ARR effortless blasting of Punjabi songs is enough to prove what a great genius this man is. Still, the audience keeps asking for where the old ARR is. Old ARR is gone; this is the new ARR 💖
Yes sir, Mr Rahman has been updating his music craft every five years. But still some sleeping in 90's still not wake up. Yes A r Rahman is a genius in rooted music ❤
ARR music is just way beyond legendary.. It's epic.. This year AR Rahman is shining with greats projects like Aadujeevitham, Maidaan, Chamkila.. All are great films..
Bhai es film main khalistan movement or punjab ke 1980 ke halat be hain or esko leker sensor board ke trap main fad sakde the es liye theatre ka risk nhi lea
Baradwaj what an erudite observations(like always). Felt like listening to a Graph Theory podcast. The way you connected disjointed aspects to form a homogenous quilt. I hope Imtiaz gets to see this review
If his reviews duration >4mins movie verdict - nothing much(not many layers/avg writing) >6 mins = Good to Great (movie maybe Good or bad or Good with some bad scenes . Anycase movie has some/many good layers/writing . 8+ mins lot of layers/ good writing Good execution etc. There is lot to talk about movie etc. (now this movie is 12+ mins, good that's what it's meant)
Chamkila is poetic brilliance The way it is told is a masterful Salute to Imtiaz Ali his best work till date Diljit is pitch perfect Music cinematography everything and I mean every performance is fabulous This story told after 35 years is immortal and will remain relevant for years to come Master Story teller is back and how 🥲❤
I didn't like the film as much as l'd like to. The narrative structure Imtiaz chose to employ was perfect, however, there were some editing choices which felt very odd for me. And that constant use of animated sequences also took me out of the experience. It was an enjoyable watch but not as immersive as l'd imagined it to be.
Barad, I never saw a review like this before, as a tamilian, I didn't understand much part of the movie, through your review I again saw this movie in my mind, beautiful review, thank you, I wish I would have seen the movie after watching your review, I may next time. SQ.. 0:10
The only thing where Imtiaz Ali fucked-up with this film is not releasing it in theaters. He would have earned way more than what Netflix paid him, especially from overseas. Punjabis would have gone crazy re-listening to those songs in theaters. This a pretty good biopic. I honestly didn't have high hopes, but Imtiaz surprised me with this one. I wasn't impressed by ARR's soundtrack as much as Baradwaj though.
@@hulkhogan8339 Chamkila is huge among Punjabis even today. It could have earned anywhere close to 100cr from Punjab + Overseas only. They could have anyway sold it to Netflix/Prime later. This is my opinion after watching the film as a Punjabi.
Your review itself was so beautiful and took me back to the movie and its small bits. Good job done at your end too & yes the film was a delight and it also is heartwarming and heartbreaking in the same breath. Leaves us wondering who are these gatekeepers of morality. And are they who keep the society free from freethinking? Apart from entertainment the film was a contemplative take on the phenomenon called “morality”.
BR I love ur reviews, I have rewatched many movies just to get a sense of ur POV... Why have u stopped reviewing malayalam movies?? Why only bollywood movies these days?
I don’t like Chamkika’s song but in those days there were no phones no television there was no source of entertainment it was only his songs and it was a public demand . Now there are many types of entertainment.:So I can’t blame Chamilika . He was very passionate about his singing . I think it was Sad whatever happened in the end
just finished watching the movie.. if a culture and faith cannot save a family- then what's the use of following such a faith/ culture..? a family is destroyed- including a 15 days old baby- in the name of what..! didn't know about chamkila until I watched this movie- and what a movie!! kudos..
A beautiful movie indeed. My only complaint is those jarring and shoddy animations that kept popping up randomly and broke the flow of the story and botched the otherwise consistent visual palette. They were 100% not needed, IMO.
Soundtrack is brilliant but with Score i hv complain...bgm is totally punjabi driven ..but the scene where Chamkila console his first wife ..that scene bgm could be tearful with Female hum or Flute but a strange bgm is played..
Because his first wife also live with him, in the end she comes see them, she lives with chamkila family, and he was not go with his friend tikki to Canada because tikki was loyal more to surinder sindha the other famous singer and ustaad of chamkila, but became rival
Imtiaz Ali made this movie so realistic, it really haunts you. The most horrifying scenes was right when the dead bodies transported from the crime scene till their house and Chamkila's father's reaction, I actually felt I am witnessing this in real. Chamila's tunes were very melodious and those songs sounded much better than the original
Bhai, jo hindi film nahi samajh paate lekin English subtitle mein dekhte hein, unke liye. Please understand Telugu film, Hindi, Malayalam, any language is reviewed in English for universal appeal. Cinema has crossed all regional borders now. Let us be happy Bhai
Please don't narrate the movie scenes...you can talk about whether the movie is good or the technical aspects of the movie.Why revealing almost half the movie😢
@@prajwaludapudi1657 then he should include a section called spoilers where he could breakdown the movie otherwise he should change the title from movie review to movie analysis.
The movie lacked depth. I expected more complexity, with the first wife and more about the death and the impact he has had on other current punjabi singers. Im tired of the fluff that indian filmakers still make. Whats wrong with going deep. Ive always thought imtiaz ali is the most overated filmaker.
I felt the same it kinda ended a bit shallow however I felt considering the length of the movie it would have caused audience to have differing opinions about his character. This would have affected people sympathizing over him at the end.
Why you didn't review Savarkar movie by Randeep Hooda? As a movie critic,are you not supposed to be liberal and open to all sorts of movies? Why such hypocrisy?
UNFORTUNATELY..MOVIE WAS A BORE MOVIE....VICTIM CARD WAS PLAYED FREELY TO JUSTIFY........MUSIC WAS GUD THOUGH.....SOMEHOW I THOUGHT BADDYS REVIEW IS BIASED...
ARR effortless blasting of Punjabi songs is enough to prove what a great genius this man is. Still, the audience keeps asking for where the old ARR is. Old ARR is gone; this is the new ARR 💖
Well said 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Yes sir, Mr Rahman has been updating his music craft every five years. But still some sleeping in 90's still not wake up. Yes A r Rahman is a genius in rooted music ❤
You snatched my mind words and rightly said, thanks. SQ.. @@MansoorUmarkathab
Love it
Ch:- that was chamkila's song
The opening song with Mohit Chauhan singing on screen and the Vida karo by Arijit is such a brilliant song
ARR music is just way beyond legendary.. It's epic..
This year AR Rahman is shining with greats projects like Aadujeevitham, Maidaan, Chamkila.. All are great films..
I cried while watching movie chmkila❤. Really made thinks about how double standerd our society is.now watching reviews.
This is the epitome of review.
Imtiaz 🔥 This movie should have been released in Theatres and save us from Bade Miyan Chote Miyan torture
Bhai es film main khalistan movement or punjab ke 1980 ke halat be hain or esko leker sensor board ke trap main fad sakde the es liye theatre ka risk nhi lea
Even if this movie is released in theatres it wouldn't have reached and the movie wouldn't have performed (take 83 movie as an example)
Yes, it would have been blockbuster 🎉
It wouldn't have performed well , people don't like to watch good movies only mass masala like salaar kgf jawan
Sensor board would have tear apart this movie
Baradwaj what an erudite observations(like always). Felt like listening to a Graph Theory podcast. The way you connected disjointed aspects to form a homogenous quilt. I hope Imtiaz gets to see this review
Yes 🙌
Finally Imtiaz Ali is back to his roots😍
You're a rock star of a reviewer for lack of a better word, keeping going bro!!
Wonder why was this movie not released in theatres As usual incisive and good review. Ageee to every point
Songs made it so well too. Imtiaz , take care of your Rahman. Big contributor to your life.
12+ mins ?! code word accepted
What's the code? 😅
If his reviews duration
>4mins movie verdict - nothing much(not many layers/avg writing)
>6 mins = Good to Great (movie maybe Good or bad or Good with some bad scenes . Anycase movie has some/many good layers/writing .
8+ mins lot of layers/ good writing
Good execution etc. There is lot to talk about movie etc.
(now this movie is 12+ mins, good that's what it's meant)
@@karthiXeyan Good analysis
"mainu vida karo" had Guru Dutt type of music from Pyasa like "jaane woh kaise log the..'
Irshad Kamil Sahir Ludhianvi
This is ARR version infinity ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bharat Ratna for A R Rahman.
Chamkila > Maidaan > Bade Miya Chote. Miya.
Galatta Plus, Subscribed because your content is fantastic!
hats off Baddy..alwayzzzz on point..now look at the reviews of Anupama & Jammy & u would realize what i'm saying!
Ar rahman super
Chamkila is poetic brilliance
The way it is told is a masterful
Salute to Imtiaz Ali his best work till date
Diljit is pitch perfect
Music cinematography everything and I mean every performance is fabulous
This story told after 35 years is immortal and will remain relevant for years to come
Master Story teller is back and how 🥲❤
when is the last time we got a 12min review
I didn't like the film as much as l'd like to. The narrative structure Imtiaz chose to employ was perfect, however, there were some editing choices which felt very odd for me. And that constant use of animated sequences also took me out of the experience. It was an enjoyable watch but not as immersive as l'd imagined it to be.
Happy for Imtiaz Ali. Diljit is a bundle of talent
ARR ❤🔥
Barad, I never saw a review like this before, as a tamilian, I didn't understand much part of the movie, through your review I again saw this movie in my mind, beautiful review, thank you, I wish I would have seen the movie after watching your review, I may next time. SQ.. 0:10
The only thing where Imtiaz Ali fucked-up with this film is not releasing it in theaters. He would have earned way more than what Netflix paid him, especially from overseas. Punjabis would have gone crazy re-listening to those songs in theaters.
This a pretty good biopic. I honestly didn't have high hopes, but Imtiaz surprised me with this one. I wasn't impressed by ARR's soundtrack as much as Baradwaj though.
I don't think people would go to movie halls to watch this.
@@hulkhogan8339 Chamkila is huge among Punjabis even today. It could have earned anywhere close to 100cr from Punjab + Overseas only. They could have anyway sold it to Netflix/Prime later. This is my opinion after watching the film as a Punjabi.
Superb film. Best actor award for Diljit Dosanjh this year
but bollywood busy with bade miya chotey miya and all that hype.
Chup chapri
chamkila is also bollywood
What a movie ❤.. made me cry how society can be cruel towards an artist
BR's passion for movies is so evident in his reviews. One of the few individuals who didn't let growth and business corrupt his perspective.
Your review itself was so beautiful and took me back to the movie and its small bits. Good job done at your end too & yes the film was a delight and it also is heartwarming and heartbreaking in the same breath. Leaves us wondering who are these gatekeepers of morality. And are they who keep the society free from freethinking? Apart from entertainment the film was a contemplative take on the phenomenon called “morality”.
Ssa boht boht vadhya uprala imtiaz ali saab va kamaal amar singh chamkila amarjot
BR I love ur reviews, I have rewatched many movies just to get a sense of ur POV... Why have u stopped reviewing malayalam movies?? Why only bollywood movies these days?
I don’t like Chamkika’s song but in those days there were no phones no television there was no source of entertainment it was only his songs and it was a public demand . Now there are many types of entertainment.:So I can’t blame Chamilika . He was very passionate about his singing . I think it was Sad whatever happened in the end
just finished watching the movie.. if a culture and faith cannot save a family- then what's the use of following such a faith/ culture..? a family is destroyed- including a 15 days old baby- in the name of what..! didn't know about chamkila until I watched this movie- and what a movie!! kudos..
A beautiful movie indeed. My only complaint is those jarring and shoddy animations that kept popping up randomly and broke the flow of the story and botched the otherwise consistent visual palette. They were 100% not needed, IMO.
Soundtrack is brilliant but with Score i hv complain...bgm is totally punjabi driven ..but the scene where Chamkila console his first wife ..that scene bgm could be tearful with Female hum or Flute but a strange bgm is played..
Because his first wife also live with him, in the end she comes see them, she lives with chamkila family, and he was not go with his friend tikki to Canada because tikki was loyal more to surinder sindha the other famous singer and ustaad of chamkila, but became rival
wow ! the best review so far .. coverage of the topic and parellelisms are so cool ... subscribed !
Galatta Plus, Subscribed because your videos are so much fun!
Sir great review......u know how to review a movie in the most unbiased manner.
Phenomenal movie each photography is so pleasant and connected
its a delightful re-view and a masterclass in film criticism
Loved Parineeti ❤ So happy for her
Imtiaz Ali made this movie so realistic, it really haunts you. The most horrifying scenes was right when the dead bodies transported from the crime scene till their house and Chamkila's father's reaction, I actually felt I am witnessing this in real. Chamila's tunes were very melodious and those songs sounded much better than the original
Insightful! And What a Film!!
Imtiaz Ali 🔥🔥🔥
Best review of the movie.
This is look like imtiaz ali film this is just wow
You are the best reviewer !
BR’s reviews are always the best
12 mins review ah wow BR
12 minutes review.
Code accepted Baddy ❤
Code word on overdrive. Both Imitiaz and Baddy are on form
Should have been a theatrical release
ARR❤
Excellent work watch with heart and. Mind
Simply Brilliant ❤
this review somehow made me love the film more
Super movie we watch today in uk
Imtiaz ali delivers one of the best biopic ❤
Ye Hindi movie ka review log English me kyu karte hai??
Till date I don't know the answer for this
Bhai, jo hindi film nahi samajh paate lekin English subtitle mein dekhte hein, unke liye. Please understand Telugu film, Hindi, Malayalam, any language is reviewed in English for universal appeal. Cinema has crossed all regional borders now. Let us be happy Bhai
For the same reason people watch Hollywood or Tollywood movies dubbed in Hindi.
Waise log Hindi ko Roman (English) script mein kyon type karte hain?!
Diljit best
Probably the longest review by BR for a well deserving movie
Such a beautiful review.
Simply brilliant.
I can't watch BR ! I am disturbed by the crease of the ironwallah's assymterical folding of BR's shirt 😂..
CHAMKILA ♥️ ♥️ ji di BALLE hi BALLE per devils di ego jutti thalle hi thalle 👇
Brilliant review
Please don't narrate the movie scenes...you can talk about whether the movie is good or the technical aspects of the movie.Why revealing almost half the movie😢
Kinda biopic... So no damage caused
@@auei he does this in every movies...so it does cause damage
@vredits9142 name a movie that caused damage bcoz br reviewed a scene.if u don't like don't watch, it is like a breakdown of movie more than a review
@@prajwaludapudi1657 then he should include a section called spoilers where he could breakdown the movie otherwise he should change the title from movie review to movie analysis.
Code word accepted gang hit like 👍🏽
How to critic 101
Great review.
Amar Singh Chamkila ❤️ ❤
A long review BR
Not good Film Average no story
Loved the movie
Great movie
The movie lacked depth. I expected more complexity, with the first wife and more about the death and the impact he has had on other current punjabi singers. Im tired of the fluff that indian filmakers still make. Whats wrong with going deep. Ive always thought imtiaz ali is the most overated filmaker.
I felt the same it kinda ended a bit shallow however I felt considering the length of the movie it would have caused audience to have differing opinions about his character. This would have affected people sympathizing over him at the end.
This movie is the perfect antidote for the Bade Miya Chote Miyan torture !!!
Arr legend
Great review ❤
❤
i guess the movie grows on you.
BS
Why you didn't review Savarkar movie by Randeep Hooda? As a movie critic,are you not supposed to be liberal and open to all sorts of movies? Why such hypocrisy?
He even didn't review Madgaon Express, Ae Mere watan k logo
You are the one who comes up with an agenda here. Let cinema remain cinema. Enough of propaganda already.
" गरीब होना पाप नाही है , गरिबी का बहाना बना के गलत चीजे सही साबित करना पाप हैं |"
जो इस फिल्म मे किया है...
UNFORTUNATELY..MOVIE WAS A BORE MOVIE....VICTIM CARD WAS PLAYED FREELY TO JUSTIFY........MUSIC WAS GUD THOUGH.....SOMEHOW I THOUGHT BADDYS REVIEW IS BIASED...
Easy with the Caps Lock, buddy
Fer tum animal dekh lo khana sahib
Justify? But Vanga rocks for justifying asshole characters. Ahh the hypocrisy.
ruclips.net/video/2KD-8fJ5AvI/видео.html ( beg to differ)