Making Dua after the prayer and raising hands
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2019
- #HUDATV
Huda TV ... A Light in Every home
ＳＵＢＳＣＲＩＢＥ To our channel :
ruclips.net/channel/UCIVS...
Join us on our official pages for Huda Tv on:
/ huda.tv ,
/ hudatvchannel ,
www.google.com/+Hudatvchannel ,
/ hudasatellitetv ,
/ hudatv ,
www.huda.tv .
Im revert to Islam but I'm confused on so many things in Islam cz lot them have different opinions as to what to follow and what not to. don't know who's right who's wrong. I pray to Allah Almighty to guide me. Peace to all my brothers and sisters
There's 4 sunni schools of thought most people are hanafi and shafi although are 2 more. Follow one and stick to it and your intentions are pure so Allah will judge you on your intentions. Do not worry brother
Welcome to Islam brother
I would suggest you to listen only to those scholars which give refrence of quran and sahih hadith
Then follow
This sheikh is also very good in providing fikh
Juat follow any school of thought practiced in area you live
Once you do that
Then build from there
Yeah I feel you brother even as a born Muslim I'm confused by certain things but I believe in this is a test for us as well. I tend not to subscribe to this school or that school. What is best is to go to the sources yourself and be truly honest with yourself. Having said that it is easier said than done. Allah will ultimately guide you as long as you be completely truthful in your heart, this is the key.
Alhamdulillah. That's a clear explanation regarding dua. Dua is recommended both in the Qur'an and in the Sunnah.
ruclips.net/video/mzts4CIe7kc/видео.html
The Dua
"Allahumma a'inni ala dhikrika, wa shukrika, wa husni 'ibadatika"
Shukran Sheikh.
The Prophet Muhammad took hold of Mu'adh's hand and told him that he loves him, then advised him to never forget to recite after every prayer
"Allahumma a'inni ala dhikrika, wa shukrika, wa husni 'ibadatika"
which translates to "O Allah! Help me remember You; be grateful to You; and worship You in an excellent manner".
Jazak ALLAH Khairan
Masha allah thank you for clear explanation.
Now listening to this thank u
Masha Allah
Alhamdulilah It answered my concern :''')
I love the explanation, so clear to understand
JazakAllah Khair.
Alhamdulillah ❤
MashaAllah💖🤲
The peace be upon you 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
الحمد لله حاضر وجزاكم الله خيرا
Very good. Simple answer 😢
اللّهُـمَّ إِنِّـي أَعـوذُ بِكَ مِـنْ عَذابِ القَـبْر وَمِـنْ عَذابِ جَهَـنَّم وَمِـنْ فِتْـنَةِ المَحْـيا وَالمَمـات وَمِـنْ شَـرِّ فِتْـنَةِ المَسيحِ الدَّجّال
play_arrow
share
video_library
Allāhumma ‘innī ‘a`ūdhu bika min `adhābi ‘l-qabri. wa min `adhābi jahannam. wa min fitnati ‘l-maḥyā wa ‘l-mamāti. wa min sharri fitnati ‘l-masīḥid-dajjāl.
O Allah, I seek refuge in You from the punishment of the grave, and from the punishment of Hell-fire, and from the trials of life and death, and from the evil of the trial of the False Messiah
Jazaq Allah
May Allah reward you ameen.May Allah forgive and accept us ameen.
When u r confuse just go back to Quran and sunnah❤️
وعن أبي أمامة رضي الله عنه قال: قيل لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: أي الدعاء أسمع؟ قال: "جوف الليل الآخر ودبر الصلوات المكتوبات". رواه الترمذي وقال حديث حسن.
Abu Umamah (May Allah be pleased with him) reported:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) was asked: "At what time does the supplication find the greatest response?" He (ﷺ) replied, "A supplication made during the middle of the last part of the night and after the conclusion of the obligatory prayers."[At-Tirmidhi].
Book 17, Hadith 36(this Hadith was found in Riyad as-Salihin
Thanks so what about raising hands during that supplication after the obligatory prayer
Glory to be Allah 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Glory be to Allah*
@Sukai Penn
You should edit your comment to " Glory be to Allah*"
Thank you for this explanation. The problem with other explanations is that they assume the question is "can I make it mandatory to make dua'a after every single fardh prayer". All I'm asking is that is it ok for me to make dua'a at all after I pray. Sometimes I do it after Fajr, Maghrib, Isha, etc. Which is what you answered. As long as we aren't making it some sort of tradition or requirement on ourselves then its permissible. JZK.
Took the words out of my mouth MashaAllah. I was thinking the same thing
I'm still confused about it. Can you tell if it's okay if I make Dua after every fardh prayer? Not because I think it's a Sunnah but because I like talking to Allah. And what is the right way to make Dua in sujood? Can I make Dua in my own language? And can I ask Allah for the worldy things in sujood?
What I am getting from this is that making Dua in your language you are comfortable during prayer rather than after prayer... Especially not in congregation everytime... The mosque near my place does it after every congregation prayer which makes it innovative. Any thoughts?
From this sheikh and sheikh Azeemul Hakeem the thing is same. No problem sheikh has turned off the comments. It's 100% correct to save ours and his time.
IN BRIEF
1. Dua can be done after pray. But its not always a must.
2. GROUP PRAYER IS BIDATH, that bidath is following in India. Imam making dua and people say ameen... ameen... without listening or understanding the dua.
2. Better dua at thashahud and most recommend.
3. You can rise hands or not, both are permitted.
Even I am her after the video Sheikh assim al hakeem. He did not clarify that doing it in congregation is bidah, doing it individually is permitted. He put off the comments which makes him even more doubtful
@@salwashaikh4854 He probably don't want muslim to fight due to his lecture, he is not wrong bro, but I agree some people that always do the tradition will be confused due to lack of source.
Can i participate in salah but not in the dua is that okay.?
Allahuma barik❤
@@salwashaikh4854
Congregation dua AFTER SALAH is bidath. Not in ARAFAH, QUNOOTH.etc
I can’t remember this 😭😭😢
Thanks Shiikh Salah. I was confused about making dua after I saw Assim Hakeem’s vedio saying it’s innovation to make Dua after Salad..
Same here
@CrypticDoc 007 did prophet ﷺ ever make dua and raise the hand after fard salah during 23 years? if no, why not?
Assim al hakrem says that group dua is innivation. Not making dua alone.
@CrypticDoc 007 give me any hadith reference instead of calling me ignorant
@CrypticDoc 007 prophet ﷺ prescribed many duas and dhikr to be made after fard salah like this one, ayat al kursi, and other dhikr. but he never raised his hands after fard salah to make those dhikr. get your facts straight
I guess the best way to make dua ist in sujood and before taslim. Both said this same thing. And to aseem Al hakeem he said that in tahajjud it is recommended to make dua after prayer. So hope you guys Gervais clear mind and don’t think too much just be cool and spread love ❤️
Get a*
How is a non speaking arab gonna say dua in salah.
@@alphaop9143 Allah will accept your dua in any language, its not like he doesnt understand english or urdu or indonesian, etc. However, if you know the dua in arabic, it is better to say that.
@@seagull6636 i thought in salah we can only use arabic until the salam.
@@alphaop9143 That applies to the fard parts of salah. For example, you cant recite al fatihah in english or say "Allah is great" instead of Allahu Akbar. Since dua is not fard, you can do it in any language. If you know the dua in arabic tho, it is inadvisable to make the dua in another language.
Should have covered if it can be done after every jamah of every salah in congregation.
❤❤❤
Shukran jazeelaah,ustadh please taik about ladies hair,is it ok to use thread to add on your hair?
Come on we will all come to a uniting solution my brother and sisters :D
When says don’t,one says do
I think idua can be made at any time and making Dua after every fardh salaah even more beneficial.
That’ was the main point. Do not make a habit of doing it after every Fardh. Don’t just follow blindly what you have seen old family members do.
Pray and make Dua during Salah. That is the only one recommended.
Others Dua after fardh regularly is just an innovation and introduced by local clerics to keep them in the loop I fear.
May Allah guide us.
Pray. Don’t miss Salah. And make Dua during pray.
@@AJ-oo6sv how do you make dua during prayer when there is a specific set way to follow??
@@Big-gp9bi AssalamO’-Alaikum brother.
There is flexibility. Our prophet ﷺ use to hold between two sajoods as lon as the Sajda. There is time there and especially before you say Salam.
Our prophet has cleared told us that Salah is the time we are nearest Nearest to Allah. That’s when we make Dua.
May Allah accept your Dua’s. انشاء اللہ
He’s confusing the whole different things on one. I mean like, he said: the messenger of Allah surlàl Allahu Alayhi Wa Salaam gifted mua’adh (Ra) that after every fard say: “Allahummà a’innī ala zikruka washurooka wahusni ībaadatika.” but the prophet (SAW) does not say raise your hand and do this dua’a anyway. Yet, he (pbuh) used to make dua’a while he will raise his both hands smtms, raises his hand above his head, and smtms he will point out his index finger. But none of these reported to had done after fard prayer once. The misconceptions among the scholars is a misguidance for the ummah too.
May Allah grant us the understanding. Ameen
Yes now I'm really confuse since from childhood in my country we used to make dua afterevery fard prayer after I come with this Hadith's I'm really confused I ask Allah now plz guide me to right path now I'm lost what to follow and what not to follow I'm really scared of judgment Day coz I don't wanna follow Islam in a wrong way. ☹️
While making dua before Tasleem, do we still need to oscillate our finger ??
Assim Hakeem says that its not sunnah and it shouldnt be done after salah as thats time for zhikr. So please clarify as your both on huda tv.
Abdullah Yusif I used to make dua after every salah and then I seen Assim Hakeem video so I stopped because I didn’t want to do bid’ah now I am more confused.
@@faxkellerman8610
Same Brother. It would be nice if a clear reference with hadith and the tafsir behind it was given rather than opinions. We need to do things the best we can but when listening to sheikhs or imams even from the same platform (upon the sunnah etc) it can get confusing. Even with Eid salah being prayed at home. Some say yes and some say no. Insha-Allah all those giving knowledge are rewarded for their efforts. However i hope insha-Allah more clarity will be given rather than quick interpretations as we will be questioned on Yumal qiyamma on where we took our knowledge and i want to be confident with whom im taking my knowledge from as i dont want to pass on mistakes to my children or anyone i know as i will be accountable for it also for giving false knowledge. May Allah make it easy for us all.
I'd rather support this guy's fatwa than what assim said. Allah bless us all
TheMysteriousGuy 67 I don’t like channels with comments turned off. If you don’t want to answer questions that’s one thing but he prevents other people from helping with questions may allah give him guidance.
@@faxkellerman8610 I know right?
I need the doa
I choose to follow the local scholars of my locality so as long as they are rightly guided. There are so many Hadith that no scholar will be able to memorize them all that it is natural for them to create this type of confusion so best just follow the scholars that was part of your foundation when growing up
@Pinkygemz Jewellery
The scholars of my locality taught me to make duah after salaah however scholars of other countries and on this channel say that duah should be made just before the two salams whilst in the tashahud position.
Therefore I choose to follow the local scholars as they are rightly guided and have proof of what they say.
However i cannot deny that other views are different because im not a scholar of Deen I merely follow
Listen to how foolish you sound, Allah the most kind the most appreciative is abandoning you supplicating to him after prayer 😟. These hadiths and teachings are pushing so many people into a ball of confusion. Take it from me, follow your heart, stick close to that Quran , and do what pleases Allah NOT MAN! Peace n love
Actually, no. Now that you know the prophet never did that, you are obliged to follow whatever the prophet has taught us to do. Furthermore, any scholar worth his salt would rather his followers throw out his opinion, if his opinion ever conflicted with the sunnah, and follow the sunnah instead (like what imam abu hanifah used to say to his followers, for example).
Why would a layman such as yourself choose NOT to follow the sunnah, frankly, defies logic.
Salam i don't know who to follow Dr. Muhammad salah or sheikh Assim al hakim, sheikh Assim al hakim said making dua after every fard salah is a bid'ah
Please improve the sound quality.
I could not quite understand, what is the conclusion? Can someone please reiterate to me what should be done .
The question is that is collective dua after salah proven from any Sahi Hadith….. we all know after salah we should raise our hand for dua. The point is should it be collectively or individually
As salami alaikum. JazakAllahu khairan but what would you say about this Hadith?
وعن أبي أمامة رضي الله عنه قال: قيل لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: أي الدعاء أسمع؟ قال: "جوف الليل الآخر ودبر الصلوات المكتوبات". رواه الترمذي وقال حديث حسن.
Have I misunderstood?
Simple things people don't know about 🧐😳🤔
Simple question 🧐🤔
He said its okay to raise your hands in Dua sometimes, but would it be OK if by choice one were to make dua regularly (in every prayer) KNOWING its not inseparable from prayer?
@@kabulibnafghanistanalkhura7794 I don't recommend it tbh because the prophet never did this (making dua after Salah). And the prophet was the best of mankind so we should do what he did. We should refrain from innovation :D
But like you can sometimes do it but always keep in mind the prophet never did this and it's not part of islamic tradition.
If you do it regularly then it's a bida'a
3:54
Assalamualaikum, please provide the hadith reference of Muadh ibn Jabal you have claimed for verification.
Sunan Abi Dawud 1522
Can u give me the dua u said in the last please?
Jajakallah khairin....
ruclips.net/video/MynOG233EO8/видео.html
Allah humma a inni ala dhikrika wa shukrika wa husni ibadatika ❤️
Oh Allah help me to remember you to thank you and to worship you in a beautiful manner ❤️❤️
Assalamualaikum brothers and sisters, I do have a question about this. In sujood or even before tasleem, can I make dua in my own language or does it have to be in arabic?
From what I have learnt, you can do dua in your own language in sujood, I am not too sure about before tasleem. Allah knows best.
@@stayxwoke5781 Yes we can do dua in our own language in both these places. Allah knows best
Some scholars prohibit, some others allow without any conditions, some others allow with condition that he or she can't speak Arabic.
Just to exit these differences you can find duas taught by Rosulullaah Shallallaahu alayhi wasallam that match your need unless you can't find one, you can do the dua without moving your lips or just simply say it in your heart.
Wallahu a'lam
2:11
Unfortunately for many who wanna learn dua or something they need to know reference. Even if he mentioned the dua, it wasn't displayed so.. Someone provide reference so thag i can memorize it
I wake up at night and catch myself making dua for my father in my mind. Also before sleep while in bed i say thikr and dua. Is it ok that i am laying down whiles saying it?
Yes
Please do not overthink your religion, live your own life to please Allah! Get out of the brainwashing, peace
u have to move with ur lips and tongue while making dua! if u just say that in ur mind it is not accepted not valid.
u have to move with ur lips and tongue while making dua! if u just say that in ur mind it is not accepted not valid.
@@Lonelyahk30 What are you saying man?
Sahih Bukhari, adab Al Mufrad 609, please explain. It's just confusing.
Asim al Hakeem said it is not allowed to make congregational dua after Salah and can't raise your hands either neither in congregation nor alone,someone pls clear this confusion
If you are not allowed to make dua, then u are not allowed to make anything as well
Can you or someone put the dua so me can learn and pass it on
Which dua?
Theres an 'one for israel' ad before this video
I highly doubt Huda TV control the ads. It just displays whatever ad
Tahajid prey after isha prey anta sunaa
I heard properly...making these dua BEFORE taslim...
Prophet did it a lot but not after every single prayer . When you start doing it after every single prayer like its something the sahaba did after every single prayer it becomes bidah. Sometimes they did sometimes they didnt . And individually its no problem . But as a group every single time there is no hadith that said he always made a dua and everyone behind him said Ameen after every single prayer .
Show proof 🧾
Assalamualaikum , Please someone clarify this for me:
Suppose I want to make a personal Dua...for example for my exams, then how to make Dua for that In Salah? since Its Innovation to raise hands and make Dua After Salah
Make dua while you are in sujood
Make duwa in sujood during salaah and u can make it in ur own language only if u cant make it in Arabic
ruclips.net/video/PaaN6Gd3QqQ/видео.html
@@patrickbateman4095 Jazakallah Brother
@@kabulibnafghanistanalkhura7794 Brother I saw ur comment. I will make sure regarding this one since I too have a little doubt. But In Sha Allah as soon as I get the answer I will reply u brother.😀.
Making Dua and raising both hands in every obligatory prayer,it is bid ah?or sunnah?.if you say sometimes we make Dua and raising both our hands after o ligatory prayer.Where is hadith of this as evidence?
Salam, you'll find your answer in the following link:
www.islamicboard.com/showthread.php?t=134296598
Do I make Dhikr First or do I make Dua first? (I'm referring to dua after the prayer)
Thank you for watching .. Plz Subscribe and Share to share in the reward
bit.ly/HudaTv
@@HudaTvChannel You did not answer his question
As salam alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh, do we have to raise our hands when making a dua before Tasleem ?? Jazakum Allah Khayr
No just move your finger
@@phewphew402 Jazakillahu khayr brother !
@@itsmish5394 wajazakallahu khair
What is the meaning of TASLIM?
Taslim means salaam
Taslim
Is when we end our swalah by saying asalam waleikum warahmatullahi
So here the sheikh is saying we can make dua before ending our swalah
Asalam aleikum
@@naveedladha4211 jazaakalaah
@@naveedladha4211 do we raise our hand before tasleem dua?
@@shajedabegum7617
The two occasions prophet sa DIDN'T rise the hands you can listen from vedeo
1. At mimber during Friday or Eid sermon
2. WHILE MUSALLEEN. ( while at prayer) thashahud is inside prayer. YOU CAN'T RISE YOUR HANDS.
ofcourse DURING QUNOOTH you can rise your hands.
Can someone type dua in Arabic for me?
RUclips C اللَّهُمَّ أَعِنِّي عَلَى ذِكْرِكَ، وَشُكْرِكَ، وَحُسْنِ عِبَادَتِكَ
اللَّهُمَّ أَعِنِّي عَلَى ذِكْرِكَ، وَشُكْرِكَ، وَحُسْنِ عِبَادَتِكَ
Parsa Nabifar sorry I wasn’t specific, I meant the dua at the end about protection from the hellfire, punishment of grave and Dajjal.
JazakAllahu khayran brother
RUclips C اللّهُـمَّ إِنِّـي أَعـوذُ بِكَ مِـنْ عَذابِ القَـبْر، وَأَعـوذُ بِكَ مِـنْ فِتْـنَةِ المَسيحِ الدَّجّـال، وَأَعـوذُ بِكَ مِـنْ فِتْـنَةِ المَحْـيا وَالمَمـات. اللّهُـمَّ إِنِّـي أَعـوذُ بِكَ مِنَ المَأْثَـمِ وَالمَغْـرَم.
#Translation
O Allah, I take refuge in You from the punishment of the grave, and I take refuge in You from the temptation and trial of Al-Maseeh Ad-Dajjal, and I take refuge in You from the trials and tribulations of life and death. O Allah, I take refuge in You from sin and debt.
#Transliteration
Allâhumma innî a’ûdhu bika min ’adhâbi-l-qabri, wa a’ûdhu bika min fitnati-l-masîhi d-dajjâl, wa a’ûdhu bika min fitnati-l-mahyâ wa-l-mamâti. Allâhumma innî a’ûdhu bika mina-l-ma'thami wa-l-maghrami.
#References and remarks
Al-Bukhari 1/202, Muslim 1/412
RUclips C اللّهُـمَّ إِنِّـي أَعـوذُ بِكَ مِـنْ عَذابِ القَـبْر، وَمِـنْ عَذابِ جَهَـنَّم، وَمِـنْ فِتْـنَةِ المَحْـيا وَالمَمـات، وَمِـنْ شَـرِّ فِتْـنَةِ المَسيحِ الدَّجّال.
#Translation
O Allah, I take refuge in You from the punishment of the grave, from the torment of the Fire, from the trials and tribulations of life and death and from the evil affliction of Al-Maseeh Ad-Dajjal.
#Transliteration
Allâhumma innî a’ûdhu bika min ’adhâbi-l-qabri, wa min ’adhâbi jahannama, wa min fitnati-l-mahyâ wa-l-mamâti, wa min sharri fitnati-l-masîhi d-dajjâl.
What about the zikr? Like AlLahu Akbar, AstaghfirulLah, AstaghfirulLah, AstaghfirulLah ...
As far as I am knowledgeable, making dua with Jamaah with a imam while raising hands is not permissible. Allah know best. And the individual making dua after every fardh prayer while raising hands is also not permissible but if once in a while is good, but don't make it a regularity. The duas found in Arabic which were found in hadith are the dua that the prophet SAW did without raising hands and not with Jamaah. Allah Swt knows best.
Question: some say that raising hands during Dua after FARDH salah is bid'ah... They say you can raise hands during Dua on Sunnah prayers only... Is this true?
Salam, you'll find your answer in following link. Although, the first half says it's bidah but later it shows a number of Hadiths confirming that the Prophets Muhammad pbuh encouraged it.
Salaam alaikum wa rahmantu Allah wa baraktu Allah ma shaa Allah ba Ramadan Mubarak pray eveyobe Ramadan is goung well al hamdu lillah al hamdu lillah in all circumstances ameen,I thank Allah i see this post and prior a few hadith because i was told as well so al hamdu lillah for proof and evidence and striving its upon every muslim to seek ilm/knowledge verily the reminder benefits the believers al hamdu lillah Allah akbar my intention to follow link below as well if i dont already have it saved...
@@muslimahsewdecor289 Walaikum assalaam, Ramadan Mubarak to you too. Alhamdulillah the link helped you to find the truth. I was relieved to find it too! Stay blessed.
@@kabulibnafghanistanalkhura7794 Salam. I'm not a scholar but we were taught to do the following:
In the final rakat-
Recite tashahud, then Darud e Ibrahim, followed by Dua e Masura before tasleem. Lastly raise your hands for supplication starting with Rabbana atina fidduniya.... I hope it's clear enough. Sending you a link to understand it better.
ummahhelpline.com/qa/355.php
Please send me your blessings. Jazak Allah khair.
@@kabulibnafghanistanalkhura7794 It's sunnah to recite dua masura. Sending you another link:
ummahhelpline.com/qa/521.php
As for raising hand while making dua, kindly go to the very first link I sent above. We've been doing it all along. Nonetheless, please ask your imam/teacher for a thorough run through. But I'm more than happy to be of any help. May Allah guide us all. ❤
I always making dua after praying, couse i feel great my intention personal im not thinking this is obligatory, i just love to repeat my dua again and again. Because allah said he loved the one who asking him repeatedly is this haram??? Or i doing wrong? Now im confused, my allah make this easy for us..
Make dua while you are in sujood, making dua after every salah while raising hands is an innovation.
JazakAllah khair
@@secretstroger4155 sukran brother☺️
@@secretstroger4155 So in the last rakat (in last sujood), we should make dua after reading the tashahud and durrod sharif etc?
@@SKPlayZRaDiuM when you are in sujood in any rakat, after saying subhana rabbi'al-a-aala you can make dua while remaining in sujood.
@@secretstroger4155 JazakAllah khairun. So can I make dua in English or in my native language or have to be arabic?
But Sheikh Asim al Hakeem said you cannot make dua after Salah and cannot raise hands. 🤔
Sheikh assim al haleem is right , www.google.co.uk/amp/s/followingthesunnah.com/2011/12/08/not-raising-the-hands-to-supplicate-after-the-obligatory-prayer/amp/
If you can’t make dua after salah, that leaves only salah as a time to make dua. But we know that there are hadeeths that say to say so-and-so dua when you wake up or in the evening or other non-salah times…
some one says it is not recommended someone says it is wht are you guys doing
What is this astagfirullah sheikh asim is saying this is bida to make dua after fard salah and here sheikh is saying it's permissible. I mean what's wrong if i make dua to allah after salah. I mean lol ill go and tell imam that make sujood and tasleem long because i want to make dua astagfirullah. Someone is saying this someone is saying that.
For sujood just make dua whenever u pray alone or in tahajjud, there's no need to make dua if ur in the congregation cuz u might not finish ur dua, or u can make a really short dua and say it during sujood.
What the heck is going on here....
Sheikh Aasim Al Hakeem said raising hands is biddah ...you are saying it is sunnah .....
I mean what the heck 😠😬😡😡
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/followingthesunnah.com/2011/12/08/not-raising-the-hands-to-supplicate-after-the-obligatory-prayer/amp/ sheikh assim al hakeem is right
Assim and you are contradicting with each other while you are in the same channel. What is happening with you guys, you are confusing the new ummah.
Dajjal dua only during faraq..
OK thanks.
By watching this and Sheikh Assim video - You can make dua anytime... But if you make it after every prayer especially fard or especially in congregation come under innovation.
The video indicated the prophet PBUH, tabeeien and tabatabeeien did no such action no reports available as proof...
During prayer you are more closer to Allah so it is better you do it then.
once in a while after prayer is fine... Even mufti menk said he was making dua while leaving the masjid...
So any thoughts?