Truth Of Savarkar | Rationalist / Veer / Or A British Stooge? | Deshbhakt Samvaad With Arun Shourie
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
- There have been endless effort to resurrect the image of "Veer" Savarkar - from numerous books to even movies now .... but what is the REAL legacy of Vinayak Damodar Savarkar?? What do the facts say about him?? Does his OWN writing expose him??? Was he crusading rationalist? / 'Veer' Freedom Fighter / or a grovelling agent of the British?
Arun Shourie's new book on Savarkar has just been released and it's an important work because it mostly quotes what Savarkar wrote himself - in his own words. Hope this interview helps you understand the difference between the truth and hyperbole.
Arun Shoure took time off to have a detailed chat on Savarkar, his ideas for India and why Savarkar remained affectionate towards the British - right till the end.
The New Icon: Savarkar and the Facts - in stores and online now.
🇮🇳 SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE VIDEOS 🇮🇳 - / thedeshbhakt ▶️
⛔️ BECOME AN ANNUAL DESHBHAKT MEMBER - / thedeshbhakt ⛔️
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
OR
Join this channel on You Tube to get access to perks:
/ @thedeshbhakt
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕
kadakmerch.com...
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact (at) thedeshbhakt (dot) in 📧
** SUBSCRIBE / FOLLOW US **
RUclips: - / thedeshbhakt
Twitter :- / thedeshbhakt
Instagram :- / akashbanerjee.in
Facebook :- / akashbanerjee.in
#savarkar #veersavarkar #arunshourie
A.P.J. Abdul Kalam once said, "Learning gives creativity, creativity leads to thinking, thinking provides knowledge, and knowledge makes you great.
*Arun Shourie was a minister in the Atal Bihari Vajpayee government and Dr Kalam was President, nominated by the Vajpayee government. Good days!*
After enjoying ministerial position.,he has turned BJP abuser, because he was ignored by Modi ji.
You need to know the reality of this deshbakth he is taking feedback of Savarkar from antiSavarkar Team.
@@cnu4 😂😂😂yeah like Savarkar is a saint
@Dadasahab1234
Exactly and this PICK AND CHOOSE Tactics is done by these PSEUDO INTELLECTUALS
Excellent Interview, excellent personality. Huge respect for Arun Shouri!!
Check out his other books and what he has written, then form an opinion 😂😂
This guy is a genius. Looking forward to read his work. Thank you Akash keep doing the great work. Love from Pakistan occupied Pushtoonkhwa
So you want join with Afghanistan?
Arun Shouri Ji is a Knowledgeable person who has in-depth understanding about history and past and present politics of India. It would be good for the country if he is interviewed regularly.
Arun shourie is really speaking 🗣 Cardinal Truth 🙈 😂😂😂😂 plummeting revenues and depleting resources of AB is resorts to all kind of Drama 🎭 Baazi 😂😂😂😂 unfortunately 🆎 is setting in to Sun 🌝 🌑 Arun Shourie is irrelevant Egocentric bloated pseudo fake intellectual 😂😂😂😂
Please lock 🔓 up both these 🆎 & Arun shourie in mock Cellular Jail ( Andaman Cell Jail )let's see 🙊 Thea Real ball 🏐s of these digital media bigots 😂😂😂😂. If Arun got ball 🏐 then debate with Vikram Sampth rather with the minnows and sub par dormat and 3rd rated pedestal 2 cents 🆎 who lacks integrity and factual reportage 😂😂😂
Thank you Akash for 34:55 the wonderful conversation with A very highly learned knowledgeable person and writer. Hats off to Mr Arun fir so detail research on Sarwakar . Today's new generation should be fortunate to hear and see this wonderful conversation.
Thank you once again Akash
Great Akash. An extremely illuminating discussion. I loved the way you made Arun Shourie explain everything without interrupting… Hats off to Arun Shourie Sir for his brilliant insights on History.
Thanks sir - since digital offers more time - no need to interruption/// however not many people listen to long & deep conversations!!!
@@attilisudhakar savarkar is easy target for liberals, he may be not great like other freedom fighter.. but the so called liberals has only one agenda, target hate Hindu leaders, bjp and do appeasement for peaceful.
Jitna bhi hate failana hai faila lo veer savarkar k bare me but truth remains truth. He is our hero ❤🚩🇮🇳, pura left liberal ecosystem ko aaj tak hila k rakh diya hai. These fools wants us to worship gandhi, who used to say "
Hindus should not harbor anger against Muslims, even if the latter wanted to destroy them. Even if the Muslims wanted to kill us, we should face death bravely".we will never worship British puppet like gandhi and nehru family. We will never accept fake borrowed secularism bcz it was imposed on us, people never demanded that. Asking for hindu rastra is our rights, why u divided india on the basis of religion? If muslims got Pakistan and Bangladesh, then india should have made hindu nation during independence only.Why muslims are living in india even after partition? They got their shares (pakistan and Bangladesh) so they have not rights to live in india .But congress failed in full population transfer of hindus and muslims. (Even Dr ambedkar wrote this in his book" Pakistan or the partition of india" that there is no point of partition if population exchange doesnt happen).But for vote bank politics congress and left liberal kept hindus in dark and we are still facing hindu muslim riots. Hindu and muslim culture are exactly opposite to each other and cant live together. The only solution to this problem is either ghar wapsi of muslims or sending them to Pakistan
@@attilisudhakar ❤️❤️
Please lock 🔓 up both these 🆎 & Arun shourie let's see 🙊 Thea Real ball 🏐s of these digital media bigots 😂😂😂😂
Excellent 👌. पूरे संवाद को हिंदी में बदलने की आवश्यकता है ताकि अधिक लोगों तक पहुंचा जा सके।
Bhai jab normal English samajh nhi aati unke followers ko toh educated ka tag kyu laga ke ghumte hai 😂...aise toh yeh savarkar ki books bhi nhi padh payenge 😂
@@prathameshj887 haha Prathamesh andhbhakt ho andhbhakt jyada chapad chapad kyu kr rhe ho....
Right
Thoda English aap ke kareeb aaye, thoda aap English ke kareb aayein.
@@prathameshj887 English doesn't mean "educated"...
I strongly admire the strength n courage for conducting this interview, thank you tons
just thik "why" this was conducted....you shall get the anser
Facts and only facts, for this reason it is very difficult for anyone to ignore, dispute or counter Mr. Arun Shourie . Many congratulations, Sir .
Shouri Ji…Have been following you since read your article in IndianExpress…Their privileges and our duties …such a joy it is to hear you. My deep respects.
Thank you for bringing such a great personality as a guest. I enjoyed every minute of it. Very insightful questions....thank you so much!
How can you identify anti nationals 😂😂😂
Very true
It’s nice to listen Arun Shouri after a long time
Same here. Last I heard him 30 minutes ago. 😊😊😊
He's a Grifter. He wrote fraud about ambedkar too to get Rajyasabha seat and BJP praised his effort by giving him a seat after mandal commission era in the 90s
Now that he knew that he never gonna get pick up by BJP. He is going all against them.
@@cinefile0075 lol he criticized bjp back then too when he was with them lol.
@@Ctba89 never In 90s. After modi he knew his career was done for. Also what kinda criticism in those days matter too. After 2014 he is going all against BJP RSS coz they didn't give him any attention.
Given by this interview, it looks like the Supreme Leader of today is a mirror image of Savarkar.
@@darajivdua Nah, this one is illiterate.
Savarkar eats 1000 modis for snacks in intellect
The fact that we don't learn about our own history in detail and completely rely on word of mouth has gotten our own civilizations down, we are on the verge of failure!! Historically, Europeans are very quick to learn and make records in writings and drew world maps many centuries ago to prosper is something we all need to learn, so we understand historical events better to take future actions.
There are more case-studies, documents, and records of Rome and Greek civilization than probably the entirety of the dawn of Indian civilization, they have got enough and well documents records of historical events, current trends to have a vision for future which ultimately paved their way to success.
Just for once, let's look beyond our faith, what we believe in, and what our parents/grand-parents thought has happened in the history, and think RATIONALLY.
Facts hurt, it is meant to be, because history is not as straight as we thought. If we think all is well, then we are doomed to failure, let's bring all the facts out, then let citizens decide for themself on the next course of action, but let's not blindly believe in our mythology. QUESTION EVERYTHING and DON'T FEAR CHANGE!
Arun Shourie has found the reason why Savarkar inspired hate and violence - 'he had such a high opinion of himself (narcissism), the disappointment became even greater, and that revealed into hatred."
Upper caste became safe from Shudras Untouchables Bahujan women and Britishers for helping their divide and rule policy by divert divide and rule policy
Upper caste also got the benefits like jobs salary pensions gifs and Jail releases from Britishers for helping their divide and rule policy
Focus of the Anger on Manusmriti and upper caste is shifted to Quran and Muslims
Power through the leadership of Hindus retained or regained by the upper caste due to the said Hindu Muslim haterate
Especially after the mission education and Satya shodhak samaj by Phule group against the inequalities and injustice of Bramhin religion
This is really a deshbhakth trying to save India
The quotes of Savarkar regarding cows, brahmins & letters to british
Should be printed on huge billboards so that his reality is known to people - & bjp is exposed with its own icon
Ask ChatGPT to analyze all of Savarkar's books and ask it to give a comprehensive Psychoanalysis, and the answer would be NARCISSISTIC
Congrats to Mr Arun Shourie for writing this revealing book. It's a great learning experience from this interview. Well done, Akash. ❤
100 Chuhe khaa kar Mr. Purie Hajj, "Oops Kashi" ko Chale. Too less too late.
Good interview Akash Bannerjee. Keep up the good work 👍
The current leader seems to have developed some qualities of Savarkar.
Current leader also created his own reverence of his younger days.
Savarkar sounds like Kangana Ranaut: I am the best and greatest (only in my head).
Educate yourself better.
If Savarkar is a traitor then my did British banned 1857 First war of independence. Why did Nehru got royal treatment from Britishers.
@@cnu4Patel : Sarvarkar killed Gandhi. The guy always apologized when he got caught with his pants down ! He learnt his lesson when he got pension as his reward from the British! I guess talk is cheap 😂
@@cnu4 go to pakistan
@@cnu4we hindus never were united actually islam is more violent and casteist unfortunately sc st support them and abhor Brahmins never india will be united by Hindus blatant truth
And this is great Khulasah of History with Facts to open the eyes of the Present. I hope people who watched this has some moral impact in our Nation
One of the best Interview/Talk with real intellectual this year.Thank you ❤
As always, like your other posts Great enlightening episode, Akash. In the times of 1 min reels, listening 1 hr 28 min nonstop with goosebumps. Only Deskbhagat audiences have that stamina 😅
I watched the interview......the complete interview. Thank you Dr Shourie for writing this book. Will definitely read this book. @thebeshbhakt thank you for bringing this interview to us.
You have interviewed one of the finest writers in India who calls spade a spade. Unhesitating and sharp whether he writes on Ambedkar or on Savarkar.
The Divide and Rule is not a British ideology but an Indian construct.
It was a British ideology, but they used Savarkar and Jinnah to implement it. Today the political leaders use religion and caste to do the same.
You forget biggest British puppet Mr Gandhi and Nehru who were biggest culprit to weaken hindu@@Subh8081
From the examples of the world neither british nor hindu Indians were the reason for divide and rule....middle East , Indian subcontinent, China xinguang, soviat union partition in 90ts, chekoslovakia partition....many have only one thing in common....truth proves itself with extraordinary amounts of evidence.
Exactly..... India was already divided even before British arrived.
@Pch070 but when the negative points are associated with British, it gives a sense of self worth and give a common enemy
Bravo Senor…One of the best interviews ever…earns the Deshbakt title..👏👏👏👍
wow! I can't imagine, who was Mr Savarkar! Akash, It's really great job you have ever done! Surprised!
I like conversations like this but try and do it in hindi please you have a large hindi viewership like me thankyou great job
English should also be given more importance. I cannot go demanding for Tamil anyways. Wish I could!
Nobody likes bovine excrement consumption enthusiasts
Bhai comment hindi me kar dete to sabhi hindi audiance padh lete
Great podcast
As we know Arun Shouri is very learned person.
Haven’t read this book,
But this analysis is excellent
It tells the personality of Savarkar
as a
“perfect example “
case study of a “Narcissistic Personality Disorder “
I guess it was not researched at that time
( By the way, why don’t you do one episode on Narcissists personalities with a researcher)
Read analysis of the self. Try to learn things from books, especially psychology. All the 'experts' on this channel are biased. I hope you know that
@@Ved-s9e I would differ you on that all experts on channel are biased.
News / Reporting can be called biased, but experts have opinions and perspectives, it’s up to audience to decide whether they agree or not… so no question of bias on this channel
Yes, as I said haven’t read the book so far, and I will have my opinion only after that
Thanks for sharing Mr fearlessly journalists Akash sir👍🏻❤❤❤ Jay Hind Jay Bharat Jay Constitution of INDIA 🇮🇳🧡🤍💚 good discussion points to facts
man this conversation is what our india needs intellectual discourse
Akash, hearty congratulations on getting Mr Shourie to discuss this interesting book and the explosive topic of its "protagonist"'s biography. Of course your cunning skills got him to talk candidly on collateral, contemp as well has bygone topics and history as well! Give Deshbhakt a hug from my behalf, or pat on his swollen head. Kudos to your work in general and this piece in particular, from someone who in has seen politician Shourie, read editor Shourie, and the iconoclast author Shourie. Speaking of this last, get Mr Shourie to talk on "False Gods", and his views on that protagonist.
Superb Interview, I request Aakash please invite Mr. Niranjan Takle investigative journalist from Maharashtra on Savarkar or Ashok Kumar Pandey. It will be very interesting.
same i was thinking (but he still dont release His book on the same) & much better would be we have a debate of both in the presence of Deshbhakt would be amazing 🤞🤞
Wow akash! Amazing interview
Now That's something really really interesting written by guy himself, Savarkar 🥸
I love Akash’s expressions throughout this interview.. 😂
Savarkar was only good in one thing , he asked to eat beef, it is good for hard working poor people for nutrition
Pork is also good, also pork has less carbon footprint compared to beef...
🐗🥩😋😋😋
@@jpatel2002 jinnah didnt told to eat pork savarkar told to eat beef
What a fall Mr Arun should.sane mind I thought. But how bitter one could become in a state of disappointment and dissolution. This man is showing.
Please call Vikram sampath,Ashok Kumar Pandey and Arun shourie for a debate on Savarkar. As all of them have written books about him
Nobody likes bovine excrement consumption enthusiasts
We don’t invite idiots like Sampath 😂😂😂😂
A debate between would just be a gladiatorial theatre, like a boxing event. Mere entertainment and bloodsport. Not many on the right will come away from it having learned anything
@ debate is between intellectuals not idiots
@rohanxdavis but they should come as they pretend to have the authority on "real" history
Brilliant discussion & insight into actual Savarkar. Thank you bringing him here 🙏
Great conversation Aakash 👍Pls continue the same vigour for factual conversation. Great to hear from Arun Shorie sir.
-- *With due respect,*
*Our first mistake* was
we have divided into two parts; India & Pakistan.
*And the same mistake* repeated this time in our beautiful Country India through Caste-system, while dividing (large percentage of our Indian's population) into Four (4) parts.
*My fellow citizens of India,* if you have any solution of Caste-system rather than Islam, kindly come forward with your solution in public domain.
*Until the solution of Caste-system, there is no welfare, Peace and Justice among the people in our society, only upper class Brahmins will get the privilege simply by birth.*
Thanking you,
Lovely interview Akash, and also kudos to Mr Shourie for such an in depth research! Truth shall prevail!
Listening to this, methinks Savarkar had illusions of grandeur and attributed a greatness to himself beyond his capacity! 😀
It was Savarkar himself who gave the epithet "Veer" to himself under a pseudonym.
Thanks
Brilliant interview. Thank you.
Savarkar is easy target for liberal's... he may not be so great like other freedom fighters... but he is targeted to appease peacful's
I wish all the andhbhakts and Savarkar bhakts watch this wonderful video. 😊😊😊❤
and cry...
Same Arun Shourie had called Baba Saheb a British Stooge 😭
Savarkar was against caste system ✅
Savakar was against 'karma-kaand' and 'pakhand'✅
Savarkar was against 'bad prathas' developed in Hinduism over period ✅
He contributed in freedom struggle ✅
He was rational thinker✅
Only thing he did wrong was he foresee schemes of turning this country back to islamic rule 😢..in india by giving refrence of Mughals of how glorious it was how peaceful it was ...and took stance for hindus??.is this your pain ???
that's why he wrote 'maafinamas'.... and If stealing Money from British from train is right✅ because it's money of indians and taking it from British by any means is right then savarkar taking pention is right..what stops you from thinking that ??..
Bhakts are blind and uneducated. They have no rational thinking.
But u are sir Syed Ahmed Khan bhakt who was great servent to British
Delightful and enriching!
Pakistanis are loving this interview..this interview will unite crores of hindus for bjp ...you guys need to understand....if you target hindutva people will be united for bjp ...those days gone where information was limited to news paper and dd national ....comparing hindutva and islamic terrorism itself big thing ...
Mr.Niranjan Takle has done an excellent research on V.D.Savarkar. If possible, Akash Bhai...pls do an interview with him...
@@rajbhushankamble9846 what about Vikram Sampats book about Savarkar?
@@bhikshusureshwarananda4576one is a historian, other a casual history writer
Exactly। Niranjan is my friend। He really did nice research with proofs
@@Axoq-d3u rightly said. A real historian vs a pseudohistorian
What can one say, but admire & respect Shourie Saab. What a powerhouse of knowledge.
Bow down to this tall, humble intellectual 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I wish you also interview Vikram Sampath. As he too has a book on Savarkar. It would be a good comparison to see.
Dear Akash, fantastic, simply Superb 👏 👌 ❤love you. You are great...and fact publicing Arun Sauri ji
At this point I'm wondering who Hindutwa lead to soften islamisation, if we internalise savarkar's hindutwa. Bcz arun is accepting that he was a rationalist and viewed scriptures with rational enquire!
Extremely good interview/podcast. Thanks for so many historical clarifications
You should interview vikram sambath so that we will get an objective picture vikram wrote the biography of savarkar as well what we need is an objective picture
I was looking for someone’s comment about Sampath and finally found someone. Thank you. Let’s be real - agents like Akash will never invite gems like Sampath. That would be antithetical to Akash’s motive of maligning Savarkar in every way possible.
I watched this in parts. Man! Such a great conversation.
May be his narcissism was a compensation mechanism for his sense of his own cowardice in his abject grovelling to the British.
Nice to see Mr Arun Shourie after a long time.His interview with Karan Thapar was equally good.
I’m starting to like Savarkar more 😭😂 he’s better than Modi yogi Amit put together
Very much elaborating and factual.
Savarker was a man who wrote many letters of apology to the British and come out from jail and be a tout of Britsher
Hence there are chances of Savarkar's face getting printed on currency if they create a new currency with Russia, to compete against Dollar 💰💵😂
What was the reason that Britishers put sawarkar in jail???
And Gandhi Sent Indian soldiers to Europe to fight for British against Germany in return of Freedom for India..was that Gandhis non violence movement?
@@Naked_Sports200You know only corner of history baby...just get know about full history
Jitna bhi hate failana hai faila lo veer savarkar k bare me but truth remains truth. He is our hero ❤🚩🇮🇳, pura left liberal ecosystem ko aaj tak hila k rakh diya hai. These fools wants us to worship gandhi, who used to say "
Hindus should not harbor anger against Muslims, even if the latter wanted to destroy them. Even if the Muslims wanted to kill us, we should face death bravely".we will never worship British puppet like gandhi and nehru family. We will never accept fake borrowed secularism bcz it was imposed on us, people never demanded that. Asking for hindu rastra is our rights, why u divided india on the basis of religion? If muslims got Pakistan and Bangladesh, then india should have made hindu nation during independence only.Why muslims are living in india even after partition? They got their shares (pakistan and Bangladesh) so they have not rights to live in india .But congress failed in full population transfer of hindus and muslims. (Even Dr ambedkar wrote this in his book" Pakistan or the partition of india" that there is no point of partition if population exchange doesnt happen).But for vote bank politics congress and left liberal kept hindus in dark and we are still facing hindu muslim riots. Hindu and muslim culture are exactly opposite to each other and cant live together. The only solution to this problem is either ghar wapsi of muslims or sending them to Pakistan
Dear Akash - This is real revelation.Thank you for inviting the such people on your channel.
This what is looks like when two very educated people talk
This interview has motivated me to have a personal copy of the book and to read it. Thanks.
Can you post such type of video on Mahatma ghandhi ?
There are many. look em up whataboutism man
Understand dialogue bhakt not defend it!! He made but your godi Media can do this same NO BHAKT
Oi bihari aukaat me rhe
" Go by what you say in public, not by private assurances" is a remarkable statement !!!
Such was the integrity in our country at that time, which the current BJP has destroyed and sowing swords of evil , shameful !!!
Great revelations .Thank you both of you for this nice and informative conversation
.
Thanks! We’re happy you enjoyed the discussion.
and thanks for being a long time subscriber!
History says that Savarkar was c0ward, begg@r, mercy pe†i†ioner and a servan† of the British. He was exact opposite of other successful freedom fighters who brought India independence.
What was Gandhi then😂😂😂
@@ARKADIP-yi4zkintolerant bhakt
@@Mohammed_Azeem converted miskin😂😂😂
@@ARKADIP-yi4zk Bro, Gandhi was a freedom fighter who gave us freedom with the help of Mountbatten and Edwina.
@@ANONYMOUS-g7c6d 😂😂😂😂😂
Wonderful discussion on the new book written by Mr Arun shouri
many new and mind blowing facts actually.
Mind blowing analysis of a book viz a viz Savarkar based on the research by an author par excellence by Desh Bakht. God bless , you , Sir and keep it up
Sir please expose our country more. Give us the reality check
Well said sir
Even if he expose our country ,@Harmandeep you can't improve it . Thatwhy you are interested in exposing it only.
Brilliant discourse! Did not even feel like it actually took over an hour! Hope the book does not get banned!
Have a conversation with Sudhanshu Trivedi 😂😂
It’s strikingly ironic that Savarkar was an atheist, yet today’s saffronists treat his ideas like holy scripture. They revere a man who didn’t believe in God himself.
Shourie is wrong on Jinnah . It was Gandhi & Rajaji( the then number 2) who made an offer in the 30s itself to Jinnah for being the PM & which Jinnah refused
Brilliant interview. Shourie has come a long way, and he remains the magnetic persona i remember him to be
jab koi gandhi, nehru ko criticize kare to andhbhakt or koi savarkar ko kare to deshbhakt
waah!! LIBERANDUS
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Akash jee you are always mesmerizing. Such a long interview and still it kept me tied the way a thriller webseries do. Congratulations to both of you. Listening to Arun Shouri is always a privilege.
Please interview him also on his controversial book "Worshiping False God".
Book promotion has become quite an important source of income for this channel.
Thanks for such a wonderful video🙏🙏
Excellent conversation. Very illuminating about little known facts about the "veer" who is now being projected as national hero. Alas, nothing will make the scales fall from the eyes of the brainwashed bhakts.
Thank you Sir n Aakash....such an intense conversation.
This really needs to be redone in Hindi. People need to hear this. Turns out even Savarkar would have found the present brand of “hindutva” extremely cringe.
New and important but true facts listened today. Tks Akash n Mr. Shouri Sir.
I am not afraid of Muslims.
I am not afraid of Britishers.
But I am afraid of Hindus against Hinduism.
- Veer Savarkar Ji.
@@minatipattnaik3646 I have no quarrel with mr jinnah i support two nation theory we hindu are a country on our own divisive talking by andhbhakt ke pawpaw sorryvarkar......
@@minatipattnaik3646 I'll always stay loyal to the crown i must be pardon by your majesty so that I can be example to other people said by Savarkar
😂 6 mahine main hi paani nikal gaya tha nakli hindu Savarkar ka jail main mercy petitions par mercy petitions dabta chala gaya 😂 jab ki 70000 hajar kaidi main se kisine bhi mercy petitions likh ke desh se gaddari nahi ki thi
He's truly afraid of hindu who used their brain instead of emotion which he can't control' hence he afraid of them because of they can expose him as a mercy petitioner to king george v lol 😂....
@@Ctba89 asli I’d se aao miya
Who are Hindus? Just define. Why some people are urinating on others? On what basis.
What Hindu?? From where u got ur identity Hindu from Arab and Persian Muslims...? See the level of identity crisis, there was no any specific belief in india as such... These manusmriti itself an alian book of thoughts to india.... There is only 15 % of so called self adhered so called Hindus india those are brahmins, kshatriya, vaishyas... All other are indigenous Balck malanin indians... Which these people call them as shudras and Dalits, untouched etc.... They makeup the 70% of majority India.
So don't tell Hindu against hindu to ur vested intrest of bloody racial supremacy.
One thing about Savarkar one must understand his inspiration for nationalism came from Europe……..specially Italian movement greatly inspired him. His criteria of being “Nationalist” was one’s loyalty towards his country of birth, & as religious capitals of Muslims and Christians lies outside his concept of “Hindudom“ (another European inspiration , I think), Savarkar believed these two communities can never be fully loyal to India. Also he considered the Maratha empire as an unfulfilled equivalent of Italian unification movement. And on the question of nationalism, he was brutally uncompromising. One glimpse can be found in his book “Hindi Pad Padsahi”, where he defended Maratha atrocities by saying that Marathas were justified in plundering those Hindus who didn’t join their cause of “Hindu unification”.
Savarkar’s submissive attitude towards the British, I think, was result of his “fear” that Ottomans & Afghan Emirs, like the past, would invade India, & with the help of Indian Muslim royals , would again establish Islamic rule. He nurtured this “fear” even in much later period of his career. His countermeasure of this possible situation though, was rather weird…….he suggested approaching Hindu King of Nepal, who he hoped would aide the Hindu royals to establish a Hindu rule in India.
Now , when we come to Savarkar’s time in Cellular Jail, I found that his own memoir “My Transportation of Life” is pretty widely used by people, including Randeep Hooda, Vikram Sampath, & whoever produced that “light & sound show” in Cellular Jail. No doubt his memoir is most elaborate one, but there were other inmates who wrote abut their time in Cellular Jail. I have read writings of Barin Ghosh,Troilakyanath Mukhopadhyay, Upendranath Bandyopadhyay, Madan Mohan Bhowmik, Bhai Paramananda, Ullaskar Dutta & Baba Pritvi Singh Azad. After reading all their writings, I would like to point out few things :
1. In his memoir , Savarkar claimed to have carried out a lot of activities. But it’s amazing how other inmates wrote so few words about him, except Ullaskar & Prithvi Singh Azad, others have almost no positive words to say about Savarkar.
2. Savarkar claimed to have carried out extensive “Shuddhi” movement inside jail. But both Upendra Bandyopadhyay & Madan Mohan Bhowmick gives the credit to Arya Samajists. Madan Mohan specially mentioned Bhai Paramananda for this.
3. Savarkar claimed the credit for library in Cellular Jail. But there is mostly no mention of his name . In fact, Hem Chandra Kanungo , who became the head of library , is mentioned few times.
4. Another interesting claim by Savarkar is that he, along with his brother, formulated a code language so that the inmates can communicate among themselves. But no other inmate mentioned any such code language. However, I found out that one inmate actually DID invented such code….but it was Hemchandra Kanungo, during his stay at Alipore Jail (Source : Atmakahini by Barindra Kumar Ghosh)
5. The accusation that Savarkar used to instigate others, but not himself coming to forefront was also made by Bhai Paramanad. Upendra Bandyopadhyay also made similar accusation but didn’t take any name.
6. One point from “My Transportation of Life”, which everyone misses out , that how he smeared Barin Ghose, who Savarkar claimed to had ratted out his fellow revolutionaries in exchange of a mercy petition. He also accused Bengali prisoners to be lackeys of jail authority. On the other hand, Upendranath Bandyopadhyay accused Maratha prisoners of being anti-Bengali & fraught with regionalism.
I am also happy that Troilakyanath Mukhopadhyay is mentioned in this video. He was a member of Anushilan Samity, & quite a character ! Now I want to share a trivia from his memoir………he claimed that he became an associate of Netaji, & under his direction he travelled across India to meet various leaders , & asked their help in revolutionary resurrection. Remember was still no arrested by the British Govt. He claimed to have met Golwalkar, Bhai Paramanand & Ganesh Savarkar. Among the three, Golwalkar & Savarkar declined to help for the cause.
This is the man who written the book for defaming Babasaheb Ambedkar. But the popularity of Babasaheb Ambedkar increases day by day.
When you say,he wrote a book on Baba Saheb for defaming him,you are attributing motives to him baselessly. He cited from the speeches and official records published by Govt. If Maharashtra and he was not beating bush or attributed his personal agenda. If you find he is defaming Ambedkar,contradict him. Immediately after release of the book on Ambedkar,ink was thrown on him in a function by some persons instead of contradicting him and rebutting him point wise with facts. Pouring ink was their response why?. Is it wrong to write a book and criticise Ambedkar.
Ambedkar lost the election 😂😂😂😂
@Veer_Bhadra-v5k But he wins the heart of majority of Indians and world, except mukh Putra 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Jaibhim007-de7pz majority of the india ?? 😂😂😂 World??? Nobody know him outside india 😂😂😂 statues of gandhi not booba saheb ambedkar 😂😂😂 he couldn't even won elections in Maharashtra died like a loser...but upper caste baad saar savarna f*ck us eveyday saar 😂😂😂
Akash! What a power-packed episode!😮
I love and appreciate the research, hard work, and energy you put into these episodes-just love it! Your channel is my go-to source when I want to know the facts.
I was the one who had been asking you to invite #AcharyaPrashant for an interview. More than anything, I was eager to see how my favorite journalist would engage with a great teacher and social reformer like Acharya Prashant!
Savarkar was British agent. He received monthly stipend from British to instigate communal tensions.
Then why did they imprison him in kalapani cellular jail....unlike the castist Gandhi.
@@TheRakeshgautam part of a play ,and play name was A great servent
Please substantiate the claim or assertion if you will with empirically verifiable data
@akshaymanta55 he got 60 rps per month for pension
Yes gomuthra nagpur half knickers you are right i know he his your father @@TheRakeshgautam
I loved this samvad... Not surprised or shocked with anything concerning him. Seeing what non-biological man was doing in 2024 April, I know who was his mentor. However I still maintain that he is only a puppet & the puppeteer is the man holding the most powerful portfolio in the country. HM
Akash your interview is really great and hats off to Intellectual Arun shourya garu.
Do we still have intellectual straight spined thoughtful thinkers ? Woow
Savarkar was against caste system ✅
Savakar was against 'karma-kaand' and 'pakhand'✅
Savarkar was against 'bad prathas' developed in Hinduism over period ✅
He contributed in freedom struggle ✅
He was rational thinker✅
Only thing he did wrong was he foresee schemes of turning this country back to islamic rule 😢..in india by giving refrence of Mughals of how glorious it was how peaceful it was ...and took stance for hindus??.is this your pain ???
that's why he wrote 'maafinamas'.... and If stealing Money from British from train is right✅ because it's money of indians and taking it from British by any means is right then savarkar taking pention is right..what stops you from thinking that ??😂
@@sanjaykumarjaiswal2119Bro , you are a paid troll 😂
@@sanjaykumarjaiswal2119 *₹2* has been credited to your account, from the *IT Cell.* 😂😂
@@pzendethat is not actually true brother you can talk to me😂... actually I wrote it and someone started copy pasting it .....
But let's suppose I am a troll...but a troll says something doesn't make it wrong or less important if he is speaking truth or a logical statement...😊
We demand a detail analysis of Rangeela Gandhi too 😂
Mr Arun Shourie is excellently transparent in his detailed explanation!
Excellent conversation with a legend of our times
Love from north east ❤❤❤
Bangladeshi ghuspetiyan 😂