IIT prof reacts to his own student's video (Tharun Speaks)!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 ноя 2021
- Tharun from the "Tharun Speaks" channel is one of my students here in the Mechanical Engineering Department of IIT Kharagpur. Recently he made a video on his experiences in the Department and he discusses about opportunities and career prospects in this line. Overall his message is positive. But, he made some contentious remarks which I thought I should respond to. So, here is a reaction video.
Link to the original video by Tharun: • IIT Kharagpur - My 3 Y...
Video by: Dr Jeevanjyoti Chakraborty, Mechanical Engineering Department, IIT Kharagpur
Fill this form if you wish to post a question to me for a deeper discussion: forms.gle/M3ksxwjJHSB9zB4D7
Interesting questions, comments from the above form may be featured in future RUclips videos.
Website: www.facweb.iitkgp.ac.in/~jeeva...
GitHub: github.com/jeevanjyoti4
Twitter: / jeevanjyoti
Blog: jchakraborty.wordpress.com/
Disclaimer: I am a faculty member in the Mechanical Engineering Department of IIT Kharagpur. However, the views expressed in this video are my own and do not necessarily represent those of my Department or my Institute.
#TharunSpeaks #reaction #iitkharagpur
Fill this form if you wish to post a question to me for a deeper discussion: forms.gle/M3ksxwjJHSB9zB4D7
Interesting questions, comments from the above form may be featured in future RUclips videos.
agar basic jaruri hai too fir sirf basic hi padna chahiyen
4:22 yes it was necessary
4:56 YES IT IS IIT TRUE
Man I am stumbled by the fact that you use Linux with a tilling window manager. So nice!
@@somerandomuserfromootooob I do not use arch, btw. :)
This is like "father watching his son's attitude status"😂😂😂
😅😂👍🏻
😂
THIS COMMENT MADE MY DAY 🤣🤣👍
Haha
😂
Thanks for the detailed breakdown of the video, Sir. I completely agree to everything you said🔥🔥
Ahh ... the man himself! "Everything" you say, hmm? :)
@@Prof_JC lol
@@Prof_JC 😂😂
😅🔥
@@Prof_JC Sir plz tell me I am confused whether to go with nsut ece or iit kgp mining btech
Plz tell sir !
Most Dangerous line: All the best for your 4th year.😂
ye toh gaya kam se😄😄
😂
😂😂😂
khatam
lol
I am myself an IITian and I must say every IIT needs more such open profs like you! Loved it:)))
Thank you!
@@Prof_JC I'm in last year of graduation, I have never seen such a empathetic, sensible and patient teachers
also ur English is a lot better than any of my teachers.
@@Kartik_Z8 Thank you immensely for the kind words. And, I, in turn, must commend you on your choice of words! And, all the best for your final year!
bhai aap toh diffrent prajati ke ho
I am your 1000 like
Teachers schooling students on RUclips... now that's a new genre 😂 .. loved it sir
Ikr.... Literally made my day, already
Professor video got more views .................... nobody cares about student :) only professor
TBH it's cool
I hope to see this genre rise!
😂😂😂
It's like the teacher checking your assignment in front of u 🤣
Now, that is a great idea for a separate video! Just kidding ... not going to happen.
He can't even slide the assignment in the center of the bunch. RUclips algorithm didn't let him do that xD
@@Prof_JC would be great if it happens, xD!
@@mj9765 bruh
Rather it's like the teacher checking your assignment in front of the whole world. 🤐
Iconic lines from the professor:
"this is bad" 😥
"Oh my god" 😩
"IF you actually become a mechanical engineer" 😋👹
"I was a very good student. OFCOURSE"💅✨
Sir I have attended your mechanics class in my 1st year in Spring 2019 . That course is still helping me in Engineering Geology .
I really liked teaching your batch.
@@Prof_JC sir I have studied a mechanical engineer from tier 3 college due to negligence of my intermediate days only prepared for public and not opted any coaching centres after joining mechanical engineering as passion i understand that is completely shit in tier 3 college so I prepared java and SQL from 2 year 2 sem so that to get a job and at 4rth year I got tcs job but one thing I want to say is studing core branches in tier3 is completely shit no knowledge no placements no proper labs and no technology in education.
How you doin today?@@adityasantosh6609
This professor is an absolute legend. I hope to make it to an IIT and be taught by such great professors
Ghiste reh jaoge
@@v5q211 haa lekin bas exam ke pehle din 😂
yes me too. hope to get schooled by an IIT professor on youtube soon
Why though?
@@ifigetbannedagainyoutubeis2018 Ur yt career seems to be going well
To be a good engnieer, cracking JEE alone is not sufficient. You have to have some passion for engineering as well. This student completely lacks passion. I studied in IIT Delhi. Professors of IITs are amazing people. They have strong fundamentals. They are up-to-date with the advancements in their technical field. I got completely transformed during my IIT days.
Thank you for the kind comment. After JEE one has to put in a tremendous amount of sustained, dedicated effort to even become worthy of being called a proper engineer much less a good engineer.
@@Prof_JC Sir, you are so fast! Thank you for hearting my comment :)
One more additional comment - many of the professors I met during my IIT days namely Prof. PMV Subbarao, Prof. SR Kale, Prof. Sangeeta Koli are still my role models. They are geniuses in their respective fields, moreover they are so friendly with their students.
True. The relatively junior professors have a lot to learn from such senior people!
True sir ur videos are helping a lot to develop these passion.
Me as an MBBS student listening to it while completing my histology journal
Kyu bhai 😂😂 padh le.. NEET PG dena hai!!
If we have professors like him, surely India has a great future.
we do, but they're in IIT, NIT, sadly very few in Tier 3 which I'm in, in my college teacher teach as if it's a 9 to 5 job
@@siddhant3457 true as fuck. 😟😟😟
@@siddhant3457 Even in IITs it is a bit rarer than you think.
@@siddhant3457 true
India will have a great future when they address the stream design mismatch with industry demand pointed out by both the Prof and the student. Then everyone will be happier: students, profs, industry, economy and society.
But that requires major reforms which will be opposed tooth and nail from all sides.
I'm in IITB Aerospace department and none of the profs. here are as chill as you :D
Now your prof will react to this comment.
@@adityanarayan5641 🤣🤣
@@adityanarayan5641 i was about to write the same
Same name
Same game
@@adityanarayan5641 😂😢
I'm currently studying Robotics at CMU, and I felt your video is extremely pertinent specially to students who want to do cutting edge work in interdisciplinary areas. My background is from CS and I recognize the shortcomings of my mathematical know-how when I see my cohort, many of them MechE from various IIT's who have a stronger grip on aspects of kinematics and manipulation. Of course, I have a stronger know-how of other aspects, but the basic foundations are extremely important and should be learnt as early as possible. Mechanics, Linear Algebra, 3D Geometry and Calculus of Variations remains the same no matter what treatment you are exposed to.
Thank you. I hope the junior students get your message.
@@Prof_JC Thank you for you service, Professor. I saw some of the other videos you posted, will keep following for advice.
hey, if you dont mind me asking, how did you get in for undergrad at cmu?
@@betabeast12 I'm a graduate student at CMU. I got my CS undergrad degrees from IIIT-H. Did a few years of research there and at an industrial lab.
@@AnuragGhosh_Xel Can you tell should one join cs in iits like roorkee,guhawati ,hyderabad (after the old 5 ones) or iiith ?
Very nice explanation sir!! I am an MTech graduate from IIT KGP from 2013 in EE. I work as Assistant Prof. at a deemed university in Odisha. I would really like to add one thing to this sir!! Core students do very well in software-based jobs or coding jobs. I have seen them sometimes outperform CSE students. That's because of the problem-solving skills which they develop when they go through tough subjects like MECH, EE, etc. Programming skills can be developed in less time but Problem-solving skills cannot be developed at once, they gradually come out of our brain when we train our brain through tough problems. That's why, a Mechanical, EE, ECE student can get into IT/Software any day but the reverse is not true. May be u r not working in the core, but the problem-solving capability u develop through core subjects helps u to excel in IT. This a students need to understand. Thanks!!!!
Nice
Crystal clear
Wow sir 🙏
This is really a comment I needed as a ME student.
If you are not into CSE how can you simply degrade this world changing filed Computer Science. Maybe one can learn coding and programming but it's not all that we learn in computer science from theory of automata, theory of discrete mathematics, architecture of computer, microprocessor, development of operating system, to the series of algorithms and fascinating concepts of computer science....
The coding is just a surface.
Very nice video Sir! It's really great to see your insights on matters like these. After graduating in mechanical engineering from one of the IITs, many of my friends joined jobs in different kinds of profiles - core job in big established companies, core job in start-ups, software jobs etc. And as I talk to them regularly, I can clearly say that the theories learnt in B.Techs do help. It's just that if someone works in a very big company, many basic things have already been worked on and therefore, it may feel like we are not utilising the B.Tech courses. But that is true only on a superficial level. It would be very hard to operate specialised software or deal with new situations (for example, if something goes wrong somewhere) if someone has not studied the basics because these basics enable us to think in a logical systematic manner. And in start-ups, the involvements of even the basic concepts of mechanical engineering are much much more because there, many things have to be worked on from scratch. And just to give a balanced perspective (related to the distortion energy point), not directly utilising basic things happens in software jobs too. I know many people working in big software companies and they say that they did not have to implement basic data structures like linked list in the job. But of course again, if the person had not studied linked list and basic data structures and algorithms, I don't think they would be able to do their job properly because those things have enabled the person to be capable of handling the job duties (like the basic skills of debugging codes etc.), similar to the way the basic theories have enabled a mechanical engineer to handle responsibilities in core jobs.
You said it so very coherently. I wish there was a way to pin this comment at the top! Many thanks.
@@Prof_JC there is a way Sir
Just click on Three dots in this particular comment and Select pin option
@@sumitthakur9661 Awesome tip! Just did it. Many thanks! :)
ruclips.net/video/iYhLV5Y_FpM/видео.html
Damn thats so long
This video made my day , people always judge mechanical engineering and civil students as lesser than CSE and IT . Can't argue with them because don't have much time and mind to waste , there's part in this video when you smiles and quote " without mechanical civil electrical engineers society will collapse" that just gave me more love for what I am doing. Loved it❣️
That's what you say when you can't get CSE/IT.
@@RadecX1 chalo yeh bhi sahi hai
Vai listen to sir again
Jobs in core are less and also lesser paying than job in CSE/ITbranch. An pura industrial Process hi mechanised ho gaya kisi din with help of AI and robotics, then what will you do?
@@adee6467 abhi electric car ko kitna he advance krloge yr sheet metal ki motor ki tyres ki raw material ki toh requirement toh rhegi he na? I've never seen somebody driving a car made out of software all alone even computers are also designed by mechanical engineers
@@sukhwindersingh-yq9cy are to ye koi nhi bol raha no jobs exist. Job to history, sanskrit ma hons ke baad mil jata hai.
Paar kisme zyada scope ha? Sanskrit hons ya maths hons? Scope aur average salary bhi to important ha na vai?
Agar tumko lagta hai mechanical ka scope CSE barabar ha, then okk. No further argument
7:58 . That's what I always wanted to hear sir. Everyone of my friends who are planning for engineering says that are all these equations really useful in our life??? You explained exactly as I wanted it to be
I have explain the importance of calculus/theory/equations etc in many different words. This is the most concise and eloquent explanation I have heard
I've never liked one major aspect of education. We're expected to make long term decisions on our career pathway at the age of 17. I am currently 25 and to this day can struggle with my career path irrespective of job. I may be passionate about my field but these passions change, so does our curiousity. It's mind boggling tbh.
True.
Exactly
Real
Professor laughing at some clips in the video, very similar to the reaction of a student watching tharun's video. Good review Sir.
Prof was also a student once! :)
@@Prof_JC Yes sir, I have seen that in the video 😂
The video he is talking about is ruclips.net/video/bB6TvY3dOK0/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/iYhLV5Y_FpM/видео.html
Being an engineer myself, during my student days, I felt the same about the courses and it's application in the real world. Due to herd mentality, all the students get the same perception that what we study is not relevant in the industry today. And students don't take the word of the faculty on it even if they say it is important. The best solution to this problem imo is to bring an external Industry working professional and let him take a seminar where he/she can review the syllabus infront of the students and explain its importance with keeping the industry aspects in mind and share it'd application in day to day work in that field with real life example. This will actually make students believe that what they are taught is really useful. And really good video sir.
I don't completely agree that rank determines what you get in IITs. My son secured an AIR of 157 in jee advanced 21. With this rank he could have easily got cse in top ranked IITs such as iitm. However, it was his dream to study Mechanical in iitb. As parents we are happy with his choice. We understand that job opportunity in the core branches is less. But is that not known? You need to focus on long term goals instead of short term (easy money). There are ample of opportunities. You just need to be in the right track to grab it. Follow your passion, and opportunities will kiss your feet.
Wow, I really respect him for choosing the stream based on his interest. Most people would have chosen CSE with that kind of rank even if they did not know a thing about computers. But he did the right thing by choosing what he is truly passionate about.
At last he gives up and goes for software placement!
@@Okiedokieyes no sir...i have been knowing some seniors who have done.btech in mech and the subject interested them so much that they have gone to the level of phd and now are working in R&D with complete passion..mechanical engineering is passionate-a student of iit kanpur mechanical eng😁😁
Study well and come to United States.
@@sanchitkumar6945 no, I'll be working for my country to make it better
As an ME undergrad who want to get into reasearch, your words are quite motivating sir! Going for research in premier institute with a good specialization is not an easy task and doesn't have financial benefits initially and instantly but I think it worth it.
Omg ....I'm going to persue Naval in IIT MADRAS this year and planning to start a utube channel but when I look at this I'm like proff are themselves keeping an eye on their students in the most impossible way .......My reaction was like BAAP RE BAAP ....bach ke rehna hai....
Proffs are actually cool........and of modern age....
And love you sir for the clarity....I watched the video till the very end ..
It's really commendable that the prof is so involved that he wants the upcoming students shouldn't be misled. Simple yet very effective decision by the prof to dispel the rumours spread by a irresponsible youngester.
*mislead
@@mohtasimbillah8708 misled*
Misal pav*
You are such a cool professor! Your analysis was so unbiased and to-the-point. You gave the boy credit where he deserves, and stated the facts where it was needed. Wishing you all the best professor!
This was an eye opening talk. So many insights and valuable pointers. Appreciate the effort.
Got this video in recommendation, im also a mechanical student passed out this year but from a state private clg. It really connected me and gave me good knowledge. It's like a healthy discussion how a student and teacher have different perspective. Really loved it. ❤️
Ohh bhai prof reacting on students video is one of the most ultimate things at IITs
@jc Sir, what tharun said explains students' minds. He wasn't wrong except in few scenes he exxagarated maybe to make content attractive. What he said is even common and one can find such videos easily. But the editing skills is over-powered!!!
But what you did is very rare and it actually explains the whole scene. Thank you so much sir. Few things must have enraged you but keeping them apart and explaining the whole thing shows how the professors support the students.
I think @Tharun speaks! should share this video through his youtube handle, so even his audience can get the other side and a better perspective.
Thank You Sir!
Imagine what happen when tharun give copyright strick to his proff 😂😂😂
XDXDXDXD
Xd 😂
Was thinking the same
Sir you are damn savage. Me being a 3rd year Mechanical Engineering student , who loves doing this course , must say that industry never supports mech engg and they are forced to go for software jobs as they cant be without job post degree
Right.
This professor is a legend just for the tiling window manager, on probably a busted ThinkPad because the CPU usage jumps to 95 while recording and playing at the same time. LOL
I am not Luke Smith! :) I use a HP laptop like any other layman. The CPU usage jump has something to do with OBS.
@@Prof_JC idk prof I never saw you and luke Smith in the same room.
@@asrjy 😂
@@Prof_JC yes OBS is a pretty taxing application to run on a PC. It even lags down top of the line PCs
the tiling wm is what caught my attention
I'm from a govt college, core civil and I've managed to stick it because of how much I'm inclined towards it. There students in my year who aren't sticking to the core at all. But this video and a proper reaction from an experienced professor really helped me. Keep it up love seeing such videos which much more insight into loopholes we as students might make.
As a mechanical engineering graduate I can feel with Tharun.
I was from Tier-2 college and was passionate with mechanical engineering but reality is different.
I feel like my all hard work, time I given for this branch preparing and studying mechanical, trust me it's not worth it unless you don't care about money. But most of us indians are poor and we need lot of money to care about of our family.
If I did even 5% of what I did in CSE than mech,I could have got lot much better package than anyone. (Sorry I am not bragging 😭)
Package increases with time. Be patient. You are thinking too much.
@@js913 sadly, after 1 year working in indian Mech company I left mechanical for all good and now working in Cognizant.
There are many factors and benefits you will get in IT than mechanical, Offcourse unless you are from big mechanical MNC like Eaton, Atlas copco etc
Most of the so called IT jobs are just a high paying clerical Jobs for me, they just know how to use tools, but I doubt they would know or even willing to know how to create them. They are like 'ITI' jobs of CSE, anybody can do it by training just like they train ITI students. Apart from having more money in your account at the end of each month, there is nothing special in these jobs and I respect hardcore mechanical engineers more than these Infosys, TCS or Cognizant so called engineers, if not these companies people who do similar jobs in not so branded companies get 10-25k ( I know them personally). Just imagine what would happen if all study CSE before mechanical engines are invented. You would be walking to your office daily today. So I ask you to respect mechanical and stop overrating IT industry
@@aravind2624 Accept the fact that world is changing. Everything which can be done manually can be done automatically with programming and IT services. You have to be adoptive to the situation. IC engines will be Sooner or later will be replaced but you can't afford to replaced. You have to learn and be adoptive. There was a age for ITI, Mechanical and now it's age for IT, AI, Machine learning, IOT.
I will be glad to do a clerical jobs if it pays me alot and if it let me have a good life. Passion, inventions are secondary for me and for most of people as well. It's cold and harsh world out there. You can't feed yourself with passion.
@@overlord7096 I didn't ask you to leave your job and become mechanical engineer. But you're demotivating those who want to pursue them. These type of IT jobs are anyday available and any decent scholar can get in no Matter what is their past is and you can also get into Google once you enter IT industry if you get skills required (these skills doesn't require any schooling nowadays, of course Normal people like us can't do it even if we are given lifetime, so you don't need to regret your decision of not studying CSE in college) but that's not the case for mechanical or civil, innovation in these fields are drastically reduced and we don't even know what inventions we lost. So encourage people studying these fields, if they aren't satisfied like you in terms of pay, there is always IT to save the day just like in your case.
Thanks sir I really willed to opt Mechanical engineering after my 12 th (currently in 12th) as my brother is also a Mech Eng. but from a private college and he is also working now as a Data analyst . After seeing his. Journey from ME to software sector and this video by Tharun bhaiya I really doubted choosing M.E. .but this video got myself some confidence .
But let me clear JEE first
(Abhi JEE diya nahi aur badi badi baatein, sorry seniors :'-( )
RUclips algorithm loves these kind of videos .
I am not from IIT . I am from Jadavpur University, Kolkata and my domain is also not Mechanical rather I'm from Electronics and Telecommunication and I'm currently doing my M.Tech in Automation and Robotics. I strongly believe one thing that "Mechanical Engineering is the BAAP of all the engineering domains." When I entered the field of engineering after 12th, I didn't have much of a clear idea regarding the various branches. But later on I realized what's the importance of Mechanical engineering. It's like Mechanical gave birth to the field of engineering and it's above all the branches. By the time I realized this it was too late to change my domain. But never mind . I have immense respect for this field of engineering and also towards the people who took this field as their main passion and I strongly protest against the people who shows disrespect towards Mechanical Engineering. And one more thing that I personally believe , people may disagree with me is that engineering is not only about earning money and getting a very handsome salary package rather it's more of creating new things, improving the old things. We engineerings we are the creators of the society, we are not money earning machines. The scientists think and we engineerings, we make it happen in reality.
After watching the complete video, I have a feeling that the world needs more such teachers like you 👏🏻
It's like a Teacher is checking answer sheet of students and pointing out his mistakes.
Nice Video Sir
Elon musk 😇✌
lol
*Teacher
Sir I have attended your mechanics class in my 1st year in 2019 ... I love your teaching style
Hello!! I loved that class. :)
Indian Railways employs lot of mechanical engineers & as an HR Officer with more than three decades of my experience my observation reveals that by educational training & experience persons of this stream are much better in problem solving , much credit also goes to their mentors 👍
It's so good see some prof (and one of our super senior ;)) sharing a very true and unbiased perspective. Must share video.
Thanks a lot! Great to see you here.
Commerce student here but didn't get bored for whole 30 minutes, excellent explanation sir👍
Thanks for listening!
Same bro😂
same because i started watching tharun videos .
His edits are amazing
I too am a commerce student but am a fan of IITs as an institute and a university.
@@csehgal29 same here
Kudos to both the student and the professor for being honest on their part. The confusions that this student has is almost very common with the students across India irrespective of the course, perhaps this is because our curriculum and courses somewhere undermines the skill building part and providing perspective to the learner and focuses more upon covering huge theories. I often feel that students have a little liberty inside the classroom to ask questions, discuss the utility of the course and understand the philosophy of the course, all they do is to cover the prescribed syllabus, mug up facts and formulas and write the paper to secure good marks. The fact that the professor took the onus of responding to these misunderstanding, clarifying things and putting things into perspective is praiseworthy.
True!!👍👍
Dang, the level of scrutiny. I'm pretty sure his students enjoys his lectures.
I just graduated from IIT Bombay and I really hope all IITs get more teachers like you who are open to discussion and polite to the students. I personally have had a few really bad experiences with some professors in my department that completely ruined my experience at the college. Some professors just need to understand that times are changing and they cannot keep teaching in the ways they were taught 40 years ago.
imagine him reacting to his video "if online exams were an anime" 😂😂😂
Enemy I guess not anime
Yes, especially that whatsapp scene
I have successfully cracked Jee adv 2021 and got MECHANICAL IN IIT KGP
I hope I gonna rock there
😄
Same bro
A very warm welcome to IIT KGP and also to the Department!
Dear @jc. I have similar stories and experiences to share as you have in this video. I got into Mechanical Engineering purely by coincidence (due to my JEE rank and my parents’ preference for me to study in Delhi). Though my father taught physics, I didn’t know much about Mechanical but grew to like it by the time i reached the 3rd year at IIT Delhi. My teachers played a key role in mentoring me to pursue a PhD, which really made me excited and passionate about this branch. Now i work in diverse areas all because of the training i received during my formative years at IITD. I have been practising my craft at IITD as a faculty since 2011 and this has been the best journey life could have chosen for me. I remain as excited as ever every single day and would not want to swap my choice for anything else.
Dear Prof. Gupta, Many thanks for taking the time to share your experiences! You have echoed my feelings ... I wouldn't change it for anything else!
Hello sir, I am currently taking your nptel course on ideal fluid flow.
@@mahadevprasanth1697 I hope you are enjoying it.
First of all I am smiling while watching your video. How cool a professor does that ! Loved it !
Great move by professor , only can be expected from IITies and other such great institution. Internet boom and what not and not many would disagree that people tend to believe totally what they see and hear more . Now questioning the authenticity of the knowledge and the level of truth in the content you watch have become very important. And the professors coming forward with their opinion is not only balancing the bias but truely inspiring to hear you all .
I really loved "circuit branches", this gives me a lot of confidence as a first time watcher into the abilities of teaching and knowledge of professors ability to convey complex ideas succinctly
Once come in circuits branch then you will get to know
@@ShivamGupta-qp6fw I did my B.Tech from an Abstract Circuit branch my friend :).
Also taking the MOOCS Course, "From NAND to Tetris"
Building a computer from scratch using NAND gates
So I did and also currently am 🌻
@@itallstartedwhen wow nice i was from tier 3 College so in my college circuits branch and not good but yeah i got one job in software company
@@itallstartedwhen i tries nand to tetris in 9th standard, I read "but how do it know" too it was amazing, Did not went too far with practicals but still Did made few gates in HDL.
And tried making a 4bit ram in A logic simulator, along with some other cool things.
still missing those happy times 2 years back
i have been preparing for JEE 2022, its really hard for me to study subjects like Organic chemistry, which i know will be of no use to me, so I just left all the Reaction mechanism Part, better not to regret after not being able to solve Questions even after studying 😂.
Still have my Arduino somewhere around my house.
Hope I don't loose my curiosity and passion after this entrance exam. 😅.
@@mersenne2486 in 9th standard 😱😱😱😱😱. How do you even know something like that exists my friend. That is great man 🌻🌻🌻🌻
Such a brilliant piece of Explanation!🔥
Hope this reaches to every misinformed Engineer and fetches a Million views.
Thank you so much Sir for making this video. I agree on every point which you have made.
Prof proves that constructive criticism is way better than bitching and cancelling someone for small errors . Love the way he corrects where ever he feels wrong and appreciates on valid points
I wish this video’s link to be in Tharun’s video description. 😅.
I really thank the prof for this useful insight.
Thank you sir for the video..loved it.
Great Video, and Kudos to sir for analyzing the same so deeply. But I’d like to mention that while there are students who want to shift from core to circuital just looking at the placements, there are also students from the circuital side who turn away from the same to follow their passion. I’m an alumnus of IIT-KGP, B.Tech CSE (2014-2021) but by the second year, it was a strong realisation that hit me that leave CSE, not even engineering is what I wanted to do in life. Thats where I shifted away from the same and what being in IIT gave me is the opportunity to try my hands on fields such as Finance, BizDev and so on before I found Marketing as the field I’m passionate about. What IIT (especially KGP) also gives, which many forget, is that platform, and the worry-free path ahead towards trying what you want in life even if your department doesn’t suit you. With that, and having an amazing faculty advisor as a support, I pivoted to refreshing myself for CAT in my final year, and I’m happily in my second year at FMS Delhi, having found my passion and love, at an age when many still are trying to figure the same out.
Even if I get an opportunity to go back in time, even with the Year backs I had, I’d still happily choose KGP all the time. Kharagpur makes your personality apart from making you ready to face life, and gives ample opportunities to do what you’re passionate about.
Pleased to have professors like you.
Video full of informations.OP
It was an absolute rollercoaster of a video to watch!😅
Sure it was 😀😅
I found this video wholesome ,I wish everyone had a professor like you in their 🧬 life 🙂😊 or any uncle / mentor ,such soothing break down ,hope you're as good in person as you look in the video sir 😅
Down to earth sir....not only need best mechanical engineering but also best human beings just like you sir to society
Nice video!Got to learn a bit!
Hahah...
What a great concept by a teacher .
Really loved this
Would love to see more of such new concept videos 👍🏻
Really appreciate you sir to make this video, need a open and broad mindset to do that. Also, you have been respectful even when you disagreeed and have not taken things personally , an amazing quality to have.
Thank you for the kind words.
Once the teachers get on YT, it all over for us guys. They don't need fancy editing to get their message across. A great example here
Everyone's a gangsta untill their teachers come along.
Brilliant video
Thank you for appreciating the message despite a very poorly made video. I am trying to make the quality a little better for the more recent videos.
@@Prof_JC Will be following you sir. You have our support 🤗
One thing off about Tharun's video I felt is that it is much more concerned with job and not joy of learning. I understand its his time to be taking that one seriously but anyone who is yet to make a decision to be a part of this wonderful subject would be scared.
Even I am a freshly graduated guy so might be lacking some real experiences but just to let IIT/NIT/BITS mech guys know, you WILL get a job and a decent one (if you're not slacking off). Just do what interests you and mechanical is bag of balls of different colors, there'd be atleast one of your liking. So in initial years instead of running after DSA, focus on why you came to college for. Explore and Learn.
Thanks a lot sir for clearing up several points which were a little off.
Spoken like a proper senior guy! Yes, some of the points in the original video were presented in an extremely polarized fashion completely shorn of any nuance. So, I thought I'd bring some balance to the viewpoint.
Other than the tests and assignments, mechanical subjects are quite interesting. It is those tests and assignments which kills the interest. This sem I could not learn the things properly. In the beginning of the semester everything was going fine but suddenly everything became fast and almost everyday I have been busy with with assignments or preparing for the tests. It's like I need to complete the tutorials as quickly as possible before the exam so that I can score good. It would have been better if the sem has been longer
What is DSA?
@@tanmoytarafder8655 Data Structures and Algorithms
@@subhadeep_2001 I thought some political organisation, like in in my medical college , which has super bad influence on juniors.😑
Watching this as a JEE aspirant, i hope next year i make it to be your student and M.E :D
nice to see profs on youtube
cheers sir❤
and so sweet of you to be kind and not be rude at your student!
HOPE SCHOOL TEACHERS TOO DO THE SAME which will eventually reduce a lot of mental difficulties and suicides
[I myself faced a lot of trouble]
Thank you for the kind words.
I wish one day I could respond to situations in life in such calm manner and articulate my opinions to the rest of the world with clarity. Thank you sir. 🙏
Such a hardworking teacher....salute 🙏
I am Table Tennis player in IIT Delhi ❤️ and will meet u sir when I come to IIT kgp for inter IIT or other sports fests ....you are wonderful !!! 😍
Sir your personality really reflects through this video, brilliant breakdown!
Did tharun meet his teacher after watching his professor's reaction on his video??sir u r great..bcs u supported him when he was correct and corrected him when he was incorrect
You were absolutely right sir, I currently in Diploma in EEE ,sometimes I do feel why we need to study unnecessary things like pathograph working,angle of banking in electrical theory rather we aren't suppose to get a job in those areas ! But it is necessary to learn all this things to become a expert in a skilled job ! I am completely agree with your points
*Learning is different from Reading*
Thank you sir , I was really confused that did I do right thing by opting Mech. Eng. ? when I could have easily gotten into CSE but this video at the end puts full stop to all those doubts , I am thankful to myself that I chose Mech even when my family , friends and teachers were against that decision .
I think the student is rightfully frustrated for the choices he made, its just that the way he conveys is as expected of someone from his age. The value of mechanical engineering or anything for that matter is worth something to someone only if they have the passion to drive it forward. For example a guy who doesn't understand "Art" cannot learn to respect the value of underlying complex mechanics which makes a great art possible, same holds true for mechanical or any other stuff in life. The underlying problem here is that kids choose these courses to earn money, and they will continue to be frustrated as long as their underlying passion gets dominated by some 60 lpa yielding juicy job market.
Aptly put sir
Sir, you are such a wonderful teacher and analyst . Loved this reaction video ❤️🇮🇳
Great video sir I am a jee 2023 aspirant.. and I was worried after watching tharuns video.. but you have explained it very clearly and elaborated it.. thx sir for your valuable reaction on this.. 😅🙂
24:00 Sir is it really difficult to become an employer in core engineering, as startups in tech are pretty common ? Startups in core combine the love for the subject while having no financial limits, tho the huge capital requirements might seem tough to conquer to a fresh graduate (I'm in 12th).
Sahi bol raha hai bro + core mai ( exclude tech here) your product must be propietry (utility patent) otherwise you'll be eaten by big fishes. So you have to basically be at the brink of knowledge of your field then research and make a bump in human knowledge then somehow convert that into a product too. So yes it's hard in core, it'll be easier with tech cus all you need is 8 gb ram maximum.
I really enjoyed this video! Teacher and students are in an open platform of constructive criticism and appreciation.And the best line for me is that if money is the only important thing for one in his or her job then forget about happiness 😊.Thank you professor. Please make more videos.
Thank you for the kind words.
good one sir
u r clearing all the problems of students
tq soo much
imagine your teacher reacting to a video which u made on your own college experience.... i myself am getting goosebumps....
IT WOULD BE SO Amazing IF ALL IIT PROFESSORS MAKE RUclips CHANNELS AND START SHARING KNOWLEDGE in contrast to just teaching. India would rise to a whole new level then . Plz sir make this possible 🥲💛💛. It would motivate students from non-iits as well !
It was expected , I myself a teacher did phd from IIT.i found b.tech students highly one dimensional (hard work, good for job, extremely capable in analytics but poor in curiosity, original thinking) and system in which they are trained; is more like a pressure cooker rather than educational inst. We admire hard work so much that we neglect every other part. IIT SYSTEM survives on high population less seat model. Teachers are more focused on teaching "how, what" but completely misses on "WHY you study certain things".
what a humble teacher. love you, sir.
Great video sir! The fact that you took the time and calmly replied to tharun's video is really appreciated.
My opinion Tharun went there just for the tag "IITian" by which he runs his RUclips channel 😢
Loved the video sir 👏. Like your attitude which kind of reminds me of one of my professors who is also very passionate and encouraging the students to take relevant and unique projects in their btech and mini projects.
I wish more profs have their RUclips channel. Thanks a lot sir.
Sir, you are very patient 😅
Coming to what needs serious thought in the IIT system is the institute's expectations from an IITian. There can be two schools of thought (or maybe more):
1. Whether the IIT system wants to help a student in learning the subjects seriously and help them smoothly achieve the related professions with ease and strong fundamental knowledge in that subject.
2. Whether students are expected to explore the practicalities and hardships of life after left free and then settling down somewhere in a long run and struggles (not necessarily in engineering).
(Because the IIT system today is way different than that of 10-15 years before)
Funfact: this video got more views than the original one
Props to you, sir for putting out this video.
A great teacher doesn't stop teaching. Thank you Dr. Chakraborty!
7:50 Many so called "engg students" have always asked what will I do with a complex concept like that. They have started questioning even Calculus! (As a species, we humans are going south!)
My suggestion to such students is please join a Java coding course after your 10th and leave the engineering to real engineers and scientists.
Beautiful explanation, Students must understand the ideas behind the boring looking formulae
IITs have become like a market for Placements & packages . Most Students are coming for the IIT tag & packages , instead of subject passion or greed for knowledge.
Tharun Sir.. Thank you so much...
Sir this video might just revolutionize youtube for Indian teachers.
First time I've seen an indian professor critique someone on RUclips