It's always lovely to listen you Professor Vinay Lal. Thank you sir. Whenever you come to India for any conference or debate please let your audience to know. Love to hear and see you.
Try to give counter-arguments about the specific things that professor Lal says that you think are wrong, using logic and historical facts. You can for example say that professor Lal says x at minute ..:.., but for reason y you think that is wrong. Debating history and historical writings is about reason and empirical facts, not simple accusations and whataboutisms.
Sir I am confused regarding the relation of the title to the actual content of the video , In my opinion the title strongly suggests ones personal emotional feelings rather than what you could factualy talk about RSS being "Anti-National".
Korean racism against Indians exists also in India. Penukonda , a small town in Andhra Pradesh along the Bangalore Hyderabad higway is howme to Kia Motors factory. A lot of Koreans work there. No Indians are aloowed to enter some of the Korean restaurants in Penukonda. This has not received enough coverage and so very few know about it.. You should cover this by going thee yourself and report it in one of your videos.
Devanuru is a good storyteller but a second rate intellectual. This book is also filled with number of misinformations and his agenda driven narratives. If such a work is really considered I must pity our intellectual community.
Initially the author released a draft on Libgen for open access and publications help later by major, highly accessible work but haven't reached beyond reading minds. But words spread, books might be less.
"Secular" word was already present in the Constitution since 1947(see Article 25). It was only added in the preamble during emergency. And they didn't add it in preamble because they wanted to bring reservation system. Now the term "secular" has been clarified in various court judgements and laws in various contexts.
Please take the controversial verses of the Holy Book of the so called peaceful community which has wreaked ha oc the world over and explain it on your channel. We would all like to know your thoughts on that as well.
Devanuru Mahadeva is a writer of unquestionable integrity. It's an eye opener for those who are unfamiliar with the divisive agenda of the RSS. The political wing of this organization has been destroying democracy in India.
Divisive agenda, i can very well defend it by pointing out tbe flaws in the ideology of other parties nd i must show u tbis bcoz apparently u don't know leftism that well nd strangely leftism as a political ideology be it post modernism or conflict approaches like marxism nd feminism, every single one of them want to obliterate every ounce of integration nd sanity left in the society, example, just read marx's nd feminist's views on family, nation, religion, capitalism nd every other thing that unites society is a super structure nd must wither away nd make way for revolution nd other ideology that operates in india is islamism nd i dont need to say anything about that it is possibly the lowest point of human thought which divides the region in darul harb nd darul islam, divides things in haram nd halal nd divides people in kafir nd musalman nd then u people have guts to talk about rss nd tag them as divisive institution when they literally have nothing that creates divide nd yess they r adamant on nation having it's central identity as hindu bcoz this country is pre-dominantly hindu nd what's wrong in it, after all it is this hindu majority that is saving democracy nd secularism in this country otherwise go nd hoist ur flag of secularism nd democracy in bangladesh nd pakistan, they r same people as indians in every aspect except one, tbey r muslims we r hindus that's it nd no wonder the day kashmir turned into muslim majority it became non-democratic.
sir why you hate Modi and RSS . Did they take something from you ? i have seen your many videos the narrative you try to build about RSS. or it something else .
Try to counter what professor Lal says with counterarguments about what specific things that he says are factually wrong. We are not in the business of opinions or “feelings”, but we talk about facts and logical arguments. That is the job of a historian.
Sir.. I am great fan of yours... But your argument disappointed me. you should come and visit with me.. I will take you arround and show the kind of society building activities they are carring out... Parnab Mukherjee who was president and hard core congressmen even couldn't resist to express his feeling for the RSS which in involved in nation building activity. Do not read text.. Come and experience... Come to India . I will Host 😊you. But the allegations are not true to the extend as expressed in the title... 😅
Sir, even Yakuzas in Japan and Pablo Escobar in Colombia did those nation building and charitable activities. Yakuzas were the first responder to natural disasters in Japan. They do it precisely because people like you will forgive them even if they do many other horrible things.
Thanks very much for this book recommendation. I agree with you that calling Narendra Modi the "Utsav Murti" of the RSS does not capture the phenomenon he is across the country. I have recently watched your wonderful lectures on the Moral and Political Thought of Gandhi and I found the last lecture where you explain the anxiety of the Indian public, giving the Guinness Book of World Records as an example, quite fascinating. You mentioned that there are no scholarly works explaining Modi's attractiveness despite his despicable political positions and actions, and miniscule achievements. Perhaps Modi's outward personality, and the general way he conducts his PR, at least in comparison to his predecessor Manmohan Singh, relieves this anxiety to the point that the public continue to vote him in power? This may also correlate well with the idea of a nation state being represented finally by a "masculine" leader as you mention in your lectures, which was the ideology of the progenitors of the RSS to begin with. I would love to have your thoughts!
He is a paper tiger like Bal Thackeray The Brahmin dominated media projects him and the Judiciary protects him up Rest he does with the brain of Ajit Doval and Co Otherwise Modi would have disappeared a long time back or probably ended up in jail for his crimes Who provides this support of media and judiciary to Modi but only RSS This differences between Modi and RSS are just a ploy to create a wrong impression that Modi will be weakened Infact both are so intertwined it is no more possible to live separately
It's always lovely to listen you Professor Vinay Lal. Thank you sir. Whenever you come to India for any conference or debate please let your audience to know. Love to hear and see you.
Good moring prof Lal. Eagerly waiting for your new lectures.
And Muslim league is most secular party...😅
It doesn't exist, and certainly doesn't rule india
And CHUSLIMs r most peaceful 😂😂
Try to give counter-arguments about the specific things that professor Lal says that you think are wrong, using logic and historical facts. You can for example say that professor Lal says x at minute ..:.., but for reason y you think that is wrong. Debating history and historical writings is about reason and empirical facts, not simple accusations and whataboutisms.
They are not conditioned to be rational @@prikkeldraad7112
Thank you for this book discussion!
Sir I am confused regarding the relation of the title to the actual content of the video , In my opinion the title strongly suggests ones personal emotional feelings rather than what you could factualy talk about RSS being "Anti-National".
Korean racism against Indians exists also in India. Penukonda , a small town in Andhra Pradesh along the Bangalore Hyderabad higway is howme to Kia Motors factory. A lot of Koreans work there. No Indians are aloowed to enter some of the Korean restaurants in Penukonda. This has not received enough coverage and so very few know about it.. You should cover this by going thee yourself and report it in one of your videos.
Don't buy kia
Devanuru is a good storyteller but a second rate intellectual. This book is also filled with number of misinformations and his agenda driven narratives. If such a work is really considered I must pity our intellectual community.
Initially the author released a draft on Libgen for open access and publications help later by major, highly accessible work but haven't reached beyond reading minds. But words spread, books might be less.
Y was the word secular included in the constitution during the emergency??
"Secular" word was already present in the Constitution since 1947(see Article 25). It was only added in the preamble during emergency. And they didn't add it in preamble because they wanted to bring reservation system. Now the term "secular" has been clarified in various court judgements and laws in various contexts.
மகிழ்ச்சி சார்
Kuch bhi sir ji....😂
He is reviewing a book. And all of us know that he is anti-RSS, and he says it clearly.
@@ssmot113 ji...🙏
Please take the controversial verses of the Holy Book of the so called peaceful community which has wreaked ha oc the world over and explain it on your channel. We would all like to know your thoughts on that as well.
Devanuru Mahadeva is a writer of unquestionable integrity. It's an eye opener for those who are unfamiliar with the divisive agenda of the RSS. The political wing of this organization has been destroying democracy in India.
Divisive agenda, i can very well defend it by pointing out tbe flaws in the ideology of other parties nd i must show u tbis bcoz apparently u don't know leftism that well nd strangely leftism as a political ideology be it post modernism or conflict approaches like marxism nd feminism, every single one of them want to obliterate every ounce of integration nd sanity left in the society, example, just read marx's nd feminist's views on family, nation, religion, capitalism nd every other thing that unites society is a super structure nd must wither away nd make way for revolution nd other ideology that operates in india is islamism nd i dont need to say anything about that it is possibly the lowest point of human thought which divides the region in darul harb nd darul islam, divides things in haram nd halal nd divides people in kafir nd musalman nd then u people have guts to talk about rss nd tag them as divisive institution when they literally have nothing that creates divide nd yess they r adamant on nation having it's central identity as hindu bcoz this country is pre-dominantly hindu nd what's wrong in it, after all it is this hindu majority that is saving democracy nd secularism in this country otherwise go nd hoist ur flag of secularism nd democracy in bangladesh nd pakistan, they r same people as indians in every aspect except one, tbey r muslims we r hindus that's it nd no wonder the day kashmir turned into muslim majority it became non-democratic.
sir why you hate Modi and RSS . Did they take something from you ? i have seen your many videos the narrative you try to build about RSS. or it something else .
Try to counter what professor Lal says with counterarguments about what specific things that he says are factually wrong. We are not in the business of opinions or “feelings”, but we talk about facts and logical arguments. That is the job of a historian.
@@prikkeldraad7112yep
@@prikkeldraad7112hindu rashtra only rss should rule
@@rrao7963 give arguments and facts, then we can talk
Sir.. I am great fan of yours... But your argument disappointed me. you should come and visit with me.. I will take you arround and show the kind of society building activities they are carring out... Parnab Mukherjee who was president and hard core congressmen even couldn't resist to express his feeling for the RSS which in involved in nation building activity. Do not read text.. Come and experience... Come to India . I will Host 😊you. But the allegations are not true to the extend as expressed in the title... 😅
Pranab Mukherjee was a sell out
Recently the daughter of Pranab Mukherjee said that visit of Modiji to him was just political
Sir, even Yakuzas in Japan and Pablo Escobar in Colombia did those nation building and charitable activities. Yakuzas were the first responder to natural disasters in Japan. They do it precisely because people like you will forgive them even if they do many other horrible things.
"Nation building" no they do "myth making" and "cultural erasure" so they can realize their vision of a hindutva nation.
@@ssmot113 Experience it be with them then you will understand.
Thanks very much for this book recommendation. I agree with you that calling Narendra Modi the "Utsav Murti" of the RSS does not capture the phenomenon he is across the country. I have recently watched your wonderful lectures on the Moral and Political Thought of Gandhi and I found the last lecture where you explain the anxiety of the Indian public, giving the Guinness Book of World Records as an example, quite fascinating. You mentioned that there are no scholarly works explaining Modi's attractiveness despite his despicable political positions and actions, and miniscule achievements. Perhaps Modi's outward personality, and the general way he conducts his PR, at least in comparison to his predecessor Manmohan Singh, relieves this anxiety to the point that the public continue to vote him in power? This may also correlate well with the idea of a nation state being represented finally by a "masculine" leader as you mention in your lectures, which was the ideology of the progenitors of the RSS to begin with. I would love to have your thoughts!
Same clichéd arguments. No original thought.
It's a book review
you need to have a brain to understand... when you grow one, come back.
Maybe he is condemned to repeating the same cliches because all the bhakt types can't even wrap your head around that.
@@anshumankanetkar may God give you some more brain. I think I have enough
❤
He is a paper tiger like Bal Thackeray
The Brahmin dominated media projects him and the Judiciary protects him up Rest he does with the brain of Ajit Doval and Co
Otherwise Modi would have disappeared a long time back or probably ended up in jail for his crimes
Who provides this support of media and judiciary to Modi but only RSS
This differences between Modi and RSS are just a ploy to create a wrong impression that Modi will be weakened
Infact both are so intertwined it is no more possible to live separately