Dr. Sayed Moustafa al Qazwini is highlighting these narrations from Sunni books not to create tension or divide but rather to unite people over the belief in Imam Mahdi [AJ]. As Muslims we have so much more in common than differences but we focus on the differences. May Allah bless you.
Dont worry, Like the splitting of the moon in the time of Prophet s.a.w. The ummah will unite with the arrival of Mehdi a.s. Allah is the best of planners
The sunni and shia are all the ummah of the prophet alayhi salam. We should look beyond the age old political establishments that created divide between the two
faith cannot be compared to politics. but those who do not have true faith in their heart are recognized in their heart, and in their speech.. and no matter how much you search in history, you will not find it. when people don't have iman they hsr a thousand excuses for their split. so neither Sunni nor Shia will ever have true Faith.. when someone asks a Muslim, are you Muslim, answer yes, I am Sunni or Shia. if you are a Muslim you belong to a book Quran .. if you belong to the Quran you are Islam .. and not Sunni or Shia .. but as God says the devil is your sworn enemy. and When the Prophet Muhammed A S changed his life .. then the devil came in between the believers, and the devil succeeds in taking the shirt off Ali .. by giving the other caliphates. The word imam means wisdom .. therefore the chosen one is guided and taught with the wisdom of God . and that is only 1 of 4 gifts God gave him.
The face of Mehdi shall shine upon the surface of the Moon. - Imam Ja’far al-Sadiq IMAM MEHDI SEYYEDANA RA RIAZ GOHAR SHAHI (as) face shines on the moon 🌙 #alratv youtube.com/@ALRATV?si=P04VTgwzcxjznB82 #ifollowgoharshahi #imammehdigoharshahi #imammehdi #امام #امام_حسین #امام_زمان #امام_مهدی
Dr. Moustafa, Yes, Sunni, and even Salafi school all believes in the birth of Al Mahdi in end times. But the Mahdi of Ahle Sunah or of the Salaf differs vastly from the school that your represent i.e. Twelver Shīʿism. Hope once the Mahdi comes all will recognize him despite vast difference about each of these schools belief about him.
Now a fundamental question arises where in ahlul sunnah does it say clearly the Mahdi is not born yet because in shia literature it clearly says he is Already born??
Thank you for your comment. Despite having differences in the belief of his current existence, it is vital that all of us Muslims unite on the belief that he is the Imam who will establish peace and justice throughout the world and as Muslims, we all have a responsibility towards working for this cause which is the cause of Allah. When Allah sees how dedicated we are to reform ourselves and our societies InshaAllah He will bless us with his reappearance.
This is a good question - I think one of the arguments is the narration that states that Allah will raise him in a single night. However, in our school of thought this is considered the time of Qiyam where Allah gives permission to the Imam [AJ] to rise which will be in Masjid al Haram. Additionally, Imam Mahdi [AJ] cannot be a "regular", pious individual who will be endowed by Allah in one night to spread peace and justice across the world. Furthermore, in both Sunni and Shia hadiths it is established that when Nabi Isa [AS] descends from the heavens at the time of prayer, Imam Mahdi [AJ] will ask him to lead. Nabi Isa [AS] then puts his hand on Imam Mahdi's [AJ] shoulder and says (I am paraphrasing) that he has a greater right [to lead this prayer]. Nabi Isa [AS] is one of the 5 Ulul Azm Prophets that has a very high status. The fact that Imam Mahdi [AJ] will be leading a universal messenger in prayer is a very important point about the status of Imam Mahdi [AJ].
@@prep4imammahdi Thank you for your response. Most schools within the house of Islam agrees, Al Mahdi will appear and establish peace and justice. Details of him and his action varies from school to school. If anyone wants to concentrate on differences then sky is the limit. End of the day as long as individuals adhere to fundamental teachings of Islam, all are BROTHERS/SISTERS in faith and part of the same Ummah. Focus of all should be to see the bigger picture instead of arguing over peanuts. Out of 8.5 billion people in the world today, over 6.5 billion are NOT Muslim. Focus should be to spread the message of Monotheism to them and enlighten and free them from eternal darkness and hell fire.
Dr.sayed,I am happy after going through your lectures,till now I know only Dr.Shiekh imron Nazar hosein (the only Islamic eschologist),I am his student, Alhamdulillah.Now I want to listen to you also.Please accept me your student.
As a SUNNI, my loyalty lies with the honour of the prophet muhammad. I defend his wife, his best friend and his enforcer. I am from the family of Aqeel ibn Abi Taalib and alhamdulilaah Allah has preserved myself and my blood from deviated ideologies that curse those mentioned in the Quran that Allah has become pleased with. I beleive the Mahdi will guide the sincere from every path of life and the stubborn will reject him.
I AM A MUSL8M AND I FOLLOW THE SUNNAH OF SAYADNA MOHAMED PEACE AND BLESSINGS BE UPON HIM. ANY 1 WHO CLAIMS SUNNI OR SHIA IS COMMITING SHIRK THERES ONLY 1 ISLAM . IN YOUR GRAVE WOE TO THOSE WHO DONT ANSWER ISLAM
@@HHH_3 I agree they need to fix themself first theirself and practice+surah al-khaf. I do hereby agree he is the only one "Guided One" so to make Ummah and fight Oppression
@@TheDragonshadow1231 Prophet Muhammad pbuh said when the false Messiah arrived you must go to mountains and recite surah kahf Now the point is what surah kahf said about that Look at that verses which openly says about dimension and sound wave technology who teleported the people of cave so is might gonna happen twice with this Ummah..
Original bukhari does not exist not even 1 paper exist written by imaam bukhari. Original text I am talking about. And even all thee books written 250 years later after the death of prophet Muhammad.
Sir with due respect its mention as imamahum or ameer (leader) of Muslim in the ahdith which you are reading... But it doesn't mean that its imam mahdi.. The word mahdi is not mentioned in Arabic matan... You are assuming that its imam mahdi... I think this is misinterpretation
Interestingly there is no mention of the Mahdi in the Qur'an, nor in the two most highly regarded books of the Sunnis, Nothing in Bukhari or Muslim. Recently a Sunni scholar from Iraq, Dr. Bashar Awad Maarouf he challenged the entire Sunni ulemah just to give him one narration on the coming of the Mahdi that has no problems with its chain. Look him up, Dr. Bashar Award Maarouf.
Sahih Muslim Book 41, Hadith 6961 Abu Nadra reported: "We were in the company of Jabir b. 'Abdullah that he said it may happen that the people of Iraq may not send their qafiz and dirhams (their measures of food stuff and their money). We said: Who would be responsible for it? He said: The non-Arabs would prevent them. He again said: There is the possibility that the people of Syria may not send their dinars and mudds. We said: Who would be responsible for it? He said this prevention would be made by the Romans. He (Jabir b. Abdullah) kept quiet for a while and then reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) having said there would be a caliph in the last (period) of my Ummah who would freely give handfuls of wealth to the people without counting it. I said to Abu Nadra and Abu al-'Ala: Do you mean 'Umar b. 'Abd al-Aziz? They said: No (he would be Imam Mahdi). sunnah.com/muslim:2913a
@@prep4imammahdi notice that this is not a staement of the Prophet (saw) And seeing thia is thr only thing you can bring from bukhari or muslim shows its weakness.
There are lot of things which are not mentioned in quran (not directly) that doesn't mean its not there... Simple example is circumcision done for every Muslim male ?? Not three Quran say aqimis Salah thats all When, how and all other explanation is in hadees... Without hadees u can't understand quran also properly.. Lot of prophets name only is not mentioned in Quran..
“His name is similar to my name” does not mean his name is Muhammed. If this was the case the prophet pbuh would have explicitly said that his name will be Muhammad ibn Abdullah. Which he did not. Therefore it cannot be confirmed that the mahdis name is Muhammad ibn Abdullah. This is a fabrication and nothing more than conjecture which has been passed down from scholar to scholar without actual contemplation on the Hadith
My proof is the Hadith itself. Where does it say Muhammad ibn Abdullah? It doesn’t. “yuatuhu ismu isme” which translates to his name is compatible with my name or his name is similar to my name. Not his name is exactly my name. The key word is yuatuhu which most people skip over completely.
Let's assume the Prophet (S) meant compatible or similar. We cannot unequivocally reject that Imam Mahdi's [AJ] name is Muhammad. Also, here is a hadith in Sunan Abi Dawud (book 37 Hadith #4267) which has been graded Hasan Sahih. You are more than welcome to contact the English translators and ask them about this narration where they use "same as mine" Narrated Abdullah ibn Mas'ud: The Prophet (ﷺ) said: If only one day of this world remained. Allah would lengthen that day (according to the version of Za'idah), till He raised up in it a man who belongs to me or to my family whose father's name is the same as my father's, who will fill the earth with equity and justice as it has been filled with oppression and tyranny (according to the version of Fitr). Sufyan's version says: The world will not pass away before the Arabs are ruled by a man of my family whose name will be the same as mine.
I respectfully agree with you in that we cannot rule out that the name may be Muhammad. But I believe that it should go both ways in that we cannot say that it is or it isn’t. Allah knows best. The question that I wanted to raise is why were the prophet’s (pbuh) words implicit rather than explicit for something simple like a name. There seems to be something veiled by his choice of wording because logically it would have been very easy for him to say his name is Muhammad ibn Abdullah.
InshaAllah when Imam Mahdi [AJ] reappears, everything will be clarified. I think the most important thing we need to do is to prepare ourselves (first) and our communities towards establishing justice and equity.
![Story of Ali ibn Mahziyar Meeting Imam Mahdi [AJ] | Sayed Mahdi al Modarresi](/img/1.gif)
Dr. Sayed, I'm sunni and I'm sick of sectarian divide and animosity - we're all ummah of Prophet Muhammad SAW.
Dr. Sayed Moustafa al Qazwini is highlighting these narrations from Sunni books not to create tension or divide but rather to unite people over the belief in Imam Mahdi [AJ]. As Muslims we have so much more in common than differences but we focus on the differences. May Allah bless you.
Alhamdiallah
@@prep4imammahdi Unfortunately, it is human nature and ignorance to divide. Insha Allah we push together as one umma
@@prep4imammahdisudi princ salman is Ebu leheb....
Dont worry, Like the splitting of the moon in the time of Prophet s.a.w. The ummah will unite with the arrival of Mehdi a.s.
Allah is the best of planners
I love prophet muhammed (sawas) and his ahlalbayt (as)!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Hopefully he comes inshallah and unites the whole ummah.
Ya Allah, guide the ummah to the right path and prepare them for the end times. Ameen.
As salam alaikum to the Imam of my era
The sunni and shia are all the ummah of the prophet alayhi salam. We should look beyond the age old political establishments that created divide between the two
Thank you for your comment. The purpose of this video is to show that we have many things in common including the belief in Imam Mahdi [AJ]
@@prep4imammahdi many things? We are 1 Ummah. Alhamdulilah.
faith cannot be compared to politics. but those who do not have true faith in their heart are recognized in their heart, and in their speech.. and no matter how much you search in history, you will not find it. when people don't have iman they hsr a thousand excuses for their split. so neither Sunni nor Shia will ever have true Faith.. when someone asks a Muslim, are you Muslim, answer yes, I am Sunni or Shia. if you are a Muslim you belong to a book Quran .. if you belong to the Quran you are Islam .. and not Sunni or Shia .. but as God says the devil is your sworn enemy. and When the Prophet Muhammed A S changed his life .. then the devil came in between the believers, and the devil succeeds in taking the shirt off Ali .. by giving the other caliphates. The word imam means wisdom .. therefore the chosen one is guided and taught with the wisdom of God . and that is only 1 of 4 gifts God gave him.
Subhan’Allah! Masha’Allah!
TabarakAllah! Alhamdulillah!
Wa Lillahil hamd! La ilaha illallah!
La ilaha illallah! La ilaha illallah!
Allahu Akbar!
May Allah reward you sayed !
Yaa mahdi
I’m so impatient
The face of Mehdi shall shine upon the surface of the Moon.
- Imam Ja’far al-Sadiq
IMAM MEHDI SEYYEDANA RA RIAZ GOHAR SHAHI (as) face shines on the moon 🌙
#alratv
youtube.com/@ALRATV?si=P04VTgwzcxjznB82
#ifollowgoharshahi #imammehdigoharshahi #imammehdi #امام #امام_حسین #امام_زمان #امام_مهدی
May Allah unite our hearts! Ameen
JazakAllah
Dr. Moustafa, Yes, Sunni, and even Salafi school all believes in the birth of Al Mahdi in end times. But the Mahdi of Ahle Sunah or of the Salaf differs vastly from the school that your represent i.e. Twelver Shīʿism. Hope once the Mahdi comes all will recognize him despite vast difference about each of these schools belief about him.
Now a fundamental question arises where in ahlul sunnah does it say clearly the Mahdi is not born yet because in shia literature it clearly says he is Already born??
Thank you for your comment. Despite having differences in the belief of his current existence, it is vital that all of us Muslims unite on the belief that he is the Imam who will establish peace and justice throughout the world and as Muslims, we all have a responsibility towards working for this cause which is the cause of Allah. When Allah sees how dedicated we are to reform ourselves and our societies InshaAllah He will bless us with his reappearance.
This is a good question - I think one of the arguments is the narration that states that Allah will raise him in a single night. However, in our school of thought this is considered the time of Qiyam where Allah gives permission to the Imam [AJ] to rise which will be in Masjid al Haram. Additionally, Imam Mahdi [AJ] cannot be a "regular", pious individual who will be endowed by Allah in one night to spread peace and justice across the world. Furthermore, in both Sunni and Shia hadiths it is established that when Nabi Isa [AS] descends from the heavens at the time of prayer, Imam Mahdi [AJ] will ask him to lead. Nabi Isa [AS] then puts his hand on Imam Mahdi's [AJ] shoulder and says (I am paraphrasing) that he has a greater right [to lead this prayer]. Nabi Isa [AS] is one of the 5 Ulul Azm Prophets that has a very high status. The fact that Imam Mahdi [AJ] will be leading a universal messenger in prayer is a very important point about the status of Imam Mahdi [AJ].
@@prep4imammahdi Thank you for your response. Most schools within the house of Islam agrees, Al Mahdi will appear and establish peace and justice. Details of him and his action varies from school to school. If anyone wants to concentrate on differences then sky is the limit. End of the day as long as individuals adhere to fundamental teachings of Islam, all are BROTHERS/SISTERS in faith and part of the same Ummah. Focus of all should be to see the bigger picture instead of arguing over peanuts. Out of 8.5 billion people in the world today, over 6.5 billion are NOT Muslim. Focus should be to spread the message of Monotheism to them and enlighten and free them from eternal darkness and hell fire.
May Allah bless you
Dr.sayed,I am happy after going through your lectures,till now I know only Dr.Shiekh imron Nazar hosein (the only Islamic eschologist),I am his student, Alhamdulillah.Now I want to listen to you also.Please accept me your student.
Unite o sunni and o shia. For the sake of the ummah, the palestinians.
As a SUNNI, my loyalty lies with the honour of the prophet muhammad. I defend his wife, his best friend and his enforcer. I am from the family of Aqeel ibn Abi Taalib and alhamdulilaah Allah has preserved myself and my blood from deviated ideologies that curse those mentioned in the Quran that Allah has become pleased with. I beleive the Mahdi will guide the sincere from every path of life and the stubborn will reject him.
I AM A MUSL8M AND I FOLLOW THE SUNNAH OF SAYADNA MOHAMED PEACE AND BLESSINGS BE UPON HIM. ANY 1 WHO CLAIMS SUNNI OR SHIA IS COMMITING SHIRK THERES ONLY 1 ISLAM . IN YOUR GRAVE WOE TO THOSE WHO DONT ANSWER ISLAM
Inshallah imam mahdi will get rid of sectarianism in islam because he is just Muslim not shia nor sunni
He will no doubt insha Allah
We need Saviour..
That's the problem. You can't help yourself and relying on someone to save you.
@@HHH_3 yes we need relying on Al Qaim
Because he's the only one who can make one Ummah
@@HHH_3 I agree they need to fix themself first theirself and practice+surah al-khaf. I do hereby agree he is the only one "Guided One" so to make Ummah and fight Oppression
@@Adam_legacy-eternal True but practice ownself first with surah al-khaf and others
@@TheDragonshadow1231 Prophet Muhammad pbuh said when the false Messiah arrived you must go to mountains and recite surah kahf
Now the point is what surah kahf said about that
Look at that verses which openly says about dimension and sound wave technology who teleported the people of cave so is might gonna happen twice with this Ummah..
My Dear Brother we all Ummmmh of Our Prophet Salallahu we Sunni don't contest to this.only Wahabis have a problem.
Original bukhari does not exist not even 1 paper exist written by imaam bukhari.
Original text I am talking about.
And even all thee books written 250 years later after the death of prophet Muhammad.
Mahdi is united by sunni & Shiaa
Sir with due respect its mention as imamahum or ameer (leader) of Muslim in the ahdith which you are reading...
But it doesn't mean that its imam mahdi..
The word mahdi is not mentioned in Arabic matan...
You are assuming that its imam mahdi...
I think this is misinterpretation
Why you take only want you want to ?
Take all or leave it all
The world is not black and white. Neither in the Shia books of hadith are the narrations 100% authentic nor in the Sunni books of hadith.
May the glorious Allah Rabbul Izza be pleased with the Holy beloved Prophet Muhammad ( S.A.W ).
Yea 12 khalifah from quraysh
Interestingly there is no mention of the Mahdi in the Qur'an, nor in the two most highly regarded books of the Sunnis, Nothing in Bukhari or Muslim. Recently a Sunni scholar from Iraq, Dr. Bashar Awad Maarouf he challenged the entire Sunni ulemah just to give him one narration on the coming of the Mahdi that has no problems with its chain. Look him up, Dr. Bashar Award Maarouf.
Sahih Muslim Book 41, Hadith 6961
Abu Nadra reported:
"We were in the company of Jabir b. 'Abdullah that he said it may happen that the people of Iraq may not send their qafiz and dirhams (their measures of food stuff and their money). We said: Who would be responsible for it? He said: The non-Arabs would prevent them. He again said: There is the possibility that the people of Syria may not send their dinars and mudds. We said: Who would be responsible for it? He said this prevention would be made by the Romans. He (Jabir b. Abdullah) kept quiet for a while and then reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) having said there would be a caliph in the last (period) of my Ummah who would freely give handfuls of wealth to the people without counting it. I said to Abu Nadra and Abu al-'Ala: Do you mean 'Umar b. 'Abd al-Aziz? They said: No (he would be Imam Mahdi).
sunnah.com/muslim:2913a
Additionally, there are many verses in the Qur'an that allude to the coming of Imam Mahdi [AJ]. Please do your research.
@@prep4imammahdi notice that this is not a staement of the Prophet (saw)
And seeing thia is thr only thing you can bring from bukhari or muslim shows its weakness.
@@prep4imammahdi an allusion and a crystal clear text are vastly different.
There are lot of things which are not mentioned in quran (not directly) that doesn't mean its not there...
Simple example is circumcision done for every Muslim male ?? Not three
Quran say aqimis Salah thats all
When, how and all other explanation is in hadees...
Without hadees u can't understand quran also properly..
Lot of prophets name only is not mentioned in Quran..
“His name is similar to my name” does not mean his name is Muhammed. If this was the case the prophet pbuh would have explicitly said that his name will be Muhammad ibn Abdullah. Which he did not. Therefore it cannot be confirmed that the mahdis name is Muhammad ibn Abdullah. This is a fabrication and nothing more than conjecture which has been passed down from scholar to scholar without actual contemplation on the Hadith
What is your proof for the argument you are putting forth?
My proof is the Hadith itself. Where does it say Muhammad ibn Abdullah? It doesn’t. “yuatuhu ismu isme” which translates to his name is compatible with my name or his name is similar to my name. Not his name is exactly my name. The key word is yuatuhu which most people skip over completely.
Let's assume the Prophet (S) meant compatible or similar. We cannot unequivocally reject that Imam Mahdi's [AJ] name is Muhammad.
Also, here is a hadith in Sunan Abi Dawud (book 37 Hadith #4267) which has been graded Hasan Sahih. You are more than welcome to contact the English translators and ask them about this narration where they use "same as mine"
Narrated Abdullah ibn Mas'ud:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: If only one day of this world remained. Allah would lengthen that day (according to the version of Za'idah), till He raised up in it a man who belongs to me or to my family whose father's name is the same as my father's, who will fill the earth with equity and justice as it has been filled with oppression and tyranny (according to the version of Fitr). Sufyan's version says: The world will not pass away before the Arabs are ruled by a man of my family whose name will be the same as mine.
I respectfully agree with you in that we cannot rule out that the name may be Muhammad. But I believe that it should go both ways in that we cannot say that it is or it isn’t. Allah knows best.
The question that I wanted to raise is why were the prophet’s (pbuh) words implicit rather than explicit for something simple like a name. There seems to be something veiled by his choice of wording because logically it would have been very easy for him to say his name is Muhammad ibn Abdullah.
InshaAllah when Imam Mahdi [AJ] reappears, everything will be clarified. I think the most important thing we need to do is to prepare ourselves (first) and our communities towards establishing justice and equity.