You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect. Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
She’s wrong, rock was a thing since Chuck Berry‘s childhood before he started playing music it was underdeveloped, but it was already a thing, when Chuck came, he developed it, but so did a lot of white musicians during his time, and after him just like black musicians after him and during his time
@@christinamaroon2615 not only that but rock ‘n’ roll was coined by somebody way after Chuck Berry was playing not only that but both White and Black people both played before Chuck Berry, what was considered rock ‘n’ roll was singing while playing electric guitar the first genre that was played was not blues. It was country which came from European folk music the people who invented the electric guitar were two White American musicians so I don’t know why this video wants to claim that it was Black people
Please don’t rock did not come from blues it was already there. The electric guitar was invented by two white musicians, singing rock I’m pretty sure Chuck Berry had influence from these since he liked the electric guitar he combined this with blues, which developed it into rock ‘n’ roll It doesn’t have an inventor
Thank you for always including subtitles in your videos. Every effort you take, from the great editing to the accessibility measure are very appreciated by me and your other viewers. Love all that you do :)
Thank you so much for your acknowledgment of this. It’s pain staking, and adds a lot of time to the editing process, but it’s important to me that the videos as accessible as possible. I’m so glad to hear that it’s helpful for you. Thank you for watching.
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect. Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
@@christinamaroon2615mayyyybe there ain't no right or wrong, but... mayyyyybe rewatch the video 'cause her explainations are really well built and coherent !!
@@DaraStarrTucker a lot of what you say is incorrect rock did not come from blues, but it was developed with the influence of blues by Chuck Berry as the electric guitar and rock music or at least this precursor was already being played by the white musicians who invented the electric guitar
@@horstdunoch3546 it’s really cherry picked and biased as rock was already being existing when Chuck Berry was a little kid it doesn’t come from blues or jazz it doesn’t have a set style Chuck Berry developed it using blues though
Most other videos are full of bias, misleading stories that if you are not careful and don't know the history, they lead you think that we had very little to do with what we created.
Ehhh it’s biased rock was already a thing It didn’t come from blues it has influence from blues Rock or an idea of rock was already around when Chuck Berry was a little kid unless you’re telling me that when he was like four or five years old he was making music and people were hearing him then she doesn’t know what she’s talking about or she does and is just biased
@@christhebonnetmann6 No, there's no evidence of that, I love her records from the late 30's but that was not rock'n'roll,even though one of her songs was called Rock me..
WOW Sis, you did your thing with this. I’ve been studying and collecting this music since the early 2000’s and have been a Louis Jordan fan since the late 80’s. You taught me something because I never heard the term “Fast Western”. You even picked out all the songs I love and would pick like “Rock Awhile” and “Rock the Joint”. This was amazing. Thank you!
im a young punk getting into a lot of rock associated and derived genres and i loved this!! i really like how you line it all out and gave both intellectual(explaining the emphasis on beats two and four) and musical(than playing the clips showing that) examples for a lot of the points you make! im a huge nerd, so if anyone has any recommendations for music education videos like this please throw them at me. i also really like that i didn’t have to unlearn a lot of this and was able to learn with mostly-fresh eyes(unlike a lot of history) about Black music(and how white music owes much of its beauty to Black and other POC music). If you read this, thank you so much! i enjoyed learning from you(the subtitles help a lot).
Hank WAS A STEALER OF BLACK SONGS . HE AND THIS BLACK GUITAR PLAYER WENT AROUND THE COUNTRY SIDE AND ASK BLACK PEOPLE DID THEY HAVE ANY SONGS. ALL OLD HANK DID WAS PUT YOLDELING WITH THE BLACK SONGS HE HAD STOLEN.
And cherry picked and biased as rock doesn’t come from blues and existed when Chuck Berry was a little kid like four years old he developed it using blues, but it already existed
Mexican American metalhead! I’ve been doing research on the history of metal and wanted to take a step further in the history if rock itself! This video made me feel so seen. Tho im not black it’s good to see a historical documentary that’s of poc experience!
She left out a lot African-Americans weren’t the only ones who brought rock ‘n’ roll as another influence of it is also country and the people who invented the electric guitar were not black Both white and African-Americans brought rock to the world
@@minathepinkpigglet2812 I’m also Mexican and please don’t lump people in just because they’re not white that’s freaking weird so second of all country is also one of its influences, and the people who invented the electric guitar were probably singing that and the people who invented it were white it was a combination of white and black musicians that made rock ‘n’ roll not just black. She left out a lot of things.
@@DaraStarrTucker did you research it fairly because all the elements you talked about in the Carnegie Hall part influence rock ‘n’ roll it was already a thing before that though it was years after till a guy coined the term by the way rock ‘n’ roll has been a thing since the early 30s went two white musicians invented the electric guitar and were singing with it chuck berry developed it using the elements you talked about but it already existed developing does not mean inventing
Brilliantly presented, thank you for sharing such a powerful resource towards understanding the landscape of early rock and roll !! Had been looking around the net for a while to really grasp it all but your explanations were so thorough and helpful
I love being educated by you. You missed one genre that many people don’t know about. It’s called Skiffle. African Americans need to learn more about Skiffle. It’s their heritage. 🖤
Very true. Skiffle was Main Street in the UK. Blue’s was brought to the UK in records from the US. Groups like Beatles, Stones, Kinks, etc left skiffle and reinterpreted those records into their version of rock, which introduced the British Invasion.
It goes a little deeper some enterprising British kids discovered you could write to an American Embassy and get albums of early blues that had been recorded out in the fields of the American South during the 1930’s. For free!
"African Americans need to learn more about Skiffle. It’s their heritage." What kind of nonsense is this? Skiffle is just a British take on American pop and R&B played on household items, and is not anyone's "heritage," except for British kids in the 1950's.
Thank you so much Dara . For breaking down how the Evolution of RocknRoll in such detail & allowing us to hear the music that your speaking about . Thank you for your hard work and detailed information .
She laughed out a lot of stuff another influence for rock ‘n’ roll is country music The first people to invent the electric guitar were white and they probably used American folk music, which wasn’t only a continuation of European music, that’s an incorrect thing to say it had its original things it was a combination of black and white musicians that made rock ‘n’ roll
There is much truth in that! Lol; Jordan realy dosnt get a lot of the credit he deserves, while its true he never really left the jump blues/swing scene, he is responsible for some of rock & rolls most recognizable songs, like, you keep a knockin, the opening riff for Chuck Berries, "Johnny B Goode", let the good times roll, and his band "tymponny five" contained some of the most renown and prolific pioneers of jump blues & early rock; Hogan, Chris Columbo, and the legendary keyboardest, Bill Doggett, who wrote what many call the jump blues anthem, "honky tonk"
Not the case either, but I think they made it recognizable and what it is today because country which is distinctly American not just a continuation of European music that is wrong is another influence of rock rock ‘n’ roll. The people who invented the electric guitar were white musicians, two of them to be exact and they would play while singing, American folk music both white and black musicians developed rock
@@neilsoulman you also leave out that country is another influence and the people who invented the electric guitar were two white musicians who would sing country while playing it both white and black musicians developed rock
Doing some research on Rock and Roll and electric sound for a character design course I'm in. this video, with how well is explains the influence of the music through other genres and time, really helped me understand what makes Rock and Roll what it is. Thank you!
Holy cow --- your intellect blows me away. I wish I had the historical and musical knowledge and understanding you have regarding how these genres evolved over time to eventually become rock 'n roll. I began casually self-studying this stuff a couple of years ago, but I have a long way to go to get even close to your level of knowledge. I have a few comments/reactions to your video. I'd love to hear any reaction you might have to what I write. First, I just want to mention this --- I watched some video a couple of years ago of Cab Calloway when he was a very young man, and it struck me that he MOVED like Elvis. Just physically --- his posture, the way he walked, surrendered his physical body to the music --- his very specific physical mannerisms. I began to wonder if Elvis might have either studied him, or, passively absorbed his physical style. Second, in the course of this self-study, I just in the last month was exploring some old spirituals, and one of the songs I listened to was a very old recording of the Fisk Jubilee Singers singing "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot". They have a female lead, with the beautiful, high voice. And they sing the song very slowly --- much more slowly than I've ever heard the song played. And with that female lead and the slow tempo --- it just elevates the to a sublime level. Have you heard it? (link at the bottom of my comments). Third, I spent a lot of time studying many of the rhythm and blues songs that Elvis covered early in his career. I compared some of the ones you mention in your "Why Many Black People Don't Like Elvis" video. So, Junior Parker's "Mystery Train", Big Mama Thornton's "Hound Dog", Jimmy Reed's "Big Boss Man" (which Elvis recorded in the '60s), and a few others. And I have analyzed and compared Elvis' versions with the original artist's, and I have figured out a basic formula that Elvis consistently applied to each song to remake it in his personal style. He did the following 3 things: (1) he sped up the tempo a lot (2) he sang with legato, whereas the black artist tended to sing more staccato (3) and he either eliminated the syncopated back-beat rhythm that dominated the black artist's version, OR, he kept the syncopation, but toned it down substantially so it almost became subtext, and then layered over it a much stronger, more dominant even rhythm. So that even rhythm dominates the song, and the backbeat becomes just sort of a delicate ornamentation. I'd appreciate any comments, insights, criticisms you have of this analysis. Again, I REALLY appreciate your videos, and I will be subscribing. Thanks very much. ruclips.net/video/LlrzonAXEW8/видео.html
Oh, I had another comment on the point you make about --- was it the Blues rhythms mimicking the rhythm of the trains. I noticed that years ago. But here is an interesting psychological insight about that train rhythm. The musical rhythm literally sounds like the sound a train makes, but it also mimics in sound the VISUAL rhythm you get when you travel fast, whether in a train or in a car on the highway. When you ride fast like that there is the fast visual rhythm of the road straight ahead coming at you, and then a secondary, slower visual rhythm of the trees, rocks, telephone poles, signs in your periphery on the side of the road. Country Western music also creates movements that suggest the various paces a horse moves. For example, if you listen to Elvis' version of "Tomorrow Is A Long Time" he creates the rhythm of a horse slowly, lazily walking, and swaying side-to-side. And he suggests it's a Western theme also by having the tambourine rattling at key moments, sounding like spurs rattling, or the horse's reins.
Thanks for taking the time to watch this and thoughtfully respond. I will say as far as Can Calloway goes, I’m sure Elvis studied him closely. He was revolutionary in terms of the physicality he displayed & his showmanship. And I am pretty familiar with the Fisk Jubilee Singers. I moved away from Nashville a few years ago after living there for over a decade. They are legendary in that city and not talked about nearly enough. I hope this video has given you a few more rabbit holes to explore. There are so many more layers, and it’s all quite fascinating. Thank you for subscribing. 🤎
Outstanding review and analysis. Western swing is often forgotten in these pieces because it's a branch that comes out of left field and is hard to fit in the narrative. You weave it in perfectly.
Just found this video. Wow, it's extremely well done and thoughtful; I learned a lot. (About a topic that is very difficult to define and tends to attract gatekeepers, no less.) Thanks for the hard work of actually defining the relevant genres, digging up the audio clips, and comparing them. Also, I love that fact that you don't cop out on the question of where rock & roll can really be considered to have started. You suggest an artist and then a song, and back that up with musical evidence, yet still allow viewers to make their own judgments. Well done!!
An hour ago I had an idea "What if I made a video detailing how rock was invented?" I look up if anyone had the same idea and here it is. Done in a quick and coherent ways. The theme that genres are a combination of what came before.
Thanks for pointing so strongly to Louis Jordan. To me "Saturday Night Fish Fry" is his most rocking (maybe because of the chorus lyric). His music was very light-hearted and fun, another important part of rock. Johnny Otis (no slouch himself) had a great radio show in the 90s that celebrated this birth-of-rock period.
Great introduction. It's understandable that he wouldn't merit a mention here, but an interesting figure that connects Louis Jordan with the rock n roll era was his producer, Milt Gabler, who also produced Bill Haley & the Comets' first album, Rock Around the Clock, reorchestrating Tympany Five arrangements and adding a backbeat to turn a western swing aggregation into a rock n roll band.
I know where this is going, but honestly I prefer to see Rock n Roll as a unifying art form of a multiplicity of races. It really shows the humanity of it. I just heard Aretha sing Satisfaction by the Stones and it just shows how we’re all one and connected.
I think you agree with me that a guy by the name of Bill Haley brought it into mainstream. Louis Jordan is one of the pioneers of early rock and roll. Thanks a lot for your video. Great!! What would be rock and roll without black artists?
He might have, but only because blacks were kept away from mainstream. Whites loved the new sound, but due to their racism against blacks they didn't want to hear it from the blacks but rather listen a water down version of it interpreted by whites. This happens with anything we create. Dreadlocks, afro, cornrows, Bantu nuts were looked down until white people and others started wearing those hair styles. Thick lips were a subject of mockery until botox was created. Now they pay money to have thick lips, so now thick lips are ok. And it never stops, it goes on and on to no end.
I think you nailed it ! Rock this Joint tonight, is in my opinion the first R&R song, that jump started it all. It doesn’t matter the color of the individual or group who started it. It was an individual thing that changed with the influence of all kinds of music throughout time.
It does matter. As soon as you say ablack person started or invented something white people say it doesn’t matter. How come I never hear this when it’s about white inventors?
Thanks for telling these stories about the history of modern music Dara! I think it's amazing just how much of popular music we owe to African American artists everything from, Blues, Jazz, R&B, Rock, Funk, Gospel, Disco, Hip Hop, Rap, House and Techno and everything that came from those... There must be something very powerful about the Black American experience good and bad that inspired so much creativity. It's a shame that many of these artist never got the credit but at least they Inspired so many. We would live in a poorer world without their contribution to music...
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect. Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
@christinamaroon2615 You are completely IGNORANT. Please do your homework & see the video HOW ELVIS COPIED THE STYLE OF ROY HAMILTON. You wont be able 2 refute that. If you'll UNBIASELY RESEARCH the inventions & contributions of so called BLK AMERICANS in the U.S. you will be blown away. After almost 400 yrs of forced illiteracy BLK ppl have more substantial contributions than most others combined. FACTS. Even the technology that lead 2 the GAMA cell technology starts with us. Even the ranch dressing, french fries, potato chips & home security system that you enjoy comes from BLK EXCELLENCE. Not 2 mention that Automatic gear shift in the car you drive everyday. Or the Electric Railway if you don't drive ✌️🖤🦾🙏😉
This is AMAZING work, Dara! Thank you so very much for pouring time and energy into this teaching. I’m so excited about this and can’t wait to share with others. Hopping over to Instagram now to look for posts of yours I can share right now! 🎉🎉🎉
Fantastic script. I must say it took me probably 2 years to find all of the information you provided here. I wonder how long it took you guys to write this script
I teach rock and roll and guitar. This is probably the best rock and roll history video I've ever seen. I DO have to take one issue though. When you first talk about the earliest country and western taking from slave music, that's actually backwards. Slaves started blues and other similar music by listening to Irish and Scottish folk and adding an African rhythm to it, as well as their own feelings. The 1-4-5 stuff came from white folk music. That's where we get the first country. The idea of making it groove, comes from slaves. Otherwise, I think you nailed it better than anyone. And if you think I'm saying that black folks appropriated music first, no. They just made the best of what they had and what they were allowed to be exposed to. White musicians stole way more and still do. Personally, I like American music and that will always be a mish-mash of black and white styles. That's the good stuff.
You certainly did your research. I'm very impressed. Personally, I think Goree Carter's "Rock Awhile" is the first rock and roll song. It was released in April 1949, while Jimmy Preston didn't release his song until August. Big Joe Turner's and Louie Jordan's jump blues definitely fathered in the genre, and I'd say their biggest influence was Cab Calloway.
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect. Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
Thank you for an informative, succinct and well delivered , constructed presentation on the subject of Rock and Roll. As an Englishman I would add that for me the subtitles were not necessary.
Robert Johnson- They're red hot. It is the earliest fast and nice guitar and rock vocals I've heard other than rhythm and music itself. You just got a new sub here I love your video!!
young lady you did a great job and i know that took a lot of time so i wil say thanks because it opened my eyes to the different people that contributed to rock and roll. i grew up in the 50's and Elvis fan also Chuck Berry but my favorite is Fats Domino i agree with Elvis i always felt Fats was the king of rock and roll mainly his songs were great to dance to and i was descent dancer. Also regarding Elvis you actually did a lot of homework on him and did a great job of squashing a lot of those rumors regarding racism that unfortunately a lot of people still believe. anyways keep up the great work
I'll tell you what I like about this video, she said something that a lot of people forget. I was born and raised in Southeastern Kentucky and she's exactly right. Back in those days, you got treated like absolute crap regardless of color unless you were wealthy and good looking and marketable. The same things coal corporations were doing to black and white miners in Kentucky and Virginia, it's the same thing that they were doing to sharecroppers in Mississippi. My family migrated from Ireland and Scotland and a lot of them were coal miners that didn't even get paid real money. It was modern day slavery back in those days for all the poor people regardless of color. Even in today's world, it's not about color it's what you can do for somebody else to make them money.
Dara offers a thoughtful overview of the history of rock & roll and Great Black American music, about as good as the best ones available, and better than most. If you're not going to read several books about the subject and listen to 200+ hours worth of blues, jazz, and early rock & roll, this video is a good 12-min education. Some minor factual errors, but mostly solid, and it comes with an educated Black perspective usually missing in most rock & roll scholarship. Good pacing and production values.
Very good exposition. Some of the inferences are tenuous though. While the influence of African American experience on Rock music must not be understated, it almost seems as though the presenter would like to suggest that without African American exposure, music would never have evolved in America?
Thank you for this informative video. I remember having a similar revelation when I was a teenager who grew up watching older "classic" movies and noticed a steady progression from big band to swing to boogie woogie. Rock-n-roll as a new genre was already mentioned in a few films from the late 1940's, not the 1950's as I had previously assumed. I think music had a lot to do with cultural integration in the United States and later Europe (where I happen to be living since 2022 thanks to my Hungarian wife : )
@@DaraStarrTucker This video was very impressive. While I knew at least half of the names, I didn't realize their music started as early as it did. (PS: Love the shout out to Scott Joplin!)
Yes, it's an argument that will never end. Great programme,Dara, I haven't seen you before. You came up with all the things I'd have expected,and far more, because I know f*** all anyway.. One record you missed, not a criticism, it's an endless list, isn't it? But "Roll 'em Pete", the classic Boogie/jump blues track from Pete Johnson and Big Joe.
This is the best, most succinct explanation of the history of Rock and Roll I have ever heard, Dara..loved it. Hat's off to you!👍👍
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect.
Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
She’s wrong, rock was a thing since Chuck Berry‘s childhood before he started playing music it was underdeveloped, but it was already a thing, when Chuck came, he developed it, but so did a lot of white musicians during his time, and after him just like black musicians after him and during his time
@@christinamaroon2615 not only that but rock ‘n’ roll was coined by somebody way after Chuck Berry was playing not only that but both White and Black people both played before Chuck Berry, what was considered rock ‘n’ roll was singing while playing electric guitar the first genre that was played was not blues. It was country which came from European folk music the people who invented the electric guitar were two White American musicians so I don’t know why this video wants to claim that it was Black people
As a jazz musician this has to be the best summary of the subject that I ever heard! Thank You
I’m a upcoming rock player I appreciate you teaching everyone how it’s supposed to be
Please don’t rock did not come from blues it was already there. The electric guitar was invented by two white musicians, singing rock I’m pretty sure Chuck Berry had influence from these since he liked the electric guitar he combined this with blues, which developed it into rock ‘n’ roll It doesn’t have an inventor
Thank you for always including subtitles in your videos. Every effort you take, from the great editing to the accessibility measure are very appreciated by me and your other viewers. Love all that you do :)
Thank you so much for your acknowledgment of this. It’s pain staking, and adds a lot of time to the editing process, but it’s important to me that the videos as accessible as possible. I’m so glad to hear that it’s helpful for you. Thank you for watching.
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect.
Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
@@christinamaroon2615mayyyybe there ain't no right or wrong, but... mayyyyybe rewatch the video 'cause her explainations are really well built and coherent !!
@@DaraStarrTucker a lot of what you say is incorrect rock did not come from blues, but it was developed with the influence of blues by Chuck Berry as the electric guitar and rock music or at least this precursor was already being played by the white musicians who invented the electric guitar
@@horstdunoch3546 it’s really cherry picked and biased as rock was already being existing when Chuck Berry was a little kid it doesn’t come from blues or jazz it doesn’t have a set style Chuck Berry developed it using blues though
THIS THE BEST VIDEO I'VE SEEN ON RUclips IN A LONG TIME.THANKS FOR ALL THIS INFO.
Most other videos are full of bias, misleading stories that if you are not careful and don't know the history, they lead you think that we had very little to do with what we created.
This channel deserves more subscribers! Dara really knows what she's talking about.
Ehhh it’s biased rock was already a thing It didn’t come from blues it has influence from blues Rock or an idea of rock was already around when Chuck Berry was a little kid unless you’re telling me that when he was like four or five years old he was making music and people were hearing him then she doesn’t know what she’s talking about or she does and is just biased
That video of Sister Rosetta Tharpe playing Didn't It Rain gets used a lot but it's from 1964.
She was doing rock n roll in the 30s
@@christhebonnetmann6She was doing Gospel in the 30's. But that song was released in 64 and that's all I meant.
@@wileym she was doing both gospel and rock n roll in the 30s
@@christhebonnetmann6 No, there's no evidence of that, I love her records from the late 30's but that was not rock'n'roll,even though one of her songs was called Rock me..
WOW Sis, you did your thing with this. I’ve been studying and collecting this music since the early 2000’s and have been a Louis Jordan fan since the late 80’s. You taught me something because I never heard the term “Fast Western”. You even picked out all the songs I love and would pick like “Rock Awhile” and “Rock the Joint”. This was amazing. Thank you!
im a young punk getting into a lot of rock associated and derived genres and i loved this!! i really like how you line it all out and gave both intellectual(explaining the emphasis on beats two and four) and musical(than playing the clips showing that) examples for a lot of the points you make!
im a huge nerd, so if anyone has any recommendations for music education videos like this please throw them at me.
i also really like that i didn’t have to unlearn a lot of this and was able to learn with mostly-fresh eyes(unlike a lot of history) about Black music(and how white music owes much of its beauty to Black and other POC music).
If you read this, thank you so much! i enjoyed learning from you(the subtitles help a lot).
Thanks so much for letting me know that you appreciated this video. Wishing you the best of luck with your music. ❤️❤️❤️
Check out folk punk.
I'm a metalhead but I also love punk. They both gave birth to crust punk, thrash, grindcore, and a lot of other stuff.
You're neglecting the influence of "hillbilly" artists like Hank Williams, especially numbers like "Move It On Over."
Hillbilly music is watered down sloppy version of blues and Country aka black American music. Rockabilly was copied from rhythm and blues.
Hank WAS A STEALER OF BLACK SONGS . HE AND THIS BLACK GUITAR PLAYER WENT AROUND THE COUNTRY SIDE AND ASK BLACK PEOPLE DID THEY HAVE ANY SONGS. ALL OLD HANK DID WAS PUT YOLDELING WITH THE BLACK SONGS HE HAD STOLEN.
Fantastic video. Informative, interesting, and important. Thank you so much for making it, and sharing it!
And cherry picked and biased as rock doesn’t come from blues and existed when Chuck Berry was a little kid like four years old he developed it using blues, but it already existed
As a Salvadorian American Metalhead, I appreciate this. Thanks to the African Americans that brought rock n roll to the world
Mexican American metalhead! I’ve been doing research on the history of metal and wanted to take a step further in the history if rock itself! This video made me feel so seen. Tho im not black it’s good to see a historical documentary that’s of poc experience!
Meathead?
She left out a lot African-Americans weren’t the only ones who brought rock ‘n’ roll as another influence of it is also country and the people who invented the electric guitar were not black Both white and African-Americans brought rock to the world
@@minathepinkpigglet2812 I’m also Mexican and please don’t lump people in just because they’re not white that’s freaking weird so second of all country is also one of its influences, and the people who invented the electric guitar were probably singing that and the people who invented it were white it was a combination of white and black musicians that made rock ‘n’ roll not just black. She left out a lot of things.
@@TheRunobenLmao
Good, complete, succinct piece! Love them all!🎶👏
Kudos to a great video, and even more for the considerable amount of research that went in to it! Thank you.
These videos are so well made and well researched its astounding!
🙏🏾🤎🙏🏾
@@DaraStarrTucker did you research it fairly because all the elements you talked about in the Carnegie Hall part influence rock ‘n’ roll it was already a thing before that though it was years after till a guy coined the term by the way rock ‘n’ roll has been a thing since the early 30s went two white musicians invented the electric guitar and were singing with it chuck berry developed it using the elements you talked about but it already existed developing does not mean inventing
Styles of music are not invented. They develop with contributions from various sources.
Not today colonizer.
@@superluminal89 Your hateful remark is noted.
@@timcarr6401 So is your ability to be easily offended.
@@superluminal89 Nope. I am just stating the obvious bitterness you have.
@@timcarr6401 No Tim. You’re just soft. Not much of a man, are you?
This is amazing info. Thank you so much for digging this up for us all. When I say all, you know who I mean.
A very well put together documentary of the growth of various musical genres.
Brilliantly presented, thank you for sharing such a powerful resource towards understanding the landscape of early rock and roll !! Had been looking around the net for a while to really grasp it all but your explanations were so thorough and helpful
You really did an excellent job with this. Very thorough & educational!
I will never argue that Chuck Berry is the King of Rock And Roll. He changed the fact that you didn't need a bunch of people with you'
Best breakdown on the subject I've seen. Thanks, Dara.
I loved this video so much! Thanks for sharing your research and knowledge. ❤
Great treatment of this topic. Love it. That Elmore James guitar sound, that's my favorite in blues.
I love being educated by you. You missed one genre that many people don’t know about. It’s called Skiffle. African Americans need to learn more about Skiffle. It’s their heritage. 🖤
I watched a documentary about Jimmy Paige that said that's what was popular in England when he was a kid.
@@lisapalmeno4488 yep. Beatles were into it too. If you Google skiffle, you’ll find mostly info on white British men
Very true. Skiffle was Main Street in the UK. Blue’s was brought to the UK in records from the US. Groups like Beatles, Stones, Kinks, etc left skiffle and reinterpreted those records into their version of rock, which introduced the British Invasion.
It goes a little deeper some enterprising British kids discovered you could write to an American Embassy and get albums of early blues that had been recorded out in the fields of the American South during the 1930’s. For free!
"African Americans need to learn more about Skiffle. It’s their heritage." What kind of nonsense is this? Skiffle is just a British take on American pop and R&B played on household items, and is not anyone's "heritage," except for British kids in the 1950's.
This was phenomenal; please keep up the great work! You helped me so much for this final I have to take tomorrow!
Lady, thank you so much for your input. You are saying everything I’ve been saying since at least 1976.
This is a great outtake on Rock & Roll. I am sharing this my Mass Communication students. I am lecturing on Sound Recording in America.
Authoritative breakdown of who created Rock and Roll. And why. Excellent! Excellent production.
Thank you so much Dara . For breaking down how the Evolution of RocknRoll in such detail & allowing us to hear the music that your speaking about . Thank you for your hard work and detailed information .
She laughed out a lot of stuff another influence for rock ‘n’ roll is country music The first people to invent the electric guitar were white and they probably used American folk music, which wasn’t only a continuation of European music, that’s an incorrect thing to say it had its original things it was a combination of black and white musicians that made rock ‘n’ roll
I think rock music wouldn't exist without Elmore James and Louis Jordan.
There is much truth in that! Lol; Jordan realy dosnt get a lot of the credit he deserves, while its true he never really left the jump blues/swing scene, he is responsible for some of rock & rolls most recognizable songs, like, you keep a knockin, the opening riff for Chuck Berries, "Johnny B Goode", let the good times roll, and his band "tymponny five" contained some of the most renown and prolific pioneers of jump blues & early rock; Hogan, Chris Columbo, and the legendary keyboardest, Bill Doggett, who wrote what many call the jump blues anthem, "honky tonk"
Not the case either, but I think they made it recognizable and what it is today because country which is distinctly American not just a continuation of European music that is wrong is another influence of rock rock ‘n’ roll. The people who invented the electric guitar were white musicians, two of them to be exact and they would play while singing, American folk music both white and black musicians developed rock
@@neilsoulman you also leave out that country is another influence and the people who invented the electric guitar were two white musicians who would sing country while playing it both white and black musicians developed rock
Doing some research on Rock and Roll and electric sound for a character design course I'm in. this video, with how well is explains the influence of the music through other genres and time, really helped me understand what makes Rock and Roll what it is. Thank you!
🙏🏾👌🏾
This is the best analysis of the birth of rock and roll I have ever seen.
I love it how you phrase it at the end, that rock is the earth child of the black experience. So eloquent and accurate!
Brilliant information! Thank youuuu
Thank you so much for making this! It’s fucking incredible.
🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
Holy cow --- your intellect blows me away. I wish I had the historical and musical knowledge and understanding you have regarding how these genres evolved over time to eventually become rock 'n roll. I began casually self-studying this stuff a couple of years ago, but I have a long way to go to get even close to your level of knowledge.
I have a few comments/reactions to your video. I'd love to hear any reaction you might have to what I write.
First, I just want to mention this --- I watched some video a couple of years ago of Cab Calloway when he was a very young man, and it struck me that he MOVED like Elvis. Just physically --- his posture, the way he walked, surrendered his physical body to the music --- his very specific physical mannerisms. I began to wonder if Elvis might have either studied him, or, passively absorbed his physical style.
Second, in the course of this self-study, I just in the last month was exploring some old spirituals, and one of the songs I listened to was a very old recording of the Fisk Jubilee Singers singing "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot". They have a female lead, with the beautiful, high voice. And they sing the song very slowly --- much more slowly than I've ever heard the song played. And with that female lead and the slow tempo --- it just elevates the to a sublime level. Have you heard it? (link at the bottom of my comments).
Third, I spent a lot of time studying many of the rhythm and blues songs that Elvis covered early in his career. I compared some of the ones you mention in your "Why Many Black People Don't Like Elvis" video. So, Junior Parker's "Mystery Train", Big Mama Thornton's "Hound Dog", Jimmy Reed's "Big Boss Man" (which Elvis recorded in the '60s), and a few others. And I have analyzed and compared Elvis' versions with the original artist's, and I have figured out a basic formula that Elvis consistently applied to each song to remake it in his personal style. He did the following 3 things:
(1) he sped up the tempo a lot
(2) he sang with legato, whereas the black artist tended to sing more staccato
(3) and he either eliminated the syncopated back-beat rhythm that dominated the black artist's version, OR, he kept the syncopation, but toned it down substantially so it almost became subtext, and then layered over it a much stronger, more dominant even rhythm. So that even rhythm dominates the song, and the backbeat becomes just sort of a delicate ornamentation. I'd appreciate any comments, insights, criticisms you have of this analysis.
Again, I REALLY appreciate your videos, and I will be subscribing. Thanks very much.
ruclips.net/video/LlrzonAXEW8/видео.html
Oh, I had another comment on the point you make about --- was it the Blues rhythms mimicking the rhythm of the trains. I noticed that years ago. But here is an interesting psychological insight about that train rhythm. The musical rhythm literally sounds like the sound a train makes, but it also mimics in sound the VISUAL rhythm you get when you travel fast, whether in a train or in a car on the highway. When you ride fast like that there is the fast visual rhythm of the road straight ahead coming at you, and then a secondary, slower visual rhythm of the trees, rocks, telephone poles, signs in your periphery on the side of the road.
Country Western music also creates movements that suggest the various paces a horse moves. For example, if you listen to Elvis' version of "Tomorrow Is A Long Time" he creates the rhythm of a horse slowly, lazily walking, and swaying side-to-side. And he suggests it's a Western theme also by having the tambourine rattling at key moments, sounding like spurs rattling, or the horse's reins.
Thanks for taking the time to watch this and thoughtfully respond. I will say as far as Can Calloway goes, I’m sure Elvis studied him closely. He was revolutionary in terms of the physicality he displayed & his showmanship.
And I am pretty familiar with the Fisk Jubilee Singers. I moved away from Nashville a few years ago after living there for over a decade. They are legendary in that city and not talked about nearly enough. I hope this video has given you a few more rabbit holes to explore. There are so many more layers, and it’s all quite fascinating. Thank you for subscribing. 🤎
Thank you!❤
Thanks
I really never knew the history behind that type of music.
Thank you for this awesome and informative video-much appreciated!
Great video while having info to back it up. History cannot be ignored
This is great. Thank you very much!
Thank you for educating me😃 I knew a bit of this but nowhere near as much as you
Carl Perkins and Jerry Lee Lewis said Chuck Berry was a black man that played country music
@@calvinguile1315Jerry Lewis is white as snow honey
Has anyone made a RUclips or Spotify playlist of all the songs / artists mentioned in this video?
Outstanding review and analysis. Western swing is often forgotten in these pieces because it's a branch that comes out of left field and is hard to fit in the narrative. You weave it in perfectly.
Just found this video. Wow, it's extremely well done and thoughtful; I learned a lot. (About a topic that is very difficult to define and tends to attract gatekeepers, no less.) Thanks for the hard work of actually defining the relevant genres, digging up the audio clips, and comparing them. Also, I love that fact that you don't cop out on the question of where rock & roll can really be considered to have started. You suggest an artist and then a song, and back that up with musical evidence, yet still allow viewers to make their own judgments. Well done!!
Excellent presentation, thank you !
Bill P.
Great documentary! TY!
Awesome video! Thank you!
An hour ago I had an idea "What if I made a video detailing how rock was invented?" I look up if anyone had the same idea and here it is. Done in a quick and coherent ways. The theme that genres are a combination of what came before.
Thank you for this educational video!
Brilliant. And important.
Thank you for your great explanation, greetings from Spain.
Thanks for pointing so strongly to Louis Jordan. To me "Saturday Night Fish Fry" is his most rocking (maybe because of the chorus lyric). His music was very light-hearted and fun, another important part of rock. Johnny Otis (no slouch himself) had a great radio show in the 90s that celebrated this birth-of-rock period.
Thank you so much for this. You ate.
Thoroughly & beautifully explained!!
We’ll done, concise, and accurate!! Thank you!!
Great introduction. It's understandable that he wouldn't merit a mention here, but an interesting figure that connects Louis Jordan with the rock n roll era was his producer, Milt Gabler, who also produced Bill Haley & the Comets' first album, Rock Around the Clock, reorchestrating Tympany Five arrangements and adding a backbeat to turn a western swing aggregation into a rock n roll band.
I know where this is going, but honestly I prefer to see Rock n Roll as a unifying art form of a multiplicity of races. It really shows the humanity of it. I just heard Aretha sing Satisfaction by the Stones and it just shows how we’re all one and connected.
Give Black people credit without all the bullshit
How convenient Wanda
I think you agree with me that a guy by the name of Bill Haley brought it into mainstream. Louis Jordan is one of the pioneers of early rock and roll. Thanks a lot for your video. Great!! What would be rock and roll without black artists?
He might have, but only because blacks were kept away from mainstream. Whites loved the new sound, but due to their racism against blacks they didn't want to hear it from the blacks but rather listen a water down version of it interpreted by whites. This happens with anything we create. Dreadlocks, afro, cornrows, Bantu nuts were looked down until white people and others started wearing those hair styles. Thick lips were a subject of mockery until botox was created. Now they pay money to have thick lips, so now thick lips are ok. And it never stops, it goes on and on to no end.
I think you nailed it ! Rock this Joint tonight, is in my opinion the first R&R song, that jump started it all.
It doesn’t matter the color of the individual or group who started it. It was an individual thing that changed with the influence of all kinds of music throughout time.
It does matter. As soon as you say ablack person started or invented something white people say it doesn’t matter. How come I never hear this when it’s about white inventors?
This a very good program, thx
Thank you, that was extremely informative.
Thanks for telling these stories about the history of modern music Dara! I think it's amazing just how much of popular music we owe to African American artists everything from, Blues, Jazz, R&B, Rock, Funk, Gospel, Disco, Hip Hop, Rap, House and Techno and everything that came from those... There must be something very powerful about the Black American experience good and bad that inspired so much creativity. It's a shame that many of these artist never got the credit but at least they Inspired so many. We would live in a poorer world without their contribution to music...
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect.
Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
Not the rock
@christinamaroon2615 You are completely IGNORANT. Please do your homework & see the video HOW ELVIS COPIED THE STYLE OF ROY HAMILTON. You wont be able 2 refute that. If you'll UNBIASELY RESEARCH the inventions & contributions of so called BLK AMERICANS in the U.S. you will be blown away. After almost 400 yrs of forced illiteracy BLK ppl have more substantial contributions than most others combined. FACTS. Even the technology that lead 2 the GAMA cell technology starts with us. Even the ranch dressing, french fries, potato chips & home security system that you enjoy comes from BLK EXCELLENCE. Not 2 mention that Automatic gear shift in the car you drive everyday. Or the Electric Railway if you don't drive ✌️🖤🦾🙏😉
Brilliant Dara!
I dig your video ive tried to reach out to you because of this video. I would like to go live with you speakkng pn this how would i can i do that .?
This is AMAZING work, Dara! Thank you so very much for pouring time and energy into this teaching. I’m so excited about this and can’t wait to share with others. Hopping over to Instagram now to look for posts of yours I can share right now! 🎉🎉🎉
🙏🏾🤎🙏🏾
Fascinating history lesson. Thanks a lot for this.
Fantastic script. I must say it took me probably 2 years to find all of the information you provided here. I wonder how long it took you guys to write this script
I teach rock and roll and guitar. This is probably the best rock and roll history video I've ever seen. I DO have to take one issue though. When you first talk about the earliest country and western taking from slave music, that's actually backwards. Slaves started blues and other similar music by listening to Irish and Scottish folk and adding an African rhythm to it, as well as their own feelings. The 1-4-5 stuff came from white folk music. That's where we get the first country. The idea of making it groove, comes from slaves. Otherwise, I think you nailed it better than anyone. And if you think I'm saying that black folks appropriated music first, no. They just made the best of what they had and what they were allowed to be exposed to. White musicians stole way more and still do.
Personally, I like American music and that will always be a mish-mash of black and white styles. That's the good stuff.
thanks!!!( don' t forget big Arthur Cudrup,the Drifters in 1953 imitated by gene vincent...)
You certainly did your research. I'm very impressed. Personally, I think Goree Carter's "Rock Awhile" is the first rock and roll song. It was released in April 1949, while Jimmy Preston didn't release his song until August. Big Joe Turner's and Louie Jordan's jump blues definitely fathered in the genre, and I'd say their biggest influence was Cab Calloway.
You are incorrect completely. You are calling Blues music as rock n roll. Incorrect.
Rock and roll was entirely different. Elvis style was more of a rock and roll. He is the one who broadened the Blues into a different style.
For me Robert Johnson laid the roots of Rock & Roll. 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
Thank you for an informative, succinct and well delivered , constructed presentation on the subject of Rock and Roll. As an Englishman I would add that for me the subtitles were not necessary.
Robert Johnson- They're red hot. It is the earliest fast and nice guitar and rock vocals I've heard other than rhythm and music itself. You just got a new sub here I love your video!!
Appreciate it, tbh, never hear of Luis jordan prior to this video!
blessings! much respect!
Probably the best accurate, succinct description that I’ve heard so far…yes, Rock’n Roll is just a label.
young lady you did a great job and i know that took a lot of time so i wil say thanks because it opened my eyes to the different people that contributed to rock and roll. i grew up in the 50's and Elvis fan also Chuck Berry but my favorite is Fats Domino i agree with Elvis i always felt Fats was the king of rock and roll mainly his songs were great to dance to and i was descent dancer. Also regarding Elvis you actually did a lot of homework on him and did a great job of squashing a lot of those rumors regarding racism that unfortunately a lot of people still believe. anyways keep up the great work
Good Job!!!
THANK YOU. This is incredible.
Thank you
Woo! SO happy to see some appreciation for Jimmy Preston.
Absolutely fascinating.
Love this explanation. Greetings from Peru.
You really know music or did your research, either way, it's impressive!
Great video! Thanks for making this. Boogie woogie (piano) is my favourite one!
I'll tell you what I like about this video, she said something that a lot of people forget. I was born and raised in Southeastern Kentucky and she's exactly right. Back in those days, you got treated like absolute crap regardless of color unless you were wealthy and good looking and marketable. The same things coal corporations were doing to black and white miners in Kentucky and Virginia, it's the same thing that they were doing to sharecroppers in Mississippi. My family migrated from Ireland and Scotland and a lot of them were coal miners that didn't even get paid real money. It was modern day slavery back in those days for all the poor people regardless of color. Even in today's world, it's not about color it's what you can do for somebody else to make them money.
This was outstanding
Dara offers a thoughtful overview of the history of rock & roll and Great Black American music, about as good as the best ones available, and better than most. If you're not going to read several books about the subject and listen to 200+ hours worth of blues, jazz, and early rock & roll, this video is a good 12-min education. Some minor factual errors, but mostly solid, and it comes with an educated Black perspective usually missing in most rock & roll scholarship. Good pacing and production values.
Very good exposition. Some of the inferences are tenuous though. While the influence of African American experience on Rock music must not be understated, it almost seems as though the presenter would like to suggest that without African American exposure, music would never have evolved in America?
Fantastic work Dara
Thank you for this informative video. I remember having a similar revelation when I was a teenager who grew up watching older "classic" movies and noticed a steady progression from big band to swing to boogie woogie. Rock-n-roll as a new genre was already mentioned in a few films from the late 1940's, not the 1950's as I had previously assumed. I think music had a lot to do with cultural integration in the United States and later Europe (where I happen to be living since 2022 thanks to my Hungarian wife : )
Great video. Love.
great work
I dig this the most thanks for sharing
This was interesting, thank you
First Rock’n’roll, Stephen Foster in the 1840s, you also neglected the influence of Hank Williams to the genre
I'm an amateur Rock 'n' Roll historian and absolutely loved your video. It was well-documented, well-written, and presented the material respectfully.
Thank you so much.
@@DaraStarrTucker This video was very impressive. While I knew at least half of the names, I didn't realize their music started as early as it did.
(PS: Love the shout out to Scott Joplin!)
Yes, it's an argument that will never end. Great programme,Dara, I haven't seen you before. You came up with all the things I'd have expected,and far more, because I know f*** all anyway..
One record you missed, not a criticism, it's an endless list, isn't it? But "Roll 'em Pete", the classic Boogie/jump blues track from Pete Johnson and Big Joe.
Thanks!
WELL done