NAK not OK Part 2 | For Whose Sake? (Warning Against Nouman Ali Khan) | Abu Mussab Wajdi Akkari
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- {Say, "Indeed, my prayer, my rites of sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allaah, Lord of the worlds.}
Soorah Al-An'am 6:162
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
✍ Notes from Imaam An-Nawawi’s 40 Ahadeeth, with the explanation of Shaykh ‘Uthaymeen (rahimahumAllaah) ✍
🌟 Hadith #1 🌟
It is narrated on the authority of Amir al-Mu'minin (Leader of the Believers), Abu Hafs 'Umar bin al-Khattab (may Allah be pleased with him), who said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him), say:
"Actions are according to intentions, and everyone will get what was intended. Whoever migrates with an intention for Allah and His messenger, the migration will be for the sake of Allah and his Messenger. And whoever migrates for worldly gain or to marry a woman, then his migration will be for the sake of whatever he migrated for."
Related by Bukhari & Muslim
✎ Linguistically, INTENTION (niyyah نية in Arabic) is what is wanted by the heart.
✎ Islaamically, it is the determination to do an act of worship SEEKING THE PLEASURE OF ALLAAH.
❤ The place of niyyah is in the HEART, not the limbs; uttering of intention is an innovation (bid’ah).
✎ The niyyah DISTINGUISHES HABITS FROM WORSHIP. For example:
a) eating out of desire vs eating in compliance with Allaah’s legislation, {O children of Adam, take your adornment at every masjid, and eat and drink, but be not excessive. Indeed, He likes not those who commit excess.} Soorah Al-Araf 7:31.
b) bathing to cool off vs bathing to cleanse from sexual defilement (ghusl).
✎ The niyyah also DISTINGUISHES ACTS OF WORSHIP FROM ONE ANOTHER. For example:
a) 2 raka’at voluntary salaah vs the 2 raka’at of Fajr
✔ CONDITIONS for acts of worship (to be accepted):
1. SINCERITY - it should be done for Allaah's sake
2. FOLLOWING - it should be according to the Sunnah/Shari'ah
✔ FOUNDATIONS of Islaam (based on these two ahadeeth):
1. "Actions are according to intentions…” - (heart)
2. “Whoever does an action that is not from this affair of ours shall have it rejected.” - (limbs)
Important point of ✿BENEFIT✿ from this hadith:
✔ Notice that in the statement, “Whoever migrates with an intention for Allah and His messenger, the migration will be for the sake of Allah and his Messenger,” the deed was mentioned again along with the sake of Allaah and his Messenger (salla’Allaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam).
✘ While in next statement, “And whoever migrates for worldly gain or to marry a woman, then his migration will be for the sake of whatever he migrated for,” the wisdom behind not mentioning the deed again is to show 👎 BELITTLEMENT 👎 of the worldly intention, and it wasn’t even worth mentioning again!
~~~~~~~
So it’s your choice: do it FOR THE SAKE OF ALLAAH ☝ or for something else 🌎? Why miss out?
#LIKE #SHARE #SUBSCRIBE
________________________________________________
👍 Follow us on:
🌍 www.onewaytopa...
🔗 Facebook: / abumussabwaj. .
🔗 Facebook: / onewaytopara. .
📱 Telegram: t.me/onewaytop...
Assalamu Alaykum, amongst the ocean of harsh and unnecessary refutations all over the internet, I feel like this one was done well & involved one of the most important aspects of our religion: intention. How many books of our beloved scholars BEGIN with the hadith about intention due to its overwhelming importance? SubhanaAllah! Allah guide us, jazakumAllahukhairan wa baarakaAllahufeekum.
Brother sajid I think back then no one knew u. I was scrolling n I found u there
Assalamualikum brother sajid
@@intakhabansari495 yeah , I never even noticed
Brother Sajid , good to see you ppl in once circle. 🥰😍🤩
Why didn't you accept Sol7 between you and Mohammad Hijab?
I'm an ordinary Muslim woman, I don't have much knowledge of Quran and Hadith . But when I listened to NAK for the first time, he explained ayatul kursi while he was laughing and goofing around. I knew something was wrong with that guy. Soon after when I listened to some of his illustrations of Quran. My heart didn't feel at ease I knew he was doing something wrong. Brother Wajdi thank you. May Allah reward you and your family with goodness in Dunya and Akhira.
when did it become haram to laugh?
Ar Az the qur’an should soften your heart, it could even make your heart trembles, not laugh. Rasulullah shallallaahu’alaihi wa sallam told us to weep more than laugh. It’s ok to laugh sometimes but better for us not to do it often.
He said: “Do not laugh too much, for excessive laughter kills the heart [spiritually].” (Ibn Majah)
He also said: “If you knew that which I know, you would laugh little and weep much.” (Bukhari)
@@YusifM411 I quoted hadiths and you said those are stupid? Ittaqillah ya akhi. And nowhere did I say that you’re not allowed to laugh, read carefully. Maybe english is not your native language, not mine too.
@@YusifM411 narrated by Aisha rhadiyallahu anha:
"I never saw the Messenger of Allah laugh fully to such an extent that I could see his uvula. He would only smile."
- Sunan Abu Dawood Volume 3, Book 41: Kitab Al-Adab (General Behavior), Hadith Number 5079;[3] Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 73: Kitab Al-Adab (Good Manners and Form), Hadith Number 114.
Jabir ibn Samurah narrated:
Simak ibn Harb asked Jabir ibn Samurah, "Did you sit in the company of the Messenger of Allah?" He said: Yes, very often. He (the Prophet) used to sit at the place where he observed the morning or dawn prayer till the sun rose or when it had risen; he would stand, and they (his Companions) would talk about matters (pertaining to the days) of ignorance, and they would laugh (on these matters) while (the Prophet) only smiled.
- Sahih Muslim, Book 4: Kitab Al-Salat (Book of Prayers), Chapter 92, Hadith Number 1413
There is a hadith that told us the prophet shallallaahu’alaihi wa sallam laughed and his teeth were shown. But you have to understand the context ya akhi.
In 'Zad Al-Ma'ad', Ibn Al-Qayyim (may Allah have mercy on him) said: Most of his laughter, actually all his laughter, for that matter, was to merely smile, in a way showing his front teeth. He smiled at whatever caused laughter or surprise. At-Tabarani in his 'al-Mu'jam al-Kabeer' and Al-Baihaqi in his 'Shu'ab al-Eman', narrated about the description of the Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam) that: Most of his laughter was smiling. [Ruled as authentic by Imam Ibn Hajar in his 'Fath al-Bari']
Rasulullah shallallahu’alaihi wa sallam told us:
"Do not laugh too much, for laughing too much deadens the heart."
- Saheeh al-Jaami’, 7312; al-Tirmidhi, 2305; Ibn Majah, 4193
@@YusifM411 no need to apologize akh, all of us should give advice to each other. Wa ‘alaikum salaam.
Problem is that we the masses of muslim don't study. wallahi brother wajddi have done us a favor may allah reward him.
But if we don't get basic education in islam people of batil ideology will always play with our eman.
At least make a dua for brother wajddi who get all the trouble to reveal us the truth.
Exactly! People don't want to take time to learn the religion from the book and sources and want other people to take time and give them ready-made material.
Use a capital A when writing the name Allah.
From someone who was kind of a fan (long ago) of NAK. This lecture is very beneficial, we shouldn’t learn anything about our deen from NAK. May Allah protect us all-ameen.
I was raised by my Christian mother and reverted a couple years ago alhamdullilah. When I and my wife wanted to learn more about Islam, the successful businessmen in the masjid referred me to Nouman Ali Khan. However, we sought out a more mature teacher. Allah bless you and all of our brothers and sisters who teach.
@Abū AbdulRahmān al-Aqeeli thank you for your duaa and thank you for this information dear brother. Allah bless you for your good deeds and give you everything you need for this channel, for this life and for the hereafter. Allah give you success and ample portions and protect you and all Muslim and Muslima. Allahum Ameen alalamien
May Allah keeps you steadfast and protect you from misguidances.
I love you for the sake of Allah ya akhi.
I never knew there was a part 2 😂.
Your NAK video 1 was the one that I watched and helped those around me get off the NAK drug when he was charming audiences all over the world.
And now, my years long of struggle of understanding intentions for Allah has been solved, Alhamdulillah through this lecture you have cleared my doubts and clarified the concept. May Allah reward you for every action that I do from now on having a better understanding about my intentions for Allah.
Hope you still use youtube 🤣
I just need the links to all the refutation he is doing on NAK can you help me with that ?
For someone who actually said and I quote, "If someone gives you advise and you got/feel offended, then you have an ego problem."
Walk the talk yaa sheikh (NAK).
Allahul Musta'an.
Jazakallah brother mussab for highlighting this issue otherwise I would be clueless.Your lecture has been beneficia please carry on with your lectures .Allah preserve you and grant you jannat firdous
JazakaAllah khayr for this! May Allah guide us and him. The people of Sunnah only want goodness for each other and sadly people don't understand that...
may allah keep you on the manhaj of salaf till your last breath, we need English salafi speakers like you, may allah give you longer, very longer life.
Dear brother this is dawah, guiding the ummah away from fitna, especially the fitna that is a wolf in sheep’s clothing !! It’s literally scary for those of us who are weak in our eman. Allah bless you brother, Allah SWT reward you and keep you steadfast Ameen 👍💛
Shocked to see this.Even though it's an old video.Subhanallah shows that no one is perfect.
JazakAllah Khair for your efforts brother Abu Mussab may Allah preserve you
Jazakallah, it put me in huge dillema and doubt abt my faith after I saw that clip abt sincerity from nak, bcs I used to do something only for the sake of Allah to get the reward in akhirah, it gives me motivation to be better and do more good deeds, but nak shake that faith of mine for a moment, but after that I knew its wrong, Alhamdulillah Allah has guided me through you, truly the lord of the world is ever merciful and care about His servant.
Tamim bin Aus Ad-Dari (RadiAllahu anhu) reported: The Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) said,
“Ad-Deen is sincerity”. We said: “For whom?” He replied, “For Allah, His Book, His Messenger and for the leaders of the Muslims and their masses”.
[Muslim].
May Allah reward you for the clarification.
Jazak Allahu Khairun brother ❤️
May Allah guide us and increase us in knowledge.
I learnt more about intentions than I learnt about NAK.
May Allah grant you a long hayat with a great health.
Wow this is so sad wallah. I didn't know it was that bad until I saw this.
VERY WELL PRESENTATION, CORRECT AND TO THE POINT! THANK YOU ABU MUSSAB! I FELT THE SAME WAY WHEN I WATCHED NAK'S LECTURE ON THIS. I THINK SOMETIMES NAK TRIES TO "REACH" FROM HIS OWN EXPERIENCES/EDUCATION RATHER THAN AUTHENTIC TEXTS!
If nouman is a Quran Scholar how would he have not known this verse
🤔
Say, "Indeed, my prayer, my rites of sacrifice, my living and my dying are for Allah , Lord of the worlds. ♥
(6:162)
He's actually not even a Hafiz of the Quran. He gives Khubas and lectures with a Quran open in front of him. He also can't conversate in Arabic. He's similar to Zakir Naik , in that he knows Quranic Arabic only. For example, Naik when interviewed by Arabic journalists can only speaks English (check any interviews on Al Jazeera) and they translate for the interviewer. I would be shocked if Nouman wouldn't be the same (although he mostly and now for many years has stayed far away from the Gulf like Yasir Qadhi). Further, remember Zakir Naik is a hafiz of the Quran.
Maa syaa Allaah, when the first hadiith in the 40 ahadiith of an-Nawawii is about the importance of intention.
2 conditions are required for our good deeds to be accepted:
1. Good intention
2. Ittiba, following the Prophet shallallaahu’alaihi wa sallam
Na'am.
Very tactfully and professionally delivered bro 👍
Ya Shaykh,
I couldn't even watch that batil even for 7 minutes, the heart really falls apart.
Some people have hearts that are harder than stones, and we are witnessing it on these digital mimbars. SubhanAllaah.
Pray for the Ummaah. May Allaah protect you, aameen.
May Allah reward you on your effort and protect you from fame and arrogance, brother. We were told that none of the imams of the Salaf would tolerate falsehood without refuting it.
The day i noticed Nouman Ali Khan losing his beard, I knew that he is changing and now he has reached this level.
May Allah guide us and him... Ameen
JazkaAllah Khair
I was too hasty in asking on a prev vid about this. Jazzakum Allahu khayrun for having addressed this. Im more upset that I didn't catch these things. Shame on me.
جزاك الله خير وثبتك على ما يحبه ويرضاه
May Allah bless you and your family brother. I have noticed one thing of NAK that most of his followers are not informed about the Islamic history, don't know anything about the previous scholars and there way of practicing the Deen. And about NAK if anyone see him closely he will be able to see his pant below the ankle which is a clear sign of how much he ignores the authentic hadiths and live his life by his own desire. May Allah forgive us and forgive u.
exactly akhi, back in a day when I was a Huge fan of his, that thing bothered me, I was like, how can you be so "knowledgeable" and not know that your lower garment isn't supposed to pass your ankles. Together with the fact that he would trim his beard from time to time. But, my admiration for him made me overlook that, till the day I watched his lecture "A balanced approach to religion". That was when I was like: Dude, I'm done with this guy. And a while after that I watched a video of Abu Mussab warning against him pertaining the issue of aqeedah, it was predictable I guess. May Allah guide him and those he misled ameen.
Mashallah May Allah reward you jannah
ma sha Allah The Sheldon of Islam ya akhi i love you for the sake of Allah and for the purity of knowledge of Allah and Rasool Ullah SAW!
Nice to see you back my brother . Mashallah
جزاك لله خير
I agree that most masjids and so called imams here are refutable and bussiness oriented
JazakAllahu khayran for the lecture
I am a new revert, from hindu-brahminism, I am currently in USA for my masters, I want to learn arabic, and islamic law, I want immerse myself in islam, is there any scholarship for people like me? I also researched about maliki fiqh. I am 24 years old. Thank You.
P.S
I haven't told my parents in india about it .
show me some way...
I dont like to ask favors, but I am clueless, I have degree in mechanical engg which I hate, my heart is thirsty for religion and scholarship.
Try abu ameena bilal philips Islamic online university
Hope you're doing well brother... May Allah SWT keep you and us steadfast on our religion.
You need to find scholars and learn from them. Where they live you move there and study the religion under them. You can also do the University route and apply to islamic universities like Medina
Knowledge College Online
Lot of love and dua for you brother. May Allah make it easy for you.
It's okay to correct each other but let's not making divide. May Allah guide us to His straight path
ikhwani?
We can only unite upon the truth and the splitting of the ummah is a prophecy from the Prophet sall Allaahu alayhi wa sallam.
Tawheed divides people on the basis of Truth and falsehood. On the basis of those who worship Allah alone, believe Allah is alone in control and believe that Allah alone is the creator and believe in all the Names and Attributes of Allah and then on the other hand are the falsehood people who innovate in the religion and preach faslehood. Yes Tawheed divides.
There is no unity upon deviance
JazakAllah khairan
Thank you so much !!
53:17 - For some people, trivial life things are worship due to their intentions//sincerity.
For some people, their acts of worship are nothing but rituals becaus they are heedless
ALWAYS MAKE THE RIGHT INTENTIONS//BE SINCERE before doing something.
Allah can make a small deed count as a lot because you were sincere. Never belittle a small deed guys.
love you my beloved akhi love you aton ❤
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
jazzakallah Khair
ASSALAMUALAIKUM brother Wajdi, Jazakallahu khayr for bringing up so many points, and really appreciate you replying to comments on a 4yr old video. am sure you must be aware that NAK offers this "learn arabic language of the quran" program, can you please refer any sound alternatives i.e something similar (in English)? .. a reply on this would be really appreciated brother. Jazakallahu khayr
If my memory is not weak, then I think that his Arabic lessons are good. I think sheikh Jalal Abu Alrub said something about his Arabic lessons. Check his video about Nouman Ali Khan and Tawheed
JazakAllahu khayran for having the courage to make this video. I don't think NAK's lectures are all bad, but you do have a point. His recent (2-3 years) lectures feel off somehow. Are they truth mixed with falsehood? Allah knows best.
It's crazy how a relatively benign issue can become so pedantic like intention for God. It seems rather simple; nearly every action we do can be an ibaadah with the right intention (and this is great for us). As humans, of course, sometimes we do not do it with the intention of ibaadah so it's not ibaadah. If I see my friend and I smile because I was bored and am happy to see him, it's not an ibaadah (but there's no harm in it either). If I see my friend, and I'm busy and rushed, but I remember a hadith or verse in the Qur'an, I might then realize smiling and greeting this friend will by for the sake of God (and not my sake since I am being inconvenienced by it). This is an ibaadah.
There seems to be this wedge being driven between the "cool relatable" Muslims and the unrelatable "holier than thou" Muslims. The "cool relatable" type seem to be over-correcting the perceived "phoniness" of those other Muslims. I definitely can see why some people are put off by the Muslims who behave in that holier than thou manner, but there's a middle approach which is closest to the truth.
I agree with you
الحمدلله
I had to go back and forth a few times between this video and NAK video you were referring to and subhan'Allah, it hurts. It hurts to see how people laughed at the matter about making intercourse to your wife. I almost forgot about the du'a when I was listening to NAK explaining it. I had to come back to your video to fully realize what NAK was saying. And I can clearly say that I am not one of the people NAK is describing. Every time a Muslim has relations with his wife in bed, he should have the niyyah and taqwa of Allah. That's the natural process of a Muslim. Just that aspect is clearly dangerous.
Also, as Abu Mussab pointed out, I had to go back and count to realize how many times NAK pulls out rulings from his own ration, rather than the ayaat & ahadith. He could not even put any citations of any of the ahadith he quoted, hence his fabricated quotes. Jazak Allahu khair for this. I would have missed this had it not been for you pointing out.
I want to do the same thing as well... Can you please tell the title name or paste the link
JazakAllah khayr brother
Assalaamu aleykum. This is amazing🥺. This is outrageous 😨. SubhaanalLah I really defended him thinking people were chastising him for his personal life mistakes, which in itself is not a good reason to shun anyone. But ohh yaa Allah!!! This is so fundamental! I am a BAYYINA student. I have to say that I want to slam the door... But I yet have to find a better Qur'an tadabbur class... Please help.
Perhaps you can watch the weekly tafseer classes held by the ustadh
Usually at 1;30 pm Makkah time
AMAU Academy.
I haven't ever seen anything like that
asalamualaykum brother i hope you also warn people regarding those DONATION SHEIKS and SELFIE ADDICT DAEES of social media.jazakaahlahu khair
Asalamualaikum Abu Mussab . May everything is at ease :)
Brother Abu Mussab I have missed listening to your lectures. Welcome back. May Allah s.w.t reward you for all your efforts. I used to love listening to NAK and other speakers you refuted by name after listening to videos refuting his ideology/philosophy and especially your video. Your explanations are very clear with evidence when listened in full. Please don't allow others to take portions out of your videos. I refrained from listening to your videos for many years because of this. I have learned a lot from videos of refutation of innovators, and the value of the 3 generations after the prophet S.A.W. Jazak Allah for exposing the fake hadiths mentioned and clarifying them and explaining in detail, because there are other refuters they don't quote and speak in general. This differs the truth from falsehood, where innovator followers can't accuse or bring excuses.
I disagree with him on many things but he made some strong points...May Allah protect us and guide us...May we be rightly guided
What things you disagree on?
Love you for the sake of Allah
i use to respect nouman now his become a comedian more than a benefiter Naudhu billaah dont worry itl be on his neck in the day of regret may Allaah protect us from this deviance ameen ya raab
we are not worried about his neck we are afraid that he will misguide muslims and specialy the reverts
Assalam o Alykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. Fe amanillah.aameen.
The dangers of becoming a celebrity are real. There's another brother I know personally. I studied at the Islamic University of Medinah with him. Now he is famous. Boy oh boy he is so famous. He talks about stuff from his own self. You hardly ever hear him quoting Qur'an and Sunnah.
he always talks about Quran .
Alhamdulillah. Keep it up. Allah Kareem Will show the truth and Will perish false practice,In sha Allah ...
thank you, Brother
Is it okay if we watch debates regularly such as Daniel Haqiqatjou , Farid Responds and etc. Should laymen avoid watching debates ( not even a single one ) because of the doubts that may enter a person? I’m confused because I was about to watch a debate right now but this question popped in my mind .
It is not ok.
Salam aleykum I have been a bayyinah student for 10 years (well ex, I left Bayyinah yesterday after I watched his video on music & your videos). Thank you for opening my eyes and sorry that I said bad things about you in the past (criticism, I though you were not sincere, jealous etc etc), may you forgive me and may Allah forgive me. I am athari myself but have been influenced by NAK, now I probably need to undo some damages. May Allah help me
Just one suggestion, if you could refrain from mocking the other person or if you do it in a subtle/gentle manner, it gives better results trust me. I watched the PART 1 of this video and you were impeccable in terms of character yet very academic and structured ; & it completely convinced me. I am still not going to follow you (not that it matters lol I am a miskina) because of your approach, I am not comfortable with it. Like I remember you made a video against ali dawah long time ago and I really did not like the approach, though I myself unfollowed him long time ago. Just a humble suggestion, wa salam !
Wa Alaykum Assalaam,
Thank you for your kind words. Will work on it inshaa'Allaah.
@@OneWayToParadise regarding this lecture I have a question if a person is a muslim he does something because he feel pain of others because he himself went through that pain . At that moment he helped out his mercy that Allah put in his heart. But in future he want reward from Allah . Will he be reward ed. Jazakallah khair. I am waiting for your reply.
@@khushiali7243 We don't know.
Salaam Ustadh, how can i explain to my parents to not watch and take knowledge from people such as Dr Israr Ahmed (they need evidence but i can’t find any 😢) Have you made a video on him and his beliefs?
"Akhira hehe, we are the nerds, hes the genius who came from planet jupiter to educate us all about islam".Your too funny brother 😂😂😂
Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
Have you heard anything from brother Nouman since this talk?
mashallah
Asalaamu'alaykum i have a question so if a muslim does a good deed like helping an enlderly without having the intention of doing it for the sake of Allah but rather he did be because the act itself is good and brings about joy, does he get rewarded by Allah?
As far as my understanding, correct me if im wrong, if person A and person B both being muslim, do the same good deed but person B has a better sincere intention of seeking Allah's pleasure, both of them would get rewarded however person B will get rewarded even more because he had done it for the sake of Allah ?
JAK
in the near future can we expect a series or a lecture or two on on correct aqeedah ?
Wa alaykum salam.
A will not get rewarded, but B will.
For examble:
A and B gave charity, and only B got rewarded for their deeds that will help one in akhirah., Whilst A only have gained the feeling of joy here in dunya, but in akhirah it would be empty.
Intention is so important and also a very hard thing, because one of the dangers that can comes into the heart, is riyaa.( Doing it, so you can be praised by the people) Also the feeling of joy, is also kind of a pride in "i've done such a good job today, thanks to me". But a muslim knows that, every acts of worship he does should be for the sake of Allah alone, and he fears that it might not be accepted, because that can result that ones good deeds can be into dust in akhirah.
May Allah accept our good deeds and protect us from misguidance and the hellfire. Allahumma ameen.
Yo Akhii when you coming to the UK lol
He lives in Saudi Arabia
Jazakallhu Khiran brother.
بارك الله فيك أستاذ
i havent see brother NAK video for long time iam wonder what vid that brother wadji talk about?
Assalamualaikum brother very good lecture may Allah reward you. In the future can you please repeat he questioners question before you answer. Jazakallah khayr
Assalamu Alaikum. ..I have been watching a few of your videos..a couple about NAK and the other was about Yasir Qadhi. I have to say I found them to be very interesting and eye opening. I (like most Muslims) am very fond of NAK lectures. Like you said he speaks very eloquently and to be honest I didn't find anything wrong in his speeches. But I am a layman so I probably wouldn't know right from wrong. I am In Shaa Allaah seeking knowledge constantly but I have to say it's becoming very difficult. I thought Alhamdu lillah with all these scholars available on youtube and with Aalimaas that I know personally, I was on the right track In Shaa Allaah. But now I'm very confused. Please tell me, how does an ordinary Muslim like myself who wants to practise deen and get close to Allaah distinguish what is right and what is wrong when one by one everyone we turn to is just belittling one another? How do I know who or what is authentic? How do I be a good practising Muslim when all I hear is one scholar completely scrutinising another? Bear in mind..I have never been taught anything about Islaam as a child. I have only read Qur'aan. I've never been taught about the life of our Rasool Sallallahu Alayhi Wassalaam. Or the Sahaabis. Or Aqeedah or hadith. Nothing. I have only been learning for a few years now. So where do I go to learn? As I cannot do any Aalimah courses either ( for my own personal reasons). And another point is..I get you are trying to guide the Muslims from destruction..but do you have to do it in such a patronising way? I'm not very knowledgeable but I do know that our Rasool Sallallahu Alayhi Wassalaam always spoke in a polite and gentle manner and not the way you are brother. If you want to guide the Muslims maybe you might want to speak in a different tone or manner as that is the first thing that will steer away those who are extremely 'obsessed' with NAK. As you say. Especially the young generation.
Wa Alaykum Assalaam,
Thank you for your feedback. There is so much to explain and my lectures will anwer all your questions inshaa'Allaah. Please take the time to watch them and not only the ones which happen to be a refutation. As for being polite, then we are polite. However, it is the way of the Prophet, the Sahaabah and the arly generations to be stern with the people of misguidance and deviance. Just remember that the prophet called the Khawaarij the DOGS of fire in front of the companions. And in that context, that was also polite. The judgement of politeness is based on the way of the prophet and not other western or eastern cultures.
قال الإمام محمد بن سيرين:
The Imaam Muhammad bin Sireen said: «إِنَّ هَذَا العِلْمَ دِيْنٌ؛ فَانْظُرُواْ عَمَّنْ تَأخُذُوْنَ دِيْنَكُمْ». “Indeed this knowledge is the religion, so be careful with regards to the one whom you take your religion from” (أخرجه مسلم في مقدمة صحيحه). Imaam Muslim collected it in the introduction to his Saheeh
Nak isn't a scholar and non of the true scholars belittle each other, they correct each others mistakes.
Assim al hakim does Q&A so does mohammed Salaah bin Salaah.
There's naseeha sessions, khaled green, Abu Ibrahim husnayn, farid responds, Muslim skeptic, this brother, Abu tameia, abdur rahman hassan, saajid lipham, dus dawah, if you are in the UK then Abu suhaib and abdur rahman dimashqia
@@iimiboy where in the Qur'aan is Allaah joking around or goofing around when He is speaking to us about the wrongdoers? Or in the hadith even? If you're going to point out mistakes and correct someone at least do it without the clowning around is all I'm saying. If I wanted to watch a cartoon I'd watch Tom and Jerry. This is the problem with half the scholars on social media. All they do is laugh and make jokes. When I read the Qur'aan I don't see any jokes. I might not know the full translation but I've heard enough to know that. On social media it's more of a comedy session than anything else. Oh here's a Qur'aanic verse then a joke in between. Ridiculous. I watch sheikh Assimal Hakeem's Q&A and I have to say he seems the most genuine to me at the moment. He's precise and to the point. His little jokes here and there are more to show the seriousness of the mistakes. And Mohammed Sheikh Salah.
@Khudeja Begum I think you have misunderstood mad gone gamer. You make the same points.
Salam wa alaykum brother whats the Hadith reference @55:30 ?
Why is it that the sub-continent is the source of so many bidʻahs and innovations?
Because of Tableeghi jamaat (sufi source)
@@amaturrahmaan964 wow what an arrogant statement
British colonialism brought 3 dangerous sects brailvi, deobandi, ahmadi to suppress divide and control Muslims.
You guys are messed up.. Tbligh jammat is a dawa that you salafis will never ever match or reach.. They are cut above you arabic educated so called preachers...
You are right... Sit on throne of salfiya and preach on RUclips you will reach the masses... These tabligis go door to door to call people to good... They are bad misguided baad people only the salafs are good.. Get a channel and put out a video and sit back... 😜😜😜
Assalamu Alaykum, so as I was watching your lecture I stumbled upon one matter and wanted your clarification.
Without any doubt, smiling is an act of worship and by doing it with the intention of pleasing Allah SWT is ibadah.
But if a person meets his friend/ colleague/ neighbor and smiled just to show them or to please them, is this considered Shirk?
I am sorry brother but I am not finding faults in your video, rather I am confused because there are many cases in life we smile and laugh without having the intention in our mind to please Allah. So does that all count shirk? Please help me to understand this clearly!
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله
No, but you won't be rewarded for it since it wasnt for the sake of Allaah. Wallahu a'lam
Brother mussab
I been following for nearly a decade...and yes since the first time i watched video my heart always guided by the lights of the truth...and from the first time i watch nourman Ali khans video..
My heart dislikes him...i think the main reason he deviated, is because he put so much thought on every matter that leads to overthinking and analyzing things that made him to conclude things with his on mind and not by the opinions of the ulama especially the salafs...
I know nouman ali khan lies not completely but he adds spice to the stories. Ex: In a meciful servant series called true motivational stories the first story is from nouman ali khan where he talks about Robert devilia a man suffering from paralysis whom nouman ali khan and his team visited. That guy was a christian and he could only see, talk, hear, and eat and he couldn't move a single part not even his neck( this is true) then NAK says that one day the man saw prophet Muhammad peace be upon him in his dream and muhammed peace be upon him said him to become muslim. (here nouman ali khan said that the man had never heard of Islam or muhammed peace be upon him in his entire life but there's another actual video of that day where Robert Devilia said that he was researching about islam then he saw that dream) at last nouman ali khan says that the Robert recited surah asr and everyone ( NAK and his team) started crying but if we see the real video Robert actually recited surah Quraish and nobody were crying. So that he lied twice in the whole story.
But nobody's perfect just coz he lies sometimes doesn't make him a wrong person. Nobody knows what's a person's heart. So never judge a person for his mistakes Allah can guide them whenever Allah wills. But also be careful with what u hear and never believe everything a person says. The arabic word insaan means the one who forgets and one craving for love. We all either love someone or wants to be loved.
Correcting a person infront of everyone is humiliating the person.
وَيۡلٌ لِّـكُلِّ هُمَزَةٍ لُّمَزَةِ
(Woe to every scorner and mocker)
Quran. Surah Humazah
And Who taught me this surah??
Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan. May Allah protect him from people like u. May Allah forgive him for his mistakes as he is a person.
So you and NAK are better than the prophet ﷺ himself who corrected people in front of everyone? Amazing Emaan.Oh wait, did you just correct me in front of everyone as well? Oh, it's Halaah for you but Haraam for me? Keep it going.
lmao ur so right brother, its giving hypocrisy 101@@OneWayToParadise
I really wanted to use his online Arabic videos, am I not recommended to do so then?
Best thing is not to do so.
NAK made up a hadith ("pokeimane") and failed to explain the source of it or who he heard that from. He gets angry when people ask him "how do we establish the sharia?", among many of the deviant things he says he says the idols should not be destroyed. He votes in democratic elections which is MAJOR KUFR. The man is funny and charismatic but that only hides his deviancy.
Whats wrong with voting? Isn't ikhtilaf between scholars? Its not Aqeedah so therefore its different of opinions Allah knows bedst
@@Rahimeeh Voting is giving somebody the "right" to make laws and that is by definition shirk
@@ArchiveofTawheed its YOUR personal opinion where is your source. Like I said before isn't different of opinions between the ulmaaa? Please if you don't have any thing 🤐
@Abū AbdulRahmān al-Aqeeli `Legislation belongs solely to Allah` If you gave the right to make laws to someone other than Allah you would be committing shirk. If you believed a king has the right to determine what's legal and what's illegal that is associating partners with Allah. As such, voting is your support for some secular leader to legislate, make laws alongside Allah. This is a major problem among the people who ascribe themselves to Islam, the shirk of voting is clear and it needs to be explained as much as possible so that the genuine among them may be guided.
just outbof curiosity I would like to watch that video of NAK, can anyone please mention the title of that video? jazakallahukhairan
Nouman is a really good speaker. and he caters to the american muslim women ego. he never once mentioned the wujoub of wife obedience to the husband. he said the Quran saying "قانتات" means qunoot to Allah. why? because the "american" muslim wife who is by now a "strong independent empowered outgoing" woman, will not accept the real haq of her husband on her no way. so why not change Islam for her? sure lets do that. Enter, NAK!
I am afraid of listening to him ,may Allah guide him to the way of sunnah
I thought i was the best salafie.. I do.. And i am actually..and all Muslims who have imaan will enter jannah even you guys and us all..
Elaborate please? Because the righteous should be humble.
Issues:
1) We give da'wah sometimes even when we don't have enough knowledge.
2) We should not get knowledge about Islam solely from watching videos. You need a teacher.
3) Not everyone can speak and convey message to people in the most beautiful way.
4) Sometimes ppl try to simplify things to explain, that can be dangerous.
5) A message can also be interpreted wrongly by listeners.
I don't like the fact that you mention about certain wrongs about certain people repeatedly in different videos... once is enough, in my opinion. What does this say about you?
MashaAllah TabarakAllah.
My suggestion is why not you make videos about those topics that you said were wrongly conveyed by these scholars, instead of "mocking" the person who conveyed the message. Let's make your version of those lectures the "right" way, so the public can learn from you.
Only Allah knows what's in the heart. And we are rewarded according to our niat.
So, in Shaa Allah, make your version of those lectures or research papers and give the world the opportunity to learn from you.
Make a video on Tablig
What is Hadith or Hadiths of people feed others while stuck in a cave ...dealing with Sadaqa? Any reference on this would be greatly appreciated.
It's the hadith about the 3 men stuck in the cave and make dua to Allah to help them because of their good deeds done for him
السلام عليك يا أبا مصعب
أحسن الله إليك
أين هذا المسجد
بارك الله فيك
I don't even remember what Masjid.
Is it okay to listen to his Tafseer which was almost 10
years ago? I guess he didn't have these influences on him back then.
NOOO
@@OneWayToParadise Can you recommend someone on the internet?
Tim Humble, AbdulRahmaan Hasan and here!!!
What do you think about the nak allegations.
Asalam Aleikum can you make a video on Nouman Ali Khan who said only idols were destroyed by IBrahim and the Prophet peace and blessings be upon them, thanks, maybe you can use the incident of Khalid ibn Walid etc.
1 - Muslim (969) narrated that Abu’l-Hayaaj al-Asadi said: ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib said to me: “Shall I not send you with the same instructions as the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sent me? ‘Do not leave any image without defacing it or any built-up grave without leveling it.’”
2 - Muslim (832) narrated from ‘Urwah ibn ‘Abasah that he said to the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him): “With what were you sent?” He said, “I was sent to uphold the ties of kinship, to break the idols, and so that Allaah would be worshipped alone with no partner or associate.”
3 - al-Bukhaari (3020) and Muslim (2476) narrated that Jareer ibn ‘Abd-Allaah al-Bajali said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said to me: “O Jareer, will you not relieve me of Dhu’l-Khalsah?” That was a house (in Yemen) belonging to the (tribe of) Khath’am, which was called Ka’bat al-Yamaaniyyah. I set out with one hundred and fifty horsemen. I used not to sit firm on horses and I mentioned that to the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). He struck me on my chest with his hand and said, 'O Allaah! Make him firm and make him one who guides others and is guided on the right path.' " So Jareer went and burned it with fire, then Jareer sent a man called Abu Artaat to the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). He said, “I did not come to you until we had left it like a scabby camel.” Then the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) blessed the horses of (the tribe of) Ahmas and their men five times.
Al-Haafiz Ibn Hajar said:
This hadeeth indicates that it is prescribed to remove things that may tempt or confuse the people, whether they are buildings, people, animals or inanimate objects.
4 - The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) sent Khaalid ibn al-Waleed (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy al-‘Uzza.
5 - and he sent Sa’d ibn Zayd al-Ashhali (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy Manaat.
6 - And he sent ‘Amr ibn al-‘Aas (may Allaah be pleased with him) on a campaign to destroy Suwaa’. All of that happened after the Conquest of Makkah.
Al-Bidaayah wa’l-Nihaayah, 4/712. 776. 5/83; al-Seerah al-Nabawiyyah by Dr. ‘Ali al-Salaabi, 2/1186.
Seriously can't believe this .....but I am not someone qualified to comment... Anyway I think we should not make this an issue as muslim
Why are we against someone who is just an Arabic scholar and want to spread Arabic
And about the name baniyyah niyyah means intention
Can't we assume baniyyah is NAK's intention is to spread the language of QURAN(isn't that for the sake of ALLAH)
Just it's a sad feeling if your favourite scholar who's hated, insulted, or rejected with some people
It feels bad when the one who helped to get back to the religion is someone's....
I don't know really what you see through his body language while he wants you understand in a fun way.
I think as a muslim we should not spot someone as if they are enemy of their own religion
I don't know but just ignore if you see something disappoint you
Let's pray for him instead watching these videos
It's not a nature of muslim to be against other muslim
Let's be friendly
These videos made me tense
I don't know what the whole thing is!
But started commenting so just this is my opinion not a comment
Lastly be a true Muslim listen to good even if a disbeliever says and never listen to bad even if a believer says
Well sister to your surprise, Islaam is not what you or I think. So either what we are doing is correct or incorrect according to Islaam. And they are not just correct, rather obligatory. Listen with an open heart and be fair.
Also, if I were to carry out an act of kindness just because that's who I am. For instance, if I were to help an old lady cross the road. Because I feel sorry for the old lady. It would make me feel good of course, but I wouldn't be doing it to show other people or so other people commend me for the act. There may be no one around to see. But would that act be accepted as rewarding? What if in my mind I didn't think I'm going to do this for the sake of Allaah? May Allaah forgive me. What if it's just a reaction? Or a part of my personality to help someone in need? How would that act be portrayed as?
As far as we know, you will be rewarded for it in the Dunya but not in the Aakhira.
And what if I was to carry out an act of worship, or and act of charity but I was afraid of riyah? In the sense that my intention is not to show off but I fear that riyah would creep in anyway? Should I carry out the act or would it be best to leave it? Can we control how we feel? What if we don't want to feel this way but we do? Is it a sin then? Will we be punished for something we cannot control? I apologise for bombarding you with so many questions but riyah is something that I am very afraid of. And it sometimes stops me from carrying out good deeds but then I fear I'll be losing out. So I am fighting with myself. I appreciate you taking the time to answer my questions. Jazak Allaah khair
Sister again we do good naturally because our parents taught us from young we get rewarded for doing good right?
Rewaded by who? By Allah of course so we Muslims by nature do good for the sake of Allah unless its to show off
@@iimiboy not everyone was taught to do things for the sake of Allaah. Not everyone was taught Islaam. I believe the brother already answered my question to this. Sometimes we do things just for the sake of it because that's who we are. Not even to show off but just because that's our character. Not everyone goes around thinking they'll do things for the sake of Allaah. That should be our intention yes, but unless your imaan is that strong and you're an extremely knowledgeable person, you're not going to do that. I know a lot of people (Inc myself) who are acting out of kindness simply because they are just like that. They don't know that their actions should be for the sake of Allaah. They're not showing of either. So I just wanted to clarify that for my own peace of mind.
Yes we should have the intention to do everything for the sake of Allaah but it doesn't mean we do. And whomever says otherwise is just kidding themselves. Don't forget Allaah knows what is in our heart and mind. When I go out shopping my intention is to feed my children. Because they are hungry and need to be fed. Is it for the sake of Allaah. If I eat it's because I'm hungry. .is it for the sake of Allaah? I say my du'aas of course but it's more because it's a requirement as a Muslim to save myself in the hereafter. I don't think to myself im going to go and eat for the sake of Allaah because if I don't I will die and Allaah will hold me accountable for starving myself which is like suicide. Although I might try to follow the sunnah and eat less. I'm pretty sure most of us are living our lives for the dunya. I don't think we even realise that everything we do should be for the sake of Allaah. Especially those without ilm. I'm pretty sure most of us act out of kindness because that's just who we are. In certain situations you do have to stop and make the intention (in your mind) that you're doing it for the sake of Allaah. For instance if you are at a dispute with someone. Family member, friend etc. Normally one would probably like to stop talking to the person or hold a grudge. But then they may change their mind and make amends for the sake of Allaah. May Allaah forgive me and grant me the ability to strengthen my imaan.
You did not undertand the lecture at all. Allaah tells us that our prayers and sacrifices and lives and death are for Allaah and you are telling us about your shortcomings!! We all have them but that does not change the truth!!
@@OneWayToParadise You may very well be right. I probably didn't understand. I have not been blessed with the amount of intellect that you have been blessed with. That is why I'm here..to learn and understand. Seeking help. So please help
Listen my sister in Islam and fellow bangali, we should make the intention before we get intimate with our wives and I make the dua before doing anything with my wife so nak saying no one does that and belittling the Sunnah shows he is dead wrong and I'm just an average Muslim with a beautiful model looking wife and I remember to make the dua in my mind
Why don't I sleep around? For the sake of Allah, why don't I go to night clubs? For the sake of Allah, why do I earn halal money? And on and on as my intentions are already made before I do anything
Anyway...I think it's been clarified that all our actions and ntentions should be solely for the sake of Allaah. May Allaah give me and everyone else the tawfeeq to do this and get closer to Him In Shaa Allaah. May He forgive us for our shortcomings and help us to stay away from shaitaans waswasa. I ask forgiveness for anything I might have said that upset or hurt anyone it was not my intention.
NAK keeps getting exposed! LOL
May Allah guide him and us.
PLEASE REPEAT THE QUESTIONS SHEIKH. OR MAKE IT SO WE CAN HEAR THE QUESTIONS OF THE PEOPLE. JAZAKALLAH KHAIR
is the original video still online or did he delete it?
No it’s still up
Missy .x. What’s the title please ?
Numan ali khan or ibn taymyah ? this explains everything - FYI I prefer the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
You prefer the prophet (SAW) ..... so u think ibn taymiyyah didn't ....he dedicated his entire life for the sake of Allah and he taught nothing except the Quran and the sunnah and the way the salaf understood it......that's why he had students like :
1.Ibn qayyim
2.Ibn katheer
And many other famous scholars.....
FYI you should know who u are talking about and how.....
The previous nations did worship their Priests and Rabies - are we on their path to the lizard hole?
Grozny Entertainment do you even study the life of ibn taymiyyah? No one is infallible but his aqidah and manhaj is sound
why was he in jail then? he was accused by the sound ulma of the time- please don't tell me it was a conspiracy against Haq. he is only famous today because Saudi spreads his books (or the whole Salafi ideology), because his opposition to shiaa
Yes I think ibn taymiyyah didn't prefer the prophet when makes fatway that someone should make the intention for the prayer silent, and if doesn't, he is asked to make tawba, and if he doesn't he is KILLED - and then we wonder where ISIS ideas came from. No that's not the way of the Prophet - so stop worshipping him without knowing
Assalamu Alaikum, anyone can share that clip in which nak say this thing
ruclips.net/user/shortsnMroKaZubBc
Salaams bro...don't you think it would be more beneficial to the people to warn against greater evils, like ISIS and the likes...my community were torn apart by isis. NAK talks never caused any brother to migrate to another country and kill people, their own Muslims at that. I searched through your channel, ive not seen any video condemning ISIS.
Wa Alaykum Assalaam,
My beloved brother this is a flawed concept. What makes someone become misguided enough to migrate to another country and kill people is their misunderstanding of the religion and its basics. Who is responsible for that? All the deviant callers who distort Islaam either by being too lenient or too extreme. It is our job to expose and warn against both. As for ISIS, I have spoken about them hundreds of times in my various talks. Check out the lectures which were delivered in Malaysia..
Idris Abdullah so your logic is its more dangerous to warn about extremism than SHIRK????? Shirk is the WORST Sin and most Dangerous
***** JazakAllah will look for those lectures.
Are you visiting UAE anytime?
Harris s
The subcontinent owes its large muslim population to such movement even if they did it with method not sanctioned in islam.. In a time when the arab peninsula was cozzying up Britain and such to gain power in the area.. A time when these ulema applied local methods to win the hearts of peasants who would have othetwise become hindus.. So allah will judge whose intention were good.. My view is these ulema were on point and brought Islam in this desputed manner to this period.. So lets tell these salafis now to go to these areas and teach instead of putting this podcast out to the wealthy.. Wake maan go give dawa house to house.