Extracting Jet Fuel From GumWeed

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 3,2 тыс.

  • @RaimarLunardi
    @RaimarLunardi 6 лет назад +3960

    "Smells like kerosene, let's taste it!" - Cody 2018

  • @arthurmorgan1960
    @arthurmorgan1960 6 лет назад +1508

    Next video extracting anti matter from ant semen.

    • @arthurmorgan1960
      @arthurmorgan1960 6 лет назад +16

      Squiggummer Figgammus XDD

    • @dadillen5902
      @dadillen5902 6 лет назад +31

      Silly human everybody knows there's no antimatter in Ant semen it's dark matter

    • @antimatter4733
      @antimatter4733 6 лет назад +24

      You called?

    • @kingplotato6025
      @kingplotato6025 6 лет назад +16

      Or is it ant matter

    • @FezTheSpaceBiker
      @FezTheSpaceBiker 6 лет назад +8

      Extracting 9/11 conspiracy theories from Flat Earthers

  • @chudat5983
    @chudat5983 6 лет назад +1220

    If this guy suddenly stops posting one day, you know why.

    • @thehen101
      @thehen101 5 лет назад +107

      he smoked too much gumweed

    • @zigg8798
      @zigg8798 5 лет назад +26

      Demonetized

    • @jacobgelven7194
      @jacobgelven7194 5 лет назад +42

      Chu Dat what, can’t he upload from mars?

    • @ymir8599
      @ymir8599 5 лет назад +2

      @@jacobgelven7194 what are you talking about??

    • @justADeni
      @justADeni 5 лет назад +30

      @@ymir8599 i bet he is living on mars secretly and he has already terraformed the planet

  • @jerry3790
    @jerry3790 6 лет назад +3181

    You know it’s Cody’sLab when he has to worry about the military doing it first.

    • @masterplay1201
      @masterplay1201 6 лет назад +26

      Cody is plain awesome.

    • @codyv308
      @codyv308 6 лет назад +7

      MasterPlay no, you're awesome

    • @DaniAurora23
      @DaniAurora23 6 лет назад +104

      I'm pretty sure the military goes to cody's patreon for ideas lol

    • @robertr.hasspacher7731
      @robertr.hasspacher7731 6 лет назад +17

      The Navy has a system that can build jet fuel hydrocarbons out of nothing but seawater and electricity. Would actually be quite a measure cheaper than sourcing from fossil fuels.

    • @omelette6422
      @omelette6422 6 лет назад +7

      Well there's a non-zero amount of CO2 in the atmosphere too. idk if it's a large enough amount, but it works for plants.

  • @larvitardratini5965
    @larvitardratini5965 6 лет назад +636

    Can you do a tutorial on how to set up the spoon?

  • @kieranodea771
    @kieranodea771 5 лет назад +112

    You need to use more water Cody, half of the plant matter should be soaked with water. It looks pretty dry in you bottom flask. Also try blending your plant matter for a better yield.

    • @JustIn-sr1xe
      @JustIn-sr1xe 3 года назад +10

      More surface area, more product.

    • @PauIieWalnuts
      @PauIieWalnuts Год назад +6

      If he broke up the gum weed it might have released trapped oils.

  • @doubledarefan
    @doubledarefan 6 лет назад +742

    Cody could almost build an actual jet (and fuel it, too) from raw materials found on his own property.

    • @natalieisagirlnow
      @natalieisagirlnow 6 лет назад +12

      given 100 years

    • @dawidex333
      @dawidex333 6 лет назад +112

      "Making f-16 fighter jet using cans and urine"

    • @Hundura
      @Hundura 6 лет назад +86

      “Hi everybody, welcome back to Cody’s lab. Today I found 2 sticks in my backyard..... let’s see if we can turn this into an X-32 Fighter Jet shall we.”
      -Cody

    • @lh3178
      @lh3178 6 лет назад +14

      HTME/Cody’s Lab crossover on how to make a jet (and use it to keep the government from taking it away)

    • @yushatak
      @yushatak 6 лет назад +2

      Almost? xD I don't see what he's missing, to be honest.

  • @f42099
    @f42099 6 лет назад +933

    "So i've got a spoon set up here". What a god. Where did he learn to set up a spoon so efficiently?

    • @explosu
      @explosu 6 лет назад +84

      The angle it sits at... the sheer grace of it... and it's clean! Every time I set up a spoon it's just covered in leftover kraft mac & cheese!

    • @lordfrostdraken
      @lordfrostdraken 6 лет назад +38

      Its cody, i bet he could have done it with a fork too, hes a genius

    • @Bishka100
      @Bishka100 6 лет назад +33

      Did you also notice how he expertly tested the flames thermal output @ 5:59?

    • @protodroidstuff
      @protodroidstuff 6 лет назад +2

      I gagged

    • @Dexter-qy5bl
      @Dexter-qy5bl 5 лет назад +8

      At a drug convention

  • @carsonrush3352
    @carsonrush3352 6 лет назад +384

    If you're smelling gumweed in the room where it wasn't before, then you're boiling it out the top.

    • @asdfald7475
      @asdfald7475 6 лет назад +11

      thanks for that life lesson

    • @nathansmith3608
      @nathansmith3608 5 лет назад +58

      if you're getting less than 100% efficiency in your processes though, at least you know you're on the right side of the law of thermodynamics

    • @-Honeybee
      @-Honeybee 5 лет назад +8

      @@nathansmith3608 the argument could be had we'd rather not, though.

    • @EllipticNGC
      @EllipticNGC 3 года назад

      I read the title and everything as cumweed

  • @trulyinfamous
    @trulyinfamous 6 лет назад +693

    That stuff would make a good lamp fuel from how it burns.

    • @zer0b0t
      @zer0b0t 6 лет назад +90

      I bet that's his final goal, he's a prepper.

    • @spine2788
      @spine2788 6 лет назад +12

      that would explain so much

    • @chadoftoons
      @chadoftoons 6 лет назад +13

      Yeah i thought so too but i think i'd take a bit to much effort for an hour to get enough oil without just killing all the plants that his bees like
      Over a year though you might be able to get alot of lamp oil like this

    • @Bob5mith
      @Bob5mith 6 лет назад +38

      Kerosene is probably cheaper than the electricity he'd use to distill an equivalent amount of oil, not to mention the time and effort. Firewood doesn't appear to be abundant for long term post-SHTF processing. Maybe if he developed a way to distill it with direct solar heating, but the return on time investment is still an issue.

    • @GrowingDownUnder
      @GrowingDownUnder 6 лет назад +20

      I don't get why he didn't just use a rosin press

  • @HankHill4
    @HankHill4 6 лет назад +1141

    Amazing renewable fuel it’s kind of like propane but it’s a liquid not a gas oh how I love the smell of propane and propane accessories

    • @milesrowe2263
      @milesrowe2263 6 лет назад +27

      How's Bobby and bill?

    • @robinhyperlord9053
      @robinhyperlord9053 6 лет назад +18

      "Wut? That boy ain't right. I sell propane and propane asseries. Wahhh!"
      The King Of The Hill was funny, still overrated though.

    • @milesrowe2263
      @milesrowe2263 6 лет назад +16

      @@robinhyperlord9053 better then family guy or any of the new shit

    • @robinhyperlord9053
      @robinhyperlord9053 6 лет назад

      @@milesrowe2263
      FG us not as one dimensional.

    • @serialexperimentsdave7213
      @serialexperimentsdave7213 6 лет назад +20

      Gumweed oil is a bastard fuel

  • @Draakdarkmaster6
    @Draakdarkmaster6 5 лет назад +74

    it burns for a long time and very cleanly, seems to me it'd make a very good low octane fuel for some kind of generator, to reduce fuel upkeep

    • @Arcanefungus
      @Arcanefungus 3 года назад +11

      If you use a burner type generator id probably just chuck the whole plant in...

    • @whoknows8225
      @whoknows8225 Год назад +2

      @@Arcanefungus .2% is oil, you'll be burning 99.8% just making heat and CO2.

    • @reeman2.0
      @reeman2.0 Год назад +1

      @@whoknows8225 Isn't making heat the exact point of a burner generator?

  • @hypercube5276
    @hypercube5276 6 лет назад +709

    Me: A spoon
    Cody, an intellectual: 5:25 "A spoon setup"

    • @RENO_K
      @RENO_K 6 лет назад +3

      Lol yep

    • @Kezbardo
      @Kezbardo 6 лет назад +51

      I think he said set up like a verb not a noun

    • @twizz420
      @twizz420 6 лет назад +25

      He has a spoon set up. Not a spoon setup.

    • @hypercube5276
      @hypercube5276 6 лет назад +12

      That's "the joke".

    • @Kezbardo
      @Kezbardo 6 лет назад +16

      Hypercube 527 is "the joke" in quoation marks because it's not a good joke?

  • @RubixB0y
    @RubixB0y 6 лет назад +265

    Missed title opportunity: Making Jet Fuel from Weed

    • @Chiaros
      @Chiaros 6 лет назад +42

      Weed fuel can't melt steel beams!

    • @CreaperSiege
      @CreaperSiege 6 лет назад +22

      Георги Ставрев
      I'd go far as to say that the more weed fuel you have in the world, the less people want to melt steel beams in the first place.

    • @EdwinCristobal
      @EdwinCristobal 6 лет назад +4

      D E M O N E T I Z E D

    • @minsin56
      @minsin56 5 лет назад

      clickbait 101

    • @Taydrum
      @Taydrum 5 лет назад

      Weed fuel can't melt your mind

  • @christopyper1287
    @christopyper1287 6 лет назад +109

    I love how Cody refers to the ranch as his backyard

  • @gamingscientist7445
    @gamingscientist7445 6 лет назад +22

    Sounds like a breeding experiment is in order. Breed a strain of the plant that produces a heavy amount of oil, thereby improving your output yield. After that, it's just a matter of improving your distillation apparatus. Might be able to produce a viable product.

  • @OneOfDisease
    @OneOfDisease 6 лет назад +26

    Cody don't stop because you saw an article, there is a huge difference between a proof of concept for running a car on weed or vs a jet on said weed oil. If the US Mil thought the plant had so much potential I think you should expand your testing.

  • @Zach-wl6kb
    @Zach-wl6kb 6 лет назад +371

    Every science class I’ve ever been in:
    “never taste the experiments”
    Cody’s Lab:
    “I’m going to taste it”

    • @martynaskerdokas8438
      @martynaskerdokas8438 5 лет назад +6

      Zach S i always taste when im making KOH crystals to make sure it is the right substance

    • @ManTheBush
      @ManTheBush 5 лет назад +8

      Tasting used to be an important part of early chemistry

    • @giuseppebonatici7169
      @giuseppebonatici7169 4 года назад +1

      you didn't have enough geology then.

    • @giannis_m
      @giannis_m 2 года назад

      @@ManTheBush To be fair early chemistry was much more dangerous. I wouldn't wanna touch anything in an alchemist's lab, there would be mercury everywhere.

    • @evelyncarsten6660
      @evelyncarsten6660 Год назад +1

      Well, in fairness - it's the known product of essentially boiling a non-poisonous plant. You could honestly argue for it to be a seperated gumweed tea

  • @ipkandskill
    @ipkandskill 6 лет назад +231

    I would be interested in seeing some test applications of this. Say in a small 2 stroke engine, maybe a small model rocket. Things like that, I'm sure you have other ideas for things that could works as fuel. It could be an interesting series if that's something your interested in.

    • @monowavy
      @monowavy 6 лет назад +7

      interesting interests.

    • @r3dp9
      @r3dp9 6 лет назад +34

      "Cody's Rocket Lab" Mini-Series
      Or maybe... "Kody's Space Program"? ^_^

    • @blameusa7082
      @blameusa7082 6 лет назад +7

      You go harvest 500 tonnes and send it to Cody!

    • @Nightxp
      @Nightxp 6 лет назад +8

      This would be perfect for the ‘Project Farms’ channel where he tests engines with all sorts of different things and see what effect they have for better or worse. Oh man please Cody get in touch the them that would be an awesome collaboration!

    • @littlegandhi1199
      @littlegandhi1199 6 лет назад

      I just watched a video on oranges and how they contain something exactly like gasoline "non polar... Something something"

  • @NurdRage
    @NurdRage 6 лет назад +116

    excellent work!

    • @Sodabowski
      @Sodabowski 6 лет назад +3

      Dude, you should make a video about the different types of condensers, so Cody gets a hint and stops using a Liebig where an Allihn is mandatory! So many losses to the wrong piece of glassware! Back when I studied to become a Physics & Chemistry teacher I was constantly amased at the poor choices that my classmates did. Oh, the delicate smell of DCM when you don't expect it! Cheers, and thanks to both of you for the vids. Can't support you guys yet but I thought a bit of constructive criticism, yet with a pinch of sarcasm, could help ;)

    • @Matando
      @Matando 6 лет назад +1

      Collaboration video when? It's ok Cody is trustworthy.

  • @t.b.d6294
    @t.b.d6294 6 лет назад +407

    perhaps if the plant was crushed instead of cut it could yield more oil.

    • @pipettejockey7464
      @pipettejockey7464 6 лет назад +58

      Not sure if the essential oils are coming from trichomes or maybe something in the pods, but drying the plants bone dry and blending it into a powder would likely increase yields, could be by a little, could be by a fair bit.

    • @Paul-gz5dp
      @Paul-gz5dp 6 лет назад +17

      You mean as is done with many other materials?
      Such as pressing with heat, and the reason for using steam is that it works with light volatiles and is limited more in the level of heat applied, and is better for getting essential oils when there is so much more dry materials than there is oil. This is the same process that is used to obtain Rose oil and many others. However it does not work with oils with a much higher boiling point than water.

    • @darkhorseman8263
      @darkhorseman8263 6 лет назад +4

      Lightly slashed then crushed. Denaturation works well.

    • @pizza-for-mountains
      @pizza-for-mountains 6 лет назад +15

      Really putting your Harry Potter knowledge to use.

    • @georgehays4908
      @georgehays4908 6 лет назад +1

      .........I would use the Isomizer style reduction . Strip all the resins along with the volatile . I ❤ my Michigan medical reductions like wax ! Peace !

  • @TheRedKnight101
    @TheRedKnight101 6 лет назад +363

    So Cody is refining uranium, manufacturing explosives, and extracting jet fuel...

    • @CryptoDatabase
      @CryptoDatabase 6 лет назад +83

      There will be a video in the future labeled "The FBI came to my ranch" or in a news article "Local ranch raided by the FBI""

    • @drearyplane8259
      @drearyplane8259 6 лет назад +72

      It's revenge for the sugar beet incident

    • @microlobbies2378
      @microlobbies2378 6 лет назад +62

      Ranch owner succeeds and declares war on United States with nukes

    • @acada6594
      @acada6594 6 лет назад +5

      If Cody needs some part of their ranch to be plowed, we can call the agency, there is some explosives or uranium hidden in underground.

    • @philipp7823
      @philipp7823 6 лет назад +15

      maybe hes using the explosive and uranium to make a nuke, and use the jet fuel to fly the bomber

  • @Pheorize
    @Pheorize 6 лет назад +15

    "So...I don't think will be good to add to soap or perfumes any times soon. But, let's go see if it burns!"
    I just love Cody's mind, that jumps from fragrances to flammability immediately

  • @dylanpritchard4981
    @dylanpritchard4981 5 лет назад +2

    I remember finding this channel a few years ago. Crazy how Cody is still managing to contour up something amazing!

  • @aveoxus1139
    @aveoxus1139 6 лет назад +26

    Cody it's also a project of the military to use a plastic made from dandelions to make tank treads. Plus it makes good tea lol

    • @myownidenity4955
      @myownidenity4955 6 лет назад

      Alex Maguire OSU is making latex from dandelions

  • @borkmaster2726
    @borkmaster2726 6 лет назад +51

    But the real question remains... Will you soon build a fully functional jet in your backyard?

  • @mr.techaky7655
    @mr.techaky7655 6 лет назад +733

    *GuMWeEd fUeL CaN'T MelT STeEl BeAms*

    • @TheDeadMeme27
      @TheDeadMeme27 6 лет назад +17

      lmao good one

    • @sarttee
      @sarttee 6 лет назад +75

      America invades Codys backyard, when plants found produce OIL

    • @AerusalePhoxJr
      @AerusalePhoxJr 6 лет назад +11

      Steel Beans

    • @araane
      @araane 6 лет назад +15

      Steel spoons

    • @ericknabenshue5689
      @ericknabenshue5689 6 лет назад +6

      You better change your tone before we fire you and hire someone who says they can

  • @xdoods
    @xdoods 6 лет назад +142

    Not a Cody video if he doesn't taste his sample.

    • @Mark-dc1su
      @Mark-dc1su 6 лет назад +2

      I haven't seen those videos...

    • @derAlphawolf9
      @derAlphawolf9 6 лет назад +1

      Thats what I thought as well😂

    • @johnpossum556
      @johnpossum556 6 лет назад

      its been awhile since he's done this much, try the cyanide video where he talks about dilution

  • @libratyanjhon3959
    @libratyanjhon3959 6 лет назад +119

    GumWeed? My childhood called that "little sunny flower" and it was on my frontyard..

    • @lutyanoalves444
      @lutyanoalves444 6 лет назад +22

      Little did Jhon know, the sunflowers on his frontyard were actually WEED

    • @seniorvenusdigital3904
      @seniorvenusdigital3904 6 лет назад +4

      You have Weeds. Gumweed is a desert weed.

    • @CarnivorousPlantsAndGardening
      @CarnivorousPlantsAndGardening 6 лет назад +2

      I think you're thinking of dandelions
      Unless you live a dry place like Arizona

    • @SoftBreadSoft
      @SoftBreadSoft 6 лет назад +7

      Weed is a relative term. One man's weed is another man's food or poultice.

    • @Guru_1092
      @Guru_1092 6 лет назад

      @@SoftBreadSoft Was just about to say this.

  • @remen_emperor
    @remen_emperor 5 лет назад

    So, just found out that one of two plants in my lawn has flammable oils in it. Immediately, I thought of this video to see what extracting said oils may entail.
    Thank you for sharing your projects, as you've been the inspiration and accidental guide for many people.
    I wanted to show my appreciation before I try anything, just as a habit.

  • @DeutscheDemokratischeRepublik
    @DeutscheDemokratischeRepublik 6 лет назад +217

    Were smoking rocketfuel from now on guys, lets make a joint

  • @drunkenhobo8020
    @drunkenhobo8020 6 лет назад +201

    So, how long until demonetised for having "weed" in the title?

    • @parkerproffitt3012
      @parkerproffitt3012 6 лет назад +12

      RUclips probably thinks weed is a good thing (I'm not getting into that argument.)

    • @drunkenhobo8020
      @drunkenhobo8020 6 лет назад +21

      Would depend on the advertisers really. Budweiser wouldn't like the potential competition, but Doritos, Mountain Dew and M'Lady's Finest Fedoras would be right in at their target audience.

    • @JohnDoe-tx8eu
      @JohnDoe-tx8eu 6 лет назад +1

      @@parkerproffitt3012 you already did by just saying that lol

    • @JohnDoe-tx8eu
      @JohnDoe-tx8eu 6 лет назад +2

      @@drunkenhobo8020 microbreweries are already making beer with hemp. Nobody will get any competition, just a new product to market lol

    • @huhulili9021
      @huhulili9021 6 лет назад +1

      But is GumWeed its different

  • @MrSmokyFly
    @MrSmokyFly 5 лет назад +7

    Cody, you're a real inspiration to go out and learn. You have awesome ideas!

  • @mikebrooka9395
    @mikebrooka9395 6 лет назад +105

    Well done!
    Many years ago, a 4-H Teen Leader raised a crop of black sunflower seeds (common name: Russian sunflower), they are oily as the dickens. He pressed the oil out with a modified cider press. It used plates with smaller and more holes. This brings me to the question, is it more efficient to press and then cook or just cook? Next question is would a solvent work better like acetone in the beaker and a layer of water in that (I forget it name) on top of the beaker. The 4-H Teen Leader ran his tractors and combines on the sunflower oil in 1981 and still to this day. He filtered the pressed oil through old denim jeans and then a diesel fuel filter. Ain't not bad science, for it's day.
    Take care from Oklahoma
    Mike and 'That Dang Woman'.

    • @dfpguitar
      @dfpguitar 6 лет назад +6

      Im surprised that was ever worth the effort. Fuel prices in the US are vastly cheaper than they are in Europe. Pressed sunflower seeds would make a high grade edible oil that would be worth much more than the equivalent amount of gasoline or diesel.

    • @mikebrooka9395
      @mikebrooka9395 6 лет назад +2

      @@dfpguitar True. At that time, sunflower oil was nothing to the gallon and only mulched and put nitrogen in the soil, when turned under, for the cash crop of wheat next year.
      Thadd told me that cost savings were about 8 cents per gallon, all said. That meant the cost of the seedings, property rent, fuel from first harvest, next few years of harvest, and resoughlting yield and per acre.
      I will say that if he did hot press the seeds, his savings would have been higher.

    • @dfpguitar
      @dfpguitar 6 лет назад +2

      @@mikebrooka9395 that is very interesting to know. Farming in the US must be very different to the UK with all that space. It's unimaginable to think of any oil crop being mulched in the UK. Also sunflowers are a strange choice as a nitrogen "green manure" . The farming I am familiar with uses plants like clover & alfalfa which fix nitrogen to soil while alive, and again when mulched as they are still soft & green. They are also perfect grazing for animals. Sunflowers are extremely fibrous by the time they flower, and by the time they seed they are like a cross between a stick and a rope. It's hard to imagine them even breaking down in a season. May I ask, do you know where the income source is for grain crops like wheat? Is the money straight from commercial buyers or is it government subsidy?

    • @mikebrooka9395
      @mikebrooka9395 6 лет назад +1

      @@dfpguitar kind of depends. Some farms sell to commercial buyers under a contract. Most of the smaller farms sell to a local co-op that stores the grain until market value goes up and then they put it on railcars for its 'final' destination. Some years, the government will see the market value too low and pay farmers to not grow wheat at all. This all stays true for all commodity markets. It gets deeper, but that is the tip of the iceberg. Oh, the sunflowers fo degrade a bit faster than you would think when plowed under. As for nitrogen, we use anhydrous ammonia. It kills everything and sets in a lot of nitrogen (that is usually the case for wheat only farms). Old fashioned farmers will rotate legumes one year and wheat or cotton the next.

    • @rchuno
      @rchuno 6 лет назад +1

      dfpguitar Generally no subsidies for grain producers, although it can happen. Usually to trigger that a natural disaster needs to have happened or something like a significant foreign subsidy has unexpectedly come into play. (Russia or China). This is generally for only one year as the farmers are expected to be smart enough to change crops if they aren't going to make any money farming what they were farming, or like my parents who couldn't afford to keep farming because of low wheat and barley prices, had to sell their farm and find new work.

  • @htomerif
    @htomerif 6 лет назад +33

    Hmm. You might want to try just a straight distillation. The sticky components are probably less volatile than the stuff that you got. I've found that if you wrap something like that (2 liter?) flask loosely in aluminum foil and let it hang over the sides of the hot plate, you get pretty even heating.
    It might also be interesting to see what you get if you put the plant in your ball mill. Definitely a lot more surface area then.

    • @mathias147
      @mathias147 6 лет назад

      htomerif wheres your avatar from

    • @Guru_1092
      @Guru_1092 6 лет назад +2

      Yeah, but he'd probably fuck up his ball mill. Just use a blender.

    • @minsin56
      @minsin56 5 лет назад

      yeah that have a large weed yield for snoopdog

  • @HazySkies
    @HazySkies 6 лет назад +3

    I never fail to be fascinated by the content you make. Chemical reactions, extractions, mining, farming bees and plants. Keep doing what you do ^-^

  • @PsychedelicMindFluid
    @PsychedelicMindFluid 5 лет назад +11

    I feel like you'd love permaculture -- and you definitely have the land for it! I would certainly watch a Cody-style gardening series!

    • @cabbageman
      @cabbageman 5 лет назад

      Is this a joke? He's had a gardening series for years

  • @barmetler
    @barmetler 6 лет назад +57

    We are sorry to inform you that this video has been demonetized.
    Cause: Title contains the word "weed"
    Your RUclips team

    • @trixiebewitched
      @trixiebewitched 6 лет назад +1

      @Quack Quark they still demonitized him

    • @ToxicPhenix
      @ToxicPhenix 6 лет назад

      Amber Bacome no way they did? Looool

  • @leethalvinylarrival4712
    @leethalvinylarrival4712 5 лет назад +12

    Getting all that weed back out of the flask must've sucked

    • @thalivenom4972
      @thalivenom4972 4 года назад +1

      metho, and a match. carbon can be washed out with acetone.

  • @jonmantooth5804
    @jonmantooth5804 5 лет назад +6

    this makes me feel like I can do science experiments with my bong.

  • @tankstavin
    @tankstavin 6 лет назад +57

    It's not gumweed that they used, it was Rapeseed, or canola oil. I actually worked on this project with ARA. We used catalytichydrothermolosis, basically putting a water/canola oil mix into a supercritical state (very high heat, very high pressure). The product came out crude, and we shipped it for refining, so I don't know what that process entailed, but it was quite interesting, and very flammable. From what I understand the yield made it more expensive than standard Jet-A, but it was renewable, so they wanted us looking into it anyway.

    • @mr.techaky7655
      @mr.techaky7655 6 лет назад +13

      +Jake Mitch You can thank Bill Cosby for both of those....

    • @drippingwax
      @drippingwax 6 лет назад +5

      How did your family get the last name Dickinson?

    • @Dollapfin
      @Dollapfin 6 лет назад +4

      Jake Mitch commonly known as canola which is just an acronym for rapeseed people can eat without getting cancer. I believe it’s erucic acid or something. Idk. It’s a brassica and one of the highest yielding oil crops we have. Also great for bees and used as a cover crop.

    • @AM-dc7pv
      @AM-dc7pv 6 лет назад +7

      Rapeseed? I thought those ended up in orphanages to be adopted? ;___;

    • @Dollapfin
      @Dollapfin 6 лет назад +3

      A M that ain’t even funny dude

  • @shiroyasha4995
    @shiroyasha4995 5 лет назад +124

    im waiting for the US army to invade cody's home since he made oil

  • @psun256
    @psun256 5 лет назад +15

    Later on Primitive technology:
    Molokov cocktail in the wild

  • @disasterexperiments493
    @disasterexperiments493 6 лет назад +25

    Idk why this guy keeps getting demonized since his videos are educational. What's youtube's vendetta against this poor guy. He's Inspired many young scientists like myself and probably done more good than harm on this platform...

    • @seigeengine
      @seigeengine 6 лет назад +6

      Demonetized.

    • @lutyanoalves444
      @lutyanoalves444 6 лет назад

      ahahahha

    • @chadoftoons
      @chadoftoons 6 лет назад +3

      RUclips probably doesn't want him demonetized but their AI does wich is another question
      Why does the youtube AI hate him so much? Its not like he is showing off guns

    • @Schmidtelpunkt
      @Schmidtelpunkt 6 лет назад +1

      The algorithm just uses indicators and every human interaction is probably to just accept those according to RUclipss rules, which are tighter than necessary to avoid things slipping through. Those humans have low paying jobs, essentially assisting a machine.
      That is what one gets when obeying machines. Soon the whole world will be ruled like that.

    • @philippsommer189
      @philippsommer189 6 лет назад

      But why they can't have an actual person look into the case before something like a demonetization is issued, is beyond me. Even more so when it comes to copyright claims/strikes. People's lifes can depend on these decisions, and having only the confirm-button be used manually seems more than irresponsible. Obviously they don't have an infinite amount of employees, but at least for channels with a certain subscriber count (maybe 100k+ or so) they should ensure these decisions are made by a human.

  • @grantp4022
    @grantp4022 3 года назад +1

    Looks like a nice slow burning jet fuel, be very nice for fuel for lighting lamps,
    and maybe camp stoves. Very creative video here Cody. Amazing what you
    can do from cheap things in your own environment. Imagination goes a long
    way.

  • @ventu2295
    @ventu2295 6 лет назад +80

    Cody! Can i add spanish subtitles to your vids?so that more people can learn from your content. Cheers from Argentina!

    • @masonp1314
      @masonp1314 6 лет назад +9

      If you speak both languages well, you could probably offer to help translate it for him

    • @ventu2295
      @ventu2295 6 лет назад +12

      @@masonp1314 Well, thats the idea. I will do all the work, and was thinking on starting on his most viewed videos like rock to ring and see what happens.

    • @ericsaul9306
      @ericsaul9306 6 лет назад +4

      Jaja gracias dude, sería chido poder enseñar estos videos a mis amigos y familia, soy el único que habla bien el inglés aparte de mi novia... Somos de la ciudad de México jaja en cualquier caso no tengo mucho tiempo pero si Cody quiere y tu también quieres podría ayudar un a traducir un poco también

    • @zer0b0t
      @zer0b0t 6 лет назад +1

      Si lo haces ojalá lo puedas hacer en idioma neutro para que la gente de distintos países pueda entender bien y no se confundan con regionalismos.

    • @ventu2295
      @ventu2295 6 лет назад +7

      Of course i will do it so that everyone can understand it, but Cody seems to miss my comments whenever i suggest something like this.

  • @recoilgaming4123
    @recoilgaming4123 6 лет назад +61

    Wonder if you would get more from a press then distilled?

    • @Sup3rman1c
      @Sup3rman1c 6 лет назад +22

      Thats the point, you press it so there is no space for the oil to be absorbed in.

    • @KainYusanagi
      @KainYusanagi 6 лет назад +8

      Y'know how they used to get olive oil, yeah? Yeah.

    • @tiusso
      @tiusso 6 лет назад +18

      Kain Yusanagi Used to? The extra virgin olive oil gets it's name because it's the one obtained with the first cold press of the olives, then comes the virgin oil which gets heat pressed from the remains of the first press and then the rest of olive oils which are unlabeled as extra virgin or virgin are extracted from what's left with solvents. This is the process from 2000 years ago and still aplies today.

    • @THX..1138
      @THX..1138 6 лет назад +6

      I think the extraction was wildly inefficient. His gloves got all sticky from cutting up the weeds. That shows there was a lot of oil in the plant in the plant material.

    • @rustygear9370
      @rustygear9370 6 лет назад +8

      It could be possible, eventhough I tried this receipe with other plants with more oil content :
      - First dry the plants under sunlight for few days (not too long or they will lose most of the oil, just the right amount of time to let them crush under stress)
      - Crush them into fine powder (the point of drying)
      - Put them back in distilled water, in the same proportions you make with pancake dough.
      - Let them inflate covered overnight, the mix will be more firm
      - Place them in press between alternate layers of fine mesh stainless steel sieves
      Water should draw out with oil, heating the layers around 70°C will make oil more fluid and ease the process.

  • @williamsmith455
    @williamsmith455 5 лет назад +2

    You could try boiling it in a pressure cooker, take the steam off that and separate the essential oil using this process, but then you should also have some heavier oil on the surface of your water in the pressure cooker. Right now you are getting only the lightest oil that evaporates easily. (I think)

  • @michaelalexander643
    @michaelalexander643 6 лет назад +76

    ***The US Army wants to know your location***

    • @lutyanoalves444
      @lutyanoalves444 6 лет назад +9

      thank god.
      that means they dont know yet

    • @damarh
      @damarh 6 лет назад +1

      lol i wanted to make an oil/invasion comment but thought, nah thats lame. then i saw yours :P

    • @denniswoycheshen
      @denniswoycheshen 6 лет назад

      Can't let the hippies win. Oil fo Lyfe ..

  • @BobMcCoy
    @BobMcCoy 6 лет назад +34

    *Extracting Gold from Pee?!*

    • @duke0200
      @duke0200 6 лет назад +3

      I mean he did do it with gunpowder a while back so it's probably possible.

    • @drunkenhobo8020
      @drunkenhobo8020 6 лет назад +3

      Maybe he'll discover a new element whilst he's at it.

    • @infinitepower6780
      @infinitepower6780 6 лет назад +11

      Peenium

    • @sithsiri
      @sithsiri 6 лет назад +7

      *Extracting pee from gold!?!?!?*

    • @randoprior4130
      @randoprior4130 6 лет назад +2

      Better hit the liquor store for some gold shclagger first

  • @Florreking
    @Florreking 5 лет назад +68

    Extracting jet fuel from steel beams

    • @innerg_92
      @innerg_92 5 лет назад +14

      only the ones found in NY.

    • @BezdomniakPL
      @BezdomniakPL 5 лет назад +2

      from weed beams

    • @justADeni
      @justADeni 5 лет назад +8

      @@innerg_92 especially in twins

  • @PKMartin
    @PKMartin 6 лет назад +18

    If you're looking for interesting solvent extraction to try, I've wondered about a Soxhlet style device using butane, so instead of heating it at the bottom you refrigerate the top to condense it, and it boils itself out of the distillate at ambient temperature. You've certainly got enough experience with pressure vessels and cryogens to give it a go.

    • @TG9910
      @TG9910 6 лет назад

      That's what I thought!

    • @EmazingGuitar
      @EmazingGuitar 6 лет назад +2

      Butane exracts more than the oils and brings pigments from the plant making the oil contaminated with pigments and plant matter

    • @housegoth
      @housegoth 6 лет назад

      Carlos Martinez butane gets the waxes and fats as well as the oils but gets very little pigment or plant matter which is what makes it better then an alcohol solvent extraction process.

  • @steve-o6413
    @steve-o6413 6 лет назад +21

    Yes the Military has people with intelligent design patents on about everything lol, an if they don't now they will in the future. But this is a great video I learned a great deal of information. One that I didn't expect is why it's so hard to put out forest fires. Plants are using jet fuel to keep them burning lol now if we can come up with a way to stop this well "if" is a big to use but you get the message.

    • @corpsie666
      @corpsie666 5 лет назад +1

      Harvest the plants, extract the oil and return the leftover biomass to become fertilizer

  • @RobertCraft-re5sf
    @RobertCraft-re5sf 3 месяца назад

    Definitely would be a great fuel for lanterns and things. That sooty flame is what you want. Awesome project. The gumweed seems very abundant and you can just gather it up and use as fuel. I love useful things like these. I truly believe the power grid will get out eventually and we will all be left to our own devices. Having cheap lamp oil or other fuel is amazing.

  • @Jaybiiird
    @Jaybiiird 6 лет назад +75

    poor cody gettin salty about the military already thinkin of his idea

  • @Eric-ox9jl
    @Eric-ox9jl 5 лет назад +3

    I did something similar extracting lemon oil, I think it helps a lot to grind it further down

  • @loricathey5416
    @loricathey5416 6 лет назад

    I like the fact that you are finding new renewable fuels

  • @VigoHornblower
    @VigoHornblower 6 лет назад +13

    I propose a challenge for you: Can you extract oxygen from Lunar Regolith Simulant? It's very rich in oxygen, so I'd imagine it would be possible.

  • @yourneighbour5738
    @yourneighbour5738 6 лет назад +97

    Waiting for that steel beam comment

  • @trulyinfamous
    @trulyinfamous 5 лет назад

    2:32 That fan sound makes me happy. It reminds me of summer, getting plants from Lowe's or something.

  • @lutyanoalves444
    @lutyanoalves444 6 лет назад +25

    GUN? and WEED on the same video???????
    no ads 4 u

  • @evannalynch9599
    @evannalynch9599 6 лет назад +69

    -Smells like Kerosene
    -Lets taste it
    lmao

    • @jakeeck
      @jakeeck 5 лет назад

      you copied the top comment.

  • @dab_yeetus
    @dab_yeetus 4 года назад

    What handsome knowledge and skills. And a winning attitude about it all. Experiments are worth the experience, I'm glad your glassware got experience, too.

  • @llo100
    @llo100 6 лет назад +7

    The weed looks quite dry.. in my experience fresh herbs have the highest yield

    • @originaljiggy
      @originaljiggy 6 лет назад

      These grow in my field. There's not much difference between fresh and dry. They have a very firm stem, almost woody. They have to support a wide top on a quite thin stem and they can get surprisingly large if they can get ahold of some water. They are wet in the pithy center where the moisture is protected from the heat and wind by the relatively thick woody layer.

  • @PeterLunk
    @PeterLunk 6 лет назад +10

    You should try and use alcohol instead of water to extract the oils next run ;)
    Then evaporate the alcohol later at low temps and the oils are left.
    Your yield will increase enormously ;)
    And alcohol will extrct the terpenes and flavinoids much better wich will give you a more potent smelling endresult.

    • @Guru_1092
      @Guru_1092 6 лет назад

      Terpenes and Flavinoids sounds like derogatory terms.
      "YOU DAMN TERPENES!"

    • @minsin56
      @minsin56 5 лет назад

      So better weed for snoopdog

  • @kataseiko
    @kataseiko 5 лет назад +1

    I know it's not high on your priority, but I would love a video of a special kind: Extract oil from some weeds (that you know aren't poisonous, e.g. nettles) and fry a piece of meat in it. I wonder if there's an oil that makes your steak taste better than butter.

  • @AmazingJeeves
    @AmazingJeeves 6 лет назад +10

    I can see people "off the grid" using gumweed oil for lanterns, if it could be stabilized enough for use. Any idea how long this would last, or would it be too volatile to store, like how gasoline breaks down over time?

  • @BambooBailey
    @BambooBailey 5 лет назад +27

    Cody: let’s see if we can extract oil from gum weed
    FBI: * muffle banging on door* FBI OPEN UP!!

  • @classycajun7806
    @classycajun7806 5 лет назад

    Dude Cody is so smart!!! It’s actually ridiculous. True talent.

  • @ericknyevz3840
    @ericknyevz3840 6 лет назад +4

    Cody you most likely over heated the terpenes and/or flavonoids in the flower. Try using a gravity-fed hexane extraction next time. Like propane or butane. Critical CO2 well work as well. Just that's not as easy to do at home.

  • @mayhem_unlimited3013
    @mayhem_unlimited3013 6 лет назад +4

    0:14
    *Military jumps on Cody yelling "give me the oil!"*

  • @randomprimary
    @randomprimary 3 года назад

    Thank you for captioning these vids. Or at least whoever did should get thanks.

  • @lukes2219
    @lukes2219 6 лет назад +11

    You could probably extract it more efficiently if you sherded it

    • @Killerspieler
      @Killerspieler 6 лет назад

      At least someone said it. I was looking for a comment on that, first thing i thought, when he started the distillation... You have to crush the cells, Cody, they contain most of the oil!

  • @AvidSurvivalist
    @AvidSurvivalist 6 лет назад +40

    *In the voice of Peter Griffin: WHY ARE WE NOT FUNDING THIS?!

    • @michaelfixedsys7463
      @michaelfixedsys7463 5 лет назад +4

      It was more cost effective to use kerosene

    • @placeholdername0000
      @placeholdername0000 5 лет назад

      If you want biofuels just gasify some biomass and use a Fischer Tropsch reaction. Significantly higher yield and flexibility in feedstock.

    • @TheAttacker732
      @TheAttacker732 5 лет назад +1

      @Aimless Studios However, considering that it's in the desert, it's a relatively low-infrastructure way to get a diesel/kerosene analogue.
      Soybeans (oil) & wood (wood alcohol) to biodiesel is probably more efficient (and can produce charcoal as a secondary output), but is less practical in deserts & desert-like conditions.

    • @TheAttacker732
      @TheAttacker732 5 лет назад

      @Aimless Studios Wood alcohol, methanol, is a byproduct of making charcoal. It isn't a direct byproduct, rather it comes from the carbon monoxide the wood lets out as it's heated in the charcoal producing process. I believe copper is the most common backcountry catalyst for methanol production.
      A few gallons of methanol is enough to catalyze most of a drum of vegetable oil into fuel suitable for diesel engines. Modern diesels can be surprisingly picky if you're forced to keep it in an emissions-test-passing configuration.
      However, I'm looking at this in the context of fueling vehicles. As well as the context of my area (wooded with lots of farmland), where soybeans have to be rotated through to replenish the fields. If we need to grow soybeans anyways, might as well make fuel from them. The remaining biomass feeds animals or goes back into the ground, although it could be turned into fuel as well.

  • @0zmosis2001
    @0zmosis2001 5 лет назад

    I really dig geeking out on your ideas and experiments really neat listening to and following your ideas and things you do on here just really cool something different and always keeps my attention for sure.

  • @Thee_Sinner
    @Thee_Sinner 6 лет назад +6

    Would pulverizing the flowers and stems aid in better extraction?
    (It would at least allow for more plant per volume)

  • @Somestupiedbudee
    @Somestupiedbudee 6 лет назад +8

    Cody'sDab

  • @music9170
    @music9170 4 года назад

    99.999999999% of the time your not the first, just because it hasn't been posted on the internet doesn't mean someone hasn't already thought of it or done it. I'm glad you don't constantly title your videos worlds first, etc.

  • @PotatoesAssistant
    @PotatoesAssistant 6 лет назад +8

    Try a large scale extraction of this

  • @redmist3570
    @redmist3570 6 лет назад +4

    would love to see you figure out a better way of refining gum weed and maybe running something on the oil, maybe a generator perhaps?? love your videos by the way, keep em coming

    • @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017
      @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017 6 лет назад +2

      There are so many promising natural sources of biofuel. It's an under researched area.

    • @redmist3570
      @redmist3570 6 лет назад +1

      We shouldn't really have to drill or mine for our fuels, if we put our minds to it that is. So many plants we can get oils from to make fuel.

    • @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017
      @stopthephilosophicalzombie9017 6 лет назад

      +Ben brazier Obviously it all boils down to economics. As long as fossil fuels are cheaper, oil companies will continue to exploit them.

    • @redmist3570
      @redmist3570 6 лет назад

      yep this is true, but fossil fuels will become more expensive when they become rarer. Plant based fuels are the future. The guy's that figure out which plants give the most oil's and the best way to extract those oil's will be laughing..

    • @erintreez
      @erintreez 6 лет назад +1

      Honestly, I'm not sure fossil fuels are actually "cheap" or cost effective. Don't we substantially subsidize that industry?? Don't the processes involved create waste, byproducts, pollutants, creating more problems/cost??

  • @Joe30pack
    @Joe30pack 6 лет назад

    It makes decent Biodiesel, lower yield as noted here, but decent fuel none the less. Cody's Lab rocks!

  • @randalmarshik4320
    @randalmarshik4320 6 лет назад +7

    We miss your videos Cody!

  • @shed1536
    @shed1536 6 лет назад +30

    America wants to: know your location

  • @onefeather2
    @onefeather2 5 лет назад

    Love these videos. Glad some people do this and experiment with all different things

  • @Articcc-x5g
    @Articcc-x5g 6 лет назад +22

    It’s not easy being green :(

  • @lazardjukovic1691
    @lazardjukovic1691 6 лет назад +43

    Always remember what jumbos neutron says : dont do drug , do science
    -but science make drug tho
    Shut

  • @buckstarchaser2376
    @buckstarchaser2376 5 лет назад

    Although the military probably made this comment first, it seems like this plant has a lot of properties that would be beneficial on a mars colony.
    -makes concentrated, liquid fuel
    -CO2 scrubbing
    -feeds pollinators
    -produces bulk cellulose for ruminants, construction, cellulose to ethanol bio-conversion, composting, and soil production
    -compact
    -low water requirement
    -low fertilizer requirement
    -can grow in a thermal-mass heat storage area

  • @gmc_
    @gmc_ 6 лет назад +8

    Nice use of interrobang in the thumbnail

  • @nonamevids5105
    @nonamevids5105 6 лет назад +13

    You can put the big oil company's out of buisness if Cody goes missing yoU know why lol

  • @diyar_ali_arif
    @diyar_ali_arif 4 года назад +1

    I hope it can be a sustainable fuel in the near future thank you for inspiring me to get into this.

  • @randoprior4130
    @randoprior4130 6 лет назад +8

    Just a question for the intelligent people who watch this channel.
    Would it be viable to use techniques similar to what is seen in the production of marijuana concentrates to extract oil from plants such as gum weed? For example using butane or isopropyl alcohol to strip some of the plant's oils and then purging it off to create a stronger oil form of that plant? I am unsure of whether these techniques would be used only on marijuana due to the active chemicals within it (thc-a) and only focusing on extracting those specific chemicals along with turpeines and cannibinol etc. Or would these processes also work for the creation of essential oils from other natural sources. Another technique would be to press the plant in a hydraulic press between to heated plates as in the creation of rosin, another extract of cannabis. I'm just curious as to if these processes would work for creating essential oils from a variety of plants, or if people use these processes to obtain concentrated forms of only the naturally occurring psychoactive chemicals in marijuana specifically.
    Cool video anyways Cody loved this one, just as much as all of your other videos! I'd love to see you try and take some Damascus steel and process it to seperate the two metals.
    (Edit: wrote this before reading through some of the comments. Seems as though others have already suggested this.)

    • @snixBE
      @snixBE 6 лет назад

      Jake Pryor wow dats alot of writing wish you luck finding some on to answer

    • @FurrBeard
      @FurrBeard 6 лет назад +3

      Probably the best technique would be to pulverize the plant material, then do a supercritical CO2 extraction - which is indeed the process used for high purity cannabis extracts. It's also used to extract delicate essential oils for fragrances and a whole host of other such uses. CO2 is cheap, non-flammable, and non-toxic - and thus at least theoretically ideal for use in industrial quantities, which is something that would be essential if one wanted to extract amounts of plant oil useful for fuel, especially if the oil is not strongly localized in a seed/bean [as with soy] that could be processed in other ways.
      sCO2 doesn't require really extreme conditions - warmer than 31.1C and at 72.9 atmospheres and up. That's a reason it's becoming ever more popular for this sort of thing. Cheap, relatively safe (definitely no fire danger from the solvent) and no residues left in the product.

    • @deansdrawings6844
      @deansdrawings6844 6 лет назад

      Tho thats what i thought

    • @anonymousidiot6163
      @anonymousidiot6163 6 лет назад

      lol I dunno

    • @randoprior4130
      @randoprior4130 6 лет назад

      @@FurrBeard I honestly had not even considered using super critical CO2. My initial thought was of course something like butane, but I can definitely see the safety benefits as well as the industrial usage. How would one purge off the CO2 that would remain in the finished product? As someone doing it at home I'm sure just letting it naturally vaporize would probably be the cheapest easiest way. But depending on its vaporizing rate it could take a while. I'm not sure exactly how long it would take but if it would be a problem I'm sure a simple double broiler would purify it fairly quickly. Or possibly a vacuum chamber. But that leaves me with another question. If one were to use a vacuum chamber would you have to determine the vaporizing pressure of the oil to know how far you can take the vacuum before worrying about losing any of the final product? I am very unfamiliar with vacuum chambers but they are fascinating to me and I would love to try some experimenting if I could ever afford one.

  • @kacper526
    @kacper526 6 лет назад +4

    Cody, is it possible to use this method for extraction other oils? For example mint.

  • @13andsim
    @13andsim 6 лет назад

    ** Cody So much easier to try out this method ... squish it between 2 heated aluminum plates in a shop press ... make hard compressed bar or puck from just the resin-y parts then place between 2 hot metal plates and press it out ... EXACTLY the process for making Cannabis Rosin ... Then refine that after zeroing in on prop temp ... may be more efficient but fun still.

  • @jwalster9412
    @jwalster9412 6 лет назад +6

    Imagin one day a car that runs off of weeds how would it sound??

    • @sonofnone116
      @sonofnone116 6 лет назад +5

      Like snoop dog

    • @minsin56
      @minsin56 5 лет назад

      @That Guy James do you mean weed car?

  • @mappy-5934
    @mappy-5934 6 лет назад +3

    In BHO (butane hash oil), you would use butane to strip off the trichomes of the plant material to get your extract then purge it off with heat and/or a vacuum pump. I wonder if the butane method would yield more oil from the plant you used or the distillation method you used. Cause I think solventless extractions run for more $$$

  • @bmunday
    @bmunday 2 года назад

    of all the skills needed on mars, @cody is a pro weedtrimmer and wildcrafter

  • @binaryneutron8126
    @binaryneutron8126 6 лет назад +25

    Volumetric flask is for general mixing and titration. You wouldn't apply heat to a volumetric flask. That's what a boiling flask is for. Did you learn nothing from my chemistry class?

    • @rustyshackleford5762
      @rustyshackleford5762 6 лет назад +2

      Yeah, using the wrong kind of flask surely reduced the yield, but it worked well enough for a proof of concept.

    • @fullnelsontv721
      @fullnelsontv721 6 лет назад +9

      Cody must of skipped watching Breaking Bad also .....
      .

    • @erichriedel466
      @erichriedel466 6 лет назад +11

      That's an Erlenmeyer flask, not a volumetric flask. And do you know who you're talking about? Of course he remembers chemistry class; he could teach one.

    • @KryptN-hc4gt
      @KryptN-hc4gt 6 лет назад +6

      @@erichriedel466 You don't get it? It's a reference for the 1st episode of Breaking Bad... When Walter steals the chemistry material for cooking and Jesse says he cook in a volumetric flask

    • @cathating893
      @cathating893 5 лет назад

      @@rustyshackleford5762 r/woosh

  • @a.mavridis2185
    @a.mavridis2185 6 лет назад +6

    Can i smoke it?

  • @TomMS
    @TomMS 6 лет назад

    "Let's taste it" seems to be the motto of this channel

  • @Winnieeeee
    @Winnieeeee 6 лет назад +4

    what happened to codys mine?

    • @minsin56
      @minsin56 5 лет назад

      It probably collapsed