@@TheLuckyOne1448 u can just tell like at the last part he decided to belt out the note and his voice cracked slightly and in general just din sound like it was in great condition (but he still slayed anyways)
@@TheLuckyOne1448 He actually was, it's ok to have a bit of a throaty kick, and a cry in the voice, it's actually a technique that helps to add colour and true emotion.
I want SO so sooo bad for this group to get the recognition they deserve.. 😭😭 this song is such a masterpiece it should chart on music shows.. Joomyeon and jungsu’s vocals are exceptional but at the same time u can’t even ignore other’s vocals..
Xdinary is one of those rare group that actually sounds 100 times better live than studio recording. Their agency picked the perfect members for an instrument rock band
Jooyeon changed his singing method bc he had a throat problem, but I wanna say I love this version of soft vocal so so much too😭it makes the song sounds even more sad and souly😭💖i love you Jooyeon so so much you have an amazing voice❤
If it weren't for the comments I would have completely forgotten that Jooyeon had throat problems, he did amazing. They all did amazing, I love this song so much
Jooyeon, pls don't forget to take care of your throat! Don't think about it too much, you still sound so beautiful no matter what. I hope you will recover soon:')
주연 군!!! 자기관리도 실력이니깐... 평생 오랫동안 가수로서 활동할거니깐... 제발 목 관리 잘했으면 ㅠㅠ 저번주 부터 노래 할때, 말 할때 쉰소리 나던데... 아돌라에서 목소리가 허스키하게 잘 나오지도 않던데... 왜 본인이 말을 많이 하는지... (다른 멤버들한테 토크 넘겨요) 아돌라에서 말할때, 노래할때 속상하고 안타깝더라구요~ㅠㅠ 주연 군은 엑디즈의 보컬이니깐 반드시 평소 목관리 잘하길!!! 말도 줄이고, 미지근한 물도 자주 마시면서 목 아껴요!!! ㅠㅠ 아직 해야할 무대가 많은걸로 아는데... 앞으로 오랫동안 계속 노래 불러야하잖아요 그러니, 건강도 자기관리도 프로답게!!! 멤버 모두다 건강관리 잘하자!!!
I was wondering why Jooyeon wasn't singing all out during the chorus unlike the usual, turns out he mentioned that his throat is in the worst condition. I'm glad that he is taking care of it tho and he's not pushing himself. This is just radio performance after all. Also idk why I found it cute that he couldn't help himself but actually sing his last line all out. Although it did crack (really shows how bad his condition is I'm so sad) but it still sounded amazing.
Ok this is so cute that junhan did jooyeons scream part for him in freakin bad 😂. I hope his throat rests and gets completely better as soon as possible.
@@SueweetieAJYPN fr lol and their reactions to Junhan were so cute. I have my trust on Jooeyon and his vocal coaches. I’m sure they know when to make him lie low a bit especially during his worst conditions. Kinda like how he recovered during strawberry cake era. Tbh I really though he would suffer a big loss if he keeps on continuing singing strawberry cake before then he just surprised me during their first live performance after a few months of rest because he sounded like he recovered, almost the same sound he had during his debut. Although his voice sounded way worse now than when they were promoting strawberry cake but I’m sure they’re taking care of it now considering how he mostly sang in falsetto during the higher parts here.
THEY ARE FREAKING INCREDIBLE. Literally sent shivers up my spine. Jooyeon and Jungsu = perfection. If this song doesn't win a BIG award at the end of the year, I will not understand.
Really love this song, Jooyeon's vocal is very beautiful, full of emotion, the lyric very deep and meaningful, this song is a masterpiece, hope many people listen to this song
Esta canción es perfecta. Y me atrevo a decir, que en lo que va del año, es la mejor canción que he escuchado. Es una obra etérea, trasciende, te transporta al momento justo para sentir lo que ellos sienten al interpretarla. ASÍ SE HACE CHICOS Anhelo que cada día más personas conozcan el tesoro que ustedes son. Me siento tan inspirada.
you can really tell how much they love music and how passionate they are about it we really need more groups like this who not only preform the songs but connect to them 👏
I can no longer count the number of times I listened to this song before I go to sleep. This song is so powerful and moving at the same time. I just can't get enough of this song. ❤❤❤
JiSeok and Seungmin are amazing, Jooyeon is without doubt, one of the best vocalists ever but Jungsu just hits different for me♥ And Gunil and Hyeongjun just ahahah-ing away is enough for me. How much I love this band is insane.
I can't express how much I love this song
Same it crazy how I can't even missed this song everyday
me either….
It's my favorite song of theirs ❣
Same
I want to cry every time I hear this song, but in a good way.
Jooyeon did so well despite having throat problems. Don push yourself too much jooyeon!
I didn´t know that he has throat problems, he sound so good, I thought that he was doing it on purpose
@@TheLuckyOne1448 u can just tell like at the last part he decided to belt out the note and his voice cracked slightly and in general just din sound like it was in great condition (but he still slayed anyways)
@@cocoridocori I thought he was singing like a rockstar wkdjsbsnq
Ohhh, I was wondering why he sang his lines with all falsetto ☹️
@@TheLuckyOne1448 He actually was, it's ok to have a bit of a throaty kick, and a cry in the voice, it's actually a technique that helps to add colour and true emotion.
I want SO so sooo bad for this group to get the recognition they deserve.. 😭😭 this song is such a masterpiece it should chart on music shows..
Joomyeon and jungsu’s vocals are exceptional but at the same time u can’t even ignore other’s vocals..
Jungsu has such good vocal control and technique him singing always gets me in the feels
Jooyeonnie despite having a throat problem you still sang beautifully
이번주 음방 샤우팅 금지.. 주연이 목 상하는거 마음 찢어진다 쇼케랑 음방 2주간 샤우팅 해준 것 만으로도 이미 감사해 넌 최고의 락스타야 우리 락스타 지켜.....
honestly jooyeon's strained vocals really adds to the emotions of the song
Xdinary is one of those rare group that actually sounds 100 times better live than studio recording. Their agency picked the perfect members for an instrument rock band
you guys don't understand how much i love this song. Thank you XH for this masterpiece
첫 발라드 곡이라는데 메보들 목소리 너무 잘 들리고 잘 느껴지고 다 잘한다...
이런 노래에서 조차 표현력이 너무 좋아...
수록곡으로 이런 노래 많이 만들어주라..
Jooyeon changed his singing method bc he had a throat problem, but I wanna say I love this version of soft vocal so so much too😭it makes the song sounds even more sad and souly😭💖i love you Jooyeon so so much you have an amazing voice❤
This song is so perfectly beautiful!!! Xdinary Heroes are so extra TALANTED men!!!! Their voices are absolutely GREAT!!
gunil & junhan:🧍🏽♂️🧍🏽♂️
Pagi siang sore malam good enough pokoke ❤
Sama😂❤se enak itu lagunya
Sama, gak kehitung dengerin. Padahal gak galau 😂
Hmm terindikasi anake bapak youngke👌😞 galau saklawase
Yoiii apalagi vibes nya lagi galau begini, tambah gamon deh
Woah Jungsu really slayed this
jooyeon having a throat problem but still singing so beautifully 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 especially this part 3:20 its so obvious yet it added flavor into the song 🔥🔥🔥
Jungsu being the tallest always throws me off and idk why
If it weren't for the comments I would have completely forgotten that Jooyeon had throat problems, he did amazing. They all did amazing, I love this song so much
jungsu, such a gem ♥
jooyeon,protect your throat,please!
Why is no one talking about how good ode and gaon did too….they are the rappers but sing so beautifully too
jooyeon please don't forget to take care of your voice❤
this song is so beautiful😢 they are so beautiful😍
Jungsu voice the best ❤❤
The third one from the left to right, I don't know who he is but he's so good. Love his voice so much ❤
Kim Jungsu! One of their main vocals
Jungsu vocal❤❤❤
i love this song with with all my heart
jooyeon did such a great job even after screaming to freakin bad so many times during promotions wow
Jooyeon, pls don't forget to take care of your throat! Don't think about it too much, you still sound so beautiful no matter what. I hope you will recover soon:')
주연 군!!! 자기관리도 실력이니깐...
평생 오랫동안 가수로서 활동할거니깐...
제발 목 관리 잘했으면 ㅠㅠ
저번주 부터 노래 할때, 말 할때 쉰소리 나던데...
아돌라에서 목소리가 허스키하게 잘 나오지도 않던데... 왜 본인이 말을 많이 하는지...
(다른 멤버들한테 토크 넘겨요)
아돌라에서 말할때, 노래할때 속상하고 안타깝더라구요~ㅠㅠ
주연 군은 엑디즈의 보컬이니깐 반드시 평소 목관리 잘하길!!!
말도 줄이고, 미지근한 물도 자주 마시면서 목 아껴요!!! ㅠㅠ
아직 해야할 무대가 많은걸로 아는데...
앞으로 오랫동안 계속 노래 불러야하잖아요
그러니, 건강도 자기관리도 프로답게!!!
멤버 모두다 건강관리 잘하자!!!
This and Dear H have to be some of my favorite songs at the moment
I was wondering why Jooyeon wasn't singing all out during the chorus unlike the usual, turns out he mentioned that his throat is in the worst condition. I'm glad that he is taking care of it tho and he's not pushing himself. This is just radio performance after all.
Also idk why I found it cute that he couldn't help himself but actually sing his last line all out. Although it did crack (really shows how bad his condition is I'm so sad) but it still sounded amazing.
Ok this is so cute that junhan did jooyeons scream part for him in freakin bad 😂. I hope his throat rests and gets completely better as soon as possible.
@@SueweetieAJYPN fr lol and their reactions to Junhan were so cute. I have my trust on Jooeyon and his vocal coaches. I’m sure they know when to make him lie low a bit especially during his worst conditions. Kinda like how he recovered during strawberry cake era. Tbh I really though he would suffer a big loss if he keeps on continuing singing strawberry cake before then he just surprised me during their first live performance after a few months of rest because he sounded like he recovered, almost the same sound he had during his debut. Although his voice sounded way worse now than when they were promoting strawberry cake but I’m sure they’re taking care of it now considering how he mostly sang in falsetto during the higher parts here.
That's the most adorable also heart broken crack😢
THEY ARE FREAKING INCREDIBLE. Literally sent shivers up my spine.
Jooyeon and Jungsu = perfection. If this song doesn't win a BIG award at the end of the year, I will not understand.
This is the most beautiful song to ever be made. Their vocals are so angelic
AHAhahahahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh this song literally got me into them I’m obsessed their voices are heaven
im so in love with jungsu vocals 🥺
junhan just standing still watching his hyung singing so cute imma cry t____t
This song is a masterpiece, top notch vocals ༎ຶ‿༎ຶ
I love this song so so much. It's just so emotional and the vocals are just stunning! Thank you XH for this so much
HOW DO THEY SOUND BETTER IN LIVE ❤❤❤❤
Jungsu’s voice is so amazing
I'll never get tired of listening to this song
Jooyeon did good although he have a soar throat. We are proud of you joojo!! ❤️🩹
Ga bosen.. Pagi siang sore lagu ini pokoknyaaa 💔
Jungsu's voice never fails to give me chills in my bones. Lessgo my rockstar! ❥
Really love this song, Jooyeon's vocal is very beautiful, full of emotion, the lyric very deep and meaningful, this song is a masterpiece, hope many people listen to this song
This track is so damn good!
Esta canción es perfecta. Y me atrevo a decir, que en lo que va del año, es la mejor canción que he escuchado.
Es una obra etérea, trasciende, te transporta al momento justo para sentir lo que ellos sienten al interpretarla.
ASÍ SE HACE CHICOS
Anhelo que cada día más personas conozcan el tesoro que ustedes son.
Me siento tan inspirada.
wow they are sooo good in live, also this song is perfect and it's live is even more perfect
you can really tell how much they love music and how passionate they are about it we really need more groups like this who not only preform the songs but connect to them 👏
jooyeon's vocal control maaaan
i get goosebumps listening to this.. i love their voices so much and this song is an absolute gem
Woaaah i cant stop admiring this song
Their live vocals are extremely amazing, their emotions in this song are truly no joke.. THEY DID AMAZING!!
This song is perfection, hands down. Never fails to get me in my feels
No importa en que versión escuché está canción, en todas es preciosa ❤.
이 노래 너무 좋아 요 3일 내내 하루종일 틀어요
I really love this song, it somehow attached me that makes me wanna cry and feel comfort at the same time 🤧
Jooyeon transmits many feelings when singing 💟
they way i saw this live…
One of the best b-side songs from Xdinary Heroes
The way this song hits me…
It's not a song. It's a masterpiece. Thank you for blessing my ears❤
OMFG I hope they’ll get the recognition they deserve!!!! They’re so talented I love them !
엑디즈야 노래해줘서 고맙다 진짜
Song of the year 🔥🔥🔥
Lagu favorit aku ❤️ candu banget sampe didengerin berulang-ulang
i was standing outside that window trying not to sob lmao
❤ Que voz más bella, me gusta mucho su música espero tengan mucho éxito
이주연 명창 강아띠 목 아껴⸝⸝ʚ̴̶̷̆ ̯ʚ̴̶̷̆⸝⸝
I can’t convey how much I love this song and I’m in love with jooyeon’s voice. It’s one of the best out there❤
I can no longer count the number of times I listened to this song before I go to sleep. This song is so powerful and moving at the same time. I just can't get enough of this song. ❤❤❤
I need a xh tour SO BADLY!!
Jungsu 🥺❤️
I am a stay, i love you and will always support you, i love smart/good music 🤍
정수!! 준호 느낌쓰!!!
지인짜 육각형 미남 느낌ㅋㅋ
세상에 육각형ㅋㅋㅋ
영케이❤ 준호❤ 정수❤
아 넘 좋아여❤
pretty gaon I can’t 🫠🫠😭😭
My ears are melting😩
My favorite song this comeback
Los vocals de Xdinary Heroes me tienen mal, están a otro nivel ❤
this song will go down in history as one of the best XH tracks ever
beautiful song and very good I love it.❤❤❤
Proud Villains🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Young K luar biasa banget lagu mu bagus wow❤
I LITERALLY CANNOT EXPRESS HOW MUCH I LOVE THIS SONG KAHDJENSJDKDIEHSM
Это великолепно. Я уже не знаю в который раз прослушиваю эту песню, но она поражает меня до глубинв души....
I'm so whipped. Listening to this song for the first time gives me chills and the vibe I am craving for ❤❤❤😊
YESS😭😭 i’ve played this song like 200 times already
정수 파이팅!!!!!
XDINARYS TALENT IS ONE IN A MILLION
jooyeon rest well!!! dont hurt your voice
jungsu's voice makes me so emotional
I'm obsessed with this song!!
guys, listen to their other songs!!
xdinary vocals !!
I replay this song everyday
잘했다
정수응원해!!!
Wow!!!!! That was beautiful!!!!!!!!!!! 😍😍 They sound sooo good!!! I have goosebumps!!!!!!!!!
Literally my favourite song from them 😢
JiSeok and Seungmin are amazing, Jooyeon is without doubt, one of the best vocalists ever but Jungsu just hits different for me♥
And Gunil and Hyeongjun just ahahah-ing away is enough for me. How much I love this band is insane.
every time this song goes and reaches into the depths of my soul and stirs something in me