How The White Sox Were Ruined By The Braves ‘Strategy’

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 май 2024
  • Signup for Rival Fantasy today, and get $25 for FREE! @rivalfantasy
    play.rivalfantasy.com/join/pu...
    Thanks for watching! The Chicago White Sox are now one of baseballs biggest failures, but how did they fall?
    Purely Baseball Twitter / purelybaseball1
    #openingday2024 #mlb #documentary
    Title: How The White Sox Were Ruined By The Braves ‘Strategy’
    By: Purely Baseball
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 482

  • @alexstone4729
    @alexstone4729 Месяц назад +338

    How come so many of these small baseball channels literally create content that would be expected from huge and popular creators. Its so good and i love this guy

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +11

      Aye thanks brother! Appreciate you 💪🏻🔥

    • @bd1zzle
      @bd1zzle Месяц назад +1

      I try different videos and all but I like comedy and since Pujos left the angels to be in LA, queer, I’ve been off/on with baseball. Football is where I waste brain cells learning the news and all. I’ve slowly been getting back into baseball more the last 3 years. Seeing trout injured constantly or striking out then out of no where ohtani goes to LA and no more Asians at the game 😂😂😂

    • @JoeSaidWut
      @JoeSaidWut Месяц назад +1

      @alexstone4729 I didn't realize this video wasnt done by one of three creators that I am subscribed to, which is a big shout out to PurelyBaseball for hitting a homerun with this content.

    • @av7899
      @av7899 Месяц назад

      Baseball creators have the best content I don't even like the game or have history, but the level of production value from these guys is insane

    • @bd1zzle
      @bd1zzle Месяц назад

      @@av7899 😂😂😂 can careless about baseball or the players or history of the teams pretty much here for the show 👍 goes to prove to LA a great production team makes a difference in tv shows.

  • @Harrja
    @Harrja Месяц назад +158

    The common denominator between them and the Bulls is Jerry…

    • @xGamerinfox
      @xGamerinfox Месяц назад +13

      Yup. He got lucky with Jordan and literally caught lightning in a bottle in 05 with the Sox. Other than that they have been terrible.

  • @kylefunderburk4194
    @kylefunderburk4194 Месяц назад +70

    Teams are replicating the Braves when it comes to contracts, but they're not at all replicating the Braves when it comes to coaching and team management. Look at Travis D'Arnaud and Jesse Chavez, and now Jared Kelenic. Players get better when they join Atlanta. D'Arnoud cited a reunion with one of his formative coaches about a month ago, and Chavez's tendency to struggle everywhere except Atlanta is well documented. Manager Brian Snitker deserves praise as well. A good example was within the first 2 weeks of this season. The Braves got shafted with some obviously bad calls that prevented some early runs. Social media was abuzz, calling for Snitker to show more emotion, stand up for his guys and have it out with the umpire. Instead, Snitker stayed in the dugout. The Braves offense eventually exploded and the team won the game comfortably. That's not to say Snitker never stands up for his guys against bad officiating, but he picks his spots because he trusts his guys to overcome. His leadership as a manager is a big reason why the Braves have had the funniest-looking dugout in baseball over the last few years. In turn, many former Braves who only had a cup of coffee in Atlanta have made their love of the Braves organization well known.

    • @Arientis
      @Arientis Месяц назад +4

      Well said

    • @connorharvey3127
      @connorharvey3127 29 дней назад +4

      Kelenic has an OPS+ 30 points lower than last year lmao

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 25 дней назад +2

      @@connorharvey3127 He's also not playing as much as he did last year. Lmao. He's platooning with Adam Duvall. Lmao. Maybe check you the roster and the games.

    • @coltrueg
      @coltrueg 18 дней назад

      @@soulknife20 Statistically Kelenic is the same player as last year stop being salty for no reason.

  • @MeargleSchmeargle
    @MeargleSchmeargle Месяц назад +44

    It's not the fact that the Chisox tried the Braves strategy that caused their downfall, it was absolutely rotten execution. Tony La Russa is no Brian Snitker, Rick Hahn is most certainly no Alex Anthopolous, and most importantly, the Braves aren't saddled with a geriatric owner like Reinsdorf.
    A lot of people seem to take issue with the fact that the Braves are owned by Liberty Media since they themselves don't spend much on the Braves, but LM also doesn't really get tangled with team affairs. The ones in the organization with real power are Terry McGuirk and Alex Anthopolous, the baseball people.
    Alex in particular is an avid scouter, and knows exactly who he wants and when. Even when nobody else considers the moves he makes, he does his homework and gets the exact guy who will fit right in with the program.
    There's also Snitker and the coaching staff he's surrounded with. They're rock stars, and in Snitker's case, the players would do just about anything for him. He keeps the vibes immaculate and is a calm, stabilizing presence where La Russa was simply a lightning rod for controversy.
    Atlanta is known for having best in the business scouting, coaching, and a reputation for success. The Chisox don't come close in terms of approach. They may have attempted to emulate Atlanta's secret formula, but they simply don't have the right mindset as long as Reinsdorf is the one holding the reins of power.

    • @rolandomedina9773
      @rolandomedina9773 Месяц назад +1

      That is pretty dumb.
      Atlanta won only one championship since WHITE SOX rebuild.
      And it was at the same time.
      So no.
      WHITE SOX didn't try to copy Braves strategy.
      In the 90's both were good teams as well.
      But remember the Braves won in like 1957 or 56 but not in Atlanta.
      In Milwaukee.
      So it's not a fact.
      It was happening at the same time.
      Reason I say it was a curse.
      It's about karma.

    • @rolandomedina9773
      @rolandomedina9773 Месяц назад +1

      Let me add.
      Atlanta may be good .
      But not great
      Atlanta doesn't have another MLB team in the same City nor State.
      And yes like AA in Atlanta.

    • @briansolo
      @briansolo Месяц назад +4

      @@rolandomedina9773 what does that have to do with anything?

    • @briansolo
      @briansolo Месяц назад +7

      @@rolandomedina9773 what? The Braves 2021 championship still happened. Is the same team expected to win the WS every year? The Braves have won 6 straight division titles. Furthermore, Atlanta won a World Series in 1995.. in Atlanta.

    • @fullcircle8231
      @fullcircle8231 Месяц назад +6

      @rolandomedina9773 Atlanta is one of the best teams in MLB... of the last 30 years💀. To say they're "good not great" just tells us all that you're either being disingenuous due to a bias perhaps, or you're just plain ignorant.

  • @devinmorrison2993
    @devinmorrison2993 Месяц назад +79

    Rick Renteria deserved to see out that rebuild. I swear they would only play for him.

    • @atm1919
      @atm1919 Месяц назад +8

      Rick got the shaft by the soxs and the cubs

    • @cmkelly842
      @cmkelly842 26 дней назад +4

      This was Rick’s team not Tony’s and that move alone is why the team completely collapsed

    • @GuyrillaBraun
      @GuyrillaBraun 26 дней назад +1

      It's crazy how big of an impact a this man had on 2 rebuilding franchises in the same city.

  • @thatguy27988
    @thatguy27988 Месяц назад +66

    Somehow failed to mention the biggest culprit in this equation Jerry Reinsdorf

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +18

      He was mentioned in the La Russa situation. Completely his fault

    • @aidenawe9359
      @aidenawe9359 Месяц назад +9

      @@PurelyBaseballYTyour absolutely right. Rick Hahn didn’t want TLR. I think he wanted AJ Hinch at the time.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +5

      @@aidenawe9359 Yep. He wanted Hinch or Cora

    • @dark_knight_3304
      @dark_knight_3304 Месяц назад +1

      @@PurelyBaseballYTtwo cheater wouldn’t have made this franchise any better Tony wasn’t the problem the problem was no player development in the minor leads to player relying on pure talent now the clown in charge of player development at the time is now in charge of the team

    • @nochey78
      @nochey78 Месяц назад

      @@dark_knight_3304it doesn’t matter… a Hinch or Cora hire would’ve still made more sense than hiring an absolute Relic who hadn’t been in a dugout in almost a decade..
      The game passed Tony LaRussa by… and it showed.
      His hire contributed to the White Sox problems.
      But the REAL PROBLEM with this organization is the relic at the very top..

  • @platinumspike9578
    @platinumspike9578 Месяц назад +35

    The similarities between the 2020-2022 White Sox to this years Red Sox organization is chilling to say the least. Signing young players early into their careers, front office not building on a solid core, injuries and inconsistency wracking the team; this could spell another Sox disaster. Hopefully the front office will learn from the mistakes of Chicago (Garrett Cooper and Dom Smith are a good start) and pull themselves out of the free fall they’re in.

    • @llee8825
      @llee8825 Месяц назад +5

      The Red Sox in their worst season will always be 100x better than the White Sox's poverty organization. 😂 The White Sox are doomed by an incompetent, senile, arrogant owner named Jerry Reinsdorf who has lived too long.

    • @nochey78
      @nochey78 Месяц назад +4

      @@llee8825 as a white Sox fan…..I CONCUR!!!!

    • @MustacheDLuffy
      @MustacheDLuffy Месяц назад

      Isn’t Garrett copper below the Mendoza line?

    • @warlordofbritannia
      @warlordofbritannia Месяц назад +1

      Except the Red Sox haven’t deluded themselves into thinking they’re currently contenders. The White Sox also had the same front office for nearly 25 years (and thus same problems), while the Sox have become instable yet nonetheless cycle highly regarded executives throughout the organization.

  • @ethanhybl7807
    @ethanhybl7807 Месяц назад +32

    Great video but you also failed to mention the that the Braves had several all star level vets on the roster and almost every year bring in a vet for a year or so to help the team. The Braves clubhouse vibe/chemistry is immaculate. Keeping Jesse Chavez, and Charlie Morton shows out important good guys on the team is. The on the field performance is a plus.

    • @willpina
      @willpina Месяц назад +3

      Markakis was also an important part of the Braves rebuild

    • @pooloftim8263
      @pooloftim8263 Месяц назад +5

      lol they get rid of Jesse Chavez every offseason, only to get him back within a few months…same with Duvall.

    • @christianlw5252
      @christianlw5252 Месяц назад +2

      Don't forget management. Snicker has been in the Braves organization for like 37 years. So the management has bought into the vision and so have the players.

  • @CrashPK77
    @CrashPK77 Месяц назад +9

    Couple quick notes: Yermin was not a "star". After he unretired, he got a shot with the Giants and couldn't cut it even as a DH, let alone at catcher.
    Also, Vaughnie isn't an OF; he's a 1B. They stuck him in RF because they had no one else out there, and had Jose Abreu still at 1B.

    • @ianhacek6002
      @ianhacek6002 Месяц назад +5

      Yeah as a Sox fan, the Yermin part was the worst minute of the video. No way we still have fans crying on his behalf

  • @truthteller4442
    @truthteller4442 Месяц назад +11

    I actually think if Hahn was allowed to be a full GM with complete operational control, he would’ve done great things.
    He did some very good things and had some great ideas.
    Unfortunately, numbnuts Kenny Williams was the President of the White Sox at that time and he still had control.
    Also, Reinsdorf if notoriously cheap and didn’t allow him to go out and get certain pieces he needed.
    The White Sox are a horribly run organization from top to bottom.
    Also, Tony La Russa gets a lot of crap, but he was the least of their problems. He was right about Yermin Mercedes, and Mercedes is an idiot.
    You don’t show up your opponents, because that team will eventually throw a 95mph baseball at your head.

    • @aidenawe9359
      @aidenawe9359 Месяц назад +1

      Jerry is cheap but not notorious cheap. I agree with the poorly run organization and your statement about Rick Hahn.

    • @bochafish
      @bochafish Месяц назад +1

      Excellent comment. I would agree with Jerry being cheap. We missed on Soriano, a couple others, and more recently Machado. We were severely outbid every time we've gone for a big free agent. And man, Robin Ventura, LaRussa, Grifol.. Jerry picks the worse managers at the worse times.

  • @BakedSports
    @BakedSports Месяц назад +22

    Rebuilding them in mlb been tough

  • @estebangonzalez4875
    @estebangonzalez4875 Месяц назад +5

    so it was Larussa's fault but they manage to win 93 games and then he left they do not win more than 70 and it 'was too late'. I think Tony is taking more heat than he should

    • @CaptainKnight22
      @CaptainKnight22 27 дней назад +2

      The thing is that core that won 93 games should’ve won more. Not just in the regular season but MOST importantly the playoffs. The only reason I was somewhat okay with the hire at the time was because the assumption was it was a hire for the playoffs since the team was going to win games no matter who was managing. We went on to get mollywhopped by the Astros and the rest is history

  • @GuyrillaBraun
    @GuyrillaBraun 26 дней назад +2

    Can't devolep players while they're sitting in the trainers room with injury after injury. As someone who has watched the Sox for 30 years, they tend to always have one huge problem when it comes to prospects in the minors. They all play the same position, Sheets, Burger, and Vaughn are all 1B/DH players. They had this problem in the late 90's/early 2000's when every prospect was a corner outfielder, or the mid 2000's when everyone played 2nd or Short.
    And they're never able to correctly leverage that depth in trades, and end up trading from thin positions like trading 2nd baseman Nick Madrigal to the Cubs for Kimbrel when we already had signed Hendriks. (I know Madrigal was hurt at the time of the trade, so maybe not the best example.)
    I don't think the execution of extending players was bad either, 6yr/$43M for Eloy is not a ton of money.
    We were a team that was loaded with talent and had a lot of things going right.
    Unfortunately, our owner is Jerry Reinsdorf, who is extremely loyal to relics of the past and feels the need to hire his old friends for prominent positions.
    Yermin wasn't a "star player", but he was playing like a star for us, and he had his confidence shattered and was publicly called out and admonished by the person on the team whose job is to look out for his players and back his players. LaRussa was ill-fit to manage a team in the year 2021, and showed often that he didn't understand baseball or the players who played the game any more.
    The Sox as a franchise fumbled the bag a few times in this stretch, but it was all being fumbled away daily by the dinosaur owner and the dinosaur manager.
    Also somebody should go see if anyone on the Sox training staff has a medical license, because they gotta be doing something wrong with those players.

  • @Extinguisher10
    @Extinguisher10 Месяц назад +4

    Tony La Russa was an amazing manager, but those days ended before he arrived with the White Sox

  • @Dodgers-sw2uk
    @Dodgers-sw2uk Месяц назад +2

    The difference was player development. The White Sox traded for their top farm they didn’t develop them. While the Braves and Dodgers both developed their talent. And because of that the Braves and Dodgers have had top farms for a 10 year stretch. One great batch of prospects isn’t enough to build what the Braves or Astros built, you need at least 2 and most likely 3 really good batches back to back to back

  • @Lazystu376
    @Lazystu376 25 дней назад +2

    This is a good video but the Braves strategy didn’t ruin the White Sox at all. It was ownership and management (or mismanagement). Some guys who should’ve been good also just pooped the bed (some SP and offense) , and I mean that’s probably due to the coaching staff in place. So I mean I think that them signing all of those promising young players to 5,6 year extensions for nothing was a good idea… they just didn’t execute with coaching, which comes back to ownership because letting Hahn choose a coach probably would’ve been a lot better than what they did.

  • @mr.benchwarmer
    @mr.benchwarmer Месяц назад

    Amazing video. So much work went into this & its incredible 🙌🏻

  • @siberian13
    @siberian13 24 дня назад +2

    Part of the problem is their core players like Kopech, Anderson, Moncada, Himenez, and Robert, could never stay healthy. On paper their batting lineup should have been a murders row. Instead, they’re all constantly injured and constantly missing games.

  • @tristonwebb7045
    @tristonwebb7045 Месяц назад +9

    9:21 a Braves team without injured Acuna, and injured and short staffed starting pitching etc. part of the braves success has been the constant depth and ability to get production out of a new or couple young guys each season when needed

    • @fallen4life080
      @fallen4life080 Месяц назад +3

      Injuries destroyed the Sox rebuild, they could never rely on anyone. Robert and Moncada and until recently Eloy were out AGAIN. When they come back theyre still going to need to adjust.

    • @horsemeattball
      @horsemeattball Месяц назад

      The Braves have very few critical injuries. If you believe the crap they sell on ESPN, its because they have special training that keeps players in the game. Longtime fans know better. The Braves use all kind of pills to maintain that. It's no secret among the people playing the game.

    • @jesusmanueltiradovazquez9514
      @jesusmanueltiradovazquez9514 29 дней назад

      They never invested in the team...what can you expect

    • @fallen4life080
      @fallen4life080 28 дней назад

      @@jesusmanueltiradovazquez9514 The Orioles haven't really invested in their team either other than signing Corbin Burns to 15 million. Yet they're one of the best teams in the majors. They acquired a lot of their prospects either through trades and a handful of them through drafts, but nonetheless, they did 80% of the same thing we did. The difference is, injuries.

    • @jesusmanueltiradovazquez9514
      @jesusmanueltiradovazquez9514 28 дней назад

      @@fallen4life080 true but the orioles didnt go crazy giving away they players they have kept their core..they developed them..THE sox went crazy giving away everybody

  • @tampadave13
    @tampadave13 29 дней назад +2

    I love how Yankees fans are pointing out how backwards Tony LaRusso is.

  • @Geoff_24
    @Geoff_24 14 дней назад +1

    I still have my doubts on Hinch being able to properly be in charge of the clubhouse and be a leader etc as a Tiger fan, but I still can't believe they hired LaRussa when someone like Hinch was out there. The Sox looked like the next Astros with so much young talent. It made zero sense.

  • @geraldZ07
    @geraldZ07 Месяц назад +4

    The only thing I remember from the previous White Sox season was "Down goes Anderson" speaks to how almost nothing can be salvaged from that poor campaign.
    At this decadent pace of the White Sox, I wouldn't be surprised if they finish the same or worse than Oakland, and the latter is currently third in its division, something very surprising.

    • @youwereprettylasttimeisawy1227
      @youwereprettylasttimeisawy1227 Месяц назад +2

      oakland is one solid run from being a .500 team, the sox have no chance of being better than them this season

    • @geraldZ07
      @geraldZ07 Месяц назад +3

      @@youwereprettylasttimeisawy1227 I agree, Oakland is hanging around aspiring to a .500 season. I'll be honest, I'd like to see them in the postseason, but that's being pretentious 😅

  • @robertlindey2538
    @robertlindey2538 21 день назад +1

    Footnote: The 2020 MLB regular season was shortened because of the Covid restrictions. Meanwhile, the playoffs were expanded to 16 MLB teams (8 in each league). So that season, more MLB teams MADE the playoffs than those that MISSED. The LA Dodgers won the World Series that postseason, but many of their players consider that a "door prize" and want to win the league championship with a FULL season.
    Also, swinging on a 3-ball 0-strike count should always acceptable. Does the NFL have an "unwritten rule" stating that it's "poor sportsmanship" to run on fourth-and-one in front of their opponents' goal line. Would it be better sportsmanship if the QB passes the ball, so the opposing team could have a "fair chance?"

  • @griffinhays2053
    @griffinhays2053 26 дней назад +1

    The biggest difference between the Braves and White Sox in this period was that the Braves have known when something isn't working and where to pivot instead, and not entirely leaning on the homegrown guys to get them over the hump

  • @RafaelSale
    @RafaelSale 18 дней назад +1

    Jerry has been ruining the White Sox for years, even with their playoff seasons of 2020 and 2021.

  • @Mamss_
    @Mamss_ Месяц назад +3

    Rick Hahn actually started this strategy before AA. Dating back to Salle and Quintana

  • @doseofreality100
    @doseofreality100 Месяц назад +6

    The white Sox have been signing their young talent before they hit their arb years for years. It's been a part or reinsdorf's repertoire for as long as I can remember...... because he's cheap. I'd say it's more like the Braves copied the White Sox plan..... but were actually successful in doing so.

    • @danielgarcia8456
      @danielgarcia8456 Месяц назад +4

      This is exactly correct. Signing early extensions was the one great thing Hahn was good at. Started in 2013 with Sale, then Quintana, Eaton and TA. Sale, Quintana and Eaton’s contracts were the exact reasons their asking prices were inflated. Really weird to start the video with the trade and not mention the history.
      Ultimately the Sox failed because Jerry forced Hahn to hire Tony, left right field and second base holes for the entirety of the rebuild, and absolutely refused to act like a big market team during some really good free agent classes.

  • @Cindoreye
    @Cindoreye 27 дней назад +1

    Tony La Russa failed as a manager on many levels, but if the manager tells you to take the pitch, you take the pitch. It has nothing to do with sportsmanship. Maybe that's why La Russa made the call, but why is irrelevant to the hitter.

  • @jonathanward1263
    @jonathanward1263 Месяц назад +3

    Not only are teams trying to mimmick the Braves strategy, but now everyone is trying to build a year long complex like they did..

  • @lanceweaver4830
    @lanceweaver4830 Месяц назад +3

    As long as Jerry owns the team none of this will change.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +2

      Complete agree. One of the worst owners in sports

  • @ZZSmithReal
    @ZZSmithReal Месяц назад +4

    The Braves winning strategy is to be in a division with the Mets, Marlins and Phillies. The New England Patriots used a similar strategy for years.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад

      No Patriot hate here 🙏

    • @jaylong4705
      @jaylong4705 28 дней назад

      As a Mets and Jets fan, this dude is correct.

    • @HappyTrillmore
      @HappyTrillmore 28 дней назад +3

      Phillies are 100% better than your favorite team

    • @Arobert1673
      @Arobert1673 27 дней назад

      @@HappyTrillmore Phillies are excellent. No clue why he picked the Phillies over the Nats for his example.

    • @soulknife20
      @soulknife20 25 дней назад +2

      Every division has their bad teams. Also, the Nats won a world series a few seasons ago, the Mets made the playoffs in 2022, Marlins last season and have two world series wins.

  • @SoraMatt
    @SoraMatt Месяц назад +5

    You might as well be talking about the 2024 Toronto Blue Jays at this rate. The parallels are uncanny. Not necessarily in signing players but in terms of illogical management and running back the same team as last year and having the same problems but worse.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад

      Super true.

    • @aidenawe9359
      @aidenawe9359 Месяц назад +1

      Your not wrong. Could also say the same for the Marlins

    • @TheWizardous
      @TheWizardous Месяц назад

      @@PurelyBaseballYTCan you do a video on regressing teams this year? That would be interesting.

    • @colesmith7754
      @colesmith7754 Месяц назад

      I was thinking the same thing while watching this.

  • @marshallshelton6262
    @marshallshelton6262 Месяц назад +6

    I like the video but the pollen filter is mentally messing with my algeries.

  • @gabrielstafford5174
    @gabrielstafford5174 Месяц назад +5

    The White Sox have the most dysfunctional clubhouse culture this year too. They say the stretching and the BP as optional.

    • @Detrison318
      @Detrison318 Месяц назад

      In the bigs everything is specialized, what works for one player doesn't work for another. At that point they are adults who needs to find out what works for them and what doesn't, those who find out what it is and are successful, stay in the league. Also if you look at other teams iternary, you'll find the same stuff

    • @aidenawe9359
      @aidenawe9359 Месяц назад +1

      Despite their terrible record, clubhouse as been mostly positive this season.

    • @gabrielstafford5174
      @gabrielstafford5174 Месяц назад

      @@aidenawe9359 last year, they let their relievers sleep in the pen.

    • @aidenawe9359
      @aidenawe9359 Месяц назад

      @@gabrielstafford5174those were rumors flying around.

  • @CJinsoo
    @CJinsoo Месяц назад +1

    i haven’t followed baseball closely in a while. only last year di I learn about the dh in both leagues. Tony Larusa was hired as manager? that’s insane.

  • @SportDawgs
    @SportDawgs 23 дня назад +1

    White sox never really spent in those offseasons either. They literally signed adam eaton over pederson and brantley in 2021 and signed harrison and andrus

  • @TTony-tu6dm
    @TTony-tu6dm 7 дней назад

    I’ve watched baseball for 55 years, and I only heard of the 3-0 swing being “poor sportsmanship” in a lopsided game. Swinging at a 3-0 pitch was considered bad hitting technique, as the thought process was make the pitcher throw a strike before you swing, so you don’t help him out

  • @Jaguar51995
    @Jaguar51995 Месяц назад +2

    I remember thinking when they fired Renteria that it would be their undoing, I didn't actually think it would happen this badly though

  • @mikemurphy8996
    @mikemurphy8996 27 дней назад +1

    I have no idea how that much talent didn’t easily win the central years in a row. It’s the worst division in baseball. Those players must have terrible character and they must have had terrible coaching. I think Hahn had the right idea, he was just forced to hire the wrong manager.

  • @ChuPapi74
    @ChuPapi74 27 дней назад +1

    As a Sox fan, you cannot compare the Braves org and the Sox. I understand your saying their philosophy was similar, but the Sox have never even come close to doing what the Braves have done. From the top to the bottom their in a different class.

  • @LiveSportsOdds-uo5xu
    @LiveSportsOdds-uo5xu Месяц назад +2

    Can you do a series on advanced metrics like war, FIP, ERA+ etc. it’s pros and cons and why they matter

  • @SamtheBravesFan
    @SamtheBravesFan 24 дня назад +1

    The White Sox did this strategy first and it backfired. The Braves largely picked the correct people to extend in this case; Strider may end up being an expensive mistake, though he always can be converted to a closer since Anthopoulos likes to spend money in relievers for God knows whatever reason.

  • @orangefox1231
    @orangefox1231 Месяц назад

    Backing up your points which were excellent, I remember when Pittsburgh gave Bryan Reynolds a 9 figure deal, I was surprised to see that one of the three teams remaining that had never given a 9-figure deal was the White Sox.
    I hadn’t realized they were that frugal or arguably cheap and I think that is what led them to offering guys contracts super early. They wanted 3 massive discounts when the smarter move would’ve been to do what Atlanta did with Acuna. He played in 2018, the Braves had enough data to believe he would continue to be a great player and then paid him. Same with Ozzie Albies.

  • @aegisofhonor
    @aegisofhonor 22 дня назад +1

    to sign a prospect with zero MLB at bats to a 43 million 6 year deal is basically the same as taking that $43 million to Vegas and betting it all on Red and hope for the best.

  • @pooloftim8263
    @pooloftim8263 Месяц назад +4

    Just checked out Giolito’s stats, he’s not nearly as good as this video implies…

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +1

      he was an ace for the White Sox at a lot of moments. 2019: 3.41 ERA. 2020: 3.48 ERA. 2021: 3.53 ERA. 2022: declines bad with a 4.90 ERA. 2023: 3.79 ERA with the White Sox (proceeded to get traded and get shelled). Clearly, they’re system worked well with him

  • @n_YYZ18
    @n_YYZ18 Месяц назад +3

    Yermin Mercedes was not a star player.

  • @razfilms1
    @razfilms1 Месяц назад +12

    It’s very upsetting as a sox fan. We’re the forgotten team in the MLB and Jerry continues to fuck over the team. My biggest fear is them moving to Nashville, and after seeing what happened with the A’s, it makes me more scared than ever. If they leave, I might be straight up done with baseball

    • @fallen4life080
      @fallen4life080 Месяц назад +1

      I dont understand how Sox fans and others dont realize that the even bigger culprit other than JR is injuries. Everytime our guys got injured it set back their development, chemistry, morale, and mechanics. then they come back and slowly pick up the pace and then before you know it 3 other guys go down putting more weight on other players. Every team has injuries.....but have you noticed how ONLY our prospects were the ones getting injured alll the time?

    • @The_Internet_Is_Overrated
      @The_Internet_Is_Overrated Месяц назад +1

      If they move I'll never go to or watch another game again.

    • @tonyhill1141
      @tonyhill1141 Месяц назад +2

      When they traded Burger for nothing and then Jason left it really was a gut punch.

    • @jeremiah_12
      @jeremiah_12 Месяц назад

      Just root for the Cubs. Some A’s fans are now rooting for the Giants.

    • @The_Internet_Is_Overrated
      @The_Internet_Is_Overrated Месяц назад

      @@jeremiah_12 I'd rather cut my left hand off

  • @oddballskull1941
    @oddballskull1941 Месяц назад +6

    The white sox want a new stadium. When you want a new stadium and dont get it in mlb, You tank.

    • @rolandomedina9773
      @rolandomedina9773 Месяц назад

      How can they tank? CBA changed that. They can only get the #10 pick.

    • @PYahWeh
      @PYahWeh Месяц назад

      That’s an interesting theory…something to look into the very least

    • @richmartin1427
      @richmartin1427 Месяц назад +1

      @@rolandomedina9773it’s not about draft picks. It’s about not spending so that fans stop showing up, then you can claim no support and that you would do better in a different city. Exactly what Fisher did in Oakland to get the Vegas move.

    • @rolandomedina9773
      @rolandomedina9773 Месяц назад

      @@richmartin1427 but they did spend. Money went on Barfield, Bannister ,Gene, and Paul Janish .
      It was to create a culture and identity.
      They know more than fans do.
      They move into a new TV setting .
      Then one year and Minor league CONtracts run out as well .
      New free agency class coming up .
      All that and they strategically announced Soxfest.
      They are not moving.
      MLB wants eXpansion.
      New teams.
      That MLBPA would also like .
      Yes,it's also about that lease or new stadium they would hope to get.

  • @F1zzii
    @F1zzii Месяц назад +2

    Seeing how bad the Sox are I've never been happier being a Cubs fan

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +2

      A lot of White Sox fans are certainly wishing they were raised Cubs fans lol

    • @F1zzii
      @F1zzii Месяц назад

      @@PurelyBaseballYT Southside Losers

  • @tonypanzarella9387
    @tonypanzarella9387 20 дней назад +1

    Any franchise that endured Charles Comiskey, Bill Veeck [twice], and Jerry Reinsdorf [who once said that he wanted to make MLB more like professional wrestling], has suffered a lot.

  • @GrowKing510
    @GrowKing510 26 дней назад +1

    Be blessed to have a team. Signed A fan from Oakland

  • @majorfomo7895
    @majorfomo7895 14 дней назад +1

    Nothing will change until Reinsdorf either sells the team or dies.

  • @davidburke9596
    @davidburke9596 5 дней назад

    I believe Reinsdorf thought getting to the Series with all Latin starters would be his ticket to the HOF.

  • @fallen4life080
    @fallen4life080 Месяц назад +7

    the biggest issue has always been injuries. It led to inconsistencies in development, growth, morale, and chemistry. Imagine what the Orioles would be if Henderson tore his hip flexor and was out till August, and then when he got back he started slow all while simultaneously Rutschman tore his pectoral muscle and was out till August. Then, ext season, imagine they BOTH again were gone every few weeks with leg issues and back issues? The all of a sudden Santander has a groin issue and is out for 2 months?

  • @monkeyboyjonathan42
    @monkeyboyjonathan42 Месяц назад +1

    It says so right in the quote. It’s poor sportsmanship to swing in a 3-0 count “when you have a comfortable lead”
    That’s important context, whether you agree with it or not.

  • @williamford9564
    @williamford9564 Месяц назад +1

    3:03: Olson and Murphy were not "young" and not from the Braves organizations. They were established players, acquired in trades and then chose to sign "extensions" with the Braves.. That is no different than with any other team.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад

      I never said they were from the Braves organization. However, they were acquired and extended. Extending young players is NOT something many teams do. Teams play with arbitration

  • @sirtorndr
    @sirtorndr Месяц назад

    Great video! Very informative. I'm not sure why it seems like there are bugs in lots of the videos segments. Is that a content creator choice or something necessary for this video to be on RUclips? Or are they just in my head?

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +1

      Haha long story but they wont be in next video!
      Glad you enjoyed brother

  • @Capnqwanch
    @Capnqwanch Месяц назад +12

    Yermin Mercedes is not and was not a star player

    • @heartman6314
      @heartman6314 Месяц назад +2

      TLR was to blame for many problems but was not responsible for Mercedes' downfall. Yes the 3-0 count situation was certainly an issue with TLR, although he was only mad because Mercedes ignored the take sign not because the count was 3-0. Mercedes retired because he was mad that he got sent to the minors, he was in a major slump and definitely needed to be sent down, that wasn't entirely on TLR it was an organizational decision. The truth is he was a hitter who got hot but couldn't make adjustments once pitchers learned how to pitch to him, not everyone can stay in the show the game is hard

  • @dougg2012
    @dougg2012 Месяц назад +2

    7:55 LMFAO 💀

  • @daviddamascus9657
    @daviddamascus9657 16 дней назад

    Don't you think you should say the White Sox failed to utilize the Braves strategy? Other than that little gripe, really good break down. This is the kind of content baseball fans love. I've almost completely gone away from analysis by ESPN and what not for better analysis by RUclipsrs such as what we just watched.

  • @chrisgotski9837
    @chrisgotski9837 13 дней назад

    Vaughn was never an outfield prospect. He was a 1st Baseman that they played out of position. Drafting Burger Vaughn and Sheets with 2 1st and 2nd rd pick in back to back years was absolutely horrible roster building. F JERRY AND larussa

  • @nb_nic
    @nb_nic Месяц назад

    I'm still early on so apologies if you mention this but signing Eloy to a 6 year deal before he's played any big league ball is exactly the sort of deal the braves would never make. All of their deals look to buy out at least a couple free agency years, basically rolling the 'extra' that they pay during what would be the remaining league minimum and arbitration years into added value by securing free agency. the really long length of the Braves' contracts are one of the biggest keys, because when you do have a success story like Ronald or Ozzie, it's easier to sit them down for an extension 6 years into a possibly 9 year contract after they've already proven themselves and would've been free agents at this point anyways.

  • @ClintSteezwood
    @ClintSteezwood Месяц назад

    Awesome vid brother

  • @Hector__11
    @Hector__11 Месяц назад

    This does bring a smile to my face. -a Cubs fan

    • @johnmatthew8710
      @johnmatthew8710 Месяц назад +1

      You're likely also one of so many who are quick to tell any Sox fan that criticizes the Cubs for any reason to worry about their own team, right?

  • @BatBoyEditz
    @BatBoyEditz Месяц назад +4

    As a twins ran, it is sad watching this team every time we play them

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +2

      On the bright side, mannnn do those Twins look good this season

    • @BatBoyEditz
      @BatBoyEditz Месяц назад +2

      @@PurelyBaseballYT Yes, And we got the entire 12 game win streak with not having Royce Lewis on the field since the first game.

    • @michaelleroy9281
      @michaelleroy9281 Месяц назад

      As a Twins fan I can't see their games because of the Bally Sports Comcast thing

    • @nochey78
      @nochey78 Месяц назад +1

      You think it’s sad watching this team as an opponent??? Try being a white Sox fan right about now…

    • @fallen4life080
      @fallen4life080 Месяц назад

      I like to tell Twins fans, imagine Byron Buxton's injury history but for 5 other stud players in your lineup. THAT's why our rebuild failed. and after 4 years of an open window nobody cares anymore. It's not anyones fault but lady luck.

  • @rationalconservative386
    @rationalconservative386 13 дней назад

    How could they replicate the Braves' strategy when it's not even their homegrown talent?

  • @24bobdylan
    @24bobdylan Месяц назад +1

    Your framing of the 2021 season is really weird, we won 91 games. To do that with all the stars injured for huge chunks of time was really impressive. Also you neglected to mention that we failed to sign any of the big time, future HoF free agents that were available in the late 2010s

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад +1

      Of course they won 91 games. And they also won a singular playoff game..
      that team had so many expectations. 91 win regular season, that was followed by the core falling apart in the following season.
      Completely agree on the free agents. If theres anything I could change for this video, definitely that. Not only the ones they missed out on, but the Benitendi signing has been so terrible 😂🤦‍♂️

    • @dusatriplife6993
      @dusatriplife6993 17 дней назад

      @@PurelyBaseballYTthis is random but I played against Benintendi in HS and bruh was real live Steph curry before Steph curry😭🔥 I didn’t play baseball n high school so I couldn’t tell how he was on the field but on the court 😂🔥

  • @ancestralFromWesnoth
    @ancestralFromWesnoth Месяц назад +2

    3-0 count… WITH AN 11 RUN LEAD… off of a position player pitching

    • @survivingwatson7430
      @survivingwatson7430 23 дня назад

      dont go down 11-0 then ?the fuck lmao have enough fuckin pride as men not to disrespect your fans and the sport by getting stomped out so badly that position players need to pitch. then you wont have homeruns hit off them

  • @yes-it-is-i
    @yes-it-is-i Месяц назад

    To me he should be in the HOF at some point, he was a staple for a team for over a decade and is top 15 in a lot of passing stats, much less an MVP that set records in yards per attempt in 2016. Vick might be considered “Mr. Falcon” but Ryan is the best falcons QB by a healthy margin.

  • @etrin5714
    @etrin5714 7 дней назад

    Breslow and Cora have a great working relationship and our completely in sync. My sources confirmed that they are actively seeking SP and infield help. Expect some transactions in the next 2-3 wks. With Bauer off the market, any chance they consider Urias?

  • @GohanVsLuffy
    @GohanVsLuffy Месяц назад

    season not over ,record looks daunting , they will play like hell and win like hell.

  • @ZeroCrystal
    @ZeroCrystal 27 дней назад

    Oddly, I saw 4 causes for the White Sux to be terrible:
    1. Tony La Russa
    2. Tony La Russa (yes, this is the same as cause 1, but i felt it beared repeating.)
    3. DOWN GOES ANDERSON!!!!
    4. DOWN GOES ANDERSON!!!!1!!

  • @danreal52
    @danreal52 Месяц назад

    Good to know there’s another A’s out there💪

  • @PastingKing
    @PastingKing Месяц назад

    Let's not forget the club gave the biggest contact in team history to Andrew Benitendi who has a negative WAR

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад

      As a Red Sox fan, amazes me how bad he’s been honestly

  • @d.l.d.l.8140
    @d.l.d.l.8140 Месяц назад

    I admit to not following closely while LaRussa was in Detroit. ( Sorry Detroit ) but he did a good job for us in St. Louis. The thing is, that 3-0 swing was a personal statement. Everyone ( shit, everyone old )knows he’s a passionate defender and advocate of the old unwritten rules, and he apparently quit rather than change. That at bat was an opportunity to personally insult LaRussa, and he did that. Must have been really bad at the end, wish he’d had a better closeout but, there’s no crying in baseball.🤫

  • @benplayzgames4368
    @benplayzgames4368 11 дней назад

    8:20 reminds me of when Lisa kicked Bart off the baseball team because he swung at a 3-0 count pitch

  • @KOrnhOliO1
    @KOrnhOliO1 Месяц назад

    A lot of the Braves success has to be credited to Alex Anthopolous. He's not only the best GM in baseball, but probably the best GM in all of professional sports!
    His moves are questionable, and many didn't get them, then the player is outstanding! AA has the ability to figure out what the team needs and then go find that need, then trade for him, and no one quite often understands why he would trade for him, and then the player ends up being awesome! He's a baseball Guru! He's done it time and time again. Fans wonder what he sees in this player, and then the player RAKES!
    AA HAS A GIFT THAT CAN'T JUST BE COPIED! 😎🤘
    Fans now trust AA and understand that if he brings that player in, it's for a good reason that we fans just don't get. Then, that player is superb, and AA again earns our trust. If he brings in a player, there's a great reason for it, and we just go with it!
    "In AA we trust!" 😁💯

  • @jayburdification
    @jayburdification 27 дней назад +1

    What’s with all the floaties in every shot. Who even came up with this idea as a video effect and thought it was a good idea? It’s distracting and annoying.

  • @Dingusberry400
    @Dingusberry400 Месяц назад

    tell em the part about how we drafted Andrew Vaughn 3rd overall while cj Abrams and Corbin Carroll was still on the board

  • @michaelleroy9281
    @michaelleroy9281 Месяц назад

    The White Sox from after 2008 ( when they previously won a division title) to 2019 were nothing to shout about either

  • @BendyDH
    @BendyDH Месяц назад +21

    ... At least they still have the best City Connect in MLB….?

    • @Commander_Bern
      @Commander_Bern Месяц назад +2

      Tampa Bay

    • @BendyDH
      @BendyDH Месяц назад

      @@Commander_Bern that’s true, Rays just topped them

    • @nomercyinc6783
      @nomercyinc6783 Месяц назад +1

      city connect jerseys are trash

    • @TheGOOFYLAUGHS
      @TheGOOFYLAUGHS Месяц назад +1

      Personally I prefer the Reds or Rockies city connects, the Sox aren't bad but the Rockies green mountain jerseys look so great.

    • @michaelparkerdesign
      @michaelparkerdesign Месяц назад

      Baltimores is better tbh

  • @igorlobkovenko9480
    @igorlobkovenko9480 14 дней назад

    What about Freddie Freeman and Dansby Swanson? They were core players but could not agree on contracts. They have moved in very well with Olson, Riley. However, Strider is out of the year and Acuna is out for the season as the result of a knee injury, again.

  • @raymundo2417
    @raymundo2417 Месяц назад

    Yermin Mercedes was the coolest shit I’ve ever seen, that dude was a first ballot hall of famer for a month straight.

  • @mattspychala7251
    @mattspychala7251 Месяц назад

    As a Cubs fan, listening to White Sox fans getting all giddy about this team and how we "gave them Eloy" for nothing (Quintana worked out pretty well for us). To watch once again Reisdorf drop a bomb on them by hiring LaRussa was just magical.

  • @Qntn04
    @Qntn04 28 дней назад

    Bro forgot "DOWN GOES ANDERSON!!! DOWN GOES ANDERSON"🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  28 дней назад

      That was on my notes for the video too 😂😂

  • @reidsal4042
    @reidsal4042 Месяц назад

    Braves nickel and dime their players into extensions. It's resulted in some pissed off players like Acuna who threatened to hold out and was apparently almost traded to the Yankees this past off season.

    • @jeremiah_12
      @jeremiah_12 Месяц назад

      Sources? He wasn’t going to be traded to the Yankees.

  • @Redmenace96
    @Redmenace96 Месяц назад +3

    Amazing how many people watch this video.... and comment on their team. Sox fan here, and the Tony LaRussa hire can, at best, be described as 'interesting'. Took a chance, had possibilities, but completely unrealized. It was Reinsdorf. Not going to crap on him like most fair-weather/internet fans. All you internet heroes can scrape together your 1 billion dollars and lay it on the line- start making real decisions. Baseball is a tough racket.

  • @williamford9564
    @williamford9564 Месяц назад

    2:07: I don't know if this list says the Braves "strategy" is a valid answer. Acuna, a once in a generational talent, and Riley bailed them out. Of the rest, none are still in Atlanta, and only Kyle Wright, of a short period, had any impact on the team in light of positive performance. The rest are either out of MLB altogether or fringe players on other teams. Chicago's list, if you eliminate Acuna from the equation, has more players still in MLB and are serviceable players. The answer to the question is really something different and it starts with luck, as in good and bad and the strength of the people in the organization.

  • @buzz9900
    @buzz9900 Месяц назад

    Even tho eloy and Luis Robert have been injury ridden they’re good enough players that buying out arb for those prices were good still good deals

  • @BigPat216
    @BigPat216 Месяц назад

    I don't think they did anything inherently wrong, it just didn't work. Not sure how else to explain it. I feel like they hit on more guys than they missed, but things just spiraled out of control quickly.

  • @bernardodeleon7979
    @bernardodeleon7979 Месяц назад

    I may be wrong and negative in saying this, but who are some top prospects, who signed an extension before making their major league debut, have panned out and been successful?

    • @ryangale3757
      @ryangale3757 29 дней назад

      Not quite before making his major league debut but Evan Longoria panned out pretty well; he signed his extension less than a week after being called up, and his willingness to sign likely had a lot to do with the Rays being okay with callng him up in the first place (so they had probably been talking to him well before that about it).

  • @bizboy5
    @bizboy5 9 дней назад

    Guy purposely ignored a sign.....and the coach is supposed to just ignore it ?!?! (knowing the entire team just saw a guy ignore the coach and get away with it ?!?!).
    Coaches like that don't get past the high school level....

  • @johnshepherd9676
    @johnshepherd9676 Месяц назад

    If the Sox anagement wanted a nostalgia pick for a manager they should have gone with Ozzie Guillen. Guillen is Mr. White Sox the way Ernie Banks was Mr. Cub despite not being a hall of Famer. He got the Sox their only World Series victory in the contemporary era. But they really should have kept Rick Renteria.

  • @DGS5218
    @DGS5218 24 дня назад

    Watching as a Mets fan:
    "I was born into the darkness, molded by it"

  • @JC-sm2in
    @JC-sm2in Месяц назад +1

    Don't look now, but it's kind of looking like it's caving in around the Braves now. All their highly paid superstars are not living up to their potential and or expectations. The Phillies are better than the Braves this year and they will run off and leave the braves in the dust in the division. I got the Phillies winning it all this year if they stay healthy.

    • @PurelyBaseballYT
      @PurelyBaseballYT  Месяц назад

      Very good point

    • @David-ig5rz
      @David-ig5rz Месяц назад

      The Braves are hitting like warmed over dogshit and they're even with the Phillies in the loss column. The bats will come around eventually.

  • @dagoodistever7186
    @dagoodistever7186 Месяц назад +186

    MLB is rigged against the tigers

  • @Redpoppy80
    @Redpoppy80 Месяц назад

    This type of trying to imitate already successful teams has backfired for the Giants as well. Despite the fact that we have way more money, we are trying to build rosters on the cheap like the Tampa Bay Rays and despite the fact that our ballpark is so eschewed in favor of pitchers we try to build a balanced jack of all trades master of all like the Dodgers when they have the picture of an average Major League Stadium.

  • @adaptationPHL
    @adaptationPHL 29 дней назад

    I mean the Braves strategy falls apart if they have to play the Phillies in the postseason…

  • @turdferguson8175
    @turdferguson8175 Месяц назад

    Words can’t even explain how much I hate Jerry Reinsdorf. It is all on him. Refusing to open the wallet and not hiring the right manager killed the team.

  • @torrey88
    @torrey88 Месяц назад

    The good thing for the White Sox is they play in the AL Central, and as a Tigers fan, I know none of the owners are willing to spend money in that division. However, Chicago has the resources to spend if they wanted to. That would give me at least a fool’s hope…

    • @MustacheDLuffy
      @MustacheDLuffy Месяц назад

      Jerry Reinsdorf would be happy to self handicap himself