Respected Professor, Problem with all Muslims Thoughts were and still today 1) We stopped evaluation in that Thoughts. We take it in Absolute Form. Everything is variable with the passage of time. No one is 100% correct. When we evaluate 100% correctness is our benchmark. Everything is time bound. Tolerance is Zero. Adjustments/ Rectification is absolutely necessary to grow.
Taimur saab aap aur aap jaise kai pakistan ke podcaster jinhe mein aksar sunta aur dekhta hun sach aman ke farishte hain. Kam se kam is khite mein aap ki bahut jarurat hai. Sachai kya hai, lekin bachpan se hi kamobesh islam aur musalmano ke bare mein alag najariya hi sikhaya gaya. Religous discourse mein ya partition ki vajah se bhi. Lekin mein UP, TAMIL, KERLA YA BENGAL MEIN REHNE WALE HINDU SE PAKISTAN KI PUNJAB PROVINCE MEIN RAHNE WALE MUSLIM SE JYADA COMMON TRAITS SHARE KARTA HUN.
@@hamza_ME_ @hamza_ME_ but al zulfiqar killed only one person named Major tarik by hijacking PIA plane .. but al shams and al badar participated in gènocìde of bengali Muslims and r*pe of bengali women ... and they talk about sharm o haya , maghribi tehreeb ki khurafat, etc. shame
A very detailed information about the history of Pakistan and role of fundamentalism. I think one more important factor that led to creation of Bangladesh was / is racism . Racism still prevails in the society and people in power in Pakistan. Pl do make some video on racism in Pakistan as well as in the world.
1:25:55. اگر یہ secularism کی definition ہے تو یہی تو اسلام ہے... اسلام بھی تو یہی کہتا ہے کہ کہ ساری communities سے ایک جیسا سلوک ہی ہونا چاہیے... بس مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ ہم نے اسلام پرہنے کی بجائے history of Muslims کو صرف دیکھا...
Dr. Taimoor has diagnosed the problem correctly for the most part but I don't think his solution is pragmatic for it is too ambiguous but we can't complain, because such lectures are not enough for detailed explanations. But I think developing on Sir Muhammad Iqbal's idea will be much more practical and pragmatic and actually possible, unlike doctor's respected solution here. Iqbal proposed something similar to a quietist ideology. The politics works separate from the religion but there must be a separate administrative body consisting of learned Islamic scholars who will influence public opinion using the religious dialectic. This is a very good idea because if we have a population who is influenced by fundamentalist ideas funded by external governments, then why not create a body of our own to influence people instead of letting them be influenced by ideas supported by external powers for their benefits. As Iqbal himself was a socialist and left-leaning, I don't think there are any inherent contradictions between the secularist ideology and Iqbal's ideas.
Dr. Taimoor. It's request to you to please conduct discussions on the popular counter narratives that we have against western capitalism and imperialism. Koi aisa nizam qaim hosakta hai jo Islamic bhi ho aur aik practical and realistic bhi ho in that it can hold its own against the imperialist forces at least in principle. I think the secular socialist narrative falls short in the sense kay it lacks an islamic coloring. And the islamic riyasat wala narrative falls short kyunkay bilkul impractical hai and eventually musalmanon kay against use kya jaata hai. Is mouzoo pay koi discussion ho
Sir, Although Said kuthab etc were used against the socialism through Fundamentalism but Maududi sab was very old than communism. Maududi 's religious thoughts (thabir deen) was so old. Perhaps ,Madudi 's piker deen maybe wrong but he is free from the wistern game against socialism.
Jnab China is a communist country with a veneer of capitalism. Takreban sare unicorn companies main unka share hai aur unki board meetings main government present huti hai. China main abhi bhi buhat masail hai jesa One party system. In masail ko agar wo hal kar lain tu China will be an ideal country. It will have the best of both worlds.
@Abton there are no civil rights in China like in the US and Europe like political , social , cultural, and religious freedom. And you know nobody from Pakistan wants to live in China 🇨🇳 Not only in China, now India is also producing unicorns like Ambani, tata , adani, etc In usa 🇺🇸 there are thousands of unicorns ..we have heard these unicorns from 1970s 1980, even almost century before Like billgates , Jeff bezos now Elon musk etc
And you mentioned disagreements between political parties of Pakistan and Establishment, do you really think that its a religious disagreement? And you also mentioned Fall of Dhaka which wasn't happend due to religious disagreement. So please don't try to make people foul.
Bhai we respect him but that doesn't make him absolute. He is very biased with communism. And qaiser raja is also right on most of his points. Faisal waraich also disagreed on his views on communism. Why are you pointing out qaiser raja for just being from religious side
taimur sb , huge fan here . However I would like you to re-visit the pentagon attack theory . It isn't as cut and dry as it was initially thought to be and numerous scientists and journalist now have such questions that the government hasn't ever provided satisfactory answer to . It is quite possible that the government was involved. You yourself teach the ills and ails of capitalism and how it completely demolishes any concept of loyalty between the super class , and the subordinate class correct ? This shouldn't be difficult for you to understand then , that a government IS CAPABLE of harming its own citizens. The objectives can be many . For example the wasted trillion dollars spent on the war on terror , that obviously did go into someone's pocket and achieved nearly nothing. They set out to crush taliban but comically failed . Anyways I digress. My main argument here was whenever the term conspiracy theory is tossed around in any enviornment , immediately the argument that is boxed in that theory is dimissed isn't that so ? . If I narrate an anecdote to you and mid sentence someone comes and tells you dont bother with this tale , it is a conspiracy theory . You would immediately cease to analyze the tale and regard it as fable. It is worth investigating whatever happened that day on sept 11. Huge fan here . Been following you since 3 years . Completely on board with whatever you teach and preach . much love !
Sorry sir but disagree on some points like world trade center and October 7 attack. The matter is not that simple. As far as Pakistan terriosim concern it's also not that simple yes Pakistan army do not want to be attacked but it's long story and without context you can't understand it. Yes we are facing religious extremism agree
So what's the reason behind world trade centre ? Is this justifiable that innocent civilians should be targeted due to some American policies ..and attackers are not Japanese and veitnames but Saudis why ?
@envalis44 to eliminate and for Palestinian freedom kidnapping of unarmed civilians , women , old persons , children is necessary ? Do you think Hammas is going to establish a free Palestine 🇵🇸 state where all a of their religions, are equal .. do you think hammas is freedom fighter? Before , in August 2021, you people used to call taliban freedom fighters . Now tell me, is pakistan state apartheid for baloch people .
@envalis44 after 7th October 28000 gaza people have been died .. is this right path to take back freedom ... o come on this is religious war in which Muslims are going to kill all Jews either they are hiding behind stones and trees ( hadith says) I think you never ever heard about kurdistan ( state occupied by 4 countries turkey , Iraq, Iran and Syria) because this does not suit your religious narrative You would never talk about Indonesian invasion on east taimur ( a Christian country) as again it does not suit your religious narrative There are lots of examples which I can mention for you Another is darfur massacre since 2003 in sudan 🇸🇩 but you don't know about it .. I support Palestine 🇵🇸 a free state Israel 🇮🇱 does brutality through bombing no doubt And thousands of Palestinians have been killed since October 7 .. is this tactic of hammas true and justifiable ? 1300 Israelis civilians have been killed and lots of Israelis have been abducted ..thousands gaza people have died Shame on this
@envalis44 is Azerbaijan 🇦🇿 apartheid state for nokornokarabakh people ? Please answer me Why you people and your media don't speak even a single word on it 🤔
Studying social phenomena through the lens of scientific analysis doesn’t imply that official government explanations are the only valid reasons. The world is complex, and it’s important to have a more nuanced approach than the one you presented, where you dismissed all motives of war as being based solely on external factors, rather than a more complex combination of internal and external influences. My comment is more on your gross oversimplification explanation on America’s lust for wars which many Americans would even disagree with, including myself.
This lecture just exposed this guy. For a good 30 mins i had no idea where is he leading us to. Necessarily he tried to complicate the topic and mix in details that were not essential at this point. However it helped him complicate, and as he wanted to paint this whole concept with conspiracies and extremism and what not as if that would fool someone on the look for some actual truth. He didn’t do justice to the whole concept and he is by no way an authority on the matter. Pakistani left is yet another shade of ignorance in our whole society, and it carries all the features of a semi literate, unsophisticated, openly biased, uncritical of themselves, and a self deceiving spectrum of thinking.
Look at the condition of 1.4 billion Muslims of this world who follow the tenants of Islam night and day, does it look like they have found the "Ultimate solution" ? na kar bhai.
@@pappu33 bro ham musalman aur specially jin k pass authority hain woh Islam ko kitna follow karte hain main bhi janta hoon aur aap bhi, ham sab mafadparasti aur beimani main lage huwe hain, sab ko bas apni apni padi huwi hai ham log ethics aur morallity main bohat nichay gir chuke hain, imandar aur sache insan ko ham log bewaqoof samajhte hain jabhi to hamara yeh haal hai
This type of Funda mentalism is main obstruction of yours economic development.you adopted a system of ruling according to your Islamic system is like "Allah ka mullah,mullah ka mulki".where are common people in your system of ruling.plz adopt the system of socialistic secular model which is real one of Indian continent.
ڈاکٹر صاحب اپنے لاہور اسلام اباد کراچی کا نام تو لیا مگر پشاور چارسدہ شمالی و جنوبی وزیرستان کے تمام علاقے جو اس دہشتگردی کیوجہ کھنڈر بن گیے نام نہیں لیا۔ حالانکہ دیکھا جاے جتنی تباہی و بردبادی جانی و مالی شکل میں پشتون بیلٹ میں کہیں اور اتنی نہیں وہی۔ تو اپ سے درخواست ہے کہ اسطرح کے لیکچر میں سب سے پہلے ان علاقوں کو بھی یاد کیا کریں
We can split the world 🌍 history in two parts 1 before 9-11 and after 9-11 This was planned by US authorities Molvi itna bara kaam naheen kr sakta Wo loudspeaker pe America ko galiyan decskta hy bs
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
بہت عمدہ تجزیہ تاریخی واقعات کے ساتھ۔بہت شکریہ لال۔
بہت مناسب سچ پر مبنی تجزیہ۔ھم ہر چیز کو کنسفریسی کے بھینٹ چھڑاتے ہیں۔یہ سب ان شدد پسندوں اور انکے سہولت کاروں کے کا رنامے ہیں
Respected Professor, Problem with all Muslims Thoughts were and still today 1) We stopped evaluation in that Thoughts. We take it in Absolute Form. Everything is variable with the passage of time. No one is 100% correct. When we evaluate 100% correctness is our benchmark. Everything is time bound. Tolerance is Zero. Adjustments/ Rectification is absolutely necessary to grow.
2 plus 2 being 4 can be variable?
Taimur saab aap aur aap jaise kai pakistan ke podcaster jinhe mein aksar sunta aur dekhta hun sach aman ke farishte hain. Kam se kam is khite mein aap ki bahut jarurat hai. Sachai kya hai, lekin bachpan se hi kamobesh islam aur musalmano ke bare mein alag najariya hi sikhaya gaya. Religous discourse mein ya partition ki vajah se bhi. Lekin mein UP, TAMIL, KERLA YA BENGAL MEIN REHNE WALE HINDU SE PAKISTAN KI PUNJAB PROVINCE MEIN RAHNE WALE MUSLIM SE JYADA COMMON TRAITS SHARE KARTA HUN.
Beautiful Approach with rational thinking 💖
Loved your lecture as always ❤
We love MOULANA MOUDOODI❤️
آپ کا ہر تقریر اعتدال پسندانہ ۔
Very beautiful talk ❤I always wait for this precious one
Dr.sahib ! Al badar aur al shams to dehshatgard thi to Al zulfiqar kia thi?
PPP ka socialist militant wing
@hamza_ME_ yes , it was formed by bhutto sons to take revenge of their father
@@hamza_ME_ @hamza_ME_ but al zulfiqar killed only one person named Major tarik by hijacking PIA plane .. but al shams and al badar participated in gènocìde of bengali Muslims and r*pe of bengali women ... and they talk about sharm o haya , maghribi tehreeb ki khurafat, etc. shame
Best analysis
Harsh but true words. It's easy to believe on conspiracy theories than to search for truth.
A very detailed information about the history of Pakistan and role of fundamentalism. I think one more important factor that led to creation of Bangladesh was / is racism .
Racism still prevails in the society and people in power in Pakistan.
Pl do make some video on racism in Pakistan as well as in the world.
1:25:55.
اگر یہ secularism کی definition ہے تو یہی تو اسلام ہے...
اسلام بھی تو یہی کہتا ہے کہ کہ ساری communities سے ایک جیسا سلوک ہی ہونا چاہیے... بس مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ ہم نے اسلام پرہنے کی بجائے history of Muslims کو صرف دیکھا...
Dr. Taimoor has diagnosed the problem correctly for the most part but I don't think his solution is pragmatic for it is too ambiguous but we can't complain, because such lectures are not enough for detailed explanations.
But I think developing on Sir Muhammad Iqbal's idea will be much more practical and pragmatic and actually possible, unlike doctor's respected solution here. Iqbal proposed something similar to a quietist ideology. The politics works separate from the religion but there must be a separate administrative body consisting of learned Islamic scholars who will influence public opinion using the religious dialectic. This is a very good idea because if we have a population who is influenced by fundamentalist ideas funded by external governments, then why not create a body of our own to influence people instead of letting them be influenced by ideas supported by external powers for their benefits.
As Iqbal himself was a socialist and left-leaning, I don't think there are any inherent contradictions between the secularist ideology and Iqbal's ideas.
Hey taimur. You didn't mention land being the reason for this. Are you ok?
Dr. Taimoor. It's request to you to please conduct discussions on the popular counter narratives that we have against western capitalism and imperialism. Koi aisa nizam qaim hosakta hai jo Islamic bhi ho aur aik practical and realistic bhi ho in that it can hold its own against the imperialist forces at least in principle. I think the secular socialist narrative falls short in the sense kay it lacks an islamic coloring. And the islamic riyasat wala narrative falls short kyunkay bilkul impractical hai and eventually musalmanon kay against use kya jaata hai. Is mouzoo pay koi discussion ho
Sir, Although Said kuthab etc were used against the socialism through Fundamentalism but Maududi sab was very old than communism. Maududi 's religious thoughts (thabir deen) was so old. Perhaps ,Madudi 's piker deen maybe wrong but he is free from the wistern game against socialism.
Who did say that ottomon empire was an Islamic Khilafah?
He did said that Ottoman khilafat not khilafat e Rashda
kamaaal
Dr.sahib! Communist/socialist khofi kren ap 1978 k baad k china 🇨🇳 ko communist keh rhe hen ? China state capitalism he
Jnab China is a communist country with a veneer of capitalism. Takreban sare unicorn companies main unka share hai aur unki board meetings main government present huti hai. China main abhi bhi buhat masail hai jesa One party system. In masail ko agar wo hal kar lain tu China will be an ideal country. It will have the best of both worlds.
@Abton there are no civil rights in China like in the US and Europe like political , social , cultural, and religious freedom.
And you know nobody from Pakistan wants to live in China 🇨🇳
Not only in China, now India is also producing unicorns like Ambani, tata , adani, etc
In usa 🇺🇸 there are thousands of unicorns ..we have heard these unicorns from 1970s 1980, even almost century before
Like billgates , Jeff bezos now Elon musk etc
And you mentioned disagreements between political parties of Pakistan and Establishment, do you really think that its a religious disagreement? And you also mentioned Fall of Dhaka which wasn't happend due to religious disagreement. So please don't try to make people foul.
It was mentioned in the context of Jamaat islami supporting the military operation.
ماشاءاللہ لو یو ملنا ہے آپ سے سرجی
Dr shb k is betreen lecture k baad ab Qaisar Ahamad Raja aa jaye ga dr shb ko jawab dainy 😂😂😂
Sahi kaha😂😂
Haha! So on point! 🤣🤣
Blkl ghalt bat k badly achi bat b honi chaye
Bhai we respect him but that doesn't make him absolute. He is very biased with communism. And qaiser raja is also right on most of his points. Faisal waraich also disagreed on his views on communism. Why are you pointing out qaiser raja for just being from religious side
Amazing
This is what happens when you change horses mid race. I'm referring to the sudden change of DG ISI. I'm shocked you failed to notice that
Fan ❤
Simply wow you're educating people in in a specific direction in a very subtle way
Love and respect ❤❤❤
ابتدائی 20 منٹس جو آپ نے فرمایا وہ آپ کی ذاتی راے ہو سکتی ہے کیوں کے جو کچھ آپ نے کہا آپ خود بھی اس کو ثابت نہیں کر سکتے کے وہی سچ ہے
taimur sb , huge fan here . However I would like you to re-visit the pentagon attack theory . It isn't as cut and dry as it was initially thought to be and numerous scientists and journalist now have such questions that the government hasn't ever provided satisfactory answer to .
It is quite possible that the government was involved. You yourself teach the ills and ails of capitalism and how it completely demolishes any concept of loyalty between the super class , and the subordinate class correct ?
This shouldn't be difficult for you to understand then , that a government IS CAPABLE of harming its own citizens. The objectives can be many . For example the wasted trillion dollars spent on the war on terror , that obviously did go into someone's pocket and achieved nearly nothing. They set out to crush taliban but comically failed .
Anyways I digress. My main argument here was whenever the term conspiracy theory is tossed around in any enviornment , immediately the argument that is boxed in that theory is dimissed isn't that so ? . If I narrate an anecdote to you and mid sentence someone comes and tells you dont bother with this tale , it is a conspiracy theory . You would immediately cease to analyze the tale and regard it as fable.
It is worth investigating whatever happened that day on sept 11.
Huge fan here . Been following you since 3 years . Completely on board with whatever you teach and preach . much love !
The word secularism should be changed to Quranic word Pluralism. Canada practice it.
Sorry sir but disagree on some points like world trade center and October 7 attack. The matter is not that simple. As far as Pakistan terriosim concern it's also not that simple yes Pakistan army do not want to be attacked but it's long story and without context you can't understand it. Yes we are facing religious extremism agree
So what's the reason behind world trade centre ? Is this justifiable that innocent civilians should be targeted due to some American policies ..and attackers are not Japanese and veitnames but Saudis why ?
Do you mean for Palestine freedom? October 7 was necessary ?
@envalis44 to eliminate and for Palestinian freedom kidnapping of unarmed civilians , women , old persons , children is necessary ? Do you think Hammas is going to establish a free Palestine 🇵🇸 state where all a of their religions, are equal .. do you think hammas is freedom fighter? Before , in August 2021, you people used to call taliban freedom fighters . Now tell me, is pakistan state apartheid for baloch people .
@envalis44 after 7th October 28000 gaza people have been died .. is this right path to take back freedom ... o come on this is religious war in which Muslims are going to kill all Jews either they are hiding behind stones and trees ( hadith says)
I think you never ever heard about kurdistan ( state occupied by 4 countries turkey , Iraq, Iran and Syria) because this does not suit your religious narrative
You would never talk about Indonesian invasion on east taimur ( a Christian country) as again it does not suit your religious narrative
There are lots of examples which I can mention for you
Another is darfur massacre since 2003 in sudan 🇸🇩 but you don't know about it ..
I support Palestine 🇵🇸 a free state
Israel 🇮🇱 does brutality through bombing no doubt
And thousands of Palestinians have been killed since October 7 .. is this tactic of hammas true and justifiable ? 1300 Israelis civilians have been killed and lots of Israelis have been abducted ..thousands gaza people have died
Shame on this
@envalis44 is Azerbaijan 🇦🇿 apartheid state for nokornokarabakh people ? Please answer me
Why you people and your media don't speak even a single word on it 🤔
Studying social phenomena through the lens of scientific analysis doesn’t imply that official government explanations are the only valid reasons. The world is complex, and it’s important to have a more nuanced approach than the one you presented, where you dismissed all motives of war as being based solely on external factors, rather than a more complex combination of internal and external influences. My comment is more on your gross oversimplification explanation on America’s lust for wars which many Americans would even disagree with, including myself.
What's common between Micheal Jackson and Muhammad??? Anyone??
What similarities between sita with raven and hawking at Epstein Island
Both r gud
Both were Pedophiles.....
The most infected area by the disease of terrorism is FATA, KPK and Peshawar. To be added
Agreed
1:25:55 ..
👍👍👍
Kon kon Ex Muslim sahil Adam seeker , zafar aur Harris Sultan, galib Kamal ko RUclips pe sunta Hain ??? 🙌🙌🙌🙌
❤🎉🎉
❤🎉
Totally not agreed with not giving the minorities as a status of second class citizens.
Pak army nay bht say attack khud krwayay ojhrhi camp ki report ab tak q ni I aur aps k baray m ahsanullah ka byan b h
❤️❤️❤️
1:02:00
Great lecture.. thanks
This lecture just exposed this guy. For a good 30 mins i had no idea where is he leading us to. Necessarily he tried to complicate the topic and mix in details that were not essential at this point. However it helped him complicate, and as he wanted to paint this whole concept with conspiracies and extremism and what not as if that would fool someone on the look for some actual truth. He didn’t do justice to the whole concept and he is by no way an authority on the matter. Pakistani left is yet another shade of ignorance in our whole society, and it carries all the features of a semi literate, unsophisticated, openly biased, uncritical of themselves, and a self deceiving spectrum of thinking.
Apko Quran ke hawalesebat bat Karni chaheay
❤
you are not even shoe of maududi
👍
ruclips.net/video/nciwFLBu7Ac/видео.html
Podcast hosts: William Darymple and Anita Anand.
Dr.sahib! Ap uighurs ko terrorist smjhte hen? 🤔
ETIM ko.
@@Taimur_Laal Hammas 🤔?
Professor sahab kuch bhi karlo aap Islam ki haqaniat ko jhutla nahi sakte Islam is the Ultimate Solution
Look at the condition of 1.4 billion Muslims of this world who follow the tenants of Islam night and day, does it look like they have found the "Ultimate solution" ? na kar bhai.
@@pappu33 bro ham musalman aur specially jin k pass authority hain woh Islam ko kitna follow karte hain main bhi janta hoon aur aap bhi, ham sab mafadparasti aur beimani main lage huwe hain, sab ko bas apni apni padi huwi hai ham log ethics aur morallity main bohat nichay gir chuke hain, imandar aur sache insan ko ham log bewaqoof samajhte hain jabhi to hamara yeh haal hai
@@list10s sawal ye hy imandari or sachai ki gawahi kon de ga ye mulla loog ya koi Constitution
Me Allah se dua krta hun k ap pakistan jese dar ul harab ko chor kr Afghanistan jese dar ul islam jldi se chle jao ..
@@umroyaaraap ko kis beaqal ne keh diya k Pakistan dar ul harb hai?
Mix things...mix truth and lies...mix knowledge and prejudices...mix shit and honey...a typical liberal secular opinion...
This type of Funda mentalism is main obstruction of yours economic development.you adopted a system of ruling according to your Islamic system is like "Allah ka mullah,mullah ka mulki".where are common people in your system of ruling.plz adopt the system of socialistic secular model which is real one of Indian continent.
ڈاکٹر صاحب اپنے لاہور اسلام اباد کراچی کا نام تو لیا مگر پشاور چارسدہ شمالی و جنوبی وزیرستان کے تمام علاقے جو اس دہشتگردی کیوجہ کھنڈر بن گیے نام نہیں لیا۔ حالانکہ دیکھا جاے جتنی تباہی و بردبادی جانی و مالی شکل میں پشتون بیلٹ میں کہیں اور اتنی نہیں وہی۔ تو اپ سے درخواست ہے کہ اسطرح کے لیکچر میں سب سے پہلے ان علاقوں کو بھی یاد کیا کریں
We can split the world 🌍 history in two parts 1 before 9-11 and after 9-11
This was planned by US authorities
Molvi itna bara kaam naheen kr sakta
Wo loudspeaker pe America ko galiyan decskta hy bs
I don't agree with you 😞
A highly skewed and biased speech as usual 😊😊🎉
Mutazillahs are also fundamentalists
Never
😂
Broadcasting your master’s voice? No originality?
secularism system (yazeed 2.0)
Pakistan has become Riyasst-e-Madina.
Riasat e pudina 😂
Make debate With This Man @QaiserAhmedRaja
Lal Sahib Lag Pata Jayega Tumhein.
🎉❤🎉
❤❤❤❤
❤
❤
❤❤❤❤