Black Sabbath - War Pigs Lyrics

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 320

  • @christopherrandolph7100
    @christopherrandolph7100 3 года назад +178

    They painted black Sabbath as evil. But they were just telling the truth about it is all.

    • @msubhasbharani3739
      @msubhasbharani3739 2 года назад +1

      I swear mate. On a day like today, we can all see who the real evil cunts are. Fuck Biden or Putin or Johnson or Modi and a these power hungry war pig bastards. They're the real tumour.

    • @edenswaterislife9214
      @edenswaterislife9214 2 года назад +1

      Brainwashed minds oh lord yeah lord is ba'al a sorcerer the masses pray to. They are outting the god the people praise

    • @edenswaterislife9214
      @edenswaterislife9214 2 года назад +1

      @@msubhasbharani3739 follow the money. Who owns the banks? They fund the wars. The jwsh cbl

    • @msubhasbharani3739
      @msubhasbharani3739 2 года назад

      @@edenswaterislife9214 💯 the Rothschilds, Rockefellers, etc are perhaps the master of puppets behind all these and more.. 😐 depressing world

    • @jimmylegs06
      @jimmylegs06 2 года назад +1

      The world is Black.
      Not this band

  • @charlenethomas6198
    @charlenethomas6198 2 года назад +54

    Been listening to Ozzy since I was 15. I'm old now but these lyrics ring more true today than back in 1972. You can hear in this dudes words that he definitely knows the Bible! People made him out to be the Prince of Darkness but there is spiritual light in most the songs

    • @lorianne4936
      @lorianne4936 Год назад +2

      I thought I was the only one in the universe that saw this. I’m a Jesus follower and work in ministry. OZZY gets it! I gave the words of Crazy Train to one of our youth pastors, he was blown away.

    • @charmainlareau6452
      @charmainlareau6452 Год назад

      Ozzy had little to do with any of it

  • @thecanoehead
    @thecanoehead 6 лет назад +207

    This song is pushing 50 years, and still relevant.

    • @PhoenyxNightbyrd
      @PhoenyxNightbyrd 4 года назад +8

      So true, and so depressing.

    • @HM-qj3ls
      @HM-qj3ls 4 года назад +1

      @@PhoenyxNightbyrd how about now

    • @TobiLaroux
      @TobiLaroux 4 года назад +2

      50 years later and Iomi is still playing the solo

    • @marktrail8624
      @marktrail8624 4 года назад

      @@HM-qj3ls I've got this song at #5 on my top 10 best conspiracy songs of all time. See my channel playlist for the playlist

    • @irene9263
      @irene9263 3 года назад +3

      more so today March 2021

  • @markobuenrostro8977
    @markobuenrostro8977 7 лет назад +120

    Still relevant today. That's when you know you've written a classic.

  • @chuckkennedy5656
    @chuckkennedy5656 2 года назад +30

    This song is as Real and Truthful as it gets. Thank You for the Lyrics. Spot On.

  • @edenswaterislife9214
    @edenswaterislife9214 2 года назад +27

    The most relevant song of 2022 and we are just begining

  • @paulmontgomery1297
    @paulmontgomery1297 2 года назад +33

    Don't judge, but I am almost 50 and finally just sat and listened and read the lyrics. Wow, you could even take this shit to church!

    • @sandman2345
      @sandman2345 2 года назад +6

      Would love to hear a church choir/band rock this out one Sunday morning!!

    • @Daggercrossover
      @Daggercrossover 2 года назад +1

      I’m in my 60s and just realized what was being said

    • @JayTX.
      @JayTX. 2 года назад +2

      It's all biblical on the book of Revelation....it's all there ...

    • @sammyking8912
      @sammyking8912 Год назад

      Seriously I'm 35 and I just told my wife that for the like FIRST time I actually listened to the lyrics. This song is like my obsession right now. Which is nuts considering how old it is... that's hoe you know you've written a classic amazing song. Like u said you could seriously sing this in church.. how were they so portrayed as evil.

    • @actionstar23
      @actionstar23 Год назад

      Better late than never!

  • @samuelrothfeld9846
    @samuelrothfeld9846 2 года назад +20

    I am absolutely 110% unable to stop playing this fuckin’ song over and over again-matter of fact l don’t even want to stop playing this. Fuckin’ MENSA level ingenious music and nothing short of that!

    • @choochoo1320
      @choochoo1320 Год назад +1

      I know

    • @paulj.stavrou5477
      @paulj.stavrou5477 Год назад

      So...what you saying is Black Sabbath has an amazing grasp of the obvious 🙄.....lol

  • @tazgrant4521
    @tazgrant4521 7 лет назад +67

    Absolutely fuckIng mind blowingly brilliant lyrics and the changes in the music are just wicked, they don't make music like this any more in fact do they even use instruments any more in bands? Ozzy your the best then Dio.

  • @PhoenyxNightbyrd
    @PhoenyxNightbyrd 3 года назад +20

    Did this at karaoke once, several years ago. I will never forget being called on with "...doing my favorite song ever by Black Sabbath!" from the guy running the karaoke. Talk about "no pressure" huh?

  • @christophpolanski3494
    @christophpolanski3494 2 года назад +13

    The words “GOD and LORD”we’re capitalized in the original album when released. They actually believed in Biblical God!!!! Awesome song and truth behind it!

    • @JayTX.
      @JayTX. 2 года назад +1

      Yes there is....

  • @cadencewinstead6700
    @cadencewinstead6700 4 года назад +37

    Thank you for posting. These lyrics are revolutionary.

  • @corrosivecopper
    @corrosivecopper 8 лет назад +83

    Well done! No lyrics are wrong, all in time, clear and not blurred, and you have it in HD. Perhaps HD should have been first..

  • @Gothguy1961
    @Gothguy1961 3 года назад +33

    And nothing has changed since this song came out.

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      Thats the problem! They pretend it can or will

    • @marktrail8624
      @marktrail8624 Год назад

      It was a warning song that fucking nobody heeded, as August 2023 the war in Ukraine continues to send more boys to the undertaker.

  • @AtulKaushal7
    @AtulKaushal7 2 года назад +8

    A globally relevant song.

  • @THEJOB3323CHANNEL
    @THEJOB3323CHANNEL 7 лет назад +120

    this was Black Sabbath's stairway to heaven

  • @Civil.Engineer.
    @Civil.Engineer. 2 года назад +31

    Still relevant in today's world

  • @amirfaisal3329
    @amirfaisal3329 4 года назад +20

    The best history lesson

  • @lockstep2354
    @lockstep2354 5 лет назад +15

    this song just says it ALL!!

  • @snowkay38
    @snowkay38 4 года назад +150

    i'm literally doing an analysis on this song for history class....

    • @cameronbruce1862
      @cameronbruce1862 4 года назад +14

      Would LOVE to see it. GREAT TRUTHS IN THIS SONG. From an old Hippy Drummer who used to play it back in the 70s. (The other version (lyrics) I don't like)

    • @funnpunn_xox6969
      @funnpunn_xox6969 3 года назад +3

      Same, except it's for ELAR.

    • @srijanalama8583
      @srijanalama8583 3 года назад

      Haha, in my analysis history is full of a made-up story! However, it would be fun to analyze the song.
      Suggestion * think of the world-famous construction company build by the politicians and look beneath the surface how the story followed in their lifetime and the effects. It can be a great way to put the lyrics in reality as an example of the pig war. In reality, it wasn't any pig power or any kind of war but against its human clashing perspective.
      Better to analyze lyrics than to dig personal information and gossip.

    • @geminitaurus8693
      @geminitaurus8693 3 года назад +2

      I did an analysis of London Calling by The Clash for English 12

    • @arlenebowers326
      @arlenebowers326 3 года назад +1

      Ozzy commented on this song in an interview. He said that he wrote it about the end of time and what will happen. He was hoping for people to renew their thoughts and actions.

  • @michellemckheen5691
    @michellemckheen5691 Год назад +3

    Been listening to Ozzy for years!! The man is a rock God in my eyes! The song is spot on n is more true today!!!

  • @ΝικοςΡαπτης-ξ2ψ
    @ΝικοςΡαπτης-ξ2ψ 4 года назад +12

    Greatest song of greatest rock band

  • @Kiyarose3999
    @Kiyarose3999 2 года назад +8

    ‘’While there are slaughterhouses, there will be Battlefields’’ ( Leo Tolstoy)

  • @claxton1959
    @claxton1959 4 года назад +14

    Epic...classic...one of the best!

  • @lindapawlowski8560
    @lindapawlowski8560 Год назад

    Oh geez! What a classic song! I had this album in like 1973 when I was 13yrs old!!! One of the 1st albums I ever bought! This and grand funk live! Lol!

  • @flavianofloris4459
    @flavianofloris4459 2 года назад +4

    Perfect time 2022! War pigs!

  • @like2bike513
    @like2bike513 6 лет назад +44

    Holy and righteous song about God pouring out his judgement on the war pigs.

    • @colleenpeterson7247
      @colleenpeterson7247 6 лет назад +6

      Like2 Bike ,, We're all Sinners, saved by grace in Jesus Christ, I am a 📖 Sabbath keeper now, God bless you..

    • @tribeofjosepht.i.community9977
      @tribeofjosepht.i.community9977 4 года назад +7

      Book of Revelation End Time.
      Awesome......
      And
      Prophetic !

    • @wildwoodsgirl1706
      @wildwoodsgirl1706 3 года назад +1

      Matthew 6:5 js

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      That’s not what revelations says

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      Picture Jesus overturning the churches and synagogue’s and they kill him but they worship him?

  • @tribeofjosepht.i.community9977
    @tribeofjosepht.i.community9977 4 года назад +21

    Totally Prophetic !

    • @hungry2hear
      @hungry2hear 2 года назад

      At the time it was about the Viet Nam war. But war is war and the politicians that keep the machine going are the war pigs!

  • @ramsestoo
    @ramsestoo Год назад +7

    One of the greatest and most epic songs ever made - sadly still relevant ( Kind of a hymn for Ukraine and humanity )

    • @lorianne4936
      @lorianne4936 Год назад +2

      When I saw Biden and Zelenskyy walking with air raid sirens going off, this song is exactly what I thought of!

  • @CherylConti
    @CherylConti 2 года назад +3

    So relevant today.

  • @jademarkclaudian93
    @jademarkclaudian93 4 года назад +10

    January 25th 2020 still listening to this masterpiece

  • @siddhartha2k6
    @siddhartha2k6 2 года назад +7

    Masterpiece ❤️

  • @donella-um7cu
    @donella-um7cu Год назад +1

    I've been listening to Ozzy since the 70's I'm a 69 yr. old female and still loving Mr. Osbourne

  • @tomkrayg8102
    @tomkrayg8102 5 лет назад +10

    Totally timeless

  • @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584
    @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584 3 года назад +9

    Will we ever hold the war pigs accountable? Stay tuned for the next generation...

    • @hanna4202
      @hanna4202 3 года назад +3

      Judgment day is coming

    • @JP779M
      @JP779M 3 года назад +1

      There WON’T BE A NEW ONE… EVER!
      🥰IN EVERLASTING PRESENCE AND, IN THE MOST GLORIOUS FACE OF OUR ENDEARINGLY PATERNAL AND JOVIAL GOD OF HIS RIGHTEOUS…
      I SWEAR, TO ALL I REVEAL IN HIS HOLIEST BREATH-NOURISHING NAME FROM ON HIGH… I SWEAR THESE TRUTHS IN THE NAME OF JESUS, OUR LORD AND SAVIOUR!!!
      LET’S HEAR an… AMEN (?!!!)
      (edited to add last paragraph 🤔❤️😇🙃

    • @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584
      @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584 3 года назад

      @@JP779M dude, stfu

  • @Divineentity6612
    @Divineentity6612 2 года назад +2

    Great song.

  • @benniferfrost6083
    @benniferfrost6083 2 года назад +2

    Relevant to this day.

  • @zosa6403
    @zosa6403 11 месяцев назад

    All these years I though Black Sabbath wrote War Pigs and wow the lyrics are written by you.

  • @clarkkent5435
    @clarkkent5435 3 года назад +5

    Spot on even for today yay Ozzy!

  • @upinflames_01
    @upinflames_01 2 года назад +1

    Thanks for posting my favorite Sabbath tune!

  • @ritchie001ful
    @ritchie001ful 2 года назад +3

    Totally applies to what’s happening today!!

  • @Wifgargfhaurh
    @Wifgargfhaurh Год назад +1

    I will never forget this song

  • @DavidGray-fu8tv
    @DavidGray-fu8tv 11 месяцев назад

    I am so glad you guys get it it brings hope to My soul😢

  • @RandyR
    @RandyR 2 года назад +5

    Sadly perfect for today 😟

  • @larrycorder8263
    @larrycorder8263 Год назад

    Love it..top 5 favorite song

  • @AntigoBreNOX
    @AntigoBreNOX 5 лет назад +8

    Kings man trailer 2 🖤

  • @jayclark9662
    @jayclark9662 2 года назад +4

    Kickass song to wipe to. Not one speck left behind

  • @kelleyrea6020
    @kelleyrea6020 6 лет назад +28

    I feel like thats y Ozzy got so effed up on drugs. He had this vision of the end times yrs ago & it messed with him. No one else could write lyrics that long ago to pinpoint with so much accuracy whats goin on today. Dudes a prophet!

    • @ziggy0076
      @ziggy0076 5 лет назад +9

      Ozzy didn't write war pigs🤪

    • @guitarlawyer75
      @guitarlawyer75 4 года назад +12

      I believe Geezer Butler wrote the lyrics for War Pigs . He wrote most of the lyrics at the time . And he's a fantastic bass player

    • @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584
      @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584 3 года назад

      Its a repeating cycle, love.

    • @JP779M
      @JP779M 3 года назад +2

      TAKES GUTS TO SING THE LYRICS WITH CONVICTION IN THE FACE OF WORLD DISGUST OF HIS KIND…. NO MATTER WHO WROTE IT, GOD GAVE OZZY THE GRACE TO SING IT TO THE MASSES!
      THE PEOPLE WHO DESPISE, IN HEARTFELT AND DISGUST, QUIETLY… THIS POINTED CONTENT… LIKE YOU, and I, RADICAL MUSICAL TEDDY BEARS…
      GOD; AND, PEACE-LOVING; CLOSET, HEAVY METAL ROCKERS… THANKS OZ… SAYS GOD⚡️🥰
      BREATHE HIS LOVE, FOREVER; BREATHE, SHILLING 😂!!!
      YOUR MONIKER, IRRELEVANT BUT MESSAGE TRUE:
      🥰IN EVERLASTING PRESENCE IN THE MOST GLORIOUS; FACE OF OUR ENDEARINGLY PATERNAL AND JOVIAL WITH HIS RIGHTEOUS; I SWEAR, TO ALL I REVEAL IN HIS HOLIEST BREATH-NOURISHING NAME FROM ON HIGH… JESUS, OUR LORD AND SAVIOUR!!!

    • @JeremyB1993
      @JeremyB1993 2 года назад +1

      Geezer Butler was the lyrics writer. Not Ozzy

  • @ufade2
    @ufade2 3 года назад +6

    War....war never changes.

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      💯

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      You may win and achieve peace then watch who starts it back up then ask your self a long list of questions of “ why?”

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      And you have found your answers

  • @JonMI6
    @JonMI6 2 года назад +3

    It’s 10/26/2022 and we’re possibly inching closer to WWIII. This song is still relevant nowadays

    • @lorianne4936
      @lorianne4936 Год назад +1

      When I saw Biden and Zelenskyy walking with air raid sirens going off, this song is exactly what I thought of!

  • @joemyk
    @joemyk 10 месяцев назад

    It's that time of the year again.

  • @ironskull57
    @ironskull57 7 лет назад +9

    THATS RIGHT LET THE POOR DO THE WORK

  • @fernandoconstantino2425
    @fernandoconstantino2425 7 лет назад +10

    Top sempre clássico

  • @jimmylegs06
    @jimmylegs06 2 года назад +3

    2022........

  • @nicolomoretto6394
    @nicolomoretto6394 2 года назад +4

    Here we go again

  • @novemberdownspianoman5255
    @novemberdownspianoman5255 Год назад

    This is deep! Can't stop singing the intro words

  • @danielt.3152
    @danielt.3152 2 года назад +5

    In a way the lyrics are kinda accurate if you look at it at a certain angle, definitely a bad ass song. In a similar vain as Stings I hope the Russians love their children. There is definitely a message here but how does one country confront evil in another country without a military conflict? At the end of the day the world needs less evil and while peace is always attractive the other side will push until it’s too late to stop it

  • @80srockandmetal76
    @80srockandmetal76 7 лет назад +5

    Legendary

  • @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584
    @growthisfreedomunitedearth7584 3 года назад +7

    Perhaps we should all sing this outside the Isreali embassy in the US?

    • @JP779M
      @JP779M 3 года назад +1

      ANY EMBASSY… good thought!!!

  • @buppo89
    @buppo89 7 лет назад +3

    posted on my birthday, nice

  • @BxCortez2050
    @BxCortez2050 Год назад

    Listen im a hip hop person ..this song totally kicks ass

  • @kayty6673
    @kayty6673 2 года назад +3

    This should be the National Anthem of the USA

  • @bubbaray8670
    @bubbaray8670 3 года назад +7

    This was a warning from back then as to what is happening now. Plain and simple.

    • @lilypagan4019
      @lilypagan4019 3 года назад +2

      Exactly!!!

    • @big4skol83
      @big4skol83 3 года назад +3

      You are 100% correct! Time will tell on the powered minds of these crooked politicians, celebrities, athletes, and corporations. Making war just for fun. Treating people just like pawns in chess. Wait till their judgment day comes!

    • @big4skol83
      @big4skol83 3 года назад +1

      @Kevin Goetz I know. Those politicians and celebrities from back then were in deed the war pigs.

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      💯

  • @raymondabrego5621
    @raymondabrego5621 2 года назад +8

    Russia invading Ukraine brought me here

  • @efthkon9142
    @efthkon9142 2 года назад

    Very nice..

  • @ClydeCash-x1h
    @ClydeCash-x1h Год назад

    One of the truest songs ever written and it ironically comes from a band named Black Sabbath.

  • @daveo562
    @daveo562 7 лет назад +7

    More accurately, you should put "Lyrics Transcribed by Paulo Antonio."
    Thank you for doing and posting!

  • @toddmiller243
    @toddmiller243 2 года назад +3

    You should get an "A"!! This is the shit!!! WWI WWII etc....

    • @lopez11711
      @lopez11711 2 года назад +1

      And we have this "etc" today

  • @laynewright1967
    @laynewright1967 3 года назад +3

    (Tony) what issues are there
    (Ozzy) 3 fucking issues

  • @prithvirajs4157
    @prithvirajs4157 2 года назад +3

    I last heard this song in the 70's but looked it up listening to accounts of war in Ukraine....

  • @leonardorocha7509
    @leonardorocha7509 3 года назад +1

    Better song ever

  • @SuperLiftRick
    @SuperLiftRick 7 лет назад +116

    In all honesty this song should replace the United States National Anthem as we are a government comprised of War Mongrels.

    • @chriswatson1997
      @chriswatson1997 7 лет назад +1

      KIll

    • @Tazman1966
      @Tazman1966 7 лет назад +13

      SuperLift Rick it's not just us, it's the entire world. Groups of useful idiot civilians are trying to destroy from the bottom while the war machine elites crush from the top. These hate groups don't realize they're sharpening the blades for the executioner's blade. Wild times. Time for the sensible middle need to stand up to one's on the streets destroying our country that call themselves the Resistance. They're a cancer

    • @jamesperkins9186
      @jamesperkins9186 7 лет назад +4

      So true!!!!!!!!

    • @kdbadk
      @kdbadk 7 лет назад +3

      I pledge allegiance to the flag
      as Satan spreads his wings
      the blame belongs to you and me
      not just moneyed men and kings

    • @Bobster986
      @Bobster986 7 лет назад +1

      SuperLift Rick since day one.

  • @kevb1959
    @kevb1959 3 года назад +3

    First line should be "Bankers gathered in their masses."...

    • @neb542
      @neb542 2 года назад +2

      It's the war pigs. He talk directly to all of them my friend. Very courageous song. Ozzy and iomi never timid

  • @ericwilkison3309
    @ericwilkison3309 8 месяцев назад

    SABBATH was dark & creative! All there METAL was the BEST shit to ever be produced 😄🙂

  • @jessicastortz9138
    @jessicastortz9138 2 года назад +1

    2022!

  • @KiraLou06
    @KiraLou06 4 года назад

    6.3.2020 anyone here but me and this classic 🔥🔥🔥

  • @averageguy6242
    @averageguy6242 8 лет назад

    Many Thanks!

  • @accazeta9351
    @accazeta9351 6 лет назад +1

    great

  • @whatdyousay1566
    @whatdyousay1566 6 лет назад +1

    My friend said this song is good and I agree

  • @jamesoconnor2226
    @jamesoconnor2226 4 года назад +2

    The plague brought me here June 30 2020 i bought this in 1970

  • @edernolasco8826
    @edernolasco8826 3 года назад +1

    majeeeees

  • @rosemariewinget9561
    @rosemariewinget9561 2 года назад +4

    Sounds like what’s happening now

  • @kirareneerich8067
    @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

    Everyone killing each other just to be right! Everyone is NOT the same

  • @marktrail8624
    @marktrail8624 4 года назад +1

    I've got this song at #5 on my Best Rock Conspiracy songs. See the others on my channel.

  • @theanunakian64
    @theanunakian64 4 года назад +1

    2020-2021

  • @zozmirjanuc4658
    @zozmirjanuc4658 2 года назад +1

    How true is this now 2022.?

  • @dbcu5306
    @dbcu5306 6 лет назад +4

    End Time Prophecies

  • @ghostfarmer358
    @ghostfarmer358 3 года назад +1

    I hope I'm standing behind G.W. on judgement day. Me "So... I'm in right?"

    • @kirareneerich8067
      @kirareneerich8067 Год назад

      That statement get your affairs in order, you have NO IDEA how true

  • @carriesmith7460
    @carriesmith7460 5 лет назад +8

    If you want to hear the funniest version of this song ever , listen to Ozzy sing it live with Black Sabbath in 1970. I'm pretty sure that he had no idea what he was singing.

    • @bashirshah5347
      @bashirshah5347 4 года назад +4

      Sad But True but wthout Ozzy there will be No Heavy Metal songs

    • @mikepuleo9375
      @mikepuleo9375 3 года назад +1

      I just listened to that and I thought he forgot the lyrics.lol

  • @Backwoods.burnin
    @Backwoods.burnin Год назад

    October 10th 2023
    No song is truer!

  • @neganlucille9950
    @neganlucille9950 3 года назад

    #save our children

  • @keepcalmcarryon3358
    @keepcalmcarryon3358 2 года назад +5

    all these comments about “relevancy” …
    as long as humans exist, war will exist
    Ukraine and USA have just as much to do with the Russia invasion as Russia
    What would the US do if Russia moved into Cuba and set up a government for hire?

  • @jackhume4532
    @jackhume4532 4 года назад +4

    Im the same age as this song and there is probably some truth in the lyrics!!!!!.

  • @jasonjohnson5773
    @jasonjohnson5773 5 лет назад +1

    Black Sabbath abba definition: God as father. 10/11/19

  • @deanramnarine7343
    @deanramnarine7343 3 года назад

    Whos watching in 2021 like .. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @breezthomas6828
    @breezthomas6828 2 года назад +1

    HOW GOVT USE THEIR YOUNG GENERATIONS FOR MONETARY BENEFITS

  • @Thinker669
    @Thinker669 4 месяца назад

    This is the pointless wars like Korea, Vietnam, Operation Desert Storm, War in Afghanistan and Iraq, and now about the situation going with Russia and Ukraine. It's not our war, not our problem.

  • @bulldogclub2162
    @bulldogclub2162 3 года назад +1

    I love ozzy, i guess.

  • @joshmacdonald9229
    @joshmacdonald9229 2 года назад +1

    Sound familiar

  • @chodechotchney5331
    @chodechotchney5331 3 года назад +3

    tldl; They do the devils bidding then he throws them all under the bus