Residents Terrified Of Their Neighbourhood Beg For Help

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 июн 2024
  • Terrified residents of South Melbourne's Park Towers are pleading for help from the government as they endure unsanitary conditions, violence and crime in the public housing block.
    #SouthMelbourne #SocialHousing #HousingCrisis

Комментарии • 412

  • @ToeKnife166
    @ToeKnife166 24 дня назад +81

    They forgot to mention the elderly people who are very vulnerable and placed next to unstable junkies.

    • @joe-dirt697
      @joe-dirt697 14 дней назад +1

      Come to qld were junkie hunters up here...
      😂😂

  • @dellishart9535
    @dellishart9535 25 дней назад +66

    Women and children need separate social housing. No one should live in fear

    • @joynicolson4158
      @joynicolson4158 25 дней назад +9

      What is a woman .?..

    • @plaidshirt9955
      @plaidshirt9955 24 дня назад +9

      That said, they definitely put rock spiders and other predators in the towers, knowing full well there are families in there as these poor people spoke about and that could definitely be controlled.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад +6

      Sure, and Bob Hawke said no child in Australia will live in poverty! Australia is no different from the rest of the world.

    • @chezzachezza7325
      @chezzachezza7325 23 дня назад

      ​​@@joynicolson4158If you dont know what a woman then maybe you need help

    • @TeyannaWilliams-pu6uu
      @TeyannaWilliams-pu6uu 23 дня назад +2

      I agree

  • @gareztakat5356
    @gareztakat5356 26 дней назад +55

    Good on that reporter for talking about her life growing up in public housing. She showed great sensitivity in her reporting.
    I grew up in public housing but it was a stand alone house in a mixed owner-occupier/housing commission neighbourhood. I had a great childhood with no problems. Fast forward now as a doctor I did outreach work into one of these towers and I was appalled by the unsafe and unsanitary conditions. It’s a dumping ground for people society would label as “undesirable”….it needs to change!

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 25 дней назад +1

      Sarah actually went to school in Brisbane and is now a multi millionaire...
      Don't think she stayed in housing commission for long in western Sydney. But good story.

    • @essdee5876
      @essdee5876 24 дня назад +1

      I love that she wasn't afraid to say that aswell - and you.

    • @Me-xoxoz
      @Me-xoxoz 24 дня назад

      What l find interesting is people expect immigrants placed in these public housing to come out different. Yes some will rise above it but some are consumed by the environment that is already chaotic.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад

      ​@@Me-xoxozImmigrants make up largest cohort of people living in public housing complexes in Australia? Hmm, fact check needed...

  • @robbainbridge1297
    @robbainbridge1297 26 дней назад +40

    It’s definitely got a terrible reputation in South Melbourne. I feel so sorry for the women with their children living there escaping domestic abuse. Please help them

    • @tkatrich3
      @tkatrich3 21 день назад

      The minute I saw the eyebrow piercing in the intro yep I was like this is UK or Australia...

  • @ulrikezachmann7596
    @ulrikezachmann7596 27 дней назад +70

    That what you get for putting junkies and criminals in public housing.

    • @MargaretCampbell583
      @MargaretCampbell583 27 дней назад +10

      I agree these people should not be there

    • @kempowarrior1954
      @kempowarrior1954 26 дней назад +2

      Spongers 👎

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад +2

      Who would have thought? 😮
      No other cities around the world have this problem....oops.

    • @skids3048
      @skids3048 24 дня назад +2

      Yes because having them on the street is better for everyone isn't it?

    • @kempowarrior1954
      @kempowarrior1954 24 дня назад +7

      @@skids3048 Anywhere away from decent people. Preferably the desert.

  • @helenahayes6150
    @helenahayes6150 27 дней назад +81

    THANK YOU. This is a very accurate description of public housing blocks in Adelaide where I live. Its not exaggerated.

    • @paulthesurfer7470
      @paulthesurfer7470 27 дней назад +8

      Well maybe you should wonder why brave police commissioner Karmha and SAPOL treat you with such disregard. Think about it. Exactly who does run South Australia? Wasn't the current premier the police minister under Jay Weatherill? If the coppers refuse to report the crime, then it didn't happen. It's the police who decide who the crims are.....

    • @helenahayes6150
      @helenahayes6150 27 дней назад

      @@paulthesurfer7470 Police have always been fantastic. I feel sorry for them having to constantly go through what they do in this housing complex. Let me give you one example. My 6'4" next door neighbour smashes up his wife and kids in a terrifying episode. Car windows smashed in (and its not easy to smash in a car window), house windows and doors smashed in. I was on the other side of a flimsy fence when it happened. I didnt think they would survive. All I could do was run inside, lock my doors, call the police and hope he didnt smash my door and windows in. I phoned up my son to come and get me because I was so scared, but at the same time I didnt feel I could leave this woman and her children until the police arrived. The perpetrator was arrested, remanded in custody, and a court date was set. Police assured me that the assault was so serious, that he wouldn't be coming back. Believing them, I agreed to testify against him in court. The judge let him straight back out again. His wife and kids were taken by police to a shelter/down market hotel. The court even gave him permission to go back and live at his old address. So he now occupies a 4 bedroom home, and all his black African mates are now there with him. And I am quite terrified having him live next door to me now. Drinking sets him off and he is in his back shed drinking every night. So go easy on the police. If the government built more jail space, the judges wouldnt need to send them home.

  • @lynnetrathen4587
    @lynnetrathen4587 27 дней назад +35

    I used to clean one apartment in there on floor 10 I was always terrified whenever I got into the lift 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

  • @steph5562
    @steph5562 27 дней назад +76

    This is horrific that anyone is subjected to these horrid living conditions, let alone children. Our Government is making Australia a 3rd world country and allowing this hell.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 27 дней назад +7

      3rd world countries don't buy nuclear-powered submarines....😮
      But what country doesn't have similar issues to this?

    • @mr.melontoyou
      @mr.melontoyou 27 дней назад +1

      Been like this for over 20-30 years
      They don’t care
      And invite more people in the country-
      It’s a Joke 🤡
      Australia sucks!

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @essdee5876
      @essdee5876 24 дня назад

      @@commonlawrights9514 inhumane.

  • @lilahsadventures5717
    @lilahsadventures5717 27 дней назад +33

    You have no idea what it’s like to be scared in our own home. My area has a government housing estate here and it’s terrifying not to mention what it is like to try and shop in our local CBD. We have a violence crisis in Melbourne.

  • @rosavaz8326
    @rosavaz8326 27 дней назад +86

    The government don’t care!

    • @helenahayes6150
      @helenahayes6150 27 дней назад +11

      correct. I speak from experience.

    • @user-yl8gd4pp1n
      @user-yl8gd4pp1n 27 дней назад +10

      ​@@helenahayes6150getting screwed by government opened my eyes to critical thinking.

    • @user-yl8gd4pp1n
      @user-yl8gd4pp1n 27 дней назад +14

      The system is not broken, it's built that way.

    • @mr.melontoyou
      @mr.melontoyou 27 дней назад +5

      Yes they dont care at all.

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад +1

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

  • @Zilron38
    @Zilron38 27 дней назад +51

    It needs to be easier to put the people who are abusive into Jail.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 27 дней назад +4

      Need to get more taxes to build more jails first! 😮

    • @user-yl8gd4pp1n
      @user-yl8gd4pp1n 27 дней назад

      Police are too busy intentionally making things worse

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 27 дней назад +5

      @@multioptionedThey could just tax the foreign companies that are getting our resources and dollars for nothing 🤷‍♀️

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад +2

      @alyssaoconnor Governments will always go after the easiest targets. Large corporations, especially multi nationals, have "legal" ways of avoiding and minimising tax. The government runs the risk of losing the foreign investment to other countries if they try to get more tax from them. That's why 800 of the largest companies in Australia pay little or no tax here. But Australia needs their investments and the jobs they create.

    • @whynot2030
      @whynot2030 26 дней назад +1

      The state is broke. Cost to much to jail people

  • @deant6361
    @deant6361 27 дней назад +26

    I was an ambo in 90’s and through the 2000’s and we were sent there a lot and not only did our stretchers not fit in the lifts but I was sometimes scared sh**less and I’m not a soft man the place is horrible !

    • @user-cz6gk2ci4k
      @user-cz6gk2ci4k 24 дня назад +3

      How are you supposed to transport frail patients. Wow, someone missed a memo somewhere !!?

    • @deant6361
      @deant6361 24 дня назад +5

      @@user-cz6gk2ci4k yep the lifts my god we had to put patients on stretcher, secure them with the straps get half in the lifts drop the foot end to the ground then lift the head end up till they were almost in a standing position it was terrifying for some frail people and every single housing flats were are the same all over Melbourne and there is about 50 of these horrible places. Peace to you. 👍

  • @user-cz6gk2ci4k
    @user-cz6gk2ci4k 24 дня назад +17

    Good on you Sarah! Thankyou for shining your light on this. 35 years and nothing has changed. People feeling so stuck and powerless. 💔

  • @adriannalyon9514
    @adriannalyon9514 27 дней назад +69

    They should assign a part of that building where only single mums and their children are allowed in that area. Those with major issues should be in another area and so forth.

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад

      Obviously Government workers don’t have that sort of IQ to follow that through…

    • @lynnetrathen4587
      @lynnetrathen4587 27 дней назад +6

      Great idea now to get the government to do it 🤬🤬

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад +1

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @tommychronos7307
      @tommychronos7307 27 дней назад +2

      Yeah thats how we grew up, single mothers, elderly and disabled in the flats.

    • @tommychronos7307
      @tommychronos7307 27 дней назад

      I grew up in croydon though.. so the suburb itself was better

  • @shonarosemarybaker9211
    @shonarosemarybaker9211 25 дней назад +20

    ONLY the deserving should get public and social housing, being vulnerable elderly, disabled, families fleeing violence, but ONLY those who are peaceful, clean, law-abiding, respectful and who look after their apartment and commin areas. No druggies, alcoholics, unhinged nutters, peverts, crimsz ex crims...; one strike and you're evicted. Public housing is necessary but also a privilege. It is unbelievable how many ferels there are in Australia!

    • @PurpleGold.
      @PurpleGold. 24 дня назад +7

      I live in housing because my twin and I have disability. I’ve had to confront my neighbours (in Brisbane suburb) disability support workers many times for running our duplex down into the ground and turning it into a cesspit. And it’s actually the support workers and NDIS service providers that are causing the Feralism but NDIS safeguard commission is already overwhelmed with petty complaints and is having trouble prioritising clients.
      People who are already marginalised are being disenfranchised even more as they are being mixed in with the rotten bunch who only want to gang bang but for the rest of us, who respect law and order, it’s a nightmare and hard to get out of the hell hole due to low income which is only a byproduct of circumstance not necessarily by choice, nor as a consequence of making personal bad choices.

  • @JoeyBlogs007
    @JoeyBlogs007 27 дней назад +69

    They need to build a new jail for the offenders on a remote island, then rennovate the building and allow those that are well behaved to live in peace.

    • @paulthesurfer7470
      @paulthesurfer7470 27 дней назад

      Sure, do that....are you ready to pay $700,000 per year to lock up a person in need of care and rehabilitation? I suggest you have a think about our privatised prisons and wonder why people like you call for dope politicians to get tough on crime while they get brown paper bags from the same criminals who own the prisons. Serco come to mind.....

    • @Wooplot
      @Wooplot 27 дней назад +1

      send em to Tassie

    • @user-yl8gd4pp1n
      @user-yl8gd4pp1n 27 дней назад +2

      What about the politicians that create such an environment?

    • @TheMightyAbs
      @TheMightyAbs 27 дней назад +2

      @@Wooplot A new penal colony eh?

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 27 дней назад

      @@WooplotNo thanks, the rich entitled tourists that you send here are bad enough 😂

  • @mo-fogarage8739
    @mo-fogarage8739 25 дней назад +13

    Sad sad world we live in

  • @Intentionallyhomeless
    @Intentionallyhomeless 25 дней назад +11

    Ide rather enjoy the freedom of homelessness than this

  • @amattes1960
    @amattes1960 27 дней назад +48

    I thought that if people were known to behave like this they can be removed and refused further government housing. What happened to that?

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад +11

      Everyone’s too scared to act , rules that aren’t enforced… empty words…

    • @lilahsadventures5717
      @lilahsadventures5717 27 дней назад +6

      I have seen countless drug dealers get busted go to jail pay extremely cheap rent to keep their place and they just come back. 😢

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 27 дней назад

      They can’t refuse housing to someone mentally ill, disability act gone too far. Every vice is a disability now but instead of treating them they just put them into housing and give them NDIS because they closed down a lot of the rehabilitation centres.

    • @TerminusEst1982
      @TerminusEst1982 26 дней назад

      it causes a spillover onto the street, then you'll complain those people aren't housed. STFU

    • @IsabellaBarkerIzusqui
      @IsabellaBarkerIzusqui 26 дней назад +10

      We go to the police, tenants get restraining orders, we constantly tell housing, but they just ignore. It's maddening!

  • @jacquelineh9248
    @jacquelineh9248 25 дней назад +14

    Is laughable: A country as big as Australia, resorts to building tower blocks. No, it wasn't done deliberately to screw up people's heads.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 25 дней назад +2

      People with no money want to live in expensive cities? 😮
      What's that property worth to taxpayers if sold to developers? 💰

  • @karinburns3226
    @karinburns3226 24 дня назад +10

    Absolutely horrible places.
    I lived in the Flemington high rise towers as a teenager in the early to late 80s and it was scary back then but it looks like there are now much more dangerous gangs due to Australia's need to import the worst of the worst from third word countries and stick them all together in a cesspool.
    I feel sorry for the genuine people who get stuck there

  • @DeidreL9
    @DeidreL9 27 дней назад +12

    The government could not care less.

  • @TheGrundycounty
    @TheGrundycounty 27 дней назад +31

    No government can be stuffed with this issue

  • @NekoEspada
    @NekoEspada 26 дней назад +11

    I live next to public housing buildings in South Sydney, I often hear domestic arguments and people partying and yelling till 2-3am.

    • @damongirl66
      @damongirl66 22 дня назад

      So, they have early nights, then?

  • @DJMandibular
    @DJMandibular 27 дней назад +25

    Government are not going to bother because the tower will be demolished

  • @noramaddy4409
    @noramaddy4409 25 дней назад +15

    Australia is a culture-dead society. If all children attended after-school lessons in music schools and sports clubs in the area they live, I mean give the kids the whole spectrum of activities from piano to drums, martial arts to ballet and table tennis or woodwork/carpentry to artwork to choose from, then these kids would have a skill set they look forward every day to participate in and develop their social skills with competent adults who support their learning and care about their progress. These young people will become adults who actively engage in the community and contribute to the economy. Right now, only children who are fortunate to live in well-off families can afford the extracurricular lessons and have the opportunity to interact in the wider community with competent mentors.

    • @christinalikoski4937
      @christinalikoski4937 24 дня назад +3

      I agree with you.
      I believe I give more free music lessons to kids and adults. Just seeing their faces of accomplishments with pride makes up for the money
      Australia 💕 Christina

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад +1

      You just described some immigrant Chinese families I know of. It's all about education, upbringing and role models. "Australians" just don't get it.

    • @KG-wv9sg
      @KG-wv9sg 8 дней назад

      I'm low income, social housing. My husband has survived cancer and other chronic health issues and cannot work. My son attends boxing lessons and chess club up to 6 afternoons per week and has access to a plethora of musical instruments. He also reads at night instead of a screen. We have to supplement his academics because the school is not good. We sacrifice a lot to pay for his enrichment. The social housing near us is occupied by total dregs, people who destroy it. We have really nice new homes but they just wreck it and continue to behave atrociously. It's depressing. We just try to be house proud and do the absolute best for our son so he has every chance to escape it one day.

    • @noramaddy4409
      @noramaddy4409 4 дня назад

      @@KG-wv9sg It`s lovely to hear your son is doing so well and enjoys his box training and chess. Yes, what can we do about the neighbours that terrorize the other tenants? The social housing employees don`t seem to care and don`t seem to have a process whereby they could move the antisocial tenants to a certain s.housing block where they can terrorize each other. The only thing I can think of is to form your own tenant's community group and meet once a month and discuss ongoing issues, support one another and collectively write to the relevant social housing office about critical issues i.e. tenants that damage communal property or threaten other tenants. Could you organize your own tenancy watch? and motivate those neighbours who are interested to participate in cleaning and maintaining the common areas and perhaps assisting old tenants with shopping or repairs. I know it isn't easy to motivate people to care and the alternative is to vacate but I know this isn`t an option for some people.

  • @paulthesurfer7470
    @paulthesurfer7470 27 дней назад +28

    I have worked within the privatised/outsoursed Victorian public housing system. This is nothing, compared to the very easy access one can obtain as to where women's shelters and emergency housing is, the entry codes and emergency key locations and identities of those who work there. Dig a little deeper, Project. This comment is bona-fide.

  • @matthewk-nt7iw
    @matthewk-nt7iw 27 дней назад +19

    I work in housing for the Aus. GOVT. I wanted to make a difference. It is impossible cept for the odd person who I can do extra advocation for in my own time at my own expense. It WILL get much worse :(.

    • @essdee5876
      @essdee5876 24 дня назад +3

      Thank you so much for sharing. I met 2 amazing workers like yourself and I can empathise with the helplessness you faced.
      1 would visit me each time I was hospitalised, until she cried during her last visit and then transferred.
      She put her heart & soul into her work and I seen 1st hand, how 1 case alone impacted her life - professionally and personally.
      I will never forget her or the fight she fought when I no longer could. I'll be forever grateful.
      I'm sure you had this affect on at least 1 life, so let me assure you that your presence and work never went to waste. Someone/People you helped will also remember you forever.

    • @matthewk-nt7iw
      @matthewk-nt7iw 24 дня назад +1

      @essdee5876 Thank you for those lovely words. They made me smile. And yes, I have had very similar experiences with clients who have ended up being lifelong friends. Vicarious trauma on the workers is so prevalent right now. We do as much as we can with what we have, and unfortunately, that is not enough. The people we see daily leave huge impacts on us. There is not that much that separates the worker from the client in this day and age.

  • @Jojoxxr
    @Jojoxxr 27 дней назад +26

    Just about sums up the entire state of housing in Aus

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад +1

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @TrueLunacy
      @TrueLunacy 23 дня назад

      With what money?​@@commonlawrights9514

    • @AussieBeautyMaven1987
      @AussieBeautyMaven1987 День назад

      ​@@commonlawrights9514and you can go do 12mths in one of these buildings while a vulnerable person takes your house!

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 День назад

      @@AussieBeautyMaven1987 yer, well that’s not my problem, they can just got buy one like everyone else

    • @AussieBeautyMaven1987
      @AussieBeautyMaven1987 День назад

      @@commonlawrights9514 🤣🤣🤘 hope you NEVER fall on hard times ay mate 😎👌

  • @katehack1677
    @katehack1677 22 дня назад +5

    Let's be real. This is happening in EVERY Australian state and territory. Not just Victoria. Liberal or Labor. Failures over decades.

  • @chezzachezza7325
    @chezzachezza7325 23 дня назад +5

    Build more public housing in these politicians' streets halfway houses, too . Demand it

  • @ReikiHealingCo
    @ReikiHealingCo 27 дней назад +11

    Disgraceful the government need to do something now, maybe the government should spend a week in their accommodation. 😡

    • @mmca7288
      @mmca7288 27 дней назад +5

      I've put down a very similar comment and just come across urs, except I said them and their families live there for a week with no security, as they need to experience what they've created.....jail would be much better to these living conditions!

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @Lowqualitystuff
      @Lowqualitystuff 27 дней назад

      @@mmca7288at this point it honestly kinda would and that’s just depressing to think about

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 26 дней назад

      Yep they should spend a week on a disabled persons payment while living in public housing as a requirement to enter politics, most of them are silver spoon children and are a long time out of touch with reality (if they ever were in the first case).

  • @helenharmer3682
    @helenharmer3682 22 дня назад +2

    Don't know who the lady is in the blue dress that grew up in housing commission but hats off to you for doing so well for yourself. Well done 👏

  • @kimsherlock8969
    @kimsherlock8969 26 дней назад +8

    Thankyou for teiiing the truth .

  • @katebowman5435
    @katebowman5435 27 дней назад +8

    The government couldn't care less.

  • @spiritedsoul2182
    @spiritedsoul2182 26 дней назад +8

    The government has a responsibility to keep tenants safe. If you want public housing you shouldn’t have a criminal record, an intervention order against you or a drug/alcohol problem.

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 26 дней назад +3

      They need to restart funding to rehabs and asylum’s but do it right. At present every group you have mentioned are classified as having a disability and are considered to be protected under the disability act. The government gives them housing and access to NDIS funding and wipe their hands of the situation, thats what happens when the government privatises everything.

  • @samanthablackmore3437
    @samanthablackmore3437 24 дня назад +7

    Here’s a question, there are hundreds of people PAYING to rent in these places, WHERE EXACTLY DOES THE MONEY GO FROM ALL THOSE RENTS?

    • @user-mz7ov3pz7j
      @user-mz7ov3pz7j 24 дня назад +4

      Definitely not into repairing the buildings. Good point 👍

    • @OgglyGoogly
      @OgglyGoogly 23 дня назад

      Its very little rent

    • @anneloving8405
      @anneloving8405 23 дня назад +1

      Its a quarter of their income

  • @carmenaquilina2431
    @carmenaquilina2431 24 дня назад +4

    Absolutely disgraceful! Let the government live there!

  • @Maddfisher
    @Maddfisher 27 дней назад +15

    The government don’t care there busy watching there investment properties brought with our tax payer money go up in value with this housing crisis , there wages our coming out of our pockets it’s disgusting.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад

      The project hosts are paid more than politicians. How many properties do they have? You think they really care about this story?

  • @Bel_leonie
    @Bel_leonie 24 дня назад +5

    Sarah u nailed it. Hasn’t changed. I raised my 3 adults kids on my own. And it was traumatic in housing at times stalked by drunks living on a lane way. The DV system is pathetic also.

  • @JA-yf7hc
    @JA-yf7hc 25 дней назад +5

    Shows the limitations of authorites - they lack teeth to deal with what needs to be done.
    Good reminder to be well schooled so you give yourself and any children the best start from your own hands.They should play this in schools - choose your future !

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад

      Who does best in schools? Non Australian background children. It's all about priorities and upbringing.

  • @bubblesdelight
    @bubblesdelight 24 дня назад +3

    The Government need to start being held accountable for profiting off this type of behaviour and way of living. It's disgusting that these Governments keep getting away with it , this is absolutely know coincidence they way the people a living!

  • @susanlazzaro7415
    @susanlazzaro7415 26 дней назад +7

    Government, politics don't give a dam about what's going on in this country , theses people should not be living in theses conditions, our children are our future. ,,, SHAME on our government

  • @deant6361
    @deant6361 24 дня назад +4

    The sad thing about this place is that there are some really good people who live here but there are some that are dangerous and the mentally unwell. You need to see it to believe. I’ve seen Sydney’s housing also and they don’t come close to Melbourne.

  • @alyssaoconnor
    @alyssaoconnor 26 дней назад +7

    This is city living, the housing apartments have always been worse than the stand alone housing (even though the housing suburbs are bad enough). This is why the big push for mass building in major cities is a bad idea.

    • @Pups195
      @Pups195 21 день назад +1

      Nailed it. I live in the CBD and I've seen and heard horror in new apartment buildings. Not as rife as commission but it's there.

  • @kreagle
    @kreagle 27 дней назад +18

    …been like this for decades. Media interest a wake up call? Poverty is a problem since dot.

  • @malexander2438
    @malexander2438 25 дней назад +4

    How is this even legal? Where are the regulators?

  • @samanthafairweather9186
    @samanthafairweather9186 24 дня назад +4

    Park Towers is just like Northcott in Surry Hills Sydney.
    The only difference is Northcott isn't as tall, but has multiple buildings in the complex.
    I'm lucky to live in a good Houso building with only 7 units, and almost all my neighbours are elderly, so it's really quiet. I thank my lucky stars evey day!

  • @LaurenSmith82
    @LaurenSmith82 27 дней назад +7

    Sick sad world

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад

      The world was and is fine without humans.

  • @roddyscott9498
    @roddyscott9498 27 дней назад +12

    These towers look like the ones straight out of Scotland and the UK.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад +3

      Every country has cities with these housing and social problems. It's nothing new.

    • @plaidshirt9955
      @plaidshirt9955 24 дня назад +1

      Yes, they were modeled pretty much directly off of the British ones. They probably even have the same floorplans.

    • @roddyscott9498
      @roddyscott9498 23 дня назад +4

      @@plaidshirt9955 straight out of trainspotting

  • @virginiawilliams7790
    @virginiawilliams7790 24 дня назад +4

    Druggies need to be in some sort of program and housing where they are helped and supervised daily and not left to languish on their own until they are clean. Then they need training for work. But I can only dream I suppose. I saw something like this happening in America where an entrepreneur put so much of his own money into it as the government bodies would not do a thing. There were some great outcomes for some.

  • @wend2239
    @wend2239 27 дней назад +12

    This is just so deplorable. It is something you'd have got in 1970s ghettos of NY...not in this day n age Australia...not good enough...

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 26 дней назад +3

      Not just NY its the same with city apartment public housing all over the world, its never worked to concentrate the poverty class into a small area.

    • @wend2239
      @wend2239 26 дней назад +2

      @@alyssaoconnor it shouldn't be and never was this way in Australia....something happened for the worse and the govt is ruining this country.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад

      US cities don't have slums and ghettos in 2024? 😮
      At least these people don't have guns too...

    • @waratahwoman
      @waratahwoman 20 дней назад +1

      @@wend2239 Nothing has changed.Same issues in the early 1980s in Richmond towers where I lived during primary school. I had grew up very fast, witnessed things no child should experience.This model does not work!

  • @stevenloynds3691
    @stevenloynds3691 27 дней назад +6

    You have no idea how bad it is.....

  • @beld6113
    @beld6113 27 дней назад +11

    Similar issues at the Sydney Towers in Waterloo..no suprises there 🤨

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад +1

      And in every other city around the world....😮 People who have no money want to live in an expensive city?

  • @MrJohnnybe123
    @MrJohnnybe123 24 дня назад +3

    The truth is it has been like that for decades and nothing will ever change. If you want to get out, you need to get a job.

    • @AussieBeautyMaven1987
      @AussieBeautyMaven1987 День назад

      😂😂 yes because gaining employment is so easy in this country, especially with our economy and the rapid rate of businesses shuttung down....but do carry on telling people they need a job... 😐🤦‍♀️

  • @loulouedmo
    @loulouedmo 25 дней назад +4

    I hope the women with children can get out of that city and find housing & work in the regional areas. Cities are sewers for those who aren’t rich

  • @kimsherlock8969
    @kimsherlock8969 26 дней назад +6

    Wonderful documentary report 👏 👌 👍 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉xxxx XXX

  • @TheRose5357
    @TheRose5357 27 дней назад +6

    Heartbreaking to say the least. Even when you think you can help the people there is evil is living there .

  • @atw98
    @atw98 24 дня назад +4

    Go to new housing towers Midtown Macquarie Park Sydney. Its not even full and police there daily. Assaults drugs and nuts screaming. And theyve built 900 units with no reasources.

  • @thewokestoner8528
    @thewokestoner8528 27 дней назад +46

    Looks like The Project is trying to piggy back off Spanians success 😂

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад +7

      There is an old saying in the media: if it bleeds , it Leads !

    • @Deemay5555
      @Deemay5555 27 дней назад +9

      I think they are trying to act like they are for the people when really they just care about themselves

    • @RebeccaRussell-cc3pf
      @RebeccaRussell-cc3pf 27 дней назад +7

      Totally, thank god for spanian shedding light on this side of life. It's not right. Send the army in to keep people safe. Lock up the crime mate

    • @Krudd07
      @Krudd07 27 дней назад

      @@RebeccaRussell-cc3pfokay boomer I don’t think that’s what spanian wanted Bec haha

    • @juleneyoung5053
      @juleneyoung5053 24 дня назад +2

      I don’t think Spanian has been there yet ?

  • @thegreatbarrerquief7473
    @thegreatbarrerquief7473 23 дня назад +3

    There should be separate living for women and children.

  • @Infinityloveforever7
    @Infinityloveforever7 26 дней назад +4

    Due to the mass child removal of children in public housing in NSW there’s no children left here to be in any danger which is very sad as families should be supported to stay together yet families are torn apart due to poverty and children placed in far far far worse circumstances. I live in the Redfern towers in Sydney. 😢

  • @TheCourse872
    @TheCourse872 26 дней назад +13

    Sending hundreds of millions to Ukraine and Israel but can’t even fix this fixable problem

    • @Damonicus1
      @Damonicus1 25 дней назад +3

      This is a State issue, not Federal. No State is sending a single cent to international concerns.

    • @TheCourse872
      @TheCourse872 25 дней назад

      @@Damonicus1 don’t think small bro.

  • @ItzJuniorBruh91
    @ItzJuniorBruh91 22 дня назад +3

    I lived in the North Richmond flats from when I was 13. I seen/heard a lot of things growing up there. I live in South Australia now & i'm 33 this year. I visit my old girl from time to time & let me tell you this... NOTHING has changed sadly. It's gotten worse since they put the injection room there.

  • @NormanFinkelstein9863
    @NormanFinkelstein9863 27 дней назад +12

    All the easy shots at the Govt, but we'll see if the Project can develop enough mock outrage for even a follow up story. If this has been ongoing for so long (it has) why have the media been so missing in action in the reportage of the problem?
    Why does it take one of the show's hosts to have a personal history in social housing for a programme like the Project to take an interest ? ? If wealthy people were suddenly forced to live here the problems would be fixed quick smart...

    • @Lowqualitystuff
      @Lowqualitystuff 27 дней назад +1

      EXACTLY

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 26 дней назад +1

      The project hosts are multi millionaires. Sarah was educated in Queensland. Her house in Sydney is worth several million dollars.
      How did an explosion in Sydney trigger this story in Melbourne? Maybe ask Spanian 😂

  • @Yirragee
    @Yirragee 27 дней назад +13

    Must be nice looking from crystal palaces. Everyone is one fall away 😢

  • @kgb2905
    @kgb2905 25 дней назад +7

    Merkel,van Leyden and Macron MUST pay for repatriation.POINT.

  • @he.5865
    @he.5865 27 дней назад +35

    Worst government in the country.

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад +2

      *State Government

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад +2

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @veronicacurrie3449
      @veronicacurrie3449 24 дня назад

      This has been going on with both Goverments for a long time !

    • @kirk5152
      @kirk5152 19 дней назад

      Other than NSW

  • @JoTracy
    @JoTracy 22 дня назад +1

    Same thing happened to our building in Redfern since the Pandemic
    The top floor was given over to a Homeless Charity, and it has made all our lives Hellish

  • @harrypotter506
    @harrypotter506 27 дней назад +7

    Need better spread public housing

    • @essdee5876
      @essdee5876 24 дня назад

      That's the answer 💯

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад

      Sure, can I use my contractors to build social housing near your place?

  • @joanamiranda9418
    @joanamiranda9418 27 дней назад +22

    Expose this government at every opportunity
    Worst state

  • @hellohello8556
    @hellohello8556 27 дней назад +10

    The way less desirable members of the community are consolidated into places like those flats every block of highrise should all have there own police station manned 24/7 and patrols 24/7.

  • @SRM-kh9eg
    @SRM-kh9eg 26 дней назад +9

    Just a pov - consider that these people are left there to maintain a sense of “importance” for the working/middle/slave class that’s, suspiciously, also left seriously wanting…the money is there, make absolutely no doubt about it. Just DELIBERATELY not for “us”.

  • @truthhurts5510
    @truthhurts5510 24 дня назад +3

    The security guards are getting abused daily according to friend working there, Have you interviewed them or listen to their perspective?

  • @arclux
    @arclux 27 дней назад +12

    There are no easy answers.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 27 дней назад +1

      What country doesn't have similar problems? Australia is not unique. People need to travel and realise there are worse places than Australia. Why do so many want to come here? 😮

    • @mr.melontoyou
      @mr.melontoyou 27 дней назад +2

      @@multioptionedcos they don’t actually know what it’s like here.

    • @noramaddy4409
      @noramaddy4409 25 дней назад +1

      It just requires investment. Unfortunately, Australia is a country that fosters social arrogance that is unkind and unwilling to address the issues that will eventually destroy the country.

    • @arclux
      @arclux 25 дней назад +1

      @noramaddy4409
      You could give every one of them a million dollars and most of them would be back there in 12 months. Some people don't want or can't be helped. It is what it is.

  • @ellap364
    @ellap364 23 дня назад +2

    SHAME ON THE GOVERNMENT....YOU ARE DESPICABLE ALLOWING THIS TO CONTINUE!!!!!!!

    • @jaddy11mash
      @jaddy11mash 20 дней назад

      They are doing it ! I won’t believe what’s happening

  • @tonycostanzo4276
    @tonycostanzo4276 27 дней назад +6

    Politicians will not help the poor people, they will help their own pay packets .they have the power to do so .its all about money not you, and they will move in people from over seas not true Australians

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 23 дня назад

      God, and politicians, helps those who help themselves...😮

  • @Jaiden-kp9dy
    @Jaiden-kp9dy 14 дней назад +1

    Exactly the same in my housing units at Gosford. Disgusting

  • @accessdenied3350
    @accessdenied3350 25 дней назад +3

    Good luck, Victoria is almost 200 Billion in debt

  • @devonrexcatz
    @devonrexcatz 22 дня назад +2

    My grandmother lived in the Inkerman Street, St Kilda units. When she was placed in hospital, her unit was ransacked and everything taken or trashed...my grandfather's horse racing trophies were taken as well as other memorabilia. We suspected someone within the complex but the police would not investigate. They were poor, on a pension. She also had her engagement rings taken by an in-home carer (just another violation 😒 they endured).

  • @heatherhigson342
    @heatherhigson342 23 дня назад +1

    This is absolutely horrendous, where’s the mayor ??? … he needs to get this sorted , it’s beyond a joke …

  • @vascoemyer
    @vascoemyer 23 дня назад +1

    Fitzroy Towers ... same. Yet four floors in Richmond - renovated, empty for years?

  • @samuelmmmk181
    @samuelmmmk181 26 дней назад +2

    Been like that since I was a kid, all the towers are pretty much the same

  • @kenphillis8605
    @kenphillis8605 21 день назад +1

    Just wow , I think a private investigator needs to collect evidence on the ones causing harm and eviction notice to them , also better security on top and bottom floors,.

  • @essdee5876
    @essdee5876 27 дней назад +10

    And if you tell DHHS, they'll gaslight everyone and accuse them of wanting to just "upgrade their housing". 99 of 100 workers don't care. The 1 that does feels helpless and leaves.

  • @Akerfuffle
    @Akerfuffle 26 дней назад +5

    Conscription at 18! 3 years minimum. Convictions... conscription minimum 5 years in the middle of nowhere!! Our society is crumbling as it rots as each year passes!

  • @joynicolson4158
    @joynicolson4158 25 дней назад +6

    Nice one Victorian Government AND Greens 🤬👹

  • @laurap3244
    @laurap3244 24 дня назад +2

    It's all by design - now the contracts for re-development and low-income housing will go to certain developers close to the right people. They let these places rot so they can revitalise them for profit.

  • @josephinefairlie9007
    @josephinefairlie9007 23 дня назад +1

    The waiting list for public housing in Victoria is waaaay longer than stated in this doc!

    • @a.k7889
      @a.k7889 15 дней назад

      I was wondering that! I live in Queensland, but I did think those waitlist times they quoted were VERY quick…

  • @patriciafinn5717
    @patriciafinn5717 24 дня назад +1

    Very sad..whoever built these towers need to make amends now.. so so tragic for anyone to live here...sort it out now.😢

    • @plaidshirt9955
      @plaidshirt9955 24 дня назад

      The government paid for it but you can thank the church for pushing the agenda to remove families from their ground level homes and into these soul destroying towers, to live with predators, in Melbourne at least.

  • @fionawalpole2122
    @fionawalpole2122 27 дней назад +15

    Women and children only block maybe??

    • @commonlawrights9514
      @commonlawrights9514 27 дней назад

      They can go buy their own house if they don’t like it rather than sponging off the community

    • @Lowqualitystuff
      @Lowqualitystuff 27 дней назад +2

      @@commonlawrights9514what do u mean by that? I’m confused cuz I keep seeing u on every reply

  • @missstayc
    @missstayc 13 дней назад

    Im a male and i would be terrified to live there... Dont forget men need protection from this violence

  • @lindamac2
    @lindamac2 27 дней назад +10

    Housing NSW are the worse. Never fix anything.

    • @MrJohnreader
      @MrJohnreader 27 дней назад +5

      cause many of the residents keep wrecking the place so why should housing NSW fix stuff?

    • @ld5382
      @ld5382 27 дней назад +1

      This is in Victoria…

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад +8

      @@MrJohnreaderThat’s a big generalisation. Do you live Ain Public housing? Have you ever lived in Public Housing, or are you just an armchair critic?
      I’ve lived in Public housing and have had decent people for neighbours in the past…

    • @paulsz6194
      @paulsz6194 27 дней назад +3

      @@MrJohnreaderPerhaps you can go and write up Op-Ed’s for the Guardian titled : " The world according to me"..

    • @samanthafairweather9186
      @samanthafairweather9186 24 дня назад +5

      @MrJohnreader I'm in public housing. I don't wreck stuff, and neither do my elderly neighbours. So you keep sitting there, sipping your latte, while we continue to live in the REAL WORLD!

  • @HN-ol7oz
    @HN-ol7oz 27 дней назад +2

    Indeed, no one should have to live under such conditions. However, the question remains: who will bear the cost of the repairs? It’s important to note that we’re not discussing a solitary structure. Should the expense fall on taxpayers? Many refer to the government, but it’s essential to recognize that the government consists of individuals who are funded by tax revenues. So, ultimately, who is responsible for the payment?

    • @alyssaoconnor
      @alyssaoconnor 26 дней назад +2

      If we taxed the minerals and resource giants we could fix the problem 10 times over.

    • @multioptioned
      @multioptioned 25 дней назад

      Why governments are getting out of public housing and giving responsibilities to private sector. Taxpayers can only pay so much.

  • @staceyblundell7667
    @staceyblundell7667 22 дня назад

    Stuck in a housing house in nsw after the courts order them to move me 3 years ago and they rejected the transfer. They keep getting the road of other services helping me and say they want him to breach avo that's no longer in place.. he is out of jail anyday now!

  • @lukecarey613
    @lukecarey613 25 дней назад +2

    Why is this a surprise?

  • @mickzammit6794
    @mickzammit6794 26 дней назад +2

    We all knew it would happen.

  • @thetechman143
    @thetechman143 27 дней назад +1

    Its always been like that there, in Melbourne..covid made things quiet for a bit and then eventually back to normal. It has always been like that.

  • @monsel97
    @monsel97 27 дней назад +2

    More of a police matter first.

  • @home8630
    @home8630 27 дней назад +3

    This situation is fixable. It requires everyone involved working together. And the blame shifting and scape goating has to stop first. It's not good to have to rely upon government for everything. The media can also be a part of the solution. It begins with I care, I and we don't want to live like this and we want better for you...but it requires everyone to come to that decision.There also needs to be equality with dignity. It's also not a quick fix and blaming the current government for the whole problem, for ignoring the fact that people that are given social housing are treated less than and given less than has been going on for ages. People need to stop behaving like they are animals. Stop blaming the pandemic for everything. People need to take responsibility of what they need to take responsibilty for. Government are not wanting to put the time, effort into this until people stop behaving like vile, agressive animals, there also needs to be listening.

    • @veronicacurrie3449
      @veronicacurrie3449 24 дня назад

      The so called goverment should of done their research as to how this crammed situation would have played out ! But instead we have people in charge who have no idea they are just interested in getting paid. unfortunately