Now, why am I not surprised? Add in Roy and Ralfy and you've got my daily check-in online. Between the four of you, you've advised in the building of a diverse, yet relatively compact, personal selection. It is being ever-refined over time. I have yet to buy my first independent bottling, but I'm looking to buy a couple of bottles of Strathmill and Blair Athol expressions. And, I am set to buy two luxury bottles (Glenmo Signet and Benromach 21) in celebration of my 70th this coming summer.
Excellent categories. I started with Speysides, back in the nineties. Glenfiddich was my initial selection, made after a hasty testing of a few different single malts then available. Cheap single malts. As time passed, I slipped into Glenfiddich's Solera and kept that in my cabinet for years. I had even purchased a bottle of Laphroiag 10 to show folks the wide variety of flavors in Scotch. It certainly tastes nothing like Glenfiddich Solera. Then, I went back to Scotland, to Orkney and the Shetlands, and I stumbled across Highland Park and their whiskys. Then, on my way home, I snagged a huge bottle of Highland Park Einar at the Duty Free shop in Heathrow. I was pleasantly surprised once I'd opened it at home. I fell hard for that flavor. Einar was IT. The problem was it was only available at Duty Free shops. In the UK. I have since filled my collection out in a vain Quest for a whisky to replace that bottle of Einar. Highland Park's offerings locally (Viking, Magnus, & Cask Strength) were trialed and did not measure up; that's my 'cask strength' bottle. Having an aversion to 'peated whisky' thanks to Laphroiag 10, I was searching for a 'hint of peat' in my desired flavor profile. I talked myself into a bottle of Lagavulin 16 (now my 'old' bottle), along with a much tamer Glen Scotia 15. Neither fit my profile. Talikser Storm was too peaty, as well. Meanwhile, I discovered that what I really liked was sherried whiskies and I went down that road in a big way...Auchentoshen, Glenmorangie, Bunnahabhain, Aberlour, and Glenfarclas, all well represented. I'm prolly underrepresented in the non-sherried and unpeated, mostly malty Scotches, although I think the Glenfiddich 12 comes close. I also dabbled in some American Single Malt whiskys and I highly recommend Westland Single Malt and Westland Peated Single Malt and almost anything produced by Stranahan's. I'm chomping at the bit to get me another bottle of Blue Peak. As for bourbon, I hear a very local outfit right here in PDX (home of Aviation Gin), known as Freeland, produces a really decent bourbon. Right now, I have a bottle of Woodford Reserve, which I'll replace once it has tapped out.
As always, top notch production quality. Really love the concept for this video of giving several options for each category. Even several years into my whisky journey I was able to add a few to my wish list to try! I just had a great experience introducing a group of beginners to whisky with the Glen Scotia Double Cask. It's affordable, easy to drink/not overpowering, and simply tastes delicious. 10/10 would recommend for a whisky that both beginners (and not only beginners!) can enjoy without breaking the bank! Really curious to try the GS Victoriana now. Soon... All the best!
I live in the United States Midwest (my state borders both Tennessee and Kentucky), and if you go to a grocery store, there’s entire isles of bourbon. Usually between a sixth and a fourth of all liquor options here are bourbon.
You've got to love a list video and this was a cracker, although its taken me an age to get caught up with this. Enjoyed putting my list together and we run on similar themes but slightly different lanes: Entry: Balvenie Doublewood Intermediate: Arran 10yo Sherried: Tamdhu 15yo (Shocker I know) Peaty: Kilchoman PX Sherry Cask: GlenAllachie BS Challenging: Laphroaig 10yo Sherry Oak Terroir: GlenAllachie 11yo Port Cask Older: Once the Glendronach 18 but that is now in the luxury category so I agree with the Arran 18 Bourbon: Makers Mark (Like Jon Snow I know nothing) World: Kavalan Solist Port Cask Local: Thompson Grain and Grape (But also like Cardrona, there bottle size not so much) Campbeltown: Kilkerran 8YO CS Indie: SMWS - mad scientist levels of experimentation Luxury: Tamdhu Gran Reserva
Those first 3 bottles were very similar to my first 3: had Laphroaig Select instead of 10 and Founder’s Reserve instead of 12. Think that was because of availability (supermarket)/price in UK. Great choice, they should be a staple in anyone’s collection. Aberlour 12 was my real awakening into whisky and no surprise it was around Christmas time - it’s such a festive drink 😄. Good to see importance of finding friends to share their faves, some of those like Craigellachie I wouldn’t have bought if it wasn’t for a friend who I swap samples with. You likely already have a bottle aware but wanted to mention Filey Bay as it’s currently my favourite English whisky, also Penderyn is a very bold Welsh whisky that I find divides my friends. Their port finish tastes like jam, I love that there’s distilleries out their pushing the envelope when it’s so tempting to play it safe. Glad to see your point about Japanese whiskies. I remember about 5+ years ago still being keen to have a bottle or two in my collection but hype has exceeded prices now.
Thanks Jim! I agree with all of that. I have never had the Filey Bay, sounds great! Hopefully some of it makes its to New Zealand for me to try. I really need to get some Welsh whisky in my collection. I used to have a bottle way earlier in my journey when i lived in the UK. For some reason though, it's hard to get here in NZ.
@@FirstPhilWhisky ….Phil, ever use The Whisky Exchange or Loch Fyne to get bottles that don’t hit NZ? The shipping to southern US is tough, maybe $40-45 per bottle, but the prices are so much better it’s still worth it. I realize they can’t deliver to some locales. Great channel, by the way. Thanks!
I agree. I have a selection of four. Compass Box Orchard House, Rock Island and Timorous Beastie from Douglas Laing, and Campbeltown Loch. It is now an active and fecund category worthy of having its own nominations.
I got 2 Glenmorangie Signet and every whisky lover should try this. Not necessarily owning one but at least taste it. The 16th whisky you should have is a limited edition cask strength. With all the info like date of casking, date of bottling, number of bottle etc just so you hold a piece of history
I end up changing my whiskey quiet a lot depending what I am exploring but I almost always have a Laphroaig 10, Redbreast 12 and the Arran 10. I feel like they are complex enough to not be boring but I can still share them with ppl that are not whisky geeks
I am a Kentuckian, so I was basically raised on bourbon. Rare Breed is legendary and absolutely one of the best bourbons I’ve ever owned. I just started watching this channel because I want to expand my horizons to Scotch and more world whiskies. I’ve learned so much in such short time. Cheers!
A must have in my collection would be Highland Park and Balvenie. Need to try some of the others you had but I’ve got a lot of them. Thanks for the list!
#1: I am quite proud of how many bottles iI have that either match your choices exactly or come very close, in every single category! #2: Speaking of Japan, can you / have you already / are you allowed to discuss(ed) the when, why,& what of the changes we’ll be seeing in the next few years?
A bit of order and clarity in that ocean of whisky, that's what your video is all about IMO. Letting aside the luxury ones, I tick all the other categories. Proud owner of a 60+ collection (the 2 infinity bottles not included) and waiting for another 2 (Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair and Loch Lomond Single Grain- took Roy's last VPub advice). Thanks for another great video. Cheers from Romania!
I really like Loch Lomond. The single grain is great. I recently picked both the peated and non peated versions and a single distillery blend from them.
Does it make sense to comment on a year old video? I do t know, but as a Scot who moved to the United States, the big gap I see here is Rye whiskey. The Wild Turkey is a bourbon with relatively high Rye content, and bumping up that spice level and body and going to something that’s rye based and not corn based is something you should really do. I don’t know what you can find in NZ, but I’d look for Michter’s Rye for a really easy smooth rye, Sagamore Spirit for something middle of the road, and Bulleit Rye for a 95% heavy rye whisky. All of those are budget options (at least domestically) but a great place to start.
I have been binge watching your videos. Great quality content with heaps of great information. I’ve always shied away from scotch because it has seemed so complicated but you are making it all very understandable. Keep up the good work.
Hi! I'm Brazilian. Fantastic vídeo. My list : First any Springbank, 2 Highland park 18 and CS, 4 Octomore, 5 Ardbeg Uigeadail, 6 Laphoaig PX, 7 Lagavulin 16, 8 Bunnahabhain toiteach Ada, 9 Bowmore 18, 10 aberlour abunadh, 11 kavalan solist any one, 12 Lamas First Ember Brazilian whisky, 13 Four Roses single barel bourbon, 14 Eagle rare ten years bourbon, 15 Glen Scotia Victoriana.
As a resident of Texas, I really enjoy some of the Texas whiskeys. I love almost everything that Balcones produces. Their Lineage is a real value for an American Single Malt at around $40 USD. Still Austin makes a really nice cask strength bourbon at around $70 USD and a nice Rye at 49.8% ABV for $44 USD and a cask strength version at 58% ABV for about $65 USD. Ironroot Republic makes some good bourbons in the $55-$65 USD, AND TX Bourbon is quite good at around $45 USD.
I Do have a small Collection of my own. 1. Highland Park 14 2. Royal Salute 21 Polo Edition 3. Macallan Lumina 4. Macallan Concept No.3 5. Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2008 6. Royal Brackla 12 7. GlenGrant 10 8. Chivas Regal 13 Caribbean Cask 9. Chivas Regal 13 Sherry Cask 10. Hibiki Master's Select Adding More and More...
Thanks Phil for another well thought out and well made video. This video will help newcomers to the Journey, and it will guide them with the insights and categories I wished I had when I first started. Great work. Cheers from Montreal!
Once again great video Phil, have been building up my collection over the last 15 years and found your splitting into categories really interesting and gives me ideas for my next purchases, cheers
Excellent video and editing. Can't dispute any of your selections, but wouldn't bother with Bourbon or Irish - I'm prejudiced, because there's enough Scotch to keep me happy!
Beautifull collection of whisky's Phil. I got about 8 whisky bottles, most of them from scotland but they are al different. A few months ago i bought a dutch whisky for my fathers birthday called frysk hynder from Friesland, amazing whisky hope you'll try it some day. My next one is going to be a sherry cask whisky so i'm going to watch your video again about sherry cask whisky to make a choice. Thanks again for the awesome content my friend. Have a nice day!
Not sure if it is the same outside the US, though I expect it is, but the right mix of price, style, and quality depends on what is being imported in what volume and what is selling. I maintain every liquor store has 2 or 3 bottles underpriced for their quality, but what those are changes for mostly business and logistical reasons. Knowing this, I love it when I find the same whisky in two different stores for $10, $20, or even $30 difference. A great example of this is Compass Box for some reason, which sells for $60 or $80, but can be had for $40, presumably when someone has overbought.
I've been drinking whiskey for several years not, but the last year I got really interested in whisky. I started a small collection, some of your choices are already on my shelf ... Bunna 12 - Ardbeg 10 - Glenlivet12, Craigellachie 13. Got another Compass Box (orchard house), from Wales Penderyn (portwood), Arran 10 & Sherry cask strength, Bruich. classic laddie, Glenallachie 12, from Ireland Whistler bodega cask. Have not tried them all yet ☺️. Greeting from The Netherlands
Very helpful as I've only started around six months ago. Your selection has some of the ones I have written down .Glencaddam is next on my list as it comes from my home town. I've reached the stage of not buying anymore 40ABV stuff. Has to be all 46ABV and above from now on.
I’ve just discovered your channel and run through nearly almost all of the content by now. It’s very digestible and I’m struck by the professional look and production. I’ve just ordered a Glencadam 10, Glen Allachie 12, Deanston 12 and Kilchoman Sanaig for a Whisky tasting evening where everyone is bringing their own stuff, so should be an interesting one. All based off comments from your videos. Cheers!
My collection as of today (it's always changing). Johnnie Walker Gold 18 Centenary Blend (from a few years back) Oban 14 Glenkinchie 12 Lagavulin 16 Aultmore 12 Deanston 12 Arran 10 Loch Lomond 12 Craigellachie 13 Glen Garioch 12 Glendronach 12 (the unchill-filtered, natural color bottling) Bunnahabhain 12 Bunnahabhain 18 Springbank 10 Glen Allachie 11 Grattamacco Cask Finish Gordon & Macphail CS Macduff 14 I'm ashamed to say I don't have a bourbon, local, or Irish pot still, but they're on the list, and I'm on the hunt for Cotswolds if I can get it at a fair price. Cheers Phil! Great video as always!
Hi Phil I'm something of a newbie as far as whisky is concerned but I have to say that I've really enjoyed this particular video. I've already built up quite a collection, some of which I won't be replacing when they're finished, eg. Tullibardine Sovereign, not because it's a bad whisky, I just feel that I've outgrown it and am looking for something a little more challenging. I was slightly disappointed that you haven't included a category for blended whiskies although I suspect that it's not because you would disregard them but it's a category in which I have discovered one or two whiskies which I regard as being absolute gems, one of which has been nominated for this year's OSWA awards, the Campbelltown Loch, and also Six Isles Batch Strength by Ian MacLeod at 58% abv. I'm looking forward to seeing more from your channel as I do enjoy the content from your channel. Keep up the good work.
Excellent video! I loved that you mentioned local whisky. Here in Brazil we have 2 great distilleries: Lamas and Union. I have arround 10 bottles from those distilleries hahaha
glendronach 21 glenallachie 15 kavalan solist vinho barrique hibiki harmony lagavulin 16 ardbeg 10 arran sauternes slyrs px laphroaig brodir peats beast px macallan 18 fine oak royal salute 21 chivas regal these are my actual favorites thanks for sharing
I definitely went through the smokey door the first whiskey I fell in love with was Talisker 10,then laguvellin 16 but it's too expensive now, I'm a big fan of kilchommen whiskies I've had the joy of a kilchommen tasting with the owners of the distillery and my old boss had 2 bottles of the inaugral release kilchommen we enjoyed one of them.
I'm not just saying, I really do think that your selections in all but one of your chosen categories was spot on. I would have chosen the exact same categories, except mine would have been kosher examples when it came to sherry, port and wine casks, with more emphasis on Israeli Single Malts, that being my local dram. I think you'd be very much at home with the collection I have. Springbank (and other cult status distilleries like Kilchoman, Edradour , Glendronach, Glengoyne etc), are very problematic for the kosher consumer, as they use predominantly Ex-Sherry/Ex-Wine casks. Consequently you won't find many examples from these distilleries (if any) in my collection. Edradour do do the occasional Ex-Bourbon but they aren't typical of the distillery style. I am a big fan of Kilchoman but 100% Ex-Bourbon expressions from this distillery are now very rare, and those which exist are Single Casks and very expensive. Springbank (as well as having almost no non-Sherry matured releases), is virtually impossible to find in Israel, yet strangely enough, Kilkerran is plentiful and you can find the 8 YO and 12 Yo almost everywhere. (I know that some in the UK complain they can't find Kilkerran/Glengyle). Where I would differ greatly with you however, is the entry level category. That is, what I would recommend to the newbie. It is not only possible to find integrity style bottles at an entry level price, I'd say that these whiskies have a much better chance of getting someone to cross that bridge from Blends to Single Malts. Why? Because the Glenfiddich 12, Glenlivet 12, Tomintoul 10 etc, are too generic (or "smooth"), too engineered, keeping strictly to a specific recipe of percentage vattings of refill casks, pleasant, non-offensive and forgettable , with no singular flavour note coming through. Frankly, (and I think they are designed this way), they could almost be Blends with a high percentage of malts. So, when asked for budget entry-level recommendations or when conducting whisky tasting evenings for newbies, I tend to have these full bodied and very flavoursome budget Single malts to hand. They all show a much more malty biscuit-y flavour which is absent in Blends, but above all, none of them could be described as bland. They all have their own unique character, which makes them readily identifiable. At the end of the evening, everyone will have their own favourite, and it's that which hooks them. Deanston Virgin Oak, 46.3% abv, Non Chill-Filtered. Glen Moray 12 Year Old, 48% abv, Non Chill-Filtered. Arran American Barrel Reserve, 43%, First-Fill Ex-Bourbon Barrels. Glencadam American Oak, 40% abv Laphroaig 10, 40% abv. Tomatin Legacy, 43% abv. Loch Lomond 12, 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 12, 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered Loch Lomond Inchmoan 12 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered
Yeah, it's been sitting on the shelf a while though. Benromach has become the new distillery, for me, to scratch the Springbank itch. Especially the Cara Gold and Peat Smoke Sherry casks ones at 46% that Whisky Galore and Whisky&More have.
Really enjoying the content. I currently have a modest number of bottles (too many get drunk for them to last long...) - Bunna 12, Glenlivet Illicit Still (my third bottle of that), Glendronach Peated (still to open), Deanston 12, Glenfarclas 8 (I guess that's my entry level one), Bulleit Rye, Bushmills Black Bush (a blend but I'd say a good one for the price) and another blend the Hankey Bannister 12 (still to try). Of previous bottles the ones I'd most like to have again would be the Arran Bothy, Bunnahabhain Cruach Mhona, Wild Turkey 101 and Cutty Sark Prohibition. I need a good smoky one, have been eyeing up Machrie Moor (Arran) or splashing a little bit on the Port Charlotte. Thanks for taking the time to make these videos.
Solid List, like how you broke it down and giving a few options for each category. Definitely look to do a group share tasting with friends and each bring something they like. It really sucks when you spend a fair amount of money on a bottle, open it, taste it and hate it.
Thanks for your "hard work" tasting whiskies for our enjoyment. Being in the United States, I've started to investigate small distilleries here that make single malt whiskies like Yellow Rose, Swift and Balcones from Texas and Stranahan's Blue Peak from Colorado. I'm not sure you can get any of these in New Zealand, but if you ever make it to the States - check them out. I'd like to hear your assessment.
I would love to get my hands on some of them. They sound really interesting. Hopefully it will be easier to access them internationally soon. Cheers Steven!
I enjoyed that amazed how many I have had in my collection over the years , many repeat buys. Just starting to notice the price increase especially in the 18yr and older range not so much in the 10yr to 15 yr range. As always value for money will dictate what joins my collection. The Arran quarter cask at 56.2% is great at £50 - 0
Arran quarter cask is incredible value. Agree, the 18yr are getting out of reach, and the 21/25 year olds i'm not even looking at any more. There are still a lot of good value 15yr whiskies out there though. Thanks Gareth!
Glad to find out that I.ve tried at least one in all your categories ( except older and funky ones).Promise to do something about it:). Appreciate your passion for single malts...keep up the good work! Cheers, mate!
I totally agree with 18 years old being the sweet spot for scotch. When i think back to some of the best whiskey I have tried, or ones that are special. It's often 18 year old scotch. In western canada 18 year old scotch is around 160-200$ but it's about 80-100$ for a decent 12 year. I would say you get what you pay for. I would rather have 1 really special 18 than 2 nice 12 year olds( I know that some 18 year Olds aren't that special)
Hi Phil, as always a great video. With my collection ?(stash) its mainly scotch single malt and its got a bit of everything, so, peated, sherry matured, different ex bourbon cask’s matured, IB’s, entry level bottles, a couple of wine cask malts and 18 yrs + malts. There’s a few Irish and some bourbon as well. Whats missing is world whiskies. Apart from that I’m happy with my stash. Slàinte Phil.
More of a bourbon guy personally but love an Islay scotch. My advice is take it slow and don’t chase the hype bottles, as someone with a bunch of them they are not worth it. Grab them at retail if you can if not leave them on the shelf. Also try funky bottles you’ll be surprised!
Excellent presentation ! Unfortunately no Springbank releases available in my accessible area (Ontario + Quebec). Another category that deserves a shout out - BLENDS. Example Johnnie Walker Green 15 or Double Black, etc
Great video, lot's of interesting picks and things for me to think about when purchasing new bottles. As a Canadian, almost half of my current collection is rye. I'm not sure how popular or available it is outside North America, so I was surprised to see it didn't come up at all here. Are you into rye at all, and what would your choices be there? A few that I really enjoy are: Lot 40 Dark Oak, Crown Royal Northern Harvest, Sagamore Double Oak, Knob Creek 7 Year Rye.
Great shout on a local whisky. I've started to get more and more Fife whiskies. Luckily there's a few to choose from (Lindores, Kingsbarns, Daftmill, Eden Mill).
Thanks Alex! Arran 10, in my mind, definitely fits in the ex-bourbon cask category. However it doesn't fit strictly in that category as it has a very small amount of ex-sherry mixed in, so I left it out. Cheers!
I started with Japanese whiskey and thought that's good why not scotch and not typical scotch Islay drops like Laphroaig really tickled my fancy. I collected an ensemble of great Islay whiskies but lacked anything sweet or aged and then the Sherried cask strength became my favorite and soo on and soo fourth there's soo much variety in Scotch alone and my taste buds are always looking for something new and delicious. The collection continues....Top 5 so far Glen Scotia Victoriana, Laphroaig Sherry cask 10, Tamdhu Batch Strength, Bunnahabhain 18 and Glen Scotia 15.
It's such a fun journey right! Totally agree, Scotch (or single malt in general) can be so diverse that there's always something new to discover. Epic top 5 there, such great whiskies. Cheers Dan!
Suggest a new category - whisky produced more than 40 years ago vs the modern version. I had a 1970's JW Black label and compared it to the current JW black. It was so different in taste and quality! However, this is one category that might be challenging to procure such old bottles.
Great video Phil! I agree with you on the diminishing returns, I think anything older than 18 years is wasted on my palette. I'm also a scotch drinker and have tried to get into bourbon but have found rye to be more my thing. Bulleit Rye is my go to or a great local example here in Oz is The Gospel Straight Rye. Cheers
Looking at my collection - I think my first XV would be as below: Front Row: Cask Strength x3 so, Glenallachie 10, Arran CS, A’bundah Locks: Rangy whisky 🥃 so Glen Scotia 15, Clynelish 14 Back Row: Rugged hard working Deanston 12, Raasay, Ardbeg An Oa Half back: light on its feet Glencadam 10 1st Five: Show pony Arran 23yo Centres: Versatile Ledaig 10, Kilkerran 12 Outside backs: Speed and skills Ardnamurchan, Old Pulteney 15, Edrador Don McLean As a group I’d feel pretty good - I have them all (and 90 others) and if that’s all I had I wouldn’t be too disappointed
My essential collection now: Peat: Artdbeg 10, Leadig 10, Port Charlotte 10, Benriach smoky 12 / Blend: Nikka from the barrel, Rock islad, Caistel Chamuis / Funk - Craigellachie 13 (Springbank not available) / Scottish: The Classic Laddie, Arran 10 / Sherry: Bunna 12, Thamdu 12 / Irish: Redbreast 12 CS, The Irishman SB Marsala cask, Tyrconnell 10 Madeira cask / Bourbon: Wild trukey 101, Four Roses SB(50%alc) / Rye: Templeton Rye 6year, Knob Creek Rye / Cocktail: Suntory Toki, Woodford Reserve Age/expensive: nothing - who likes to spend on it, I don't // + whiskey for girls: Nikka from the barrel, Telling SB (rum cask), Wild turkey 101 There are many matches - but this is not surprising, because the 20-30 whiskey channel - summarizes quite well what is worth spending money on.
Good whisky, soda is not needed. You want to get the pure taste. I have low end whisky with coke, soda, bitter lemon but I shall start with neat before going for mixer.
Great advice ,to have some local whisky. It lead me to find out that my country (Estonia) also have our own whisky called Le Coq 5y. I also send you email about it and some pictures and info . Great video, thanks Phil Renee
Are the Japanese whiskeys included in the WORLD category? Probably those should have had their own eh? All in all, great information here to keep adding nice stuff to the collection and the pallet. Cheers!
Availability is the key word as most of the bottles are hard to find, at least over here in South America. About the categories mentioned, ¿no blends in a collection?
You speak of diminishing returns and I can't speak for the rest of the world, but here in Atlantic Canada, Scotch prices have really gotten out of hand compared to some great choices from other countries. Really out of hand. To the point that it's maddening enough that I am not even going to shop them until they do something about it. So for right now, I'm loading up my cabinet with much better options (for the money) from Ireland and America with even the odd bottle from my own backyard. When I can buy 2 Elijah Craig's for the price of one Glenlivet, the Scotch will be the one collecting dust at my local outlet. Cheers.
Fantastic content as always, really appreciate your input, I think we have very similar taste and I love you sense of humor that sneaks it’s way into your videos (like flipping a bottle and dropping it)! 🤣 Now to get my budget on point!
Love your channel, bro. On the NZ whiskies, i will definitely look at the Cardrona and see if i can get it here in oz. have you tried the Scapegrace Timbre? If you haven’t yet, will you look at doing a nz whisky review vid?
So you are in what seems to be your private bar. All the bottles are, from what I van see, opened. Do you manage to drink all of those bottles within a year before they start to loose flavour and aroma?
Here is a question that has been bothering me for a while now: how come watered down and bottled whisky doesn’t get cloudy? Even if they are higher strength? It is clear in the bottle and a lot of them (especially the higher strength ones 45 and up) get cloudy if you add a little water. How come they don’t get cloudy in the bottle when watered down by the producer ?
I'm a bit further on in my journey, as it were, so I'll mostly just commend you on a good selection, but your 'Local' category has prompted me to give a shout-out to the Dartmoor Whisky Distillery, situated just down the road (about 100 yards/metres?) from the house I lived in from birth to age 3 (sadly since demolished and replaced by flats/apartments). They do good ex-bourbon, ex-sherry and ex-bordeaux red wine cask whiskies, so could fill several 'slots'...
Great video Phil. Such a nice balanced take on how to build yourself a collection and explore the wonderful world of whisky. Totally agree with Cotswolds being a great value and well presented non scotch whisky. Lots of ideas now for my next buys also! Cheers! 🥃
You said that with cask strength whiskeys, they haven't watered them down like the others. But then why are they still only like 54%? How come they're not 100%?
Absolutely shocked how similar my picks would be to yours in practically every category. Excellent picks, Phil. loved it! 🥃
Cheers Geoff. I got the PC PAC off your recommendation. Excellent stuff, I had no idea what it was or if It would be good at that price before that.
Greetings from Argentina for both of you guys! Great channels to follow.
I watch you both. Really great videos. Thanks🧡
Now, why am I not surprised? Add in Roy and Ralfy and you've got my daily check-in online. Between the four of you, you've advised in the building of a diverse, yet relatively compact, personal selection. It is being ever-refined over time. I have yet to buy my first independent bottling, but I'm looking to buy a couple of bottles of Strathmill and Blair Athol expressions. And, I am set to buy two luxury bottles (Glenmo Signet and Benromach 21) in celebration of my 70th this coming summer.
Same for me too! This is the first list/video I’ve seen where I was “yes, yes, love, have that, should try that one, love, great…”
Excellent categories. I started with Speysides, back in the nineties. Glenfiddich was my initial selection, made after a hasty testing of a few different single malts then available. Cheap single malts. As time passed, I slipped into Glenfiddich's Solera and kept that in my cabinet for years. I had even purchased a bottle of Laphroiag 10 to show folks the wide variety of flavors in Scotch. It certainly tastes nothing like Glenfiddich Solera. Then, I went back to Scotland, to Orkney and the Shetlands, and I stumbled across Highland Park and their whiskys. Then, on my way home, I snagged a huge bottle of Highland Park Einar at the Duty Free shop in Heathrow. I was pleasantly surprised once I'd opened it at home. I fell hard for that flavor. Einar was IT. The problem was it was only available at Duty Free shops. In the UK. I have since filled my collection out in a vain Quest for a whisky to replace that bottle of Einar. Highland Park's offerings locally (Viking, Magnus, & Cask Strength) were trialed and did not measure up; that's my 'cask strength' bottle. Having an aversion to 'peated whisky' thanks to Laphroiag 10, I was searching for a 'hint of peat' in my desired flavor profile. I talked myself into a bottle of Lagavulin 16 (now my 'old' bottle), along with a much tamer Glen Scotia 15. Neither fit my profile. Talikser Storm was too peaty, as well. Meanwhile, I discovered that what I really liked was sherried whiskies and I went down that road in a big way...Auchentoshen, Glenmorangie, Bunnahabhain, Aberlour, and Glenfarclas, all well represented. I'm prolly underrepresented in the non-sherried and unpeated, mostly malty Scotches, although I think the Glenfiddich 12 comes close. I also dabbled in some American Single Malt whiskys and I highly recommend Westland Single Malt and Westland Peated Single Malt and almost anything produced by Stranahan's. I'm chomping at the bit to get me another bottle of Blue Peak. As for bourbon, I hear a very local outfit right here in PDX (home of Aviation Gin), known as Freeland, produces a really decent bourbon. Right now, I have a bottle of Woodford Reserve, which I'll replace once it has tapped out.
Lovely story and experience 🙌🏻
As always, top notch production quality. Really love the concept for this video of giving several options for each category. Even several years into my whisky journey I was able to add a few to my wish list to try!
I just had a great experience introducing a group of beginners to whisky with the Glen Scotia Double Cask. It's affordable, easy to drink/not overpowering, and simply tastes delicious. 10/10 would recommend for a whisky that both beginners (and not only beginners!) can enjoy without breaking the bank!
Really curious to try the GS Victoriana now. Soon...
All the best!
Really hope you're able to explore Bourbons and other American whiskey's in the future. Some are a real treasure.
YES very true!
I live in the United States Midwest (my state borders both Tennessee and Kentucky), and if you go to a grocery store, there’s entire isles of bourbon. Usually between a sixth and a fourth of all liquor options here are bourbon.
You've got to love a list video and this was a cracker, although its taken me an age to get caught up with this.
Enjoyed putting my list together and we run on similar themes but slightly different lanes:
Entry: Balvenie Doublewood
Intermediate: Arran 10yo
Sherried: Tamdhu 15yo (Shocker I know)
Peaty: Kilchoman PX Sherry
Cask: GlenAllachie BS
Challenging: Laphroaig 10yo Sherry Oak
Terroir: GlenAllachie 11yo Port Cask
Older: Once the Glendronach 18 but that is now in the luxury category so I agree with the Arran 18
Bourbon: Makers Mark (Like Jon Snow I know nothing)
World: Kavalan Solist Port Cask
Local: Thompson Grain and Grape (But also like Cardrona, there bottle size not so much)
Campbeltown: Kilkerran 8YO CS
Indie: SMWS - mad scientist levels of experimentation
Luxury: Tamdhu Gran Reserva
Those first 3 bottles were very similar to my first 3: had Laphroaig Select instead of 10 and Founder’s Reserve instead of 12. Think that was because of availability (supermarket)/price in UK. Great choice, they should be a staple in anyone’s collection. Aberlour 12 was my real awakening into whisky and no surprise it was around Christmas time - it’s such a festive drink 😄.
Good to see importance of finding friends to share their faves, some of those like Craigellachie I wouldn’t have bought if it wasn’t for a friend who I swap samples with.
You likely already have a bottle aware but wanted to mention Filey Bay as it’s currently my favourite English whisky, also Penderyn is a very bold Welsh whisky that I find divides my friends. Their port finish tastes like jam, I love that there’s distilleries out their pushing the envelope when it’s so tempting to play it safe.
Glad to see your point about Japanese whiskies. I remember about 5+ years ago still being keen to have a bottle or two in my collection but hype has exceeded prices now.
Thanks Jim! I agree with all of that. I have never had the Filey Bay, sounds great! Hopefully some of it makes its to New Zealand for me to try. I really need to get some Welsh whisky in my collection. I used to have a bottle way earlier in my journey when i lived in the UK. For some reason though, it's hard to get here in NZ.
@@FirstPhilWhisky ….Phil, ever use The Whisky Exchange or Loch Fyne to get bottles that don’t hit NZ? The shipping to southern US is tough, maybe $40-45 per bottle, but the prices are so much better it’s still worth it. I realize they can’t deliver to some locales. Great channel, by the way. Thanks!
Would love to see a bottle of blended malt in this list as well. Plenty of great choices there.
I agree. I have a selection of four. Compass Box Orchard House, Rock Island and Timorous Beastie from Douglas Laing, and Campbeltown Loch. It is now an active and fecund category worthy of having its own nominations.
I got 2 Glenmorangie Signet and every whisky lover should try this. Not necessarily owning one but at least taste it. The 16th whisky you should have is a limited edition cask strength. With all the info like date of casking, date of bottling, number of bottle etc just so you hold a piece of history
I end up changing my whiskey quiet a lot depending what I am exploring but I almost always have a Laphroaig 10, Redbreast 12 and the Arran 10. I feel like they are complex enough to not be boring but I can still share them with ppl that are not whisky geeks
I am a Kentuckian, so I was basically raised on bourbon. Rare Breed is legendary and absolutely one of the best bourbons I’ve ever owned. I just started watching this channel because I want to expand my horizons to Scotch and more world whiskies. I’ve learned so much in such short time. Cheers!
I always get a smile when someone features the G.Signet. My fave. :)
It's expensive. But fits that category well. Thansk Paul!
A must have in my collection would be Highland Park and Balvenie. Need to try some of the others you had but I’ve got a lot of them. Thanks for the list!
Thanks for watching Erica!
Top quality content as always, Phil. Great for the beginner and enjoyable for the well acquainted.
Tried that Redbreast 15 recently and it is outraaaaaageously good.
#1: I am quite proud of how many bottles iI have that either match your choices exactly or come very close, in every single category!
#2: Speaking of Japan, can you / have you already / are you allowed to discuss(ed) the when, why,& what of the changes we’ll be seeing in the next few years?
A bit of order and clarity in that ocean of whisky, that's what your video is all about IMO. Letting aside the luxury ones, I tick all the other categories. Proud owner of a 60+ collection (the 2 infinity bottles not included) and waiting for another 2 (Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair and Loch Lomond Single Grain- took Roy's last VPub advice). Thanks for another great video. Cheers from Romania!
Thanks so much! Sounds like two interesting bottles. I'm yet to try either of those too.
I really like Loch Lomond. The single grain is great. I recently picked both the peated and non peated versions and a single distillery blend from them.
Does it make sense to comment on a year old video? I do t know, but as a Scot who moved to the United States, the big gap I see here is Rye whiskey. The Wild Turkey is a bourbon with relatively high Rye content, and bumping up that spice level and body and going to something that’s rye based and not corn based is something you should really do. I don’t know what you can find in NZ, but I’d look for Michter’s Rye for a really easy smooth rye, Sagamore Spirit for something middle of the road, and Bulleit Rye for a 95% heavy rye whisky. All of those are budget options (at least domestically) but a great place to start.
Very comprehensive list Phil, it was a journey to watch :)
I have been binge watching your videos. Great quality content with heaps of great information. I’ve always shied away from scotch because it has seemed so complicated but you are making it all very understandable. Keep up the good work.
Thanks Paul! Great to have you watching.
Hi! I'm Brazilian. Fantastic vídeo. My list : First any Springbank, 2 Highland park 18 and CS, 4 Octomore, 5 Ardbeg Uigeadail, 6 Laphoaig PX, 7 Lagavulin 16, 8 Bunnahabhain toiteach Ada, 9 Bowmore 18, 10 aberlour abunadh, 11 kavalan solist any one, 12 Lamas First Ember Brazilian whisky, 13 Four Roses single barel bourbon, 14 Eagle rare ten years bourbon, 15 Glen Scotia Victoriana.
I don't know how available they are in New Zealand, but a good rye whiskey is a fun thing to have in a collection.
Just started my whisky journey
Got Glenfiddich 15
Laphroaig 10
Glenfarclas 15
And a Tomatin legacy
Twice I've splurged for Glenmorangie Signet. Absolutely delicious. The chocolate and citrus notes make it a great alternative to dessert.
As a resident of Texas, I really enjoy some of the Texas whiskeys. I love almost everything that Balcones produces. Their Lineage is a real value for an American Single Malt at around $40 USD. Still Austin makes a really nice cask strength bourbon at around $70 USD and a nice Rye at 49.8% ABV for $44 USD and a cask strength version at 58% ABV for about $65 USD. Ironroot Republic makes some good bourbons in the $55-$65 USD, AND TX Bourbon is quite good at around $45 USD.
I Do have a small Collection of my own.
1. Highland Park 14
2. Royal Salute 21 Polo Edition
3. Macallan Lumina
4. Macallan Concept No.3
5. Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2008
6. Royal Brackla 12
7. GlenGrant 10
8. Chivas Regal 13 Caribbean Cask
9. Chivas Regal 13 Sherry Cask
10. Hibiki Master's Select
Adding More and More...
Great job here, Phil! I think I’ve managed to cover all the bases here with what I have in my stash.
Thanks Phil for another well thought out and well made video. This video will help newcomers to the Journey, and it will guide them with the insights and categories I wished I had when I first started. Great work. Cheers from Montreal!
Thanks Michael! Appreciate that. Exactly, I was so confused when I started out too, so hopefully this video can be a potential roadmap for some.
Once again great video Phil, have been building up my collection over the last 15 years and found your splitting into categories really interesting and gives me ideas for my next purchases, cheers
Thanks Aaron! Glad to hear!
Excellent video and editing. Can't dispute any of your selections, but wouldn't bother with Bourbon or Irish - I'm prejudiced, because there's enough Scotch to keep me happy!
Beautifull collection of whisky's Phil. I got about 8 whisky bottles, most of them from scotland but they are al different. A few months ago i bought a dutch whisky for my fathers birthday called frysk hynder from Friesland, amazing whisky hope you'll try it some day. My next one is going to be a sherry cask whisky so i'm going to watch your video again about sherry cask whisky to make a choice. Thanks again for the awesome content my friend. Have a nice day!
Not sure if it is the same outside the US, though I expect it is, but the right mix of price, style, and quality depends on what is being imported in what volume and what is selling. I maintain every liquor store has 2 or 3 bottles underpriced for their quality, but what those are changes for mostly business and logistical reasons. Knowing this, I love it when I find the same whisky in two different stores for $10, $20, or even $30 difference. A great example of this is Compass Box for some reason, which sells for $60 or $80, but can be had for $40, presumably when someone has overbought.
I've been drinking whiskey for several years not, but the last year I got really interested in whisky.
I started a small collection, some of your choices are already on my shelf ... Bunna 12 - Ardbeg 10 - Glenlivet12, Craigellachie 13.
Got another Compass Box (orchard house), from Wales Penderyn (portwood), Arran 10 & Sherry cask strength, Bruich. classic laddie, Glenallachie 12, from Ireland Whistler bodega cask. Have not tried them all yet ☺️.
Greeting from The Netherlands
Very helpful as I've only started around six months ago. Your selection has some of the ones I have written down .Glencaddam is next on my list as it comes from my home town. I've reached the stage of not buying anymore 40ABV stuff. Has to be all 46ABV and above from now on.
Thanks Bill!
Thank you Phil, I really enjoyed watching this video. Didn't skip a second! 😀
Thanks Pavol! Grateful to have you watching
I’ve just discovered your channel and run through nearly almost all of the content by now. It’s very digestible and I’m struck by the professional look and production.
I’ve just ordered a Glencadam 10, Glen Allachie 12, Deanston 12 and Kilchoman Sanaig for a Whisky tasting evening where everyone is bringing their own stuff, so should be an interesting one. All based off comments from your videos. Cheers!
My collection as of today (it's always changing).
Johnnie Walker Gold 18 Centenary Blend (from a few years back)
Oban 14
Glenkinchie 12
Lagavulin 16
Aultmore 12
Deanston 12
Arran 10
Loch Lomond 12
Craigellachie 13
Glen Garioch 12
Glendronach 12 (the unchill-filtered, natural color bottling)
Bunnahabhain 12
Bunnahabhain 18
Springbank 10
Glen Allachie 11 Grattamacco Cask Finish
Gordon & Macphail CS Macduff 14
I'm ashamed to say I don't have a bourbon, local, or Irish pot still, but they're on the list, and I'm on the hunt for Cotswolds if I can get it at a fair price. Cheers Phil! Great video as always!
Great collection!
I have a problem, I don’t collect them, I drink’em
Fantastic video from both a information and production quality perspective. Cheers
Much appreciated!
Hi Phil I'm something of a newbie as far as whisky is concerned but I have to say that I've really enjoyed this particular video. I've already built up quite a collection, some of which I won't be replacing when they're finished, eg. Tullibardine Sovereign, not because it's a bad whisky, I just feel that I've outgrown it and am looking for something a little more challenging.
I was slightly disappointed that you haven't included a category for blended whiskies although I suspect that it's not because you would disregard them but it's a category in which I have discovered one or two whiskies which I regard as being absolute gems, one of which has been nominated for this year's OSWA awards, the Campbelltown Loch, and also Six Isles Batch Strength by Ian MacLeod at 58% abv.
I'm looking forward to seeing more from your channel as I do enjoy the content from your channel.
Keep up the good work.
This was a fantastic video. Also, your video production is on point. Keep the videos coming!
Appreciate that! Thanks!
really nice and informative video, planning also to start my whiskey collection, thank you for the list! :)
Thanks Patrick!
Excellent video! I loved that you mentioned local whisky. Here in Brazil we have 2 great distilleries: Lamas and Union. I have arround 10 bottles from those distilleries hahaha
Nikka Yoichi is on my list of must have under the world category…
Yeah, hopefully, the price will drop a bit and age statements will become more available for the Yoichi as they release more stock.
glendronach 21
glenallachie 15
kavalan solist vinho barrique
hibiki harmony
lagavulin 16
ardbeg 10
arran sauternes
slyrs px
laphroaig brodir
peats beast px
macallan 18 fine oak
royal salute 21 chivas regal
these are my actual favorites
thanks for sharing
I definitely went through the smokey door the first whiskey I fell in love with was Talisker 10,then laguvellin 16 but it's too expensive now, I'm a big fan of kilchommen whiskies I've had the joy of a kilchommen tasting with the owners of the distillery and my old boss had 2 bottles of the inaugral release kilchommen we enjoyed one of them.
I'm not just saying, I really do think that your selections in all but one of your chosen categories was spot on. I would have chosen the exact same categories, except mine would have been kosher examples when it came to sherry, port and wine casks, with more emphasis on Israeli Single Malts, that being my local dram. I think you'd be very much at home with the collection I have.
Springbank (and other cult status distilleries like Kilchoman, Edradour , Glendronach, Glengoyne etc), are very problematic for the kosher consumer, as they use predominantly Ex-Sherry/Ex-Wine casks. Consequently you won't find many examples from these distilleries (if any) in my collection.
Edradour do do the occasional Ex-Bourbon but they aren't typical of the distillery style. I am a big fan of Kilchoman but 100% Ex-Bourbon expressions from this distillery are now very rare, and those which exist are Single Casks and very expensive. Springbank (as well as having almost no non-Sherry matured releases), is virtually impossible to find in Israel, yet strangely enough, Kilkerran is plentiful and you can find the 8 YO and 12 Yo almost everywhere. (I know that some in the UK complain they can't find Kilkerran/Glengyle).
Where I would differ greatly with you however, is the entry level category. That is, what I would recommend to the newbie.
It is not only possible to find integrity style bottles at an entry level price, I'd say that these whiskies have a much better chance of getting someone to cross that bridge from Blends to Single Malts. Why? Because the Glenfiddich 12, Glenlivet 12, Tomintoul 10 etc, are too generic (or "smooth"), too engineered, keeping strictly to a specific recipe of percentage vattings of refill casks, pleasant, non-offensive and forgettable , with no singular flavour note coming through. Frankly, (and I think they are designed this way), they could almost be Blends with a high percentage of malts.
So, when asked for budget entry-level recommendations or when conducting whisky tasting evenings for newbies, I tend to have these full bodied and very flavoursome budget Single malts to hand. They all show a much more malty biscuit-y flavour which is absent in Blends, but above all, none of them could be described as bland. They all have their own unique character, which makes them readily identifiable. At the end of the evening, everyone will have their own favourite, and it's that which hooks them.
Deanston Virgin Oak, 46.3% abv, Non Chill-Filtered.
Glen Moray 12 Year Old, 48% abv, Non Chill-Filtered.
Arran American Barrel Reserve, 43%, First-Fill Ex-Bourbon Barrels.
Glencadam American Oak, 40% abv
Laphroaig 10, 40% abv.
Tomatin Legacy, 43% abv.
Loch Lomond 12, 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered
Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 12, 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered
Loch Lomond Inchmoan 12 46% abv, Non Chill-Filtered
I am 76 years old. I do not collect, I drink and enjoy.
Can't believe you managed to score a SB 12CS here in NZ! They are becoming so hard to find!
Yeah, it's been sitting on the shelf a while though. Benromach has become the new distillery, for me, to scratch the Springbank itch. Especially the Cara Gold and Peat Smoke Sherry casks ones at 46% that Whisky Galore and Whisky&More have.
You are absolute right in your concepts!!! Im doing it from two years ago. Thanks a lot Phil!!!
Really enjoying the content. I currently have a modest number of bottles (too many get drunk for them to last long...) - Bunna 12, Glenlivet Illicit Still (my third bottle of that), Glendronach Peated (still to open), Deanston 12, Glenfarclas 8 (I guess that's my entry level one), Bulleit Rye, Bushmills Black Bush (a blend but I'd say a good one for the price) and another blend the Hankey Bannister 12 (still to try). Of previous bottles the ones I'd most like to have again would be the Arran Bothy, Bunnahabhain Cruach Mhona, Wild Turkey 101 and Cutty Sark Prohibition. I need a good smoky one, have been eyeing up Machrie Moor (Arran) or splashing a little bit on the Port Charlotte. Thanks for taking the time to make these videos.
Solid List, like how you broke it down and giving a few options for each category. Definitely look to do a group share tasting with friends and each bring something they like. It really sucks when you spend a fair amount of money on a bottle, open it, taste it and hate it.
Thanks for your "hard work" tasting whiskies for our enjoyment. Being in the United States, I've started to investigate small distilleries here that make single malt whiskies like Yellow Rose, Swift and Balcones from Texas and Stranahan's Blue Peak from Colorado. I'm not sure you can get any of these in New Zealand, but if you ever make it to the States - check them out. I'd like to hear your assessment.
I would love to get my hands on some of them. They sound really interesting. Hopefully it will be easier to access them internationally soon. Cheers Steven!
Nice to see some Bourbon recommendations! Wild Turkey 101 is a classic any whisky drinker should have
It's so good. I wish I had more access to other great bourbons
I enjoyed that amazed how many I have had in my collection over the years , many repeat buys.
Just starting to notice the price increase especially in the 18yr and older range not so much in the 10yr to 15 yr range. As always value for money will dictate what joins my collection.
The Arran quarter cask at 56.2% is great at £50 - 0
Arran quarter cask is incredible value. Agree, the 18yr are getting out of reach, and the 21/25 year olds i'm not even looking at any more. There are still a lot of good value 15yr whiskies out there though. Thanks Gareth!
Glad to find out that I.ve tried at least one in all your categories ( except older and funky ones).Promise to do something about it:). Appreciate your passion for single malts...keep up the good work! Cheers, mate!
I totally agree with 18 years old being the sweet spot for scotch. When i think back to some of the best whiskey I have tried, or ones that are special. It's often 18 year old scotch. In western canada 18 year old scotch is around 160-200$ but it's about 80-100$ for a decent 12 year. I would say you get what you pay for. I would rather have 1 really special 18 than 2 nice 12 year olds( I know that some 18 year Olds aren't that special)
Hi Phil, as always a great video. With my collection ?(stash) its mainly scotch single malt and its got a bit of everything, so, peated, sherry matured, different ex bourbon cask’s matured, IB’s, entry level bottles, a couple of wine cask malts and 18 yrs + malts. There’s a few Irish and some bourbon as well. Whats missing is world whiskies. Apart from that I’m happy with my stash. Slàinte Phil.
Great collection! Thanks David!
More of a bourbon guy personally but love an Islay scotch. My advice is take it slow and don’t chase the hype bottles, as someone with a bunch of them they are not worth it. Grab them at retail if you can if not leave them on the shelf. Also try funky bottles you’ll be surprised!
Excellent presentation ! Unfortunately no Springbank releases available in my accessible area (Ontario + Quebec). Another category that deserves a shout out - BLENDS. Example Johnnie Walker Green 15 or Double Black, etc
True! Blends would of been a great category
Very informative 👍
Great video, lot's of interesting picks and things for me to think about when purchasing new bottles. As a Canadian, almost half of my current collection is rye. I'm not sure how popular or available it is outside North America, so I was surprised to see it didn't come up at all here. Are you into rye at all, and what would your choices be there? A few that I really enjoy are: Lot 40 Dark Oak, Crown Royal Northern Harvest, Sagamore Double Oak, Knob Creek 7 Year Rye.
Great shout on a local whisky. I've started to get more and more Fife whiskies. Luckily there's a few to choose from (Lindores, Kingsbarns, Daftmill, Eden Mill).
Fantastic! I want to explore all those distilleries. Hopefully I can try some of them soon.
Great whiskies here! Arran 10 and 18 didn’t make the cut. Surprising! At least the 18 got a shout out 😁 great job as usual Phil!
Thanks Alex! Arran 10, in my mind, definitely fits in the ex-bourbon cask category. However it doesn't fit strictly in that category as it has a very small amount of ex-sherry mixed in, so I left it out. Cheers!
This pretty closely resembles the variety that I have, though it happened in a much different order.
Great video Phil. Would like to add some Tasmanian whisky to my collection.
I started with Japanese whiskey and thought that's good why not scotch and not typical scotch Islay drops like Laphroaig really tickled my fancy. I collected an ensemble of great Islay whiskies but lacked anything sweet or aged and then the Sherried cask strength became my favorite and soo on and soo fourth there's soo much variety in Scotch alone and my taste buds are always looking for something new and delicious. The collection continues....Top 5 so far Glen Scotia Victoriana, Laphroaig Sherry cask 10, Tamdhu Batch Strength, Bunnahabhain 18 and Glen Scotia 15.
It's such a fun journey right!
Totally agree, Scotch (or single malt in general) can be so diverse that there's always something new to discover. Epic top 5 there, such great whiskies. Cheers Dan!
Suggest a new category - whisky produced more than 40 years ago vs the modern version. I had a 1970's JW Black label and compared it to the current JW black. It was so different in taste and quality! However, this is one category that might be challenging to procure such old bottles.
Great video and new fan. Glad I found your channel.
I would , respectfully, add a Balvenie (any one as they are incredible) and Lagavulin 16.
Great video Phil! I agree with you on the diminishing returns, I think anything older than 18 years is wasted on my palette. I'm also a scotch drinker and have tried to get into bourbon but have found rye to be more my thing. Bulleit Rye is my go to or a great local example here in Oz is The Gospel Straight Rye. Cheers
Looking at my collection - I think my first XV would be as below:
Front Row: Cask Strength x3 so, Glenallachie 10, Arran CS, A’bundah
Locks: Rangy whisky 🥃 so Glen Scotia 15, Clynelish 14
Back Row: Rugged hard working Deanston 12, Raasay, Ardbeg An Oa
Half back: light on its feet Glencadam 10
1st Five: Show pony Arran 23yo
Centres: Versatile Ledaig 10, Kilkerran 12
Outside backs: Speed and skills Ardnamurchan, Old Pulteney 15, Edrador Don McLean
As a group I’d feel pretty good - I have them all (and 90 others) and if that’s all I had I wouldn’t be too disappointed
90! I wanna be you when I grow up.
ha love the Rugby analogy. I should of listed the 15 graphically in the first 15 format. Great bottles!
Outstanding video! Both informative and entertaining ‼️
My essential collection now: Peat: Artdbeg 10, Leadig 10, Port Charlotte 10, Benriach smoky 12 / Blend: Nikka from the barrel, Rock islad, Caistel Chamuis / Funk - Craigellachie 13 (Springbank not available) / Scottish: The Classic Laddie, Arran 10 / Sherry: Bunna 12, Thamdu 12 / Irish: Redbreast 12 CS, The Irishman SB Marsala cask, Tyrconnell 10 Madeira cask / Bourbon: Wild trukey 101, Four Roses SB(50%alc) / Rye: Templeton Rye 6year, Knob Creek Rye / Cocktail: Suntory Toki, Woodford Reserve Age/expensive: nothing - who likes to spend on it, I don't // + whiskey for girls: Nikka from the barrel, Telling SB (rum cask), Wild turkey 101
There are many matches - but this is not surprising, because the 20-30 whiskey channel - summarizes quite well what is worth spending money on.
Glenlivet 12 is my favorite for scotch and soda.
Good whisky, soda is not needed. You want to get the pure taste.
I have low end whisky with coke, soda, bitter lemon but I shall start with neat before going for mixer.
I think a lightly peated whisky would be a good addition. Something like an Oban or highland park. A gateway drug to introduce people to peat
Great advice ,to have some local whisky. It lead me to find out that my country (Estonia) also have our own whisky called Le Coq 5y. I also send you email about it and some pictures and info . Great video, thanks Phil
Renee
Thanks Renee! Interesting!
15 is a collection!
Are the Japanese whiskeys included in the WORLD category? Probably those should have had their own eh? All in all, great information here to keep adding nice stuff to the collection and the pallet. Cheers!
Availability is the key word as most of the bottles are hard to find, at least over here in South America. About the categories mentioned, ¿no blends in a collection?
Amazing content Phil! Great collection you've got there.
Thanks James!
Another fantastic video!!! Cheers Phil!
Always good video topics Phil!
Much appreciated
You speak of diminishing returns and I can't speak for the rest of the world, but here in Atlantic Canada, Scotch prices have really gotten out of hand compared to some great choices from other countries. Really out of hand. To the point that it's maddening enough that I am not even going to shop them until they do something about it. So for right now, I'm loading up my cabinet with much better options (for the money) from Ireland and America with even the odd bottle from my own backyard. When I can buy 2 Elijah Craig's for the price of one Glenlivet, the Scotch will be the one collecting dust at my local outlet.
Cheers.
Fantastic content as always, really appreciate your input, I think we have very similar taste and I love you sense of humor that sneaks it’s way into your videos (like flipping a bottle and dropping it)! 🤣 Now to get my budget on point!
Thank you so much!
Good list, I’ll skip the local stuff though. Canadian whiskey sucks 😂
Love your channel, bro. On the NZ whiskies, i will definitely look at the Cardrona and see if i can get it here in oz. have you tried the Scapegrace Timbre? If you haven’t yet, will you look at doing a nz whisky review vid?
elijah craig , top class ,, most single cask scots are good to best ;;
No blended whiskies? Johnny Walker Double Black is a great whisky to have on hand for those who are new to whisky.
So many whiskies on this list I have been dying to try but haven’t been able to find around me (us Midwest) ancnoc and glencadam at the top of my list
Excellent show, good knowledge to have.
Much appreciated
So you are in what seems to be your private bar. All the bottles are, from what I van see, opened. Do you manage to drink all of those bottles within a year before they start to loose flavour and aroma?
Here is a question that has been bothering me for a while now: how come watered down and bottled whisky doesn’t get cloudy? Even if they are higher strength? It is clear in the bottle and a lot of them (especially the higher strength ones 45 and up) get cloudy if you add a little water. How come they don’t get cloudy in the bottle when watered down by the producer ?
What are your thoughts on the Springbank 10-year? I was actually able to track down one of those from one of my local specialty shops.
I'm a bit further on in my journey, as it were, so I'll mostly just commend you on a good selection, but your 'Local' category has prompted me to give a shout-out to the Dartmoor Whisky Distillery, situated just down the road (about 100 yards/metres?) from the house I lived in from birth to age 3 (sadly since demolished and replaced by flats/apartments). They do good ex-bourbon, ex-sherry and ex-bordeaux red wine cask whiskies, so could fill several 'slots'...
Amazing, I don't think i've had a Dartmoor. Sounds great!
Enjoyed your video very much! Just one disappointment! No mention of my favorite whisky...Talisker!!!!^^
Talisker will definitely fit in the peated section, especially the 10 year old. Thanks Chris!
such a useful video! thanks Phil.
Cheers Paul!
Hey, Great Shirt and equally great video.
Thanks Casey!
Awesome to see the Cley bottle, great stuff!
I was really surprised with how good it is, considering its age! Thanks Roley!
@@FirstPhilWhisky yeah i know, makes you wonder what it will do with a few more years in it. 😏
Great video Phil. Such a nice balanced take on how to build yourself a collection and explore the wonderful world of whisky. Totally agree with Cotswolds being a great value and well presented non scotch whisky. Lots of ideas now for my next buys also! Cheers! 🥃
Thanks Simon! Big fan of what Cotwolds are doing!
You said that with cask strength whiskeys, they haven't watered them down like the others. But then why are they still only like 54%? How come they're not 100%?
Love your videos, Phil.
Wanted to ask.
Do you have a video about websites that ship whisky worldwide?
Thanks in advance.
Your fan from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷
Not sure. Maybe master of malt? We have a few companies here in NZ that seem to do a good job of importing good bottles.