Stephen A. & Shannon Sharpe DEBATE 👉 Can Brock Purdy take the 49ers over the hump? 🤔 | First Take
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Stephen A. & Shannon Sharpe DEBATE 👉 Can Brock Purdy take the 49ers over the hump? 🤔 | First Take
On First Take, Stephen A. Smith and Shannon Sharpe debate whether the San Francisco 49ers can get over the hump with Brock Purdy at QB.
#ESPN #NFL #FirstTake
✔️Subscribe to ESPN+ espnplus.com/yo...
✔️ Get the ESPN App: www.espn.com/es...
✔️Subscribe to ESPN on RUclips: es.pn/SUBSCRIBE...
✔️ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on RUclips: bit.ly/SUBSCRIB...
✔️ Watch ESPN on RUclips TV: es.pn/RUclipsTV
They can't get rid of Aiyuk, not only is he one of the best receivers period, but he's also one of the best blocking WRs in the league, and Kyle's offense relies on their whole crew blocking for the guy with the ball on their hands
Yes they can how quickly we dispose of deebo what was the 9ers record with no deebo last year no deebo and aiyuk in what was the record now it's a small sample size but what was the record with aiyuk out and deebo in???? Whether ppl like it or not whether they want to admit it or not the team goes as deebo goes for some reason don't ask me how but the proof is in the W-L record they fall apart without deebo not without aiyuk and since this appears to be the case then they can probably find a replacement for aiyuk in the draft
Yeah depends on the money
And it’s hard for a qb and a wr to have chemistry like that it takes time to make that new connection and to get them going no matter how good or bad they are
Yes they can lol, nobody even knew B.A. until Purdy was QB
i agree , the shannannaannanhans rely on running behind schemed blocks
Brock Purdy isn’t the problem. It’s Kyle Shanahan not knowing rules or running the ball when he’s ahead in the 2nd half is the problem
He knew the rules but he also agree beforehand 49ers won't win the sb
@@willjimenez9013 he’s choked away 2 leads in the Super Bowl vs the Chiefs and did the same as the Falcons OC.
NFL isn’t rigged but some coaches are wildly incompetent & just not smarter than the average fan.
Wrong. The 49ers beat themselves. Darrell Luter Jr. lost situational awareness allowing a punt to hit his foot. Ray-Ray McCloud didn't follow the fundamentals of fumble recovery and instead went for the big play and didn't recover the punt fumble off of Luter Jr.'s foot. The Steve Wilks defense tried to blitz with undisguised elementary blitzes at the wrong time losing crucial downs. The defense was in odd formations that at crucial times during the game and in overtime that allowed the Chiefs to make 3rd and 4th downs. Dre Greenlaw, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, Arik Armstead and others entered the game injured, were injured out of the game or played through their injuries. In overtime backup offensive lineman Spencer Burford decided to "play on instinct" instead of following his blocking assignment Chris Jones. This allowed Chris Jones to free rush Brock Purdy on a touchdown play to Jauan Jennings. Had Spencer Burford blocked Chris Jones, Brock Purdy would have made the pass to Jauan Jennings as the space in front of Jennings was wide open. Kyle Shanahan didn't defer possession of the football in overtime, which was an error in judgment. Instead, he listened the analytics team and kept possession. Over and over, the 49ers beat themselves. Without the mistakes they would have won the Super Bowl. But they made all of those mistakes and they lost. Hopefully, the individual players and team learn from it.
Just stop
I mean he very nearly did it just now so I'm gonna go with...yes
Its a bit wonky to even have this as a debate coming out of his 2nd season and actually having a full off season to prepare rather than recover.
Purdy made a SB without an offseason to prepare, let that sink in..smdh
I’m very curious what a QB would rather have. A number one receiver, like Harrison or a number one tackle like Joe alt? I guess that’s a tough answer.
THAT topic should be a video all on it's own. Maybe take a poll of QB's to get a correct answer.
The 49ers beat themselves. Darrell Luter Jr. lost situational awareness allowing a punt to hit his foot. Ray-Ray McCloud didn't follow the fundamentals of fumble recovery and instead went for the big play and didn't recover the punt fumble off of Luter Jr.'s foot. The Steve Wilks defense tried to blitz with undisguised elementary blitzes at the wrong time losing crucial downs. The defense was in odd formations that at crucial times during the game and in overtime that allowed the Chiefs to make 3rd and 4th downs. Dre Greenlaw, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, Arik Armstead and others entered the game injured, were injured out of the game or played through their injuries. In overtime backup offensive lineman Spencer Burford decided to "play on instinct" instead of following his blocking assignment Chris Jones. This allowed Chris Jones to free rush Brock Purdy on a touchdown play to Jauan Jennings. Had Spencer Burford blocked Chris Jones, Brock Purdy would have made the pass to Jauan Jennings as the space in front of Jennings was wide open. Kyle Shanahan didn't defer possession of the football in overtime, which was an error in judgment. Instead, he listened the analytics team and kept possession. Over and over, the 49ers beat themselves. Without the mistakes they would have won the Super Bowl. But they made all of those mistakes and they lost. Hopefully, the individual players and team learn from it.
No. Not as long as Kyle Shanahan is still the 49ers head coach.
Floyd over armstead, got a dude from the bay to replace greenlaw the first half of the season
The jury is still out on Purdy
The whiners are a stacked team
Kittles & his shirts suck
Sounds like someone it mad 😂
Cj stroud is in the SAME SYSTEM as purdy and they both came into the nfl and had success but one guy gets praised because he was the second pick and one gets hate because he was the last lmaooo (i do think stroud is definitely better tho) honestly the difference is the talent and team that was around purdy too tho
The draftism is ridiculous
Stroud’s team isn’t nearly as good as Purdy’s. The Texans had one of the most ineffective run games of all time. Purdy had 6 all pros on offense alone. Stroud had none.
@@sakthithanigai5036 exactly wat i said in the end💯 and y i think hes better but they both run the same system and wat casuals dont understand is system is more important than talent all around aslong as u got a qb
@@bigmo1699 no but he inherently gets significantly less credit. You could put around half of the NFL’s QBs on the niners and they’d have lost in the SB to Mahomes.
The Cincinnati Bengals will face The San Francisco 49ners in Super Bowl 59 and will win
Shannon had a bunch of what out there
Once they pay him…they’re team will be shredded. Ball game. 😂
🚮
Purdy left the field w/the lead
in the SB. Only about 50 NFL QBs in the World can say that.
No Sophomore Slump either.
Jalen Hurts left the SB field with the lead as well…. So what are you saying?
@@anthoneykarimbey6156no, he didnt
SF will get back to the NFC Championship game as long as everyone stays healthy
😂So the lions and Green Bay will get worse huh…boy that road will even harder next year. I think not. Jordan love will only be better dude is a threat to everyone in that conference.
@@lees5953yea I forgot u could tell the future 🤣 I bet that’s what u said about Daniel jones when he went off two seasons ago and then surprised he did horrible the next 🤣💀
@@lees5953 Detroit Philly and Green Bay are not going anywhere
@@lees5953the lions will lion the packers we'll see if Jordan's for real he had an up and down season last season lets wait and see if he gets better the 9ers a proven commodity and brock didn't even have a full healthy off-season and training camp it's not an outrageous statement to say the 9ers will be back
@@terencew7716 😂just like y’all aren’t dude is a rookie deal….when you have to pay him top dollar for an average quarterback ball game…Purdy hasn’t done anything Jimmy g couldn’t do. Kyle is a silly rabbit that chokes in the game never winning a superbowl with mediocre quarterbacks.
3:29 what Shannon said about the bills 😂😂😂😂😂
4 times in a row
Knocked on the door, knocked on the door, knocked on the door, knocked on the door
Must hurt for Bills Mafia
Ayyyyyyeeeeooooooo😂
John Lynch did say on the report before that they are not at all interested in trading Brandon Aiyuk. Extending him is their top priority. John Lynch wants to keep Aiyuk for a long time. Also, Brock Purdy is only going to get better because last season was his first full season as a starting quarterback, and he's that impressive on leading the team to the Super Bowl. Also, he started the season coming off with a recovery from surgery and still being that impressive. He will have much more time to improve himself during this offseason now that he doesn't have to worry about getting well with recoveries and injuries like last offseason. Its amazing that Brock Purdy overcome his adversities.
As a cowboys I hate to admit but Brock is real deal
Casuals keep talking about Purdy being surrounded by the Avengers, but the 49ers got one of the worst olines in the league and a bunch of paper tiger slow receivers with average hands who can't beat man.
Exactly. That’s why they were getting clamped up in the Super Bowl.
Stop the Cap
As a niners fan, I agree. I mean, our line let NINE FREE RUSHERS THROUGH during the game. Including that crucial third and short where Jennings was wide open and our right side leaves Chris freaking Jones UNBLOCKED. I mean, wth is the QB supposed to do about that? I don't care how good your QB is, a free rusher is a free rusher, and it's almost always a pressure, sack, or throwaway. Even for Mahomes. We NEED to get this one. There is no B plan. It's imperative. I don't blame Brock for nothing. In his sophomore year, with no off-season, he broke the franchise passing record and got us to the super bowl, and the last time he was on the field, he got us the lead in the super bowl. What more is he supposed to do?
I put that loss on Kyle for not having his head in the game and running the ball. And also for not having his players ready for the overtime. That's the COACH'S JOB. You're supposed to get your players READY. They already have to know all the film and plays and whatnot. Little stuff like the OT rules are YOUR JOB
The O-line and CMC humbling hurt the 49ers more than Purdy’s play
Miners always making excuses, they had so many chances over the last 5 years and lost them all. Not a coincidence
Well when you play in a league where the refs rule it you can’t win niners were the best team for years they shoulda won eagles were the best team in the Super Bowl last year ravens were the better team in the afc even the bills and bengals last year but the league has decided to give it to the chiefs and let them hold in every Super Bowl they play in even if they are the worse team
@@sauceytj5714 kc was just better there is not evidence to suggest eagles or 49ers were better i 4 quarter of football last year and this year chiefs beat ravens cause patrick mahomes played his a game and the other qb did not do enough
@@Hannah-xi8yidid you watch that game??
@@Username-hd1co i did kc was better in the big moments aka second half there was nothing they could have done against kc kc being down 10 was the best thing that ever happened in that game they had the 49ers right where they wanted them you dont want to see patrick down 10 in the sb trust me patrick mahomes is always better in the big moments
Media said this exact same thing about the Broncos before they went back to back 98-99. These arguments hold absolutely no weight.
As long as kyle controls and doesn't give Purdy the offense Kyle is a choker
Someone gets it. I will never forgive Kyle for not running out the clock in my Falcons Super Bowl. He will always blow a lead.
@@andrewfalconer8599no he doesn’t get it
They need to keep Aiyuk, who allows Brock to throw downfield, and they need to find a replacement for Trent who will be retiring, and without him niners oline is Swiss cheese
It’s the last run for this version of the Niners. Aiyuk is their only outside receiver. Who’s gonna give up the first round pick and the money for Aiyuk?
Unless 49ers upgrade rightside of oline, idk.
Everyone keeps forgetting the 49ers had a 3- game losing streak. And did anyone see the performances during the playoffs- they beat thr packers by the skin of there teeth and the lions coach gave them that game 😂😂. Im not convinced. If this offense is so special 😂😂😅😅
I can pull multiple games of Patrick playing bad, with Brady, manning, and more. That’s a terrible argument every qb has had a bad stretch. The problem was the o-line and defense the defense got exposed heavily and the o-line got dominated many times.
@@Slade_Chill if it's was josh allen or lamar jackson they would be told to elevate they team with less talent. Purdy basically had an A+ team of avengers on offense and still they lost to mahomes in the superbowl.
@@dorothyhunter4656 yea because losing to Mahomes in the superbowl is bad thing knowing how much experience Mahomes have in there superbowl. Mind you that was Brock first Super Bowl. A+ offense is a stretch because that oline is bad, Debo can’t stay healthy. The offense at minimum is an A. And if you actually sit down and analyze Brock Purdy game he’s a really good qb, he can process information fast, make tight window throws, accurate, understanding how to read coverages, one of the best QBs against blitz, and getting the ball out in an efficient time. Josh Allen has talent on offense, but he just can’t get it done in the playoffs. Lamar Jackson a two time mvp, this was best chance and couldn’t do it, he choked against the chiefs. Lamar record in the playoffs leaves a lot to be desired. Don’t matter how much talent you have if you can’t get it done then it means nothing. The cowboys has had more all pros and pro bowlers than any other team and they can’t even make it past the second round.
@@Slade_Chill A+ is a stretch 😂🤣🤣😅
@@dorothyhunter4656 yes, A+ offense means you also have one the best olines which they don’t. They were bottom 15. The oline has ways been 49ers weak point.
Brock is the reason the beat Greenbay he made sum key throws that a lot of qb’s don’t attempt over the middle but this team is a second exit at best next season if they even make the playoffs i see them winning 9 games and that defense drops down a level with the talent that left and that aged
Aiyuk, Aiyuk, Aiyuk!!!
49ers will win if they don't run into mahomes
They aren’t going back the superbowl book it
@shizzoflex3121 nobody in nfc is remotely close
@@matthewwilliams4168 the eagles packers lions to name a few stop it bud
Or then Bengals
@shizzoflex3121 did any of them beat them last year?
SF have a loaded roster and they play in the NFC where in the last 20-25 years it has been wide open they’ll be back in the NFC title game and or SB
Niners win that Super Bowl if Greenlaw doesn’t get hurt and everyone who was watching that Super Bowl knows it too. It is what it is they’ll be back in the next one
LOVED it when ALL the POWER RANGERS RETURNED for FINAL BATTLE LED BY TOMMY OLIVER THE GREATEST POWER RANGER IN HISTORY
also this idea that kc was strggling because of greenlaw i dont buy with or without greenlaw chiefs would have won because patrick mahomes played his a game in the second half which is hard to beat
there is a reason patrick mahomes started off slow in the sb because then they end with a bang unless you are partrick you cant start off slow in the sb
49ers lost because kc was just better and patrick mahomes played his a game in the 2nd half san francisco did not "have their way them kc got them right where they wanted them it dont matter how much pressure you put on a healthy patrick mahomes he gonna find a way
Travis Kelce had one catch with 1 yard before Greenlaw went down. Afterwards he had 9 for 91 yards
@@Audisknfj doesnt matter did not need other guys like rashee rice so this idea that green law was slowing him down no he wasnt patrick mahomes always starts his sbs off slow to end with a bang mecole hardman and rashee rice and vs stepped up that was the plan all along to start off slow you dont want to see patrick mahomes trailing trust me chiefs were always gonna start off slow to end with a bang you werent not stopping them whe it mattered in the 2nd half and overtime
Stephen A’s Roster was wayyyy better than Shannon’s
Stacked roster this.. stacked roster that.. like maybe y’all teams should learn how to draft and adjust. 7 players remain from the 2020 super bowl team yet here they are about to run it again. Behind the 26th ranked offensive line Brock led the league in QBR (72.8), passer rating (113.0), yards per pass attempt (9.6), yards per completed pass (13.9) and passing touchdown percentage (7.0). But okay, Does he have great players around him? Yes. Should we be supportive instead of bashing the guy? Yes. Nobody wants to see Caleb with the bears like seriously. Mahomes was the 7th overall pick who had Tyreek hill, Sammy Watkins, kelce, Kareem hunt and Andy Reid in his 2nd season! Bro was blessed and has been blessed ever since.
They forgot about Hufunga coming back
I read a stat early last season that something like 92% off Brandon’s receptions go for either a first down or a touchdown down!! If that’s accurate it’s an amazing stat and that’s what makes him worth 30M.
It's like Kyle has a kryptonite for loosing superbowls. He wants everything but that. As great as they say he is. He always makes the wrong decisions when it matters. And it's all his fault because he doesn't give the players too much chance to do their thing. He has all the control. Too much control. It's all his fault. He like that coach from the water boy movie. 😂
Purdy walked off the field with the lead in the 4th and in OT, they had two chances to win by getting a stop on defense. If they don't get over the hump, it's not because Purdy can't do it.
0:15
who cares what the 49ers get to. they got 5 superbowls in there franchise. time for someone else.
Brock is a young Mobile Drew Brees.
#13 PURDY IS A GAME CHANGER 💯
SF's issue is their HC IMO.Your players not knowing OT rules is just bad coaching.
Purdy is clearly good enough to make them contenders each season because IMO they shouldn't have made the SB to begin with given how bad their defense was Vs the Lions.
The issue is their coach..who somehow always blowseads and never gets any accountability.He did it with MVP Matt Ryan and continues to do it.
He is a good coach who messes up in big spots.
The 49ers would be wise to hire Belichick
If we keep Aiyuk and another year with Jennings could give us the trio that we need to get to the next level... 3rd year Brock Purdy will be deadly barring injury next year... we're close and I feel with their Defense being better then last year we could close it out... The Injury Bug had been our Achilles Heel since Shanahan has been our Head Coach... We're get our 6th soon... God Bless Everyone... NINERRRS!!!
He showed that he can make plays. He’s top 8 qb in the league rn. The stats show it and he lead his team to back to back playoffs wins while being down. He can most definitely get over the hump
What Shannon said about putting the ball in players hands and let them do the job is true, but he should’ve pointed out the Purdy scrambles out a lot and makes some ridiculous throws
Sign him to a long term deal or draft McCarthy and restart 5 years of a rookie deal? The rest of the NFL hopes the 49ers breaks the bank and breaks up the roster.
This needs to stop! Brock put the niners in a position to win last year! He did his job, but the defense couldn't.
an extra point away, regulation outplayed Mahomes, and would have won..
The coach that’s overrated cost them and Brock purdy is overrated let’s be real
9ers have no depth too top heavy . KC was too but they had Mahomes
Nothing matters as long as they stick with that same coach
🎵🎵LEEEMUUUU EEEMMMUUUU...🎵🎵
Not against the browns they weren’t 😂😂😂
Aiyuk about to walk.
4:00 she Blinks alot
Brock Aiuk
No
Niners are loaded again but they are getting older, they have to draft and develop more now.
Brock Purdy is 24
Bosa is 26
Warner 27
Deebo is 28
AIyuk is 26
CMC is 27
Kittle is 30
Only one who is old is Trent Williams and he's 35
TF you saying lol
I'd agree if you just said that about Trent Williams, the rest of the roster is fine, just need someone to replace our anchor at o line.
The more ball control the Niners have the more difficult they will be to beat years to come.
Naw they still weren’t gonna win the SB against the Chiefs. Honestly they should’ve lost against the Packers if Love didn’t throw one of the worst picks I’ve seen lol
Chiefs shouldn’t even be a Super Bowl contender if they don’t get away with all those halls and get all these bull calls then they aren’t a threat
than you for acknowleding patrick does exist
LOL Seahawks must have hacked the WiFi network where Brock is at to be on First Take so 49ers faithful can be embarrassing 😂
i had a stroke reading this
Kyle shanahan is the problem 😂 just look at the patterns. When he was offensive coordinator for the Atlanta falcons what did he do in forth quarter. He took the ball out of his key players hand and let Matt Ryan throw. #2 he comes to the 49ers. What does Kyle shanahan do in the fourth quarter takes the ball out of his key players hand he let Jimmy g. Throw lost super bowl #2 😂😂 #3 what does he do in the forth quarter again takes the ball out of his key players hand he let Purdy throw the whole forth quarter with the #1 running offense and lose Superbowl #3😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 does anybody see the pattern 😂😂😂😂
These topics are becoming desperate and lazy. If Rex Grossman can be the starting QB for a SB team, then this argument should no longer exist. Mediocre QB's can take their team to a SB, so long as the rest of their team is complete. SF is complete. Next.
He didn't do well in the SB. So no.
No not close purdy is a bottom five qb
Great QBs are drafted to teams that snck! Brock Purdy sncks n is on a great team!
@gunner-qf9eh 49ers at .706 with Brock Purdy! Sure not lying! 🤮🤮🤮
Alex Smith .813
Kaepernick 1.
Kaepernick .813
Jimmy G .813
Numbers don't lie...Brock Purdy sux! 🤮🤮🤮🤮 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@gunner-qf9eh Steve Young, Kaepernick and Dobbs are the only Ivy QBs the 49ers ever had and you want a dnmb azz running the offense. Kyle Shanahan ain't doing it! 🤣🤣🤣
@@theophilusone7you're a 🤡 and a liar, Purdy has a .77 career winning percentage, including the post-season. He just turned 24, it's his first full season as a starter, and he hasn't had an off season yet.
Go be a cowboys fan, so you can cheer for Lance in the pre-season.
Once they pay him…they’re team will be shredded. Ball game. 😂
Purdy won’t even win a SB, that I know for sure
0:14
aiyuk is overrated 😂😂😂
Scooby Doo “runch a riggers on there”
No Brock Purdy can not take the 49ers over .....He needs the weapons without those guys hes very average ....
Those same weapons didn’t put up the numbers they did this year under Jimmy G. Purdy elevated that offense by many miles
Deebo and Kittle had better years with Jimmy G stop the cap smh😂@@paulreyes6221
@@paulreyes6221 Purdy 0-3 without them and we saw how poor he was against Baltimore and in the playoffs he's an average QB on a great team 🎯
@@CoachRJ334 tired argument. He won games in his rookie year without Deebo and BA had a breakout season because of him. Kittle didn’t have 1,000 yard season since 2019 until this past season. You say he was poor in the playoffs, yet he made a bunch of clutch plays. And guess what happened to Baltimore? Choked against Mahomes as usual.
@@paulreyes6221 I'm done arguing with you yahoos ....Purdy is average until proven otherwise 🗣️🗣️🗣️.