(2.7) Which Honkai: Star Rail character is the REDDEST FLAG?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 янв 2025

Комментарии • 96

  • @Sjusbsuxgsjaj
    @Sjusbsuxgsjaj 20 дней назад +30

    Sparkle is definitely Green Flag. She's the only person who didn't lie in entire Penacony story.

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +12

      i dunno, i'd rather have someone who may omit details or lie for an understandable reason than someone with no moral compass who could decide to turn on me on a random tuesday

    • @redvelvetisbetter.1377
      @redvelvetisbetter.1377 20 дней назад +2

      ​@kimcchik acheron and blackswans lies were 100% justifed

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +2

      @redvelvetisbetter.1377 true! although tbh, i don't even remember black swan ever actually LYING to us? the only instance i see people bring up occasionally is her deal with aventurine, but she was never obligated to tell TB about any of that to begin with

    • @GabrielMichaelDels
      @GabrielMichaelDels 19 дней назад +2

      Are you a History Fictionologist?

    • @lennyfacebutnotreally3198
      @lennyfacebutnotreally3198 19 дней назад

      "Didn't lie" the first thing she did was lie about who she is.

  • @zachryel
    @zachryel 20 дней назад +15

    All shall support the greenest of flags sparkle

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +2

      @@zachryel INSANE PEOPLE EVERYWHERE I GO

    • @zachryel
      @zachryel 20 дней назад

      red is green and green is green🤌

  • @mateusrodrigues7983
    @mateusrodrigues7983 20 дней назад +16

    It looks like Sparkle is using her alt accounts in chat e.e

    • @graw19
      @graw19 20 дней назад +1

      yeah. insane

  • @sizaak
    @sizaak 20 дней назад +11

    I just want to add to the comments saying sparkle less than red flag, cause I feel like she acts like she's gonna do insane stuff but really she just likes messing with people and keeping people from being complacent. At the end of the last story she was in, the giant thing she did ended up actually being to help someone; yeah it looked like it was gonna be mass murder but it never actually was gonna be and never actually would be.
    (idk maybe I'm just coping cause she's hot)

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +4

      i don't think she'd be the type to just go on a killing spree at random or something, but if what she considers "fun" at any point should involve murder/death, whether direct or indirect, she wouldn't mind in the least.
      and even disregarding that, she doesn't exactly follow rules or any moral compass, so unless she considers you interesting to be around, she either couldn't care less about your suffering or might even try to add to it to get some entertainment out of it
      but i mean, hey...nothing wrong with a little copium!

  • @kirbymasterdeluxe
    @kirbymasterdeluxe 20 дней назад +3

    I really love Firefly. If it were just her being her, greenest of flags. But remember that you have to wrestle with the fact that she will die before most of your other friends. Also… criminal.

  • @ignis842
    @ignis842 18 дней назад +2

    For Rappa, I sorta get what you're talking about with her energy but I feel like she's more so in the yellow range because of how she's the way she is due to being a victim of circumstances out of her control and she's shown to be caring about stuff in her weird way and has her serious moments as well which i feel like one could click with if you're more sympathetic to her story while in a relationship, but for you I'd argue more for orange with this knowledge in mind
    For Hanya, I'd say orange because she's got a lot of baggage regarding her and Xueyi's story
    Himeko, I'd say the coffee thing is more a lime deal since she'd probably be understanding if nothing else if you refuse her. Also I'll cook for us both ;)

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  17 дней назад +1

      @ignis842 rappa is only a red flag for me in terms of a ROMANTIC relationship, really. i think as a friend/sister figure, while she'd still be exhausting, i wouldn't mind it as much!
      i don't know much about hanya, but the trauma aspect has been brought up a few times - can't judge how well i'd be able to handle that if i haven't looked into it myself yet, though!
      and regarding himeko, it's moreso the idea of dating someone who loves coffee to THAT extent, i'm just a worrywart so i'd prefer my partner to try and keep healthier habits/preferences if they can help it lmao

  • @lo4tr
    @lo4tr 20 дней назад +4

    I pretty heavily disagree with Galagher being in green. He might have been ultimately on the 'good' side of Penacony, but he is also one of the foremost manipulators.

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      understandable! i get why he acted the way he did & to me, his reasons & actual motivations mattered more than the few tricks he played for his goals

  • @f4h5s38
    @f4h5s38 18 дней назад +1

    11:42 You are right about her being busy with work but you make a horrible mistake when you compare her with Fu Xuan(Hanya is literally a prisoner and never will be out of it)

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  18 дней назад

      as i said, i'm not too familiar with her character so that was all i had to go off

  • @pancakethepikachu6193
    @pancakethepikachu6193 20 дней назад +5

    BRONYA AND SEELE BEING IN RED FLAG BECAUSE THE OTHER EXISTS IS SO FUNNY AND TRUE AAAAHAHAHAHA also the quote "the lesbians and Gepard" took me the FUCK out-
    I think in general the fact that you took into account the ships was the best part for me cuz that never failed to get a laugh, fave parts was ranking the Trailblazers ("one creature and feature, featuring creature-") and absolutely when ranking Robin and Welt into green flag- they deserve that placement

    • @Matthew-je9iu
      @Matthew-je9iu 19 дней назад

      its tough being a male bronya fan 😔

  • @TheNoobHunter._
    @TheNoobHunter._ 20 дней назад +2

    *likes* "im not a fan of Herta" *removes like* *keeps watching*

  • @f4h5s38
    @f4h5s38 18 дней назад

    9:18 She is reserved by King Yuan

  • @ŸYenØôô
    @ŸYenØôô 20 дней назад +4

    Nah sparkle is objectivly the biggest green flag ever fr 🔥

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @ŸYenØôô get well soon... /j

  • @Tyrique-uq3hh
    @Tyrique-uq3hh 17 дней назад

    Its doesn’t matter if my queen Jingliu is a red flag she’s still the best

  • @SaltedBonez
    @SaltedBonez 19 дней назад

    For the lore behind them, both Hanya and Xueyi can’t be anywhere below orange flag. They may not harm you but neither of them are available physically, emotionally or any other way plausible

  • @Imre1213
    @Imre1213 20 дней назад

    First time watching a video of yours, was fun. Thanks a lot! I'll try to check out when you're live. The list is also pretty accurate I think, with a few parts I would disagee on :D
    Firefly - well, the only apparent problem I see is her life expectancy with her illness. Otherwise I'd say green flag - you get Sam for free in this relationship xD
    Galagher - a history fictionologist. A person(?) whose entire purpose is to spin up lies?! Thats like super red flag, I could never trust anything this man said to me q.q
    I love how hard you tried to move a literal gambler on life out of the red flags xD And its funny to see that like half of the HSR cast are either workaholics or have a bounty on them.
    March - wow poor March got absolutely gutted by you D:
    And Robin depends on if you can handle all the showbizz stuff. Just look at Taylor Swifts Era Tour and imagine that hellish shedule on a galaxy level :D
    Sunday would be absolutely crimson if it wasn't for his current redemption arc that he's having. He's the kind if person that would force you to change if he thinks its for your best, even if you wouldn't want that. Like even with his love for Robin he would force Order on her because he thinks its the best for her.
    And I absolutely love Seele + Bronja and Acheron + BS being next in the same :D Oh and the differenece in each tier is funny - Boothill an alcoholic with a bounty on its head is just as bad as Himeko that has a coffee addiction and can't cook??? Talk about double standards xDD

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +1

      HEYYY thank you so much, glad you liked it!!
      - if firefly wasn't a stellaron hunter, i'd probably be fine with her honestly. the terminal illness is definitely an understandable point, though i think i personally wouldn't let it stop me
      - i did go with gallagher the "character," who all things considered, was very much a decent guy. the fictionologist behind him, though....yeah that one would probably be a no LMAO
      - i do actually like march DFKJGHF she'd just be way too exhausting for me irl
      - for robin that's actually a very fair point, and with that in mind, i would probbaly move her down to lime or yellow. personality-wise she's SO lovely, though!
      - i'd say pre-2.3 sunday would definitely have been another matter yeah, man's been indoctrinated to hell and back, but with him recognizing his wrongs & actively trying to do better, he's just a little guy!
      and for sure, my reasonings for some of these can definitely be considered very "trivial" in comparison to others LMAO

  • @nogard0497
    @nogard0497 18 дней назад

    Argenti: “he’s a handsome and gentle man” oh so he is a green flag
    “He’s also a theatre kid” oh yeah that’s a big red flag 😂

  • @f4h5s38
    @f4h5s38 18 дней назад

    18:34 Guinaifen * 100 She is a galaxy level music star
    She will be half a year on concert

  • @f4h5s38
    @f4h5s38 18 дней назад

    22:46 Grampa has a family (Don't say "it's different" because then we have to reconsider a bunch of other characters)
    - has PTSD
    I know that video is purely subjective but i just can't stand when a criterias are ignored when things got compared
    Unless if you say that you are bias about it

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  17 дней назад

      @f4h5s38 once again pointing out that i haven't played hi3rd & am going solely based on what we see of welt in THIS game!
      and the ptsd would honestly be the least of my worries, i wouldn't deduct points for trauma

  • @TommyTwoThings
    @TommyTwoThings 20 дней назад +1

    red is my favorite color so I see no problem

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @@TommyTwoThings u know what, based

  • @Decodex25
    @Decodex25 16 дней назад

    I might be into red flags

  • @kyuuketsukikun420
    @kyuuketsukikun420 19 дней назад

    i argue that boothill is not an alcoholic as he only takes 1 sip from every drink he orders. as seen in the slumbernana arc

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @kyuuketsukikun420 fair point - full alcoholic might be leaning more into my personal interpretation, but he does seem to "enjoy" it more than the average person at least from what i gather, which wouldn't sit right with me either way

  • @waggashi
    @waggashi 19 дней назад

    sparkle is the most greenest flag out of all the green flags

  • @KingEdgeLord
    @KingEdgeLord 11 дней назад +1

    Kim i love your voice very much it's super cute on you

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  11 дней назад

      @@KingEdgeLord thank you!

  • @x-0hero4
    @x-0hero4 20 дней назад

    Its kinda funny that welt yang, the only canonically married person male in all of hoyoverse is a green flag, yeah in hi3 he has a wife and a kid, and yet here he is, in a mission to fight a god and he did not warn anyone before jumping to the express, and it's not like this is the first time that something like this happens, the first time that you see him in hi3 he was trapped in an alternate dimension for like 2 years, all because he decided to fight a god killer, my point being that this man is not a green flag, because of his tendency for going disappearing for multiple years at a time without telling anyone, he is not a green flag he is yellow at least,
    that being said he is still one of my favorite characters ever, hes just so cool

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      i haven't played hi3 and only know bits and pieces of his story in that game - i do know that he had a kid & heard that he was married (though i also heard some people say that he wasn't? no clue about that one but it doesn't really matter methinks), though. but that's why i only judged based on what we've seen of him in HSR so far

    • @x-0hero4
      @x-0hero4 19 дней назад

      @kimcch it is HIGHLY implied that he is married, it's basically confirmed, tho hoyoverse won't fully confirm it because gacha

    • @x-0hero4
      @x-0hero4 19 дней назад

      @kimcch also that's completely fair, I just think it's kinda funny

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @@x-0hero4 ohhh one of those situations, i see i see

    • @EdaCupcakey
      @EdaCupcakey 19 дней назад

      @kimcch oh no that guy is just bullshitting. Welt Yang is not married. The girl they always assumed he is married to literally RAISED him since he was 8 yrs old and she was 22 yrs old jfc. It was never implied, they just lack reading comprehension. (not to mention welt himself sees her (Tesla and Einstein) as his older sisters and mentors. He never sees Tesla as love interest since he literally calls her as "2nd guardian" and not "wife"

  • @twilightwolf6248
    @twilightwolf6248 19 дней назад +1

    Bronya and Seele are not Red flags wtf, you even read Bronya's dialogue about her dream to leave Belobog and travel the universe with the Trailblazer?

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад +1

      @twilightwolf6248 first of all, no need to sound so hostile. second, both bronya and seele's rankings were for lighthearted/partially joking reasons, which i thought i made obvious enough

    • @twilightwolf6248
      @twilightwolf6248 19 дней назад +1

      @kimcch I wasn't being hostile I was just confused.

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  17 дней назад

      @twilightwolf6248 apologies then, it's hard to accurately judge tones over text sometimes :')

  • @Sali_Krab
    @Sali_Krab 20 дней назад

    To be fair, i think every stellaron hunters should be at least in orange category. The reason for it is you don't know when you will be in Elio's script. You can be their demise, fear, game over if you become a sacrifice for better future. And worst part they can't do anything about it, cuz fighting with Elio's prophecy is useless (Firefly tried to bend her fate but she died 3 times, like she should have been in her script)

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +1

      correct me if i'm wrong, but doesn't elio's script contain more than just the stellaron hunters' destinies? in which case it shouldn't matter too much whether your name is in there and connected to THEIR fate or anyone else's, if you know what i mean
      and while it's true firefly wasn't able to break free from the script, her three "deaths" were technically not real deaths, so there might be some leeway, possibly

    • @Sali_Krab
      @Sali_Krab 20 дней назад

      Unfortunately, we don't know much about scripts, other than it's plan to play out in trailblazer's favour to beat Nannok as& in the war. But I thought about their goals, their reasons they became hunters in a first place. And being too close with them, you will be inevitably involved with their destiny and you're not fully aware of what happens next. Heck, you don't even know you're in script in a first place and what's your role there
      Maybe, there's a loophole but chances are lower if you don't pull a few strings for your survival, just like how Sparkle helped Firefly's third death. It was special case, Sparkle was hired by Reca or Elio themself, so it's pretty dangerous to stick with them

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +1

      @Sali_Krab hmmm, true.....to be fair, even without taking elio into account, being with any of them would already be risky/not *great* for various reasons fjdjshd

    • @Sali_Krab
      @Sali_Krab 20 дней назад

      Also Bladie is marastruck and without any controlling ability or pocket sized Kafka, your cooked🫠

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @@Sali_Krab POCKET SIZED KAFKA HELP but true....sadge

  • @Dragon_Song1
    @Dragon_Song1 19 дней назад

    Screwllum is hands down a dark green flag.
    It’s interesting to see how work based character rise up the ranks of flags. As a guy working women don’t really redden the flag for me. As long as they make a little time in the week for me. But maybe it’s just the male instinct to help support their partner when they get back from a heavy shift. But it’s interesting to see how some people aren’t a fan of work heavy partners.

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @Dragon_Song1 screwllum would probably be lime for me, mainly because of his VERY rational & analytical thinking which might spark some disagreements every now and then...honestly, i should've included some of the non-playables...
      and most characters that are in the higher tiers ARE the ones that i get the impression wouldn't take time off for themselves, whether its because they can't or just dont want to. i get your argument, though!

    • @Dragon_Song1
      @Dragon_Song1 19 дней назад

      Btw for me Serval is interesting, she is such an easy going vibe of a women. Like I would like to hang out with her “as friends” but. I don’t think I would put her in green. It’s lime for me.
      She has been in other relationships canonically in game. And she seems like the type to go to home base in those relationships. Even with that, she just feels like someone who hasn’t figured out what she is looking for when it comes to settling down. She just gives off vibes that dating isn’t what she needs right now in her life. Now being “with” other partners before is an orange flag normally for me. But it’s not a deal breaker. But Serval idk what I trying to say. She is interesting now that I’m thinking of flags. 🤔

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @@Dragon_Song1 i think it'd be totally fine to date someone with more experience, depending on how and WHY the past relationships ended....but i think i get where you're coming from!

    • @Dragon_Song1
      @Dragon_Song1 19 дней назад

      @kimcch yeah i totally agree. I should have specified that it an experienced partner that has past relationships raises questions that need answers. And depending on the answers we would move forward. So do you think yellow or orange is the flag for serious question that need answers lay?

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @Dragon_Song1 hmm, depends on whether they'd be willing to ANSWER those questions. if they're too secretive about it, that'd be an instant yellow or orange at least. if they're open about it & if there *was* a problem on their end, it's just a matter of what exactly it was & if they're trying to work on it

  • @SungHanbinniee
    @SungHanbinniee 20 дней назад

    although welt is so green flag there are two points that i think might bring him down for me: first, BAGGAGE, A SHIT TON OF TRAUMA, alot of that trauma hasnt been opened up yet and i feel that might get in the way a bit, and second: SELF SACRIFICIAL TO A FAULT like yeah he might die for me but i dont want that, have some self respect i beg 😞 also why i would put hanya in orange, since her trauma and baggage is very VERY present and you can tell

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +1

      fair enough! a friend of mine pointed out the emotional baggage aspect too LMAO but hey.....i may not be able to fix him but i can try....
      honestly, most if not all of these characters are mentally ill/traumatized in SOME way or another, just depends on how much you'd be willing to deal with dfkgjf

  • @Desculpa_Arty
    @Desculpa_Arty 19 дней назад

    Gepard not being on green flag is atrocious, did u see how he treats his sisters?? He is lovely, totally golden retrevier...

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      again, his job....i did say that personality-wise he'd be a total green flag for me, but he's always working & at high risk of getting killed on-duty, so :(

    • @Desculpa_Arty
      @Desculpa_Arty 18 дней назад

      @kimcch I was kidding, sorry if u get sad, also it's normal people don't agree in everything LOL

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  18 дней назад +1

      @@Desculpa_Arty oh no it's all good DFGDH, trust me i'd love to put the man where he belongs but alas

  • @shadowbuddy8034
    @shadowbuddy8034 20 дней назад

    I think Sparkle is a yellow flag, because depending on who you are, she can be a red or green flag. She's mischevious and sassy, and while she plays pranks that may be extreme, as of yet she actually hasn't been shown to kill someone with any, and she almost certainly won't if you're someone she likes/are interested in!
    She's personally a green flag for me, but I understand if she seems untrustworthy to others, and if you can't trust her she's a very red flag

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @shadowbuddy8034 fair point, actually!
      to me, even that aspect alone would be way too risky though, because you don't know what'll happen once she loses that interest & decides she's had enough of you, y’know? while we haven't actually seen her kill anyone yet, given her mentality, she'd most definitely be capable of doing it, or she may try to mess with you in order to keep things "exciting"

  • @I_Need_Help_19
    @I_Need_Help_19 19 дней назад

    My 2 favourite characters are Rappa and Seele and their both red flags idk how I feel

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @I_Need_Help_19 to be fair, seele was a partial joke because of bronya, if i had to give a serious judgement i'd probably lean more towards yellow! and i do still like rappa very much, but in a relationship it just wouldn't work

  • @Desculpa_Arty
    @Desculpa_Arty 19 дней назад

    Me, clearly uncomfortable with the tier list 😢

  • @baappletheapple1885
    @baappletheapple1885 20 дней назад

    I disagree with Rappa in red, lime only because of the trauma and ninja brainrot

  • @ImUnstableHi
    @ImUnstableHi 20 дней назад

    The fact you said sparkle is a red flag is 1 hell of a stretch she was the only one in penacony who funny enough i could trust i didnt hear no lies coming from her despite the fact she follows the masked fools
    Also she can be whoever you want easy green flag

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @ImUnstableHi the first time we "met" her WAS literally her posing as sampo and trying to stir things up, though? and after that it was sunday when she tried to mess with him as "robin"
      her whole point is that she does what she wants, regardless of whether it's against the law or immoral, and you can only really trust her not to abandon or harm you as long as she finds you entertaining
      and i mean, i'd personally prefer the person i date to be who they really are instead of changing character on a whim

    • @ImUnstableHi
      @ImUnstableHi 20 дней назад

      @kimcch when she has the mask on she plays an act for her own amusement since she follows elation but there is more to her character than that her whole life she has been playing an act I mean she isn't even the original sparkle but there are times you see her real self in that form she never lied once and tries to make other people laugh
      a bit extreme sometimes but that's just who she is
      It is when you see her real self that you see the green flags

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад

      @@ImUnstableHi i mean, i'm still assuming her "real self" is the one that clearly says she doesn't care for morality or the law as long as SHE has her fun. and if she considers it a bummer for someone like sampo to have boundaries & lines he won't cross, then to me that indicates she DOESN'T, meaning she wouldn't shy away from violence for the sake of her entertainment either
      i also wouldn't date someone who has no issue being blatantly racist, so there's that too

    • @ImUnstableHi
      @ImUnstableHi 20 дней назад

      @kimcch personality moral ambiguity never really been a problem with me because of how I grew up and how the world is but who was she racist to I generally can't remember it's been a long time since I seen the story for penacony

    • @ImUnstableHi
      @ImUnstableHi 20 дней назад

      If you are talking about aventurine she was just using insults to get the upper hand in that conversation because he refused to join the masked fools

  • @celestealtalune
    @celestealtalune 19 дней назад

    Is it concerning that all of my waifus are orange flags or up?

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @@celestealtalune is your favorite color red?

    • @celestealtalune
      @celestealtalune 19 дней назад

      @kimcch its purple…

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  19 дней назад

      @celestealtalune there may still be hope for you.....

  • @graw19
    @graw19 20 дней назад

    doesn't Robin travel? 🤔

    • @kimcch
      @kimcch  20 дней назад +1

      .....fair point actually- though depending on how much she's away it'd probably only put her down in lime or yellow at most

  • @bread_axie
    @bread_axie 20 дней назад

    yayyyyy