What Really Happens When A Sub Catastrophically Implodes
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 июн 2023
- What exactly caused the tragedy that claimed the lives of the five people on board the Titan? Here's a quick look at how extreme conditions can destroy a submersible.
#Submersible #Implosion #Explained
Read Full Article: www.slashgear.com/1321221/wha... 
Наука
I'd rather die quick than being cramped up and crapped up with 4 others knowing we only had 96 hours of air left and chances were 1/1000 of rescue.
To be honest if it was the full vessel they were searching for it probably would’ve been easier. I bet it’s a lot harder searching for a debris field, especially when that debris field is sitting on the ocean floor next to The Titanic’s massive debris field.
Same, not to mention they would've waited in a freezing dixie, while not even wearing shoes.
I was thinking. If I was slowly suffocating, trapped on a sub with the person who built it AND my son.. idk
Yea...great point!
I’d rather not die
It may be a bit morbid to think about, but would be interesting, from a learning perspective, to see someome build a 'scalled down' submarine model out of carbon-fiber, and stick it into a water-pressure chamber to see just how differently carbon-fiber implodes vs metal.
Or better, build an exact replica of the titan made out of the same material and then it would be accurate
This has already been done literally. It was done 11ish years ago or less there’s a RUclips video out there.
ruclips.net/video/lwvUvIKhK1Q/видео.html
Found it just for you buddy.
@@tingles3091 looks like it does what i'd expect.. 'snaps' rather than bends.... where metal might 'crinkle up' in an implosion, the carbon fiber would sheer off into strips/sections and look more like shattered glass.
So, undertake just the sort of tests that should have been mandatory to pass before this death trap was ever allowed to carry humans, especially fee paying public ........ yes, I agree !!
The passengers were shredded apart and they didn't even know it was happening. They didn't feel a thing, but their bodies won't be found. Even the bones got shattered.
Yep... Maybe clothes, jewelry, and shoes. No flesh or bone
It sounds painful but I’m glad they felt no pain
RIP
Nope. They were turned to ash since an implosion at that depth would make the air in the sub as hot as the surface of the sun before crush.
@@cycloneaction2211 Agreed...literally microscopic fish food pellets you feed the fish in your fish tank with.
You are painfully stupid. Their bodies won't shreed at all,just like fish doesn't shred.
The pressure at those depths is so immense that it would crush the entire human body like if your were crushing an egg with a tenderizing hammer, so yeah death would be pretty much instantaneous. Maybe they weren't the most sound people out there, but they're still people with families that love them, may they Rest In Peace🖤
@@F2PARTIESwell Imagine an egg inside a can, now crush the can with a hammer. what do you think will happen with the egg?
edit: myth busters actually have a test on this, check mythbusters compresed diver
Sulaiman didnt even want to go💔
@@F2PARTIESshredded
@@F2PARTIESThe passengers went from 14 square pounds per square inch to 5200 pounds per square inch in 20/1000 of a second. They didn't feel a thing.
It’s crazy how some fish and other underwater organisms can easily withstand that kind of pressure. Evolution is amazing.
God's creation is amazing.
@@nicolcacola 💯💯🙏🏼
Not many though only a very very few fish and star fish
Creation ----- not evolution.
I though that too.
Great "implosion" explanation. Many people will be looking at how an implosion looks/works/feels in the coming days/weeks.
Leviathan 1989, The Abyss 1989
Deep Star Six 1989
There's no way anyone could ever know what it feels like. Just like those who jumped from the top floors of the WTC on 9/11, when they hit the ground below they wouldn't have registered any pain at all or even know they hit the ground. The only difference here is those jumpers would've had time to think on the way down. Not so with these people on the Titan. They would've had no clue what was about to happen. Therefore there was absolutely no mental anguish at all.
@@user-zw7xi2jd3q well there could of been anguish if one of them had gas on the way down
I know I am, it's scary I'm trying to and not imagine them on that sub in their final moments.
Passenger hull was made of carbon fiber instead of industry standard metallic. Bonded to titanium caps on both ends sealed via epoxy and galvanization prone bolts. Ocean Gate played Russian roulette with each dive. Not a matter of if but when.
I know it sounds morbid but I'm glad this is actually what happened. I'm glad they didn't sit for 4 days in a tiny metal tube waiting to run out of air. I feel bad for the kid that didnt really wanna go... so sad
his Mom said he very much wanted to go and she gave up her seat to him.
@@wintercame I heard he went because of father's day? I may be wrong though!
@@williamritson6357 He'd been wanting to go for some time his mother said, but he was underage at the time his parents first booked their own tickets so he couldn't legally. I think the Father's Day ended up being a coincidence of scheduling.
William,
Hi, I do not think your comment is morbid at all. A tragic accident occurred. I was relieved to learn it was quick and painless.
My biggest fear is they came back up and bobbing along with no way to get out. Or down there in the dark. Hungry and terrified.
Much respect 🙏🏻💕
I’m glad you mentioned the part about it not being like the movies with the window crack getting bigger.. no in real life at that depth it’s curtains if something goes wrong
Who thought firing real expert engineer would be a good idea
The rich 😂😂
The woke ceo who valued virtue signaling over vessel safety and structural integrity.
I'm waiting for someone to create an animation of what a catastrophic implosion looks like.
I know we're all curious...
Look up coke can de pressure, I expect its similar
Look up byford dolphin accident it shows pictures of how they look
ruclips.net/video/LEY3fN4N3D8/видео.html
@@agustintorres2649the people aboard the titan would look even worse as the pressure is even higher down there
@@agustintorres2649 I just read the story on Wikipedia. Holy crap that was gruesome. I’m too scared to view pics. 😳
Prior to news of the implosion, I said a prayer for the 5 souls on board. I realized that they were projected to run out of air and I thought slowly suffocating to death cramped inside a tiny tube in complete abyssal darkness would be a terrible way to go.
Although it’s sad that they died, I am grateful that the implosion was very sudden and that death was instantaneous. They were there one instant and then gone the next… that’s the best way it could have happened.
@@psykhs Do you mean that cause you wanted them to suffer less? Just wondering.
Wow, weird conversation here👆
@@psykhsok? no one asked you and god doesn’t love you 🙏 do not stay safe 🩷
Same here, going without oxygen and suffering is way worse, instant death when they wouldn’t know is better. Not that them dying is a consolation, Just knowing they didn’t suffer helps it a little bit.
One of the many things that are bad about this is the CEO was supposed to be a billionaire yet he was cutting corners to save money and refused to have the Titan certified or tested at depth. It would have been illegal for the Titan to dive in US waters because of the lack of certification and testing. So that douchebag cutting corners to save money costed several folks lives who were unaware of the level of negligence there was from the CEO.
One of them was a 19-year-old who was allegedly terrified of the trip but wanted to make his father happy by going with him. It really is sad that it wasn't safer. A lesson for us all that money isn't the root of evil, but greed can be. The right allotment of money and time could have saved this submarine and the people inside it. Instead corners were cut, the science was ignored and people without the proper expertise tried to explore something dangerous. No matter how much money you've got, if you're an amateur, go visit a Titanic museum or something. Don't do this.
@@JarethTheGoblinKingForever Awesome analysis.
Also, slap that magic spell on me.
At least he went down with his ship. Honorable captain.
@@hfarthingt He had no choice but to go down but he's a selfish person who killed 3 other people cause his greed and selfishness
Family money, dude married into the Macy’s family.
They paid $250k each to experience death by implosion in the most expensive underwater coffin. This is History in the making.
Truly terrible
Better than assisted euthanasia in Switzerland, with all the interviews to take and forms to fill. Im in.
The most expensive Darwin Award there is…
At least they got the full titanic experience
I'm sry!! But this top the dumbest way to die. $250k to become fish food & probably $100k tax dollars to find the debris.
Even if it started as a pinhole crack, the resulting needle jet of water would have cut everyone in half instantly.
Imagine the pressure of the weight of a truck exerting on the surface of a fingernail. It's easy to imagine the remains of all five people filling a thimble. Dreadful indeed.
Instant fish food...locals were dining well that day.....
Yeah but we're made mostly of water and water doesn't compress. So more likely, they were liquified and ended up squirting out in any available directions.
@@joeshmoe7967 five people perished horribly!!! Stop the comedy central!!!
@@elroy-kq7we I'm trying to picture what the recently mentioned "human remains" must look like. I'm having issues here.
This comment section is filled with either savants or mentally handicapped individuals, no in between.
😅😅😅😅😅😅
I could only imagine what was going through the guy sons head knowing that he did not want too be there in the first place and was only doing it too please his dad for fathers day then realizing that they may never make it back up too the surface... so sad!...😢
That is very sad and would make for a great scene in a Hollywood movie but that's not how it happened. They were thinking about how they were almost to the wreck site..then they were gone. No time to process anything. At least according to science and case studies of other implosions
They wouldn't have had time to realize anything. They never knew what hit them. In a nanosecond they were monitoring the trip going down and then nothing. No lives flashing before their eyes, no warning something was wrong. They did not suffer in the slightest. Implosion is violent and certainly doesn't happen slowly, not with the amount of pressure pushing in on that vessel. They were dead the moment contact was lost.
@@CameronRoser-Peet But it is though? They knew and tried to get back up, James Cameron said they tried to drop weight and go up
Thanks for the explanation and quick post turnaround on this video.
Obviously these passengers knew something was going to happen because they released and dropped their bottom section in case of emergency so yes they did know what was happening.
And I'm sure it was terrifying.
They didn't know shit you don't know what they dropped commutations and tracking went out the same time only one thing explains that quick
@@kmix7928I agree they didn’t drop anything and didn’t realize anything they vaporized unfortunately…. They skid and other stuff was dropped because it imploded that other stuff was on the outside and didn’t
Thus not instant
@@kmix7928 They knew
@@aClownBaby- I hope they did serves em right 🤷♀️
It’s so crazy reading all this. Why don’t people value their lives more! Why do people do these crazy things!!! I mean send a robot instead!!!
Losing power is enough to drive me crazy..under water in the dark even for 5 seconds then to be crushed is beyond …may they Rest In Peace
The crushing was instant. Over 5000PSI at those depths. Think of the weight of a car on your big toe, and then the weight of a car on each and every square inch all at the same time.
Grab and egg and crush it in your hand as fast as possible....like that only much faster.
They were on the way down when it happened and they did have lighting. I don't think they even lost power, it just blew!!!😒
They surely Rest in Pieces.
''Death is likely to happen before a human central nervous system can even register that something has gone wrong.''
Thank god. I hope they were gone before they even had time to panic.
the best explanation so far
amazing how fish can live and thrive at those depths...
Because they are not full of air like humans, they don't have eardrums lungs. If humans had lungs full of fluid along with sinus cavities and any air pockets we too could live like fish.
@@Physics072 Thanks for that answer, but still the thousands of pounds of pressure imploding.... So those fish don't regulate oxygen through their gills like all the other fish? I don't know, I'm not an aquatic scientist, but it's still amazes me how they can survive in those below freezing temperatures and pressure.
@@Jaeger713An expert was saying there’s no fish at that depth. Only Jellyfish type beings.
@@beachbliss9366 there are fish, you can see them in much of the footage around and in the Titanic wreck
@@Jaeger713 they just live in that pressure. Their bodies are used to it and the pressure actually keeps them together- just like the wreck of the Titanic is being held together by the pressure of the ocean. If you brought it up it would collapse. There is a fish called the blob fish that lives about 1km below the surface. It looks like a normal fish in the ocean. But if you take it out of the water it collapses into a blob.
The titanium ring over the fibreglass hull were reacting to the same pressure differently and this caused the seam the bust. That’s why the rov found the ring because it blew off the fibre hill
Very interesting
You just learned that it's easier to go to outer space than go below our deepest seas.
In an aircraft, repeated flights cause metal fatigue over time, so planes are constantly inspected. Submersibles sound like they have tremendous forces constantly bombarding them. Are they inspected more often than aircraft?
Yes. But this one wasn't.
Subnautica kinda holds your hand in that regard huh. it gives you a whole lot of telegraph to get out of crushing depths where as IRL its an instakill boundary.
It just amazes me how perfect we are for our surroundings as opposed to being say living on another planet or in the areas in the lower oceans.. (I know I’m gonna get grief for my next comment by I’m fine with it) God knew what He was doing to provide the “perfect” pressure for our survival..
The perfect pressure wasn't put in place for our survival, its the other way around.
We had to adapt over millions of years so that our bodies had the perfect make up to survive the already existing pressure.
Thats how evolution works
great video
A sub implosion is like crushing an empty soda can by releasing a full fridge on it
They died so fast they still think they are on the submersible
Maybe their ghosts are meeting the ghosts of the Titanic
@@edp3202no, they're in hell
They didn't feel anything but unfortunately they definitely know that something serious was wrong
Yes the anxiety of knowing that something is wrong is terrifying
Well pick 1
From what I've read they drop their weights so that they were on their way back to the surface. They must have heard some noises and seen some alerts on their instruments. I am very interested in what their mothership monitors have to say. I want to know what they know just before the implosion, before communications was lost. 🤔🤔🤔
Naw the implosion caused that
I haven't heard that at all. Which website/news station said that they realized something was wrong and so decided to turn back?
@@racquel127I saw that a couple different places... The sub was equipped with some sort of alarm if the hull started to crack... So it was possible they were on their way back up
@@joeytacey743 The system was faulty, and it was a known issue. It would quite literally sense a failure immediately as the carbon fiber failed, so, yknow. Too late.
What is so profound and so irey about all this.....the ghost of those that lost thier lives on the Titanic greeted the 5 in the after life......and wanted to send a message to those who will return someday.....PLEASE LET US ALL REST IN PEACE AND LEAVE US ALONE!!!!
The spirit of that 19 year old, must be terrified....😢
Don't be silly.
@@MsMaxinejoy One can only imagine the torment that occured in those final seconds....I'm just baffled by ppl with all the blessings life can give, ie being billionaires....and still that's not enough.
Get out of fairy tail land bud
@@alexanderwright1774 I was simply giving my interpretation of life after death, has nothing to do with fairy tails. And since none of us know what happens after we die, I'll stick my analogy, bud
I would think you would hear some sort of cracking noise before it actually implodes
Possibly in the second before implosion
"A chain is only as strong as its weakest link." It only took one tiny defect to cause a catastrophic implosion. Death was instataneous, didn't have time to say "What's that noise?" followed by "Oh, crap!"
Yes I agree. They were hearing cracks, loud bangs and the hull pushing in due to the pressure. They knew just before it imploded they would never make it back home.
It would be the mercy of God if they imploded. They would feel no pain. It would happen so fast that their brains could not understand. On the other hand, if they were trapped in a can on the bottom of the ocean and waiting for air to run out... that would be hell.
or just the mercy of 5000PSI at that depth, and the over all physics of the craft and forces. 'God' is not merciful, or if 'he' is, very very selective....
@@kaya856 shut up for what? For speaking facts? Millions innocent people, children die from atrocious deaths all the time and suddenly these 5 would be spared from suffering? It was pure coincidence or "luck" they didn't feel anything , a combination of various factors
Oh great, five peeps die and we credit god for being "merciful"!? Credit him for killing five people first please...
If there were a god, and he could prevent this, then he is a psychopath for not doing so.
@@landsgevaer God gave humans free will. He didn't force those people to go on that dive. God did not kill those people.
@@Gung_Ho_Vids God could have created a world where people have free will but where he knew that they were going to chose differently, right...? So I maintain that either he didn't have the power to do things differently, or he didn't care to.
Btw, until I see evidence for free will and for god, both go in the same basket as the loch ness monster for me.
The owners fault. He was a real idiot for not following basic safety protocol with inspections.
My heart breaks only for the son and the families of the deceased, not the 4 billionaires who were stupid enough to pay250k to see the titanic in the honda civic of submarines. The poor kid was absolutely petrified of the trip and only went because he wanted to appease his dad for father’s day. Tragic.
Hey, don't put down Honda Civics.
Yea Hondas are actually very expensive now. Lol maybe a ford focus
I hope karma meets you one day :)
Yeah, I mean you're a billionaire and you can't spend a little more for a safer submersible? Paid a pretty heavy price in the end though.
@@ScottSavageTechnoScavengermore like a Audi or bmw
Seen some back and forth on bodies 'vaporizing' or 'disintegrating'. Disregarding the material debris compression mutilations, does bone and tissue actually liquify at instantaneous 5500 psi burst?
The energy released on implosion is equivalent to several kilograms of TNT, so basically liquefied.
@@natalyawoop4263Jesus
45 million kilograms or 100 million pounds of water above you at that depth would blast the cabin into a furnace, within milliseconds.
@@MeastrasElKachelinoyes, a friction furnace
I just want to see a simulation of what happens to the human body at that depth
The soda can with Quint crushing it explains it perfectly.
This amateur video could somehow bring hundreds of experts in the comment section. That alone is a great achievement. Thank you sirs for all your expertise.
Another morbid possibility is that the central carbon fibre portion of the sub disintegrated, and the two titanium spheres instantly collapsed on each other forming a tight sphere, turning the inside of the sub into the area between the two hemispheres for moments before the pressure equalized. That means the 5 occupants would have been squeezed into a very tight and mangled state, recognizing their predicament for possibly a few moments before dying.
No. The implosion would have caused extreme heat due to oxygen present in the chamber. Oxygen is made of water. Extreme pressure would have vaporized that in nanoseconds due to extreme heat, the blood in the vessels made of water would have also vaporised in nano seconds and oxygen in the lungs would have vaporized everything would compress and nervous system wouldn’t even be able to send signals to the brain in that time. Death in nanoseconds
Anymore painful insight😒?
Horse shit
They wouldn’t have had seconds. They were liquefied from the heat and pressure and ejected out of the wreckage before they knew what happened to them
wrong as they would of imploded themselves before those ends ever came together. It would of been over before the millisecond it took for a vision or feeling reached the brain. The human body becomes part of the sea, a cloud. Which is quicker than a vision or feeling can be processed
That's Terrible.
Nope, thats phisics
It’s a horrible thing that they died however at least they were not in pain
@@user-is4dp4bw6o they were just stupid i think, most the ceo of oceangate
@@botpro160The utter lack of empathy that the internet has caused is a marvel to see
@@kingcurrent6054 if I had billions i wouldnt pay 250k to die
Just for explanation...at that depth of 40MPa the speed of implosion would be over 2200 feet per second, or around Mach 2.. Then because of massive compression of the atmosphere inside the sub, the atmosphere along with all the passengers body fats and tissues would have detonated...YES 'detonated' in an almighty outward explosion, turning everyone to ash n dust in a ball of plasma! There was no leaking water, most probably no creaking, no warning what so ever! In fact without a high speed camera, you couldn't distinguish the transition from implosion to explosion, as it happened in a couple of milliseconds. Sorry to be graphic...but peoples explanations are bugging me...There's nothing to recover!
We recover ghosts
@@edp3202 good for you Egon
I’d like to know if the sub had any pressure reading instruments on board and if so wouldn’t the pilot have noticed anything that was seriously going wrong?
It had a failure warning system for the carbon fiber, but it was repeatedly noted as being moot as it would have sensed trouble right as the craft imploded and not before. Carbon fiber is a great pressure retaining compound, but it does NOT resist pressure well. It cant flex, it just shatters suddenly and violently.
Think thst crack was the 7 inches of plexiglass window. Accompanied by a sheared bolt. Imo
The ceo said in an interview that the plexiglass flexed in about 4" every dive. That is terrifying in itself.
Video didn't mention if there were tell tale noises that the crew could have heard before the implosion? if the crew heard noises of impending structural failure they would have been terrifying.
Hmmm i don’t think so. It might’ve been quick but you never know. It might’ve been an implosion and blow everything apart in half a second or it might’ve taken a few seconds and everyone was aware of what was happening. We don’t know how that material reacts to extreme pressure . It shatters ? it bends ? Maybe the sub structure started bending and making weird noises before the implosion.
I was thinking the same. Maybe they folded first? Nuts
so they new somthing was going wrong but they kept going deeper,,,
ruclips.net/video/cz9fw5lrLBo/видео.html
@@sarac1118 At Titanic, the sea pressure is near 6500 pounds per square inch. Multiply that by the total surface area of a pressure vessel and you're talking hundreds of thousands of tons of force. The first point of failure of a submersible's hull would be like the cracks propagating through a shattering window....essentially instantaneous. They never knew what hit them.
Firstly, composites don't tend to fail like that. They don't bend. When they reach their stress limit, they tend to fail completely.
Secondly, at these kinds of forces, a progressive failure like this isn't going to happen. The speed that literally any point of failure would progress to a total collapse would be unimaginable. Small forces can cause cracks to propagate over time because the force is concentrated at the tips of the cracks. That's why drilling out the end of a crack can make it stop propagating, it increases the area where the force is acting and thereby reduces the stress concentration. In this case, the forces would be so great that the stress concentrations at the ends of a crack would approach infinity.
James Cameron said on CNN that the company knew that the submersible dropped its ballast (which he says they only would have known if the pilot had relayed that information to the surface ship.) If that's the case then they were trying to head back up. It may be the case that they heard noises that told them that the hull was going to fail, which would be terrifying.
They may have had an idea that it was coming, but once the failure actually started, it would have been effectively instantaneous.
@@tmoney1876 The forces gradually increased as the sub went down . The forces were greater and greater . How do you know the sub did t first bend and they weren’t able to go to the surface and as they kept on going down it eventually imploded ? How do you know titan and carbon fibre reaction to pressure ? You all think it’s instant, it could be but the sub was not dropped at 13000 ft , it went slowly to that depth . Sorry you’re not convincing try again. After graduating from The Naval Academy i have a hard time letting myself taught by a youtube comment . Unless it makes sense, you on the other hand don’t understand that it was going down slowly and you’re not an expert on titan and carbon fibre composite. Can you prove they didn’t drown at 5000 ft underwater then the sub imploded at 12000 ? noup . It’s about the evidence . The evidence is the Titan was destroyed due to pressure from the outside . What happened before that moment is unknown .
May all five Rest In Peace.🙏
No amount of money can buy common sense!
Let s face it: while people spent a lot of money to find the SUB and people pray for them etc......
But every single day many more people starve to death around the world.........
Rest in Peace those who perished. I am glad they did not suffer. x
Irony is, the cause of deaths in Titan boiled down to same reason for cause of deaths in Titanic. Cutting corners to save money and greed to make money. Titanic used cheaper rivets instead of the stronger, safer ones which wud have been more expensive. Also not enough life boats as they didn't want the deck "cluttered" up and preventing first class passengers looking out to the ocean
Usually they build spheres the shape of that thing was weird.
its almost like spheres handle compression better than cylinders.
Dead right' they only had a big Pringles tube ........................
Imagine carrying 45 Million Kilograms of weight on your back... That's the weight of water above you at 4km below the sea level, the titanic depth, from all directions.
guess in 111 years from now there send people down to look at this wreck!
Precisely on June 18, 2134.
In short, submersibles dont spring leaks when they've reached their max depths. They just fold.
It was over before it even began
Don’t want to sound like I’m joking on people’s lives but would this go on Guinness world record for the death occurring as close to the earths core?
Most instantaneous death ever in recorded history...probably in ALL history (since cavemen I don't think had submarines etc.)
@@ojbeez5260 No that occurred at Hiroshima.
@@Moneymyke357the speed of the deaths of those in the submersible would rival that of those at ground zero Hiroshima. Both instantaneous
Wow that’s scary
Such an extreme change in pressure would instantly vaporize all organic matter. The enormous amount of water pressure unleashed would compress the hull's gas column and everything within it down to the size of a tennis ball. This super-heated gas would have a temperature exceeding the sun. We've seen remnants of liquified steel with Implosions at far less depth. As the compressed column cools, material would be ejected.
Can you help me understand why we can still see China plates next to Titanic, would they have imploded and vaporized? And this would mean their bones had imploded and vaporized? But why not China plates?
Exceeding the _surface_ of the sun. Not the core.
Vaporize 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
The pressure is only a problem when not in equilibrium. The inside of our bodies is exerting 1 ATM of pressure on the surface. So when you go over a hill and your ears pop, your internal pressure is adjusting to match external so you no longer feel the pressure, because there's no longer a differential. Because those people in the sub were "calibrated" to 1 ATM, just like the inside of the sub was at 1 ATM (not sure about this part, the sub may have been pressured a bit to help withstand the depth) , this meant the hull was taking on the full job of resisting the pressure. Once the hull failed, the sub crushed immediately. Think of a balloon being dragged to the bottom of the ocean, at sea level it would be of normal size, but at the bottom (assuming it doesn't pop) it would be miniscule. Same goes for the sub except instead of a rubbery material that deforms, it needs to stay rigid.
So as for plates, I am just guessing here, but I'd say the reason they don't shatter is because they are a relatively solid object. Especially the silverware at least. Gasses expand and contract readily with pressure changes, but a solid can handle it because it acts on all surfaces of the object. If there was an air bubble in one of the ceramic plates, perhaps that would shatter?
I think the bone shattering comments are a little misleading. I would think any bone shattering would be from hull impolsion, not the pressure difference.
@@williamstaib4623 thank you! This really helped me picture and understand the difference, yes I am assuming about bones exploding going by what has been said that they vaporized so I assumed bones were included. Even going by your explanation would it make sense that bones could shatter as well since they are hollow with marrow, an almost liquid substance? But now I can see why plates and other solids would not have shattered on the way down with the Titanic.
It is merciful the best outcome in the worst possible situation solace and peace they did NOT suffer or even felt any suffering or pain only pain left behind is loss to their families
The original reports of 96 hours of remaining oxygen and time running out to mount a rescue, so the fact that it was an implosion resulted in a instant and merciful death.
The Thicker The Steel The More Pressure it Can Take?
No pain u just disappear essentially.
It implodes?
Tremendous mistake using carbon fiber in the pressure chamber. Carbon fiber is very brittle. The Russian Sub uses 4.5 inch titanium for the pressure chamber.
Another factor is the rapid compression of the air in the vessel creating tremendous heat, like the compression stroke of a diesel engine, but much more extreme.
LOLLYGAG! You're taking absolute LIGHTYEARS and using visual drivel to run out my clock... I overstayed my reason and left at 3:20!
ANybody remember that grade school science experiment where the teacher heats a 1 gallon can with a torch till it is red hot, then screws the cap on and tosses some cold water on it? That!
That type of incredible pressure literally changes molecuar and atomic structure. There's probably nothing left of them.
In fewer words a coke can smashed by an 18 wheeler.
Flatter than a pancake
Yes it can - something they should have thought of in advance!
The President used to drive one of those.
@@ZilogBob hi 5?
The dead spirits of the Titanic had something to do with this tragedy.
...and everybody turns to jelly. Ho hum.
The universe allows us to survive and even thrive but only on its terms which can be harsh for those of us made of flesh. Flesh is weak, nature, unforgiving.
The sea will give up it's dead first on that great day. 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Unfortunately these poor souls became ground beef.!!😪
This idea that they didn't even realize what was going on before they died keeps getting repeated and may actually be incorrect. Does anybody actually know what exactly your conscious being is still able to experience when the physical body gets suddenly liquified?
You wouldn't think out of such a tragic incident there would be a blessing...thats they didn't suffer and went very quickly....thoughts are with the familys ....R.I.P to all 5
Anyone every llayed squash the lemon on the slide imagine everyones bidy weight pushing towards the glass in the way down 9-14 hrs of being uncomfortable n worried
Like hagfish tearing at a whale fall. Quite natural but grotesque to behold.
Water pressure main reason why it
imploded
250k to go thousands of meters down in a carbon fiber "submarine" with video console controllers, and has never been tested? Sounds like a bargain to me.
TRYING TO MAKE EVERYONE FEEL BETTER. EVEN IF IT WAS A SLOW EVENT DON'T EXPECT TO HEAR IT.
I'm just wondering if OceanGate is going to get a refund for all the parts purchased at Harbor Freight?
Only if they bought the extended warranty.
That's why those deep-sea fishes die soon as they go up near the surface
At that depth, the sub just imploded like a balloon bursting faster than the blink of an eye. I would rather be in the Titan submersible than be in the USS Thresher.
For those of you who claim they didnt feel a thing, you are wrong. They knew the submersible was being crushed at that depth at least a minute before it imploded. When a sub imploded it doesnt just implode out of nowhere. There are warnings. First you hear a sharp crack and the sub hull "moaning" as much pressure and weight is applied to it. You can physically see and feel the hull pushing in. You are terrified. Seeing this could lead to cardiac arrest, stroke or shock. Im sure there was panic going on. The temp of the sub gets to around 10,000 degrees. I hope they died of heatstroke before the sub imploded. But yes they felt terror in their final moments. An implosion doesn't just happen.
Money is the root of all evil
1 Timothy
The love of money ----- to being the root of all evil. Not money of and by itself.
@@T800-theRealOne facts
@@maxamahnken7325 facts
@@CrazyHustlerTV The love of money ----- is the root of all evil.
Is this what you are referring to?
Please, specify.
So frigin sad.
you never mentioned the 10,000 degrees of heat...
At least they did not die by a painful lasting drowning death
The maxim of all good RUclips creators: "Never let a good tragedy go to waste."
Always sensationalize and profit from recent events. It's essential.
So why are you here?
@@T800-theRealOne " we got a bubble headed bleach blonde
comes on at five.
She can tell you about the plane crash,' with a gleam in her eye.
It's interesting when people die.
Give us dirty laundry"
@@danstrayer111 That stuff gives them their ratings. You can't blame them for wanting to be the number one source for reliable and trustworthy news.
Would they have not felt unbarable heat before it imploded
Too fast for perception. It was a millisecond or less.
I uploaded a video of Stockton talking about what happen.