I'm sorry but Geno Smith wasn't good anywhere he went until last year. Should the Jets have hung onto him for 9 years just waiting for him to turn it around? That's absolutely ridiculous.
Bc people thought of him as a backup and the jets gave up on geno after his rookie year in which his point is that If they were patient he would've been his 2022 form
@@batchadirector963 no they didn't give up on him after his rookie season, and he didn't do anything with the Giants or any other team, this was a career year for him and no guarantee he does it again
@@Jfen79 they signed Fitzpatrick I'm confused if that's not giving up and I guarantee he most likely will bc he can't just have a good year and not like he is still in the same system
In all fairness, the injury Brees had that year ended a loooot of potential hall of fame qbs careers, sugery back then wasn't nearly as polished as it is now. Also, Phillip Rivers was a very good qb for a very long time, definitely not a gold jacket recipient but its not called the hall of very good
Johnny Unitas is the one quarterback who is credited and responsible for establishing the two-minute drill in “The Greatest Game Ever Played” in the 1958 NFL Championship Game en route to guiding the Colts to a 23-17 overtime victory over the Giants!
Honestly I really feel bad for Derek Car like yeah he wasn’t the best quarterback but the raiders refused to actually build a proper team to compete with and picked terrible coaches for the team
Yeah that happened in a different era back when you did not have to have an elite-level quarterback to win a Superbowl. That is the same timeframe the Ravens won would Trent dilfer and the buccaneers won with Brad Johnson
@@patrickprun1467 Jim Haslett was our coach then, and Aaron Brooks (Vick's cousin) wasn't elite but okay, however, him throwing interceptions wasn't. We was close to getting to being a elite team. We had a great O line, and the talent was there, but we needed someone that was capable of throwing a football on target.
@@cjmarsh504 Jake was an undrafted. The team had no investment in him and no expectations. Not to mention brooks flashed that elite talents. And who's to say the issue wasn't the coaching. Jake improved immediately after leaving. And we never got to see Aaron play any where else. The saints were no then a QB a way. Brook only had a winning record one time. I know throw a bunch of picks. But I know there as at least one year he didn't. And y'all still didn't have a winning record. The saints were good but look at the team's y'all were playing against. You guys had to deal with the historically great buccaneers defense twice a year. The bears defense was nothing to fuk with. The Ravens, green Bay, colts, eagles, rams, patriots, and the Panthers.The week was stacked in the saints roster just didn't have the same town as the top. You guys realistically word the third best team in the division
@@redseashtposts Supposedly the giants thought geno was better than eli but didn't want to piss off the fans and the locker room by putting geno in. Rex Ryan tried to trade for him when he was on the bills staff. Clearly he had talent, or else there wouldn't have been multiple nfl teams viewing him as a starting qb
There are many serviceable QBs that were able to be a starter a few years without being top level. Carr is one of them. There was also Dalton, Flacco (he did great in some playoff games but the Ravens had good D to help that team), Shaub. Someone who can be a starter over 5 years. Many QBs don't even last 5 as a starter
A lot of QBs are given up too early on. Fans called for Rex Grossman's benching in the preseason after the Bears went to the Super Bowl. The team had the second most improved offense in the NFL and he was the only significant addition. The team ahead of them was the Saints, who had their new coach Brees and their new coach Payton.
The Bears should have played Kyle Orton instead of Grossman in the Superbowl loss to the Colts. Orton got them to that game...Grossman was "injured". Dumb move. Same can be said of the 49ers using Kapernick over Alex Smith. Smith is a much better QB...had too learn a different offensive scheme every year. And the list goes on....
@@lfd_eng9219 Many criticize Kap but when you look at it Kap had more playoff wins than Smith in their careers. Smith had one with KC and 1 with SF. Kap had 4 with SF. Smith only led a team to a conference title game once- Kap did it twice and 1 super bowl. I'm a Chiefs fan and Smith helped Mariota comeback
Geno wouldn't be the player he is today without sitting behind Wilson for so long. He benefitted from being coached in an excellent system while having no pressure on him to win for years. This isn't a shot at him though. He never gave in to the idea of being just a backup for the rest of his career and worked towards an opportunity at a starting job he may have never had a chance at had things gone differently. He's truly become a mature and balanced player that gives his absolute all at every opportunity because he knows what a blessing it is to have it. He believed in himself to succeed when just about anyone else would have given up and it shows every time he's on the field. Geno may be one of the greatest comeback stories of our era and he's definitely not done improving. There may not be another QB who knows exactly how special his opportunity is and how quickly it can be taken away. He's a true team player and he's grateful for every second he spends on the field. If this guy can win a championship someone better make a movie because stuff like this doesn't just happen.
Brett Favre was such a legendary gunslinger of a tremendously terrific franchise quarterback in Green Bay especially winning a super bowl championship in 1996 and won 3 NFL's MVP now he's a hall of famer
Norm Van Brocklin still holds the record for the most passing yards in a game an NFL Record of 554 in 1951 but nobody or anybody at QB hasn't come close to breaking it yet it still remains in almost 73 years 7:25
Palmer wanted to leave and it was the right time to ditch Dalton. He had his chances to prove himself in the playoffs and he couldn’t. If they kept him too long they would have missed out on Burrow.
Some of these picks are all about context. The Steve Young situation wasn’t about the Bucs giving up, he wouldn’t have become who he became if he stayed there.
Saying the cowboys Should've moved on from tony romo by 2012 shows me you know nothing about football🤣 that man carried those teams and his best season was in 2014
Kurt Warner had Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt along with Faulk, bounced around the league and led another team to a SB when he had Larry Fitzgerald, Anquon Boldin and Edgrin James, hall of famers and borderline hall of famers
You should do the same video of this but "When Fanbases give up to early on a QB" for example if Russ does well the broncos fan base gave up too early BTW I still believe in Russ
As a Jets fan, Geno was never going to develop in New York. The team a QB ends up with can be the difference between a bust and superstar, and the Jets just haven't been a good spot for young QBs to develop in historically.
The too lates refer to very good to great QBs who may have been washed up but still run out there by their franchise. Don't agree re Unitas: He won a Super Bowl in 1970 in his twilight, and Carr had one crappy year when the rest of the team went to hell. To me, the category should have been about the "never was" QBs like, for example, Cleveland sticking with Mike Phipps for five full seasons in the 1970's b/c he was the third player picked in 1970 and had a lifetime passer rating in the '40's.
The example of Brett Favre is why I am annoyed by the section of the Falcons fanbase that wants anyone but Ridder at QB in 2023. He was denied the extra time that could have cleared up any concerns of whether he can become a legit starter or not.
I will never forgive my Falcons for getting rid of Brett Favor…I mean Favray…I mean Favree…Favreh? Favrie? Favier? Fairve? No no no…Favre. Favre. I meant Favre. Damnit! Why Atlanta?! Just why?!
Maybe because they went 14 - 2 the next year ( then got Bradyed in the playoffs ) then 11- 5 and won their 1st playoff game since '94 and then won 2 more division titles in a row
@@jacksonconley5117 I didn't say he didn't have a better career and hindsight is always 20/20 and SD still had a pro bowl QB who is borderline hall of fame which is why I think he was on the list, I mean yeah if they had a chance at a redo they would've kept Brees but there's no guarantee he has the same career without Payton as his coach
It’s a good thing Geno never stayed with the Jets. Ownership basically set him to fail. Rex Ryan and Todd Bowles cannot be compared to Pete Carroll by a long shot. Imagine playing under Adam “Googly-eyes” Gase. According to Christopher Johnson, he’s a “brilliant offensive mind.”
You gotta feel real bad for Matt Ryan because just when you thought he was this close like so close to win your 1st ever super bowl title the Patriots took it away from him after you had a 25 point lead when you know if you put more and more points in the 2nd half it would be over but that was not the case here 6:53
But dude... Carr should not get the blame the coach is the one who makes the playes go not Carr and your saying it is too late? We got jimmy G if you have been around you know it is just being biased ( Don't hate on me i am doing an opinion and also Carr is very good it is just josh Mcdaniels )
Hey Tps do some research...check the rank of the Raiders defenses when Carr was there. Cowherd came out and said Tom Brady wouldn't have won all those rings with defenses like Carr has had.
Your list immediately became flawed when derek carr was too late yet you put geno smith too early for ONE playoff appearance....that was even before matt ryan pick... good lord
Colts fan here, can't blame Derek Carr for the Raiders failing to build around him, he did make things happen for people to talk smack and consider them something. They went nowhere obviously but the first time he got injured and the "leaders" blew it up, and gave the dude a terrible o line and 1 person to throw it to reliably a year, wooo yeah f that guy for doing what he did.
I disagree on the Matthew Stafford comparison mainly because he won a super bowl as soon as he got out of Detroit. I'd call him a very good, not great, but very good. Quarterback that just wasted away in a bad situation. I'd bet money we are about to see the same situation with DeShaun Watson, he is very talented but there can be no success in a franchise ran that poorly. It was looking like that was going to happen with Trevor Lawrence under urban Meyer as well. Thank goodness people realized that and changes were made.
Geno Smith had a good season this year but it's a bit of a stretch to say the Jets let him go too early. He was there for 4 years and it took until his 9th season to have a good season. That's 5 years after the Jets released him.
2014 had Chris Ivory, Eric Decker and Percy Harvin 2015 had Chris Ivory, Eric Decker and Brandon Marshall That's far from being scrubs. Even the offensive line was good during that time.
@@davidepling724 Percy Harvin wasn't even much of a recieving weapon Also ivory had 3 seasons with jets and had 1 year with 1000 rushing yards Eric decker was the only one who seemed like a weapon
@@batchadirector963 he still had half decent weapons. While not good they were decent and the original comment replied to said he didn't have half decent weapons. Ivory had 800+ yards every season, only had 200+ carries once in 3 seasons and never averaged less than 4.1 yards a carry. If you don't get 200 carries there's no way to reach 1,000 yards. You didn't look deep enough into the stats before criticizing only one season with 1,000 yards rushing.
I feel like the New York Jets gave up on Sam Darnold too early. The last season he was with the Jets, he was doing pretty good. He could’ve been a great mentor for Zack Wilson. Maybe.
@@NAT-turners-Revenge he was drafted by the jets. He struggled with New York his entire career. He’s the one that “famously” said, “I’m seeing Ghost” during a game when he threw an interception to a defender when there was no receiver anywhere near the defender. The last couple of games of the last season he was with the jets he played the best games of his career. Because he played so well the jets lost the #1 overall draft pick and the chance to draft Trevor Lawrence who went to the Jacksonville Jaguars; New York went with Zack Wilson instead. A few sports analysts said that New York should have stayed with Sam Darnold at least one more year to see if Sam’s performance wasn’t a fluke. He went to Caroline Panthers and he did really good the first half of the season. A lot of analysts believe it was because of Christian McCaffrey, but in the beginning of that year they looked like a team to beat.
I stopped after the back to back Derek Carr and Geno Smith. Carr is better than most think and almost everyone thought Geno was washed. He's had 1 good season and I wish him the best but it could be a fluke.
Geno Smith career before last season was 34-37 TD Int no team is hanging onto him after that. And if he regresses next year 2022 will go down as a fluke
I'm a Jets fan and they give up on every "franchise" QB to fast!! Every QB they draft is the next "franchise" QB!! Then 2 seasons later they draft another "next franchise QB!! J E T S JETS JETS JETS. We also like Green Bay left overs.
Idk I feel like most of the qbs had weapons and a defense they would be hof qbs. Steve Young had Rice, Taylor, Craig, and a defense with the 49ers. He would have never been to a superbowl with the lack of talent in Tampa. Vinny was a good qb with no talent.
Are you serious right now with that geno smith take ? Was they supposed to keep a trash QB for 9 years till he magically got better ? Use your head bruh.
He should have been fired in 2013 after going 8-8 3 straight years and losing a “win and in” game to each team in the division. The only thing that saved him was that Romo didn’t play in the 2013 week 17 game against the eagles. Jerry Jones used that as an excuse to keep him beyond that point.
I'm sorry but Geno Smith wasn't good anywhere he went until last year. Should the Jets have hung onto him for 9 years just waiting for him to turn it around? That's absolutely ridiculous.
Bc people thought of him as a backup and the jets gave up on geno after his rookie year in which his point is that If they were patient he would've been his 2022 form
I said the same thing
@@batchadirector963 no they didn't give up on him after his rookie season, and he didn't do anything with the Giants or any other team, this was a career year for him and no guarantee he does it again
Exactly, geno was mostly trash with off field- team problems. If anything he was a guy who needed to mature and found a system that fit him
@@Jfen79 they signed Fitzpatrick I'm confused if that's not giving up and I guarantee he most likely will bc he can't just have a good year and not like he is still in the same system
Too early: Drew Brees with the San Diego Chargers
The Chargers winning 4 straight Division titles after trading Brees might be the reason they weren't here, even with Brees winning the Super Bowl
He got hurt the end of the year and the surgery he had it was less than a 5% percent chance of coming back healthy
Love brees from his Purdue days but ur wrong.... chargers did just fine without him
They wouldnt have Won anyways. Trust me im a Chargers fan lol
In all fairness, the injury Brees had that year ended a loooot of potential hall of fame qbs careers, sugery back then wasn't nearly as polished as it is now. Also, Phillip Rivers was a very good qb for a very long time, definitely not a gold jacket recipient but its not called the hall of very good
Johnny Unitas is the one quarterback who is credited and responsible for establishing the two-minute drill in “The Greatest Game Ever Played” in the 1958 NFL Championship Game en route to guiding the Colts to a 23-17 overtime victory over the Giants!
Johnny Unitas will forever be the textbook example of the team making the player. He had that 2017 wentz treatment for 6 years
Honestly I really feel bad for Derek Car like yeah he wasn’t the best quarterback but the raiders refused to actually build a proper team to compete with and picked terrible coaches for the team
Too early: Chargers and Drew Brees
At least they got rivers
@A MONSTER 900Bc and I said at least, so i meant not a total disaster, like other franchises
Brees didn't break out til they drafted Rivers. By then they had no choice to move on
Chargers went on to win the division title 4 straight years in a row. I think they did alright.
Also Steve young and the buccaneers
"I bet the Jets are wishing that held onto him right about now"
I think they're all right 😂
no they are okay they got arod
@@ThunderPlayz599 Rogers signed?
@@theo4real1 will be soon
@@theo4real1 he will soon
@@ThunderPlayz599 well this should be interesting to watch
I remember when the saints traded Jake Dellomme to the Panthers, and the Panthers went to the super bowl. Talk about too early
🤔 .. Too many variables..... coaching, city, o-line, scheme, etc
U risk not signing brees if u hang onto delhomme too long
Yeah that happened in a different era back when you did not have to have an elite-level quarterback to win a Superbowl. That is the same timeframe the Ravens won would Trent dilfer and the buccaneers won with Brad Johnson
@@patrickprun1467 Jim Haslett was our coach then, and Aaron Brooks (Vick's cousin) wasn't elite but okay, however, him throwing interceptions wasn't. We was close to getting to being a elite team. We had a great O line, and the talent was there, but we needed someone that was capable of throwing a football on target.
@@cjmarsh504 Jake was an undrafted. The team had no investment in him and no expectations. Not to mention brooks flashed that elite talents. And who's to say the issue wasn't the coaching. Jake improved immediately after leaving. And we never got to see Aaron play any where else. The saints were no then a QB a way. Brook only had a winning record one time. I know throw a bunch of picks. But I know there as at least one year he didn't. And y'all still didn't have a winning record. The saints were good but look at the team's y'all were playing against. You guys had to deal with the historically great buccaneers defense twice a year. The bears defense was nothing to fuk with. The Ravens, green Bay, colts, eagles, rams, patriots, and the Panthers.The week was stacked in the saints roster just didn't have the same town as the top. You guys realistically word the third best team in the division
I think Geno Smith belongs on a different list. Most surprising player
right like no team is gonna wait 10 years for their qb to actually do decent
@@redseashtposts geno wasn't the problem, the jets were.
@@symptomofsouls explain further since i clearly don’t know
@@redseashtposts Supposedly the giants thought geno was better than eli but didn't want to piss off the fans and the locker room by putting geno in. Rex Ryan tried to trade for him when he was on the bills staff. Clearly he had talent, or else there wouldn't have been multiple nfl teams viewing him as a starting qb
@@symptomofsouls that is a good point, didn’t know that
30 decades later if the Atlanta falcons still exist they will never forget that
I heard that error too
So he did say that, I wasn't sure
You forgot to mention the Pittsburgh Steelers who dumped both Len Dawson and Johnny Unitas too early!
There are many serviceable QBs that were able to be a starter a few years without being top level. Carr is one of them. There was also Dalton, Flacco (he did great in some playoff games but the Ravens had good D to help that team), Shaub. Someone who can be a starter over 5 years. Many QBs don't even last 5 as a starter
A lot of QBs are given up too early on. Fans called for Rex Grossman's benching in the preseason after the Bears went to the Super Bowl. The team had the second most improved offense in the NFL and he was the only significant addition. The team ahead of them was the Saints, who had their new coach Brees and their new coach Payton.
The Bears should have played Kyle Orton instead of Grossman in the Superbowl loss to the Colts. Orton got them to that game...Grossman was "injured". Dumb move. Same can be said of the 49ers using Kapernick over Alex Smith. Smith is a much better QB...had too learn a different offensive scheme every year. And the list goes on....
@@lfd_eng9219 Many criticize Kap but when you look at it Kap had more playoff wins than Smith in their careers. Smith had one with KC and 1 with SF. Kap had 4 with SF. Smith only led a team to a conference title game once- Kap did it twice and 1 super bowl. I'm a Chiefs fan and Smith helped Mariota comeback
Geno wouldn't be the player he is today without sitting behind Wilson for so long. He benefitted from being coached in an excellent system while having no pressure on him to win for years. This isn't a shot at him though. He never gave in to the idea of being just a backup for the rest of his career and worked towards an opportunity at a starting job he may have never had a chance at had things gone differently. He's truly become a mature and balanced player that gives his absolute all at every opportunity because he knows what a blessing it is to have it. He believed in himself to succeed when just about anyone else would have given up and it shows every time he's on the field. Geno may be one of the greatest comeback stories of our era and he's definitely not done improving. There may not be another QB who knows exactly how special his opportunity is and how quickly it can be taken away. He's a true team player and he's grateful for every second he spends on the field. If this guy can win a championship someone better make a movie because stuff like this doesn't just happen.
Bert Jones was great for the Colts before Manning
Keep up the great work TPS!
Too long: Cincinnati Bengals Andy Dalton!!!!
I actually think it was Marvin Lewis who was held onto too long in Cincy
@@Jfen79 yes 😁
Geno winning that come back player award is one of the silliest things I’ve seen. “Look everyone, I don’t suck anymore!”
"30 decades later". Are you saying the Falcons still suck in 2292?
Yes.
The dolphins Needa give up on Tua the team is to stacked to have the game decided by him if he’s healthy or not
Man stfu lol 😂
There not getting rid of him
True
Extra venom for the cowboys as usual. Typical from a giants fan who is tired of losing to Dallas year in and year out.
Ha, the Steve Young and the 59ers crushed the Cowboys spirit in that 1995 NFC Championship Game.
Prime Time Deion Sanders made the 49ers defense #1 that years, also cowboys Right Offensive tackle eric Williams being out hurt them that year
Derek Carr is a good Qb
Matt Ryan wasn't the problem in atlantal
You're right, the patriots were
Let the casual pander man talk.. He has to meme on Atlanta for the clicks.. it's that bad
@@aidanconrad6117 the o-line was
@@aidanconrad6117 😂
Brett Favre was such a legendary gunslinger of a tremendously terrific franchise quarterback in Green Bay especially winning a super bowl championship in 1996 and won 3 NFL's MVP now he's a hall of famer
Norm Van Brocklin still holds the record for the most passing yards in a game an NFL Record of 554 in 1951 but nobody or anybody at QB hasn't come close to breaking it yet it still remains in almost 73 years 7:25
The bengals and Carson Palmer
@konner5880 or even Andy Dalton.
Palmer wanted to leave and it was the right time to ditch Dalton. He had his chances to prove himself in the playoffs and he couldn’t. If they kept him too long they would have missed out on Burrow.
The lions were the problem not Matthew
Dak Prescott will be on this list in the future.
😁 yes
Some of these picks are all about context. The Steve Young situation wasn’t about the Bucs giving up, he wouldn’t have become who he became if he stayed there.
Saying the cowboys Should've moved on from tony romo by 2012 shows me you know nothing about football🤣 that man carried those teams and his best season was in 2014
*TOO LONG* cowboys-Prescott
Ravens- jackson
Dolphins- tua
Jets need to move on from Zach Wilson and I'm not even a Jets fan
1:51 As a Dallas fan, I would rather not talk about Super Bowl 5.
Makes ya wonder how guys could have turned out if they were on better teams...
Thirty decades later? Didn’t realize Favre played in colonial times…
Kurt Warner had Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt along with Faulk, bounced around the league and led another team to a SB when he had Larry Fitzgerald, Anquon Boldin and Edgrin James, hall of famers and borderline hall of famers
Edge wasn't on the 2008 Cardinals
@@CC-rb1yf you may wanna do a little more research because he most certainly was, played 13 games that year
@@Jfen79fr fr. I hate it when people just say stuff lol.
@@Levidawgs7744 I know right, a quick Google search would've prevented his foot from going into his mouth
5 points why Aaron Rodgers should go to the jets and 5 why he should remain right in Green Bay and finish his career. TPS!???
You should do the same video of this but "When Fanbases give up to early on a QB" for example if Russ does well the broncos fan base gave up too early
BTW I still believe in Russ
They didn’t give up too early they were realistic and his playing showed how he should be viewed 😅
Fan bases are always "what have you done for me lately?" It's nowhere near the same as the franchise giving up too early
@@eastern1015 You should watch the last 2 games of the season
@@Jfen79 that is true
Steve Young would’ve never hit elite status if he stayed with the Bucs
1:31 woah woah woah Bret Farve isnt that old
Arizona should give up on Kyler Murray
They just signed him dumb ass
And he’s young
And he’s hurt
Who tf are they gonna go get ??
Kirk cousins, Derek Carr, dak Prescott, and Tony Romo are a pure example of that
As a Jets fan, Geno was never going to develop in New York. The team a QB ends up with can be the difference between a bust and superstar, and the Jets just haven't been a good spot for young QBs to develop in historically.
Geno on this list is a joke. Should the Jets have held on to him for 7 years of suck?
The Colts QB purgatory included Bert Jones. Put some respect on the name
The too lates refer to very good to great QBs who may have been washed up but still run out there by their franchise. Don't agree re Unitas: He won a Super Bowl in 1970 in his twilight, and Carr had one crappy year when the rest of the team went to hell. To me, the category should have been about the "never was" QBs like, for example, Cleveland sticking with Mike Phipps for five full seasons in the 1970's b/c he was the third player picked in 1970 and had a lifetime passer rating in the '40's.
The example of Brett Favre is why I am annoyed by the section of the Falcons fanbase that wants anyone but Ridder at QB in 2023. He was denied the extra time that could have cleared up any concerns of whether he can become a legit starter or not.
I will never forgive my Falcons for getting rid of Brett Favor…I mean Favray…I mean Favree…Favreh? Favrie? Favier? Fairve? No no no…Favre. Favre. I meant Favre. Damnit! Why Atlanta?! Just why?!
Two teams for Kirk Cousins both Washington and now Minneapolis holding on way too long!
Brett faver🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣 got me dying
Love your video TPS
You should do a video about hall of famers getting shut down. An example is Justin Jefferson playing against jiare Alexander
Brett FAVOR? REALLY?
How was the Chargers giving up on Drew Brees too early not here!?
Maybe because they went 14 - 2 the next year ( then got Bradyed in the playoffs ) then 11- 5 and won their 1st playoff game since '94 and then won 2 more division titles in a row
Yah, but they won no Super Bowl @@Jfen79 and Brees had a much better career than Rivers.
@@jacksonconley5117 I didn't say he didn't have a better career and hindsight is always 20/20 and SD still had a pro bowl QB who is borderline hall of fame which is why I think he was on the list, I mean yeah if they had a chance at a redo they would've kept Brees but there's no guarantee he has the same career without Payton as his coach
It’s a good thing Geno never stayed with the Jets. Ownership basically set him to fail. Rex Ryan and Todd Bowles cannot be compared to Pete Carroll by a long shot. Imagine playing under Adam “Googly-eyes” Gase. According to Christopher Johnson, he’s a “brilliant offensive mind.”
Too late. Bengals with Andy dalton
I guess you had no clue that pittsburgh had unitis first so they gave up on him to soon not the colts
You gotta feel real bad for Matt Ryan because just when you thought he was this close like so close to win your 1st ever super bowl title the Patriots took it away from him after you had a 25 point lead when you know if you put more and more points in the 2nd half it would be over but that was not the case here 6:53
My bears not drafting PATRICK M. WILL FOREVER HAUNT US BUT GO BEARS 💙🧡🧡💙🧡🧡🧡💙
You should do the biggest chocks of the NFL 2022 season
But dude... Carr should not get the blame the coach is the one who makes the playes go not Carr and your saying it is too late? We got jimmy G if you have been around you know it is just being biased ( Don't hate on me i am doing an opinion and also Carr is very good it is just josh Mcdaniels )
Bro he has NO PLAYOFF WINS
Fuck what you’re talking about lol 😂
Hey Tps do some research...check the rank of the Raiders defenses when Carr was there. Cowherd came out and said Tom Brady wouldn't have won all those rings with defenses like Carr has had.
Unitas too early giving up by the Pittsburg Steelers
Carr was good enough, the raiders never having a top 20 defense was the problem lol
That’s my thing the dam Defense was ass
Khalil Mack has entered the chat 😂😂😂
@@luiscastaneda5250 team sport. And even WITH him, they still weren’t top 20 lol
Thank God someone in the chat who knows what was truly wrong
@@djjones635 media has these people brainwashed thinking Wins/Losses are a QB stat lol
How do you think Rodgers will do in Gotham and Who will sign Elliott?
If Dallas had Tom Brady holy cow they would be super bowl contenders right off the bat 10:38
Your list immediately became flawed when derek carr was too late yet you put geno smith too early for ONE playoff appearance....that was even before matt ryan pick... good lord
Isn’t 30 decades 300 years ???
Steve Young went from a nobody to one of the best if not the greatest quarterback with 49ers winning a super bowl championship in 1994
Tony Romo and Dallas cowboys parted ways at the perfect time honestly cuz Romo had trouble staying healthy
What about Joe Flacco (too late) and Drew Brees (too early)?
You left out giants with Eli should’ve let his ass go after 2013 but no jerry Reese just had to keep him
Colts fan here, can't blame Derek Carr for the Raiders failing to build around him, he did make things happen for people to talk smack and consider them something. They went nowhere obviously but the first time he got injured and the "leaders" blew it up, and gave the dude a terrible o line and 1 person to throw it to reliably a year, wooo yeah f that guy for doing what he did.
Too early Pittsburgh Steelers Johnny Unitas and Len Dawson
Patriots need to give up on Mac Jones. He's okay but they tried to draft Brady's replacement and fell flat on their face
I disagree on the Matthew Stafford comparison mainly because he won a super bowl as soon as he got out of Detroit. I'd call him a very good, not great, but very good. Quarterback that just wasted away in a bad situation. I'd bet money we are about to see the same situation with DeShaun Watson, he is very talented but there can be no success in a franchise ran that poorly. It was looking like that was going to happen with Trevor Lawrence under urban Meyer as well. Thank goodness people realized that and changes were made.
Ah yes, 30 decades later. 200 more years 🤦♂️
Geno Smith had a good season this year but it's a bit of a stretch to say the Jets let him go too early. He was there for 4 years and it took until his 9th season to have a good season. That's 5 years after the Jets released him.
@@Believe2312lmao that's facts
2014 had Chris Ivory, Eric Decker and Percy Harvin
2015 had Chris Ivory, Eric Decker and Brandon Marshall
That's far from being scrubs. Even the offensive line was good during that time.
@@davidepling724 Percy Harvin wasn't even much of a recieving weapon
Also ivory had 3 seasons with jets and had 1 year with 1000 rushing yards
Eric decker was the only one who seemed like a weapon
@@batchadirector963 he still had half decent weapons. While not good they were decent and the original comment replied to said he didn't have half decent weapons. Ivory had 800+ yards every season, only had 200+ carries once in 3 seasons and never averaged less than 4.1 yards a carry. If you don't get 200 carries there's no way to reach 1,000 yards. You didn't look deep enough into the stats before criticizing only one season with 1,000 yards rushing.
@@davidepling724 ok but your point is saying this was the 2023 giants? 😅
It's a crime Brees ain't on this list. Or even Brady considering he won another ring in TB.
I feel like the New York Jets gave up on Sam Darnold too early. The last season he was with the Jets, he was doing pretty good. He could’ve been a great mentor for Zack Wilson. Maybe.
Isnt darnold with carolina 😳
@@NAT-turners-Revenge Not anymore Sam Darnold signed with the 49ers on Tuesday.
@@NAT-turners-Revenge he was drafted by the jets. He struggled with New York his entire career. He’s the one that “famously” said, “I’m seeing Ghost” during a game when he threw an interception to a defender when there was no receiver anywhere near the defender. The last couple of games of the last season he was with the jets he played the best games of his career. Because he played so well the jets lost the #1 overall draft pick and the chance to draft Trevor Lawrence who went to the Jacksonville Jaguars; New York went with Zack Wilson instead. A few sports analysts said that New York should have stayed with Sam Darnold at least one more year to see if Sam’s performance wasn’t a fluke. He went to Caroline Panthers and he did really good the first half of the season. A lot of analysts believe it was because of Christian McCaffrey, but in the beginning of that year they looked like a team to beat.
Tom Brady after they beat the Rams in SB 53 it would have saved the humiliation of losing the wild card game to the Titans the year after that
5 Times A Team Gave Up On A RB Too Early...And 5 Times They Gave Up Too Late
Whose name is Thomas Dimitrioff?? It's Dimitroff!!!
Bad Carr take because the Raiders would've just held up or ruined another promising qb had they traded Carr
Gave Up: Jay Cutler
I stopped after the back to back Derek Carr and Geno Smith. Carr is better than most think and almost everyone thought Geno was washed. He's had 1 good season and I wish him the best but it could be a fluke.
Geno Smith career before last season was 34-37 TD Int no team is hanging onto him after that. And if he regresses next year 2022 will go down as a fluke
I'm a Jets fan and they give up on every "franchise" QB to fast!! Every QB they draft is the next "franchise" QB!! Then 2 seasons later they draft another "next franchise QB!! J E T S JETS JETS JETS. We also like Green Bay left overs.
Cardinals gave up on Josh Rosen 🤷♂️
Wow being a falcons fan and seeing we got rid of a QB too early and a QB too late we fuckin suck 😂😂😂😂
Geno Smith is a product of the Seahawks system. NYJ didn't do anything wrong to dump him
@@Believe2312 no
Bridgewater with the Vikings & Saints
I don't know about Geno, he was mediocre at best with other teams, I think it's the system with the Seahawks, look how Russ is in Denver now
who's Brett Favor?
Idk I feel like most of the qbs had weapons and a defense they would be hof qbs. Steve Young had Rice, Taylor, Craig, and a defense with the 49ers. He would have never been to a superbowl with the lack of talent in Tampa. Vinny was a good qb with no talent.
How os Drew Brees not on this list with the Cargers?
I like to call Tony Romo Tony Dull, because romo means dull in spanish.
Too early to judge Derrick Carr. Just look at how many head coaches he went through amd no defense.
Are you serious right now with that geno smith take ? Was they supposed to keep a trash QB for 9 years till he magically got better ? Use your head bruh.
With the cowboys they should’ve gotten rid of Jason Garrett way earlier than romo
He should have been fired in 2013 after going 8-8 3 straight years and losing a “win and in” game to each team in the division. The only thing that saved him was that Romo didn’t play in the 2013 week 17 game against the eagles. Jerry Jones used that as an excuse to keep him beyond that point.