The Debut: Dream Academy - Mission 1 Commentary (feat. Guest Advisor) | 더 데뷔: 드림 아카데미 - 미션 1 코멘테리
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 авг 2024
- Have a listen to Mission 1 commentary from our evaluators, Mitra Darab, Charlie Christie, and Sungdeuk Son,
featuring guest advisor, Melanie Fontana, to help make your top selections for the Dream Academy.
드림 아카데미의 상위권 참가자 선택을 위해 평가자들 미트라 다랍, 찰리 크리스티, 손성득, 그리고 게스트 어드바이저 멜라니 폰타나의 얘기를 미션 1 코멘테리를 통해 들어보세요.
Coming Up:
미션1 팬 투표 시작 @위버스 & 유튜브
9/10 3:59PM (KST) 까지 가능합니다.
Vote for Mission 1 right now.
Available @Weverse & RUclips until 9/9 11:59PM (PT)
#DREAMACADEMYHQ #HYBE #GEFFEN #드림아카데미
CONNECT WITH THE DREAM ACADEMY
WEBSITE: HTTPS://DREAMACADEMYHQ...
RUclips: / @dreamacademyhq
INSTAGRAM: / dreamacademyhq
X: / dreamacademyhq
TIKTOK: / dreamacademyhq
FACEBOOK: / dreamacademyhq
WEVERSE: HTTPS://WEVERSE.IO/DRE...
this is why i would like to have normal episodes, specially when the votings are open. they said Manon missed rehearsals but we dont know why? why would they give zero context... also it would held build a bigger fanbase and know the girls chemistry and teamwork better.
they will sep 15
That's because all that will be included in the documentary
@@nuellawayne2308 they'll say those things sep 15
This is also why you need to watch the entire video before commenting 😊
@@binsoy728 i know there will be a live stream and a documentary 😊 but i just wish we could see normal episodes to see the process while the votings are open. thats what i meant
Rooting for lara, samara,ua,nayoung,Sophia,celeste
NAYOUNG!!! Yesss
And Megan
And ezrela 💌
Same but also Megan and Emily
And ezrela. She had the best stage presence imo.
Manon was literally sick her friend confirmed it why would they say this and not say the reason knowing everyone would make assumptions like they did that on purpose I’m worried they wanted her to fall out of top6 so they could cut her. Please vote today is the last day !!!
Thankfully she debuted
the fact that Manon didn't show up to rehearsals probably explains why she didn't get many parts I think which is unfortunate because she has the ability to be a great artist.
From when the intro video was released that girl has been attracting stans from left and right like everyone is rooting for her but her not showing up to REHEARSALS I know we are not suppose to judge she might have school work she's dealing with but I feel she might have changed her mind
@@nuellawayne2308 this could have been a health issue
@@ilyastepanov8847i feel like if it was a health issue they would have said, cause they know telling us she missed rehearsals would’ve put her in a negative light.
@@nuellawayne2308 was this on an episode that we can see? Like how did they know she missed rehearsals? They don't have any behind the scenes content? i'd like to see it.
Yeah ikr, everyone was bashing Brooklyn for having most of the lines but now I am sure it has cleared most people's doubt, turns out there is a reason Manon had few lines. That's why I am telling you people don't just vote based on assumptions
sophia could slay it if she could have more lines honestly
But she slay on the harmonies too
Exactly!!!!
소피아는 아직 존재감이 덜해
@@yoonsehyeon DISAGREE!
@@anneubay4485 각 파트에서 오히려 다른 연습생들 파트가 더욱 눈에 띄었다
The fact that Melanie caught Lara and Nayoung’s synergy is CONFIRMATION those two slayed. Like, they really did stand out the best amongst the vocalists IMO.
100%
Gotta be conscious of what they want you to see vs what actually is. We dont have a static live performance to measure if that's the case. HYBE does this all the time...they'll edit, cut, line distribute to present to you the concept of Slay. So yeah, they've had a year, the handlers have probably predetermined who they want and are now presenting their favs to "Slay" which is reality, but sadly at the expense of the talent of others and their fanbases. HYBE is corporate greed at its best.
Rooting for Samara, Lara, Nayoung, Sophia, Celeste and Ua
Samee Ua is my favorite so far 🤭
ua is too young
Megan too :
Manon also
Marquise Ezrela Emily Celeste Sophia
I wish the judges had told us why manon didn’t attend rehearsals like was she sick or something. Cause now it makes her look like she’s not as determined to debut. I feel like she’s definitely better that this performance since they were dissapointed, however she was barely given any lines or time to shine so as a viewer we hardly got to see it ourselves. Rooting for you Manon ❤
That is personal stuff we don’t always need know what is happening to someone we are just fans period
@@Hiyyihcorei agree, but they could have said due to personal reasons. Instead she kinda comes off as irresponsible and uncommitted.
melanie has been exposed for being a racist on twitter, she wants to make manon look bad bc of her racial bias
@@Hiyyihcorethen why even bring it up??? They know what they are doing
Samara, Ezrela, Lara, Sophia, Megan, Nayoung are my picks so far.
Yes...
Rooting for Sophia, Nayoung, Samara, Lara, Marquise, Megan ! Fighting !
ezrela, samara, Lara, Sophia, nayoung, marquise need to debut rn or ill riot
Yesss
But pls know to not let the show be like ru next
I would've add Megan , Ua such a center material and has the ace energy
agree
SAMARA DESERVES EVERYTHING!!!
Samara Praise 👏🏽. I love this lady she really gave the right judgement on vocal group
so right about samara her vocals is moving
I don't think everyone in Team A's vocal was able to shine especially due to the line distribution and the song choice. I agree that Lara, Samara and Nayoung shined a lot, and the voice blended. I didn't know Manon couldn't attend some of the rehearsals, maybe she was sick? and the fact that they say that it definitely affected her performance means she's even better than how she performed. I wish we could see her more. Hybe should have just give each trainee an individual video as 1st mission
I am so rooting for manon I hope she is alright I don't want to see her drop from the show
they will on sep 15... its in the end of the video..........
It's very telling that they are questioning Manon's commitment to the project. Manon seemed down during the performance
yeah they were questioning if she's committed to the show and i fully understand that!@@maeglina9687
A mutual of Manon said she missed rehearsals bc she was sick. Imo she even looked and sounded sick in the performance.
Nayoung is so magical and touching , I always feel an explosion of feelings on me, her vocals is so delicate and unique, and her charisma is on another level…She is my favorite with no doubt. Every single time that she sings, I feel so alive.
Agreed, and I feel like her and Lara have to stay together ❤
My faves so far: Megan, Daniela, Sophia, Celeste, Lexi, Ezrela and Samara! But everyone is so talented and cool, will prob change.
Lara | Samara | Nayoung | Emily | Daniela | Megan were the best performers imo
Samara, Sophia, Lara, Nayoung and Celeste were amazing!
Samara is amazing
y'all your too much (that's my name 😆) but in all seriousness yes she is!! Cheering her and supporting her! She is so talented. But everytime they say Samara it really trips me up 😆😆 (it's kind of a rare name so that's why it's so surprising)
Melanie fontana has been exposed for racial remarks on twitter. Absolutely vile comments. A billion dollar company(HYBE) doesn’t care and here she is. Judging a competition that’s incredibly diverse. This is insane.
I think how it is also very clear in the commentary because of her mainly saying the white contestants did better and where “leading” the performances.
fr its disgusting
@@PatoAndOsa No? She praised Samara, Lara and Ezrela who aren't white. Ans she also gave criticism for Adela so stop saying It's racism when it's constructive criticism. Idk about her other racist allegations but this one sure wasn't racist. Even I felt a bit uneasy listening to Manon (not because of her voice but how she presented herself)
Celeste, Nayoung, and Ezrela stood out to me the most!
Yess NAYOUNG was so amazing
Celeste, Nayoung, Sophia, Lara and Samara were literally the best amongst them all...
Please vote for Samara, she is wonderfully talented and beautiful and will really captivate you with her charisma and talent
Sophia’s sweet angelic voice with the song about sparkling love hits different!
We can all agree that the members don't have fair/enough line distribution and screentime.
That's why some members standout and some didn't. It's all about 'exposure'. I hope in their next performance they'll be able to show their talents equally.
this is totally true! haayaah
@@dhaniemanalo4154 In this mission 1, it's so obvious that they already have members they want to debut. They're just making the fans to vote for their picks. However, it'll be tough bcs the members are representing their own country, which means it's kinda like pageantry. People will support their country's representative.
i hoped HYBE would be better than this, and do this trick to push someone forward. But yes, its not only they who produce / finance all, so they are influenced by investors
it’s crazy, i literally thought manon stood out the most and was the best despite her few lines. and here are these panelists saying that she needs to push harder…
Let's go Lara, Sophia, Ezrela, Marquise, Samara!
From what I’ve seen now I really like Mei, Megan, Emily, Samara, Nayoung and Lara. They really slayed and I’ll definitely vote for them the following days
That’s exactly who I voted for too! Hah. That’s awesome!
Samara has the best vocal tone…that’s why she is my pick for vocalist while that one girl from Hawaii is my pick for dancer.
i feel like people don't talk enough about lara's voice. she gave main vocal vibes for me. she's definitely in my picks with celeste, samara, nayoung, manon and megan
I agree! I think the other girls have a larger or devoted fandom / bias. If Lara doesn’t make it, this whole thing is a joke 😭
All I was rooting for Sophia, Lara, Samara, Nayoung, Marquise and Megan as of the moment.
Lara, Nayoung, Samara, Manon, Megan, Ua, Emily, and Mei stood out the most to me from mission 1
Agreed
Hybe for the next round should keep a songwriter/vocalist guest advisor, but also include guest advisors that are also choreographers/dancers. I really want to hear an expert opinion on who executed the choreography the best for the next round. And the more guest judges mean we can hear differing opinions on who did well.
Yeah I don't want to see any favoritism ESPECIALLY after what went down in runext
I wish Sung Deok could have given his opinion about the dance performances, being BTS and TXT choreographer I wanted to hear his opinion too.
@@ajamzmom4882this isn’t the full commentary they will show more sept 15
they will on sep 15... its in the end of the video.......... yall need to see the video before leaving comments
@@maymayyyythey should added at least some expert comment on the dancing ( besides "they look like they were having fun"…… "this person slayed") why wait till after voting ends to comment on 2 performances completely focused on choreography Sung Deok is right there…..
we really got kkk member melanie fontana as a judge 🗿🗿
Honestly Samara stood out the most for me during the first teaser and though she had little time on camera this time she still made a huge impact. She has to be selected.
NAYOUNG WAS SO UNBELIEVABLE, she was the best for me
Her range is mind blowing!!
@@alyssagartist YESSSS
Es obvio que samara va a ser una elegida, ademas de encantarle al jurado, lo hizo también con el público ❤
Su voz es muy dulce y sabe hacer las notas altas muy bien y con pasión. Algo que no me gusta es que sus fans odian a celes 😢 necesitamos unión latina
@@luchigimenez04não odiamos não, até algum estão se juntando para votar nas latinas.Celeste é talentosa ❤
Oh espero que no sea verdad eso, porque yo apoyo muchísimo a Samara al igual que a celeste
@@luchigimenez04 porq vc acha isso? Nós queremos as duas no grupo latino-america sempre 🤝🏻
Celeste não está no meu top 6 por motivos q outras me cativaram mais, mas não nego a voz unica que ela tem, é um timbre tão doce e lindo. Se ela debutar, ficarei feliz tbm.@@luchigimenez04
Rooting for Ezrela, Marquise , Samara, Lara, Daniela and Karlee . honorable mention: Megan and Celeste. Also i think Celeste needs another song i lm curious about discovering her voice more
Rooting for Karlee! She is Sooo underrated!!😭😭😭
@ginatanaka5657 ikr she has such a beautiful tone of voice. one of the top singers for sure!!!
Mannon missed rehearsals due to being sick, super unprofessional to mention it and frame it like she was skipping out.
Yeah, we want more Adéla she's super amazing! Her expressions in fancams are more visible and it's just impossible not to love her
Adela stood out a lot to me, rooting for her and samara
Rooting for Manon,Lara,Nayoung,Ua,Sophia,
Samara,Marquise,Megan,Ezrela,Lexie to
debut 💪💪
it’s only 6
Adela needs to debut she‘s like the prettiest for me
Emily to she is also a very good dancer who should not be missed.
@@ag923i think she just got eliminated
Samara is center material;
Daniela/Emily is main dancer candidate;
Sophia is main vocalist candidate;
Ezrela is cute dandang;
Ua is Japanese/dancer candidate;
Megan/Marquise is visual.
Uma das poucas vezes que concordei demais com os avaliadores, Ezrela e Samara brilharam demais
Eu tbm
Q pena q só são 6 pq eu gostei de 8😪
eu tbm, queria que todas debutassem 😢
I Hope team B vocal and omg can win!
In the pink venom performance Adéla and Megan were the once who stood out the most. I wish we could hear the opinions of the other evaluators before the voting ends.
Lara is amazing and the chemistry between Lara & Nayoung is really good. Perfect for debute♥️
Adela is underrated, please guys vote for her! All rounded talent!
Yeah, its so sad 😢
Yess shes in dangerous position now😢😢
Aguante celeste🇦🇷 y Samara 🇧🇷
Voten por ellas 🙏😍
Samara have such a big hability with her voice, o love how she can sing ❤️
I LOVE THE COACHES' OPINIONS ON THIS. No sugarcoating and just fully based on the performances and charisma on the videos. Good job HYBE PLUS on this one, so far. Keep up this kind of constructive criticism so that whoever debuts will debut worthily.
💀 ain’t one of the judges a full blown racist twitter user😭 lmfaoo
I'm rooting for Samara, Nayoung, Mei, Sophia, Manon and Brooklyn!!!
sophia, samara, UA, ezrela, nayoung, marquise, manon are the most talented and charismatic for me. i also chose them based on their facial expressions ⭐💗
Rooting for Lara, Samara, Ezrela, Emily and Megan!
GO SAMARA 🇧🇷
Keep doing your best in your limit Samara, and OMG I'm so excited all the girls are so talented, like Melanie said they're out of this world.
Rooting for Celeste, Megan, Daniela, Samara, Sophia & Nayoung
oh yeah, ntm on manon. the judges knew what they were doing with mentioning her missing rehearsals. since she's one of the main contestants that went viral. like i knew y'all were waiting for a moment to drag her. we do not know why she missed rehearsals so stop making assumptions.
I don’t think it really matters why she’s missing rehearsals. Evidently it’s been too many
i mean of course it’s gonna make a bad impressions on the judges to see her missing rehearsals consistently 💀 stop with the victim complex fr
literally we don't know even know why she missed rehearsals because the judges didn't say why. they know what connotations come with what they said. these are people who work in the industry, they're not stupid.
and what i said still reigns true? we don't know why she missed them. i think she's well aware of the famous companies she's working work....do you really think she's intentionally missing rehearsals or trying to slack off over this one-man opportunity??
@@daysssssss some people are immature and afraid of success
Rooting for Celeste, Samara, Sophia, Nayoung, Marquise and Manon!!
Let's debut Samara, Lara, Nayoung and Sophia!
Omg they are all so talented. But for now my choice is for : Megan, Marquise, iliya , Celeste, Samara and Ezrela
Team B vocals won hands down !
Honestly melanie said it perfectly about the remix vocal team. A buncha solo artists singing on one song
I'm just saddened that Sophia got only a few lines but she still nailed her parts. Hoping for more lines/screen time on her next. Given that Filo fans are watching, I hope she isn't being used only for clout for viewership bc that would be totally heartbreaking for. She has the talent, skills, and personality. Please showcase her more next time. Thank you.
even if Sophias not included in this project, many fans all over the world will still be watching this. why do filipinos think the world revolves around them? 😂
sophia had few lines (she did great) but those lines are important, it doesnt matter if u got a bunch of lines and you still cant deliver so stop whining
@@renzoperez8077 because Filipinos are active in social media. There have been many incidents where Filipino contestants were included just for viewership (ex. international beauty pageants such as Miss U) There are even content creators who purposely mention the country just to get engagements. Mind you, with many overseas Filipino workers (medical professionals such as nurses in the US, Can, UK, Aus, etc), it is the Filipinos revolving around the world. Not to mention the thousands of Filipino seafarers crossing across the oceans as well. Go to the Middle East countries, you will definitely bump with Filipinos.
So, it's neither whining nor thinking that the world revolves around Filipinos. In fact, it is the other way.
My point here is that it is proven how social media marketers often target Filipino audiences since engagements are guaranteed. This is the situation that should not be the case here; hence this sentiment.
Sophia thankfully ranked within the top 6 in Mission 1. It's still far from the end but so far, things are doing well.
União Latina Samara y Celeste, juntas para su debut s2
También Daniela es latina , aunque nació en USA. Apoyémosla también
Vai Samara vc brilha garota ❤🇧🇷
They mentioned Manon has been missing rehearsals but I don’t like that they didn’t give context as to why. And I don’t like that Manon can’t explain it herself.
That’s non of your business
@@HiyyihcoreLol you’re missing the point big time. It’s not about me being nosy. If they are going to give a snarky remark about how they need to see commitment from everyone in regard to Manon missing rehearsal, then Manon should be able to explain why she missed the rehearsals. We’re left to assume that she’s not committed based on the comment they gave.
They did manon dirty with the clickbate false narrative
We have to see the singers dancing and the dangers singing to make a further decision. That would solidify it for ME. So far I have 3 fav based on talent only for what I can see and their experience since childhood. IF one is not getting along. I would definitely and sadly not vote for that person. I hope people understand that and not get angry and start bashing the group just because their choices didn't win.
my faves are definetly lexi, lara, ezrela, celeste, yoonchae, samara
Celeste have the most distinct and unique voice out of all of them, I hope she wins
Aguante cele y Samara voten por ellas 💙🤍💙🇦🇷 💚💛💚🇧🇷
Rooting for Emily, Yoonchae, Ezrela, Lexie and Iliya to debut😩🙏🏻
I’m with you 🤗💜
EZRELA, SAMARA, MEGAN, SOPHIA, NAYOUNG, + MANON are my faves!! + Marquise!
ILIYA is such a great singer and she blended so well with Lexie and Karlee, her voice makes me feel the song and emotions she expresses. I DEFINITELY ROOT FOR ILIYA 💜💜💜
More lines for Sophia please ! Want to hear more of her angelic voice !
CELESTE AND SAMARA FIGHTING!!!! VAMOS QUE SE PUEDE LATAM 🛐✨💕💕💕
The girls that stood out the most in each performance to me are: Iliya, Lara, Adéla, Ezrela
Samara, Lara, Sophia e Nayoung
My top 6 rn are Samara, Sophia, Megan, Lara, Nayoung, Marquise ^^
Lara and Samara amazing ❤️
I love that Mr. Son is working with the Dream academy girls but I'm kinda sad we didn't hear his opinion as a choreographer, his work is the foundation of big hit/hybe dance style so I want to see his feedback
they mentioned manon missing rehearsals and talked about commitment, but there was no explanation why she missed rehearsals..
Unfair
I personally believe there should be 2 guest advisors. One to evaluate the vocals like the current one and another for dance. That would be much fairer
yeah, why a songwriter have an opinion on dance? it's ok on vocal cuz that's her field
Yeah. Why they didn't have a dance expert? Do they intend us to vote based on the opinion of someone who are not an expert?
They already do.
Sungdeuk Son (the Korean guy in the video) is a multiple-award-winning choreographer who has been BTS's main choreographer and performance director since the very beginning of Big Hit Entertainment.
You know the Korean guy right there is bts choreographer right?
@@LuccasCam no I mean the one who are commenting. He was quite for almost the whole video.
If he had commented on the dance missions then it would have been better
But ig he couldn't say anything cos he is an official judge so they could have brought a dance expert guest like the songwriter
Samara is incredible, a super talented girl! I'm rooting for her
Rooting for Samara, Lara, Nayoung, Manon, Ua and Emily!!
Us is too young.
@@suem4337/20 contestants are 17 she’s turning 16. They the same ages
@@mystiqur114816 is still pretty young… I would prefer if the older contestants won but I’m not the one choosing so who cares
@@mystiqur1148i thought she's 14?
@@lanaliciousshe was born March 2008 so she is 15. Depending on when they debut next year she might even be 16 by then. The other Japan girl is 14 I think so you might be mixing them up?
I wish All the trainees could debut! They are all so talented and gifted! 💕
Not logical
Manon’s friend said she missed rehearsals because she was sick. Not sure how true the claim is but the way these evaluators put it they made it seemed she skipped for shits and giggles. Just plain nasty.
Yeah I agree, I just started to get to know the group and them started watching this whole series so I'm new, but I wouldn't think Manon would miss practice on purpose, the people made it seem like she didn't care
Todas son buenas vocales y bailarinas 👌 Sigamos apoyando a Cele🇦🇷 No bajen la guardia Argentina!!! NO SE OLVIDEN DE VOTAR EN WEVERSE Y COMENTANDO EL POST DE CELESTE Y EN RUclips EN SU FANCAM 😊🇦🇷💙
VAMOOOO CELE🇦🇷 VAMOOO MANON🇨🇭 VAMOOO NAYOUNG 🇰🇷
EL PUEBLO ARGENTINO TIENE QUE ESTAR UNIDO SOMOS DE HIERRO PARA SEGUIR LUCHANDO Y QUE ELLA SIGA LUCHANDO 🇦🇷💙
Lara and ezrela are so cool❤
Debut please❤
Mei,Yoonchae,Nayoung,Sophia,Lara,Lexie are my picks💕
The main obstacle for vocal B was the line distribution. Let’s go Sophia. I hope you get into the final mission 🫶🏻
Yes, it was the same impression I had regarding the two vocal teams, group "a" more like solo singers singing together, on the other hand group "b" seemed to be more in harmony, as a group. I really hope that Samara debuts, her voice is like an angel, her talent is undeniable.
i feel like ultimately hybe gonna end up pickin the debut participants as they did with I'll-It
Celeste y Samara el team latino debe quedar 💜💜💜💜
Exatamente, latinoAmérica tenq ficar juntas 🤝🏻
tambien daniella
@@cellular7881Daniela tem descendência latina?
@@ellensuzy6289 Si. Cuba Venezuela parents.
It is the first time that I feel that a judge's opinion really reflects the general feeling; Melannie was very accurate. The B teams were the best, the A vocal team really felt like some vocalists trying to do a collaboration. On the other hand, Vocal group B was really harmonious and combined very well, they had a lot of chemistry. Dance group B was completely entertaining and fun to watch, you could tell how they enjoyed it and they also had chemistry.
I want to see a thorough breakdown on each team. I want to know how well each vocal team sang. I want a professional dancer to also breakdown each dance team, what are the key points that made each participants stand out both vocal and dance. Although this is just a short one, I'm sure they'll be showing the second whole part of the first evaluation. I'm excited to see how the vocal team looks like dancing and how the dance team would sound like while singing and what would they look and sound like once they fuse the singing and dancing. Anyway, my top picks are Manon, Samara, Nayoung, Sophia, and Mei.
My pick
1.Nayoung
2.Samara
3.Sophia
It's confirmed Manon was sick, that's why she missed rehearsals, how is a vocalist supposed to "push harder" when sick? You can hurt your voice. Evil editing.