China repeating Soviet Union's mistake
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- [03/27/2024 uploaded]
🫐 Blueberry Creative Spring Blossom Sale 🫐
👉 Use this link for 15% off on all products code "David"
lanmeiyoupin.shop/en
⭐️ Free shipping over 70 USD (US Only)
==========================
My social media:
Instagram: / chinainsiderwithdavidz...
X or Twitter: / davidzhang360
Gan Jing World: www.ganjingworld.com/zh-TW/ch...
==========================
⭐️ Support me and my work ⭐️
Donate to support me: donorbox.org/china-insider-wi...
==========================
Subscribe for the latest:
- Daily News and Analysis on China's political landscape.
- Exposing Communism in China
- Expertise in the geopolitics of US-China
It's like they're advanced at faking stuff.
Even more super advanced at "stealing" stuff 😂
@@c.yamaura4239 Many, you beat me, I was going to say innovative in theft.
中国一直在偷窃其他国家的技术，而且现在还在偷，你们知道spacex吗？spacex开放火箭回收等技术给全世界，但是中国拿到这些技术后马上申请了专利！把那些技术占为己有了！并且中国发明的“中国版星舰”和spacex的星舰一模一样！同时“中国版回收火箭”也和spacex的猎鹰9一模一样！这种盗窃行为中国墙内一直都是公开的事实！甚至没人批评这一行为！而且，中国在用着这些技术的同时，还贬低和攻击spacex！
火箭技术只是其中一个例子，中国盗取的美国技术还包括openai的AI大模型和特斯拉的汽车技术等。
而且你们不知道的是中国墙内局域网中所有能发展起来的应用平台、APP和商业模式等，全都是盗取的美国的！最典型的就是微信、淘宝、和微博等，这些分别是脸书、亚马逊购物和ins。
Tofu dreg... aka Chinese pensions
vranya
BYD wanna be Tesla, Baidu wanna be Google, Alibaba wanna be Amazon, etc. Laughable and cringy..
In a very very cheap way😂
Dear Mao wants to be Uncle Sam.
Xinnie the Pooh and his party certainly DRESS like Uncle Sam, with their bashing the west while wearing western suits and colonial nooses (ties), sending their kids to Harvard, while telling the masses to be proud of their ''culture', it's ironic for sure.
China wants to be the United States of America.
Google and Amazon are evil
The CCP aims to crush independent thought. The problem is that these original, creative thinkers, are the people who come up with new inventions and innovations.
When you have cash, you can buy anyone you want from anywhere you want.
And that is what they are doing, same as USA was doing for last decades.
Currently, China leads in many technological fields, because they pay at least 2x the salary compared to USA.
If you had watched at least some other sources aside of garbage channels like these, you would have known that.
The chinese people need a fresh start, they deserve to be heard and not led through hell once again
Poor Chinese people, they always get a lousy government out of pure bad luck. After a few millennia, maybe it's time to lay the blame where it belongs, at the feet of the populace who enable the government.
I'm worried about China. It is supposed to be the next world power, but it looks like it needs more freedom, which the current regime doesn't provide at all.
You can do pretty much anything you want as long as you stay away from politics.
It's actually sad. When I look at Taiwan, I see the potential of what China could become. Both are of Chinese ancestry. It's like two brothers that left home to find their way and lot in life. They came to a point where the road divided into two going-off in different directions. One chose one road, while the other chose the other road. One chose wrong, and one chose right.
@@albin2232 Not really.
China is unfree in many ways. Lack of economic and intellectual freedom, Rule of man rather than rule of law, Hukou system, corruption etc...
@@albin2232 Damm that abusive.
That call you are being owned by CCP and yes you just didn't realise it
What a cruel world like an animal
@@seekthetruth1478 completely agree. I see Taiwan as the most authentic and positive version of China, that is actually true to its cultural and historic roots. Imagine if the mainland had chosen capitalism first... instead of the stinking tofu dreg it is today.
There were 12 "top level" educated Chinese engineers at the Shanghai engineering office. One of them told me his teacher told him he taught him everything he needs to design a jet engine. He told me there is nothing I can teach him. I just smiled and put that in my memory bank. Sounds like the later Chinese generation is not any better.
very proud to call myself not china
You aren't a landmass/country?? No way!
@@jakejutras5420 You get no bitches?? No way!
ccp destroyed the image of ancient China, the culture of ancient China, Chinese people should revolt all over the nation and reclaim their nation.r
A moron would never know how stupid he is, this felt proud
You are not CHINESE, you are just a 🇺🇸🇬🇧🐈🐕
What innovation, when they only copy? And in inferior quality?
Yk China tried to copy Nvidia but their GPUs literaly got 1 fps in 4K on cyber punk 🤣🤣🤣
History is like a cycle repeating and repeating!
Aided by forgefulness and total illiteracy and ignorance.
At least technology have gotten better and accessible, for now :)
@@Zyzyx442 agreed,but right now is similar to the time before ww2
@@kevinsun0711 In some aspects it is, but in general the world is completely different to 80 years ago
@@andreaslukas2252 The world is different but people aren't.
Excellent understanding of the violent, terroristic nature of the CCP. The loss of legitimacy of the CCP and its deadening impact on innovation and individuality are admirably explicated.
I’ve actually been receiving the mailing pamphlets from Shen Yun myself in California for a few years now. With the CCP threatening a humble theater show, that not only demonstrates its massive insecurity, but solidified an eventual purchase of my ticket. How comical of them. Can’t wait to see the show next time it’s in town.
Thank you David, As always excellent topic!
I have been saying much of the same thing for quite a while now. And the continued weakening of the Chinese economy at the hands of the CCP will also weaken them militarily as well. There’s a reason why they haven’t gone after Taiwan yet, it’s because they can’t. With the U.S. being involved in protecting Taiwan, China would be going to war with not only the U.S. but NATO as well. In China’s current state, this is not a war they can win, and would ruin the already shaky legacy Xi has, as well as would be the end of the CCP. So they can’t, because they know they will lose, and they know they will lose power, so everything that comes out from them is nothing but bluffing bluster and saber rattling.
Agreed. I think what happened to Russia in Ukraine gave Xi much to think about, especially the poor performance of Russian (Soviet) weapons. Since many of China's weapons are (you guessed it) counterfeits of Soviet weapons he is rethinking his war plans. I know it's popular to say that the US has rotted and now is only a paper tiger but I do believe they would prevail in a war against China. It's not that the US is so strong, but that China is so weak. Their soldiers have poor weapons, poor training, a corrupt leadership, and no battle experience. Not a winning formula.
Well said David!!
oh wooow, thanks for the vid ❤
Be careful if you're into collecting coins...there all over it.
I have seen some of their old coin counterfeits. Knock offs are second nature to communists. Morally bankrupt. Half of Chinese students admitted to US colleges cheated in admissions. And that doesn't include students who are expelled afterwards for cheating.
Great job moefokah God bless you and your family. Continue doing great work and reports honest reality wants happen inside ccp..
Hey, any thoughts on that suicide bombing that killed 5 Chinese people and their local driver? They mentioned the car was filled with explosives, so I wondered if the driver even knew and if the Chinese people were the targets, given how the CCP is doing other sketchy things.
Literally I believe that at least 80% of the sketchy stuff in the world is done by either China, Russia, or US. These countries keep stirring up heat everywhere, assassinate targets, overthrow governments etc.
Thank you for reporting this.
"Mobilization and fast productions" are the best characterizations of the CCP.
Quality and human life are not the priority.
In the civilized world, it needs a step by step procedures but the quality will last forever.
That is China in a nutshell, fast production and cheap.
It's actually sad. When I look at Taiwan, I see the potential of what China could become. Both are of Chinese ancestry. It's like two brothers that left home to find their way and lot in life. They came to a point where the road divided into two going-off in different directions. One chose one road, while the other chose the other road. One chose wrong, and one chose right.
Taiwan broke the typical pattern: they chose freedom over repression. How...un-Chinese.
One chose Left, there is the Left, and there is Right.
China: We want to be the Soviet Union 2.0!
Me: *remembers that the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991*
Me: I don't think that means what you think it means.
Thank you David
China's Motto " If you cant beat em STEAL em"
Absolutely right. Great analysis on fundamental issues China(CCP) is confronting.
Awesome video 📹 my buds
Excellent video, thank you.
It's so refreshing to hear actual points being made instead of just saying communism is bad over and over
The breaking test seems to have broke things just fine.
great video!
Well done David, "China before communism!"
Hey David! Have you ever thought of making a video about what led you to start this channel and maybe how you grew up? Love your vids !
Maybe I should !
So well explained. You have the words I've been looking for.
Actually, the CCP was not started by the proletariat, but by the peasants. The proletariat are industrial workers. There is a big difference. Mao himself was from a prosperous peasant background.
The thing about this is that Marxism assumed that the revolution would start in industrialized countries with a large industrial proletariat. Marx assumed the revolution would start in countries like Germany, the UK and the US. Don't forget the communist slogan, "WORKERS of the world unite" (emphasis mine). The fact that it started in a country, Russia, which was underdeveloped industrially, would have appalled Marx. He believed that countries must progress to that industrialized stage to have a Marxist socialist revolution. Heck, Russia had only abolished serfdom in 1861.
What the Marxist-Leninists did in Russia was to offer the peasants "free stuff". Of course, this free stuff had to be taken from someone. That was the bourgeoise, of course. The ironic thing is that they then took it away again. The Chinese communists were trained in Russia.
The CCP’s main problem is young people reject it and its ideology. Material satisfaction and the political stability that flows out of it, will never answer people’s fundamental need for freedom and human dignity. Its weakness was shown up in the post COVID protests last year in which people demanded an end to the Emperor mentality underpinning the Chinese political system. A top bottom approach longer works. To be sure, the Party survived the protests but its future isn’t guaranteed in a country in which dynasties have come and gone.
Bingo 👍🏻
The ccp has SARA AI, and she is younger and beautiful.
And she speaks with an accent, but it’s not a Chinese accent.
Sara speaks with middle East accent; Farsi, Arabic or Palestinian.
@@jamesblair9614that's due to the 5g technology
Very very good explanation David.
Ferengi plus Pakleds vs the Federation.
China needs to model itself ala Singapore / Taiwan...
I am a Chinese American through naturalization and I am very proud to not be a Chinese 😊
David, your analysis is spot on.
Thank you, David! This is essential info to knowing the truth about China. So many geopolitical analysts in the West don't see this. China hangs around other countries offering to build infrastructure while planning how to infiltrate and steal resources from that country. Mexico is a recent example of this. Would love to know your thoughts on this infiltration strategy of the ccp.
Great topic, learned another aspect of communism and why the world sjould stay far away from it. The human element is missing in that ideology, which drives the human spirit to advance, learn & grow. ❤🇺🇲🙏 Thank you again for your intel.😁🇺🇲
Karl Marx did not understand human beings so he didn't factor the human element into his theories. He just assumes that people are meat widgets who have no dreams, aspirations, or will of their own and will just automatically do what they are told to do. That is the main reason Communism never works. Humans aren't interchangeable units. NPCs.
modern China is difficult to compare with the USSR because China has a market economy. Of course, the state interferes with it, but even in such a reduced form it provides stability to the system. The same can be said about Russia
After seeing these videos those days aren't far when china can even make human copy of Bezos zukerberg 😅.
I like the brutal honesty of this guy
Thanks for your sincere and good news, about ccp,and praying for Chinese people that some day things will happen soon, God bless..
So true lol everything is "great" as if it's a frosties cereal commercial:
"Very Great movement for the great people symbolizing the great party that will lead us to the great future so we can all be great and have a great time sometime".
"Central Planning" doesn't work
Communism and central planning are great in theory, but when planning and power are centralized, human nature takes advantage of the power and things go downhill. Xi must be an idiot to have not learned the lessons of the 20th century when most undergraduates understand them well, but it's also human nature to think "I can avoid the mistakes, this time will be different!". Just can't seem to keep his hands from getting stuck in that honey jar.
There is no "central planning", it's just a smoke screen that the CCP likes to say to enrich themselves and control others.
You've made some great points and earned yourself a new subscriber! ❤
Another good video. I don’t expect you are on the CCP’s Christmas card list.
They send me flowers sometimes 😃
I agree, communists/socialists/dictatorships suppress people therefor creativity innovation and curiosity. That is against human nature.
Good summary. Thank you
Excellent commentary
And they have the audacity to blame others for stealing lmao.
The braking test worked perfectly ----
The computer in the car was ordered to break every bone in the skater's body.
So yes ---- technically --- it passed the breaking test --- but not the braking test ---- English is so confusing.
You're missing a core reason for China's demise. Their culture dictates that if you take any risk and fail, then YOU are tagged a "failed person" in their society and are never given another chance to try again. THAT is why they steal proven technology rather than taking the risk of experimenting and developing their own technologies. By contrast, the US provides a fantastic living laboratory for people to try, fail, learn and try again WITHOUT the social stigma of being a "failed person". In fact, we applaud "fail often, fail fast, rinse and repeat" rather than vilify it. It's CULTURE.
History may not repeat, but it sure does rhyme.
first 🎉
I mean, Shen Yun is just as cultish as the CPC, but that doesn’t mean they should be any more stifled than any other group.
you also stated this number of "5000 years of civilization", but what is this number actually based on? I have asked this question for more than a year now and no one could ever give me an answer. 4000 years I get, it is based on the mythical Xia dynasty, and while I reject it, I understand what it is based on. But what is the 5000 years supposed to be based on.
The beginning of China’s history is set as the rule of Emperor Yan.
@@ChinaInsiderWithDavidZhang ok. Albeit I reject that as well, This character is even more mythical than the Xia dynasty. I personally start "chinese" history no sooner than the Han empire.
brilliant rundown
Thanks!
Thank you!
Looking good these days
Good summary
I saw Shen Yun a couple of weeks ago on the Gold Coast Australia. It is anazing !!
Great presentation. We need more focus on China to create better understanding and rapprochement.
:26 Come on!!!! It did stop!!!! /s
I love the Chinese people and their history and civilisation. It's not such a "free World" as you assume elsewhere where people are not really free but slaves to big business. Voting every 4 years for politicians sponsored by big business is no freedom. Now you have a one party state in US using state and legal power to jail the regime's political rival. What "freedom" is that?
Still better than working 12 hour everyday 6 days a week , still living conditions and shit wages
they r evolving just backwards
Market Socialism like all its other forms, unfortunately tends towards failure. We know what works.
It's sad that China hasn't been able to learn from it's long long history, even if they didn't know what to do, they should have already learned what not to do. I guess when you don't learn from history, you are doomed to repeat it. In plain and simple terms a revolution by the people is needed for reform. But this time, it needs to be the majority, not minority of people to take their country back
Xi Xi Ping: Write that down!
My boy back with the factz
this year or the end of next year, I’m feeling this year is not good, something will be change soon
I disagree, one can find the same Han supremacy, racism, xenophobia and authoritarian rule in Singapore, a country supposedly based on Confucian values. Lee Kuan Yew was a prominent member of the triads, where they operate with impunity. One can check the July 2019
Orchard Towers Murder case to see how the law actually protects the triads.
Chinese societies have some serious problems and it’s simplistic to just blame the CCP. Actually because of Chinese mentality, thugs like the CCP could take control. And one must remember Taiwan’ Koumintag has also connections with the triads.
In Thailand, drugs and prostitution are in control of Thai-Chinese, thus they have opposed legalisation.
This is not about being anti-Chinese or anything but one must identify the root causes to address the problems in Chinese societies
Except the CCP isn’t a “Han” problem. It’s a western ideology and it has no place in Chinese culture.
You are talking about Marxism and Communism? Anyone with any experience on the ground in China knows those ideologies are just window dressing, Communists officials love money more than anyone.
Yes, it’s a Han problem because in you look at Chinese history, this is not the first time genocide is being committed in China. An Hui province was a Miao kingdom as late as the 7th century; all wiped out. Same for Dali Kingdom, the Bo people in Sichuan.
And where are the Manchus? Totally destroyed as a people, they even lost the name of the country, now it’s Dongbei.
And this is not only happening in China. The first Han settlers in Taiwan went there to work for the Dutch tin mines. The country was mainly inhabited by ingenious people. Now they are a minority, treated like scum.
Again, Singapore is a fine example why this is not only a problem of the Chinese government but it has deeper causes because in Singapore, it’s the same Han supremacy, racism and xenophobia. The Malay minority is treated there as scum. They are 5% of the population but 70% of inmates in prisons are Malays
Soviet Union? There are also elements of 1920s to mid 1940s Imperial Japan in the mix.
Interwar / WW2 Era Imperial Japan compared to present day People's republic of China
Army faction vs Navy Faction internal strife is comaprable to the Beijing / "Hardliner Communist" versus the Shanghai / "More liberal" cliques / factions.
Both nations in their eras experienced economic sanctions / embargo that lead them to rely on other means of getting the raw materials their economies desperately need.
Both nations want to expand their territory as a buffer against encroaching Western Powers
There are a lot more comparisions I can make.
Yet see what Japan went through in the post war. I loved your historical context here!
"Removing individuality" Any church methodology.
Winnie the Pooh will run out of honey soon.
if CCP collapse hope Taiwan help china to have transition government
Douglas MacArthur had an argument once with one of his subordinates about dictatorship vs. democracy - MacArthur's stance was that dictatorship works only during times of crisis and once the crisis was over, democracy must be restored. Lee Kwan Yeuw was a pseudo-dictator and built the modern day Singapore - but he used free-market capitalism to power Singapore - a big difference from a planned Soviet style economy.
China's ten-dash line ambition could be what brings them down.
終國萬碎
I think these videos need to be archived
“culture and value is the antithesis to communism” thank you, this could also go for many other insidious “isms”
Environmental reviews, court reviews, etc.
Yes, the Soviet Union beat the Germans, but you must remember that the US was supporting them just as much as we were supporting the UK with "lend lease." If you look up the number of war machines and weapons (tanks, planes, trucks, jeeps, etc) and amount of ammunition and food (millions of tons of food and bullets and shells) that we sent to the USSR, you'll be pretty shocked. We sent thousands of train locomotives and rail cars. Etc etc etc. Without the US, the USSR would have had a much, much harder time. And, then, the USSR turned on the US. Oh well.
Communism never truly ended in russia.
Was that a person in the brake test video
I can see you avoiding using the name Falun Gong, but it would seem you are quite closely connected.
Do you want to clarify?
Hitler used defeat(humiliation) in WWI for WW2 aggression now XI-tler is using 100 years of humiliation for its aggression on the way to WW3 towards its own destruction like the former USSR for it need to shoulder alone the mintenance cost of its military and its hardware, as compared to distributed cost to USA and its allies
Do you say happy Easter?,…, I did not
😂
Wow. I've seen quite a few anti-China channels, This one is surely in the top three. This should keep haters sleep well at night.
A more planned economy is required for high technology manufacture which requires long supply chains to work. For example a car manufacturer could not start up unless someone else decides to simultaneously set up to provide the steel in close proximity. You need the vertical integration to cut production costs. A nation of shop keepers though is more suitable to a free market system because the traditional shop was efficient on a small scale and could be family-owned. With small business the consumer is faced with a wide choice. Monopoly suppliers break free market rules. Each type of business has an optimum scale it can run at. Take a look at Germany post WW2. It was categorised as a capitalist country, but was one of the most socialist of those called capitalist. The US is considered capitalist, but it has lost its manufacturing economy. There are many other factors also, like the US reserve currency status.
even copying failures. Classic copycats
Could you tell us something about persecution of religions in China? There are very few sources of data about this and many people would want to hear Your opinion.
Evil makes you stupid.
LG