ITS A LOGISTIC WAR!!! ...Kursk window is closing... | Ukraine War Conclusions
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 ноя 2024
- DPA's Ukraine War Mapping: defensepolitic...
#UkraineWar #Russia #Ukraine
X: x.com/defensep...
Telegram: t.me/defensepo...
DPA Forum: t.me/DPAForum
DPA Chat: t.me/DPAChat
Discord: / discord
WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/c...
---
Support DPA's reporting and work financially (to circumvent RUclips's suppression):
Patreon: / defensepoliticsasia
Locals: defensepolitic...
Ko-fi: ko-fi.com/defe...
Boosty - boosty.to/defe...
RUclips Membership:
youtube.com/@De...
youtube.com/@DP...
---
Discover DPA presence across the internet with DPA's Linktree: linktr.ee/defe...
![[ SITREP ] Here we go again.... RUSSIA ANNOUNCE MORE CAPTURES!!! | Ukraine War Summary](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Rja0YQROt1g/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lil Uzi Vert - Chill Bae [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D7F42F_JM3U/mqdefault.jpg)
Hello
CONGRATS! YOU ARE AWARDED THE DPA FIRST MEDAL~!!!
SLAVA DPANI~!!!
Commander, get some rest! Don't become a victim of war! You need to introduce a co-anchor whether you want to or not. Eat well, sleep at least 6 hours per day, exercise 30 minutes per day, and treat yourself good once in a while.
❤well said
Hello my 🦌 friend, Wyatt, from Defense Politicss Asssiaaa.
This is my favourite formate when you explain what is strategic situation in the front :)
I really like this format where your reporting and analysis are in separate videos. Great idea!
Thanks commander for sharing your opinions.
I hereby support your efforts, Wyatt!
Ukrainians are stuck after capturing a string of villages in the middle of nowhere at a staggering snowballing cost and this string of villages can't be held anyway due to horrible logistic. This operation proved to be an unmitigated disaster for Ukraine from the military standpoint. Both Zelenskyy and Sirsky are heavily invested in this failed Kursk misadventure, so they are just reinforcing the failure as they did in Krinki, Bakhmut or a failed Zelenskyy offensive in 2023. It's their usual pattern. They kept Ukrainian troops in Bakhmut when all escape routes were under Russian fire control and it turned into a senseless slaughter. But they didn't stop even at that, after May 20, when Russians took Bakhmut they launched for months wave after wave of suicidal attacks in a futile attempt to recapture Bakhmut. I remember even NYT called it an obsession.
Delusional
@@LeoTheLion66 Supporters of the US's dirty war in Ukraine are indeed delusional.
Lets not forget that it was also Syrsky that launched all those ill-fated attempts to retake Bakhmut BEFORE Zuluzhny's fall from grace :) and now that man is in charge, doing exactly the same things that earned him the name "butcher" by his own men, for how many of his men died in his operations.
Open fields without cover, no air superiority, extended logistics, NATO led. Catastrophe.
Both Zelenskyy and Sirsky are heavily invested in this failed Kursk misadventure;
The Ukrainians would not have done it without US and UK direction. These are the real minds behind it, but they will slink away and say they had nothing to do with it.
Ze actually WEAKENED his negotiating positions by Kursk
By the russians - No more negotiation with Ukraine! That was stated by Lavrov , Medvedev , Peskov.
He destroyed it completely.
Not weakened, ended completely.
negotiations? do you really think theres any? 😂
@@XNAGP There was prior to Kursk. One side wanted to hold onto the oblasts it currently holds most of in addition to protections for their culture/people and not joining their enemies. The other side didn't only want those oblasts but wanted territory lost in a previous conflict(despite that half of these oblasts had armed rebellions prior to the current war). Essentially Russia did negotiate since the original terms had been much MUCH more ambitious than the terms Russia offered. Ukraine in turn did not negotiate and wanted everything. Whether you are pro Ukrainian or Pro Russian, it is a fact that Ukraine refused to negotiate.
Thank you for all your work, DPA! You are the best 💜
Ciao Wyatt, my best wishest to the most unbiased channel on Ukro Russia war.
“CIA did it, may be the RUSSIAN” 😅😅😂😂
Thank you we appreciate your contribution to informative updates
Small problem when fighting a numerically superior foe, your diversion often end up diverting your own forces instead of the enemies.
The thing is - Russian army is not numerically superior (or not significantly). From the beginning, it was numerically inferior. This is something that many don’t understand. Russia did 1 batch of mobilisation. Ukraine has effectively squeezed most of what they are able to squeeze.
@@sergeyd2199 Russia can continue to mobilize more troops very progressively whereas Ukraine has already mobilized to the bone plus the huge flight of population.
@@sebc8938 they can, but haven’t done it yet, obviously.
Mr. Dpa, as I can see, you're finally catching up with reality!!!!!! You finally red the writings on the wall!!! 👍💯
huh?
@@DefensePoliticsAsia Mr. Dpa, you are the mannnn!!!!!👍👍💯💯
Morning Wyatt. Good report. J
Military golden rule. Never reinforce failure.
Brilliant job you are doing.....Hooked to your channel for many weeks!
..three hours ago on TV, the actress said that the objective in the Kursk area was fulfilled!? that is, after 10,000 dead and thousands of destroyed equipment, they will retire as winners?? how many will return??
Thanks for giving us information
Speculations based on the facts and facts only! I love this channel!!!
I love this guy
We love your work and keep it up bro
You work really hard
Like always great work
excellent report
Every war is won by logistics! Or lost because of logistics.
That's logical..!
Since the time of Alexander
Wrong,
What logistic was disrupt for US army in Afghanistan?
@@danielkurtovic9099 The last part of it. Don't you have anyone serving in Afganistan? Do you know how they drove on the roads? In fear as any ride could be ambush. But US didn't lose that war. They were moving out as they needed everything to support Ukraine as it's 10 times more money in the game. Or you still think US was selling democracy in Afganistan?
@@marinkovacevic8732Lol. US leaving Afghanistan has nothing to do with the current war Russia-Ukraine, they wouldn’t have left £80 billions in military equipment, that equipment would have made it easier on Ukrainians. US got tired, like others before. Soviet Union didn’t lose in Afganistan, they were tired and it was not economical to fight for such insignificant piece of land. Btw Kabul fell to US- supported radical islamists 5 years later, not during the withdrawal. US could win this war for Ukraine, tomorrow, freezing current situation + return of occupied Kursk lands.
I was wondering about Transnistria for a while. The only reason is that it would mean attacking a friendly neighbour. Legality of such action and related consequences???
Always made me wonder why thr Russians left Kursk open (no mines, trenches or personnel) ... Genius move to see if US intelligence would be fooled into the trap and they did.
And now the Russians know who their informants are.
Это территория газопровода в Европу. По договорённостям, боевых действий там быть не должно, чтобы не повредить поставкам газа. Зеленский нарушил договор. Будет отвечать.
It certainly is acting as a troop sink for Ukraine. The troops there are needed elsewhere and what they have taken is of no significant value.
No simply came down to Russian believing the Ukrainians would never be so desperate to expand themselves war as remember day one Russia was on the door step to Kiev so they could easily stop this invasion if they wanted to they clearly don’t, why? It is sucking resources the Ukrainians do not have to waist.
@@михаилроманов-ф7ч nice info
Cheers Wyatt.
Saludos desde Ecuador, Grande la madre RUSIA
You are my hero Wyatt! Be careful with the men in black!
love ur work
Thanks for the love!
DPA chocked. CIA DID IT
Hello DPA
The thermite drone looks impressive... in infrared, but in daylight it shows that it is essentially glorified Bengal fire stick, it will do fire damage if it is concentrated into one place, but spreading it over a wide area will likely not be that bad, it is doubtful if it can even burn through or ignite a standard wooden ammo crate. And it is just common sense to actually not store ammo crates in the open, but rather in trench niches, where the top soil will insulate it from any fire. Thermite is just a shower of sparks, it doesn't have weight and momentum to penetrate, and it won't burn long unless it is dumped at a single spot.
You surely dont know what thermite is.
Cant burn through a wooden box????
See some RUclips movies where they weld rails together with termite. Very interesting and informative
@@LeoTheLion66 Is this the latest 'wonder weapon' to add to the long line of failures that don't change the fact Russia is winning the war?
@@LeoTheLion66 railway tracks are welded by containing and concentrating the heat to one specific area. If thermite is spread, it’s pretty useless. Concentration is the key.
@@LeoTheLion66 You surely don't know what reading comprehension is. Rail tracks are welded by concentrating a massive amount of thermite in a single spot and with direct contact, not spreading it over a vast area from above. It's back to first grade for you I guess, and this time, pay more attention! Also, those crates are treated with fire retardant chemicals, they are quite difficult to set on fire. Add enough of them to a burning fire, and they will actually put it out.
@@dgo4490 thermite consist of aluminum and ferrite. When it burns it will alter into liquid iron at a temperature of 2500 C.
If you vatniks beleive something different I really dont care
DPA 🎉
Please put a video in the 5th to 8th dimension. That will be great. Really needed in the 5th dimension for urgent needed intel
Nice 👍
LOOK south of Kostiantynivka...the water-body; Klean-byk. Look the river aside the roas to Pokrovsk... Canal allows to encercle Torretsk and meet Kleban Byk with Kryvyi Torrets- Druzhba.
Russia replaced defense minister Shougi with Andrey Belousov, an economist. He probably wondered... "Why spend all that money sending Russia's armies south into Ukraine, when Ukraine's armies can be more efficiently obliterated if they would come to Russia."
Could be so....if it wasn't so that the Kursk invasion is a huge embarrassment for Russia.
But continue to fool yourself
😂
@@stefanobiggini6526 Seriously, Russia considers Ukraine (at least the eastern part) to be its own territory... just like the Kursk area. So it makes a LOT more logistical sense to host the war inside of Russia.
@@SunriseLAW it is the outcome now anway and also the russian state get more warsupport now
FOOL
Thanks for 83 subscriber's ❤️❤️🎉
🎉🎉😂U welcome for 87 now
You do good reports
Hello everyone
All major ground wars are decided by logistic. All wars depend on logistics.
I have pressed the like.
One of the first comments and you already pressed "Like"?
Why?
You has not Seen the Video!
@@alexanderweigand6758 Not when I pressed like. But Wyatt seems like a nice chap. I don’t think he is going to say anything to me, that makes me unlike his video.
I pressed because he asked gently
I beat the sh*t out of that like button.
@@sergeyd2199 Your Phone (or another device) is able to sh...?
Who wants this?
Defense Politics Aaaaaaaaaaaaasia! LFG!
Commanda, is it possible that you spend a minute or two to compare where the frontline was month and half a year before as you did once?
That can be done once a month so it is easier to track the progress of war
Looks like fish trap..
They have sometime before serve at the table
Russians paused ops in Pavrost for the Ukrainians to gather and concentrate forces. This will allow economic use of Mr. Iskander or Mr. Kinzhal.
@@starexminefield5792 I just saw a video on redd it where orcs were cooking their meal over Mr Thermite. It was hot
@@LeoTheLion66 The 'orcs' are Ukrainian Neo-Nazis, right? Plenty of those have already been cooked along with NATO/mercenary goblins.
@@LeoTheLion66 I can only see trees, poor trees burned.
@@watDfacts of cause..... You cant see what has burned apart from metal
The city is not evacuated yet.
They can't continue until evac is complete.
I'm busy when I watch the videos so I can't always watch it...
your reporting is funny and i laugh but i remember its actually people losing their lives. Ukraine is fighting a losing battle
Ukraine is reaping what they've sowed. If you sow the wind, your're gonna harvest rain.
'Nski is snorting the line.
Filip the table... Best line in the video for the very end.
At this rate, Ukies will be so desperate, they might try to trigger meltdowns on their nuclear power plants, just like what they tried to do with donbass and kursk.
These people are desperate and diabolical. Didn't they blow up a Dam? And than shelling the Zap NPP than blaming the Russians. Russia ain't dumb to try to blow up a NPP which was under their control.
Congratulations on the unbiased content. Where r u from?
DPA! That was funny " press the like button if you don't support me." 😅😂😂😂
Prefer having conclusion that is short then sitrep that is getting too long
Came for info - stayed for jokes
Transenistra was a part of Moldova.
Ukrainian soldier abandoning their position on foot usually means their request for evac or additional reinforcement was denied.
what do you use to draw the lines on your map?
great report wyatt... i think u don't need justify yrself always... but doesn't matter cuz u have good jokes 😹
I'm sure there was a sane reason for taking a summer-trip to Kursk,,, maybe Polish smugglers were low on cigarettes, so the Ukies thought they could perhaps fetch some vodka,,,, or maybe they'd had too much vodka, and went in the wrong direction for cigarettes,,, hard to say
Nice
Logistics would akways be an issue.
5:24 the halt at Pokrovsk -
Most likely because the city is not evacuated yet.
If the Russians continue now, there will be many civilian casualties.
Evacuation should be complete in 1~2 weeks?
ukraine is going to keep kursk forever because of its strategic importance /ukraine is defeated in kursk .kursk isn't strategic at all and ukraine never planned to hold it
Zelensky is already retreating from Kursk. Couldn't even make it a month. Afu is the second best military in Russia! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ukraine should stop trying to attack and build real defense where it matter.
Time is actually a problem, very hard to spend so much time for other countries war which is not relevant to our country
Good information although would be good if you can detail more information on what Squads are being used because when you see some front line changes its like 8-12 soldiers but the media spins it to be like a full brigade when it is a squad or a platoon
And if it is more like battalion how far are they from the forces they send to the front
Although your analysis is good i think their is even more detail you can show and maybe this is why you have low numbers as some mappers talk more about the different aspects and not just do analysis also you could be being blacklisted as the media does not like the truth to be told they like it to be muted also not sure having 2 channels helps although i get why you did it i actually think the open mic gives alot of detail but i never really see you do a lot of these. but yes maybe you don't do these all on you-tube and that is why
you know like if their was more detail on the death accuracy that is not really reported on in the war the war might actually end faster but the main stream is not doing that either.
Ukraine best option at the moment would be to accept their going to lose territory and withdraw their troops to the area that Putin said in his agreement he wanted from them then make a deal with Russia. Although he may now want even more territory now Ukraine is in a no win situations that can only get worse for them.
Their are options for Ukraine but throwing out your government i mean this seriously is the story no one is talking about but this will not benefit Zelensky it puts him in an even weaker position it just looks more and more like he is the one that needs to be removed to solve the war weather its to carry on with war or get a peace deal.
Naja die Grenze verlief vor einigen Wochen so motich mal behaupten, inzwischen steht man bei Dneprpetrovsk ,Sumi...,wenn ich einigermaßen informiert bin.
I think after all this "stronk leader" stuff Zelensky simply just cannot order to retreat somewhere, especoally in Vuhledar, which became symbolic much as Bakhmut. It is PR trap to not allow himself look weak even if it is strategically bad at frontline.
10:41 the line you showed includes Chasov Yar, if Russia takes Chasov Yar they will attack Konstantinivka from the heights without needing Bakhmut as a "supply base".
Thats why in my op, they will first try taking Chasov Yar which is located in heigths, and then attack the city of Konstantinovka.
Yes, as we all can see how "trying" is going on for the past two months. They just don't care about it as much as you do.
@@branimirbutkovic9424 What are you trying to say? .............
I agree, when you chocked you said must be Russians. Yes for sure 😀 Anytning ever happens, it must be Russians, or chinese 🤣
في كورسك يوجد فقط محطة الغاز في سوجا التي هي استراتيجية بالإضافة إلى المدينة كل المناطق المسيطر عليها هي ارض مفتوحة وقرى يجب السيطرة على لوغوف والمحطة النووية تعتبر ذو اهمية
18:41What? You can't simply attack Transnistria as you would declare war to Moldova as if not considered as independent nation, Transnistria is an autonomous republic of Moldova. Moreover you drag in Romania also into this conflict and not in Ukraine favour. Then you would also launch an attack against a UN protected area. Please, this suggestion is a sign of lack of understanding about anything regarding Transnistria. Attacking Belorussia would be less problematic.
Actually the resistance Russia is fighting is from NATO soldiers.
They cannot easily attack Pridnestrovye, it's officially part of Moldova and will be interpreted as invasion of foreign country who is not part of this war. Since Ukraine depends on PR, they cannot afford it. It's pointless as it won't distract Russian troops either. They may capture some locals who hold Russian passports and work as peacekeepers, which would be a horrible PR as well. There are no actual Russians there for decades at this point.
Not to mention it will destabilize the region and will turn both Moldova and their big brother Romania hostile, as they don't need reignation of the civil war in the region which will quickly degenerate to ethnic cleansing Balcan style.
For the algorithm
Unless you have a PAPR unit huffing it in full kit with a gas mask is aids! Imagine doing that in winter? :( Short distances are fine though.
So Kursk was another never interrupt your enemy when he’s making a mistake in the favor of the Russian Empire. Top Ukrainian troops were relocated and struggling in the azz end of nowhere Russia. Meanwhile Ukrainians are being teared up in the Donbass where the fighting really counts
Logistics is about having the right number of men and material in the right place at the right time. Timing is everything. Get it wrong and you lose. Thankfully, for the Russians they have the CIA on their side and for the CIA, logistics is having the right click-bate on the right MSM channel at the right time and that is all they are concerned about.
❤️🔥🚀🇷🇺🙏✝ БОГ БУДЕТ С НАМИ В ПОБЕДЕ ✝🙏🇷🇺🥇🕊️
Transportation, provisioning vs communication, message/in formation conveyance. 4:30
Transnistria for Odessa?
I agree with your analysis. Having more ressources the Russian probably consider that a longer front gives them a strategical adavantage. So they do not want to suppress Ukrainians saillants like in Siversk or Kremina forest where their rears can be bombarded by artillery and drones easily. They do not want also to make the positions with the back to the Oskil river in Koupiansk fall too quickly as it is a very bad position grinding the Ukrainians a lot. It is also thus highly possible that they will not try to reduce completely the kusrk saillant but will try to transform it into an artillery pocket death trap. The wise movement from the Ukrainians would be to reduce the front length just as the Russians did when they were lacking troops leading to sucessful Ukrainians offensives in Kherson and Izium. So they should get rid of their positions across the Oskil rivers and the Donetz canal completely to reconstruct an operational reserve. I am not sure they have the political will to dit nevertheless.
Views will go up with better prep and some editing.
What they going to do with the nearly 10K dead Ukrainians soldiers
Will NATO & US compensate the victims families
Wtf... You should hide then.. hahahhha 😂😂😂
that's what I was thinking...or 'make like a tree'...😊
🍻
🎉
What a fool of a President.
"can't do $hit about"
Russia maintains a few battalions of peacekeepers in Transnistria, and already even 2008, we witnessed how an UNPREPARED Russian battalion was capable of defending against what was effectively TWO DIVISIONS worth of troops after a 12 hour extremely massive artillery barrage.
The Russian troops didn't even take serious casualties while the Georgian advance units were completely gutted.
The Russian troops in transnistria were better prepared even before 2022.
If Georgian troops couldn't crush an EASY target in 2008, with their most elite troops, i really doubt UA would have an easy time about it against a wellprepared and heavily entrenched target NOW, when they have trouble scraping together anything but civillians in uniform with a rifle.
One interesting technical issue (at least to me) in the Ukraine War is:
Why can't Russia destroy the commie blocks in Vuhledar? Vuhledar is within easy range of all Russian weapons.
It is difficult to believe that the fortifications in Vuhledar are impervious to destruction in 2024. Has Ukraine along with the Soviets of long ago, been able to build an indestructible fortification?
Would Tall Boys or Grand Slams work?
It is not an interest of Russia to destroy city after city. Simple as that.
The FAB1500 and 3000 are the heaviest bombs they have. To my knowledge unlike the tall boy/grand slam they are not equipped with penetrative bodies and delayed fuses. They could knock down the buildings but bunkers and tunnels underneath might remain intact. The kinzhal probably enough kinetic energy to initiate a seismic effect but they aren't generally used on tactical battlefield targets.
I pressed the like button so you could buy your noodles and dog meat for dinner. 🙂
I havent ate dog before. I'm curious though, how it would taste like....
I will tell you WHAT THE HELL IS HAPPENING (12:34). RF carry out *raids* close to the urban centres like Kostyantynivka so the civilians pack their things and go. If the front line was too close too fast, you would get panic like Pokrovsk and RF could not storm the city anyway. They are not animals.
Isn't every war a logistics war? Lolz
I think the Russians are the ones holding back toward Pokrovsk, and would probably start to even out the front to left and right flanks and consolidate forces in those sectors, as their movement into Ukrainan sector leaves them very open to a cauldron when looking on the map now.
I've given it more thought. You need to adopt a posh british accent and only use your native accent for Uncle Rodger jokes. Follow this advice and DPA will conquer all the youtubes.
It takes brain power to use a different accent... LOL~
... and then I get distracted by myself... LOL
One thing is sure. Ukraine will never recover from this. Biologically most important. It will become Europe's Afghanistan
Why Afganistan? They have bunch of children.
@@marinkovacevic8732 Afghanistan in terms that will never recover from war. What was Saur Revolution for Afghanistan in 1978, that was Maidan for Ukraine. Demographically, Ukraine is a case for itself
@@risbolensky3921 I still do not understand. From what exactly does Afganistan needs to recover? Talibans took 19 billion of dollars in equipment, US spend millions in bribes, Afganistan never saw that kind of money in their life. Taliban government pushes religion instead of education. That's the only reason I see that is huge issue for life improvements in Afganistan.
Afghanistan double their population every 20 years
@@user-pl8kc2lo1r its simply not true. Hunger, diseases, war, lawlessness significantly impacted Afghan demographic. Hunger and diseases even more then war