I couldn't agree more, though the "Echoes Part 1" from Live at Pompeii is what I always think of, or any number of incredible live performances like this. That bass line during the "Funk Movement" makes all the difference in the world. I definitely prefer live versions of Echoes over the Studio version for this reason alone. It's only a few extra notes, but goddamn it makes that section SO MUCH FUNKIER! It's my favourite piece of music ever created. -
@@rchuso This is special, is after pink and i like too... but this is the first version of echoes i ever heard, is brute, is power... (and stoned jajaja)
What I cannot fathom is how Pink Floyd always play in such musical synchronicity, each member is a master of their own instrument. And all equally contribute in creating this unwordly atmosphere within their music. This is precisely why they are the greatest band in the history of rock and roll.
Funny thing is…only David was extraordinary in his primary instrument. However, the other 3 knew their limitations but even better, knew how to incorporate their craft into a magical mesh with the other members
Roger is not really a great bassist. He admitted that Dave plays the bass lines in many of the studio cuts, and there's the slight problem of his being tone-deaf and thus not always being able to tell when his bass would go out of tune on stage. If he noticed, he'd have Rick tune it, if he didn't, Dave would come over and tune it for him.
I'm Jealous! I saw Led Zeppelin and Moody Blues that year in the Coliseum, but not PF. And this song has been in my top three favorites since '71. By any chance do you have the bootlegs?
I saw them in 1971 at the paramount in Seattle and at hec edmundson pavilion in Seattle 1972. They were a lot better in the Dark Side of the moon tour than the Echos tour.
Je l ecoute encore ce soir pour lamillieme fois ... que du plaisir , et surtout depuis plus de createurs plus debonne musique . Ce monde m'ennuie alors vive les60et 70...
Echoes x me migliore brano della loro storia musicale .li ho visti a Rotterdam nel 1971 e'stata una magia pura.si era stato da pochi mesi ricoverato in un manicomio xche'viveva di acidi.x me quelli da me visti avevano un carisma unico quando Roger si stacco,e'mancato qualcosa di magico.però la loro musica rimarrà x la eternita' dentro di me.fanno parte della mia vita.ho 74 anni quando li ho visti ne avevo 22 e vivevo in Olanda,la magica Olanda tempi strepitosi mentalmente più avanti di tutti in Europa.in un parco sosta vano giornalmente 200000mila giovani.parco messo a disposizione dalla regina d'Olanda.ogni settimana venivano gruppi musicali atmosfera magica.in quei tempi si faceva l'autostop e si viaggiava x l'Europa.altri tempi.Dainese Aldo.
Esto simplemente es una joya musical..... Pink floyd es más que una canción..... Sir David Gilmour y sus solos de guitarra tan diferentes creando atmósferas únicas en cada canción.... Rick poniendo la magia de sus manos en la canción.... Nick, con el ritmo y el latido mágico del corazón floydiano.... Habrá un video en las redes de esta presentación en vivo....???
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band? I think it's audacious to say that.
@@milkywayexplorer942 Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band? I think it's audacious to say that.
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band?
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band? I think it's audacious to say that.
@@Oh_I_Will God you're such a fucking prick. I've seen you in a few different comment chains being a pure asshole. Just listen to the music & shut the fuck up.
t18amgr Second chorus. Should be “no one speaks and no one tries.” Gilmour sings “something speaks and something tries.” And then it sounded like he was trying to correct himself in the last line of the chorus “no one flies around the sun” but didn’t quite get it.
. Original: "no on speaks and no one tries" to: "something speaks and something tries" as in technology AI starting to "speak".. Humans have lost. And the next part he says "no one flies around the sun" as in the great deception of governments not really spending money on exploration, but instead on the "something" that is consuming our humanity.. Technology. The original lyrics are "deep", but the rearranged lyric work just as well and in my opinion are even deeper.
![FendiDa Rappa - Clock Dat ft. Shamar Marco [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3NBU8KHdxYY/mqdefault.jpg)
This is probably the best song ever made
Sicuramente!!!
Totally agree. I love seeing the actual video of this in Pompeii.
It’s good…but best ever….nah
It is
it's close.... "to the edge"@@Oh_I_Will
When one whole world is compressed into a song...
I wish I could go back in time and listen to this again for the first time.
Same. It was almost a religious experience
Echoes. Shine on you crazy diamond. Child in time. Stairway to heaven. The best.
Right in the apple
Stairway…..LOL
69 year old loooong time fan. seen them many times . this song is just pure greatness.
i'm catching up to ya and I agree
What difference does your age make???
The “funky movement” of Echoes is the greatest 4 minutes in the history of music.
I couldn't agree more, though the "Echoes Part 1" from Live at Pompeii is what I always think of, or any number of incredible live performances like this. That bass line during the "Funk Movement" makes all the difference in the world. I definitely prefer live versions of Echoes over the Studio version for this reason alone. It's only a few extra notes, but goddamn it makes that section SO MUCH FUNKIER! It's my favourite piece of music ever created. -
this is far the best echoes i heard in my life... i heard a lot of version and I still prefer this
For the first half of the song? Absolutely! Still like the studio album for the 2nd half.
What about ruclips.net/video/fZBOCbX2v8o/видео.html - I think that's perfection.
Live at Pompeii, all 23 minuets.
Live at Pompeii is the best IMHO, get the live DVD.
@@rchuso This is special, is after pink and i like too... but this is the first version of echoes i ever heard, is brute, is power... (and stoned jajaja)
What I cannot fathom is how Pink Floyd always play in such musical synchronicity, each member is a master of their own instrument. And all equally contribute in creating this unwordly atmosphere within their music. This is precisely why they are the greatest band in the history of rock and roll.
Funny thing is…only David was extraordinary in his primary instrument. However, the other 3 knew their limitations but even better, knew how to incorporate their craft into a magical mesh with the other members
Roger is not really a great bassist. He admitted that Dave plays the bass lines in many of the studio cuts, and there's the slight problem of his being tone-deaf and thus not always being able to tell when his bass would go out of tune on stage. If he noticed, he'd have Rick tune it, if he didn't, Dave would come over and tune it for him.
I agree completetely. I was there in 1972 and since than I come back to recordings like this to enjoy the balance of emotional bliss
I saw them do this Sept 29 1972, a year later in Seattle.
I'm Jealous! I saw Led Zeppelin and Moody Blues that year in the Coliseum, but not PF. And this song has been in my top three favorites since '71. By any chance do you have the bootlegs?
You saw them….ok, tells about what you remember
I saw them in 1971 at the paramount in Seattle and at hec edmundson pavilion in Seattle 1972.
They were a lot better in the Dark Side of the moon tour than the Echos tour.
I think this Echoes is best live performance.
Amazing!
Je l ecoute encore ce soir pour lamillieme fois ... que du plaisir , et surtout depuis plus de createurs plus debonne musique . Ce monde m'ennuie alors vive les60et 70...
2h43 - 27 / 01
Simply the best Band Ever! Words and music just as one...It fills my mind! Beautifully strange music.
Pure magic with raw instruments...
Top 3 band of all time
Vraiment une version très spéciale. Merveilleux !
pépite - c'est vraiment le titre le plus emblématique du Floyd que j'aime ; une construction sans faille , du béton pur -
the best music work of PF je l ecoute tous les jours et meme toutes les nuits !! il y a tant de versions differentes !! genial
un pur chef d'oeuvre!
Du génie à l'état pur
Gilmour's voice and guitar are perfect
But lyrics…not so much, but who cares
Echoes x me migliore brano della loro storia musicale .li ho visti a Rotterdam nel 1971 e'stata una magia pura.si era stato da pochi mesi ricoverato in un manicomio xche'viveva di acidi.x me quelli da me visti avevano un carisma unico quando Roger si stacco,e'mancato qualcosa di magico.però la loro musica rimarrà x la eternita' dentro di me.fanno parte della mia vita.ho 74 anni quando li ho visti ne avevo 22 e vivevo in Olanda,la magica Olanda tempi strepitosi mentalmente più avanti di tutti in Europa.in un parco sosta vano giornalmente 200000mila giovani.parco messo a disposizione dalla regina d'Olanda.ogni settimana venivano gruppi musicali atmosfera magica.in quei tempi si faceva l'autostop e si viaggiava x l'Europa.altri tempi.Dainese Aldo.
this is so good you don't even need drugs, but since i'm high all the more enjoyable!!
I never needed drugs to enjoy their music.
@@milkywayexplorer942 You don't need drugs to enjoy Pink Floyd, Pink Floyd makes drugs more enjoyable
Esto simplemente es una joya musical.....
Pink floyd es más que una canción.....
Sir David Gilmour y sus solos de guitarra tan diferentes creando atmósferas únicas en cada canción....
Rick poniendo la magia de sus manos en la canción....
Nick, con el ritmo y el latido mágico del corazón floydiano....
Habrá un video en las redes de esta presentación en vivo....???
In the prescence of perfection.
this is awesome i love this soo much
First heard this on purple microdot back in '75 .
Congratulations
Echoes best version of all times
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band?
I think it's audacious to say that.
my favourite Song of PINK FLOYD 🎶🎵🎸🎶🎵
me too,at infinity💫
Definitely some of the best music ever written
Have heard many versions including being there live. This is in the top two. Thanks for the upload.
Why 2 !!?
@@milkywayexplorer942
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band?
I think it's audacious to say that.
La magnificenza in musica
Lejos mi tema preferido...
25 minutes already???👏👏👏 Amazing
Just a few days before playing at Pompeii (October '71)... interesting comparison of both versions ;-)
I can't believe it's very old music, but on the other hand, I also think it's a sound that can't be created in this century or in the future.
Love the baseline
Holy Shit!
excelente cancion , la BBC lo transmitio en vivo a la radio WNEW FM de new york; la version dura 27:15
Perhaps the best version.
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band?
WARNING :
don't watch on full screen while high
don't watch on full screen while high
don't watch on full screen while high
Actually the best version
Be careful not to confuse a good version with a good recording. In this case it is an excellent recording. Soundboard quality. But is it really the best version ever performed by the band?
I think it's audacious to say that.
@@gabrielsacks5267 stop with the Copy Paste crap please. We heard you the first 3 times….sheesh
@@Oh_I_Will Be careful. :P
@@gabrielsacks5267 or what…you gonna shadow ban me…you gonna report me or do you have to ask your husband first
@@Oh_I_Will Be careful. Or i will get my axe.
Watch echoes in Pompeii. Best live recording
Sicuramente!!
Rick is on every note this is why David can't play it any more.
No it’s not…you Dolt
@@Oh_I_Will God you're such a fucking prick. I've seen you in a few different comment chains being a pure asshole. Just listen to the music & shut the fuck up.
Have this on vinyl.
wow! how did you find it?
That is way cool.
This version?
Esse solo bate de frente com o de 'pompeii'
Logicamente. Esse show foi apenas alguns dias antes da gravação do filme...
a mon avis leur pièce maîtresse -
So stoned they confused the lyrics
Where?
t18amgr Second chorus. Should be “no one speaks and no one tries.” Gilmour sings “something speaks and something tries.” And then it sounded like he was trying to correct himself in the last line of the chorus “no one flies around the sun” but didn’t quite get it.
. Original: "no on speaks and no one tries" to: "something speaks and something tries" as in technology AI starting to "speak".. Humans have lost.
And the next part he says "no one flies around the sun" as in the great deception of governments not really spending money on exploration, but instead on the "something" that is consuming our humanity.. Technology.
The original lyrics are "deep", but the rearranged lyric work just as well and in my opinion are even deeper.
Btw David Gilmour was sooooo cute
John Peel show
pompeii version>all
No it’s not…there are better edited versions