되게 신화는 터프하고 남성적인 이미지면 방탄은 부드럽게 섹시한 느낌..? 신화 영상은 별로본적 없어서 몰랐는데 확실히 신화가 레전드라는 이유를 알것 같고 저 남성적인 이미지에 컨셉을 지금 저렇게 소화하는 그룹을 없을것같고 방탄은 또 방탄 느낌으로 자기곡 처럼 부드럽게 섹시한 느낌으로 커버를 저렇게 잘했다는게 정말 둘다 대단한 가수들 인것 같다...
+Carol Nunes When I watch this video I realize that they are somehow very similar. They are both short (sorry ha ha), and extremely sexy and charismatic when it comes to dancing.
one question: did jungkook ate the freaking shinhwa cd just to have the same voice as the shinhwa's guy?? im impressed with this boy, seriously his talent is very on point.. im in awe
Kpop Lover yeah it's crazy. Late 90's and early 2000's had a more mature and 'manly' beauty ideal. They even had moustache in some of the concepts (and a lot less make up on). Kpop fans these days look for a more cute young image.
And Shinwa have the "bad boys" image. Just imagine it if their stylist put make up on them, they'll really hate it lolol I my self cant imagine them wearing make up or have the sweet image XD
I would say that Shinhwa were a couple years older (average around 23 yo), and by that time they were already titled beast-dol anyway hahaha (they left the cutesy image since their 2nd album), so can't really blame them for looking like that ;)
+Sehixneeo Sensen Bangtan boys have longer legs but they need to work out more and practise more to be professional and not to collapse after several songs like this. They are hot and can be perfect, I like them but this song needs a little more flexible. Just work harder, they can be perfect on every single point.
Shinhwa is a legendary group (which I knew them a long time ago like bigbang and suju and 2pm) BUT, BTS is my favorite of all boy groups, ever, I always listen to them everyday.
i still can't stop rewatching BTS's performance of this song I think they were phenomenal. i checked out Shinhwa's original song after seeing BTS's and i think BTS did it justice and more. they were really good... vocals and choreo. i thought BTS were amazing. i hope Shinhwa and their fans liked it
+Maymuna Kabir Many Shinhwa fans, including myself, loved it! We thought it was the best Shinhwa cover done so far. BUT BTS did not do better than Shinhwa. I'm sorry but I gotta say the truth. Shinhwa has better feels when they dance which is solemnly owned by themselves so I don't blame BTS for not being able to follow that. Vocal wise Shinhwa members' voices fit better with each other as well as the song itself. Especially the beginning part (Dongwan's part) it gets a little more obvious ans Dongwan has a very unique and strong base voice.
+meidi sore your salty about it it's ok people usually are when a group does great but as bts is getting bigger they remain unbothered as even though this was just a cover it already has nearly 7M views
i cannot imagine the amount of time, effort, and hard work BTS put into being as precise as possible, it's just so good and exact and beautiful i'm in awe
omg i remember youtube wasn't big that time i used to torrent and download this shinhwa, rain, hot and fly to the sky videos and burn them into a CD. the struggles were real.
haha woow You reminded me of how much of a struggle watching dramas was! At the time i didn't know about kpop and i only watched full house ^^ good times
Yes. views and likes were not counted and didn't matter before, and updates from your fave groups were limited. You enjoy their material after the difficulty of finding them.It was like treasure. Fans these days enjoy fandom wars more LOL.
I know this is a 2 year old video, but I'm right here with you...I'm currently uploading those vids I had gathered on my channel right now, because I still got all these videos collected on DVDs ^^;; and youtube wasn't only not big, it was non-existent!
제가 한창 신창일때는 커버한것중엔 낫지만 그래도 별로네 생각했는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 거의 반 아미 되고보니 그래도 현존 아이들중 신화를 잇는 애들은 얘들밖에 없단 생각이 ㅋㅋ 1세대 돌부터 시작해서 이때까지도 이민우의 간지를 따라갈 자는 없는게 확실한데요(여기저기 춤선생으로 나오는걸로 짐작은 하시겠지만 저딴영상은 이민우의1/100도 못담음) 방탄 지민군 또한 그누구도 따라할 수 없는 독보적 춤선이 있어요! 민우오빠는 남성적인 간지면 지민군은 여성적(?)인 간지 ㅋㅋ 둘다 아이돌중에 탑오브 탑 댄서입니다!! 그리고 어린 아미여러분들 신화는 퍼펙트맨보다 x99999 배쯤 간지나는 안무와 노래를 보유하고 있습니다. 방탄 봄날만 알고 쩔어/불타/not today/상남자/런/아니쥬 모르는사람 답답하듯이 신화는 펄팩맨 말고도 only one/all your dreams/wild eyes/yo/T.O.P 정도가 90년대-01 노래지만 현존 방탄노래 분위기 나요 추천드립니다. brand new / this love 워낙 레전드라 아실거라 생각돼서ㅋ 신창과 아미는 친하게 지내야만 합니다!!! 명불허전 20세기 최고 남돌 21세기 최고 남돌 입니다! 서로 안좋은 소리도 오가고 하길래 길게 달고갑니다ㅋㅋ
신화♡방탄 퍼팩트맨은 신화가 최고지만 방탄소년단만큼 커버 잘해준 무대없다고 생각해요~ 이거 직캠보니까 마지막에 턴돌고서 윤기님이랑 석진님 살짝 주저앉으시던데 그만큼 온힘을 다해서 췄다는거잔아요~ 다른멤버들도 마찬가지고요~ 정말 동작하나하나에 힘주면서 추는게 느껴지고 신화의 느낌을 최대한 내려고 한게 눈에 보여서 전넘뿌듯했어요^^ 사람들 마다 느끼는게 다르겠지만 가수가 다르니 당연히 느낌은 다를수밖에요~ 진짜 역대급 커버무대에요!!^^ 신화와 방탄의 콜라보 무대를 원합니다...ㅋㅋㅋ 커버 멋지게 잘해주어서 넘고마워요방탄소년단^^ 신화산!!
연말일정이 너무 많아서 며칠만에 외웠던 걸로 알고있어요! 그래서 무대 끝나고 나서주저앉았던 것 같아요 저 때 멤버가 아픈 일도 있었고 윤기분은 아픈 곳 회복된지 얼마 안되서 힘들어하고요 ㅎㅎ 대선배 무대 커버라 엄청 열심히 연습했엇더라구용 신화 명곡이 너무 많지만 단연 퍼펙트맨 꼽아봅니다 체고죠 👍🏻 차애곡 온리원 👍🏻
You want someone to do justice to a song, you give it to bts to do a cover. They really learnt them well and did amazing that night. After 3 years i keep on coming to this cover 💜
oh my gosh Jin and Suga did such a good job! their damcinv has improved so much and they are so amazing at performing now. im sure they worked hard to get here and it's well appreciated. 😌❤
Thank you for posting for its time Shinhwa song and dance was that good that even now there voices are just amazing, but i must say there is something about BTS style and charisma of the of the guys that make it seem effortless in a way. They did exceptionally well covering that song.
You can't ignore the fact that Shinhwa prefers live over lip sync. Shinhwa can both sing and dance at the same time without sounding breathless. There's a reason when an idol group this old is still maintains a stable fandom :)
THIS VIDEO IS LIFE. I love the blended vocals but if I take off one half off my headphones I can hear the separate groups. This is beyond phenomenal and I have no words. Thank you thank you thank you!
최근에 퍼펙트맨 한것도 있는데 굳이 화질 안 좋고 반 이상이 관객을 찍은 무대로 비교해야하나? 그리고 신화가 원조니까 잘하고 애초에 칼군무라는 말 붙었던 최초의 아이돌이 신화임. 그러니까 방탄소년단이 더 낫네,더 잘 추네 이딴 소리 좀 하지 말라고요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ SNS에서 보면 퍼펙트맨 무대 몇주년 이런거 챙기는것도 봤었는데 구 신화창조였던 사람으로써 진짜 기분 나쁘고. 신화 노래 커버했던걸 왜 기념일로 챙겨. 근데 보면 신화 안무들 하나같이 다 진짜 지금 봐도 촌스럽지 않고 개빡쎔. 천재 안무가 이민우; ㄷㄷㄷ;;;
If anyone loves bts for their creative art and how real and funny they are, how they are so clos,also how hard all of them worked to be in a group believe me you will fall in love with shinhwa. This group is the funniest and the most natural with each other, playing all the time cracking jokes and doing random dances and voices . They were the kings of verity shows and that was because they were so funny, try to check that out. Shinhwa members suffered since day one and they pulled each other up, two of them were broke and had no where to go but the rest gathered and gave that member every thing they had to help him on his feet. The leader gave up huge amount of money when they got out of smtowm just to keep the name shinhwa, out of all Koop groups Eric was something else, he gave everything and more for his members silently without saying a word. Plz love them they deserve it.
I'm a BTS and Shinhwa fan, but If you want to compare their performances then you should select a video that is during the time the song was released. I don't think shinhwa from back then dance any less than BTS
I don't think they did either, the camera angle was just bad for the Shinhwa video. Though you could tell they were doing the exact same choreo, down to the removal of the jacket.
SHINWHA JJANG!! They will always be the best at this performance --- especially Hyesung's flying kick hehe -- but I love when hoobae's honor thier sunbae's like this~~ BTS 고마워!
Girl, I don't know how you did it but somehow you got BTS' audio in my left earbud and Shinwa's on my right. Thanks! I love being able to compare the sounds of the performances
Just watch the fan cam, BTS almost collapsed after the performance. That's when I realize how hard Shinhwa had worked out and practised. They can perform several songs like this for fans in one concert. OMG I just know both groups in 2015 and I'm obssessed with SHinhwa after watching them in Shinhwa Broadcast and I'm addicted to their songs.
+Anh Nguyen ..Maybe I'm getting this comment the wrong way.. but are you implying BTS didn't work out or practice enough? 'Cause that's totally wrong. BTS's choreos are exhausting as hell and they are doing perfectly fine in concerts. I saw all the fancams and I didn't see anyone "almost collapsing"..
1기 때부터 신창이었던 사람으로써 이야기 하지만 ㅋㅋ 아무래도 신화가 나이가 이제 있다보니 최근꺼는 여유롭게 센스있게 추는 경우가 많아서.. 예전 무대가 확실히 파워풀 하고 멋있긴 합니다 ㅋㅋ 저 영상때도 우비 입고 주황색 풍선들고 가서 응원법 외쳤던 신창인데 확실히 저때 쩔었죠 신화 ㅠㅠ
아이고... 이런 영상 자체도 별로 보기 안 좋은데 댓글까지... 일단 신화가 퍼펙트맨을 냈을 당시랑 지금이랑은 시대가 다름... 유행하는 안무부터 해서 모든게 달랐단 거임 방탄 안무 빡세다고 신화 안무랑 비교하시는 분들 계신데 신화가 이 시대에 20대 초반으로 나왔으면 어떤 안무를 했을지 모르는거임... 방탄보다 더 빡센 안무를 했을 수도 있고... 그리고 정국이랑 민우가 나온 브로맨스편을 보시면 알겠지만 방탄 석진님께서도 신화 커버무대 안무가 정말 빡세다고 했음^^ 니들이 직접 춰본거 아니면 보이는 것만 대충 눈대중으로 보고 평가질 좀 하지마라... 그리고 비교 영상 무대 카메라의 퀄리티, 영상화질부터 시작해서 옛날 무대캠 중에서도 어쩜 저런 발캠을 가져다가 비교를 할 수 있을까... 이런 걸 갖다가 비교랍시고 내놓으면...차라리 내가 다시 편집해서 올리고 싶은데 비교영상 자체가 안 좋은데 굳이 그래야하나 싶고... 그리고 옛날 아이돌이랑 팬덤들 싸잡아 비난하는 댓글도 봤는데 그런 과도기가 없었다면 지금 아이돌들이 그런 걸 안 겪었을 거 같냐... 1세대 아이돌이 없었으면 그 문화는 고대로 후대 아이돌들의 몫이 되었을 것임... 선배 아이돌들을 존중하고 또 존경해야되는 이유에는 단순히 나이 들었다고 그러는게 아니다...악플러들아... 그 시대의 그룹들이 조금씩 조금씩 해외시장도 개척하기 시작하고 했기 때문에 지금 방탄도 빌보드에 오르고 그러는거지...물론 방탄 노래가 좋아서도 있지만 선배 아이돌들이 개척해놓은 시장을 무시할 수 없다는 거다...아무리 뛰어난 그룹이라도 k-pop이라는 걸 처음 들어본 사람들한테 씨알이나 먹힐 것 같냐... 아이돌들이 괜히 나이 때매 존경하지도 않는 선배들 존경한다고 말하는거 아니다... 내 결론은 일단 이 영상도 내렸으면 좋겠는데 그러진 않을 것 같고 그럴거면 최소한 방탄 욕이나 신화 욕이나 하지말고 아 이땐 선배분들이 이런 무대를 꾸몄었구나 아 후배 아이돌들이 무대를 이렇게 멋있게 커버해줬네 하고 선플 달려면 달고 좋게 감상하고 넘어가라고...제발 좀... 그리고 편집영상 원작자야...신화 무대영상 좀 딴 거로 바꿔라...무슨 의도에서 저런 관중캠발캠 영상을 갖다 붙였는지는 몰라도...
I can't take my eyes off Jimin and stop replaying this clip again and again. His moves are unbelievable... He is the perfect man as he is!!! Plus it's hard to believe this song released 10 years ago. It's still really nice though!
되게 신화는 터프하고 남성적인 이미지면 방탄은 부드럽게 섹시한 느낌..? 신화 영상은 별로본적 없어서 몰랐는데 확실히 신화가 레전드라는 이유를 알것 같고 저 남성적인 이미지에 컨셉을 지금 저렇게 소화하는 그룹을 없을것같고 방탄은 또 방탄 느낌으로 자기곡 처럼 부드럽게 섹시한 느낌으로 커버를 저렇게 잘했다는게 정말 둘다 대단한 가수들 인것 같다...
일단 비교자체가 안되는게 저 안무는 신화 멤버인 이민우가 직접 짠거야...
@@user-fn9kp2we1l 댄스 원작자를 커버댄서가 이긴다고?
난 방탄으로 이곡을 알게됨
아이돌중에 빠박머리로 나온다는거 자체가 진짜 패기 ..
My eyes were trying to focus on each one of the members, but eyes kept on going Jimin. He dances with so much passion.He was perfect in this😍
Ikr! He's not my bias for nothing xd😍
Same he is my bias and he danced so sassily in this dance
Park Jimin has been slaying my heart since I found him last year.
OMG SAME !!! I FEEL LIKE I CHEATED ON MY BIAS JHOPE 😂
same. he's not my bias but he is just so freaking hot in this performance
what a great song. i'm grateful that bts got the chance to perform this and did. great job
I keep repeat this song because of BTS especially Jimin >////<
They're really done a good job to cover super sunbae song
Same🤭
후배가수가 우리 신화 노래커버한다는게 너무 자랑스럽다! 신화부심이라는게 이런거지! 퍼펙트맨이 가지는 터프하고 거친 남성적인 이미지는 신화를 따라올 수 없지! 신화 사랑해♡ 방탄도 잘 커버해줘서 고마워요~~
Jimin's voice is so beautiful tho
신화의 저돌적이고 남성적인 몸짓은 참 명불허전이다. 다들 저때 20대 초반이었는데도 거친 숫컷의 느낌이 살아있어.
I love BTS and Shinhwa
+Carol Nunes Same, lol.
+Carol Nunes When I watch this video I realize that they are somehow very similar. They are both short (sorry ha ha), and extremely sexy and charismatic when it comes to dancing.
*Whisper* I envy them, too
i love jungkook and dongwan ♡♡♡♡
i'm both bts and shinhwa fans now.
Carol Nunes Seeing Jimin take off that jacket was gift for me
저게 14년전 안무여 믿을수가없다 요즘 안무랑 비교해도 꿀리지않아
맞아요
Hamtol Yoon 연습시켜서 만든애들이아니라 춤잘추는애들잡아다 만든걸껄요~몇명빼고 안무에도참여했다고함ㅋㅋ 스엠에서유일하게맘에들었던가수
ㄹㅇ트렌드 앞서감...지금 봐도 촌스럽지가 않아....
J jj 사실 신화중에 춤 전문적으로 잘추는 멤버는 두명뿐이에요ㅋㅋ 나머지멤버들은 노력형입니다... 노력으로 이루어진 결과에요
노력형은 혜성,동완이구요 민우,전진말고도 춤잘춥니다 에릭,앤디도 어릴때부터 팀만들어 춤추고 노래했어요
I always thought Jimin taking off the Jacket was just Jimin being Jimin...I apologize for that now.
same xD
I feel ya :c We were always blaming Jimin for hurting us x''D
HopesBangtan same 😂
Yeah i feel you too 😂
lol same. But Jimin would probably do it anyways
Trying to watch BTS, but can't help but watch Shinhwa. This was a classic back in the days. And just look at wave of Changjo.
오, 그래도 센스있네 방탄 무대 꾸며주신분 신화=주황이라고 매인 조명 등을 다 주황으로 한거?
다른말이필요없네요!
감동그자체네요!지민의모닝커피향기처럼이 나를입덕하게만든
신화의커버무대,진짜쩔었습니다
지민이가 윗옷 벗는게 걍 벗는건줄 알았는데 신화보고 한거구가
I'm in love with this song T.T
+Nora KPOPaholic omg yeah i know how you feel me too!! its like these days im getting more interested in old kpop songs!!!
+Nora KPOPaholic omg yeah i know how you feel me too!! its like these days im getting more interested in old kpop songs!!!
+DancE LoVe YOLO Exactly thanks for understand my feelings T.T
+Nora KPOPaholic omg same
방탄이들 종종 신화 커버 춰 줘서 고맙네요 ㅋ.ㅋ
one question:
did jungkook ate the freaking shinhwa cd just to have the same voice as the shinhwa's guy??
im impressed with this boy, seriously his talent is very on point.. im in awe
+eccentric jeon he can imitate voice and singing style very well. I remember the bit of HOT song he did I was so impressed!
eat the CD
😄😃 died right there
also watch him do Zion T
+eccentric jeon He is the Golden Maknae after all hahaha
I was there and they lips synced
+meidi sore I know they lip synced but even if it was pre-recorded, it was still an amazing performance.
울오빠들 날라다니던 시절 ~~ 신화 세상이던 시절~~그립기도 하여라!!!!!!원조는 역시 달라🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡으른섹시로 빨리 컴백해주세용!!기다릴께요 ^^
bangtan shd do more shinhwa covers. it really suits them
they did another cover in 2014 I think. u can search it, just search something like "BTS covers shinghwa "This Love" That dance was also amazing!
+Fin Perrett i watch it before. every time i watch it i die inside
+SuperVengency x32393994 omg, i rlly need more shinwa covers ;;
+SuperVengency YASSSSSSSSS... Shinhwa's Sniper.....
agree 😂
change the earphones and mess up your brain😄😄 It feels like shinhwa has bangtan's voices and vice versa 😄
omg true hahahah
IKRRRRR
Lillyz omg this proves how important it is to have the right one in each ear
SO THIS IS WHY I WAS SO CONFUSED, I HAD MY EARPHONES THE WRONG WAY ROUND AT FIRST THEN I SAW THIS COMMENT and omg im so dumb
Lillyz you right
jungkook sounds just like him .
Beauty standards have changed so much ever since it's hard to believe BTS and Shinhwa are the same age in those videos...
loved both performances btw
Carol Azevedo Omg really??? thats crazy!!
Kpop Lover yeah it's crazy. Late 90's and early 2000's had a more mature and 'manly' beauty ideal. They even had moustache in some of the concepts (and a lot less make up on). Kpop fans these days look for a more cute young image.
Carol Azevedo Oh wow thats so interesting how things have changed since then!!
And Shinwa have the "bad boys" image. Just imagine it if their stylist put make up on them, they'll really hate it lolol I my self cant imagine them wearing make up or have the sweet image XD
I would say that Shinhwa were a couple years older (average around 23 yo), and by that time they were already titled beast-dol anyway hahaha (they left the cutesy image since their 2nd album), so can't really blame them for looking like that ;)
Both groups are good, but BTS has their own style...BTS is sharp, and Shinhwa is a little soft at dancing
BUT LOVE BOTH!!💖
you need to wacth more shinhwa
I agree with the precious reply you really need to watch more shinhwa
+Sehixneeo Sensen Camera showed very little of Shinhwa, watch 'Wild eyes' for a completely on point dance
+Sehixneeo Sensen Bangtan boys have longer legs but they need to work out more and practise more to be professional and not to collapse after several songs like this. They are hot and can be perfect, I like them but this song needs a little more flexible. Just work harder, they can be perfect on every single point.
yeah, that's right. BTS is the new generation of KPOP, I really hope they can stand out in tons of groups nowadays
JIMINS VOICE GIVES ME LIFE
오 신창인데 방탄소년단 분들도 잘하네여ㅇㅅㅇ!
Shinhwa is a legendary group (which I knew them a long time ago like bigbang and suju and 2pm) BUT, BTS is my favorite of all boy groups, ever, I always listen to them everyday.
i still can't stop rewatching BTS's performance of this song
I think they were phenomenal. i checked out Shinhwa's original song after seeing BTS's and i think BTS did it justice and more.
they were really good... vocals and choreo. i thought BTS were amazing.
i hope Shinhwa and their fans liked it
+Maymuna Kabir Many Shinhwa fans, including myself, loved it! We thought it was the best Shinhwa cover done so far. BUT BTS did not do better than Shinhwa. I'm sorry but I gotta say the truth. Shinhwa has better feels when they dance which is solemnly owned by themselves so I don't blame BTS for not being able to follow that. Vocal wise Shinhwa members' voices fit better with each other as well as the song itself. Especially the beginning part (Dongwan's part) it gets a little more obvious ans Dongwan has a very unique and strong base voice.
+Carla Anderson
Yeah, Dongwan quite easily has one of the most powerful voices in Kpop. He has a power ballad voice, with strong vocal chords.
+Carla Anderson Agree, their voices suit this type of song much better, even Hyesung's vocals sound unique.
OMG WHERE DO I LOOK
MY EYES KEEP WANDERING LEFT AND RIGHT
신화님들 방탄이들 엄마아빠 비키트 유튜버 가요대전 엠카들아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ내가이거볼수있게해줘세ㅣ고맢ㅂ다요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ신화 이노래만들어주셔서 감자함니다..(크엉)
멋지다 방탄!! 활동하는걸 보면서 항상느끼는건데 실력차가 분명있음에 불구하고 각자 튀지않고 딱딱맞듯이 칼군무같구낭 이게 바로 팀이란거야ㅑ 앞으로도 힘내자
지민이♡ 방탄 신화 둘다 멋져요
The parts that Jimin got, I don't know the name of the guy from shinhwa, go well together. Their voices are so alike I'm honestly shocked
seriously every shinhwa member has a really great stage presence and they were manly even back in their early 20s wow.
Beauty standards were much different before, women preferred men huskier
I think it's safe to say BTS did shinwa's song justice
+Miss Kpop Agree. BTS nailed this cover. The powerful dancing style suits them so well.
lol no
+meidi sore lol, thy did great,.
+meidi sore your salty about it it's ok people usually are when a group does great but as bts is getting bigger they remain unbothered as even though this was just a cover it already has nearly 7M views
i cannot imagine the amount of time, effort, and hard work BTS put into being as precise as possible, it's just so good and exact and beautiful i'm in awe
Well they did get help from Shinhwas choreographer with the dance
omg i remember youtube wasn't big that time i used to torrent and download this shinhwa, rain, hot and fly to the sky videos and burn them into a CD. the struggles were real.
haha woow
You reminded me of how much of a struggle watching dramas was!
At the time i didn't know about kpop and i only watched full house ^^ good times
HAHAHA that was real tough!! I remember those times as well. Kids these days have it pretty lucky unlike us... xDD
Yes. views and likes were not counted and didn't matter before, and updates from your fave groups were limited. You enjoy their material after the difficulty of finding them.It was like treasure. Fans these days enjoy fandom wars more LOL.
I know this is a 2 year old video, but I'm right here with you...I'm currently uploading those vids I had gathered on my channel right now, because I still got all these videos collected on DVDs ^^;; and youtube wasn't only not big, it was non-existent!
All perfect men
제가 한창 신창일때는 커버한것중엔 낫지만 그래도 별로네 생각했는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 거의 반 아미 되고보니 그래도 현존 아이들중 신화를 잇는 애들은 얘들밖에 없단 생각이 ㅋㅋ 1세대 돌부터 시작해서 이때까지도 이민우의 간지를 따라갈 자는 없는게 확실한데요(여기저기 춤선생으로 나오는걸로 짐작은 하시겠지만 저딴영상은 이민우의1/100도 못담음) 방탄 지민군 또한 그누구도 따라할 수 없는 독보적 춤선이 있어요! 민우오빠는 남성적인 간지면 지민군은 여성적(?)인 간지 ㅋㅋ 둘다 아이돌중에 탑오브 탑 댄서입니다!! 그리고 어린 아미여러분들 신화는 퍼펙트맨보다 x99999 배쯤 간지나는 안무와 노래를 보유하고 있습니다. 방탄 봄날만 알고 쩔어/불타/not today/상남자/런/아니쥬 모르는사람 답답하듯이 신화는 펄팩맨 말고도 only one/all your dreams/wild eyes/yo/T.O.P 정도가 90년대-01 노래지만 현존 방탄노래 분위기 나요 추천드립니다. brand new / this love 워낙
레전드라 아실거라 생각돼서ㅋ 신창과 아미는 친하게 지내야만 합니다!!! 명불허전 20세기 최고 남돌 21세기 최고 남돌 입니다! 서로 안좋은 소리도 오가고 하길래 길게 달고갑니다ㅋㅋ
퍼펙맨보다 only one 커버했으면 더 대박이었을 듯
김동완이랑 이민우도 인정했죠!!
Why dont bts stylists choose the same outfit like shinhwa's ? Im waiting for sleeveless boys
Agreed!!!!!! 😍😂
신화콘서트에서 부른거 보세요~~ 찾아보면 많은데 왜 저 영상을.....;;;
박선영 인정합니다!!!
콘서트가 훨씬 낫죠!!
다시봐도 좋습니다 선배 레전드와 후배 레전드의 무대!! 너무 멋지고 좋아요 ~!!!!!!!
신화♡방탄
퍼팩트맨은 신화가 최고지만
방탄소년단만큼 커버 잘해준 무대없다고 생각해요~ 이거 직캠보니까 마지막에 턴돌고서
윤기님이랑 석진님 살짝 주저앉으시던데 그만큼 온힘을
다해서 췄다는거잔아요~ 다른멤버들도 마찬가지고요~ 정말 동작하나하나에
힘주면서 추는게 느껴지고 신화의
느낌을 최대한 내려고 한게 눈에
보여서 전넘뿌듯했어요^^ 사람들
마다 느끼는게 다르겠지만 가수가
다르니 당연히 느낌은 다를수밖에요~
진짜 역대급 커버무대에요!!^^
신화와 방탄의 콜라보 무대를 원합니다...ㅋㅋㅋ
커버 멋지게 잘해주어서 넘고마워요방탄소년단^^
신화산!!
연말일정이 너무 많아서 며칠만에 외웠던 걸로 알고있어요! 그래서 무대 끝나고 나서주저앉았던 것 같아요
저 때 멤버가 아픈 일도 있었고 윤기분은 아픈 곳 회복된지 얼마 안되서 힘들어하고요 ㅎㅎ 대선배 무대 커버라 엄청 열심히 연습했엇더라구용
신화 명곡이 너무 많지만 단연 퍼펙트맨 꼽아봅니다 체고죠 👍🏻 차애곡 온리원 👍🏻
You want someone to do justice to a song, you give it to bts to do a cover. They really learnt them well and did amazing that night. After 3 years i keep on coming to this cover 💜
both groups are beautiful
I was trying to read the comments- but I literally couldn't tear my eyes away from Jimin
ONE OF THEIR BEST COVERS! ~
agree
신화 칼군무 멋짐 ㅎㅎ👍
oh my gosh Jin and Suga did such a good job! their damcinv has improved so much and they are so amazing at performing now. im sure they worked hard to get here and it's well appreciated. 😌❤
저때 신화 엄청좋아했눈데....ㅠㅠ
신화6명이서제일잘함신화창조화이팅
How you just gone slay the hell out of someone else's choreography like that BTS? Dang these boys and their disrespect, lmao!
wonderful song and amazing cover. Much respect for Shinhwa and BTS for the great cover. 👏👏
신창아미로서 그저 훈훈하고 기분좋네요~~ㅎㅎ
Thank you for posting for its time Shinhwa song and dance was that good that even now there voices are just amazing, but i must say there is something about BTS style and charisma of the of the guys that make it seem effortless in a way. They did exceptionally well covering that song.
when I was listening in my earphones. at my left ear im hearing bts's sings. and my right ears was the shinhwa's sing
와...진자 멋있어요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 나중에 선배님들이랑 듀엣도 하고 그랬음 좋겠네요 방탄 가문의 영광...♡
wow man they all are so amazing, jimin is just killing me with his dance moves too
THEYRE VOICE IS FREAKING SAME BUT AWSOME 😍
Shinhwa were my first love in Kpop and seeing my current love perform this song is heaven. They did such a great job! 👏❤️🙃
You can't ignore the fact that Shinhwa prefers live over lip sync. Shinhwa can both sing and dance at the same time without sounding breathless. There's a reason when an idol group this old is still maintains a stable fandom :)
No one can beat 20-year-old ShinHwa. Legend is always legend 🍊
아이고... 주황공주, 아미... 감격입니다ㅠㅠ 신화산! 보라해♥
난 너무 고마운게 이좋은 노래를 신화가 불러줬기에 방탄도 부를수 있었던거잖아요 애들 꿈이 신화처럼 오래오래 노래하는건데 그냥 여러가지로 좋아요..
I'm like... Jan 1 2016...? Oh that's pretty recent.. Then I realise it's already 2017 -.-
lol wakeup
Oh and now im watching this in jan 2018 lmao
THIS VIDEO IS LIFE. I love the blended vocals but if I take off one half off my headphones I can hear the separate groups. This is beyond phenomenal and I have no words. Thank you thank you thank you!
+minnie1247 thanks for watching~
지민이 진짜 와...진짜
최근에 퍼펙트맨 한것도 있는데 굳이 화질 안 좋고 반 이상이 관객을 찍은 무대로 비교해야하나?
그리고 신화가 원조니까 잘하고 애초에 칼군무라는 말 붙었던 최초의 아이돌이 신화임.
그러니까 방탄소년단이 더 낫네,더 잘 추네 이딴 소리 좀 하지 말라고요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
SNS에서 보면 퍼펙트맨 무대 몇주년 이런거 챙기는것도 봤었는데 구 신화창조였던 사람으로써 진짜 기분 나쁘고.
신화 노래 커버했던걸 왜 기념일로 챙겨.
근데 보면 신화 안무들 하나같이 다 진짜 지금 봐도 촌스럽지 않고 개빡쎔.
천재 안무가 이민우; ㄷㄷㄷ;;;
As a kpop fan for over 10 years... and with shinhwa being THE group that got me into kpop
진짜 너무 죠타..넘 잘어울려..ㅜ 감사해여😍방타니들에게 이곡을 맡겨(?)주셔셬ㅋㅋ
우리 신화 짱♥
If anyone loves bts for their creative art and how real and funny they are, how they are so clos,also how hard all of them worked to be in a group believe me you will fall in love with shinhwa. This group is the funniest and the most natural with each other, playing all the time cracking jokes and doing random dances and voices . They were the kings of verity shows and that was because they were so funny, try to check that out. Shinhwa members suffered since day one and they pulled each other up, two of them were broke and had no where to go but the rest gathered and gave that member every thing they had to help him on his feet. The leader gave up huge amount of money when they got out of smtowm just to keep the name shinhwa, out of all Koop groups Eric was something else, he gave everything and more for his members silently without saying a word. Plz love them they deserve it.
I fell in love on both versions.
Wow Jimin
Did you see Kim Dongwan's reaction to this on 'I Live Alone' he looked so happy aww
I'm a BTS and Shinhwa fan, but If you want to compare their performances then you should select a video that is during the time the song was released. I don't think shinhwa from back then dance any less than BTS
I don't think they did either, the camera angle was just bad for the Shinhwa video. Though you could tell they were doing the exact same choreo, down to the removal of the jacket.
SHINWHA JJANG!! They will always be the best at this performance --- especially Hyesung's flying kick hehe -- but I love when hoobae's honor thier sunbae's like this~~ BTS 고마워!
both of them represent for 2 generations. Great performances!
Sinhwa💕BTS. JJang!! 신화 98년도에 데뷔.. 울 아기 때 네..ㅎㅎ 동완 오빠랑 정국이 목소리 넘 비슷하고 좋네. . 지민이도 춤 멋지고. . 다들 멋져요~~^^
aaaaaa bts omg jimin❇😉❤🙈😍
I am soo proud for our boys!! BTS DID GREAT AS ALWAYS!!❤ Shinhwa are LEGEND and I love them as well! May our boys be the LEGEND of this generation ;)
This is great!! thank you haha ^^ Things learned: Camera Work has improved over the years
This is so cute. It just proves bts is like the second best generation of kpop.
the synchronization is real.
This is how a cover should be, on point/beat with the original artist.
BTS did a great job. Shinwa is proud!!
By the way the camera work back then where also like crap 😂
+Ceyda Efe Good that they "upgraded" a little bit xD
that cracked me up XD LOL
I know can barley see 😄😃
Ceyda Efe one thing doesn't change for sure😅
M A R U "same camera guy"
Me:thinks of the camera guy in As I Told You
Ohhh sheeeiiittt
daym both sang it perfectly
저렇게 격렬하게 추는데도 라이브했다는 사실~~방탄이들도 참 다이나믹하게 잘추네요~
신화 춤 보고 싶은데...발카 실화냐
래하나 ㅇㅈ mbc가 더잘잡음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ요....
Girl, I don't know how you did it but somehow you got BTS' audio in my left earbud and Shinwa's on my right. Thanks! I love being able to compare the sounds of the performances
+tillydancer101 yessss I thought that might have a nice effect! thanks for watching ^^
They all so amazing 😍😍😍...
I've realised how amazing the camera work has gotten over the years. Yay.
Just watch the fan cam, BTS almost collapsed after the performance. That's when I realize how hard Shinhwa had worked out and practised. They can perform several songs like this for fans in one concert. OMG I just know both groups in 2015 and I'm obssessed with SHinhwa after watching them in Shinhwa Broadcast and I'm addicted to their songs.
+Anh Nguyen
..Maybe I'm getting this comment the wrong way.. but are you implying BTS didn't work out or practice enough? 'Cause that's totally wrong.
BTS's choreos are exhausting as hell and they are doing perfectly fine in concerts.
I saw all the fancams and I didn't see anyone "almost collapsing"..
+Lilly Bus no, just need a little more, they r almost there, but they need to be a little harder so they wont be exhausted
I really like BTS Lilly, I watched the performances many many times. All I want is to see them improve and be No1 in the future
Anh Nguyen give me the link then.. cause I don't see it
what link?
i really like this song, most Jimin parts ever. I really in love with his voice
so much respect for shinhwa, i'm so glad bangtan did this! too amazing
thanks for this video!
Regardless of comparing the two groups, they both are talented men and we should be grateful for these beautiful performances.
Thanks for making this comparison video...^^
아니 신화 최근껏도 많은데 궂이ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ᄋ몽키매직 제말이요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 유튜브에 펄펙맨 치면 딱 뜨는 레전 영상도 있는데 굳이 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1기 때부터 신창이었던 사람으로써 이야기 하지만 ㅋㅋ 아무래도 신화가 나이가 이제 있다보니 최근꺼는 여유롭게 센스있게 추는 경우가 많아서.. 예전 무대가 확실히 파워풀 하고 멋있긴 합니다 ㅋㅋ 저 영상때도 우비 입고 주황색 풍선들고 가서 응원법 외쳤던 신창인데 확실히 저때 쩔었죠 신화 ㅠㅠ
아이고... 이런 영상 자체도 별로 보기 안 좋은데 댓글까지...
일단 신화가 퍼펙트맨을 냈을 당시랑 지금이랑은 시대가 다름... 유행하는 안무부터 해서 모든게 달랐단 거임 방탄 안무 빡세다고 신화 안무랑 비교하시는 분들 계신데 신화가 이 시대에 20대 초반으로 나왔으면 어떤 안무를 했을지 모르는거임... 방탄보다 더 빡센 안무를 했을 수도 있고... 그리고 정국이랑 민우가 나온 브로맨스편을 보시면 알겠지만 방탄 석진님께서도 신화 커버무대 안무가 정말 빡세다고 했음^^ 니들이 직접 춰본거 아니면 보이는 것만 대충 눈대중으로 보고 평가질 좀 하지마라... 그리고 비교 영상 무대 카메라의 퀄리티, 영상화질부터 시작해서 옛날 무대캠 중에서도 어쩜 저런 발캠을 가져다가 비교를 할 수 있을까... 이런 걸 갖다가 비교랍시고 내놓으면...차라리 내가 다시 편집해서 올리고 싶은데 비교영상 자체가 안 좋은데 굳이 그래야하나 싶고... 그리고 옛날 아이돌이랑 팬덤들 싸잡아 비난하는 댓글도 봤는데 그런 과도기가 없었다면 지금 아이돌들이 그런 걸 안 겪었을 거 같냐... 1세대 아이돌이 없었으면 그 문화는 고대로 후대 아이돌들의 몫이 되었을 것임... 선배 아이돌들을 존중하고 또 존경해야되는 이유에는 단순히 나이 들었다고 그러는게 아니다...악플러들아... 그 시대의 그룹들이 조금씩 조금씩 해외시장도 개척하기 시작하고 했기 때문에 지금 방탄도 빌보드에 오르고 그러는거지...물론 방탄 노래가 좋아서도 있지만 선배 아이돌들이 개척해놓은 시장을 무시할 수 없다는 거다...아무리 뛰어난 그룹이라도 k-pop이라는 걸 처음 들어본 사람들한테 씨알이나 먹힐 것 같냐... 아이돌들이 괜히 나이 때매 존경하지도 않는 선배들 존경한다고 말하는거 아니다...
내 결론은 일단 이 영상도 내렸으면 좋겠는데 그러진 않을 것 같고 그럴거면 최소한 방탄 욕이나 신화 욕이나 하지말고 아 이땐 선배분들이 이런 무대를 꾸몄었구나 아 후배 아이돌들이 무대를 이렇게 멋있게 커버해줬네 하고 선플 달려면 달고 좋게 감상하고 넘어가라고...제발 좀... 그리고 편집영상 원작자야...신화 무대영상 좀 딴 거로 바꿔라...무슨 의도에서 저런 관중캠발캠 영상을 갖다 붙였는지는 몰라도...
옳소😀😍🧡🧡💜💜
I like BTS performance the all members was very strength and very energetic person xpecial jimin singing so good and expression was very very good
I can't take my eyes off Jimin and stop replaying this clip again and again. His moves are unbelievable... He is the perfect man as he is!!! Plus it's hard to believe this song released 10 years ago. It's still really nice though!