Part of "Rio Grande" was based on the 5th US Cavalry Regiment's rescue of kidnapped girls taken to Mexico.The Officer Commanding(OC) was Brigadier General (Retired) R. J. MacKenzie AKA Slidell. He started using his mother's name after Confederate Ambassador (Uncle) John Slidell (1793- 1871) was taken off a limey flagged civilian ship by the USN.
Im Kickapoo, Comanche, Apache but respect to the American warriors the only men to beat us in battle. Marines, Cavalry, Raiders and Seals who can beat America? ✝️🇺🇸
To be fair ,we only beat you because we had an overwhelming force. Kill one and 10 more soldiers show up at the next fight. We were also technologically advanced and you couldn't catch up. You had to adapt by taking our weapons. And, many people do not realize there were many native American tribes and half of them didn't like the other half and were killing each other long before the white man showed up so it was easy for the US to get help from one tribe to defeat another tribe . In a fair fight, US probably would have lost.
Probably the best Cavalry trilogy movies of all time! Unfortunately, the Hollywood version of the cavalry and how they looked was far from the real thing but.....very entertaining. How can you not like any John Wayne western?
None that I know of. I meant the three movies together all with similar themes are the best. Each in it's own way but all starring the Duke!@@Custer0706
Debbie. 86yr. Just Love the Horses @ Cavalry @ Bugle. Born in Wrong Country ! 😊.STARTED With Stagecoach! Wore Yellow Ribbon- And That Thunder Storm- but Did It Rain On the Cavalry ? BBC. Show Again last week😊
Fort Apache, Arizona was built and manned by the 10th US Cavalry Regiment. Colonel Grierson, Officer Commanding (OC). John Wayne's "The Horse Soldiers" was based on one of his operations.
Col.Grierson's Civil War exploit " Grierson's Raid" (600 miles in 16 days through Confederate Lines from LaGrange Tennessee, to Baton Rouge, destroying Railroads, supplies, and avoiding Rebel Forces sent to stop him. Hollywood made another poor retelling with " The Horse Soldiers"...the real story would make a blockbuster, but not Hollywood ( no women, no soapy story, all action.)
I could not remember the book's title.Tearing up railroads seems to be dumb.They had to be rebuilt by the north instead of being re-gauged.They were the closet thing to an all weather transport system. @@astridvallati4762
My favorite part is when they’re training tenderfoots how to ride ,Hank Worden loses his “yankee hat “ and Pedro Armendariz shakes his hand,walks away and comes back and gleefully shakes it again! at first I obviously resented the scene but then I realized how funny it is…
@@Renan.Parente You must have this confused with another movie. Let. Col. Thursday is a vain, weak man the troops do not respect. He leads them to their doom because his ego won’t let him admit he made a mistake.
I May regret Saying anything more than I already did about this Film Earlier. But all I will say is. That Henry Fonda, and John Wayne were Actor's playing Key 🗝️🗝️ Roles opposite Each other in this Film. And the Producer & Director was the Legendary Mr John Ford. Who had been a Military Commander in the US Navy During WW2, prior too His Career in the Film Industry. That is Where I had placed & gained my own thoughts about the Influences it had, towards the US's Military Interests at that Time. As I stated then. The Thoughts were only my Own recognized assumptions, which I had recently Come too acknowledge only in the Past few Decades or Year's. Before then those Trilogies had always been favorite's of Mine Growing up in the Sixties & the Early Seventies of My Youth. Thank You for Sharing, and Allowing Comment.
Actually i like this music. Especially The Girl I Left Behind Me. When my dad was away in WW2 my mother had a stdio photo taken and sent it to him with the message written on it, “Does this look like the girl you left behind?”, I scored it after he died. In real life most of those men prepared to die were when all is said and done, family men.
Served 30 yes in fire/ Rescue and had a studio picture of my wife when she was 14 yrs old on my locker door. She's in her 76 Yr, and still that 14 Yr old pretty girl. Thanks for sharing ❤❤
Yeah, Robert E. Lee. 'Let's make sure black people are kept as slaves'. And John Wayne. Go off to war? Har, har, har. And I bet you consider yourself a patriot. Har, har, har.
At 1:48, Shirley Temple plays the commander's daughter. At 2:52, (years later) she plays an officer's wife. So very many families have a tradition of service.
Music copyright laws screw up a lot of movies , necessitating alternative music & the elimination of the original soundtrack , including spoken dialog . There should be a sunset clause for films more than 30 years old , IMO .
Debbie. SO why DID All the Cavalry Films Have Mostly Retired Military Experts ON Them? Discipline Was Needed For Stuntman- Actors most All Were Horse Riders And Wranglers ? And Location !!. Not All Indoor Hollywood !
I grew up with these movies. Never thought about it before but that fort is in a terrible location. In a valley with high ground overlooking the parade ground.
Ce n'est pas son véritable titre , je connais ce film sous le nom de "Massacre de Fort Apache " car si l'on regarde bien le film la plus part des cavaliers seront massacrés par les indiens dans un embuscade que le colonel y entraine ses troupes sauf queques uns qui auront la vie sauvent .
IT was Such Great Film's as those. That instilled the false Pride of believing in the Military and the Government, completely so that they then could recruit US into the Armed Forces & make us believe? That what we were doing was then Correct or say Acceptable. IN Hollywood at that Time. The Industry was providing a lot of Propaganda too Support the US Govt. at that Time, in it's Various Global intentions of that particular Decade. Thank You for Sharing. 🤔👏👏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👏👏🤔📽️📽️📽️.
@@Bruce-1956 Yeah I am I guess. Because the attitude at that Time was that America had too be the Bastion of Democracy and the Free World. Therefore it's Military was the Best & it was potrait as Such, with it's most Attractive and Glorious Past & Proud Tradition, of Pageantry being Shown along with it's identity of Greatness. Maybe I'm Wrong 🤔, or being too Critical of the Era, & the Power's of Government that were then influencing the Younger Member's of The Society at that Time. These Were and Are My Opinion Only, as I'm Now? Recalling how I took the Film's & TV program's as I watched them back then. Also Now that I'm a Senior Citizen of 65 years Old, who has Lived in both the USA, since 1976, and formally I was a Dual Canadian Resident for almost 18 years before then? With this Unique POV, Knowledge. Here I Really had the Good Fortune too be, able too REALIZE that tho the Two Countries, ideals & Idea's 💡💡of Thier Same Form of Government, were Ugh Basically so Similar in Form. The Fact that they both are Democratic forms of Democracies, But are So entirely just, Different in How they are Used, Run or have Say Functioned under Thier Many Past, Leaders and Political Parties. These comparisons are what has Led Me too My POV's and Conclusions. So there You go @Bruce -1956 is My POV and Explanation for My Comment's of Before. Hopefully I haven't Pissed You Off, or made You Overly Mad 😡😡 by these Views? Cuz believe Me I'm Only making My Own Observations of these Clip's and Video's. Thank You for Sharing and Asking for My POV. May God Bless US All, and Amen. 🤔🤔❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👏👏🤔🤔.
Great movie? Har, har, har. An idiot Colonel gets lots of brave men killed because he is too pigheaded to learn? Yeah, that sure makes for a great movie.
At the time this movie portrays, Cavalry Regimental Standards were not the modern brach color of yellow. They were still deep blue. The dress uniforms were not correct either. Those changed to the Prussian style, including plumed helmets in 1872. But...movies are movies
Back when they made Great Movies!!!
I would advise everyone who liked these movies to watch John Fords SARGENT RUTLEDGE. Just remember time in which it was made.
The women standing there watching their husbands ride off to battle was such a beautiful homage to "How Green Was My Valley."
This movie is very good too. :)
One of my very favorite films, along with She Wore a Yellow Ribbon and Rio Grande!!
Part of "Rio Grande" was based on the 5th US Cavalry Regiment's rescue of kidnapped girls taken to Mexico.The Officer Commanding(OC) was Brigadier General (Retired) R. J. MacKenzie AKA Slidell. He started using his mother's name after Confederate Ambassador (Uncle) John Slidell (1793- 1871) was taken off a limey flagged civilian ship by the USN.
Favorite movie? An idiot Colonel gets lots of brave men killed? Huh?
It was a great movie.@@dougamundson6836
Im Kickapoo, Comanche, Apache but respect to the American warriors the only men to beat us in battle. Marines, Cavalry, Raiders and Seals who can beat America? ✝️🇺🇸
To be fair ,we only beat you because we had an overwhelming force.
Kill one and 10 more soldiers show up at the next fight. We were also technologically advanced and you couldn't catch up. You had to adapt by taking our weapons.
And, many people do not realize there were many native American tribes and half of them didn't like the other half and were killing each other long before the white man showed up so it was easy for the US to get help from one tribe to defeat another tribe .
In a fair fight, US probably would have lost.
Very good, sir. I'm also a descendant of the indigenous people of Brazil.
@@Renan.ParenteRespect 🇺🇸🤝🇧🇷
Whenever possible John Ford used natives rather than Europeans to play their part. Gave them the respect they're due.
Why are you giving props to your colonizers?! Have some self-respect.
Like all of the trilogy.
SHE WORE A YELLOW RIBBON. Is my favorite of all time
Probably the best Cavalry trilogy movies of all time! Unfortunately, the Hollywood version of the cavalry and how they looked was far from the real thing but.....very entertaining. How can you not like any John Wayne western?
What other cavalry trilogies are out there?
None that I know of. I meant the three movies together all with similar themes are the best. Each in it's own way but all starring the Duke!@@Custer0706
There Ronald Reagan and those few others that made western Charles Heason and
Agreed. I was Cav. We had Hueys... so not accurate. 😉
Using this 😮for your ytggyyyuyyyuy😢😢😮😮😢😢and 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😢hubby and y have 😮😮 1:19 1:19
Debbie. 86yr. Just Love the Horses @ Cavalry @ Bugle. Born in Wrong Country ! 😊.STARTED With Stagecoach! Wore Yellow Ribbon- And That Thunder Storm- but Did It Rain On the Cavalry ? BBC. Show Again last week😊
Fort Apache, Arizona was built and manned by the 10th US Cavalry Regiment. Colonel Grierson, Officer Commanding (OC). John Wayne's "The Horse Soldiers" was based on one of his operations.
Very interesting. Thank you very much for the information. :)
Col.Grierson's Civil War exploit " Grierson's Raid" (600 miles in 16 days through Confederate Lines from LaGrange Tennessee, to Baton Rouge, destroying Railroads, supplies, and avoiding Rebel Forces sent to stop him.
Hollywood made another poor retelling with " The Horse Soldiers"...the real story would make a blockbuster, but not Hollywood ( no women, no soapy story, all action.)
I could not remember the book's title.Tearing up railroads seems to be dumb.They had to be rebuilt by the north instead of being re-gauged.They were the closet thing to an all weather transport system. @@astridvallati4762
One of the greatest westerns of all time. Check out the scene where Henry Fonda is questioning the sergeant major about his war record.
Excellent film. The Colonel Henry plays is very brave and strong.
My favorite part is when they’re training tenderfoots how to ride ,Hank Worden loses his “yankee hat “ and Pedro Armendariz shakes his hand,walks away and comes back and gleefully shakes it again! at first I obviously resented the scene but then I realized how funny it is…
@@Renan.Parente You must have this confused with another movie. Let. Col. Thursday is a vain, weak man the troops do not respect. He leads them to their doom because his ego won’t let him admit he made a mistake.
Thank You So Very Much. I thought I was the only one who knew how much of an a$$hole Thursday was. @@lancecampbell4323
The song, "I Left My Girl Behind Me" is why I am here.
Un des meilleurs Westerns! Henry Fonda et John Wayne Sont magnifiques.....
Amen🙏👏👍💖
I May regret Saying anything more than I already did about this Film Earlier. But all I will say is. That Henry Fonda, and John Wayne were Actor's playing Key 🗝️🗝️ Roles opposite Each other in this Film. And the Producer & Director was the Legendary Mr John Ford. Who had been a Military Commander in the US Navy During WW2, prior too His Career in the Film Industry. That is Where I had placed & gained my own thoughts about the Influences it had, towards the US's Military Interests at that Time. As I stated then. The Thoughts were only my Own recognized assumptions, which I had recently Come too acknowledge only in the Past few Decades or Year's. Before then those Trilogies had always been favorite's of Mine Growing up in the Sixties & the Early Seventies of My Youth. Thank You for Sharing, and Allowing Comment.
Ford was already an established director before World War II.
1948 still real horsemen around that what made the scene perfect today u could not afford that many real horsemen they do not exist 😢😢😢
All you need is Staring John Wayne and directed by John Ford.
True, sir. John Wayne is very good. One of the great actors of Classical Hollywood cinema.
God Bless the US Cavalry.
My people prefer Forrest and Mosby's cavalrymen.
@@alswann2702 well bless your heart!
Actually i like this music. Especially The Girl I Left Behind Me. When my dad was away in WW2 my mother had a stdio photo taken and sent it to him with the message written on it, “Does this look like the girl you left behind?”, I scored it after he died. In real life most of those men prepared to die were when all is said and done, family men.
Served 30 yes in fire/ Rescue and had a studio picture of my wife when she was 14 yrs old on my locker door. She's in her 76 Yr, and still that 14 Yr old pretty girl. Thanks for sharing ❤❤
Fantastic film trilogy.
True, sir. I really like.
Fantastic!!!
John Wayne is america USA, he is missed so much what a president he would be the Best, and I love Robert e Lee and traveler 😊 😊 😊 😊
PS i have fort Apache on super 8, big screen and she wore a yellow ribbon on super 8 as well both from derann films England
Yeah, Robert E. Lee. 'Let's make sure black people are kept as slaves'. And John Wayne. Go off to war? Har, har, har. And I bet you consider yourself a patriot. Har, har, har.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Très beau western, avec de grands acteurs.serait il possible de passer Rintintin si possible 🐕🦺 merci beaucoup 🍀👍
Merci pour votre commentaire. Rin-tin-tin est très bon. C'est certain. :)
At 1:48, Shirley Temple plays the commander's daughter. At 2:52, (years later) she plays an officer's wife. So very many families have a tradition of service.
Beautiful !!!
Amazing flute music!
Thanks, Mr. Lawrence. :)
I believe this is a fife which is probably very similar to
Brilliant ❤❤❤
Music copyright laws screw up a lot of movies , necessitating alternative music & the elimination of the original soundtrack , including spoken dialog . There should be a sunset clause for films more than 30 years old , IMO .
love this song thank you
Thank you very much for your kindness. :)
LOVE IT!
A Young John Wayne apearance
Yes, sir. I really like John Wayne. :)
Young? He had been acting for 18 years by then.
Fantastic😊
US Cavalry tribute? More like a tribute to Hollywood horsemanship of the time, which was excellent.
Grande filme!
Wonderful!!!
The best thing about US Cavalry was the horses.
🔥🎶🎶🎶
my ancestors helped to build fort apache
Excellent 👍
Thank you very much, Mr. Michael! ✨😁
The spare music is amazing.Less is more.
La mejor!!!
Alguien tiene información de donde estaba ubicado fuerte Apache y cual fue el final del fuerte Apache?
🙏🙏🙏👏
..my favorite line if the move is "pour me some scripture.."
Suoerbe trilogie ❤❤❤❤
Indeed, Sir. Florence.
I went on a bus tour trip went to Fort Apache. The tour guide said it was never attacked
Debbie. SO why DID All the Cavalry Films Have Mostly Retired Military Experts ON Them? Discipline Was Needed For Stuntman- Actors most All Were Horse Riders And Wranglers ? And Location !!. Not All Indoor Hollywood !
Dommage il n y a.pas de sous-titres j en comprends le sens mais des chanteurs comme Fts Domino est plus facile à traduire
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
fort appache-tue rollf
How come only one guy gets the flap to protect his neck from sunburn?
En voyant, fort Apache, je pense à Rintintin , le berger allemand ?
Now why did you replace the correct score with that inferior piece?…
Such a magnificent film soured by meddling..
👵🇦🇺🇺🇸
I grew up with these movies. Never thought about it before but that fort is in a terrible location. In a valley with high ground overlooking the parade ground.
Gott erhalte unser Kaiser und Konig, Georg Friederich!
.
. 0:59
Who's the Bugler, Egarn?
The bugler is Frank McGrath, portraying Corporal Dotrice. He is better known as Charley Wooster of "Wagon Train" fame.
Sorry i left a girl behind me
what is the instrument ?
Is drum and fife.
Ce n'est pas son véritable titre , je connais ce film sous le nom de "Massacre de Fort Apache " car si l'on regarde bien le film la plus part des cavaliers seront massacrés par les indiens dans un embuscade que le colonel y entraine ses troupes sauf queques uns
qui auront la vie sauvent .
This is not the correct music that accompanies these scenes - what happened to the actual soundtrack?
The movie, the Indians were great full to get the money.
Muito bom 👍...VIVAAAA A LIBERDADE VIVAAAA a sétima cavalaria....🇧🇷🇺🇸
Conquerors Always Undefeated like Christ the King 🇺🇸✝️🇧🇷
A Fantasy.
No, that's the way it was.
It is always the women who suufer
IT was Such Great Film's as those. That instilled the false Pride of believing in the Military and the Government, completely so that they then could recruit US into the Armed Forces & make us believe? That what we were doing was then Correct or say Acceptable. IN Hollywood at that Time. The Industry was providing a lot of Propaganda too Support the US Govt. at that Time, in it's Various Global intentions of that particular Decade. Thank You for Sharing. 🤔👏👏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👏👏🤔📽️📽️📽️.
You are saying that films depicting US Cavalry solders in the 1880s were used to recruit soldiers into the US Army in the 1940/50s !
@@Bruce-1956 Yeah I am I guess. Because the attitude at that Time was that America had too be the Bastion of Democracy and the Free World. Therefore it's Military was the Best & it was potrait as Such, with it's most Attractive and Glorious Past & Proud Tradition, of Pageantry being Shown along with it's identity of Greatness.
Maybe I'm Wrong 🤔, or being too Critical of the Era, & the Power's of Government that were then influencing the Younger Member's of The Society at that Time.
These Were and Are My Opinion Only, as I'm Now? Recalling how I took the Film's & TV program's as I watched them back then. Also Now that I'm a Senior Citizen of 65 years Old, who has Lived in both the USA, since 1976, and formally I was a Dual Canadian Resident for almost 18 years before then? With this Unique POV, Knowledge.
Here I Really had the Good Fortune too be, able too REALIZE that tho the Two Countries, ideals & Idea's 💡💡of Thier Same Form of Government, were Ugh Basically so Similar in Form.
The Fact that they both are Democratic forms of Democracies, But are So entirely just, Different in How they are Used, Run or have Say Functioned under Thier Many Past, Leaders and Political Parties. These comparisons are what has Led Me too My POV's and Conclusions. So there You go @Bruce -1956 is My POV and Explanation for My Comment's of Before. Hopefully I haven't Pissed You Off, or made You Overly Mad 😡😡 by these Views? Cuz believe Me I'm Only making My Own Observations of these Clip's and Video's. Thank You for Sharing and Asking for My POV.
May God Bless US All, and Amen. 🤔🤔❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👏👏🤔🤔.
Pretty pathetic post
@@ronalddownham6470 So what I haven't seen any of Yours being very Fantastic. So stick your @#$@_& stuff where the Sun 🌞🌞 doesn't Shine.
......
Shalom@@robertwaid3579
Great movie. In real life those Indians lost and are disappeared
Great movie? Har, har, har. An idiot Colonel gets lots of brave men killed because he is too pigheaded to learn? Yeah, that sure makes for a great movie.
@@dougamundson6836 You're the only one who thinks so.
@@formwiz7096 So: getting all those men killed was okay? Also, lots of people have been the only one who thought so, for a while.
W gli indiani!!!
Live es
Mr. Ford screw up. Take a close look at the American flag, it has too many stars for the time frame.
At the time this movie portrays, Cavalry Regimental Standards were not the modern brach color of yellow. They were still deep blue. The dress uniforms were not correct either. Those changed to the Prussian style, including plumed helmets in 1872. But...movies are movies
At this stage in their history the Untied States had not really evolved much further than a renegade British people.
Genocidas .
You think if the Indians had the means they wouldn't have tried it? And remember this, we let them live.