Sad situation I used to live in Italy about 10 years ago I am a Bangladeshi guy I lived there for 4 years worked very hard very physical jobs but I was lucky that I arrived in Italy young about 16 years old so I managed to learn the language fast and speak it very well I still do I saved as much money as I could and left for Brazil I booked a 1 way flight to Bolívia from Italy and then crossed illegally into Brazil as Brazil doesn't allow Bangladeshis in without a visa and Bolívia does anyway I came to Brazil learned the language in 3 months got my refugee documents and started working hard and now I have a comfortable life in Brazil I live by the sea and run my own online business and earn more than I did in Italy and life in Brazil is just so much better than Italy anyway I hope my brothers in Italy will see that Europe isn't the answer sometimes they need to go to other countries but I will always thank Itália for giving me this Italiano language that opened the doors to Brazil for me
@@namesthales I live in Sergipe state in the north eastern part of Brazil, it's the smallest state in Brazil but also one of the safest and best places to live and work in as a foreigner
I'm from Italy and this is not ! talked about enough, it's hardly ever on the news and people like Yvan often don't receive the respect that they deserve. I will be looking for No Cap products next time I'll go grocery shopping. Thank you DW for sharing this.
@@robertruggiero9999no their land was colonized and looted by your grandfather that’s how u became developed by leaving nothing in Asia and Africa and Latin america
This is all true i myself a migrant who live in Italy amd work in different places for around 5 year's, seriously i myself went to Borgo this exact place i was so sad i couldn't believe and my heart goes out to all those people out there its really unexplainable and very poor poor living conditions,then i saw a young woman who was mentally ill i yope the situation gets better and wish everyone a better life THE JOURNEY CONTINUES 💪🏾✌🏾
I dont condone what is going on with migrants in italy, but I am italian myself… i work a regular job (i have two degrees) and make 1300 euros/net month - take 800 euros for rent and thats all I have to live. Italy is not the place. I am leaving in two months. Rent is insane, and so are bills and groceries.
i'm an immigrant in italy too and i came 10 years ago to study masters in telecommunication and now i have more than 5 years working experience in informatica in milan but i can say to you the pay in italy is very poor with high taxes compared to other G7 Nation . I'm starting a new job in january 2025 in Norway as a Cloud Architect with a good pay almost tripple of my salary in Italy . Thank you Italy and Long live Italy
Challenge to us Africans-find solutions to our problems. I feel for these people who wouldn't have to go that far if not for bad leadership, selfishness, lack of vision and chronic lack of accountability.Kudos to Yvan for his advocacy, no little achievement 🙏🏾
@milesinnz Africans have always valued large families - that won't change and spirituality is also very important, and not going to change. The "leaders" are the problem.
@@wakandavibranium5053 the leaders are the smallest part of the problem... so you tell me... given the best leadership in the World.. where can all the hundreds of millions of job come from. the average age in Africa is 18, in the USA it is 38,, in Singapore it is 43.. I am all ears or like any good African will you now run for the exit ? oh and you cannot tell me where the jobs can come from, tell me what happens when there are hundreds of millions of young Africans without work and no hope ? But you won't will you ? That's also the African way.. always running around looking for other people to blame..
We know "Allah will not change the condition of a people until they change what is within themselves." The change of location and making Euros does not change their livelihood.
The greediness for cheap laborers, this is how slavery started and continues. We need a new Albraham Lincoln to prove that you can stop slavery and work hard again.
It was an incredible and truthful introduction documentary about the exploitation of migration labors by Italian agricultural sectors through Italian mafia intermediate bonds between Italian farmers and potential farm workers ...thanks for sharing
@@aintEvanescencenot unless your governments and companies sieze to exploit their resources and orchestrating conflicts in their own countries. You talk like a caveman who just woke up.
The pay in italy generally is bad even for degree holders . I learnt that 50 thousand italian youths are leaving the country every year for greener pasture in some countries where they will pay them well .
@@georgepapa2950 No, these working and living conditions are worse than where they come from for use( I don't know which country they come from... Africa is not a country) in their countries they probably have big open land for agricultural purposes..
@@sanelemwelase Actually its better than any African country, as i said if its better at home they would have left. I was born in Africa and have worked in many African countries. Please dont make judgment as you cannot fully understand the whole system
We have lots of migrant workers in Canada but they are not necessary, The local population wants those jobs. Not to mention the migrants are often taken advantage of. This is happening all over the world, In any Western Nation.
I'm originally from Niagara falls and picked peaches as a teenager. The worst job I ever had. Where did you get the idea that modern teens would work in farm fields?
@@ArgusAlfin Canada we have a huge migrant worker population which is often taken advantage of and mistreated. But the problem is they are not necessary we have enough locals that want those jobs. Them being here is causing a huge strain on our country. The infrastructure cannot handle it, and the standard of living has gone down drastically.
My friend (european) met a girl (chinese) in Australia. They wanted to stay longer in Australia and needed money, so they went to work illegally in a Chinese owned farm. He said working there was like slavery. Sometimes they got no salary, they had to work very hard. Basically expoitation of the illegal workers is happening everywhere in the world
I swear if the African people were doing these sacrifices and working this hard in their own countries I'll give them few years they’ll be developed countries. I bet most of them would never think of doing a farming job in their own country
Fare wages but no citizenship, the same for their children, no citizenship even if they marry an Italian citizen. How sad that they don't fight to improve their own country.
Italian government needs to get more involved to get owners of farms ,rid of shantytowns build better conditions if there are to let migrants legal or illegal to work on the farms
Slaves can't quit their jobs and go home. Slaves don't get paid. These are criminals who depress the working wages for legal citizens and burden the Healthcare and education systems to breaking point
People ALWAYS forget what you give them, soon they will say that Europe is part of Africa, Isn't Europe the continent of the White People? Everyone should live and makes his continent better place for living ...
The European government is controlling all African countries,so how do you expect the people in Africa to have a job,no Job in Africa except scam and stealing 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 Africa currency is very poor 😢😢😢😢😢😢so if the European government can stay way from Africa everything will be fine😢😢😢😢
it´s better to grow in the african countries and keep the people there, and not grow crops which are labour intensive where labour is unavailable in Europe
@@AlK-t4x Italy abd tiger countries can use prison labor. The prisoners could earn some money and when they are released tgey would have some to start their lives again Prison labor is and has been used in many countries abd in many industries
So what? All those people come and work by them self, not because of smuggling or by threaten. If the working conditions do not suit, then they can go back or find anywhere else. Simple as that. If the labor force isn't enough, then those companies will come up with a quota including proper agreements, good working conditions and etc. This is how businesses are behaving. There is no point of talking about human rights on this matter
Thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers to comment on our channel in English so that we can answer questions and encourage dialogue. Thank you and all the best, The DW Documentary Team
yes those immigrants reducing wages and destroying our infrastructure abusing our welfare are evil and we will have to remove them by force since our governments are bought and paid for by corporations and are using slaves to destroy our way of life in western countries.
Sorry,it is the reality.Or,at least it was 8 years ago I shared the fate of these peoples ,working hard and sometimes without to be paid.The difference was that I have been covertly working for the Human Traffic section of Romanian Police and my duty was to infiltrate the romanian human traffic network from Italy ,to send weekly reports to Romania regarding the activity of traffickers and eventually to locate and to get close to romanian criminals hiding in Italy.What I can say is even the italian judges or carabiniers were ilegally using the immigrants labour force ( without work contracts,paying 4 or 5 euros /hour to each worker plus 2 euro/hour to the traffickers) For me Italy,despite being a beautiful country,it is the most corrupted country from Europe,even more corrupted than Ukraine ,and I know what I say because I rescued over 20 ukrainian girls forced in prostitution in Turkey. I am now retired ,and I had to leave Romania imediately after retirement.For a police officer ,the rettirement means the end of gouvernamental protection.
So, your idea is to keep enslaving people and spend a little less? Also, a ton of costs go into distributing the product, and the cost of caporals themselves, who are mafia and don't do things randomly, but because they extract money from that.
What was based about it?The situation exists whether or its reported or not. The narrator expressed no opinion during the entire report. If Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni doesn't like migrant workers, she could try having Italys prison population harvest the fruits and vegetables instead.
This is completely false and misinformed aligation. There is no exploitation of foreign workers in Germany in comparison to so many other parts of the world, especially in the Middle East. I am also an immigrant and find Germany one of the most fair places to work.
It's literally not if you listened to what they said. And you have no clue what you're talking about. Have you been to different parts of Africa and Italy? I doubt you've ever left your crap US town. If you had you wouldn't be so ignorant
Sad situation I used to live in Italy about 10 years ago I am a Bangladeshi guy I lived there for 4 years worked very hard very physical jobs but I was lucky that I arrived in Italy young about 16 years old so I managed to learn the language fast and speak it very well I still do I saved as much money as I could and left for Brazil I booked a 1 way flight to Bolívia from Italy and then crossed illegally into Brazil as Brazil doesn't allow Bangladeshis in without a visa and Bolívia does anyway I came to Brazil learned the language in 3 months got my refugee documents and started working hard and now I have a comfortable life in Brazil I live by the sea and run my own online business and earn more than I did in Italy and life in Brazil is just so much better than Italy anyway I hope my brothers in Italy will see that Europe isn't the answer sometimes they need to go to other countries but I will always thank Itália for giving me this Italiano language that opened the doors to Brazil for me
Where in Brazil are you located? Glad you managed to get your documents here.
Are things real bad in Bangladesh?
congrats bro
@@namesthales I live in Sergipe state in the north eastern part of Brazil, it's the smallest state in Brazil but also one of the safest and best places to live and work in as a foreigner
I'm from Italy and this is not ! talked about enough, it's hardly ever on the news and people like Yvan often don't receive the respect that they deserve. I will be looking for No Cap products next time I'll go grocery shopping. Thank you DW for sharing this.
Were they captured and forced to go (and stay) in Italy ?
@@robertruggiero9999 Poverty and despair forced them. And if you haven't been in that position yourself, simply have some empathy.
@@robertruggiero9999no their land was colonized and looted by your grandfather that’s how u became developed by leaving nothing in Asia and Africa and Latin america
@@ThePukhtoon786 oh like how the Muslims did?
@@alicebrnra no poverty and despair are their own problems and they made a choice. Nobody and nothing force them you dunce.
I would rather eat tree leaves than be exploited in a foreign country
You already do
This is all true i myself a migrant who live in Italy amd work in different places for around 5 year's, seriously i myself went to Borgo this exact place i was so sad i couldn't believe and my heart goes out to all those people out there its really unexplainable and very poor poor living conditions,then i saw a young woman who was mentally ill i yope the situation gets better and wish everyone a better life THE JOURNEY CONTINUES 💪🏾✌🏾
I dont condone what is going on with migrants in italy, but I am italian myself… i work a regular job (i have two degrees) and make 1300 euros/net month - take 800 euros for rent and thats all I have to live. Italy is not the place. I am leaving in two months.
Rent is insane, and so are bills and groceries.
where will you go
Agree
I’m Italian by myself
i'm an immigrant in italy too and i came 10 years ago to study masters in telecommunication and now i have more than 5 years working experience in informatica in milan but i can say to you the pay in italy is very poor with high taxes compared to other G7 Nation . I'm starting a new job in january 2025 in Norway as a Cloud Architect with a good pay almost tripple of my salary in Italy . Thank you Italy and Long live Italy
@@Afro_Updatesin Norway you have to pay a lot of taxes though
@@Afro_Updates 3 times the pay but life there is also more expensive
It will maybe be cheaper regarding traveling but everywhere it is going downhills
Spain. England. USA, etc., etc.
No
Challenge to us Africans-find solutions to our problems. I feel for these people who wouldn't have to go that far if not for bad leadership, selfishness, lack of vision and chronic lack of accountability.Kudos to Yvan for his advocacy, no little achievement 🙏🏾
a population explosion has destroyed Africa.. and religion has a lot to do with this..
@milesinnz Africans have always valued large families - that won't change and spirituality is also very important, and not going to change. The "leaders" are the problem.
@@wakandavibranium5053 the leaders are the smallest part of the problem... so you tell me... given the best leadership in the World.. where can all the hundreds of millions of job come from. the average age in Africa is 18, in the USA it is 38,, in Singapore it is 43.. I am all ears or like any good African will you now run for the exit ? oh and you cannot tell me where the jobs can come from, tell me what happens when there are hundreds of millions of young Africans without work and no hope ? But you won't will you ? That's also the African way.. always running around looking for other people to blame..
I recognized the accent before he mentioned the country he’s from, a brother is sending you hugs bro you are a savior your dreams shall come true ❤
Getting out from poverty in your own country then landed back in poverty in another country
Head back home byeeee don’t ever come back
We know "Allah will not change the condition of a people until they change what is within themselves." The change of location and making Euros does not change their livelihood.
Allah isn't God @@aasiyapowell875
I wanted to say the same thing 😢
It's quite a pity
The greediness for cheap laborers, this is how slavery started and continues. We need a new Albraham Lincoln to prove that you can stop slavery and work hard again.
We all are slaves to somebody, child to parent, student to teacher, employee to employer, board of directors to shareholders……
Thank you for sharing!
It was an incredible and truthful introduction documentary about the exploitation of migration labors by Italian agricultural sectors through Italian mafia intermediate bonds between Italian farmers and potential farm workers ...thanks for sharing
Where is EU human rights!?
Oh wait , they speak about others and ask for sanctions on other nations outside the EU but not within EU.
enters illegally and asks the guests treatment. 🤡
@@aintEvanescenceso just like the Europeans
@@aintEvanescence it's no reason to dehumanize and mistreat people.
@@miriamepage6991 .. they can gladly leave the country 🤝
@@aintEvanescencenot unless your governments and companies sieze to exploit their resources and orchestrating conflicts in their own countries.
You talk like a caveman who just woke up.
It’s not just Italy but whole southern Europe Spain Portugal Italy and greece
Germany was screaming human rights for Qatar World cup but turning blind eye on exploitation in Europe.
The pay in italy generally is bad even for degree holders . I learnt that 50 thousand italian youths are leaving the country every year for greener pasture in some countries where they will pay them well .
I pray they find a way to move out of that place and find a better life.
They already are living much better conditions than in Africa, if it was so bad they would have gone home!!!
@@georgepapa2950where in Africa?
@@georgepapa2950 No, these working and living conditions are worse than where they come from for use( I don't know which country they come from... Africa is not a country) in their countries they probably have big open land for agricultural purposes..
@@sanelemwelase Actually its better than any African country, as i said if its better at home they would have left. I was born in Africa and have worked in many African countries. Please dont make judgment as you cannot fully understand the whole system
We have lots of migrant workers in Canada but they are not necessary,
The local population wants those jobs.
Not to mention the migrants are often taken advantage of.
This is happening all over the world,
In any Western Nation.
You guys elected a 🤡 like Justin Trudeau 2 times , you shouldn't complain.. when elected a clown 🤡 , be ready to enjoy circus 🎪
"The local population wants those jobs."
@@TheDanEdwards my kids can't find entry level positions.....you sound ignorant with your response.
I'm originally from Niagara falls and picked peaches as a teenager. The worst job I ever had. Where did you get the idea that modern teens would work in farm fields?
@@Plug604they can find a job anywhere try again
You said you need better life…for the past 12 years and this is your situation. Is that a better or worse life?
We’ve them also in Canada 🇨🇦
Every western nation does. That's why they want the migrants
You have whom in Canada?
@@ArgusAlfin Canada we have a huge migrant worker population which is often taken advantage of and mistreated.
But the problem is they are not necessary we have enough locals that want those jobs.
Them being here is causing a huge strain on our country.
The infrastructure cannot handle it, and the standard of living has gone down drastically.
A Gambian is here 🙌🏿
One love from another brother ❤
Very informative,tks to DW
Thanks for watching!
This’s really sad
The world has failed some people
enters illegally and asks the guests treatment. 🤡
*Majority of people
enters illegally and wants everything to be given to them.
This is the real face of Italy
My friend (european) met a girl (chinese) in Australia. They wanted to stay longer in Australia and needed money, so they went to work illegally in a Chinese owned farm. He said working there was like slavery. Sometimes they got no salary, they had to work very hard. Basically expoitation of the illegal workers is happening everywhere in the world
well don't work illegally .. what part of this cannot you understand ??
I hope they were not chastised after appearing in this documentary.
This is similar to America's agriculture sector.
Even in the industriale jobs in Italy are the same issues...
I swear if the African people were doing these sacrifices and working this hard in their own countries I'll give them few years they’ll be developed countries.
I bet most of them would never think of doing a farming job in their own country
Respect !
Fare wages but no citizenship, the same for their children, no citizenship even if they marry an Italian citizen. How sad that they don't fight to improve their own country.
Wait!! Italy doesn't grant citizenship to foreigners when they marry an Italian?
Im embarrassed to be ltalian😢😢😢
In Portugal, many from Pakistan and India. 😒
Portugal is now full of Bangladeshi migrants.
How many hours they worked per day ?
First day I been this place I get sickness almost week
Italian government needs to get more involved to get owners of farms ,rid of shantytowns build better conditions if there are to let migrants legal or illegal to work on the farms
@@brc9064 the Italian government just hopelessly corrupt
your country would actually benefit from going libertarian
Lol this is exactly what the italian government wants
ITS NOT FAIR IF ITS NOT YOUR COUNTRY!
Good vocabulary
Not a few doors down, "a few shacks away" 😡
That is modern day slavery. 😡
Slaves can't quit their jobs and go home. Slaves don't get paid. These are criminals who depress the working wages for legal citizens and burden the Healthcare and education systems to breaking point
What's a No cap?
I work with contract in Italy 5 euro per hour and ten hours 50 euro is hard to survive 😢
What can you expect from Italy 😂
People ALWAYS forget what you give them, soon they will say that Europe is part of Africa, Isn't Europe the continent of the White People? Everyone should live and makes his continent better place for living ...
The European government is controlling all African countries,so how do you expect the people in Africa to have a job,no Job in Africa except scam and stealing 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 Africa currency is very poor 😢😢😢😢😢😢so if the European government can stay way from Africa everything will be fine😢😢😢😢
it´s better to grow in the african countries and keep the people there, and not grow crops which are labour intensive where labour is unavailable in Europe
@@AlK-t4x Italy abd tiger countries can use prison labor. The prisoners could earn some money and when they are released tgey would have some to start their lives again
Prison labor is and has been used in many countries abd in many industries
Make a show about slave labour in Germany during WW2 and no compensation paid to these people until today.
Is like u loose everything from Africa and now u living with hope...be patient success is very close..u can't risk to go back to zero
Send them home.
I think people sometimes forget that they are humans too. Would you say that to your family members
They are humans they should get treated well and paid well
@@hopeliveshere1121Go take care any of undocumented immigrant in your house, and see how it will goes.
@@jevonwilliams4579Snakes even treated well, they would bite.
Yes. Send them home
But what are guys doing there 😢living in such condition haibo be srs how can you leave your home land to live in such conditions
Italians do not want these jobs.
So what? All those people come and work by them self, not because of smuggling or by threaten. If the working conditions do not suit, then they can go back or find anywhere else. Simple as that. If the labor force isn't enough, then those companies will come up with a quota including proper agreements, good working conditions and etc. This is how businesses are behaving. There is no point of talking about human rights on this matter
Agree
Had this happened in China it would be all over the news
Who goes to China for work?
My God 😮 really this is in Italy ?
The Europeans love to criticize Qatar when the world cup was hold there. What a hypocrite.
Illegal immigration has always been a business
So sad
Can someone help me i live in Italy but I've heard in Sweden they 34thousand euro to return to your country can someone help me i want to go back
An immigrant asking for more free stuff from the country they invaded. Typical
I'm sorry but don't you have any shame?
Are you for real? 😂😂😂😂
Israel IDF
I heard that but not Sweden it's Switzerland
Has A Son of Africa..
Swahili..
Kwa Mustakabali Mwena
Rastafari king guide and protect..one love
Italy did this to Romanians too.
Better than their country
Where is EU,human rights,,,WOW😢😢😢
They have them in Israel to pick their avocados.
Where is Israel
Its looks like Africa
영상에 나온 모든 분들께 행운을 빕니다 🍀
Thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers to comment on our channel in English so that we can answer questions and encourage dialogue.
Thank you and all the best,
The DW Documentary Team
Can you guys please come to sicilia
Shacks in Europe!
Very wicked people
yes those immigrants reducing wages and destroying our infrastructure abusing our welfare are evil and we will have to remove them by force since our governments are bought and paid for by corporations and are using slaves to destroy our way of life in western countries.
👍
😭😭😭😭😭
This is crazy and I am italian🤢
Sorry,it is the reality.Or,at least it was 8 years ago
I shared the fate of these peoples ,working hard and sometimes without to be paid.The difference was that I have been covertly working for the Human Traffic section of Romanian Police and my duty was to infiltrate the romanian human traffic network from Italy ,to send weekly reports to Romania regarding the activity of traffickers and eventually to locate and to get close to romanian criminals hiding in Italy.What I can say is even the italian judges or carabiniers were ilegally using the immigrants labour force ( without work contracts,paying 4 or 5 euros /hour to each worker plus 2 euro/hour to the traffickers)
For me Italy,despite being a beautiful country,it is the most corrupted country from Europe,even more corrupted than Ukraine ,and I know what I say because I rescued over 20 ukrainian girls forced in prostitution in Turkey.
I am now retired ,and I had to leave Romania imediately after retirement.For a police officer ,the rettirement means the end of gouvernamental protection.
Do they not realize that with minimum wage, either the prices of everything raise or the work will be consolidated into fewer people to save cost?
So, your idea is to keep enslaving people and spend a little less? Also, a ton of costs go into distributing the product, and the cost of caporals themselves, who are mafia and don't do things randomly, but because they extract money from that.
How is he expected to say the truth about the conditions around his work when his Italian boss is standing right there?
Modern day slavery
Only let them in if you can exploit them 😉😉
Brag about this treatment of humans like you talk about your democracy.
GOD forbidden life. This is shameful, just to earn a living.
Yeah, but it's voluntary! I refuse to take these jobs; to force higher wages!
It’s not voluntary, most of them have no choice and can’t refuse the jobs. You can because you’re not poor.
They get here and still moan go back never come back
The funny thing is, they left Africa cause of farming, and the farm was their's 😂 they doing it as double with no pay 😢 too bad ,they should come back
Stay in your country! No victim card here 🤷
Politicians let me in, it's simple they are needed to work in fields since locals don't want to work. And politicians turn blind eyes
Local want to work, but for a living wage.
If they don't like it, they can go home
It's crazy, I never thought some of us lived like this in Europe. Why can't you adventure in the northern part of Italy?
These people don't have documents. They can't go anywhere.
Wow Just love it
By Cristiano ronaldo ❤
Again another biased "documentary"
You're from NJ with that name, it's not like you're an actual Italian who knows anything about this.
they are literally enslaving them. Many died
What was based about it?The situation exists whether or its reported or not. The narrator expressed no opinion during the entire report.
If Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni doesn't like migrant workers, she could try having Italys prison population harvest the fruits and vegetables instead.
@@LorenzoGabriele-gk7kw then why don't they go back to their country where they're not "enslaved"
@@antoniousai1989he's just another racist
This is completely false and misinformed aligation. There is no exploitation of foreign workers in Germany in comparison to so many other parts of the world, especially in the Middle East. I am also an immigrant and find Germany one of the most fair places to work.
This is about Italy and there is exploitation in Germany as well.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
respect to this guy
i have a toilet but i choose to use a bucket
plumbing shouldnt be necessary
And? Always better than they came from
It's literally not if you listened to what they said. And you have no clue what you're talking about. Have you been to different parts of Africa and Italy? I doubt you've ever left your crap US town. If you had you wouldn't be so ignorant
if they do jobs that nobody wanna do and produce cheap goods for us, least we can do is provide clean water n cheap shelters with ok-food
😢
That is slavery
A simple solution … they go home ??
Their life is ten times better in these conditions then in Africa..
Not 1 of them will want to go back to Africa or Asia where they came from
Get sense
L'amour toujours Gigi D'Agostino and the problem is solved.
😂👍
Their gonna exploit some workers, would you rather it be natives or migrants? (I LIVE IN REALITY)
if they don't want to work in Italy, then go elsewhere... how about Nigeria or Sudan ? They have a choice...
enters illegally and wants everything to be given to them. 🤌🔥
Is it that you lack sen§e or you choose ignorance?
Even in the industriale jobs in Italy are the same issues...