A CALCULATED RISK (also spur damage)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 май 2018
  • This is from the "How would you do this" video from last week. I asked the question and here is how I did the job.

Комментарии • 113

  • @markwheeler202
    @markwheeler202 6 лет назад +21

    I love your videos,Blair. You're actually teaching and informing. Not just a bunch of chainsawing.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +7

      Mark Wheeler I appreciate this comment very much. I’m trying hard to build a collection of useful videos for those people with a genuine interest in trees. Aspiring Arborists as well as non tree workers. Understanding trees is my mission statement.

    • @lindaandrews9245
      @lindaandrews9245 6 лет назад

      We had a big lime tree that started with a hollow and over the years it was totally hollow but every year it had masses of leaves.
      Eventually it came down in pieces. Even though only half the hollow trunk was standing, it had one branch that still leafed up every year,
      The last fell in a storm.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +2

      We all go back into the earth eventually

  • @skyrunr
    @skyrunr 6 лет назад +13

    wow! You should add "example of spur damage" to the subject for more views / meta searches. I've watched a ton of tree videos and you're the only one really mentioning this. Not to mention such a good example of inside the tree!

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +5

      skyrunr skyrunr Thanks. You are right about search terms. I don’t do all the social media stuff so my channel is growing slowly-But, my viewers are awesome!

  • @MrSmith-no5pg
    @MrSmith-no5pg 5 лет назад +4

    I watched 1 video and some how 2 hours have gone by. Great videos

  • @ravixof159
    @ravixof159 5 лет назад +1

    Anyone else like to live vicariously through Blair's videos?

  • @marbleman52
    @marbleman52 6 лет назад +9

    Blair, your solution was a lot simpler than a lot of us offered....glad it worked according to plan..!! I am thankful that you have showed and taught us the damage that spurring can do to a tree. I will never allow any tree trimmers to ever use spurs on my trees.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      marbleman52 that spur damage dissection was informative.

    • @giovannidimatteo8158
      @giovannidimatteo8158 5 лет назад +2

      Better than informative, it was proof. It's hard to hang onto a false belief when shown clear evidence. Thanks for taking the time.

  • @andrewgourd8486
    @andrewgourd8486 6 лет назад +2

    Thank you for the wonderful lesson on the impact of spurs on the trees. I really appreciate the time you took to make those cuts to show the interior damage.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      Andrew Gourd my mission is to produce a thousand tree and Tree work videos before I die. Thanks for commenting.

  • @robertmiller2831
    @robertmiller2831 6 лет назад +13

    I am glad the oak didn’t take a hit. An old tree like that deserves the right to die when it is ready.

  • @s.1889
    @s.1889 2 года назад

    Wow, that oak was amazing. Very educational for everyone to see the proof and damage that spikes cause to trees. Thank You for sharing!

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  2 года назад

      So many still have the attitude that trees can tolerate damage. What I am trying hard to impress on people with my channel is how a tree is impacted by what we do to it. From limb removal to topping to shaping to spurs and root damage.

  • @VAM_Physics_and_Engineering
    @VAM_Physics_and_Engineering 6 лет назад +5

    I liked your analysis of the affects of trimming the tree. Keep up the good work!

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      VAM! Physics & Engineering thanks, sometime you need to dig into the tree to see what is happening.

  • @pandvsims
    @pandvsims 5 лет назад +1

    I have made up cable chockers that are 25, 50, 75 and 100 ft. Long. Some have knobs on both ends so they can be used as extensions. I use a bulldog cable clamp so I can attach to my cable wherever I want to. I use large turfor jacks to pull the cable. I use pulleys to vector the load where I want it to go. I always get professional results.

  • @RWBHere
    @RWBHere 5 лет назад +1

    Just about every tree in the streets around this city has been topped, and has branches removed every few years. They all look like candy floss on sticks, and the council thinks that they look beautiful. Need I say any more? Thanks Blair.

  • @michaeldougfir9807
    @michaeldougfir9807 6 лет назад +1

    OK, back on track here. I appreciate the disected slices of tree wood. INFECTED wood. Cut in both directions. It was reminiscent of Dr Shigo's diagrams of tree rot from infection. A good lesson in CODIT.

  • @jamesb6087
    @jamesb6087 5 лет назад +1

    Blair Glenn
    21 year climber, very impressed with your situational awareness and foresight

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  5 лет назад +2

      James B this is a business that can get you killed. The more situations you get through, the more those experiences become part of your memory and awareness for the next job.

  • @pjmtts
    @pjmtts 6 лет назад +6

    Please make a video edit of the only the spur damage. It should be seen by everyone.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      pjmtts making videos that get lots of views means “exciting” . I am hoping that this video will get more views and because more people watch, more people will see the teaching aspect of this. It’s all a game but I rely on folks like you to share my efforts. Thanks for commenting.

  • @sinatralerby7545
    @sinatralerby7545 4 года назад

    that is one ancient oak suprised the remaining limb didn't fall a long time ago

  • @moikechan
    @moikechan 5 лет назад +2

    Excellent content as usual but in this case, I would have proposed the use of a sling or strap on the anchoring redwood instead of a raw chain. I expect there to now be permanent damage to the tree from this stress.

    • @markpetersen912
      @markpetersen912 5 лет назад +1

      Mike D'Addario I was thinking the same thing.

    • @Rickimusic
      @Rickimusic 4 года назад

      Ditto, hard to believe a "pro" wrapped a chain around that tree and then 5 tons of pull power. These BS channels are sad.

  • @kengamble8595
    @kengamble8595 6 лет назад +1

    Worked out this time! ✔
    That's why it's worth taking the time to look it over and make a plan !
    Thanks for sharing and take care. 👍

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      Ken Gamble I thought it would work but wasn’t completely sure. It was however the safest way that I could come up with.

  • @bigpapi3636
    @bigpapi3636 6 лет назад

    Very good technique and it worked out great, congratulations on an efficient and safe removal. Quite ironic in that my neighbor had a cottonwood taken down on a slope by an inexperienced crew last weekend. When they were bucking it sure enough did a top cut and pinched the chainsaw big time. No experience, minimal equipment and no protective gear. Had it been on my property I would have sent them home without even starting any work. I admit I did make a proper cut and got the saw released and handed out ear plugs and safety glasses to both guys. I'm continually impressed that you take safety as a major factor in all your work. Well done!

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      Big Papi safety is important but good sense is really important

  • @countlurpak
    @countlurpak 6 лет назад

    Great tutorial, Blair -once again! Gracias 👍🏼

  • @JimsEquipmentShed
    @JimsEquipmentShed 6 лет назад +1

    It was cool to see the home owner was really interested.
    And a bit surprised about the ants she almost grabbed. :-)

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      JimsEquipmentShed she needed her glasses

    • @JimsEquipmentShed
      @JimsEquipmentShed 6 лет назад

      arboristBlairGlenn I’ll bet her sense of feel kicked in pretty quick with those little buggers! ;-)

  • @rustybird4955
    @rustybird4955 6 лет назад

    Beeeuuuutiful!! Good job once again.

  • @dirtyshirtinfo
    @dirtyshirtinfo 6 лет назад

    Great vid - analysis at the end was really good to.

  • @bretthuet1396
    @bretthuet1396 6 лет назад +1

    Great job with dissection - super informative!

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      Brett Huet and exciting to help keep folks interested.

    • @bretthuet1396
      @bretthuet1396 6 лет назад

      The damage caused by the spurs was very useful. As in, it will be used as a training tool.
      I realize Shigo has many diagrams that we can use, but most folks will choose to watch a video these days.
      I am wondering what the differences would be in different species, thicker bark, etc...

  • @a.wilson4809
    @a.wilson4809 6 лет назад

    Nicely done Blair. Only ever used a turfing winch once on a tree job but it was to remove small trees from areas that a stump grinder couldn't reach.
    I've never known a climber to spur up trees that aren't marked for removal. Interesting seeing the damage that can be done though.

  • @jenniferwhitewolf3784
    @jenniferwhitewolf3784 6 лет назад +1

    Very educational!!

  • @dwaynemadsen964
    @dwaynemadsen964 4 года назад

    Hormigas en el roble, hormigas en el álamo, hormigas en su camisa. ¡Qué buen día! Also, thank you for an entertaining video!

  • @CosmicStargoat
    @CosmicStargoat 6 лет назад

    Every once and a while, things go right. Refreshing.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      Ruthless Goat we had fun!

    • @CosmicStargoat
      @CosmicStargoat 6 лет назад

      That is really the ultimate compliment that you can pay to your career. A career where you can lose your life in an instant. Always stay safe as you can.

  • @oldschoolmoto
    @oldschoolmoto 6 лет назад +1

    glad it worked out well thumbs up

  • @mele9627
    @mele9627 5 лет назад

    wow! what an interesting video!

  • @armstrn
    @armstrn 6 лет назад

    great and informative video :)

  • @craigmooring2091
    @craigmooring2091 6 лет назад +3

    Taking time to show the client what caused the tree to fail even though ants were invading your pants. Whatta guy! [I know you weren't in Beverly Hills but her voice sounded just a little like Jethro's Granny.]

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +3

      Craig Mooring she was a hoot that old gal. Out there with us draggin brush And Fixed us lunch! Love having a client who is really interested. 75 years old and I should have put a hard hat on her.

  • @caseG80
    @caseG80 5 лет назад

    Sorry I believe the fungus question was the video before. Nature is opportunist correct and with the tree being spiked all over it gave the ants an opportunity to move in where the cuts were made. Would you say this tree just had to much to recover from.?

  • @johnmventers398
    @johnmventers398 5 лет назад

    Do all trees suffer the same fate after topping? Like apple trees that are routinely pruned?
    I had the pleasure of working in a garden for a while that had the oldest ape trees in Scotland and they had significant amounts of decay.
    This orchard was in excess of 200 years old and the trees even though tangled, damp and broken still produced real tasty fruit

  • @JohnBare747
    @JohnBare747 6 лет назад +3

    Do spurs damage trees? Well here we have a classic case of facts vs. opinion, you can have an opinion but you can't have alternate facts to suit your opinion. Damage a fact and that is damage no matter how much you argue against it. Just like Jack Webb used to say "Just the FACTS mam!" Nice double Widow-maker removal Blair.

  • @deanon021
    @deanon021 6 лет назад

    Like the message Blair spikes are not the way when pruning. Good video.

  • @kencanoe
    @kencanoe 6 лет назад

    Nice one!

  • @smallengine
    @smallengine 6 лет назад +1

    Cool video!

  • @caseG80
    @caseG80 5 лет назад

    What does that fungus mean towards the end? Thanks

  • @michaelpettit1263
    @michaelpettit1263 6 лет назад +1

    Will the chain you anchored against the redwood damage or kill the far side of the trunk? I've always been taught to use a flat tree strap when using a tree to mount a winch pulley. A 5 ton winch seems like it can crush the wood underneath chain links.

  • @richardwaterreus4848
    @richardwaterreus4848 5 лет назад

    Hi there blair that's sounds like fun

  • @christophergruenwald5054
    @christophergruenwald5054 5 лет назад

    What do your guys use when climbing trees if not spurs?

    • @jiffypop247
      @jiffypop247 3 года назад

      Most of the time throwlines are used to install a rope prior to climbing. Various styles of ascending the rope are then used. You get pretty quick at moving though the canopy without spurs. Check out tree climbing competition videos

  • @imortaldeadead
    @imortaldeadead 6 лет назад

    WoW

  • @steveskouson9620
    @steveskouson9620 6 лет назад +1

    Blair, about 15 minutes in, why do you
    have that safety screen covering your
    helmet? They're not as expensive as
    a head.
    Seriously, I just cut off a dead limb,
    wearing shorts, t-shirt, and a ball cap.
    Socks, but no shoes.
    Oh, the palm tree, from a few days ago,
    was EASY! Thanks for all the advice.
    steve

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +3

      Steve Skouson ok, I screwed up. Nobody is perfect especially me!

  • @kerfnut7898
    @kerfnut7898 6 лет назад

    How do you manage exposed tree roots in your lawn without disrupting the tree?

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      Todd Gallagher that is a question that needs an example to explain.

    • @kerfnut7898
      @kerfnut7898 6 лет назад

      arboristBlairGlenn I have a 30 ft tall birch 4ft away from my lawn. However, some roots from the tree have surfaced about 8ft away from the trunk and run for about 3 ft. I don’t think it’s best to cut them out but wasn’t sure if all I need to do is just cover them with new soil???? Thanks for your help.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      Todd Gallagher cover the roots if you can. Birch are very sensitive trees.

    • @kerfnut7898
      @kerfnut7898 6 лет назад

      arboristBlairGlenn Thanks for your help.

  • @michaeldougfir9807
    @michaeldougfir9807 6 лет назад +1

    Actually I do have something of value to contribute. But first: Did any of you old guys, like me, think of the scene in the old movie, where there was a race to find the Big W? It was trees. Similar to these two leaning trees. The movie in which Jimmie Durante "kicked the bucket".
    Can anyone name the movie?

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      Michael Dougfir that sounds like a really old movie. Sorry

    • @rranger1014
      @rranger1014 6 лет назад

      "It's a Mad Mad Mad Mad World" 1963

    • @michaeldougfir9807
      @michaeldougfir9807 6 лет назад +1

      rranger1014: YES!!!! You win the prize of acknowledgement! That is the correct answer. It was a popular funny movie that was loaded with big stars at the time. I believe it can still be had on eBay, if one is so inclined. Just don't kick that bucket!

  • @ElectricityTaster
    @ElectricityTaster 6 лет назад

    Is there any risk of barber chair at 10:45 ?

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +2

      agun17 always a risk of a barber chair when you don’t know what is going on inside. Always be ready

  • @whatthefunction9140
    @whatthefunction9140 6 лет назад +1

    what is the bush with all the white flowers?

  • @lepetitnabot
    @lepetitnabot 5 лет назад

    Sketchy as frig!

  • @garymccoy2888
    @garymccoy2888 6 лет назад

    At 13 mins. the suspense was killing me...anticlimactic when it finally went.

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад +1

      Gary McCoy sorry, I can’t predict how exciting the job will be but I can play with the edit for added suspense!🤔

  • @redbirdromannose6554
    @redbirdromannose6554 6 лет назад

    Nice work on taking down that oak...

  • @paultreiber5597
    @paultreiber5597 6 лет назад +1

    Anyone interested in seeing a video of some 75 to 100+ year old cottonwood trees?

    • @arboristBlairGlenn
      @arboristBlairGlenn  6 лет назад

      Paul Treiber put up a link

    • @paultreiber5597
      @paultreiber5597 6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/7uVsc-GnZx8/видео.html here is a link to the video I took. There is also a part 2

    • @paultreiber5597
      @paultreiber5597 6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/dl9gVpBXnFk/видео.html here is part 2

  • @63256325N
    @63256325N 6 лет назад

    Oi, all the ants! Is there an ant repellent on the market? Anyway, a job well done, thanks for the video.

  • @dungeonmaster6292
    @dungeonmaster6292 3 года назад

    That last one is a cottonwood? Doesn't look like any cottonwood I've seen. Looks like a birch or something

  • @johnlord8337
    @johnlord8337 6 лет назад

    Definitely sounds and feel like a tree root canal operation ... ew-w-w-w-w--w ....