This song has haunted me through the deaths of two grandparents. During the final days of my grandfathers life, we knew what was coming next, I could hear this song playing in the back of my head. It is a beautiful song but it just brings me back to the side of the bed.
The original song "Heartaches" was about forgetting someone who broke your heart. I think recognizing that our minds do that is sad in a way but it's comforting knowing you can always move forward with your life.
for second verse: heartaches, heartaches, I love you so much that my heart breaks, please don't leave me for, someone neww my heart only lives for you.
I find the original Caretaker version to be strangely optimistic yet haunting. But this version is just pure nostalgia and comfort, reflection and fondness for old memories, but a slight sense of sadness from the fact that you cant go back to how things were then. Its beautiful.
Today we buried my grandmother, she passed away... 2 days ago.. she started to forget everything 9 years ago... I hate so much the Alzheimer, I will never forget you Alina...
@@imoldcheese4927 same, I've been searching songs I like and checks if Re Music Box have them, and 98% of the songs I searched shows up at their channel.
How the hell have you made a version that's even sadder than the normal one? The first time I put this on, I was in tears in seconds. I don't think I've ever been as fearful of my own mortality as I was when I first heard this. Thanks for the existential crisis, you complete and utter genius.
Think sad, think gloom, think heartaches, think crisis, think Alzheimer’s Heartaches, Heartaches… My loving you meant only heart aches… Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me! I can’t believe it’s just a burning memory…
Imagine a backrooms movie where the protagonist dies and this plays during the credits. Or this plays in your head while you’re slowly starving/dehydrating or exhausted from your lack of sleep, as you slowly lose your mind, turning into a wretch.
I remember now. When I first met the love of my life. This song was playing through my headphones, the way they stared at me brings back so many memories, haha. But they had to go at such a young age..Please. I will never forget you, Emily.
When you remember the memories of the past, those old days when you used to go with your friends and spent hours in laughs and cries. man, nostalgia is such a weird feeling, i can't tell if i like it or not
I got interested in EATEOT through the Uncanny meme. And this is the only song I dare to listen to. Reading the comments scare me to go for the rest. Anyways, good cover
@@LordTerias well, I did listen to bits of every part, and the last 6 minutes. I got jumpscared at the start of stage 5. But I still curious, tho. Might try it again sometimes Stage 1 is a-okay, I think. It's actually sounds good due to less edits
I love this. I reminds me of something a scene in a move that takes place in a ball room in a castle, everyone is dancing happily not knowing that a blood thisty, ruthless murdering creature will come out soon...
POV you exit the backrooms after several years of growing from a teenager to an old man, you die, and wake up where you started…. In this world reality doesn’t make sense
I’ve recently started hearing this song everywhere (not the uncanny meme, I didn’t even notice that was the same song at first) and then this video comes out.
When you find some piece and comfort at the with your dementia, some memory of the past not being entangled for a brief period, finally being able to see a memory clearly in who knows how long.
Nostalgic ending: You are tired from level 467. You find yourself in your childhood and see a music box. You wind it up and your memories come back. You realize that the music you hear is real and the floor is soft. Could it be?
The sands of time pass through your fingers, the hourglass of your existence shattering upon the cold marble floor of inevitable mortality. Go forth and remember no more.
One time, A robber broke into our house, He didnt rob anything though, He went to the living room and sat down on the couch, he played this and started sobbing, We were scared at first but we comforted him, He told us everything, He said "My mother died not to long ago, Im homeless and live on the streets at (One of the street names, I forgot the name.) ive lived there ever since, I heard this playing and i knew i had to listen to it to get my tears out, So yeah." More tears ran down his face, i hugged him and he hugged me back, He broke down into more tears, But they were happy and sad at the same time.
![DUET/OMORI [Music Box]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/azbGB6ol26s/mqdefault.jpg)
![Serenade (Ständchen)/Schubert [Music Box]](/img/1.gif)
This song has haunted me through the deaths of two grandparents. During the final days of my grandfathers life, we knew what was coming next, I could hear this song playing in the back of my head. It is a beautiful song but it just brings me back to the side of the bed.
Why does this comfort me and make me sad at the same time?
The original song "Heartaches" was about forgetting someone who broke your heart. I think recognizing that our minds do that is sad in a way but it's comforting knowing you can always move forward with your life.
I forgot
I appreciate how this song makes me feel like I have lost something I still have.
Same
@@xanosghoul wow that’s a cool message
Heartaches, heartaches
My loving you meant only heartaches
Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me
I can't believe it's just a burning memory
I LOVE THE ORIGINAL SONG SO MUCH..
This is so gentle and sad :(
heartaches, heartaches
what does it matter how my heart breaks?
I should be happy with someone new
but my heart aches for you
*repeats*
for second verse:
heartaches, heartaches,
I love you so much that my heart breaks,
please don't leave me for, someone neww
my heart only lives for you.
I find the original Caretaker version to be strangely optimistic yet haunting. But this version is just pure nostalgia and comfort, reflection and fondness for old memories, but a slight sense of sadness from the fact that you cant go back to how things were then. Its beautiful.
I find the original Al Bowly nicer
I nean then again it was Al Bowlly's song after all
It's not just a burning memory
If you still remember it's still live inside your heart
- a wise man
@@poliwazawaza55 Good play, but you still having a bullshit english.
ThiS comment is so wholesome
Wholesome comment
If you don't, it's still just a burning memory.
“The memories don't live in the head
The memories live in the heart.”
That's like saying you don't consciously think of memories; they only reside in the sub-conscious.
but eventually it always rot and decompose into soil.
genuinely the most comforting version of this song tbh
Al Bowley's heartaches is on the same level I think
@@user-mv4zi6ey4yThen again that IS the song everyone's talking about especially with all the covers and whatnot, so it makes a lot of sense.
I just found this after hearing the original it's just a burning memory
Yoo me to!!!
That is how it is mate
@@michaelaplicador5754 you obviously cared enough to comment this in his reply section.
It’s just a burning memory will burning your burning memory
im pretty sure thats a remake of heartaches
Today we buried my grandmother, she passed away... 2 days ago.. she started to forget everything 9 years ago... I hate so much the Alzheimer, I will never forget you Alina...
Rest in peace...
@@KeiRa63127 thx
I’m really sorry for your loss 😢😢😢
much support from here!!!
😢
I never expected this to be covered on this channel, let alone sound this pleasing
Exactly me too!! Didn't expect to see it here and didn't expect it to sound that good either
thanks for doing this one, I really respect how you do covers of all different types of music. Always something for everyone
indeed , literaly been one of my favourite channels since i found it
@@imoldcheese4927 same, I've been searching songs I like and checks if Re Music Box have them, and 98% of the songs I searched shows up at their channel.
How the hell have you made a version that's even sadder than the normal one? The first time I put this on, I was in tears in seconds. I don't think I've ever been as fearful of my own mortality as I was when I first heard this. Thanks for the existential crisis, you complete and utter genius.
Think sad, think gloom, think heartaches, think crisis, think Alzheimer’s
Heartaches, Heartaches…
My loving you meant only heart aches…
Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me!
I can’t believe it’s just a burning memory…
Si aceptas a Jesucristo como tú Salvador personal, las cosas no seguirán siendo así.
when dementia hit hard but you still have a sick music box to jam to
"i aint NEVER listened to this before idk what yall talkin about"
Still giving nostalgic times-
And also gives me "you're not supposed to be here" vibes ;-;
Me on my death bed but thousands of memes flash before my eyes instead of cherished memories of family and friends.
you in stage 5 dementia randomly at 3am: "OH MY GOD STOP POSTING ABOUT AMONG US" "dude that meme was 50 years ago" "OH RIGHT. WHO ARE YOU AGAIN"
this is so calming thanks for making this
It sounds more comforting than I thought it would be.
Imagine a backrooms movie where the protagonist dies and this plays during the credits.
Or this plays in your head while you’re slowly starving/dehydrating or exhausted from your lack of sleep, as you slowly lose your mind, turning into a wretch.
I remember now. When I first met the love of my life. This song was playing through my headphones, the way they stared at me brings back so many memories, haha. But they had to go at such a young age..Please. I will never forget you, Emily.
Aww
I hope everything is okayyy
We are here for you
That's sad, I hope you're okay.
We all support you.
the last song you hear before a killing disease takes you away
nah a place in the world fades away is
I need an actual music box of this.
When you remember the memories of the past, those old days when you used to go with your friends and spent hours in laughs and cries. man, nostalgia is such a weird feeling, i can't tell if i like it or not
Fell asleep and forgot everything when I woke up.
Get recommend
I got interested in EATEOT through the Uncanny meme. And this is the only song I dare to listen to. Reading the comments scare me to go for the rest.
Anyways, good cover
Yeah the rest of it is pretty demented. You were wise to only listen to the first track
I tried listening to EATEOT while doing homework. I didn’t get very far on either...
@@LordTerias well, I did listen to bits of every part, and the last 6 minutes. I got jumpscared at the start of stage 5. But I still curious, tho. Might try it again sometimes
Stage 1 is a-okay, I think. It's actually sounds good due to less edits
@@beavisbunghole stage 2 is rly depressing, stage 3 is chaos, stage 4 is even more chaos, stage 5 is black midi, and stage 6 is without description
i remember i was watching an all ending video and stage 5 just started playing and i literally fell of the couch
I love this. I reminds me of something a scene in a move that takes place in a ball room in a castle, everyone is dancing happily not knowing that a blood thisty, ruthless murdering creature will come out soon...
"Heartaches, Heartaches
What does it matter how my heart breaks?
I should be happy with someone new, but my heart aches for you."
Why Do i feel like i'm slowly drifting away while listening to this.
it sounds so calming yet unsettling at the same time
Day forty four of listening to it’s just a burning memory. Happy birthday brother!
Are you okay?
This is a beautiful cover. Well done.
I get chills down my spine just thinking about this
This should be the end song of the Uncanny meme.
pov : everything is now ok
@@le_twerkiumII yes!
And backrooms
Quit relating The Caretaker to this stuff. It is just downright idiotic. It's supposed to mean dementia, not this stuff.
@@ShrekTheShrexyOgreyes, it is about a life-ruining disease, not the yellow office.
This makes my heart hurt but also comfort me at the same time
Day five of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
“Where’s your favorite music box grandpa?”
“I.. forgot..”
I can’t believe it’s just a burning memory.
This actually made me cry, i really miss myself from a decade ago
Everything’s okay, you’re safe now, I may not be hugged, but you’ll be now.
“I think I’ve heard this song before… But I can’t remember…”
Finally, something a bit more peaceful. Still a bit eerie but more reassuring
@Derekanic D:
Day three of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
Day seven of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
True ending: you escaped and that place is now just a *burning memory...*
I'm tearing up
I might be 29 years old with dementia.
But i might be 29 years old with dementia.
-stanleyMOV
But I might be 29 years old…
BUT WITH DEMENTIA!
@@WheresYourMotivationAt But i might be dementia with 29 year old
everytime I hear this song, it only make me flashback to my good old time
Day eleven of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
You hear the faint voice of someone saying...
I might be 29 years old with dementia
But on the other hand...
I might be 29 years old with dementia
Day one of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box.
おおお良い！！これはこれで夢の中のような儚い感じがして良い
POV you exit the backrooms after several years of growing from a teenager to an old man, you die, and wake up where you started…. In this world reality doesn’t make sense
I’ve recently started hearing this song everywhere (not the uncanny meme, I didn’t even notice that was the same song at first) and then this video comes out.
Day thirteen of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
Oops! Unlucky Me!!
U ok?🫤
Sounds like a theme that would play during a flashback in a rpg game
This is amazing thank you for making this
"Horrid experiences leave one's soul to rot and decay until you can only find comfort in the horrid."
Day nine of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
this is the thing I would put on when im tired to keep me awake, to push myself to think about the burning memories
This is just like what the backrooms entitys play when there about to go to sleep😴❤
I WAS REALLY SAD READING ALL THE OTHER COMMENTS AND I SEE THIS AND JUST BREAK DOWN LAUGHING
"i love you mom.." (mother) "i love you too" "i will always love you"
When you find some piece and comfort at the with your dementia, some memory of the past not being entangled for a brief period, finally being able to see a memory clearly in who knows how long.
どうぞ、これは素晴らしいです！メロディーは人生の重荷のように心を落ち着かせてくれます...
This sounds beautiful...
Day thirty of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
For some extra and historical context, the song is actually called Heartaches by Al Bowlly, which was a song that implied a romantic break up.
*Just a Sleepy Memory.*
Nostalgic ending: You are tired from level 467. You find yourself in your childhood and see a music box. You wind it up and your memories come back. You realize that the music you hear is real and the floor is soft. Could it be?
The sands of time pass through your fingers, the hourglass of your existence shattering upon the cold marble floor of inevitable mortality.
Go forth and remember no more.
This sounds more like "Your first memory"
I felt Like a DreamCatcher.
Day six of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
Oh my god... you actually did it.
this song is very beautiful
you unlocked the secret ending wherein everything that happened was just a dream
It was a burning memory
Day twenty of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
Oh so we're doing the caretaker's songs now, lads? 👀
this make me feel sad and scared (also feel like i want to sleep RIGHT NOW!)
This makes me feel so comfy and nostalgic :3
This sounds like the lullaby ver of its just a burning memory
Day eighteen of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
he ain't called the caretaker for nothin'
One time, A robber broke into our house, He didnt rob anything though, He went to the living room and sat down on the couch, he played this and started sobbing, We were scared at first but we comforted him, He told us everything, He said "My mother died not to long ago, Im homeless and live on the streets at (One of the street names, I forgot the name.) ive lived there ever since, I heard this playing and i knew i had to listen to it to get my tears out, So yeah." More tears ran down his face, i hugged him and he hugged me back, He broke down into more tears, But they were happy and sad at the same time.
Day thirty two of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
You reborn, trying to understand why this is familiar even if you just started living
This made me tear
This grew a big smile on my face and i cant nor want to stop it my face is this emoji >😁
Day twenty one of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
Beautiful, i love music box
What just happened
This songs make me have many happy sad and strange feelings
Best part is this channel made red sun over paradise
0.5x speed sounds like a really slow version of the the song music box. Sounds really nice
this song has been used so fucking much that i dont think i'll ever hear it again without going "IS THAT THE TROLLGE SONG!?!?!??!?!?"
just finished listening to it for the first time, it's great!
right?!?! the music box matches so well with the theme
right?!?! the music box matches so well with the theme
Day sixty of listening. To it’s just a burning memory
Day fifteen of listening to it’s just a burning memort
very interesting how The Caretaker managed to turn songs into an album that describes dementia
When in reality it's a remake of Heartaches by Al Bowlly. That's the true origin of the song.
Day thirty one of listening to it’s just a burning memory played on a music box
This sounds so bittersweet I love it
This felling is beyond words...