The Dark Side of "Opus Dei"

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 янв 2025

Комментарии • 83

  • @monicadevine3668
    @monicadevine3668 9 месяцев назад +5

    so many errors, including pronunciation ones, I don't know where to start. Tries to be a hit piece but leaves me more sure of my vocation than ever lol

  • @paulkiernan3256
    @paulkiernan3256 Год назад +3

    Associats like numeraries do not get married (stay single for God) but they do not live in centers of Opus Dea but in their own homes. Very good ordinary people who want to be dedicated lay catholics are members.

  • @rudya.hernandez7238
    @rudya.hernandez7238 Год назад +8

    Making people feel unique and important... how dare they?

  • @gregsterc5294
    @gregsterc5294 Год назад +8

    If you have the honesty to meet some people in Opus Dei and get to know them, you will find out that they are not secretive at all. They are not monks or nuns, but ordinary people in the middle of the world who are seeking to follow Christ closely. This is done through ordinary life and ordinary work. Very simple, not sinister at all.

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад

      I wish I have my man

    • @coingalleon
      @coingalleon 11 месяцев назад

      well some are. Remember that violent albino dude? I am talking about that documentary they made about Opus Dei a while back; I think it is called The Davinci Code"

    • @HalasterBlackCloak-u2w
      @HalasterBlackCloak-u2w 3 месяца назад

      Thats not true. They are the continuance of the inquisition. They are working with heritage in the us to try to ban contraception.

    • @technoshaman101
      @technoshaman101 3 месяца назад

      ​@@coingalleon that wasn't a documentary it was a fictional work.
      That said there are many people who've supposedly been members of Opus Dei who've come out stating it is a dangerous cult.
      That said there is always the possibility that these people are lying. Still their views can't be entirely ignored, because we simply don't know for sure what the truth is, so all views have to be weighed. Many in Scientology claim that Scientology is completely friendly and benevolent, but I would argue it's foolish to ignore the many people who've left the COS claiming abuse.
      Also the person above who claims they aren't secretive may themselves be fooled, after all if they are secretive then they might not want you to know that they are keeping secrets.
      A book recently came out linking Opus Dei to attempting to control world politics, and to a currently existing slave trade. This may sound like a conspiracy theory, but I have to give it at least a modicum of credence seeing as how this wouldn't be the first time the Catholic Church has attempted to have as much political control as possible.

    • @Ashakat42
      @Ashakat42 3 месяца назад +1

      Tell that to the US Supreme Court and Leo

  • @eamonbreathnach4613
    @eamonbreathnach4613 Год назад +15

    NOTHING ABOUT WHAT Pope Francis is supposed to have said.
    Another misleading headline???

    • @GiftofChaosStudio
      @GiftofChaosStudio Год назад +3

      Of course not. He's trying to paint Opus Dei as some clandestine organization and that is far from what Opus Dei is. This guy has never experienced Opus Dei and it shows.

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад +1

      @@GiftofChaosStudio you are right,I've never experienced, but that can't stop me from speaking about it.
      Painting Opus Dei as a clandestine organisation is not the goal in the video,that's for sure. It is about the enigma that Opus Dei brings being different

    • @GiftofChaosStudio
      @GiftofChaosStudio Год назад +2

      @@HistoricalWhispersYT no, I can't stop you. However, you will encounter resistance when what you clqim is outlandish. You don't try to paint them as secretive and clandestine? Your entire video spoke about them keeping things from the Church. The back ground music sets the tone also. Using what I can only relate to X-files type suspense music, sets the tone of something sinister. Also a click bait title, never stating what the Holy Father possibly said, if anything at all, is sketchy too. You have a lot going on against your statement here.

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад +2

      @@GiftofChaosStudio because it is shrouded in mistery,it is not all clear about what they do and that is public info,you can search.
      The headline should be changed,I agree with you on this.
      Your POV is very clear, I accept it and I thank you so much cause you took action on what you believe.

    • @tony1685
      @tony1685 Год назад

      @@HistoricalWhispersYT catholicism is antichrist, friend.

  • @ebufi7957
    @ebufi7957 Год назад +4

    "...taking care of families and work...santification of work...make people feel unique and important...holiness in daily life ..." sounds good

  • @jotsonbey611
    @jotsonbey611 Год назад +1

    Why Roman Catholics practised such doctrine which is not found in the Holy Bible? It demonstrates that Roman Catholic denomination is not complete Christian.

  • @gregbraum7330
    @gregbraum7330 Год назад +5

    There is no secrecy at all with Opus Dei. Holiness in ordinary daily life.
    The confusion that exists among many laity is that the measure of holiness relates to how like a priest or religious one can become.
    What's got lost in the confusion is that marriage is a sacrament. If one is married, holiness lies in being a husband and father, being a wife and mother.
    There is no secrecy in Opus Dei, and the miracles of conversion to Christ are most encouraging. Scott Hahn, Kimberly Hahn, Jordan Peterson 's wife.

  • @jamesstuder5045
    @jamesstuder5045 Год назад +7

    Your AI reader mispronounces numerous words. Disconcerting.

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад +1

      The voice is 100% human,indeed the pronunciation is different but I can assure you there is no A.I. involved. Thank you so much for the feedback!!!

  • @SkaterGameplay
    @SkaterGameplay Год назад +3

    cool vid, keep it going

  • @AD50697
    @AD50697 Год назад +9

    Why is the narrator espousing such bizarre pronounciations of common words? Is it a robot or computer generated voice speaking? Whatever it is, it makes the video unwatchable. Why the deceptive title... given that there is absolutely no coverage given to Jorge Bergoglio's position on Opus Dei? Strong THUMBS DOWN for wasting people's time!

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад +1

      I assure you that the narrator is not a robot voice,this is his accent.
      I really thank you for the feedback 🙏 and for your thumbs down,it helps a lot.
      I hope on the next one you will come with the thumbs up

    • @SkaterGameplay
      @SkaterGameplay Год назад

      This video actually provides a lot of information you'd never understand.

    • @AD50697
      @AD50697 Год назад

      @@SkaterGameplay I don't understand your comment.

    • @edelmary1131
      @edelmary1131 Год назад

      yes I do not mind critiques as long as not grudging innuendos or misrepresentative sneering

  • @anonimo-um2ng
    @anonimo-um2ng Год назад +5

    My cousin was a playboy, he entered the opus dei and he quited that life and became a father of his 4 children and we are all proud of him. Any organization has flawed members but the balance is positie for many.

  • @carlosfigueiredo8193
    @carlosfigueiredo8193 Год назад +4

    Why do you link it to Pope Francis in the title? An attempt to denigrate him in the eyes of those who do not see the hollow content of the video as regards its title? Your future videos will have no place in my viewings.

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад

      I really accept your critics. It's not about the Pope himself,it's about what he represents, the Catholic Church, this is what the video is about. Hope you will reconsider about the future videos

    • @tony1685
      @tony1685 Год назад

      catholicism is antichrist, carlos - please study God's Word.

    • @DanielOliveiraCarvallho
      @DanielOliveiraCarvallho Год назад

      Click bait. Using pope missquote to promote unrelated videos

    • @albertjoseph9684
      @albertjoseph9684 Год назад

      True. This is not a good way. I will be not watching this channel

    • @HistoricalWhispersYT
      @HistoricalWhispersYT  Год назад

      @@albertjoseph9684 I have the feeling you do not appreciate the work I put on this channel

  • @sandystephen4506
    @sandystephen4506 8 месяцев назад +2

    This Group Is Very Very Controversial

  • @heinrafael
    @heinrafael Год назад +5

    we love Opus Dei

  • @sandystephen4506
    @sandystephen4506 8 месяцев назад

    I Was Co opreator InOpus Dei,They Are More Intrested In Personal lives

  • @KathleenOmolo
    @KathleenOmolo Год назад +1

    Get your facts right. You got the dates wrong about Associates. They do not get married. The founder was not canonised in 1992.
    Why should I believe what you say when you get wrong such simple facts that are available anywhere online?

  • @1234swingit
    @1234swingit 5 месяцев назад

    Pope Francis appreciates Opus Dei very much. Fact.

  • @juanpena405
    @juanpena405 Год назад +4

    Don’t let Francis destroy the good work of Opus Dei

    • @paulkiernan3256
      @paulkiernan3256 Год назад +1

      Did video have anything to day about pope ?

  • @billyfolse1316
    @billyfolse1316 Год назад +1

    Spain ish Conquest still exists

  • @petersclafani4370
    @petersclafani4370 Год назад +4

    An evil pop3 fear$ them.

  • @KRYSSHIA
    @KRYSSHIA Год назад

    Waiting for an applause?
    I don’t think is coming!

  • @chicomacdonald7843
    @chicomacdonald7843 2 месяца назад

    Many untruths in this presentation. Read ONLY the Vatican's explanation of Opus Dei.

  • @rosebonney211
    @rosebonney211 Год назад +1

    You ban, we ban You

    • @rosebonney211
      @rosebonney211 10 месяцев назад

      Thank goodness he is going to retire soon

  • @percycesar769
    @percycesar769 Год назад +1

    It appears that pope Francis does not like discipline.

  • @mrsuperger5429
    @mrsuperger5429 Год назад +4

    Catholic Nazis. Thank God for Martin Luther.

    • @geordiewishart1683
      @geordiewishart1683 Год назад +1

      Abraham Lincoln supposedly saw the hand of the papacy in agitating the American civil war.

    • @edelmary1131
      @edelmary1131 Год назад

      Martin Luther preached Faith alone whereas James 2:22-24 says "for a man is not saved by faith alone"

  • @domithompson5490
    @domithompson5490 11 месяцев назад

    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @janellthompson6498
    @janellthompson6498 8 месяцев назад

    Get your facts right next

  • @janellthompson6498
    @janellthompson6498 8 месяцев назад

    Get your facts right next time you have no idea of what you are saying ..all rubbish

  • @nicolaedomnariu5633
    @nicolaedomnariu5633 Год назад +1

    all these people are selfish.

  • @etiennenobel5028
    @etiennenobel5028 Год назад

    fascism

  • @etiennenobel5028
    @etiennenobel5028 Год назад +2

    . Catholic fascist.ism. Europe has certainly seen a lot of that in past centuries. Welcome back the inquisition .

    • @pmds4304
      @pmds4304 9 месяцев назад

      @historicalwhispersyt As you liked this comment, it’s clear what your views are on Opus Dei!