This video has been here for 3 years so it came sometime around 2020-2021. There has been geological evidence (by independent groups) from 1984 and until 2017 (even more recent could be there) which reveal a wide paleo channel (8 km wide) containing the current Ghaggar-Hakra river. Cores from five locations across the basin reveal the presence of this basin until 20000 BCE. Yet, Prof. Habib states ‘… Saraswati, a minor tributary of the Ghaggar river…’ If he really is the eminent historian who himself claims that history is based on facts.. then it’s conclusive to say that he is a liar.
I am 61 years old my subject was medieval history in graduation and had opportunity to read Shree Habib sir and view of many historians and still I continue to read history books . What I learned in history is that many historian are biased while writing Indian History secondly history always comes with new facts with modern research . How eminent historian advocate what they have written is correct and final . History is not one man and one book show . In the history of world many nation , history has been rewritten . In our childhood Ashoka changed after Kalinga war and it was due to Buddhism but new research find Ashoka was already adopted Buddhism before Kalinga war this is one example . Before partition Indian has one history and after partition Pakistan has new history . So in my opinion history has been written and rewritten and impartial historian should not make hue and cry if Indian history is rewritten we are already late in rewriting Indian history .USSR historian had written history of Ukraine according to their view point and Ukrainian historian have rewritten Ukrainian history making Ukraine history a new chapter a new nation different from USSR history .
Hinduism, Jainisim, Buddhism & Sikhism are religons of this land. Islam & Christianity are not. What happened to the ancient temples in North, moment you go south of Vindhayas you find numerous temples.
A living legend,Sir! Dr. Irfan Habib, Dr. Jadunath Sircar have always inspired me to delve deeper into the discipline of Historiography. As a scholar of Medieval and Islamic History, I have always learnt so much from your works and literature.
Sir,the Indian history has been totally communalised in 2 camps: Muslim and Non-Muslim/Hindu. It is similar 2 nation theory without a common ground except for timeline of historical events. On the one side is glorification and justification of Arab religion invaders rule and a contrarian view of its damnification and its battles and destruction of hindu/jain/Buddhist temples and replacing them with mosques. And neither of 2 camps is willing to give up its space.
Ridiculously when there is a debate on the Aryan Invasion in India, then kids (in terms and stature of history) like Abhijit Chavda and many others like him who are tunder he Govt's pressure are invited whereas seasoned and great historians like Irfan Habib and Romila Thapar are not invited for such debates.
@@IndiaHereNow See when one uses community image to justify or deride an act it will come to this. Can you give some examples where Irfan Habib has given support for actions which is not supportable , i would like to know what you have in mind. Besides he does not bark, he is barked at by ugly elements in India and I know that ,either you have a particular individual voice based hearing capability or you do not understand what is barking
This man is not abiding by his own two rules. He rubbishes basis of current revisions of history as based on falsehood. He wants to stick to AIT without shred of evidence. He calls Saraswati a small stream of Ghaghar Hakra when all evidence shows it to be a mighty river.
Pehle apni history to dhang se samajh le, #Bharat ki #history tere baski baat nahi h. Better you realise your own history first and then dare to study the basics of #Bharat history. #converted
Mukesh Yadav please take away this negativity. So what if some people converted to Islam? Pretty much all of Europe converted to Christianity - no one keeps calling them converts. It’s part of history - it’s what it is. We are all indian together. Let’s please please focus on a good future for all - whatever one’s religion.
@@ashutoshaman3893 Hahaha When was #jainism and #buddhism formed ? Buddhism aur Jainism kab bana tha ? 🥴 Isiliye kehta hu...aise godam(irfan habib) se tumhare jaise hi students bante h jinko ye tak nahi pata ki Jainism aur Buddhism ka janm kab aur kaise hua tha.
Greatest Asian Historian, as good as Legendary Eric Hobsbawm
This video has been here for 3 years so it came sometime around 2020-2021. There has been geological evidence (by independent groups) from 1984 and until 2017 (even more recent could be there) which reveal a wide paleo channel (8 km wide) containing the current Ghaggar-Hakra river. Cores from five locations across the basin reveal the presence of this basin until 20000 BCE.
Yet, Prof. Habib states ‘… Saraswati, a minor tributary of the Ghaggar river…’ If he really is the eminent historian who himself claims that history is based on facts.. then it’s conclusive to say that he is a liar.
💀
Islamic Religious sanskar with communist tadaka !
😅
He will never discuss about Rakhigarhi and Sinauli.
Usse tum kaale Aryan nahi ho jaate
Please cite sources for what you are referring to here
Thank you for making this platform. Listening Mr Habib is a blessing for us.
Thank you
Disgusting to listen to him! 😮
Came here just to read hateful comments for this hateful habib
I am 61 years old my subject was medieval history in graduation and had opportunity to read Shree Habib sir and view of many historians and still I continue to read history books . What I learned in history is that many historian are biased while writing Indian History secondly history always comes with new facts with modern research . How eminent historian advocate what they have written is correct and final . History is not one man and one book show . In the history of world many nation , history has been rewritten . In our childhood Ashoka changed after Kalinga war and it was due to Buddhism but new research find Ashoka was already adopted Buddhism before Kalinga war this is one example . Before partition Indian has one history and after partition Pakistan has new history . So in my opinion history has been written and rewritten and impartial historian should not make hue and cry if Indian history is rewritten we are already late in rewriting Indian history .USSR historian had written history of Ukraine according to their view point and Ukrainian historian have rewritten Ukrainian history making Ukraine history a new chapter a new nation different from USSR history .
Hinduism, Jainisim, Buddhism & Sikhism are religons of this land.
Islam & Christianity are not.
What happened to the ancient temples in North, moment you go south of Vindhayas you find numerous temples.
A living legend,Sir! Dr. Irfan Habib, Dr. Jadunath Sircar have always inspired me to delve deeper into the discipline of Historiography. As a scholar of Medieval and Islamic History, I have always learnt so much from your works and literature.
Jadunath sarkar is fair, this habib is a jihadi writer. Pl change your view of habib
😂😂😂
😂😂... Inspirational liar
still relevant ❤️
Sir,the Indian history has been totally communalised in 2 camps:
Muslim and Non-Muslim/Hindu.
It is similar 2 nation theory without a common ground except for timeline of historical events.
On the one side is glorification and justification of Arab religion invaders rule and a contrarian view of its damnification and its battles and destruction of hindu/jain/Buddhist temples and replacing them with mosques.
And neither of 2 camps is willing to give up its space.
Must watch on 2x
thanks😂
Rikk to atharba. If you are prof.
The amount of ideology buga buga this person spews
Can anyone recommend me any book available on how banking system working during the reign of Tipu Sultan?
Ajkal mai sunta nahi bollna chahta hoon. Gaon me library hahi apna paisa leke ,so am a poor.
Ridiculously when there is a debate on the Aryan Invasion in India, then kids (in terms and stature of history) like Abhijit Chavda and many others like him who are tunder he Govt's pressure are invited whereas seasoned and great historians like Irfan Habib and Romila Thapar are not invited for such debates.
There was no Aryan invasion.it was introduced propoganda by British.
Sir he is fake and jihadi historian!? 😮
A well known genocide denier. What a shame.
Marxist ke chole me Islamist
Which genocide? Gujrat or Jammu?
@@ABO-Destiny no.. he barks a lot on them. He only feels pain for a certain peaceful community, overlooks their crimes ( which for it is existential).
@@IndiaHereNow
Which genocide? Gujrat? Jammu?
@@IndiaHereNow
See when one uses community image to justify or deride an act it will come to this.
Can you give some examples where Irfan Habib has given support for actions which is not supportable , i would like to know what you have in mind.
Besides he does not bark, he is barked at by ugly elements in India and I know that ,either you have a particular individual voice based hearing capability or you do not understand what is barking
Irfan Habib should be ashamed to distort history into ideology based fable ......
Get out haters ......
Read history not story or WhatsApp
Even jadunath sharkar called rajput horses as slow week tattu compared to arab horses
School ja bkl ab too classes b lag gyi hy.
Lagta ha gao mutr pi ke aaye ho
🌹🌹🌹🌹👌
According to him Amir khusro & Abul fasal first gave the idea of india ..... You liar
inquiry should made against his agenda driven work and the motive to distort India civilization. He must be prosecuted.
Dear Habib you are irrelevant now.
Gou mutr Piya ha kya
This man is not abiding by his own two rules. He rubbishes basis of current revisions of history as based on falsehood. He wants to stick to AIT without shred of evidence. He calls Saraswati a small stream of Ghaghar Hakra when all evidence shows it to be a mighty river.
@Simple Minded exactly. leave it. they don't read them .
Where
@@rajkamald684 What do you want to know?
Very wrong facts.
Name one
Pehle apni history to dhang se samajh le, #Bharat ki #history tere baski baat nahi h.
Better you realise your own history first and then dare to study the basics of #Bharat history. #converted
Mukesh Yadav please take away this negativity. So what if some people converted to Islam? Pretty much all of Europe converted to Christianity - no one keeps calling them converts. It’s part of history - it’s what it is. We are all indian together. Let’s please please focus on a good future for all - whatever one’s religion.
Habib Sir's history is based on facts and sources and not on mythology or astrology.
@@maliniadiga8456
Obviously not based on astrology and astronomy also because his crap book taught him #flatearth theory.
Ho skta h tumare ancestor bhi phle Buddhist ya jain ho jo baad me convert hokr hindu bn gye honge...
Isiliye baat baat pr convert mt bola kro
@@ashutoshaman3893
Hahaha
When was #jainism and #buddhism formed ?
Buddhism aur Jainism kab bana tha ? 🥴
Isiliye kehta hu...aise godam(irfan habib) se tumhare jaise hi students bante h jinko ye tak nahi pata ki Jainism aur Buddhism ka janm kab aur kaise hua tha.