Why Punjab farmers won't stop burning stubble, despite the black fields & air pollution
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024
- As Punjab continues to witness stubble burning throughout the state during this harvesting season, why are farmers not ready to stop burning stubble. Though stubble burning adds significantly to air pollution, Farmers aware of the fact say that they have no other option. Watch ThePrint ground report by Disha Verma and Amogh Rohmetra
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![Lil Uzi Vert - We Good [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DrSfBULAsek/mqdefault.jpg)
This problem actually started 15 years back when Punjab Govt made laws to shift the sowing season of paddy by a couple of months forward, so that there's less pressure on groundwater level during peak summer months of May-June. This meant that harvesting months shifted as well. Traditionally farmers have been burning stubble since ages, but that used to happen in the post monsoon months of September hence smoke used to dissipate easily with winds. Now, they do it during Oct end and November, which is the onset of Winters. The winds blow from west to East and smoke accumulates easily in cold temperature. Given Delhi's geography, this smoke traveling from west gets trapped by hills in Uttarakhand in North, and Aravallis in the south. That's why the issue of smogging has become quite apparent in the last 10-15 years.
We know. The issue is why the hell are they planting paddy in a place thats as dry as Punjab?
@@excitableboy7031 because of huge government subsidies and better MSP or market prices for paddy . Although the magnitude of this income from paddy isn't high but a little more money is great for anyone given the fact that inflation is really high .
Also a lot of rice from india is exported which is a water guzzling crop so you are basically exporting water to the world while simultaneously managing to choke the people who are the one of the highest tax payers in the country .
Really? Paddy?
@@ashwatimenon5481 Punjab is the 3rd largest rice producing state after WB and UP.
Kyun bhai .ab diwali ko blame nahi karoge.
Aur annadata sabko gas se maar dega
Punjab is quickly becoming a problem state. How has Haryana curbed stubble burning to a respectable extent but Punjab is getting worse?
It's all due to govt efforts in Haryana.
😂😂😂 haryana curbed it...ok
@@theindianliberal
Can't we make ethanol from these stable ?
@@surojeetchatterjee Yes - the the rest of the country does it. Not these lazy buggers!
@@surojeetchatterjee Rice stubble should be ploughed into the ground (as shown) post harvest as a superior farming practice to help improve soil quality for the following crops. Wasteful government subsidies and rules encourage producers to be irresponsible in their crop growing methods.
People in power should also be held accountable for this madness. Is there a Government by the way?
किसान अन्नदाता से कॅन्सर दाता बन गया है पंजाब का।
kya baat hai par tere modi ki tih gaa nd mar gye punjab
This is a controverisal topic but look at the hypocrisy of the AAP and the farmers. 2 years ago, Delhi pollution was caused by stubble burning in Punjab as per them, this year its a north India problem and not Delhi Vs Punjab. AAP changes the narrative and the scapegoat to toot its own horn. The same "ALLEGED POOR" Farmers who had the funds to stage an 1 year long dharna/ruckus with all the facilities on Delhi borders and had the tolls ransacked from Chandigarh to Delhi are suddenly short of funds to take care of stubble burning. I mean who are these people trying to Fool.
Solution also exists. No MSP for paddy crops and you will see no paddy in the fields and no burning.
@@Delhi_Guy then in that case we should be ready for another dharna 😔
See the suicide rates among poor farmers.. Jiske ghar me hua vahi janta.. Comment krna asaan hai.. Kabhi beth kr kisano ka haal bhi jaan lo.. Delhi Pollution ka major Source Vehicular specially SUV and industrial hai.. Uske bare mei baat nhi krna but vo 2% stubble burning is pinching you... Good Hypocrisy at its peak😂
Solution is very simple. No MSP for paddy crops and give MSP for substitute crops. Let us see if govt is able to bell the cat (I mean farmers).
When aap in delhi they blame punjab gov. Now they are in power in punjab and doing nothing.
They are in govt for only 7 months and this problem will need some time. Let us see next year if they are able to tackle these greedy farmers who are getting free electricity and MSP but giving deaths to the people.
@@Delhi_Guyaqi crossed 300 today
@@nishantnimish7825 Delhi Pollution ka major Source Vehicular specially SUV and industrial hai.. Uske bare mei baat nhi krna but vo 2% stubble burning is pinching you... Good Hypocrisy at its peak😂
@@seeratkaurm han bhai 😂😂 pure saal November December me hi toh SUV chalti naal sardar buddhi 🫡🫡
@@nishantnimish7825 haha.. I wrote Industrial waste also but you selectively picked SUV( check the pollution by SUV ,then btana non sardar budhii🤪) . Baki 330 dino ka hisaab kon dega 😂 Le me correct you oct nov due to stubble burning and that too very meagre and what about the rest of year.. Tab to aram se pollution enjoy krte ho.. Hypocrite insaan, keep crying in oct nov baki tym to fresh air me rhte ho jaise last year January ka data check kr lena tab to stubble burning nhi thi.. Joker like you can only talk illogical without facts🤡
Punjab increasingly seems to think the state exists in a parallel universe where it is okay to be irresponsible towards the environment and the country. The difference in political inclinations has exploded into lack of team work with rest of the country.
Well Punjab is the main reason why India has its own Wheat
@@ChandranPrema123 sorry it's MP
Mat bolo, kisaan bura maan jayenge 😂🤫
@@ChandranPrema123 We are over producing wheat by artificially subsidising it. It's bad for farmers in longer term if they don't diversify. There is only so much fiscal deficit the state can justify before going bankrupt by supporting kamikaze subsidies. Farmers in other states are more diversified with their produce. We have forgotten the finer details of the team work needed to build a prosperous economy that we learnt during Bhoodaan and the Green Revolution. All conversations have reduced to MSP and Land Pricing.
@@ChandranPrema123 Not anymore. Punjab's wheat is also expensive and excessive fertilizer is used on it. It has even failed to clear food safety tests in Europe due to this.
This is why we need to spend R&D in agriculture. Find cheaper and innovative ways to tackle issues in agriculture.
There is option to roll these stubble and other alternatives too. government has given these free too. But selfish people alwaysdo what they want.
No.
This is why we need to stop MSP in Punjab and stop buying a single grain of rice or wheat from Punjab till they stop burning their stubble and behave themselves
@@iaf010 how can you mess up so bad when talking about MSP?
We need to actually diversify MSP(preferably assigning a crop by district after agro surveys) to prevent Indian agriculture and nutrition being so staple dependent.
Btw it could also help us massively improve in the so called hunger index(it is more of a nutrition index) because here people aren't exactly hungry but rather they only eat carbohydrates which isn't very healthy.
@@tge2102 MSP should be scrapped and it is consumers who should get the subsidy - not farmers.
Farmers who can't do agriculture in a competitive way need to stop farming as they are ineffecient and destructive for the industry. Just as any other business - those who cant compete must perish through market forces.
Also, we dont need so many farmers - they are just parasites rent seeking on land they stole.
Govt must aquire their lands and hand it to pvt agriculture companies to produce crops at market competitive rates with high quality.
To deal with market dynamics it is consumers who should get "support prices" not these farmers.
Feed these stubble to biogas plants, to recover manure. Burning it, is utter waste of important minerals
They do it deliberately....being Punjabi myself I know Punjabi attitude.....only harsh measures work ...
Or militancy works too...
@@srinisbir8781 Op Blue Star also Works as does anti sikh riots !
Farming is a a business at the end of the day, so there has to enforcement of environmental laws like any other business.
The govt does not goes and pleads to industry… they are penalised ( very rightly)
💯
Actually NO small industries also don't follow any environmental or safety regulations since following them will increase cost so much that they will be out of business.
That's exactly the problem. It is not really treated as a business. The farm laws were trying to separate the govt. dependency, but the Punjab farmers were against it. The farmers in Punjab rather hold govt hostage for forcing to buy their produce, while at the same time getting free electricity, water etc. Why would farmers in Punjab consider paying anything from their side for stubble burning when they are so used to the freebies! Punjab is a pretty unique state in that sense, where the people don't even really seem to care about the depleting water table. None of environmental concerns bother Punjab. I don't think any govt can stand up to the farmers 'mafia' in Punjab. The only way to address this stubble burning issues in Punjab it is for govt to spend its 'own' money to collect the stubble from all the farmers and then figure out the next steps of using/destroying it.
@@g1y3 Not following law and not having any Law are very different. The small industries if they are in court they would be penalised.
Agriculture is a sensitive voting issue ; No political party dare touch it ; BJP did that but had to backtrack ;
Delhi should vote for delhi not punjab, kejriwal will not do anything as he has larger stake in punjab, bjp also has stake in punjab, while congress is out of Punjab.
Kejriwal is the best in media management, BJP can't beat him ever in Delhi. Plus most people don't know that during UPA , congress did delimitation in Delhi in such a way that BJP became a minor player in 25+ constituencies......
@@theindianliberal oh we will see about BJP not able to beat Kejriwal in Delhi....
@@srinisbir8781 just like Gujarat is so called "Gadh" of BJP, Delhi is "Gadh" of kejriwal and it's almost impossible to beat both in their "gadh".
@@nikhilkheni7872 why does the so-called "gadh" of Kejriwal not give him votes in MP elections?
@@theindianliberal
Delimitation exercise will be carried out in 2026. If at all BJP wins 2024 then BJP may also delimit constituencies to benefit itself
Where is our Keju bhai….
Does all farmers live in Punjab or Haryana only? No other states complaining. It clearly shows where problem lies but difficult to admit.
Punjab Is literally killing itself. Did they burn parali in past like 50, 60 years ago?, or is this a after effect of their green Revolution?
What ever it is looks terrible for environment and soil health.
It increased after the 2009 law that forces them to sow 2 weeks later than the actual time that they uses to. That law was brought because water tables in these areas had gone down due to excessive cultivation of paddy.
So u r not punjabi??
Making fool out here??
@@arunsar7893 it stopped now..
N nobody wants paddy.
They want replacement
@@OhiSandhu Replacement with a MSP guarantee, which isn't going to happen.
Not to that scale. But to a degree yes. It is the easiest way to sort out agricultural waste. However post green revolution the scale of everything is bigger. Also given the time frame of paddy has been moved due to monsoon season, there is an urgency post paddy, which isn't there post wheat. So this is also the most urgent solution.
Farmers can never do anything wrong in this country. Especially farmers from Punjab. They are entitled to anything and everything.
Why no incentive added to MSP to curb farm fires? It is the wont care attitude; destroying themselves and all others
Greedy dirty people
MSP should be stopped and tax on petrol should be cut. MSP budget is equal to 80% of annual excise duty on petrol. Whole country is paying for this.
Bihar is poorer state, but farmers there doesn't burn it. Punjab ke farmers to free ki aadat padi hue hai. Inka bas chale to hagane ke liye paisa maange. Punjab farmers ne desh ke saare farmers ka nuksan kiya hai.
Bahut dheel de diya hai Punjabiyon ko.
Very True.
@@srinisbir8781 bhai saare punjabiyon ko dheel ni
Jatt(kissan) SC or criminal
Sab ko kuch b krne ki ijjajat hai
Baaki reh gye punjabii Hindu
Police in pr daily jhoothe FIR file krti hai
Agar hindi use kre koi hindu usse daraayeya jaata hai
Roz paise cheene jaate hai
Maar kutaai aam hai punjabi hinduyo ki
So
Punjabiyon ko dheel ni
In criminals ko hi khula chorra hua hai
@@srinisbir8781 bhai saare punjabiyon ko dheel ni
Jatt(kissan) SC or criminal
Sab ko kuch b krne ki ijjajat hai
Baaki reh gye punjabii Hindu
Police in pr daily jhoothe FIR file krti hai
Agar hindi use kre koi hindu usse daraayeya jaata hai
Roz paise cheene jaate hai
Maar kutaai aam hai punjabi hinduyo ki
So
Punjabiyon ko dheel ni
In criminals ko hi khula chorra hua hai
Inko charbi bahut chadi hai Jat sikh lobby ko
Policy+ strict action needed immediately
lun fadd loo
Why doesn't AAP party provide these farmers free resources to take care of stubble in the correct way knowing fully well it's affecting the health of people in Delhi?!?!? Are the party goons sleeping there? Haryana is solving these problems so effectively ⭐️
Aap creates a problem for every solution. Good luck with Punjabis voting for AAP.
The farmers in this part are the spoilt lot. When the farmers in other parts of the country can afford it consider it their responsibility not to burn stubble why can't these farmers do? Those supporting farmers agitation should explain
Easier to shame them than provide them affordable solutions.
It's the Punjabi attitude, they do it deliberately!
Their thinking - we can repeal farm laws, create chaos, do anything the way we want to do!
It seems like farmers from this area feel entitled and don't want to change their habits. They know that no one can force them as they can use "khalistani" card or "sikh sentiments" card to scare people who question them. Unfortunately this entitlement has only grown because of overwhelming MSP funds give to these farmers compared to farmers from other states. In effect, tax payers are funding these farmers (thru MSP) and in return getting gift of pollution/cancer etc.
True. The whole farmers protest was a farce. They were not even farmers they were just rich farm owners. These people don't care a bit about the inconveniences and hazards they're causing.
In the old days these farmers used to lick boots of Britishers to buy cloth and salt.
Today because of Indian Goct dams and canals and MSP they do farming from AC rooms!
Time to show them their real place and stop all procurement from Punjab
They got a lot of sympathy and support from all over the world for being the so called 'farmers' but in reality they're not your average humble farmers like they have been portrayed during the protest. They are rich farm owners with modified fancy vehicles. The bring farmers from Bihar and have them work as low wage labourer and also abuse them a lot. The whole farmers protest thing is a farce. These hardheaded Punjabi people have no concern whatsoever for the health hazards they are causing, only way to discipline them is by applying the Indira Gandhi way like in 1984.
@@iaf010 then do so .. why keep barking over here.. no wonder why rest of India was colonized by Britishers much earlier than Punjab. The boot licking Madras, Bombay and Calcutta regiments fought for Britishers against Punjab during 1840s. You better read the history.
@@monkbusiness4009 kahi tera haal kashmir ke hinduo wala naa ho jaye
The people who blindly say that farmers are the reason of this then they should stop eating food because that is the reason for farmers to produce so much for your consumption.
Lol, so they do it for free to feed the nation? What a moronic sardar brain
Jai jawan Jai donkey kisan
😂😂😂😂, where is Krazywal??? The utopian super cm
West Bengal is largest producer of rice. Still nobody does stubble burning. I don't know why Punjab farmers needs stubble burning.
its to do with the climate. and growing season duration
Khujaliwal kha h ab. दिन रात बस झूठ बोलता रहता है
Because they arent punished. And government keeps on giving them subsidies. Here in odisha we dont burn just let it rot in field or sell it to dairy.
They do it deliberately.. they don't care about pollution or health hazards. I'm from Delhi and my eyes get watery and chest feels tight.
This needs to stop. This is crazy. Who will want to invest in India if these basic things can't be fixed.
because only the farmers of punjab do and get whatever they want. farmers of the deccan and east lost out economic prosperity to this selfish lot.
as long people consider straw a waste product they will continue burning it, if the same straw can be used for mushroom farming.
Correct. Plus the straw can be used to feed cattle as well. Also to produce ethanol.
Problem is not with the straw itself, problem is managing that straw. There were machines provided to cut straw but the entire quota of these machines has not been delivered. And, farmers burn it to clear the fields so that they can get their crop fields ready for a sowing season. They do not know the benefit of keeping the straw, they burn it to clear the fields. If they are provided with tools to clear the fields on time and get the straw taken care of, they will be happy to do that.
@@SodiumSyndicate Cattle doesn't eat rice straw as it has absolutely no nutrition (cellulose), they mostly eat wheat straw. As for ethanol, that too is produced from things (wheat, corn, sugarcane etc) that contain cellulose or other sugars (sucrose, fructose etc), which these rice straws lack.
The straw should be fed to biogas plants, to recover biogas and manure. These people are burning valuable stuff. We import so much gas and fertilizers. The fertilizers make up body of the plant, and we are burning it, instead of recovering it.
Bio-cng and ethanol plants are being setup still farmers don't take a pain to transport the parali. Stubble can also be burnt in thermal powerplants and brick chimneys.
A lower middle class youth leaving everything behind having to pay for rent and many lifestyle expenses have to pay tax when their income is just more than 5 lacs.
But big farmers of Punjab earning in lacs or crores with zero tax exploitating labor self sustenance farmers working on farms taking subsidised supply is not willing to stop stubble burning reducing life of North Indians shows their greed and so much lack of morality.
Sorry state of affairs... Where is government
Government is busy playing odd-even.
In Gujarat trying to fight a loosing election
Spending tax money from Punjab in Gujarat elections.
Getting kicked out of flights abroad.
Air pollution is a part and parcel of a Delhiites life. Enjoy!
The only way out is just to start enforcing laws that ban stubble burning and are already present !
Sure ... Give them an out or an alternative ...
But they wont opt for it unless they are penalised for not opting for the alternative.
In simple terms ... You need both ... The carrot AND the stick !
Last time they were in Delhi for almost a year in protests.
Hand over MSP to states.
These stubble should be fed to biogas plants, to recover manure. Burning it, is utter waste of important minerals
I’m so sick from this pollution and the ill negligence of the farmer and how the state sorkar takes action for someone to resides here in Delhi with thick pollution… they only want us to get our money from their harvest but kill us with their smoking 🥺
literally it's far more dangerous than smoking a 10 cigarettes each day because it will impact highly on our lungs dust & particles
No no it's because of Diwali 😅
It is ALSO because of diwali.
Not because of diwali, but because of idiots who burst crackers on diwali
@@nickarvas9566 917 trillion babies are killed every second due to Diwali crackers but these bhakts don't care.
Solution to stop burning is Central Government announce those donot obey their crops will not be purchased by government for that central does surveys of field name crop quantity so that can recheck when come to sell this people we can run bulldozer but this can do
Haha nice try... how can anyone win election with that strategy?
That will destroy farmer's lives. They are the backbone of India's economy.
@@TheDonMan97 not farmers are not back bone. They were made as backbone for votebank politics. Anything a farmer does can be replaced by a machine? Stop patronizing.
@@TheDonMan97 How they are the backbone of India's economy?
It’s getting out of hands something needs to be done fast
This is getting a bit out of hand. AQI in some parts of Delhi was supposed to be 800 ...still no one wants to take a step towards resolving it. Guess, they do not wish to lose farmer votes. The farmers might have their reasons, so high time government works with them to resolve this. It does not matter if it is state or central government. Someone needs to act!!!
Can't blame Diwali for pollution now..
Because Bio Mass burning causes pollution..
AAP kindly stop spending on advertising and help farmers
Aap never helped anybody. Ever... they create problems for every solution.
Blame These SiCK sikhs
@@iaf010 please stop trying to spread unwarranted hate.
40% of Punjab is Hindu and this isn't a religious issue.
@@tge2102 Hate is not Unwarranted.
How many Hindus did Brindanwale and his gang of Khalsa dogs kill? Khalistani dogs still imagine in their small minds that these turbaned dogs somehow "saved Hindus" from Islam when it was the Marathas who defeated and ended Mughal rule in India after 400 yrs of campaign. The only people the sikhs can legitimately claim to have beaten were the Afghans - and that too in the shortest lived empire that lasted just short of 100yrs.
Also when you examine their religion - it is a joke , created by someone who couldn't even read or write with a hodgepodge of ideas that have neither head nor tail, a mixture of Islam and bhaktism. I mean to call it an Indian religion is an insult to the great religions of India like Buddhism, Jainism and Hinduism. Even the Zorastrians and Jews and Christians have deeper philosophy than this half baked utilitarian humanism they call a religion. I mean the absurdity of not shaving as a path to spiritual discipline is itself absurd on the face of it. Buddha was clean shaven - there isnt a Sikh past or present who holds a candle to him!
Also, this claim that they are a warrior religion is also a joke - their 5th guru was a boy - the son of the previous guru who was killed by the mughals. It is due to this boy who wanted revenge that they allegedly became "warriors" - not much different than Lashkar e Taiba in their tactics too. Unlike Rajputs or castes like Kshatriyas who were bound by rules and concepts unique to them, there is no difference between a warrior Sikh and a sweeper sikh in terms of ethics. The fact that these savages who are untrained in how to use a sword are even allowed to carry a sword by right is a joke!
@@tge2102 ofcourse he should not bring religion into this. But even though Punjab has 40% hindu population, hindus are not landlords here nor they are involved in farming at that much level. Most of the land belong to sikhs and specially jatt Sikhs. I won't generalize but these are same people who abuse UP and bihar people like "baiya", "chuda" and what not.
Too bad the country is not serious about Farm Reforms .
Govt needs to find a cheaper option.
One cannot blame farmers alone.
There should be a cheap alternative. Period.
Because farmers are Easy Targets
Reduce paddy cultivation. Cultivate long lasting trees like fruit orchards,etc. Allow cattle to graze as much as possible.
why Punjab and haryana is producing paddy in ist place , its not their natural crop traditionally.
thats real question , everyone know answer to that but no one will solve it.
Control population and stop consumerism
Why can't the govt buy them super seeder in the way like one of the farmers suggested? A group of farmers can use one seeder
Governmemt spends a lot of money through subsidies for farmers. It can't sustain buying stubble from farmers.
Free electricity is enough
Why only free super seeder why not one bolero,one Lamborghini,one Ferrari bc
I could not understand one thing. If Govt's are serious very simple solution lies to this problem , Govt should give bonus based on average expenditure incurred per acre on straw chopping and mixing in soil or other methods suitable for handling straw to the farmers after verifying that a particular farmer has handled the paddy straw as per specifications fixed by the Govt. Only then farmers will comply otherwise they won't. Since Govt is the only purchaser of the crop. So its very easy to verify and controll stuble burning.
Punjabi farmers are not ready, some Sikhs even think this is their religious duty.
I think it's not about the straw it's about getting crop fields ready for sowing season. There was an ancient practice in agriculture called jhum, also known as slash and burn agriculture. They burn their current remaining yield and then plant on it again as the remains had fertility potent in it. The whole problem arises due to not being able to manage the straw. They cannot cut it, so they choose an easy way out to burn it. It gets cleared on time and they are quite in the timeline in reaping soil.
Whatever may be the reasons . Govt should pay bonus to farmers on pady for stubble handling ,based on site inspection . Considering it to be part of paddy cost to be paid to farmers.
@@bundusingla1045 You have to hand them the equipment. Farmers during winters have a tight schedule of planting staples. The problem is not with the straw, the problem is managing it. They have to sow for wheat simultaneously as they sow for rice. If they are getting a bonus, I haven't done the calculation, if the money isn't at all equivalent to what they can rent from the govt for the macines that cut straw effectively, they won't do anything rather choose an easy way out.
70 percent agriculture did for animal husbandry,so minimise animal agriculture so problem will minimize and instead of paddy and wheat production plant trees in farmlands like local tree bamboo,Guava, peepal ,mango etc local tree
Delhi has become "little bit hazy"! Are you kidding, it's full of smog and highly polluted for years now with no positivity to be seen soon. Something needs to be done!!
at the same time delhi private vehicles should be banned for 1-2 weeks till aur improves. schools, college and offices should be virtual.
Paise kon dega iske? Also how will, say, the post or RTO work if everyone works remotely?
Believe me, nothing will change .
Diesel was subsidised during congress govt .due to which machine rent was less.
Now superseeder costs 1200₹ per acre .which will increase investment cost .so burning stubble is easy .
Congress 👍
This problem will persist until all governments (Centre & states) sit together and work together. And give a decent big budget for this problem. Enough of this bullshit!
In India problems are not allowed to be solved. They linger on and on. Politicians understand the pulse of the people. The public doesn’t care about pollution. It is the westernised elite of India and in the drawing rooms of Leytens Delhi that they worry about pollution, but they are not willing to pay the farmers for not burning stubble. Everyone wants clean air for free but nobody is prepared to pay for it. The same situation is playing out with our water resources and groundwater levels that are shrinking at a rapid rate.
Why not use stubble as cattle feed as in south
Good point. Im from TN and spoke to few farmers. They said there is a huge demand for cattle feed
Delhi city people stop burning petrol, punjab farmers shall stop burning stubble
Govt. Should make arrangements for collection of stubble
Govt should make efforts to kick these farmers out of their fields and auction them to new farmers from other states
@@iaf010 the collected stubble can be used to produce ethanol. Couple of months back one such ethanol producing plant was inaugurated in Haryana. ruclips.net/video/WJ09Hl6_C-0/видео.html
I am from Assam, and we do not do stubble burning.
let's not blame poor farmers there...they have being doing so for so many years and there isn't easy alternative for them....plus they gave short time to prepare to plant other plants in the season...
But these poor farmers have 5 cars at home
@@kartikgarg4446 That's a rare situation. Though Punjab has some of the most well paid farmers bugt the average is still 10,000-12, 000 which is not that much to make a good living.
@@kartikgarg4446 easy target most of farmers have 2-3 acre of land.. Talk sense.. Btw in Delhi people have SUV which contributes 20% more pollution.. So what would you say on that... They should also stop using SUV.. Don't play selectively 😂
One could make pellets, packing material like card board or paper plates or even charcoal. The county has enough brain power ND they could find a solution. This problem has existed since a few years and I don't think that government can solve it, all they do is talk. It has to make economic sense for the farmers otherwise they will resort to burning as it is cheap for them in the short term
Give them incentives and viable alternative and they wont burn anymore with this ancient practise to renew the soil
More non-smoking lung cancers in India, compared to smoking-associated lung cancers the World over. Indians decide if this is a price worth paying.
these farmers should be arrested and land should be acquired by govt after paying good compensation and given to hardworking bihari with condition they cant burn stubble. farmers currently pay zero tax and destroy environment.
BHutiye insan wtf its all agenda.
Crackers make more pollution than this.
Nobody burns these days..
Ek 2 ko khda k tumlogo ka kaatre ye... Or kisi k baap ka maal h kya jo isko dedo usko dedo..tera bda se bda hardworking haath khade kr wapas chla jayega ghaate k saudhe me..and they already not doing farming ..they r doing other things in metro cities which r more earning.
Abhi tumara pet idr se he bhar ra only...or jo choud dikhayi abhi export krke..ussse kisan ko kuch profit nhi mila...
Hum rice lgana he nhi chahte tum praali ki baat krte..hume dusri crop pe laaya jaye
.na hum ye khaate h..tere jese 80 CRORE ko baantne k liye hum hmari soil or water aur barbad nhi kr skte..tumare mehnge rice export k chkr me hume apni dharti banjar nhi bnani
.but nobody is giving us replacement.. everybody just shitting out coz there is hidden agenda behind it jo pura hua nhi but try jaari h..koi na aana khushboo lga k wait rhega..iske liye to bhai bhai k katal ho jate galt vehm me h
Whenever government decided to take land from farmers, and give them compensation, the farmer doesn't receive even 50% of the compensation he is due, and sometimes they receive it 10-15 years later.
Biharis can't even take care of Bihar, you want to make one more Bihar?!
There's just one way to stop it, they need to start putting fine on them at the rate of Rs10,000 per acre.
Then they'll start doing it. 🙄🙄
That fine was part of the farm laws... you know what happened when those laws were brought.
They would rather go to prison than to pay the fines. Moreover, librandus all over the world would quickly jump in to rescue them.
@@hemiacetal1331 i doubt it, coz then they would fail to manage their crops.
Also Stop demanding food under NFSA then..Better alternative
@@seeratkaurm nfsa is stupid.
They should give money to the poor not grains.
When you give free electricity, free water, take zero taxes from a community. That community would never ever listen to you again. This is the real situation. The poor service class people who actually runs the country by paying income tax is suffering.
So who saved the economy or Run the country in Covid..?
@@seeratkaurm Kindly elaborate your point. Hope to have a good discussion
@@anuragpandey2635 okay first of all the concept of Free electricity and water this all started with so called GREEN REVOLUTION( sponsored by govt and now suffered by farmers). The long term impacts are suffered by Farmers now. Do you know how many Farmers do suicides daily? The ground water is dyeing at alarming rate.. We can't even imagine the Agriculture (rice mainly) in future. Punjab whose main sector is Agriculture what is their future? Have we ever thought farmer is struggling to survive.. Har ek ka DA increase hota but what about farmers.. Have we ever shown or interested in listening their problem as well? Always a point come k poor service class is suffering the point should be that Our farmers should not be suffered at any cost, Farmer Income is in negative growth .. Just imagine the life without food, this is the basic necessity. Now think of Covid when evry sector was dying it was agriculture who saved our economy and us as well.
It is easy to blame farmers bcz they are already oppressed.
same problem happen each and every years don't know when they will take action . NEXT time framer should Burn Stubble next to Minister home then they will realize how difficulties to Breath and take action next to no time.
They are ready to listen.
Madness,send wheat grass to south more demand here for cattle foodet,railway can help
AAP good in giving lecuters and giving targets for next 200 years...haryana doing something
🙏🙏🙏 Punjab Chardi Kala
This is the worst govt of Punjab..what do you expect from AAP..
Kejariwal already invented the solution for this as he did umpteen times earlier. By next year (again as always), he would have solved this problem(as every other problem).
Alas, we have magician in our hands. Lucky us.
People in India in don’t bother about environment or nature and only think about their own personal benefit. Government officials are lax about implementation of laws and people end of doing anything for their own benefit. In long term this has led to pollution of water bodies, rivers, land and air.
"इंदिरा खड़का दी तुम्हारे फेफड़ो की क्या औकाद" कैंसर दाता फ्रॉम पंजाब।
Delhi people are very much tolerant and busy in becoming rich by wealth but poor by health.
This is one of the reasons that the educated wealthy class of South Delhi are leaving India.
If govt of Haryana and UP could reduce stubble burning what is unique about costs and other excuses in Punjab and AAP govt. Punjab always behaves as if it’s a foreign and invader society. They always want more from the Union than they deliver and quite shameless about every bad Karma. It was these same Punjab farmers who stole the most reformist Agricultural laws from farmers of rest of Indian Union.
AAP is in power in both the places but, they will do nothing.
AAP party bullied Farmars
That;s just bad excuse....if the farmers who are usually a lot poorer in other parts of the country can get rid of stubbles without burning it. why can't they?..we saw the same during farmer protest movement, the more entitled demands more. And both state and central govts are letting it play as part of the politics while citizens are suffering and paying the cost with their actual lifetime.
If the govenment wan't this to stop, maybe establish a way to Co-op State sponsored equipment. The State invests millions on deficient programs, how about investing in one that actually address a matter of consequense? Someone is already driving to the fields to inspect and critique, why not make it a truck with a trailer hauling the needed equipment, useable by the Community? In the end, what is the cost compairson as such relates to the entire problem?
मेरे किसान भइयों क्यों एसी तेसी krne pr हो paisa साथ nehi जाना सब यही रह जाना
Pay the farmers not to farm for 2 years and see if it makes a difference in air quality
Haryana improved but punjab getting worse.
So this year also Delhi will become smoked barbeque Owen.. Politicians should settle this matter amicably
Farmers are not ready.
Where is kanjarwal and his punjab govt. now…😂😂😂
Maybe the national capital should be shifted to south India for six months. And Punjab should be turned into a union territory.
Tax Delhi.. pay Punjab
Because Law enforcement is not doing their job
Yes we should ask AAP why police is not arresting people for this.
what happened to the bio decomposer scheme
time to pull paddy out of punjab, need to give msp on pulses and low water using crops which are native to the region.
also, farmers need to take responsibility, simply bucking the blame on sarkaaran is not the solution.
you are literally pumping toxic gas in your children’s lung, ffs stop it.
The stupid government should start a plywood factory which convert all stalk into bhusa which can be used to make plywood or door or Government should give incentive and subsidy to make farm own mini crusher which can be buy by government to make bhusa for furniture of low cost and good quality
They tried it with farm laws, but they opposed it so the government is stupid.
Why point Punjab only...Is it because of Delhi pollution....What about 50% of pollution in Delhi coming from vehicles....????
you dumb quiff....go back to subsidy seeking thats what you are made for....
@@amanj3051 Hatred and abuses are the only what u people know…Get ur facts first, stubble pollution constitutes less than 10% in Delhi…For a while leave the WhatsApp and apply ur brain a bit…only then start ridiculing others…And stop blaming Punjab farmers for everything please 🙏
I again say please apply ur mind before u go on believing whatever governments say otherwise this hatred will lead us all towards killing each other….Please use ur brains and see the facts first….Thanks and Peace 🙏
@@jbslach Its not hatred....its pity & frustration u moron....punjab farmers are producing smthing which ppl dont want to buy....and these ppl are asking govt for min prices also.....can you also apply ur mind......its like main toh yahin ugaunga aur mujhe paise bhi jyada do,paani bijli free do,tax mat lo nahin to sadak jaam kar dunga....
@@amanj3051 ok…u win…Now please 🙏
And stop abusing I again say…If u really want that then come and do it in front of me at Chandigarh…. Please 🙏
@@jbslach why would some self respecting punjabi will come or live in randigarh?
Bihari up mp and other state kisan should brat punjabi sikh kisan
Ghanta awareness. Arrest the stubble burners and provide them free use of stubble removing machines.
What about AC and SUV ,industrial pollution which contribute 50 percent of pollution.. Talk sense😂.. People of Delhi suddenly knows the Pollution in October November.. What about Rest of Year??? Who is doing pollution for rest 10 months 😂😂.. Such a hypocricy
1 superseeder in patiala 😅 😂 🤣
Aur yeh h Annadata ,😂😂😂