Nado, about to cry and I am sitting in the bus. As a person dealing with major depression, I remembered how badly I cried when I read the news. Bogoshipda jonghyunah~~ Edit: I am crying,🥺😢
jonghyun's hyeya feels like the raw desperation, holding back someone's hand by the door. kyuhyun's hyeya is like the longing late night thoughts for someone who left for years.
The way kyuhyun sing this song I got goosebumps. After listen this song I believe that jonghyun will be happy up there. So please everybody please remembered jonghyun.
SM, please, realize how precious your artists are, treat them well, you have the most talented artists in KOREA, don't neglect or exhaust them TT TT Kyu, we did great TT TT
When sm gave them jobs, you said they’re exhaust the artists but when sm sent them to the dungeons like you said sm doesnt give them any work to do. You fans are seriously one of a kind. Make up your mind people.
@@ellalovelyella LOL they are neglecting groups that are supposed to be having their comebacks, while those need rest are overworking... No wonder their artists are one by one leaving the label.
You can actually hear his voice shaking. He’s really emotional with this perf. It’s amazing he chose this song and believed he could pull through without sobbing in between.
His technique is literally perfect. It's amazing how he can still convey such emotions with impeccable technique. Very few singers who sit on the top could do this as most usually go one way or another. I watched the episode and I really think that the reason he lost was because the judges wanted to know his identity 😂
kemalasari dina i think they knew for sure who it was. Kyuhyun is a very well known ballad singer. Kim Gura heard him sing regularly for 6 years due to Radio Star and , a guest judge said right off the bat that Genia was an idol with a long career, once a member of OMG slipped and called Genie “sunbae”. I suspect he was the one who asked to be pulled out, SJ’s comeback was just around the corner and he also had many individual schedules: salty tour, love at first song, his youtube channel, various solo appearances in concerts...
this is so incredible and I don’t think anyone could’ve done it justice like kyuhyun did. very beautiful. I’m sure jonghyun’s very proud. we miss you❤️
joel rabin I rlly enjoy the swordwomans performance and voice but I am kyuhyun biased and since he was friends with jonghyun his emotions were very well portrayed.
I think there's been quite a few people who can keep the emotional well in tact while performing this song. But I think it hits Kyuhyun a bit harder because he was close with him & he was deeply effected from the incident so he can convey it really well.
Las personas deberían ser más cuidadosas antes de comentar aquí. NO se trata de una competencia entre Jonghyun y Kyuhyun sobre quién cantó mejor la canción. Ellos dos eran muy buenos amigos, y Kyuhyun interpretó su canción como una forma de rendirle homenaje, incluso él lloró mientras lo recordaba después de terminar su interpretación y quitarse la máscara. AMBOS son excelentes artistas y sus interpretaciones son preciosas. Qué grosera la gente que insiste en demeritar a Kyuhyun, cuando básicamente no hay nada malo qué decir de su presentación.
Concuerdo, igualmente siempre al escucharlos cantando esta canción en el video, se me pone la piel de gallina por el sentimiento que le pusieron en ese momento al cantarla. 💜✨ Kyuhyun es un gran cantante💙 Pero no olvidemos que Jonghyun también lo fue💙
Yo realmente lo escucho y sigo pensando en la letra de la Alejandro Sanz, se ese amor que se va y regresa, pero nunca nos damos cuenta que es el amor viniendo a nosotros en diferentes rostros💖 Obvio que como la cantan es genial, es una canción difícil por el estilo flamenco al que fue cantado, pero si ellos la cantarán con la letra en español, que es la original, moriría por escuchar eso 😍😍
@@eeshitayadav7215 they were friends from training days he said. They also performed in the SM sub-unit “SM the Ballad”. They have some great songs in that. Please check it out. “Hot Times” is my favourite.
Kyu purposely didn't even sing some parts of this song that i think maybe the lyrics hit him hard.. the part he didn't sing: I don't want to live What should I do, what should I do without you? Living while pretending I don't know you I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this Hyeya, you are leaving me With just the cruel greeting of goodbye I'll resent and resent you Hyeya, please don’t leave, Hyeya You did well too Kyuhyun... Kim Jonghyun we miss you..
I wonder if Kyuhyun chose to wear the mask of the blue genie from Aladdin, because its voice actor and comedian Robin Williams also took his life due to depression. When Robin Williams died, many fans shared this poster of the genie being released from his bottle, with a saying on the top that says: "You are finally free."
1:53 that simple "ohh" sound literally made me cry. He sounded so much like Jonghyun and it left me in tears. You can tell just how much he truly misses him. You did well Jonghyun. Kyu, Jonghyun is proud of you.
Kyuhyun isn't title as the best voice for no reason. He touched everyone. This stage especially bcs he dedicated his whole heart on this song for jjong. Rest in peace jonghyun
@@michelrodrigues5686Kpop idol, I agree. I'd use the term "objectively" carefully since there are other K - Pop artists better than him. PHS, Naul, etc.
@@tssss3966 Wouldn't that mean that they should use the word "subjectively," which includes personal preference, rather than "objectively," which excludes personal opinion?
He defended his title with "Breathe", a song composed by Jonghyun and ended his 5th straight reign by singing "Hyeya" which is also Jonghyun's first solo/single performance. 😭😭😭 The way he wanted to give tribute to Jong is too precious.
@@isabelperalescalatayud9483 Wrong. SM Bought the rights for this song from Alejandro, the music stayed the same with another arragment, but the lyrics are different and written by Jonghyun.
this performance just goes to show how much kyu has listened to this song. you can tell that he’s gone over it so many times by all the pauses and slight breaths he makes. you can tell he’s gone over it so many times just by the fact that he (at certain parts) sounds *just* like jonghyun did in his own version. you can tell he put his all into this. he wanted to make jonghyun proud and i’m positive he succeeded. this song obviously means something to him, and he recreated it so well. he absolutely mastered this.
this whole performance was absolutely gutwrenching and beautiful but i don't know why that pause at 4:00 just hits the hardest no sounds for a few second, everyone is just stunned after kyu poured his heart out honoring his deceased and ends with a soft "don't leave me hyeya" it hurts but its beautiful
He sang Y si fuera ella (Hyeya) i can't ask for more ㅠㅡㅠ He said even though he was only a trainee for 2 month and couldn't make a lot friends, he was close with jonghyun and was in a unit togethet (SM The ballad). Kyuhyun: hyung did my best performing your song jonghyun-ah, did you hear that? I want to tell him that ㅠㅡㅠ He said jonghyun would've heard his performance today with a happy heart I'm Proud ELF Thank you kyuhyun, this is the best performance on KOMS for me and jonghyun i miss you 💙
I got goosebumps he is really really deserved to be the king . O don't how he lost the king title with such a phenomenal perfomance may be the opponent was on some another level . The best K-pop vocalist . I got emotional after hearing this song.
As a shawol and an elf, this song means a lot to me and to us, I love both performances and they both make me cry everytime ♥ Love you both to the moon and back.
his last stage in KOMS has always been phenomenal, back then he sang Wild Flower after taking off the mask, and now he delivered such a wonderful tribute. haven't seen such a sorrowful performance in a while, damn i have goosebumps everytime i listen to this..
Seré el primer comentario en español... Seguía a SUPER JUNIOR y a SHINEE desde sus inicios. Me gustaba mucho ver la evolución de Kyuhyun y Jonghyun, lastimosa desde la muerte del integrante de SHINEE deje de seguir el género pero ver esta versión de Kyuhyun que es en homenaje a Jonghyun que es el que interpretaba está versión coreana (Originaria de Alejandro Sanz), se me enchino la piel... Canta precioso, me hizo recordar la forma en que la cantan Jonghyun... Grandes talentos
Es el mejor comentario y mas respetuoso que he leido sobre esta cancion y sus interpretes coreanos, mencionando a Alejandro Sanz , autor de musica -letra e interprete ( que no es poco) . La gente se empeña en hacer comparaciones y restando merito a los otros. Las voces maravillosas, cada una con su personalidad, pero la letra a mi sinceramente me gusta mas la version original
como el Elf me siento complacida de escuchar a mi bebe ... como persona senti muchisimo la muerte de JongHyun... hubiese deseado conocer mas cosas de el... ver a mi Kyu llorar cuando habla de el, me destruye pero mas me duele lo que debe haber sufrido ese chico... gracias JongHyun por ese hermoso cover de Ale Sanz y gracias Kyu por reencarnar esa hermosa cancion...
A very good interpretation. It's not even surprising since it's Kyuhyun. Powerful voice. As for the emotions, it would have been more impactful if you saw his face expressions too. But that's the show and still, the message was there.
@ZeeZ - We have this show in Canada (televised from US) - they are anonymous behind the mask - you have to concentrate on their voice not their appearance
Kyuhyun for me got one of the most beautiful and clean voices in this industry. Protect him to all cost. If exist a person that can sings this song after Jonghyun, it's Kyu ❣️ God bless him voice.
I swear to god, I had this video playing in the background while I was doing other things and I swear to god some parts he actually sounded so much like jonghyun I actually had to stop and remind myself that it wasn't him 😭
Almost two years have passed since Jonghun's death, but his departure is still very painful and his close friends have not forgotten yet what is this fulfillment?!!! 😔
I don’t know who Jonghyun is so I googled him. So sad. After learning about Jonghyun, I listened to this performance again, and tears just fell. Jonghyun heard your singing Kyuhyun, and you made him very happy for sure 🙏🏻💐 I wish there is a pill I could buy at Walmart to make me speak Korean right away. Kyuhyun’s singing is the reason why I want to learn more about K-pop.
Maravillosa interpretación💖Gracias por ese homenaje a Shinne en especial por recordar a Kim Jonghyun. Por ello a nombre de la comunidad de latinoamerica👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
ALEJANDRO SANZ DEBE ESTAR MUY ORGULLOSO DE ESTA PRESENTACIÓN. Qué hermoso y créeme que es jodido encontrar una versión de sus canciones a este nivel tan perfecto 😭
Listen this song with earphone🎧, you can hear his amazing voice and his vocal technique so clearly, even you don't know what translate of this song, you will got amazed and goosebumps. i'm promise ㅠㅡㅠ but, if you know, i think you will listen this song 1000x like me and still crying & goosebump ㅠㅡㅠ Proud elf💙
Verse 1] Ella, say that you're sorry Someday very far away then Will you not say it at the end of the end? So even this painful time right now As we smile later on We can call it a good memory [Pre-Chorus] Ella, you said it with the heart of a good friend You loved me forever Don't say those words again They are so light to you but are too heavy to me This heart must have given you a hard time I'll back off a little, I'll wait I'll stand so far away that you're comfortable I beg like this [Chorus 1] Ella, how can you leave? Cruelly saying goodbye with those smiling eyes It kills me and my breath stops The melody that made me happy Is still so glorious Please don't abandon me, don't abandon me I don't want to live What should I do, what should I do without you? Living while pretending I don't know you I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this Ella how can you leave With those cruel words of goodbye I'll resent you for leaving Oh, please don't go Ella [Pre-Chorus] Ella you said with the heart of a friend You loved me forever Don't say those words again They are so light to you but are too heavy to me This heart must have given you a hard time I'll back off a little, I'll wait I'll stand far away so that you're comfortable I beg like this [Chorus 2] Ella, how can you leave? With those cruel words of goodbye I'll resent you for leaving Oh, please don't go, Ella Living while pretending I don't know you I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this Ella, you are leaving me With just the cruel greeting of goodbye I'll resent and resent you Ella, please don't go, Ella Don't go, Ella
i'm tearing up again after watching this video. Been years since Jonghyun passed, but his soul and music still lives on today. I definitely know that Kyuhyun and Jonghyun were especially close, so for him to sing this song in dedication was truly amazing. It's such a hard song to sing without crying. So for him to sing this without crying is honorable, and you can tell he was able to stop himself from crying since you can hear the shaking in his voice but didn't crack.
My heart squeezed tightly remembering Jonghyun-oppa 😭😭😭😭 I felt the longing, the resentment in Kyu's voice 😭😭😭 him saying "kajimara"(don't go) and I was bawling my eyes out 😭😭😭
I was never his fan, but strangely whenever I see his video or any video related to him in this last 3 years, I start crying. Jonghyun, what effect did you leave on me. Even when I remember my granny who passes away a year ago, I didn't cry that much.
Esta presentación me parte en mil pedazos, Kyu extraña y ama demasiado a Jong Hyun y eso se nota, para mi fue espectacular escucharlo y por supuesto saber que esto iba para el ángel!
Wow solo con el inicio de la melodia identifico esa canción super linda, conocida en latinoamerica por ser de Alejandro Sanz y muy bien interpretada también por jonghyun quien la dio a conocer en Corea.
Estás equivocado. Sólo la música es de Alejandro Sanz porque la letra es de jonghyun de SHINEE. Nada que ver con la de Alejandro Sanz ya que tienen un significado diferente.
Juro que escucho la voz de Jonghyun cada que escucho este cover. Lo extraño tanto. Precioso angel, a estas horas te recuerdo escuchando a todos aquellos que cantan tus canciones.
Una hermosa canción de nuestro Alejandro Sanz interpretada por el hermosísimo Kyuhyun realmente es una voz bellísima y su nivel de interpretación es exquisito.
La música es de Alejandro Sanz... pero la letra de “Ella” resultó ser muy complicada para traducir al idioma coreano. La adaptación la hizo Kenzie... quien trabaja para la SM y sus artistas. E hizo una historia de desamor. 😊
you know i got into super junior a little late and even then i haven’t really gotten to know them really well so i am not familiar with the extent of their vocals but kyuhyun is giving me CHILLS throughout this whole song. his voice is so soothing and i could listen to this all day
![Kyu Hyun Sends a Message to SHINee Jong Hyun [The King of Mask Singer Ep 222]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SlrEAP-YNpM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kyu Hyun Sends a Message to SHINee Jong Hyun [The King of Mask Singer Ep 222]](/img/tr.png)
!['Y Si Fuera Ella' Is The First Solo Song from JongHyun (SHINee) [The King of Mask Singer Ep 146]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EkCZB9jfdv8/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that he refused to sing the part of not wanting to live... so much respect.
Si
“It’s just a performance, it can’t hurt you”
The performance :
Is he kuyhuyn from super junior?
@@sugabts8771 yes
@@sugabts8771 kyuhyun
@@sugabts8771 i laughed, thank you you made my day 🤣
I've been crying for two days.
the fact that kyuhyun didn't sing the "I don't want to live" part just makes this all the more emotional for me and just gosh I miss him so much :c
What part?
@@kkpoplover7683 im jonghyuns version he sang further at 1:59 "i dont want to live..." But kyuhyun cut it
Nado, about to cry and I am sitting in the bus. As a person dealing with major depression, I remembered how badly I cried when I read the news.
Bogoshipda jonghyunah~~
Edit: I am crying,🥺😢
Ouhh the feeling tho😭
@@dikshagoyal5021 How are you now???
jonghyun's hyeya feels like the raw desperation, holding back someone's hand by the door.
kyuhyun's hyeya is like the longing late night thoughts for someone who left for years.
Damn this feeling though..
yes
This is the best description for both of them
😭😭😭😢😢😢😣😣I am crying!!
this is probably the most accurate interpretation of the emotions i’ve seen
This is how close SM artists are.
Really made me cry.
Yeah they are so close but SM doesn't change.
me: okay, im not gonna cry this time
kyuhyun: hyeya..
me, tears in my eyes: aw, shit, here we go again
I said the same thing and well. My eyes are full of tears and everything. This made me emotional all over again.
Same here, I’m crying over hear.
The way kyuhyun sing this song I got goosebumps. After listen this song I believe that jonghyun will be happy up there. So please everybody please remembered jonghyun.
Always remembering jonghyun😭
ah eve we never forget him to start remembering him..
Whenever I hear this song I feel so sad that he is the one who left now 💔..
RIP Jonghyun 🌹
yes.
Forever! '😞
Miss you jonghyung oppa 😥
the fact that you can hear his technique of singing is like a musical. as expected our kyuhyun
SM, please, realize how precious your artists are, treat them well, you have the most talented artists in KOREA, don't neglect or exhaust them TT TT Kyu, we did great TT TT
Yes. I agree & 2nd this 100%!
Now SJ have a sub label under SM so they're incharge of all their own songs i think.
When sm gave them jobs, you said they’re exhaust the artists but when sm sent them to the dungeons like you said sm doesnt give them any work to do. You fans are seriously one of a kind. Make up your mind people.
@@cloverthv yeah yeah yeah you're right! ❤️
@@ellalovelyella LOL they are neglecting groups that are supposed to be having their comebacks, while those need rest are overworking... No wonder their artists are one by one leaving the label.
It's weird how Jonghyun's version and Kyuhyun's version hit so different but make us all bawl our eyes out nonetheless.
You can actually hear his voice shaking. He’s really emotional with this perf. It’s amazing he chose this song and believed he could pull through without sobbing in between.
His technique is literally perfect. It's amazing how he can still convey such emotions with impeccable technique. Very few singers who sit on the top could do this as most usually go one way or another. I watched the episode and I really think that the reason he lost was because the judges wanted to know his identity 😂
kemalasari dina i think they knew for sure who it was. Kyuhyun is a very well known ballad singer. Kim Gura heard him sing regularly for 6 years due to Radio Star and , a guest judge said right off the bat that Genia was an idol with a long career, once a member of OMG slipped and called Genie “sunbae”. I suspect he was the one who asked to be pulled out, SJ’s comeback was just around the corner and he also had many individual schedules: salty tour, love at first song, his youtube channel, various solo appearances in concerts...
this is so incredible and I don’t think anyone could’ve done it justice like kyuhyun did. very beautiful. I’m sure jonghyun’s very proud. we miss you❤️
엠마Emma• personally I think The East Invisibility(Swordwoman) have done a better job
joel rabin I rlly enjoy the swordwomans performance and voice but I am kyuhyun biased and since he was friends with jonghyun his emotions were very well portrayed.
엠마Emma• ya, actually it’s true... his performance is more emotional and beautiful whereas hers is more powerful and dynamic... Agree ?
joel rabin yeah 100%
You're right! he isn't considered the best K-Pop vocalist for no reason!
He tastefully cut out the "I don't want to live" part. Thank you Kyuhyun for this ❤
kyuhyun may be the second person other than jonghyun himself can sing this song with proper emotion. jonghyun ah saranghae.
But there is Alejandro Sanz
You should also check Seungyeon
@Jjongs Cheekbones who?
@Jjongs Cheekbones yes Kihyun performed the song decently and he was a trainee back then..
I think there's been quite a few people who can keep the emotional well in tact while performing this song. But I think it hits Kyuhyun a bit harder because he was close with him & he was deeply effected from the incident so he can convey it really well.
can't imagine how many tears covered by that mask.
I can hear the pain in his voice😢
Me too!!!!😭😭😭His performance gave me goosebumps!!!!The pain in his voice......I am sorry I can't😢😢😢😢
Every so often I remember this performance and come back just to cry all over again. What a performance!
Someone's voice hasn't given me chills in a while but damn, I had them this entire video.
That's our kyuhyun 💙
@ Faith ! you should watch Son Seung Yeon`s performance cevering this song. She did a really great job.
You should also watch Kihyun, MONSTA X, very nice.
Las personas deberían ser más cuidadosas antes de comentar aquí. NO se trata de una competencia entre Jonghyun y Kyuhyun sobre quién cantó mejor la canción. Ellos dos eran muy buenos amigos, y Kyuhyun interpretó su canción como una forma de rendirle homenaje, incluso él lloró mientras lo recordaba después de terminar su interpretación y quitarse la máscara. AMBOS son excelentes artistas y sus interpretaciones son preciosas. Qué grosera la gente que insiste en demeritar a Kyuhyun, cuando básicamente no hay nada malo qué decir de su presentación.
I agree with you.
@ Daniela Ct - I think he sang the song very well.
I am from Canada, we don’t have this exact show here.
Concuerdo, igualmente siempre al escucharlos cantando esta canción en el video, se me pone la piel de gallina por el sentimiento que le pusieron en ese momento al cantarla.
💜✨
Kyuhyun es un gran cantante💙
Pero no olvidemos que Jonghyun también lo fue💙
Toda la razón. Preciosa canción y preciosa voz. Comparar es desconocer el talento y hermosa voz de ambos.
Yo realmente lo escucho y sigo pensando en la letra de la Alejandro Sanz, se ese amor que se va y regresa, pero nunca nos damos cuenta que es el amor viniendo a nosotros en diferentes rostros💖
Obvio que como la cantan es genial, es una canción difícil por el estilo flamenco al que fue cantado, pero si ellos la cantarán con la letra en español, que es la original, moriría por escuchar eso 😍😍
The most painful part is that,youre away when your friend passes away,and cant do anything.Then you came back you cant see him anymore😭
This comment makes me sad😭😭😭😭
Was he close with jonghyun??
@@eeshitayadav7215 Real close :')
@@eeshitayadav7215 they were friends from training days he said. They also performed in the SM sub-unit “SM the Ballad”. They have some great songs in that. Please check it out. “Hot Times” is my favourite.
You make me crying so hard😭💔
I felt for a moment listening to Jonghyun... That was so emotional, kyu made it beautiful.
Kyu purposely didn't even sing some parts of this song that i think maybe the lyrics hit him hard.. the part he didn't sing:
I don't want to live
What should I do, what should I do without you?
Living while pretending I don't know you
I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this
Hyeya, you are leaving me
With just the cruel greeting of goodbye
I'll resent and resent you
Hyeya, please don’t leave, Hyeya
You did well too Kyuhyun... Kim Jonghyun we miss you..
I wonder if Kyuhyun chose to wear the mask of the blue genie from Aladdin, because its voice actor and comedian Robin Williams also took his life due to depression. When Robin Williams died, many fans shared this poster of the genie being released from his bottle, with a saying on the top that says: "You are finally free."
@@octopu5ie No, that's the staff's decision.
Thank you for explaining the omission. I wouldn’t have known otherwise. KY really expressed the song beautifully.
@@octopu5ie I wondered same. It made watching this so much harder. I loved both Jonghyun Oppa and Robin Williams too.
@@wananajackbandit1 how... How are you able to say "oppa". And why.
1:53
that simple "ohh" sound literally made me cry. He sounded so much like Jonghyun and it left me in tears. You can tell just how much he truly misses him.
You did well Jonghyun.
Kyu, Jonghyun is proud of you.
Kyuhyun isn't title as the best voice for no reason. He touched everyone. This stage especially bcs he dedicated his whole heart on this song for jjong.
Rest in peace jonghyun
@Red Ivy bdsk, sj and shinee are close since trainee days. They even live together back then.
@Red Ivy He is objectively THE BEST in the K-Pop industry.
@@michelrodrigues5686Kpop idol, I agree. I'd use the term "objectively" carefully since there are other K - Pop artists better than him. PHS, Naul, etc.
@Red Ivy Yes,Kyuhyun's the best singer of k-pop and of the world
@@tssss3966 Wouldn't that mean that they should use the word "subjectively," which includes personal preference, rather than "objectively," which excludes personal opinion?
Así no seas fan de Kyu Hyun debemos admitir y admirar su hermosa voz, realmente es uno de los mejores cantantes que he escuchado.❤
gracias Army♡
Lo es claramente, ame escuchar este hermoso tributo a otro gran cantante ...
He defended his title with "Breathe", a song composed by Jonghyun and ended his 5th straight reign by singing "Hyeya" which is also Jonghyun's first solo/single performance. 😭😭😭
The way he wanted to give tribute to Jong is too precious.
This song dont 'not composed for Jonghyun,this song is composed for Alejandro Sanz,singer of Spain
The best singer of the world Kyuhyun
@@isabelperalescalatayud9483 im pretty sure the op meant that jonghyun composed breathe by lee hi not hyeya
@@isabelperalescalatayud9483 Wrong. SM Bought the rights for this song from Alejandro, the music stayed the same with another arragment, but the lyrics are different and written by Jonghyun.
@@isabelperalescalatayud9483 Jonghyun wrote hyeya lyrics T.T
çok duygulu söylemiş insanın ağlayası geliyor
why do I always cry when I hear Jonghyun's song? Whoever sings Jonghyun's songs makes my tears drop suddenly. I miss SHINee, I miss Jonghyun ...😭
Jjong, did you hear, many ppl love you..be happy and pray for the world will get better...
This song isn't Jonghyun's song, 'Y si fuera ella' is a song composed by Alejandro Sanz, an Spanish artist.
@@bmuri3349 but the korean version was subbed by him ... Yea but you are right
@@binaanand3218 Even if it was subbed by him it's not his song
@@kaihae9931 yes right
this performance just goes to show how much kyu has listened to this song. you can tell that he’s gone over it so many times by all the pauses and slight breaths he makes. you can tell he’s gone over it so many times just by the fact that he (at certain parts) sounds *just* like jonghyun did in his own version. you can tell he put his all into this. he wanted to make jonghyun proud and i’m positive he succeeded. this song obviously means something to him, and he recreated it so well. he absolutely mastered this.
His voice is him screaming out to Jonghyun 😭😭😭 man there was no way I couldn't get through that without crying 🥺
This.
this whole performance was absolutely gutwrenching and beautiful but i don't know why that pause at 4:00 just hits the hardest
no sounds for a few second, everyone is just stunned after kyu poured his heart out honoring his deceased and ends with a soft "don't leave me hyeya"
it hurts but its beautiful
He sang Y si fuera ella (Hyeya) i can't ask for more ㅠㅡㅠ
He said even though he was only a trainee for 2 month and couldn't make a lot friends, he was close with jonghyun and was in a unit togethet (SM The ballad).
Kyuhyun: hyung did my best performing your song jonghyun-ah, did you hear that? I want to tell him that
ㅠㅡㅠ
He said jonghyun would've heard his performance today with a happy heart
I'm Proud ELF
Thank you kyuhyun, this is the best performance on KOMS for me and jonghyun i miss you 💙
@ Penguin Evil - Which fandom are ELF?? So I don’t have to Google it .
Thank you
@@mjj1434 super junior's
I got goosebumps he is really really deserved to be the king . O don't how he lost the king title with such a phenomenal perfomance may be the opponent was on some another level . The best K-pop vocalist . I got emotional after hearing this song.
i think its bcos he want to focus on sj comeback
He also has a lot of show coming that's why he needs to let go of this show.
He is said that he want to lose bcz he want to focus to suju comeback
@@lastelfstand2461 where did he say that?
@@widzelf5248
In his 4th win
As a shawol and an elf, this song means a lot to me and to us, I love both performances and they both make me cry everytime ♥ Love you both to the moon and back.
his last stage in KOMS has always been phenomenal, back then he sang Wild Flower after taking off the mask, and now he delivered such a wonderful tribute. haven't seen such a sorrowful performance in a while, damn i have goosebumps everytime i listen to this..
Seré el primer comentario en español... Seguía a SUPER JUNIOR y a SHINEE desde sus inicios. Me gustaba mucho ver la evolución de Kyuhyun y Jonghyun, lastimosa desde la muerte del integrante de SHINEE deje de seguir el género pero ver esta versión de Kyuhyun que es en homenaje a Jonghyun que es el que interpretaba está versión coreana (Originaria de Alejandro Sanz), se me enchino la piel... Canta precioso, me hizo recordar la forma en que la cantan Jonghyun... Grandes talentos
Es el mejor comentario y mas respetuoso que he leido sobre esta cancion y sus interpretes coreanos, mencionando a Alejandro Sanz , autor de musica -letra e interprete ( que no es poco) . La gente se empeña en hacer comparaciones y restando merito a los otros. Las voces maravillosas, cada una con su personalidad, pero la letra a mi sinceramente me gusta mas la version original
Desde la muerte de Jonghyun ahora cuando escucho está canción me pone muy sentimental 😢
como el Elf me siento complacida de escuchar a mi bebe ... como persona senti muchisimo la muerte de JongHyun... hubiese deseado conocer mas cosas de el... ver a mi Kyu llorar cuando habla de el, me destruye pero mas me duele lo que debe haber sufrido ese chico... gracias JongHyun por ese hermoso cover de Ale Sanz y gracias Kyu por reencarnar esa hermosa cancion...
A very good interpretation.
It's not even surprising since it's Kyuhyun. Powerful voice. As for the emotions, it would have been more impactful if you saw his face expressions too. But that's the show and still, the message was there.
@ZeeZ - We have this show in Canada (televised from US) - they are anonymous behind the mask - you have to concentrate on their voice not their appearance
Kyuhyun for me got one of the most beautiful and clean voices in this industry. Protect him to all cost. If exist a person that can sings this song after Jonghyun, it's Kyu ❣️ God bless him voice.
I swear to god, I had this video playing in the background while I was doing other things and I swear to god some parts he actually sounded so much like jonghyun I actually had to stop and remind myself that it wasn't him 😭
cresildaa I know.. There was these parts where his voice sounded like Jonghyun’s 🥺💔✨
Yes sometimes even I found it hard to believe that was not Jonghyun! It’s like he was channeling him! 😭
Found this vid late but I feel the same way.
Almost two years have passed since Jonghun's death, but his departure is still very painful and his close friends have not forgotten yet what is this fulfillment?!!! 😔
Increíble voz!! El rey de la balada!!
Kyuhyun es capaz de tocar las cuerdas más sensibles del corazón!!! Amo a este hombre y su voz... BRAVO!!!
Kyuhyun es la mejor voz del k-pop y del mundo,su voz traspasa,ningun otro cantante consigue eso,por lo menos en mi.
Igual .
El ya está en otro nivel
Xia junsu es mejor
Comparto tu opinión hermosa voz, escuchar esta versión en Coreano y la original en español (ambas me impactan y estremecen mi corazón) 👏👏👏
I love all Kyu's songs but DAMN the way he put his emotions into this wins every song he sang!!
He's not here as a person anymore.. but we all know that he's here, with us, through his music
I don’t know who Jonghyun is so I googled him. So sad. After learning about Jonghyun, I listened to this performance again, and tears just fell. Jonghyun heard your singing Kyuhyun, and you made him very happy for sure 🙏🏻💐 I wish there is a pill I could buy at Walmart to make me speak Korean right away. Kyuhyun’s singing is the reason why I want to learn more about K-pop.
@Alexander A - I recently saw the tribute concert video for Jonghyun ( filmed 2 months afterwards ) .
I wanted to know more as well !!
Sadly there is no pill, but if there's something that heart truly desires, you can achieve that with practice.
This song is not Korean, it's just a cover version of the original. Inform yourself before you speak 😉.
@@Ivanahirodesyeah the original is in Spanish but he is definitely singing in Korean man
I'm crying for this cover. I'm hurting my heart 😔😭 Kyuhyun is a great singer and I love him 👏 and Jonghyun always be in my heart 💎
There is a few other singer that covers this song as well , but somehow , someway , Kyuhyun's version hits much harder , like a damn truck speeding 🥲
The absolute silence he left the crowd in, as if they couldn't even recover their breaths to applaud... i felt that.
Kyu canta impresionante, es una de las mejores voces de Korea. (Tal vez la mejor)increíble, canta con tanto sentimiento
En un gran interprete por eso esta muchos musicales y canta mucho ost. (Su voz es muy poderosa)
I'm in tears because that's so respectful and precious. Kyuhyun is a vocal king HE'S VOICE IS SO PERFECT PLEASE
Yes,Kyuhyun the best vocal of the world
it's rare I see the original panel with tears in their eyes. Not just tears but they feel the anguish and sadness. Great singer Kyuhun is
I think he really sing this song for jjong with all of his heart 😭😭
Maravillosa interpretación💖Gracias por ese homenaje a Shinne en especial por recordar a Kim Jonghyun. Por ello a nombre de la comunidad de latinoamerica👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
listening this song while sobbing so hard 😭
guess i really miss Jonghyun 😭
When Kyuhyun sang Heya, tears just kept flowing out of my eyes.
I felt like Jonghyun is singing 😔❤❤❤❤❤❤
Kyuhyun's voice is *chefs kiss
😮😊❤🎉Me encanta su extraordinaria voz y es muy lindo,,, este actor y cantante,, maravilloso ❤❤❤❤
It is singing a soul that desperately screams how much it longs for and misses its loved one...
This is so beautiful yet so sad 😭😭
Miss Jong Hyun 💕🌹
Yo extraño mucho a Jong Hyun... no me imagino a las personas que eran allegadas a el... chico te queremos mucho... Kyu eres genial!
Listening again and again, but still crying
ALEJANDRO SANZ DEBE ESTAR MUY ORGULLOSO DE ESTA PRESENTACIÓN. Qué hermoso y créeme que es jodido encontrar una versión de sus canciones a este nivel tan perfecto 😭
deberías de escuchar sus canciones son muy hermosas
I’m crying bc his voice is cracking while he is singing and that shows the meaning of how important is this for him ❤️
Mi querido Kyu estoy segura que tu voz se escuchó en el cielo 💙💎
Remembering Jonghyun today (12.18.22) & everyday..
You can feel the pain Kyu is singing with, and it's beautiful.
Listen this song with earphone🎧, you can hear his amazing voice and his vocal technique so clearly, even you don't know what translate of this song, you will got amazed and goosebumps.
i'm promise ㅠㅡㅠ
but, if you know, i think you will listen this song 1000x like me and still crying & goosebump ㅠㅡㅠ
Proud elf💙
Presiosa interpretación de Kyuhyun con su melodiosa voz ❤❤❤
Kyuhyun has a calm voice he did well really this song is one my fav song be of Jong hyun thank U Kyuhyun
聽到泛淚..
I think those people who disliked this masterpiece, were just clouded with emotion and their eyes welled with tears. And they missed the like button.
Verse 1]
Ella, say that you're sorry
Someday very far away then
Will you not say it at the end of the end?
So even this painful time right now
As we smile later on
We can call it a good memory
[Pre-Chorus]
Ella, you said it with the heart of a good friend
You loved me forever
Don't say those words again
They are so light to you but are too heavy to me
This heart must have given you a hard time
I'll back off a little, I'll wait
I'll stand so far away that you're comfortable
I beg like this
[Chorus 1]
Ella, how can you leave?
Cruelly saying goodbye with those smiling eyes
It kills me and my breath stops
The melody that made me happy
Is still so glorious
Please don't abandon me, don't abandon me
I don't want to live
What should I do, what should I do without you?
Living while pretending I don't know you
I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this
Ella how can you leave
With those cruel words of goodbye
I'll resent you for leaving
Oh, please don't go Ella
[Pre-Chorus]
Ella you said with the heart of a friend
You loved me forever
Don't say those words again
They are so light to you but are too heavy to me
This heart must have given you a hard time
I'll back off a little, I'll wait
I'll stand far away so that you're comfortable
I beg like this
[Chorus 2]
Ella, how can you leave?
With those cruel words of goodbye
I'll resent you for leaving
Oh, please don't go, Ella
Living while pretending I don't know you
I didn't know it would be insanely saddening like this
Ella, you are leaving me
With just the cruel greeting of goodbye
I'll resent and resent you
Ella, please don't go, Ella
Don't go, Ella
and yet, he cut that part and didn't sing it : i don't want to live........
This made the song even more painful and gloomy 😔
i'm tearing up again after watching this video. Been years since Jonghyun passed, but his soul and music still lives on today. I definitely know that Kyuhyun and Jonghyun were especially close, so for him to sing this song in dedication was truly amazing. It's such a hard song to sing without crying. So for him to sing this without crying is honorable, and you can tell he was able to stop himself from crying since you can hear the shaking in his voice but didn't crack.
The way he starts the song... so gentle and soft, just like Jjong would and it gave me chills
My heart squeezed tightly remembering Jonghyun-oppa 😭😭😭😭
I felt the longing, the resentment in Kyu's voice 😭😭😭 him saying "kajimara"(don't go) and I was bawling my eyes out 😭😭😭
You can feel his heart by his singing. I've been listening to Kyu for almost 8 years and I'm still amazed
I was never his fan, but strangely whenever I see his video or any video related to him in this last 3 years, I start crying. Jonghyun, what effect did you leave on me. Even when I remember my granny who passes away a year ago, I didn't cry that much.
He showed his heartfelt sadness through his voice as we can see
Im here again 😭 Kyuhyun voice is just so heavenly 💙
Esque esa voz es inconfundible!!, Kyu tiene una grandiosa voz
HYU HYUN 👏👏👏👏 DESDE ARGENTINA 🇦🇷 POR SIEMPRE EN NUESTRO CORAZONES ❤️ JONGHYUN EL ÁNGEL MAS LINDO ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
أفضل كوفر لهذه الأغنية ، كيوهيون بين فيها كمية مشاعر كبيرة
QUE HERMOSA CANCION DE ALEJANDRO SAENZ INTERPRETABA POR ESTOS CANTANTES CADA QUIEN CON SU ESTILO DE VOZ ...JONGHYUN Y KYUHYUN
La musica es de Alejandro Saenz y la letra es de Jonghyun como dices, quien la re adapto al coreano.
i've been watching this more than 100 times and never get tired
I've listened to some singers who covered this song, but Kyuhyun's is the best... He sang it with his own style.
He sings with so much support that I had eargasms listening to his voice.
Kyuhyun I'm so proud for you giving justice to the song of Jonghyun
本当に美しい歌声で、何度も聴いています。
Esta presentación me parte en mil pedazos, Kyu extraña y ama demasiado a Jong Hyun y eso se nota, para mi fue espectacular escucharlo y por supuesto saber que esto iba para el ángel!
Wow solo con el inicio de la melodia identifico esa canción super linda, conocida en latinoamerica por ser de Alejandro Sanz y muy bien interpretada también por jonghyun quien la dio a conocer en Corea.
Estás equivocado. Sólo la música es de Alejandro Sanz porque la letra es de jonghyun de SHINEE. Nada que ver con la de Alejandro Sanz ya que tienen un significado diferente.
@@patriciarivera2510 pero bueno la version original es de Sanz
Al final, Alejandro Sanz creó la canción. La SM probablemente compró los derechos de la melodía y Jonghyung cantó esta hermosa versión.
@@mrs.autumnrainno compró nada de los derechos.Quizás SM le pagó en plan de regalías pero Ale Sanz no vende su catálogo.
kyuhyun is so amazing
Juro que escucho la voz de Jonghyun cada que escucho este cover. Lo extraño tanto. Precioso angel, a estas horas te recuerdo escuchando a todos aquellos que cantan tus canciones.
Hermosa forma de homenajear a jonghyun. Hermosa interpretacion de kyu!
He sang it in a totally different way and technique but still perfect !! What a song! What a performance! What a voice!
wow. what an amazing voice. its so beautiful kyuhyun. we miss jonghyun.
Una hermosa canción de nuestro Alejandro Sanz interpretada por el hermosísimo Kyuhyun realmente es una voz bellísima y su nivel de interpretación es exquisito.
Sólo la música es de Alejandro Sanz. La letra es de Jonghyun de SHINEE. Es muy diferente.
La música es de Alejandro Sanz... pero la letra de “Ella” resultó ser muy complicada para traducir al idioma coreano. La adaptación la hizo Kenzie... quien trabaja para la SM y sus artistas. E hizo una historia de desamor. 😊
We are really miss him it's almost 2 years.... Jonghyun oppa
Una canción que a través de los años se vuelve mas sentimental y dolorosa...
you know i got into super junior a little late and even then i haven’t really gotten to know them really well so i am not familiar with the extent of their vocals but kyuhyun is giving me CHILLS throughout this whole song. his voice is so soothing and i could listen to this all day