-esque nightmares when I sleep listening to such videos. The true nature and scale of the universe terrifies me!
I wish people would be more excited to learn science instead of social media and celebrities
Justin Bieber, Kim Kardashian
they want to be tik tok dancers when they grow up
I wish ppl were excited just to learn in general lol.
Well, we are an anomaly in a sea of intellectual disintegration
It's not for everyone plain and simple let people enjoy whatever they want
Massive respect to the camera device who survived this Big bang and delivered to us a wonderful footage.
😂😂 there are many naive ignorants out there. And just because of them nazza keep consuming 50mln$ of our money for cartoons like this. I will never forget how many dumbs are between us. Some of them even after 2 years keep wearing a mask in their car.
I’m with you 110%!!! It’s had to believe that folks are so ignorant
@@derrickwalker538 even after we have seen how many they are. Heroes that save society by wearing a mask😂
They were definitely using a Nokia!
😂nah... am the one who shoots this spectacular videos.....
Fair play to Brian Greene for standing on that accretion disk, not many men would have the balls to do so.
He could only do it because black holes are not the most dense object in the universe - that title belongs to his balls.
It's a good thing that someone was there to film it all!
It’s probably CGI because this happened before humans were born
My guess is a GoPro, the Big Bang must have been intense
Brian Greene was there
@@greenamogus yeah of course it’s recreated. Hubble has shown us wonders but it isn’t perfect. It takes a long time do get the data from these vast distances. But none the less Hubble is amazing and stands as one of the best if not the best single object ever created. We had no idea the universe was as vast as it currently is. What’s crazier is the universe may be way bigger than we currently think it is. We may never see any further either because parts space are expanding faster than the speed of light. So light from those distances will never reach us in an infinite amount of time. 🤯
@@u.p.trailseeker7350 and.... you are exactly right (especially regarding size and expansion)... Although some would argue that man's greatest invention was the internet?!?
What's equally as fascinating as our understanding of the universe is our grasp of English. I don't understand 94% of what was said in this amazing video.
97%, only the words in particular 😃😃😃
It’s the use of big words made by people that don’t know anything to confound the public.
@@dalecain1158 So... Einstein was an idiot then? Because he was a Theoreticsl physicist at the bleeding edge of science and he revolutionized the field in a way that brought us groundbreaking discoveries about the nature of reality and causality.
These are the best theories we have, and science will continue pushing that boundary. Of course, right now, the most intellectually honest words we can say are "We don't know." And we may never know. Perhaps if we created a highly intelligent AI we might, but that doesn't stop us from searching in the present.
@@etherealstars5766 did I say he was an idiot? No. Science says all this happened by a Big Bang. That’s like saying “s$&t happens!” Give us all a break. Science can’t explain the universe much less it’s origin.
@@dalecain1158 I'm sorry, but all the best, rigorous scientific evidence shows us a universe that started in a hot dense state. With observations of the night sky and rigorous mathematics, we can determine things that happened beyond a reasonable doubt. I'm no expert, but this video highlights that ruclips.net/video/aPStj2ZuXug/видео.html
There is no competing theory that comes close to explaining the evidence that we see.
The animation of these temporal phenomena is breathtaking. I love Brian Greene's ability to clearly describe theory and process in the simplest terms. Amazing video!
I just need every single wallpaper used in this video.
@@suningchen I'm absolutely with you. I have screenshots from Interstellar on my desktop the images are so breathtaking. I just can't get enough of these phenomenal visualizations.
Exactly...animation...CGI...this never happened 🤦♂️
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us. Y
I am convinced that our universe was made by alternate universe scientists trying to understand the big bang
I’ve heard of that one. And that one day we could end up doors the same. Probably not for few hundred years.
There was a book by Gregory benford I think called cosm. Scientist did just that but by accident
@@adamnsmartguy3574Scaremonger with religion is a very un evolved and archaic intelligence. You’re living in 2023 and you manage to think like that
@@adamnsmartguy3574keep your beliefs to yourself and respect other peoples beliefs. Thank you
I’m thinking that at the end of our universe when it’s just filled with black holes. That they go though their own big bangs. Basically a on and on life cycle
I think, big bang, stars are made, planet's are made, life on planet's, star's die, planets die, life dies"repeat" then a black hole come along, eats all planet's and stars, black hole eats all galaxy's, no more planets and stars, then the big bang. "repeat"
Before the Big Bang there existed a mythical age called "The Good Ole Days"
I was gonna try to just comment, saw yours and thought wow!
yeah, when parents walked up hill both ways, over volcanos through the iceage
@@robmadsen5732 Take your medication.
Better being in them days than sitting here even trying to begin to comprehend something of this magnitude... its astronomic... how we shouldnt even exist and we do, how quick a video made by computers and being watched on a computer can easily sway the attention from thinking about the mad possibilities within what we are seeing. To just simplify one thought is truly how trapped the system has people, just at least weigh the options, doesnt mean you have to stop doing anything you're doing that you defend against one thought you have about what you're thinking about, since GOD, why cant he be real and create all this, just because you feel guilty you jerk off or something, do youunderstand, lol, I believe in god, doesnt mean I'm perfect, doesnt mean people have to do all this perfect stuff, the fact we can even watch this, expands my mind to the next level, think on it, doesnt mean you gotta pay the preacher if you know what I mean... peace
Now imagine , just saying , someone floating around thinking or dreaming of reality and woke up and said let their be life 😂 and all things literally just exploded and formed perfectly , like I am the shit 😂😂😂 ideas , like a child with live world's and toys and we're it , well that's everything and alien or monsters whatever floats your boat 🤔🤔🤔 someone's brain synapses , boredom , people want to argue but we are here ya know and who knows , no matrix crap either , ya know that make me think man really just is completely jealous of a God if any , and he'll lie to make himself feel good about being less than God 😇😇 ❤️ total contradictory knowing man can't explain someone else work , to explain or create is from one self 💯
I think it is important to be mindful that when we ask the question: "What was there before the big bang?" We are basically saying: "What reality existed before the reality we are familiar with?" Which is the space-time continuum. I think scientifically it is almost impossible to answer this question because we are only familiar with our current dimension, we can only especulate about it which is part of our curiosity. Additionally when we ask this question we are always forced to ask: "What was there before that and before that and before that ....etc" which will ultimately always lead to infinitum, something without beginning or end. Can our 3 pound brain ever comprehend that?
It's not the brain that does the comprehension, that is what keeps eluding them. The brain is yet an finite organ that transmits the consciousness, which is infinite; therefore we need constructs to help with perspective, thus the illusion of space & time- a beginning/end, start/finish, yesterday/tomorrow, etc. There is only a continuation of Now, there has always been and always will be only the Moment.
~The Matrix has you Neo
@@bennyjet7 Conciousness isn't infinte, what does that even coneptually mean?
@@okaydetar821 you answered your own question, trying to perceive something, that has always been and always will be (therefore always is) with a physical organ (the brain) that hasn't always been and will cease to be eventually; thus you are not conscious (aware) that you are a part of something that is eternal. Consciousness ( a.k.a. awareness, knowledge, information, energy) being infinite means: a substance/matter/entity/a knowing can't be destroyed, only altered into different states. Therefore, it has no end. And logically if something has no end then neither does it have a beginning. If there's anything "conceptual" about all of this is our perspective and perception. If our perspective is based in a 3 dimensional frame, on a multidimensional subject, then our perception will be limited. example: H2O has 3 states of being, liquid, solid, gas. I pour some water into a tray and make ice, the ice melts and evaporates into the atmosphere making water again. Which came 1st? Our perception says "the water" because our perspective was at the particular stage in the cycle, however that cycle had been happening long before we came on to the scene. [I'm not suggesting H2O is infinite, just using it as metaphor of how we tend to view and interact with cycles].
@@bennyjet7 Ima have to take this one piece by piece, at least the pieces I can understand, because man, you said some wild stuff here.
"Consciousness ( a.k.a. awareness, knowledge, information, energy) being infinite means: a substance/matter/entity/a knowing can't be destroyed, only altered into different states."
You can't really just say matter/knowing in the same category, they are extremely different things, also, matter can be destroyed, so can a substance, so can an entity, energy is the only thing that can't be "destroyed" and "knowing" is a concept not an actual thing ,and destroying a concept is a nonsensical proposition, its like counting the third side of a circle, even conceiving of that is invalid.
" And logically if something has no end then neither does it have a beginning. "
That is not logical, that is flatly and demonstrably wrong. A whole number number line which starts at 0 will never have an end, but the beggining is 0, this assertion is bunk.
" If our perspective is based in a 3 dimensional frame, on a multidimensional subject, then our perception will be limited. "
That is a BIG old if right there, and even granting it, we live in 3 spatial dimensions where we DO have perception of the fourth (Time) just fine despite not living on that dimensional frame, making this another assertion with nothing backing it up.
" H2O has 3 states of being, liquid, solid, gas. I pour some water into a tray and make ice, the ice melts and evaporates into the atmosphere making water again. Which came 1st?"
Well this is an easy one, because the conditions required for the hydrogen and oxygen to bond is to high for it to be any other state, the h20 had to start as a gas. Its like the chicken or the egg question, it sounds like a smart question, but ultimately it has a definitive answer and scientists aren't curious about it at all.
@@okaydetar821 lol, i'll leave you with this (cause this can be the primer to the rest) its been proven scientifically that all matter (down to the quantum level and beyond) consist of energy; so if a material substance is destroyed, does it stop existing? I feel your struggle. I once too had disbelief in the intangible, until I had an experience that allowed me to be open-minded (or maybe I was open-minded to having an experience? egg & chicken conundrum) to the awareness that everything (all material substance seen, even unseen) is connected. That "things" being separate and unrelated is an illusion (yet can have a purpose). At that moment "I" became conscious! In spiritualism its called "enlightenment", in computer engineering it would be considered "self-aware" (theoretically with A.I.). So, from that moment on my "concept" of life and death fundamentally changed. If I am a material substance composed of energy at a sub-atomic level, then everything about me is just released back into the universe, at my time of physical decay; thus starting another cycle. I understand the perplexing frustration. It seems as humans we're OK with something going on forever, but it seems to drive us mad when we don't have a starting point. This, I believe is why we need to use the concept of a space-time continuum, which is an illusion (with a purpose) within itself. Question: when you say something to yourself without speaking it out loud, who's doing the talking? Most people would agree that it was "themselves" speaking. "Self" consisting of mind and body. But if you allow your "self" to think outside the box, that would be like saying, "myself is operating a car, therefore I am a car". ~Sincerely, Morpheus
It’s always sobering to take a step back and recall how fascinating the universe is. From the cosmos, to the depths of the deepest oceans. To the roots of antiquity to studies of the paranormal.
It’s bollocks
@@gaglet what is?
@@jermainerucker2027 the universe
@@gaglet i agree a load of gobeldygook nonsense
Why people don’t want to believe their is a creator!!
any chance you could address the question posed in the title of the video, i.e. "before" the big bang ... rather than just have another video describing what happened in the stages after it?
Good Luck. The only explanation is a god. Then the question would be is the creation of a god. Logic pretty much says there had to be a god that could create something from nothing. Not much chance of them admitting that.
I'm very grateful for this content.
Toxic Gamer
The animation of this is amazing. I’ve spent countless hours watching universe videos and most are very hard to visualize, but this helps a lot. Still needs work, but the endeavor is visible
@@jaydeeppatel7369 was just about to comment this
@@jaydeeppatel7369 melody sheep is the best
The BIG Bang-Bit Bang/Supermassive White Hole inflation-expansion of energy & information into the void 13.77 billion years ago was spawned by a supermassive black hole at the heart of a galaxy in our 'parent universe'.
See Seal #1a at 7seals.blogspot.com - only the returned Christ & Einstein reincarnated could produce that. It's triggered The Apocalypse/Revelation which is NOT the 'end of the world'. COVID-19 was added to Seal #4: S=19 (18.6) Theory.
Fart
The fuk is this reply section?
Beginning and the end are just human concepts created by us living on this one grain of sand , probably that's why we can't understand what was there in the "beginning"
I agree! who says there was a 'beginning'? what a strange concept?!
Human lives have a beginning and an end. If nothing existed before the Big Bang, is that not a beginning to the universe?
🙄
There has to be a beginning. At some point there was nothing and then there was something (everything). Everything has to start somewhere. No?
@@Scott-hq3jq how could there not be a beginning? Your saying something can just have always existed? Everything has to start somewhere. Everything has to have been created with something. Seems like it to me anyways. I know this sh*t makes my head want to explode freaking thinking about it.
For the big bang to have started, the concept of time must have already existed.
Exactly
this, it just doesn't make sense that time was created out of an explosion
That's because Christ created time, space and matter. @@forget4478
@@forget4478 I agree. Isn't time just a human invention, not some actual thing that magically started up with the big bang?
Time does not explain how there was nothing that then became something.
Brian Greene is my favorite science communicator, love listening to programs with him.
Lies again? Spank Bang
this stuff absolutely blows my mind i cant put it into words
@ Evan
It sure does. Personally I dont belive the religious explannation, but also believe the scientific explanation.
@@afcansf5996 ok and why do you believe in the scientific explanation ? Since there is no proof to neither of them. But relegious (Islamic) explanation makes more sense
I wonder if we live inside a black hole and maybe that is what caused the Big Bang
7:34 "the big bang was an interesting event, but not the first..."
Whenever I hear this and think about an infinite regress of universes/multiverses/turtles, I have this flash of "this is fucking crazy".
Same here, I can't put my finger on it at the moment but it seems that it violates some basics of logic.
It’s because it makes no sense, it’s just a story, not science or scientific.
I don’t think we have found anything yet that has not come from somewhere else. Logically everything comes from something the singularity is (I think) the only time things seem to have appeared for no reason. I think this is why the struggle to explain it ends up at the idea of infinite big bangs. But everything I learned about cosmology I learned on RUclips. 🤣
@@fiftycalguru even a universe with a finite beginning blows my mind. Something from nothing. Just incredible. And if it doesn't have a finite beginning and something always existed... Equally as mind blowing.
@@JoshyStuart agreed, I wasn’t trying to make fun of your comment at all.
I feel that time never stops, you only can measure it by what’s inside time but time itself is infinite
time is finite there was a beginning and will be a end to space time
@@gecg7393 There is no empirical evidence whatsoever to support your claim of time having and beginning or an end; more so, logically this cannot be the case because then there would be a time before time and a time after time, of which is impossible. Time and space are both eternal, and the big bang was merely a change in said spacetime.
Furthermore, if the big bang was truly an event that occurred at all, then time and space must have already existed; if not, then there was no time for said event to occur (all change requires time), and no space for it to occur within. The big bang is merely the beginning of our own spacetime bubble, it was not the beginning of time or space, nor can such things (or really, one thing--spacetime) ever begin or end.
@@scaryperi3051 you've spoke a lot of mans evil imagination, fairy tales of the none observable of man made hocus pocus theory's of a supernatural premise, but let me say time space and matter came into existence all together for one can not be with out the other, so finite or we would not see this young and full of matter and energy universe and fine tuned to a atom for the universe to be, but I'll reach for the supernatural as well there was a timeless all knowing all powerful all HOLY HOLY HOLY GOD who brought all that we see, know and our into existence which as been documented by the SPIRIT given to devout man who were moved by the HOLY SPIRIT of GOD for GOD is SPIRIT for GOD as made HIM self known to us and if you deny that it changes nothing HE will still be.
@@gecg7393 You're projecting. My claims are based on pure logic, which requires no empirical evidence but itself--that's how logic works. If you want to indulge in the fantasy that time and space can have a beginning (or an end), then feel free to do so.
And of course you're a theist, which is an inherently irrational position. There is no evidence for the existence of ANY god, including yours, and the fact that you and your like believe in such without said evidence is indeed irrational, by definition. Congratulations on not being an exception.
If your god existed outside of time, then he is impotent and cannot do anything, because as previously mentioned, it takes time for any change to occur, including the creation of matter and energy. But again, you fail at logic, science, and of course, reason. Just like every single theist does, to varying degrees. Enjoy your delusions! They're all you've got. Ad be sure to protect them from that pesky reasoning and that stupid need for empirical evidence; just ignore them and believe on!
Every single theistic argument is based on logical fallacies, and your finetuning fallacy is no exception.
@@scaryperi3051 the point is time began in this universe due to the big bang
Hats off to whoever did the visuals ! Really fascinating trying to understand what it would have been like during recombination. LOVE THIS
I'm not wearing a hat.
@@proto-geek248 Same here
Not afraud of serial killers or war etc etc, the scientist that figure this stuff out is truely fearsome. These people are straight up insane working on a level most normal people can comprehend.
We are alone in the universe or there are other beings out there. Either concept is equally scary.
Oh wow did you come up with that yourself?
That's really original
Sir why is Monday so far from Friday, and Friday so close to Monday?
Lol!
🤣🤣🤣
Imagine being able to spectate these kind of things… and to be able to fly freely and discover what’s out there. And see how other intelligent living beings live their life.. so many things I want to know
There are no other types of intelligent life in the universe. At least not in a sense that we are accustomed to
@@jamesearlhayes so are you God to be able to know that?
Seeing this video and some others last days, make me think there must be countless other life forms on countless other planets in countless other galaxies eventually in countless other universes.
To know how much forms of life we know on earth, i’m pretty sure there have to be so many other life somewhere out there.
@@haiderameer9473 no. I'm not God but I am his son. Do you believe in him
@@jamesearlhayes it doesn’t matter if I do lol. You can’t say there’s no intelligent life so definitively. Anything is possible with the universe being as big as it is.
Continuing Searching for Answers : the perfect sentence of science.
That's the theory
Seek and ye shall find. I did. And a physicist can ask "what was there before the Big Bang," but only a METAphysicist can answer that question: Before the "Big Bang" there was perfect harmony of all Being. Yes, that includes YOU. Because, the "Big Bang" was nothing more than the answer to a problem that erupted when some beings attempted to empower the idea of DISCORD. Yes, that includes YOU. The "Big Bang" was when "God" "spoke" a single "Word" that created the physical Universe. (I note that the word uni-verse literally means ONE WORD.) And this Universe is nothing more or less than a pre-determined MATRIX that will return you to rational thought. GUARANTEED. Want to know more? Give me a "click." God's prophet has spoken.
@@tomrhodes1629 Can you tell me the 'exact' method you personally used to verify your assertion?
1) Answers only lead to more questions,
2) see above.
When did God come to this? Who made him?
In a cosmos where we use MASSIVE numbers to describe quantities or distances or sizes, 13.8 billion years is terribly unimpressive. That alone should be enough to think there's more to the story.
Perks of being single. You can watch these videos all night before sleeping without getting interrupted.
My wife is asleep next to me, no need to be single. I watch videos most nights
@@lcano2222 facts lol
@@lcano2222 been married, divorced and dating - it’s better single
@@HypePerformanceGroup Na.
@@lcano2222 you must really love your fam
Time as a countable beat, whether there was a universe or not, is infinite. I could have never started because there is a moment before any point in time.
Brian Greene is my favourite physicist.
Not Brian Cox ?:(
@@S3aCa1mRa1n Brian Cox is left leaning
@@ripper5941 Is Brian Greene not left leaning ?
@@S3aCa1mRa1n I don't know
@david ludwig In what way is he left leaning ? I mean to a certain extent aren’t most people ?
This brings me back to before there was anything, and you didn't have to worry about a comet or asteroid ending your existence. Those were the times, maaan. You didn't have to do anything.
I was pondering this exact same subject earlier - just before it dawned on me I need to pay my council tax.
This is kinda amazing and scary, it just show that there are so many things we still don't know.
I don’t know about that
What we know today isn’t the tiniest tiny fraction of 0.0000000000001%.
You will never know everything
@@robortalien im choosing to look at it from the pov that we never run out from things to resarch, sound more fun to me
@@amospinhas767 whats the fun in endless researching and never coming to an end
Im personally a fan of the theory that the universe rubber bands on itself. Eventually things travel so far out they begin to pull back, eventually compressing back down into one ball of unimagineable mass ...compressing and finally exploding out again ..repeating the cycle of creation on an unknown time scale.... so nothing is ever truly lost
I like this concept. It doesn’t hurt my brain. Lol.
Unfortunately thats not what the math says. I think Penrose is on to something when he explains the Universe will eventually evaporate into nothing. When all the black holes evaporate and the last photon particles disappear,and there’s nothing left….time stops and the infinitely large universe is exactly the same size and state as the singularity event at the very beginning of our universe…, that is where the new big bang might occur. Its mind blowing to imagine such a vast size is the same equal size as the unimaginably small singularity . No matter,equals no time or size. This event goes on and on and on….
Great stuff to ponder.
@@Boogieplex now my brain hurts. Thanks. Lol
The closed universe theory was already dis-proven decades ago.
Our universe is an open universe that will ultimately evaporate into an evenly distributed, entropically neutral, sea of sub atomic particles after trillions and trillions and trillions of years
ruclips.net/video/Qg4vb-KH5F4/видео.html
They have noticed that the galaxies are moving away from each other at a faster and faster rate...that's what prevents the Big Crunch....maybe it the repulsive properties of gravity that is expanding the universe......or maybe it's just god......
I swear this kinda stuff cures depression. The galaxy is too big to be depressed about some bullshit. I understand clinical depression, I suffer from it. But when you're reminded of the big bang or anything related to the vastness of the galaxy, I feel it can really bring you back to existence and straighten your way of thinking. At least for a little bit.
🔷 The Infinite Conglomerate of Universes Theory: Creating Universes with BIG Bangs-Bit Bangs/Supermassive White Holes-Quantum Tunneling Wormholes 🔷
combining GOD/Nature, ancient religions, astronomy, cosmology, fined-tuned laws of physics/general relativity/quantum mechanics, chaos theory/fractals, laws of biology & chemistry, programming the Universe/GOD=GOOD=7_4 or FOD=6_4 (on Planet Nestor) Theory - Design Worlds Theory/’Theory of Everything’, mysticism, philosophy/anthropic principle
Everything is energy and information. Info can be created but not lost, only shared, preserved, and transferred.
Universes reproduce. 'The BIG Bang-Bit Bang/Supermassive White Hole-Quantum Tunneling Wormhole' inflation-expansion of energy₇₄ and quantum information into the void 13.77 billion-years-ago was spawned by a supermassive black hole at the center of 1-in ~200 billion galaxies in our parent₇₄ universe. This duality combines general relativity’s singularity point₇₄s of infinite density tunneling through energy barriers in ‘Cosmic Egg hatchings’ creating all baby universes in 'The Infinite Conglomerate of Universes': multiverse with no random quantum fluctuation bubble universes, no parallel universes or parallel worlds and all universes have identical laws. Our Universe is 1-of-infinite self-similar fractal offspring each with alike inherited traits/‘DNA’.
“In the beginnin₇₄’”, the Planck density of the core₇₄ of a SBH is a birth canal. SBH-SWH umbilical wormholes are quantum tunneling seed transitions with energy-matter and data transferred, albeit scrambled/garbled and encoded - shuffled. Reproduction is GOD/Nature’s plan to greatly spread life from cells to universes, thus eternal life.
Why does this Universe exist? It’s our play-ground₆₄ (god+run).
- Seal #1a of the 7seals.blogspot.com . This has triggered The Apocalypse/ Revelation which is NOT the ‘end of the world‘ - it‘s the return of the Christ and Albert Einstein reincarnated (Seal #7). COVID-19 was added to Seal #4: S=19 (18.6) Theory. GOD=GOOD=7_4 or FOD=6_4 (on Planet Nestor) Theory - Design Worlds Theory/’Theory of Everything’ - Seal #2.
@@BradWatsonMiami that's quite the response. Thank you!
Try watching criminals in total isolation. You will not feel so bad about your life
What if instead of the Big Bang there were multiple bangs at roughly the same time? That would explain the current growing size of the Universe and why it's accelerating. Also, what if another Universe existed before the Big Bang, which collapsed thus creating the Big Bang? This could have happened more than once. Additionally, time is a life creation. The Universe does not know time or even care. All things simply exist. Time is irrelevant to physics and the existence of matter since matter cannot be created or destroyed. Matter takes different shapes and forms. That matter that becomes self aware realizes the passage of time. Matter does not.
i like this idea, i wish it wouldve got more attention
This was one of the best theory which explained how solar system exist it shows that whole system which exist today was from the small cell which exploded and all things including planets natural satellites are moving far away
multi-verse.
But where did the original matter and energy come from before any big bangs or singularities?
And where did that come from?
Where did existence come from before that?
How is it possible that something has always been?? No beginning or no end???
What mortal mankind needs to understand is there may be beings and entities more knowing and more powerful existing in an unknown dimension(s)
@@AlexZander688 maybe it has always existed..no beginning..no end.
Since these concepts make my head hurt, I will instead choose to believe in an invisible man in the sky watching me... Ignoring injustices and tragedies for tens of thousands of years but will somehow hold us all accountable for every word, deed and thought.
Yeah, That's the ticket!
I’ve loved for decades now, when I say I don’t believe in the generally accepted idea of “God,” being asked some version of “well then where DO we come from, Mr Know It All?”
Not only is it such that not accepting YOUR explanation doesn’t mean that there aren’t plenty of others
(not to mention I never claimed to have one either myself)
your question illustrates (though it wasn’t your intention) that your “belief” is simply one you’ve been gifted that fills the voids you need to have satisfied.
The only sincere belief one can have is to start from “I know absolutely nothing for sure” and learn from there.
That a person thinks “there’s an almighty Man who made it all so” is an “explanation” is embarrassing.
Great one, man. That made me chuckle
Not a straw man at all….
@@Cortezuma it's isnt.....it's totally spot on!
@@oldleadfoot9026 yes, belief in God is simply scared people talking to a magical invisible sky daddy, and evolution is that thing where fish grew legs and started doing math. Sounds like a totally intellectually honest assessment of belief systems on both accounts with no straw men in sight!
I think Rick from Rick and morty said it best “ don’t think about it “
Probably the wisest comment ever on the subject! :-)
@Mike Seork and if everybody thought like you, we'd be in World War 5 on the brink of extinction. Lighten up, take a joke.
I've been trying to frame this question and haven't had the appropriate vocabulary for it.
I'd ask, "Into what did the Big Bang explode?"
And if the answer was nothing, then, "How did all that nothing get there?"
How, then, did the singularity form?
What was the spark that set it off?
I liked the observation of "the totality of reality."
That will give me a great deal to toss and turn over.
That's something beyond any explanation in the language of Science. But it requires an unworldly realization which may give the feeling of our very existence that cannot be described in the language of Science... But Brian Greene mentioned here there might be an existence of something before Big Bang and I think it's true. Actually if u wanna search about the secret of Universe then you've to be a thinker of free entities rather than hardcore mathematical rigorous equation of equities...
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us. H
Yes, I don’t buy that nothing caused the Big Bang. Cause and effect is a basic rule in science.
😊😊😊
The scariest thing about life is that no matter how much we research, we will simply never know the anwser to these questions. It feels like the question of life itches on my brain and it will simply never be put to rest, sigh.
Ever thought about God created all this?
@A. Mehra IMO there's no other explanation but God created everything.
Just not possible to go non existence to existence with a higher power preexisting.
@A. Mehra well the video is about the big bang and the universe.
There's no other possible explanation other than a creator who created everything.
@@mikeyounes2756 and who created your great creator?
@@purpepurpe4759 you need to first establish that there's a God before you want to know how this God came about.
This is the same desperate question I get everytime from non believes.
Do you first acknowledge that there's a God?
I think we’ve reached a point where we ought not to confuse physics with mechanics! Our biggest challenge is that the education system globally, is so invested in Newtonian explanations of mechanics, and Einstein’s build up on that; that we’ve devoid a whole generation (perhaps more) of theoretical physics that should be the real pursuit
This video didn't say what was before 'the big bang '
@@waterproof4403 there is no before after big bang time started or entropy and it's always increasing nobody yet knows why big bang happened did it happened due to some god or quantum mechanics
@@gamingcreatesworlddd2425 what do you mean there is no before lol?
When there is no time, there is no "BEFORE".
There isn't no time and space in the spirit world heaven. OK I am talking about a different thing. But unfortunately I have been there. I died once I am a near death experience. This world is amazing and so god
@@stevenhensman2541 Do you see angels or not yet?
@@fitzburg63 Yes, I do see angels. They walk the Earth plain. They.
Are very, very beautiful. They usually come to test you and help you. I am a clairvoyant medium. Still going forward with my developer development. All kinds and say what a journey.I have seen many things beautiful.And yes , I have seen anne angels
@@stevenhensman2541 Try to change your weed.
Everytime I fall off my bed or in anybody's eyes the earth moves a bit towards me
Thank you Mr.Greene for an awesome explanation and excellent graphics that accompany this format. Your the best!!
He didn't explain anything 😂
He didn't say what was before ' the big bang'
Love these types of videos. It always makes me feel excited about the future because there is always something awesome to discover after we have discovered something.
@Wiegraf this video didn't explain shit
@@waterproof4403 i agee then again how can he explain a question which hasn't been answered by scientists yet
@@waterproof4403, then try to explain it yourself
@@sahilsahoo6478, someday in future.....who knows what we will discover. Most of the things are just "theories" after all. No one said that they are true facts, not even scientists themselves
@@thatpoorlonelyguywhonobody2143 another one doesn't know what "theory" means. folks this is grade school stuff. think better.
1:17
Where time started?
Question: how can you start time, without having a conscious their to view it? Nothing can exist elsewhere until it is viewed from something outside itself.
I seriously love this type of knowledge
@@alirazacan Still love it!
@@alirazacan not necessary jus like how we been right on something they could be right on this as well. But we will never know until Jesus Christ return to confirm our theory
@@alirazacan It's not a theory or myth. It is hypothesis.
@@nyquilnu2221 it's a conclusion of ideas
@@alirazacan let's seee yours then..lol
Gravity doesn't pull, the "pull" is more like an illusion, because mass warps spacetime around it and thus straight lines become curved.
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us.
Ok Einstein
As a species, I don't think we'll survive long enough to fully understand it all. I feel, we are at the stage of our evolution where we are merely scratching the surface and, with each itch that is scratched, more unexplainable questions arise. We should be lucky we have survived this long to know what we know now...
True
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us. T
There's no such thing as evolution. It's all a theory. Just like big bang
Knowledge is infinite.
“In the beginning was the the Word, and the Word was with God; and the Word was God….. Through Him, all things were made” The Gospel of John, chapter 1
This video at least allows for the most logical & reasonable explaination that if our observable "part" of space was created in part by a "big bang" type event, that we are merrily one small piece of a potentially infinite number of other such events and that where the matter came from was more than likely a collapse from a previous such event and this is how the real infinite universe recycles time and time again. The previously floated idea that the entire universe is only what we can observe is ridiculously naïve, and even then what we can observe is unreliable as well due to all that we still don't understand and may never will until we can get out there., if even then.
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us. I
I just thought of a metaphor of the early universe being a seed that was waiting for water. It could sit around for along time before sprouting. So from the plants perspective time started the moment the shell broke.
I like it. UniSprout
Where did the seed come from
@@JonathanMartinezjjmarti9 A superbeings science kit, they were really popular back then. Superbeing's would get them as gifts but soon grew tired of them. Most were packed away or recycled, some like ours, continue to exist in the far flung corners of dusty attics and cellars.
@@ajarnangus8837 😂
@@JonathanMartinezjjmarti9 killjoy /s
What was it that exploded when things went Bang ? What existed before it went Bang because 'something' must have been there ? Were there stars and planets before the bang ? If the Universe is constantly expanding what is it expanding into - what exists beyond the Universe into which it is expanding ? Is whatever is beyond our Universe being crushed by our expanding Universe. What shape is the Universe - is it Spherical expanding equally in all directions ? Is the Universe expanding into whatever it is - the same 'entity/thing' in all directions around our Universe ? I hope that makes sense !
We probably can't even understand or comprehend the shape or what even if the universe is because with our three-dimensional brains we couldn't even possibly fathom truly what exists in other dimensions if there even are any. Are we even asking the right questions? Maybe the questions were asking are completely irrelevant in there is a different answer and a completely different question that needs to be asked
"i hope that makes sense"
Ehm, what exactly? You literally just asked like 30 questions, soo
It’s a bit unsettling to not understand what was before the Big Bang.
Wanting to know is a human desire, but there's no need to know.
This is true, also to note, knowing has no needs or emotions. Never gains or loses. Isn't for or against anything, has no ideas or desires. Everything that is universal has foundation in that knowing which has none.
It is not the need to know but rather what is important to know.
@@dalisabe62 That which is important to know comes from the need to know. First, you feel thirsty and then you drink water; not the other way around.
I loved the info in this video, very clear and simplified to the correct level for a non-physicist who is familiar with many of the concepts presented. The visuals were a bit unimaginative for my taste, and only served as a distraction.
The kids like them bc they don’t have to listen they can just watch and pretend to listen
I've always imagined universe being inside of a singularity, infinitely large but non-existent. It was there but it was not there because it could not expand. When time kicked in, space started expanding together with time. Like a reversed black hole :D
I like this analogy. It's a good way of conceptualizing spacetime. Thanks for posting it.
Where did the singularity come from? Time was always there.
Azazel aka Lucifer was Imprisoned underground alone in the desert by Jesus for corrupting the Earth before the flood of Noah's time. He is at Area 51....The angels who followed him are underground in a different place together. AZAZEL is where all our Technology and systems come from. The Vatican Jesuit Freemasons dug him up long ago.
ruclips.net/video/TGXhNlsF6iQ/видео.html
There is a United Nations base on Mt Hermon where the Fallen angels descended that followed Lucifer aka Azazel when they came and corrupted the Earth
ruclips.net/video/JUO4ixB2DU8/видео.html
the Book of Enoch chapter 10 verses 4-7:
And again the Lord said to Raphael: 'Bind Azazel hand and foot, and cast him into the darkness: and make an opening in the desert, which is in Dudael, and cast him therein. And place upon him rough and jagged rocks, and cover him with darkness, and let him abide there for ever, and cover his face that he may not see light. And on the day of the great judgement, he shall be cast into the fire.
That Dudael is now Nevada at Area 51.
The Earth is also Flat with a clear dome called the firmament above the dome is water above the water is the heavens. The Sun moon and so called planets and stars are just lights moving around above us..
God was always there no beginning, and no ending . 🙏
If there was anything that everyone could agree on in the Bible, it would have to be that "a Creator" set off the Big Bang. The only time there is "nothing" is when something hasn't BEEN CREATED yet.
I love science and physics, but this is something humans may never understand completely correctly...
We may one day mathematically. We may one day in terms of physics. But we are totally ill equipped to comprehend the beginning of time.
We understand universe as much as our brain allows us.
@@Haylash8We need to ponder whether science has answered these two basic questions:
1. The universe has nearly infinite atoms. Where/how did the first atom come into being from nowhere?
2. And from those random non-living atoms, how did the first life originate? Surprisingly most/all of the science principles like gravity, etc apply across the universe, except occurrence of life. Very strange.
A physicist can ask "what was there before the Big Bang," but only a METAphysicist can answer that question: Before the "Big Bang" there was perfect harmony of all Being. Yes, that includes YOU. Because, the "Big Bang" was nothing more than the answer to a problem that erupted when some beings attempted to empower the idea of DISCORD. Yes, that includes YOU. The "Big Bang" was when "God" "spoke" a single "Word" that created the physical Universe. (I note that the word uni-verse literally means ONE WORD.) And this Universe is nothing more or less than a pre-determined MATRIX that will return you to rational thought. GUARANTEED. Want to know more? Give me a "click." God's prophet has spoken.
Peace and quiet, and being able to get a seat at the “restaurant at the end of the universe “ 😉
I'm not a very religious man. But God seems to be the answer to a lot of those unknown variables mentioned in this video.
Not really. It's just using an ultimate wildcard placeholder concept for everything you don't understand. Saying "God did it" is not actually answering anything. It's just surrendering the search for actual truth by saying some magical genie did everything that's too complex for our personal education limits. Please care about truth over lazy convenience.
What if the universe was just always here and always will be…?
Eternal universe? Yea that theory was ditched decades ago 🤣
But that doesn't make sense what created that.
As a matter of fact what created anything? How can there be a source out of nothing?
@@dosomestuff1949 ditched serves ago. . . I doubt that.
@@Dezmond_Roman - nothingness is only a concept cooked up in the human mind. Like Superman. Nothingness is a fiction that doesn't exist, never has existed, cannot exist. What are we left with?--something is all that could ever be. There's no alternative.
@@gives_bad_advice so what's your viewpoint? Have there always been something there to create the universe as we know it?
If the universe is finite then so is expansion. The universe can only expand to the point where measurement, observation, or interaction is still possible after which nothing has any definite position in spacetime and therefore can no longer be expanding. It becomes immeasurable which is basically the conditions right before the big bang. It doesn't have to experience a big crunch to reach the same conditions as pre big bang. At which point I suspect that random quantum fluctuations cause another big bang. An eternal cycle happening over and over with every possible outcome occurring and eventually even this universe reoccurring exactly as we see it. Which is in some sense is also a multiverse. If you think about it before any one universe won out every universe was possible. There was truly a state pre big bang where anything and everything was possible. Amazing!
Sounds like Roger Penrose’s current thinking?
@@fusionfan6883 You'd have to find evidence of a 'crunch' episode...there are none. There was never a Big Bang, just a continual flow of the exhaust of a black hole...and it is endless, no cycle, no end as long as matter is present.
Velocity is a human concept....as well as 188kmps being the absolute speed limit...Hubble has already proven that wrong.....
@@imtheonevanhalen1557 Sorry but I don't understand your reply? I was merely commenting that what the original poster said sounded like the Penrose theory. I did not state that it was correct or that I subscribed to it. But, in any event, your statements are wrong. We simply don't know what precipitated the Big Bang, and whilst what you say is basically the white hole theory, that is most definitely NOT proven. Equally Hubble has not proven definitively that the speed of light varies, but that too is something that physicists are contemplating may be a possibility. Clearly you are are not a physicist, but I guess you are interested in popular science. Being interested in the subject however, does not qualify us to make declaratory statement about the state of knowledge on the Big Band or other major cosmological theories. Humility is a good thing......
@@fusionfan6883 yeah his comment doesn't make a whole lot of sense lol
@@imtheonevanhalen1557 "188kmp being the absolute speed limit"
Not sure what you smoked, but i need that shit lmfao
Well done Greene and Tyson! Always need an alternative hypothesis in science. Question everything, including a favourite hypothesis.
Today we're in the physics dark ages (Flat Earth physics).
@@wulphstein What do you mean? What is your main concern?
And we have people on this tiny insignificant rock floating in space killing others and thinking their lives are so important. This puts it into perspective for me how tiny and insignificant each of our lives really are.
Pale blue dot
Voyager 1 picture of the earth 🌎 too
Good contemplation!
Sure, when looking from such a perspective, the whole universe is kind of useless.
Going to work is useless i mean you work for someone, do things you dont enjoy all your life just to die anyways.
I get what you mean, but technically such a perspective of "we are insignificant" is redundant/dumb to begin with
On the grand scale of things, there probably isn't much that we can ever begin to understand. I highly doubt the universe we live in is the only one and I imagine in the grand scope of everything, each big bang is a heartbeat that sees life flourish across worlds. I don't believe in a higher power but I fully believe in life, far beyond carbon based and what we can even dream up.
I tried discussing this exact subject with my pet goldfish last week, turned out she knew more than me on the subject, made me feel such a fool.
quite the opposite. your fish is a fool for even talking to you. you are beneath his understanding of the universe. take heart, i also have a very smart turtle
You know what so funny about goldfish? Their eye(s) is bigger then their brain.🧠
You're like the guy in HHGTG who calls his cat The Lord and unknowingly runs the universe 😜
"In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth." -Genesis 1:1
Lol you really believe some space genie created all of this just for you.
Ahhhh yes talking snakes 🐍 that's a good and believable start to the story lols
@@ghostcon The fact you put so much faith in humanities self made understanding in the absence of a god than believing in a “space genie” is far more alarming. Go ahead, put your faith in your fellow man that lie and cheat about everything and let me know where you’re at in 20 years. But lemme guess, mainstream science wouldn’t lie, cheat, deceive or attempt to steal your own conclusions would they?
@@jordanc9169 I put my faith in science, and as such have gained vaccines to polio, smallpox, covid19, and all sorts of diseases that god put here to kill us, they built infrastructure to combat the weather that god designed to kill us, they have generally created countless improvements in my standard of living, and are continuing to do so day in and day out. People don't even have evidence god exists, let alone does anything for them in daily life.
The more answers we get, the more questions arise. Never ending hows and whys in the universe and beyond universe. That is why there will always be a powerful creator who created everything that we see and can't be seen.
The problem with the big crunch is that there still has to be a beginning @ some point to these big crunches. Otherwise it is a good theory, if we go to a frozen universe, the last energy left must be gravity.
Nah wouldn’t be that, black holes will die out trillions beyond trillions of years. Last things to be here would be dark matter and dark engery. Atleast 90 % of the universe is made of those 2. 10% is what we see in the universe with the stars and galaxies.
I had a vision about this. "At first there was absolutely nothing. Then a voice asked: "I wonder how it would be to be." And then everything burst into existence."
Whether that happened way before or with the Big Bang I have no idea.
Bill Hurtz said this
@@jacquiventurini7877 You have a link? Would be interesting!
Question: Why put scientists names on these recording and have them only in a small part of the video?
For the same reason Chuck Norris was listed in the credits of The Expendables 2 despite having so little screen time and so few lines.
I’m reminded of human gestation as the growth of the universe is shown. Are we just a large being of some sort and the Big Bang was literally our birth.
No reason to assume "before" requires time in the way we define/measure it. There will be a different meaning of time before our time began
Awesome topic. We discussed the “oscillating” universe theory eons ago in college. Big Bang followed by the Big Crunch. Fun stuff.
Yes but what is holding it and what is "infinity" this is the question for the ages.
Origin and infinity.... the spacetime is a fabric so you can't have one without the other. So in essence there is no such thing as "nothing"
We know the coldest possible temperature, namely minus 273 degrees Celcius approximately. It would suffice to know in the other direction that's the most possible hot temperature. And we'd thus understand why the Universe contracts and retracts from all times.
In addition if we look at the figures, we see that in fact life can only arise at very cold temperatures compared to the hottest ones we can reach. On the spectrum from the coldest to the hottest temperature, life is at the very bottom of that scale.
The key to the Universe is temperature.
You might find a soulmate in the online Deepak Chopra quote generator .
@@rabokarabekian409 LMAOOOO
Thus, suffice to say that in addition to that when
@@vincent2053 lmao
Jeez man @Senfout
“Put on your dinosaur suit and recreate the beginning of time. Find the answers to unanswerable questions “
Maybe the use of tracing backwards can aid finding an answer, ie. start by explaining how and why the universe is infinite (to say it's finite one has to tell what is there beyond the finite universe), then work backwards towards the origin of the universe.
Wonderful. So greatful, Mr. @Brian_Greene is an amazing theoretical physicist.
It's pretty obvious that we're all a tiny part of something much bigger that we'll never know the scale of but we might be able to plot our rough place in it one day,maybe when we can find our equivalent on a tiny scale
The BIG Bang-Bit Bang/Supermassive White Hole inflation-expansion of energy & information into the void 13.77 billion years ago was spawned by a supermassive black hole at the heart of a galaxy in our 'parent universe'.
See Seal #1a at 7seals.blogspot.com - only the returned Christ & Einstein reincarnated could produce that. It's triggered The Apocalypse/Revelation which is NOT the 'end of the world'. COVID-19 was added to Seal #4: S=19 (18.6) Theory.
I mean think about it, 100 plus billion galaxies and 100 billion starts within each galaxy. Imagine that only 10% of the stars have planetary systems (which is most likely way smaller than it is actually is) around them with an earth like planet placed within the Goldilocks zone, that number is in the sextillions.
I think we live in an infinite multiverse and that there are aliens out there that can exceed the speed of light in machines. Anything that your mind can comprehend, I think is possible in other universes. Because humans are not the final step in evolution, we're going to keep evolving up to a point. But even with all this evolution, will humans be able to create a universe? I don't think humans will be capable of or have enough evolutionary time to construct a universe...Artificial Intelligence could since machines live for a long time. However something was there before us and will always be there. That means that 'God' is actually the infinite multiverse because our universe created us. There will be universes that have no life in them, and then there will be universes like ours. So 'God' does stuff randomly, God has no emotions. Clearly religions like Christianity and Islam are silly, Hinduism has it right somewhat but I'm not a Hindu. Hinduism has always mentioned an infinite series of Big Bangs and Big Crunches, and I think it already mentioned the multiverse being possible. Sadly, I don't think there is a God who is all-loving, or actually cares about people, hence why there are natural disasters and stuff. The 'fine tuning' argument doesn't hold weight in my opinion, because if there is an infinite multiverse then we're just lucky to be in a habitable zone in a Solar System in our universe. So the infinite multiverse is God, and it will always be all-powerful and ever existing. If the infinite multiverse DOES have a consciousness and really does care for certain members of its creations, like humans, then that would be a good thing. Sorry if I sound crazy, just my thoughts.
@@aspiknf I definitely believe our universe is apart of many other universes before it created and destroyed in a continuous cycle with each cycle of billions of multiple trillions of years; furthermore I do believe the multiverse is a pretty plausible thing considering there is so much we don’t know about even our own universe let alone, galaxy and solar system even our own world.
Although, I do believe without any doubt that there is alien life forms out there; wether that’s intelligent or not it’s extraordinary to think about and even extraordinarily foolish to think there is none out there; I don’t believe based on our laws of physics anyways that they can travel at the speed of light considering mass can move extremely fast with enough power and force but the more mass you have the less close to the speed or light we can achieve.
I don’t know if humans can create a universe, it’s more of a challenge of intellect or more so a race of intellect if you will; I think it would take longer than our star life from beginning to end to create anything the slightest fraction of the universe. Machines would have to have the intellectual capability to do such a feat, and computers are an input output system so they can only know as much as we allow them to learn and compute; also while computers can “outlive humans”, the earth is facing a certain death in approximately 5 billion years when the sun goes red giant.
I think the idea of religion and it having an all powerful, all knowing, all loving being comes from us needing sense of relatability and assuming beyond matter that the universe must relate to us on an emotional level; now we know that even though we are made with similar matter emotion comes through development throughout evolution.
@@JacobMDittman Yes, I agree, nice comment, thank you :-)
This whole video should have been 10 seconds: "I don't know",.... thank you and good night!
To think that many of these folks are so smug if you dare to suggest that intelligent design could be involved in the formation of the universe. When in truth they are dealing in speculation and will never figure out an answer that will be anything other than an educated guess.
@@dio777777 you religious folk love to think the universe and life could not possibly be created without your intelligent designer, even though there is NOTHING intelligent about the design of us frail humans. You need to make up a “designer”. But if something so complex as to be able to create a universe existed, it would have had to be created by something even more vast and intelligent. But no, your invisible god always existed. It’s more likely that whatever caused this incarnation of the universe always existed. And scientist are not saying there is no intelligent designer they are just saying there is no evidence for an intelligent designer but there is lots of evidence for the Big Bang that caused this local incarnation of the universe that we experience.
@@CaptainVideo1960 Lmao, there’s nothing intelligent about design of humans? Intelligent design exists even in the design of an atom to an ant, humans are just another level. Think about the earth itself and how everything is designed for our sustenance. The protective atmosphere guarding us from uv rays, the perfect distance from the sun so we don’t get burned or freeze to death, all the right conditions for resources, fresh water, and livestock. Only the ungrateful are left in utter confusion to a point where they think there is no intelligent design in humans, the earth, and especially the universe as a whole. Those who seek can understand the signs provided for us, everything from the probabilities to the improbabilities, balancing of day and night, good and evil, pain and ease, signs exist all around us, except for those blinded by ego, arrogance, and pride like the Satan himself. Humble yourself so that the guidance may find you.
@Mike Seork 75% of the earth is not habitable by humans, but it still holds sustenance for humans, whether in the form of water or fish. Most of the oxygen we breathe comes from there as well. The ocean regulates the climate, takes in carbon, and supports the greatest number of life. As I said, there is purpose to everything designed and created, from a rat in the street to the tiniest of atom, and especially more so humans. And we don’t need the 99.9999% of the universe, all that we need is here, earth is meant as our beginning and it will be where we end, regardless of how many trillions we spend trying to run away from it. You’re only seeing the small picture, look a little deeper, and don’t let your ego and presuppositions blind you so that u live an ungrateful life of meaninglessness, while sacrificing your hereafter as well.
Even if we can see what was before "big bang" (if it even was one) our brain or consciousness could not process it ! But hey, that's why we are human , we keep asking questions that sometimes are just beyond our reach and understanding...
humans are annoying aren't they
Before the Big Bang? Nothing existed before the Big Bang. Not matter, not energy, not even space-time. The only thing that existed was the everlasting Father.
Umm... God isn't real its just the reaction to the fear of death.
I doubt it.
Bull shit
@@oldtimeycabins Prove me wrong.
I am firmly drawn to the idea that the big bang is the result of a collapsing star, forming a black hole. As the black hole sucks up immense amounts of matter, inside the hole, hidden behind the event horizon, all matter and space itself condense into a hot, dense mess. At some point, it reaches a critical state and expands (the big bang).
Time is relative and ticks differently inside the black hole than it does outside of it. Inside, the big bang was the start of time and 13.8 billion years have passed since. Outside, the black hole already existed for a long time and started vaporizing. The moment this black hole fully vaporizes is the same moment our universe inside reaches its "heat death".
Our edge of the observable universe is the event horizon of a black hole. The mysterious dark matter / dark energy accelerating the expansion of our universe is in reality just the edge of the event horizon pulling spacetime back outwards, like a rug or gum. As more of that limited space is being stretched and pulled to the edge (where it ends up folding and emitting the matter it contains as Hawking radiation or something) the stretch becomes stronger, causing the distance between objects in space to appear to increase as well.
Light can't reach the ever-expanding edge of our universe in the same way it can't escape a black hole after crossing the event horizon. Because space itself is moving against it at higher speed.
Imagine a treadmill. Put it to the highest speed and try to keep up. The side the treadmill is moving towards is the inside of our universe / black hole. The side it's coming from is the edge. The rubber band is space itself. No matter if you start running from the inside (trying to reach the edge of our universe) or jump on it from the outside (entering the event horizon from the outside), its high-speed movement will immediately push or pull you towards the inside and prevent you from ever reaching the far end again.
I think all matter a black hole contains and sucks up during its lifecycle forms the 0,0,0,0 point in the universe it creates. We can't observe new matter entering our universe. So if a black hole is still feeding and sucking up new matter, why doesn't that matter magically enter our universe? I believe that's where the time dilation takes place.
The birth, life, and death of our entire universe on a timescale only takes place in the very last brief moments the black hole exists. Similar to how people describe seeing their entire life flashing before their eyes in the very moment they die. And when the moment comes that it evaporates, the big bang and the 13.8 billion years and all the rest until it dies off happen "at once".
A black hole doesn't destroy information. It simply contains it and until it dies, it briefly leaks it out. A bit like "from ashes to ashes". Einstein's theory of relativity works perfectly on a macroscopic scale. Only two instances cause the theory to fail. The singularity that was the big bang of our universe, and the singularity inside the event horizon of a black hole. Two different things that are oddly similar in so many ways.
Well, that's about my hypothesis, the stuff I made up for myself. Every black hole contains a universe. The black holes cause the big bangs inside those universes. And while billions and trillions of years pass inside the universe contained in such a black hole, not even a second has passed outside.
I just had to get this off my chest.
But where did that star come from? Where did all the matter it sucked up come from? I always arrive at the same point. There is no reason or source for existence, therefore there is no existence. Yet, here we are.
Things look different in Japan ...
Cool idea! But that would result in an endless loop with infinite universes. As within the blackholes universe, there are billions of black holes. Each containing a universe of it's own, again containing billion black holes,..... And so on
Sure, that might be the case, but highly unlikely. But who knows right
@@Birds0ong you are talking nonsense :D
@@crateer Well, the universe itself is said to be infinite. So if there is an infinite universe, that presents the possibility of infinite universes within.
As for the magnitude: Maybe our universe is on a level which has billions of black holes. Inside these black holes are universes with million black holes. Inside those, there are more universes with just tens of thousands of black holes. Maybe we're one universe inside a black hole of a universe with a quadrillion black holes.
Like, there might be some total limit in the amount of mass and energy of this enveloping system. And each new universe and black hole can only contain a lower fraction of that.
Since infinity is such a huge scale, it would be hard to tell where on that scale our universe might be.
But apart from my rambling, I think the fact alone that we live inside a space so huge that we can not (and will possibly never be able to) see the end of it is already mindblowing.
Nothing in our lives is infinite. Except for the universe we live in, as perceived through our eyes.
What is the edge of our universe? And what's beyond it? Let's say there is no edge and it's like the surface of a balloon. Then what's around the balloon? an empty room? an empty house? an empty city? What's the scale of whatever is out there?
I think multiverse is a thing and there are beings that exist in interdimensions that we can't just see or understand now. I think once we evolve our consciousness beyond this material world, we can get a sense of that.
"I think multiverse is a thing, and there are beings that exist in interdimensions that we can't just see or understand now" you confidently state. Question: why on earth would you "think" (which is essentially a BELIEF) such things without the necessary hard, testable, credible evidence to support your claim? It's much more truthful and far less deceptive, at a personal level, to merely admit that we currently do not have the answers, and indeed may never have them.
Hypothesising is one thing, but the true nature of the universe may be quite another. Ergo, only strong, testable evidence should ever be sufficient to encourage 'belief' in ANYTHING...and yes, that includes the 'multiverse' you refer to, and especially your claims of so-called 'interdimensinal beings'. Conversely, where there is no hard evidence, then the intelligent person should always adopt the sensible, rational, neutral position of NEVER accepting anything as 'true' unless there are utterly compelling arguments to do so.
Unfortunately, your muddled view is hardly scientific, and is based on little more than wishful thinking at this precise moment in time. On that basis, I really don't understand why you, or anyone else, would choose to deceive yourself.
@@Turrican60 not everything you see or hear needs an evidence for it to be true. There are some unexplained theories that even science cannot solve. Everything in the quantum realm is based on probabilities, and hence I stated that as we evolve our consciousness, we may find a better understanding of how the universe/s work.
And i wouldn't call mine as wishful thinking. I'm just making predictions based on the evolution of science.
Multiverse concept is true but to think that 1400 years ago a man said there are 7 heavens one above the other each one small as a grain next to an ocean to the next heaven.
What if other life forms are all around us? We don't know they are there because we don't have the tech to pick up the frequencies yet. There are plety of examples of this...like xrays, gamma rays, infrared, etc.
I think a lot of things too, one of them being you are delusional
The assumptions grow greater and stronger and more magnificent with each passing year of ever-changing theoretical science. But I like to show. Great video
I mean, according to the laws of energy conservation, you cant destroy energy, so I would say energy is so exotic, that it can exist outside space / time. In other words, you rewind it all to the big bang its self, and space time is gone. There couldn't be a "before " if time itself didn't exist at that point we think of as "before" . So, I'm theorizing that energy exists even outside space time. Energy was not created in the big bang, but as soon as the 1st point in space and time was born, there must be a window, between space time, and the energy that existed outside space time. Something during the big bang, acted as a conduit, allowing for energy outside the universe, outside spacetime, to dump into it. My guess is, that a single point in space time, must have an energy limit, a finite amount of energy that is able to be present in a single point of space time. That amount of energy, is constant, and the total energy of the universe now, or any time, must be equal to the amount of energy, the was present in space time, when there was just a single point of space time. At some point in the big bang event, the energy that came into space time must have been sealed off from its source. And no matter what, even if we discover how it works, we cant tap into it, because that would add more energy to our universe, and were not allowed to do that. However, if we could adjust our energy levels to a frequency high enough, we may be able to phase out of our space time, and access this energy outside the universe, allowing us to use that energy, and not violate any laws of physics, since we would be phased out of the universe slightly, in other words, if we could make our own space time, independent of the universe, we may be able to access this energy, much like the big bang, use it for technologies etc. I don't think we know enough yet to dive to deep into this question.
Very good points. If it is ok to ask, are you atheist?
This made my faith in 1 Gd even stronger. Gd created existence. He is omnipresent, omnipotent and a singular entity. Amen.
Lol. Magic. Way to stretch your mind.🤦♂️
What I find most interesting is that we live in a world where scientists can hypothesize and explain how the universe can come into being billions upon billions of Sol-Terran years ago without any direct observation or personal experience, but refuse to entertain the existence of a higher power (or even aliens) because they are unable to directly observe or have personal experience. I find that a fascinating part of the human experience.
Well, they look at evidence, such as the rate of expansion in the universe, to come up with these theories. They use what we can see to give us a clues about what we can't. Whether or not an intelligent higher power exists, there is no evidence to trace to its existence, so it's difficult to create theories pointing to it. Its purely a faith based theory - "well stuff is here so a powerful being created it". And on a seperate note, many scientists do believe in a faith based higher power.
@@Dozz66 Missed the point of my comment but a valid response nonetheless; however, I did clearly state *hypothesize* not *theorize*. There is a galaxy's worth of difference between the two statuses. Even Einstein's General Relativity Theory is being questioned to this day, despite having evidence to support it, and Einstein's Theory overwrote many of Newton's Laws concerning gravity. Which means it may be only a matter of time before a new Hypothesis comes forward to overwrite Scientific knowledge as we know it. Hopefully it will not include an intrepid, strapping Captain asking "what does god need with a starship."
That’s what science is for, to try to explain things without resorting to superstitious beliefs. If you want scientists to say god did it, you don’t need scientists, you just need a holy book of your choice
@@AMC2283 Again...missed the point, but valid nonetheless. Is there anyone out there who understands the point before leaping straight to religious dogma? Although I will point out...not all faiths have holy books.
@@thewhitewolf7241 maybe you didn’t make your point very well
I believe in the multiverse experience, imagine a soda bottle being cracked open, every bubble is a unique universe. A continual treadmill
What kinda soda
@@williammasters1620 speed cola soda
The universe is just way too clever to be a random event.
and it's a system so massive to think that we even matter. as if beings were living in some random electrons. Would you even notice, would you even care?
@@tokyworld not necessarily
To me the Big Bang is just of many that occured before, like a repeated process (circle of "life"). Energy expelled along with any debris does not vanish, but is rather absorbed by the closest system (the universe we know so far), which, in turn, evolved from a prevoius big bang. What is your take on that?
I’m 100% with you. A cyclical process that has occurred countless times previously. Eventually all matter converges and sits there in stasis until it’s disturbed. My current thinking is that instead of a single mass it was two, forming very far apart, and after an unfathomably long period of time they meet and either collide or get close enough to each other that their gravitational pulls rip each other apart super violently and release their potential energies all at once. Makes sense in my head anyway🤷♂️…
That is what I thought to, as mentioned in Hinduism.
@@joax5955 Indeed, it's one of those things where currently, from our perspective, it doesn't make sense and there's no limitation to this expansion. But our perspective may also be very limited, from only able to view the universe in the past to simply not understanding how dark matter works.
What's not to say that the sudden expansion comes to a halt and reverts, like an elastic band that's fired forward only to contract back to its launch point? Perhaps dark matter or other forces we can't see or understand in terms of gravity on a much larger scale works that way or that there's a limit to the seemingly limitless boundaries of the universe that pushes things back?
For now though we can only settle on the theory that proves to be the most correct, but it's like settling for a word in a crossword with only a few hints to what the word could be and so far it's our best bet, but there's a ton of other words that could fit into it depending what the rest of it may be.
The universe is too well atomically balanced to think we could just "Blip" into existence, out of nothing, after an infinity of nothing-ness.It's not possible. So if you extrapolate from there, anything is possible, and that "anything" could have been going on for a larger/longer time than you can wrap your head around. Time can't just start...it has to have always been. There could have been intelligence a trillion to the trillionth power years ago, who didn't know the beginning of it all.So I go for some kind of intelligent design..farming, in a way. What are the fruits of the galaxy? Planet crusts and asteroids ? Nebulae ? Us ? Guess that depends.
Law of thermodynamics would disagree.
God, God was there
I was looking for a comment like this. Can you please explain, where & what God was doing before the universe??
They say the cosmonaut who filmed these beautiful images is still out there floating away since the age of 3½ .
I know they have schmancy technological machines, but it amazes me how they can confidently say what happened 1 second after the Big Bang.
It's not a matter of confidence in that particularly aspect, it's a confidence in the scientific method. We can only trust and deliberate on what we currently believe to be true, knowing full well that every hypothesis could be shattered at any time. If you trust science, you trust the leading theories. For most of human history scientists truely believed the earth was flat. We just repeat what we know to be true until we gain a greater understanding and then we repeat that until something else comes along that is provably a better theory and the wheel turns on and on.
And a second before??