How UPSC exams should change ft. Dr. Vikas Divyakirti
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- “Interview is so subjective.” If the government were to ask Dr. Vikas Divyakirti to recommend changes to the UPSC exams, this is what he’d say. Write it down. @RanveerAllahbadia
Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
The only 2 possible reasons for the "hard" exam pattern is
1. Increase in the competition, and finding possibilities how to eliminate them rather than select the appropriate ones.
And/ or
2. Sadistic pleasure derived by paper setting section
(Objectively speaking) plus Reservations being too high (not against it, but needs to be rationalised). 60% reservation for mere 1000 jobs leaves only 400 posts for merit. That needs to be changed. Either the vacancies need to increase or reservations need to be rationalised (around 20-25%)
Decision making is important to judge candidate for their application based skill set. Hats off to XAT to have a dedicated section for this subject.
I would like to suggest that the students that couldn't clear the interview should be given jobs in the government. They are not less than an IAS just like sir suggested that interview can ruin life's.
They are getting jobs
Aur jo un jobs ke liye govt exam dete hai lakho aspirants vo kya karenge?
kehne ki baat hai.. hamara dard hum hi jaane
1. They get rejected based on mains marks, not interview.
@@curious_one1156 They also get rejected in interview ! Interview also has some 200 or something marks
1. Its simple business strategy, not only UPSC but all the exams.
India has the highest youth population and there is a another level of obsession with Government Jobs. So, number applicants will be higher as much as you can think, even for 1 post vacancy, there are 1000+ candidates. So, the application fees helps them to earn.
2. Government will not interfere by any means unless there is a harm on their vote bank or public demand. Plus, it boost the economy too. How, coaching institutes, Travel appliances and other things.
3. High number of applicants means, a lot of competition which decides the level of exam. Most of thr questions will be given to make sure that most of the candidates can't do, so no need to stress on evaluation. Questions will be asked based on the competitive level not based on the job profile. Although, the syallabus is based on the job profile, so thats count.
4. Again there is no need to stress on how many applicants will be coming. Because of the people mindset, anyone state that they can do UPSC is Just the bad luck or their life is incomplete if they didn't appear in any of such exams.
According to me, its fine that you do or try such exams but don't let these exams decide your future. Because whats the point of keep trying for years and years and still no response and even if you did after the hard work of a lot of years than whats the point of doing so unless you really a passion of it. I don't find problem if you have passion of anything, because if you do have than it doesn't matter either it even takes your half of your life years but if you are not passionate and doing just to pretend that you're doing something from trend or because of others than i think you should stop and get some rest. Because anything is not for everyone and everyone is not for everything.
Absolutely correct. Making csat cat level is just ruining the future of children and this country as many deserving candidates are not getting selected because of it.
I think optional subjects should be removed.. Becaz in some optional subject people get high marks and in other get low marks. Though they have got same marks in general studies paper.
Syllabus and subjects should be same for all the aspirants
UPSC is just like any other Exam....
People are giving importance more than their life this sets very bad precedence in our society.Govt. must step up certain steps just like eligibility age must be reduced to 25.
So,that people can do other thing in life.
1. I do not agree with CSAT recommendation
2. Agree with interview recommendation
Overall, I think these are very small changes, the entire recruitment process should change drastically, with ministeries conducting their own regulated recruitments, even for IAS.
Even the police requires specialists. UPSC should conduct multiple specialised exams (slightly like SSC does) for each subject.
It should be like GATE. Specialised.
Sir said why is Maths needed. I ask, why is anything needed ? Do you think ANYthing in the syllabus actually helps in the actual job ?
It is just a random selection of subjects, that most people do not disagree with.
Are you sure of what you are saying? Is it really a random selection of subjects?
I support ur views
He never say maths not needed , he say the level of maths is too difficult, and even portion of maths has been increased while csat supposed to include other section as well in equal proportion ...
@@victoryv116 UPSC isn't asking Calculus i.e. integration, differentiation or geometry & algebra in CSE. They are asking basic maths,so how is it difficult??
This exam is bad. They even cut marks for word limits and handwriting. A great handwriting guy will get more marks than an average handwriting guy in this digital age.
After watching 12th fail, one thing that caught my attention was the panel of interviewers.
- The people at the top do not know what is happening at the ground level. They are unaware that many villages have the problem of cheating in exams.
- They have a prejudice against hindi speakers. They also have prejudice against non science students.
- They are recruiting people who say yes sir, yes sir. People who have different POV are considered arrogant.
As an Indian I feel that Manoj never failed. It is our system that failed. Our people at the top have failed.
I simply love this man ❤❤
so calm and such a clarity of mind 😊
Even in ca course 1no ka diffrence decide your next step😢
My friend CA is different hustle. In CA we don't have limit on maximum number of attempts. It is tough to see yourself getting failed by one mark but at same times ICAI test our patients, dedication and ability to handle pressure. It is highly probable that one who is failed by 1 mark will get passed in next attempt.
Marks can't decide leadership skills
but marks can surely decide whether you will get authority to lead or not🤓🤓
@@manaswali5032 modi laughing at the corner
@@Mrrohan-zc4mp except politics**💀💀
@@Mrrohan-zc4mp😂😂😂
Everything is based on a flawed evaluation system
When you have cleared JEE and are a little surprised that 40 marks only causes 400 rank difference😂
Total seats in upsc are 1000 and total seats in jee are 50000. Now check the difference. Clearing jee is not enough, you should have common sense.
@@xohanmalik9515 chill its just a joke
@@xohanmalik9515bhai kabhi advanced ka paper dekhna.... Gotte muh me aa jaenge
Isiliye iit kr k b upsc dena padhta hai...taaki goote wapis apni jagah poonch paaye....haha
@@xohanmalik9515😂😂 lol
I agree with him 100 percent on interview part
I feel 275 marks shlould be reduced to 150 and more weightage should be allotted to descriptive papers of Mains
Kitna v scaling kr de mains me . Select wahi 1000-1200 bacche hi honge...utne hi ias ips bnenge jitne ban rhe h
Panels ruins aspirants careers...very true ..
Couldn’t see any general crying for quota here😂
Are you sadistic ..you enjoy people's pain due to unfairness and mock for it...good going
CSAT is very much important, I expect our officers to be good in all subjects, it may be maths, economics or history...
You have no idea what they are asking. Unless you seriously sit in CSAT, you won't know. They are asking hardcore maths questions, that too mostly from 4-5 topics belonging to number systems. Even the English comprehension passages have become problematic- too short paragraphs and too vague questions. Civil services don't need mathematicians, economists and historians. They need administrators.
@@ssmot113 who are you to determine the requirements of civil services? It is the UPSC that will decide. We need administrators with a good amount of knowledge on every subject.
@@TanmoyDeb what nonsense argument. Then who are you to determine? I'm just giving an opinion, just like you. And it's reality that administrators needn't be mathematicians, even a baby would understand it.
@@ssmot113 I am no one to determine,, UPSC is already doing it by increasing weightage of Maths to 50% in the CSAT. Why should history be given more preference than Mathematics, economics & statistics? Every subject should have equal importance (not physics, chemistry or biology)... This is the point.
@@TanmoyDeb68% focus on maths 32% on passage, includes 32 passage giving u one mark.
these passage are very open ended , there are multiple options.
its upto UPSC which is right and which one is wrong
in pressure moments u generally mess up like im doing from past 2 attempts.
Right bro ,
I agree with him that the interview process is not up to the mark
Please tell and write the upsc about this ..
Do whatever you want to do,you will keep attracting left-over talents.Please read ex-upsc chairman P.C Hota committee 's report.
Can u explain
Indeed very true!
Asli kaam toh Corruption aur netaji ki chatne ka hota hai..
Uspe aap sawal hi nahi poochte. Ek bhi nahi
Copied from beer biceps
Instead of conducting 3interviews.. they can simply normalise the interview marks wrt interview panels. #kaam_khatam
👏 👏 👏
Nice editing 😅😅
I'm preparing for Judiciary, not UPSC
Analytical skills nehi hai 10th class ka to he/she don’t deserve to be IAS
Suggestions are well intended.
Bring the old British style syllabus back
Selection jhaant bhar aur bakchodi raat bhar; agar ye desh ka bhala chachte toh caste based reservation k khilaaf kaam karte
Vikas sir ka 4 ghanto ka reservation wala lecture dekho phir baat karo
wo dekhne me time lagta h bro ek youtube reel se gyyan lena aasan h XD@@Pain53924
aap mere 24 saal ka experience suniye fir baat kariye@@Pain53924
@@raktimbharali3183 ha bolo
Unka khud ka first attempt me selection hua hai tum kahan ke IAS ho woh batao
Bakwass advice 😊
Only if you don't know that he actually talking facts! 😇