Dear viewers, lots of you are saying that Arafat is a liar, and not to be trusted. In response to this, we would like to say two things. Firstly, we think it’s important to speak to a government representative, because we have to ask them tough questions and challenge them where necessary. And secondly, we will address some of the issues you are raising in far greater depth tomorrow on our show News Desk, live at 19:00 Bangladesh time, and 15:00 in Western Europe. We hope to interact with your comments then! ruclips.net/user/postUgkxMv5fjLwg8F6w1X8pJ3oFWUqrhkQHtGiv
I request DW to enquiry Mrs. Debarati Guha's journalism. She is speaking like government ministers of Bangladesh. How can a DW journalist even say this "I saw the devastation of national TV office. I am sure it can not be vandalised by students". She is already saying who can do what before any proper investigation. This kind of journalism is not expected from DW news. I knew DW is a trustful source of news.
Thanks DW for addressing the issue immediately. However, there's one more thing I want to repeat: I don't know whether Ms. Guha made unintended mistake, or she intentionally lied. But it's clear that her reporting doesn't represent the true picture of the situation here in Bangladesh. If she didn't lie, which I hope is the case, then I'm 100% sure that she didn't do her job sincerely. This kind of reporting is disgrace to journalism, especially when it comes from a well-reputed international media outlet like DW. I'd request DW to put more hard-working and realistic people on the field who take their responsibilities more seriously rather than relying on someone who chooses shortcut ways to do the investigation. We all know, there are no rooms for shortcut in investigative journalism.
I think it's safe to say the reporter Mrs Guha or DW BANGLA wing is complicit in her/their views since she tried her best to paint a rather subtle picture of the reality on ground. Shame!
I am a Bangladeshi, I hate this liar minister 😡😡😡 Police & government party members attacked students by a strong declaration of top government Ministers. They killed students and people who had no weapons in hand. 😢😢😢 It is a genocide
I think it's safe to say the reporter or this news media is complicit in her/their views since she tried her best to paint a rather subtle picture of the reality on ground. Shame!
Debrati Guha spoke like spineless Bangladeshi journalists. Her intention maybe support govt in different way but she didn’t give actual picture of the protest. We don’t expect this type of journalism from DW
Al-Bukhari reported that Abu Bakra (Nufay' ibn al-Harith) narrated that “when news reached the Prophet that the Persians had made Khosrau's (Kisra Shirawayh) daughter (Buran) their queen, he said: 'Never will such a people succeed who make a woman their ruler.
The majority of the Bangladeshi people are calling for a UN investigation into the genocide occurring in Bangladesh. Many of our brightest students have been killed by security forces acting on orders from the ruling party. At present, all Bangladeshi citizens live in fear of arrest at any time and in any place. We urge the international media to closely monitor the situation in Bangladesh. No one in the country is safe, not even young children and women.
Not only Arafat but also the whole party of government is liar. 900+ dead 10000+ injured 50000 + arrested Now the situation of Bangladesh is so difficult. Students can't stay their home safly. Police and govt are Acting in daylight but at night their mission is only arreste to our students.
I am Bangladeshi. But i hate this government. This government killed last 15 days 900+ general people and student. 20000+ injured and 50,000+ arrested.
Wtf is this Debarati saying. She talked about National Mourning Day, but did not mention that the entire country or all the students have rejected this program.
Didn't even think of mentioning the mass boycott of the "national mourning" by the mass of the people. Seems like some whitewashing efforts from Hasina's Indian cronies 😅😅
I’m a student of Dhaka University from Bangladesh. I need your attention to the fact that Arafat is a liar (one of the biggest liars I have ever seen). Most of the top officials of current government are liars. Here are two examples: You have seen a video (verified by Amnesty International) of killing Abu Sayed by Bangladesh Police. But even after having such a video, the FIR on this case says that Abu Sayed was died being hit by bricks thrown by students. So just think about that. Secondly, in July 18, the Minister of state for Posts, Telecommunications and Information Technology, Zunaid Ahmed Palak, stated that they shut down the internet to stop spreading rumors about the protest. After that he again said that the internet was shut down because of the attack on Mohakhali Khaja Tower by protesters, the data center was burned and the internet was shut down automatically. But when Bangladesh Muthophone Grahak Association stated that there was no damage of the data center that will require internet shut down, Palak again himself said in 27th July that they didn’t shut down the internet, it was shut down automatically.
I,m a Bangladesh student. • 11000+ injured 15000+ arrest More then 500+ students have been killed by Bangladesh police, BGB, RAB, ARM & ruling perty awami league.. These incidents took place in Bangladesh on the orders of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. The network is kept off to prevent the news from reaching the world. We want Justice
The government says it is a crime committed by BNP and Jamaat Shibir . I am a student and a citizen of Bangladesh saying this is a heinous lie of the government.
I'm an University post graduate student. I'm agee wih you. His lier Govt use this trump card to suppress opposition and justify their crimes for a decades. Only We bengali are know this.this Govt always hide thier crimes from the world by blaming opposition.
Debarati Guha is basically serving India & Dictator Sheikh Hasina's dictatorial purpose here. She failed to put forward the voice of the students or the civilians. Secondly almost all opposition party asked Dictator Sheikh Hasina regime to resign while she totally blindsided that. She shouldn’t be the person to talk about Bangladesh.
I Utterly agreed with you. DEBORATI GUHA indirectly acted as a spokewoman of present fascist regime lead by autocrate Sheik Hasina. She actually reflected the voice of ALI ARAFAT Who is well known for his heinous lie , toad , hypocracy ,racist attitude in political arena of bangladesh. To find the fact about ALI ARAFAT we would like to request DW to conduct a survey here to figure out what sort of hateful and disrespectful person he regarded as in BAngladesh. WE DO BELIEVE "DEBARATI GUHA" COULD HAVE BEEN MORE IMPARTIAL AND DIDN'T BIASED BY INDIAN GEO-POLICAL VIEWS TO BANGLADESH. Debarati failed to cover the actual scenerios that have been going in Bangladesh for more than couple of weeks. DEBARATI YOU HURT US !
I'm agree with you. They shouldn’t send any indian correspondent to observe this horrible situation. Bangladeshi people can't stand for Justice. Today 31 jully 2024 You'll see how they arresting those will try try to join "march for Justice" event in the road of dhaka city
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
Debarati Guha intentionally giving misinformation about 3rd party. There is no 3rd party.This crimes like BTV arson and Jail incident are done by Bangladesh Awami League(BAL).So that they can avoid the responsibility of genocide by blaming the opposition party!
Third party! Third party! Third party! Blah, blah, blah. Why does so-called third parties enter in every peaceful protest!! What are your law enforcement agencies doing? How were students shot in front of the police, RAB, BGB? That’s impossible because there were no third parties involved. The only outsiders were the Chatro League, Jubo League, and the MPs. Those culprits were involved in this to stop the protest at any cost. We have seen them attacking the protesters along with the police. Some of them were carrying guns, and Mr. Arafat is backing them.
I am a citizen of Bangladesh.🇧🇩 Primarily, Arafat was a liberal minister in the history of Bangladesh. He provided you with totally false information regarding this. On 18th July 2024, it was total the protest movement was all the students and, general citizens were present there. They killed more than 900 people and buried most of the people with an unknown citizen. Moreover, this reporter could not provide you with the real information regarding the ongoing torture that the government imposed upon the students. They are checking the students' phones and if they get anything check to the protest they arrest them and torture them brutally. If you do not trust me, then come and see or ask the general citizens of Bangladesh. Thank you.
@@Lobikill Prothom Alo (the most popular newspaper in Bangladesh) reported the death toll is 900+ I don't know if the report is still there in their website because the media is being controlled by the Government. Maximum owners of the channels are either connected to Government or are insanely rich
@@liverpool-YNWA-mwmi28 I don't speak bengali but apparently there is a Prothom Alo English version, and 2 days ago it only reported 150 dead :/ en(dot)prothomalo(dot)com/bangladesh/1hmcovbabm
One thing I must add: yes, there was destruction at the BTV building and the metro rail, and who is to blame for that is a separate discussion. The first thing to address is what happened on July 16th. On that day, they killed our six brothers who were peacefully protesting for their rights. The next day, July 17th, more people joined the movement, and the police responded with brutality, directly shooting to kill innocent students. Around 54 people died that day. As the movement grew stronger, people from different parties and sectors joined to support the students the other day, resulting in more than 900 people being killed that day, over 20,000 injured, and 426 losing their vision. They tried to hide the dead bodies, imposed a curfew, shut down the internet, and started arresting students everywhere, whether they were protesting or not. The destruction began when they started brutally killing people, and the situation spiraled out of control. Sources suggest that the destruction was caused by bus drivers who lost their income due to the metro rail, provoked by an MP from their own party, Awami League. They want to arrest all the students, labeling them as Jamat Shibir, but they refuse to acknowledge that it's not just Jamat Shibir; it's the whole country rising against them.
Ms Debarati Guha misinterpreted the situation either willingly or unwillingly. National mourning day was announced by the govt, but nobody participated such horrific joke of an event where the govt who ordered the kill announced mourning for the martyrs, who are labelling the martyrs as terrorists. Debarati Guha should do a better job or resign.
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
DW should fire Debarati Guha if they wany to save their reputation. Seemed like the Govt paid her to speak on behalf of them just like they are doing to the local journalists and media. This is not a true journalism. Complete rubbish.
And why is international media not talking about the minister who asked Chhatra League, now a paramilitary force, to control the student protesters with violence?!! HE MUST RESIGN
Debarati Guha doesn’t sound like she was actually here in Dhaka!!! She did not mention that today the whole nation rejected government’s proposal of mourning day and wore red bandana as a symbolic gesture of that. She did not mention about the true picture of cruelty against the students instead sounded like the govt. is somewhat telling the truth!!!!!!!!!!
Debarati completely changed the narrative by bringing third party involvement, she said she met Arafat the minister, seems she has been bought. And the government and Arafat is a downright liar. DW should be more careful whom they bring for interview.
Debarati Guha is not telling truth. She is trying to support the government side technically. Almost everyone rejected the national mourning day instead everyone was changing their facebook profile as whole red. Please make sure your representatives are transparent enough to uphold the truth.
Ms. Guha clearly failed to fathom the actual scenerio here in Bangladesh puting her professional sincerity into question. For example, 1. She overlooked the fact that general public also took part in the demonstrations. 2. She didn't mention that the mass population, specially students, rejected the declaration of the national mourning day by the government because the killers are now mourning - crocodile's tear. They showed red card against it. And Facebook platform turned red today with people changing their DPs and Cover Pictures to colour red. University teachers, Supreme Court lawyers, celebrities also came in solidarity. 3. She also seemed more focused on the loss of real assets than the loss of lives. This is exactly all the beneficiaries of the govt. are doing currently. 4. Even after the presenter asked her about the accountability of the govt., she didn't mentioned the fact that the govt. is not even acknowledging the killngs perpetrated by the law enforcement agencies- let alone taking responsibilities. The govt. is still puting the responsibilities on their political opposition party despite clear evidences of most of the killings were done by Police and BGB shooting demonstrators to death. 5. Many of the student leaders (Including Nahid Islam & Asif Mahmud) have been detained and tortured severly under police custody. If leaders like them who got such extensive media coverage are tortured in such brutal manner, then what can be happened to general students is a matter of grave concern. A 17 year old boy has been put into 7 days of remand despite being a minor shows how aggressive they can be. @dwnews
Ms Guha reached Dhaka on the 20th. She did not witness any of the clashes but there were enough video evidence. Without any verification she claimed there is a 3rd party involved. How do we know that 3rd party is not chatra league, or shromik league? There are reports and cc camera report showing faces of Shromic league leader burning govt buses and properties. Who were those individuals wearing civilian dress with arms and weapons along side with the police shooting at the students. Why were the police and government forces working with them? Sorry to say but This is a sub par reporting at best from Ms Guha and put her integrity in question.
Debrati Guha had the opportunity to speak out against the government's wrongdoings, but it seems she chose to play it safe and refrained from criticizing them. It's evident that she is protecting the government with her nonsense.
Bangladeshi students were peacefully protesting against quota, but the Bangladesh Student League (BSL), an organization of the government, along with Police protection launched attacks on us and are continuously doing so. Nearly three hundred students are already injured and many were killed in the attacks. A student was shot by the police on his chest, and achieved martyrdom. At this point, we need you very much because the journalists of our country are with the government. savebangladesh
Please rather than believing a minister’s speech, talk to general people and students to get the real picture. There is a list of almost 300 dead people in hand with names and identities! Many are unknown and unidentified. Thousands of students are getting arrested. We seek international investigation and support to save our country and people.
This channel is reporting based on Arafat speech and also an indian girl....The indian girl is a fan of Modi...They invite neither BD Students nor BD PPL here
This is called True Journalism. The journalist was not afraid to ask tough questions or confront the responsible Bangladeshi government minister. shame on Bangladesh Govt
Speaking as a Bangladeshi, the Newscaster did a Phenomenal job by asking Tough yet Important Questions to the Minister and for pressing on issues he tried to avoid. However, Debarati Guha, from DW's Asia Department is at best, willfully ignorant and at worst Biased towards the Bangladeshi Government. Next time Please DON'T Invite Indian Journalists to talk about Bangladesh - they Will Have a Conflict of Interest. That's because the Current Prime Minister of Bangladesh - Sheikh Hasina, is well known inside the country to be an Authoritarian leader who has been accused of holding onto Power Primarily with the help of the Indian Government for the past 15 years. She also supports Indian Policies which are detrimental to her own country - Bangladesh and to her own countrymen. For an Accurate portrayal of the situation on Ground you can invite Bangladeshis, especially, University Student Protesters who can explain the situation the Best, or even Researchers from Amnesty International who know the track record of the Human Rights Abuse of the Current Government towards both the country's Civilians and Political Dissidents.
Mr. Arafat is a bad liar. Every word he said is lie. One example, he said- Court accept student demands for quota dated 18 July. But it happened on 22 July instead of date 11 August, after government genocide. Shame on you Arafat.
I am Bangladeshi, i hate this liar minister, police and government party members attacked students by a strong declaration of top government minister. They killed students and people who had no weapons in hand😢😢😢 It is a genocide
Debarati isn’t the correct person for people of Bangladesh, she is serving India and dictator Hasina , she isn’t a fair journalist or honest journalist
This reporter did biased in interview. Because she favours Indian Government . She did not speak about truth and actual situation at Dhaka. Even she did not mention about law enforcement involvement in student murder. This Debi Rati is an indian agent. DW shouldn’t assign her at Bangladeshi news cover. Please let another Reporter to Dhaka
I,m a Bangladesh Students.🇧🇩 20000+injured 30000+ arrest more then 2000+ students have been killed by Bangladesh police, BGB,RAB,ARM & ruling party Awami League. Please help us International community Help Bangladeshi people
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
Because they're not free Look what they say about Palestine and Israeli backed genocide of Palestinians people and now after posting this might be removed soon this is the freedom rest you can check it in bd situation.
Debarati Guha either doesn't understand the reality of Bangladesh as an outsider or is super biased towards Awami League. Multiple political parties have been demanding Hasinas resignation for the past 10 years after 2 sham elections, including the BNP. Where is she getting her info?
She understands everything but serves the BAL. At the end She intentionally said that 3rd party Jamat-Sibir ke today ban kora hobe as if Ato students death er jnno orai dayi
please also consider interviewing/inviting people outside of politics as well who is in the country, there is teachers of our top universities, advocates, maybe some student willing to risk their safety to say the real picture of what happening.
Let me get this clear. Ms. Guha visited Dhaka to investigate this difficult and complicated situation. She spoke with government officials, visited the destruction sites, and then thought, "Oh, I have seen enough; I'll learn the rest from the TV," and came back! She didn’t bother to talk to at least one family member of the 200 people who were officially reported as killed, nor did she speak to any organizers of the movement. All she saw was chaos! She merely stated some of the government’s statements that Mr. Arafat forgot to mention. Is this really the work DW pays her for? Or someone else does the payment?
Mrs Debabrati Guha didn't give the right information. 1)BNP and other parties called for the resignation of pm. 2) Today govt. declared the national day of mouring. But the people of Bangladesh totally rejected it. You can see that everyone change their facebook profile picture into Red to reject this mourning. Please give appropriate information
I am speaking as a common citizen of Bangladesh. Bangladesh has now become unlivable due to the oppression of the present government. The student quota movement is centered around. These tyrannical governments are firing from helicopters. 😓 Many adults including 3 year old children have been killed in their own homes due to firing. Apart from this 1000+ students have been shot dead indiscriminately by this government. Thousands of students are now missing. Here is another reason why these brutal murders have been used. UN authorized helicopters and equipment. So is the United Nations behind this murder?? But the Bangladesh government has shut down the internet to keep this information secret. So that the international media does not get the correct information. In this situation our wish for the intervention of the United Nations. At the same time, I call on the international media to present the correct information to the United Nations🙏
I want to repeat: I don't know whether Ms. Guha made unintended mistake, or she intentionally lied. But it's clear that her reporting doesn't represent the true picture of the situation here in Bangladesh. If she didn't lie, which I hope is the case, then I'm 100% sure that she didn't do her job sincerely. This kind of reporting is disgrace to journalism, especially when it comes from a well-reputed international media outlet like DW. I'd request DW to put more hard-working and realistic people on the field who take their responsibilities more seriously rather than relying on someone who chooses shortcut ways to do the investigation. We all know, there are no rooms for shortcut in investigative journalism.
To get transparent & true report DW shouldn't appoint any Indian Civilian Journalist here in BD. They will never expose anything of this BAL Govt. like genocide on 18th, 19th & 20th July 2024. DW should rethink
Dear viewers, lots of you are saying that Arafat is a liar, and not to be trusted. In response to this, we would like to say two things. Firstly, we think it’s important to speak to a government representative, because we have to ask them tough questions and challenge them where necessary. And secondly, we will address some of the issues you are raising in far greater depth tomorrow on our show News Desk, live at 19:00 Bangladesh time, and 15:00 in Western Europe. We hope to interact with your comments then!
ruclips.net/user/postUgkxMv5fjLwg8F6w1X8pJ3oFWUqrhkQHtGiv
I request DW to enquiry Mrs. Debarati Guha's journalism. She is speaking like government ministers of Bangladesh. How can a DW journalist even say this "I saw the devastation of national TV office. I am sure it can not be vandalised by students". She is already saying who can do what before any proper investigation. This kind of journalism is not expected from DW news. I knew DW is a trustful source of news.
That's nice that you guys read comments
@@dwnews the news presenter was honest but Mrs guha was not fair
Mr. Arafat said govt have the ability to shot the protesters for five years continuously.
He is one of the Mastermind of the genocide.
Thanks DW for addressing the issue immediately. However, there's one more thing I want to repeat:
I don't know whether Ms. Guha made unintended mistake, or she intentionally lied. But it's clear that her reporting doesn't represent the true picture of the situation here in Bangladesh. If she didn't lie, which I hope is the case, then I'm 100% sure that she didn't do her job sincerely. This kind of reporting is disgrace to journalism, especially when it comes from a well-reputed international media outlet like DW. I'd request DW to put more hard-working and realistic people on the field who take their responsibilities more seriously rather than relying on someone who chooses shortcut ways to do the investigation. We all know, there are no rooms for shortcut in investigative journalism.
Arafat minister of information❌
Arafat minister of misinformation✅
Actually he is a minister of disinformation.
True
shame on this liar
True 💯
Right
Arafat is a 100% liar.
900+ Dead Students
10,000+ Injured
50,000+ Arrest
What can you expect from themm😅😅
All over Bangladesh, more than thousands....& much more, It's just Genocide.
It's 100℅ true
গনহত্যার বিচার চাই
I think it's safe to say the reporter Mrs Guha or DW BANGLA wing is complicit in her/their views since she tried her best to paint a rather subtle picture of the reality on ground. Shame!
I am a Bangladeshi, I hate this liar minister 😡😡😡
Police & government party members attacked students by a strong declaration of top government Ministers.
They killed students and people who had no weapons in hand. 😢😢😢
It is a genocide
*Мир сейчас вышел из-под контроля ☫*
@@GuardianFederationtrue
A little correction: "liar" thank you
Agreed.....
I think it's safe to say the reporter or this news media is complicit in her/their views since she tried her best to paint a rather subtle picture of the reality on ground. Shame!
Debrati Guha spoke like spineless Bangladeshi journalists. Her intention maybe support govt in different way but she didn’t give actual picture of the protest. We don’t expect this type of journalism from DW
Shame on DW to have a biased person like her
900+ killed, 50,000+ arrested, 4000+ vanished by the dictator regime!
Please save Bangladeshi students, they needs immediate international help.
Right Information.
@@MHWorldwide 100% Right...
900+killed, 50000+ arrested 100% true Mr Arafat is a liar.
Deutsche Welle representative in Bangladesh have they found any evidence of the death of so many thousands of people?
I'm a Bangladeshi and i can say that this Minister is a great lair
and 98% of Bangladeshi people believe that.
I'm also from bangladesh.
You're right. He is a very big lair🤬🤬🤬🤬
Yes he is biggest liar
Great lair😮
True
Agreed
Don't trust Bangladeshi ministers because they are also involved in these crimes. Save Bangladesh
Indeed
Right
Right
1000+ killed
12000+ Arrested
20000+ injured
Please save students save Bangladesh.
I am a student of Banglasesh.
Arafat is a 100% liar.
1000+ Students Dead
10,000+ Injured
50,000+ Arrest
and info directly coming from heaven... 😂
I am from Bangladesh. There was no third party as Arafat mentioned. There were only two parties - police and innocent civilians. Full stop.
Chatro league was the third party.
Right @@miqsirajuddin5378
Mr. Arafat said rubbish as a minister of ruling Govt.
But Debabarati said more rubbish as a neutral😢 Shame
Liar everywhere
We are residents of Bangladesh. We love our country. But,this government is illegal in power.Illegally ruling his power against public opinion.
Al-Bukhari reported that Abu Bakra (Nufay' ibn al-Harith) narrated that “when news reached the Prophet that the Persians had made Khosrau's (Kisra Shirawayh) daughter (Buran) their queen, he said: 'Never will such a people succeed who make a woman their ruler.
900+ Dead.
10,000 +Injured
40,000+ Arrest
He is a Liar.
900+ dead
10,000+ injured
50,000+ arrest
Please save Bangladeshi students
The majority of the Bangladeshi people are calling for a UN investigation into the genocide occurring in Bangladesh. Many of our brightest students have been killed by security forces acting on orders from the ruling party. At present, all Bangladeshi citizens live in fear of arrest at any time and in any place. We urge the international media to closely monitor the situation in Bangladesh. No one in the country is safe, not even young children and women.
You are absolutely right we heard that from Bangladeshi relatives save our country Bangladesh save our students 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Agreed
Agree
Agreed
1200+ Students killed.
13000 + Arrested.
23000+ Injured.
Please save us save Bangladesh
Not only Arafat but also the whole party of government is liar.
900+ dead
10000+ injured
50000 + arrested
Now the situation of Bangladesh is so difficult. Students can't stay their home safly. Police and govt are Acting in daylight but at night their mission is only arreste to our students.
@@junaidhossain4022 right 👍
Right
I am a student as well as one of the protesters...
This minister is a liar,totally a liar...
We don want this government.
Agreed
900+ dead
10,000+ injured
50,000+ arrest
Please save Bangladeshi students
Step down Hasina is a criminal
900+ died by police , 10000+ injured
I am from Bangladesh & also Bangladeshi student,, we want justice and save my country. Mr. Arafat (Minister) is completely lair.
I am Bangladeshi.
But i hate this government.
This government killed last 15 days 900+ general people and student.
20000+ injured and 50,000+ arrested.
Wtf is this Debarati saying. She talked about National Mourning Day, but did not mention that the entire country or all the students have rejected this program.
She is Indian and probably works for Modi.
She was trying to pitch an idea about a third party. Bullets are from law enforcement not from a third party.
She is playing press secretary of Arafat; (ghush khoor)
Please reach out to DW to investigate if she received a cheque from Arafat, this is ridiculous
Didn't even think of mentioning the mass boycott of the "national mourning" by the mass of the people. Seems like some whitewashing efforts from Hasina's Indian cronies 😅😅
I’m a student of Dhaka University from Bangladesh. I need your attention to the fact that Arafat is a liar (one of the biggest liars I have ever seen).
Most of the top officials of current government are liars. Here are two examples:
You have seen a video (verified by Amnesty International) of killing Abu Sayed by Bangladesh Police. But even after having such a video, the FIR on this case says that Abu Sayed was died being hit by bricks thrown by students. So just think about that.
Secondly, in July 18, the Minister of state for Posts, Telecommunications and Information Technology, Zunaid Ahmed Palak, stated that they shut down the internet to stop spreading rumors about the protest. After that he again said that the internet was shut down because of the attack on Mohakhali Khaja Tower by protesters, the data center was burned and the internet was shut down automatically.
But when Bangladesh Muthophone Grahak Association stated that there was no damage of the data center that will require internet shut down, Palak again himself said in 27th July that they didn’t shut down the internet, it was shut down automatically.
You are absolutely right. Salute.
you are right my siniour brother .
i am the studen of dhaka college.
I,m a Bangladesh student. • 11000+ injured 15000+ arrest More then 500+ students have been killed by Bangladesh police, BGB, RAB, ARM & ruling perty awami league.. These incidents took place in Bangladesh on the orders of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. The network is kept off to prevent the news from reaching the world.
We want Justice
The government says it is a crime committed by BNP and Jamaat Shibir . I am a student and a citizen of Bangladesh saying this is a heinous lie of the government.
I'm an University post graduate student. I'm agee wih you. His lier Govt use this trump card to suppress opposition and justify their crimes for a decades. Only We bengali are know this.this Govt always hide thier crimes from the world by blaming opposition.
Debrati Guha had the chance to tell the full truth but she acted just like the spineless journalists of BD.
She got no spine! Sold her soul
Yeah every journalist who does not accept your misinformation campaign is "spineless" 😂
Paid agent of India
Spineless or complicit?
Right.. because of maximum time she spent in materials visit with government
There is no 3rd party.
3rd party is the Government.
Then BNP is the second party.
People and journalists like Debarati Guha are 3rd parties,.... shame on DW
@@Zeet_BaralBNP doesn't even exist now😂they are no better than sidechicks😂
@@screenrecord7302 yes brother
It is said in Abu Saeed's case that no policeman died in the shooting. Even a 16-year-old child has been arrested in this case.
I am a Bangladeshi student.Arafat is lying here.Dedarati is not telling the truth.
Agreed totally
Right
Right
Debarati Guha is basically serving India & Dictator Sheikh Hasina's dictatorial purpose here.
She failed to put forward the voice of the students or the civilians. Secondly almost all opposition party asked Dictator Sheikh Hasina regime to resign while she totally blindsided that.
She shouldn’t be the person to talk about Bangladesh.
Exactly. How's she the Dw Head OF asia ? Maybe,Just because she's from India.
Debrati is an ineligible person as a journalist as she hides the reality of ground.
I Utterly agreed with you. DEBORATI GUHA indirectly acted as a spokewoman of present fascist regime lead by autocrate Sheik Hasina. She actually reflected the voice of ALI ARAFAT Who is well known for his heinous lie , toad , hypocracy ,racist attitude in political arena of bangladesh. To find the fact about ALI ARAFAT we would like to request DW to conduct a survey here to figure out what sort of hateful and disrespectful person he regarded as in BAngladesh.
WE DO BELIEVE "DEBARATI GUHA" COULD HAVE BEEN
MORE IMPARTIAL AND DIDN'T BIASED BY INDIAN GEO-POLICAL VIEWS TO BANGLADESH. Debarati failed to cover the actual scenerios that have been going in Bangladesh for more than couple of weeks.
DEBARATI YOU HURT US !
Agreed with you.
Exactly
Mrs. Debarati Guha intentionally hiding information and she is also giving some misinformation! unbelievable. Please change this correspondence!!!!
I'm agree with you. They shouldn’t send any indian correspondent to observe this horrible situation. Bangladeshi people can't stand for Justice. Today 31 jully 2024 You'll see how they arresting those will try try to join "march for Justice" event in the road of dhaka city
The correspondence served the BAL
Yes, she could have added some more information rather she hides many things😢
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
She gave misinformation to us. Even she is not our country's journalist. She paided by Bangladeshi government.
I am a Bangladeshi student. Today almost 7 students have been killed by police, army, rab, and Bangladesh Chatro league.
Raise voice for Bangladesh
900+ dead
10,000+ injured
50,000+ arrest
Please save Bangladeshi students 😭🙏
Step down Hasina is a criminal ❌
Step down hasina
Step down hasina
Step down hasina
Step down hasina
🔴🔴🔴♦️♦️♦️♦️🔴🔴🔴
Please save the innocent unarmed students
Abdul va abdul is not genocide😂
@@thegodkratos1275You bot, harrasing people.
Are you unemployed😂?
@@thegodkratos1275 lindu
They arrested a 16 year minor student for abu sayeed's muder case. Everyone sees in the video that police killed abu sayeed. What a nightmare!
You'rw Lying 🤥
Seikh Hasina Is Great . Thank You Seikh Hasina. And Everything Is Fine In Bangladesh. Don't Be Blind
Please save Bangladesh's students we want to live 😢😢😢
Debarati Guha intentionally giving misinformation about 3rd party. There is no 3rd party.This crimes like BTV arson and Jail incident are done by Bangladesh Awami League(BAL).So that they can avoid the responsibility of genocide by blaming the opposition party!
Devarti is an agent of Indian Modi
You are right I agree with you
Generally Hindus like Sheikh Hasina...so no surprise
She is a puppet of the ruling party, misleading world media
@@abdurrahmankhan1145 Not all Hindus, only the Indian producta
Third party! Third party! Third party! Blah, blah, blah.
Why does so-called third parties enter in every peaceful protest!! What are your law enforcement agencies doing? How were students shot in front of the police, RAB, BGB?
That’s impossible because there were no third parties involved. The only outsiders were the Chatro League, Jubo League, and the MPs. Those culprits were involved in this to stop the protest at any cost. We have seen them attacking the protesters along with the police. Some of them were carrying guns, and Mr. Arafat is backing them.
Same
I am a citizen of Bangladesh.🇧🇩
Primarily, Arafat was a liberal minister in the history of Bangladesh. He provided you with totally false information regarding this. On 18th July 2024, it was total the protest movement was all the students and, general citizens were present there. They killed more than 900 people and buried most of the people with an unknown citizen. Moreover, this reporter could not provide you with the real information regarding the ongoing torture that the government imposed upon the students. They are checking the students' phones and if they get anything check to the protest they arrest them and torture them brutally. If you do not trust me, then come and see or ask the general citizens of Bangladesh. Thank you.
He is a lair
Save Bangladeshi student 😢
We don't want them to apologize, we want justice.
Arafat is a liar.
They already excluded that particular policeman who killed Abu Saeed on that day from their charge sheet.
900+ dead ( students, children)
10000+ injured
50000+ arrested
Right
Can you provide a source? Couldn't find anywhere saying more than 201 dead. Thanks!
@@Lobikillmany newspaper had published more than 300 people killed by the government force.. I can give u prove
@@Lobikill Prothom Alo (the most popular newspaper in Bangladesh) reported the death toll is 900+
I don't know if the report is still there in their website because the media is being controlled by the Government. Maximum owners of the channels are either connected to Government or are insanely rich
@@liverpool-YNWA-mwmi28 I don't speak bengali but apparently there is a Prothom Alo English version, and 2 days ago it only reported 150 dead :/ en(dot)prothomalo(dot)com/bangladesh/1hmcovbabm
One thing I must add: yes, there was destruction at the BTV building and the metro rail, and who is to blame for that is a separate discussion. The first thing to address is what happened on July 16th. On that day, they killed our six brothers who were peacefully protesting for their rights. The next day, July 17th, more people joined the movement, and the police responded with brutality, directly shooting to kill innocent students. Around 54 people died that day.
As the movement grew stronger, people from different parties and sectors joined to support the students the other day, resulting in more than 900 people being killed that day, over 20,000 injured, and 426 losing their vision. They tried to hide the dead bodies, imposed a curfew, shut down the internet, and started arresting students everywhere, whether they were protesting or not.
The destruction began when they started brutally killing people, and the situation spiraled out of control. Sources suggest that the destruction was caused by bus drivers who lost their income due to the metro rail, provoked by an MP from their own party, Awami League. They want to arrest all the students, labeling them as Jamat Shibir, but they refuse to acknowledge that it's not just Jamat Shibir; it's the whole country rising against them.
Arafat the Minister of misinformation... He is a liar🤬
Ms Debarati Guha misinterpreted the situation either willingly or unwillingly. National mourning day was announced by the govt, but nobody participated such horrific joke of an event where the govt who ordered the kill announced mourning for the martyrs, who are labelling the martyrs as terrorists. Debarati Guha should do a better job or resign.
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
@@in_tasin There's no "neutral narrative" against a genocide.
There were no 3rd party involvement. This man is shamelessly lying.
Ms Guha do not know the real picture, she landed 20th where all the violence was made before the date.
In a single hospital death toll was 103 in dhaka. 150 is the total death count? This man is a pure liar.
they can only tell lie
DW should fire Debarati Guha if they wany to save their reputation. Seemed like the Govt paid her to speak on behalf of them just like they are doing to the local journalists and media. This is not a true journalism. Complete rubbish.
Arafat criminal
Please keep an eye on Bangladesh for every moment.
And why is international media not talking about the minister who asked Chhatra League, now a paramilitary force, to control the student protesters with violence?!! HE MUST RESIGN
1000+ Students Killed,
12000+ Arrested,
20000+ Injured
Please Save Us Save Bangladesh
12000 arrested
100% true.
I am a Bangladeshi student. In this quota movement Bangladeshi government killed almost 1000+ students.
Please support & help us 😢🇧🇩🥲
Debarati Guha doesn’t sound like she was actually here in Dhaka!!! She did not mention that today the whole nation rejected government’s proposal of mourning day and wore red bandana as a symbolic gesture of that. She did not mention about the true picture of cruelty against the students instead sounded like the govt. is somewhat telling the truth!!!!!!!!!!
This, i mean she is not entirely wrong, but she didn't reveal a lot of crucial info
I was thinking exactly the same. As if she is speaking on behalf of BAL
Well seems she makes money from her risky visit at Dhaka
She's one of the many RAW informants/agents who are helping Hasina Regime to contain the Protests by any means.
She is a family friend of Hasina...
No freedom, no internet, no right to speech, no limit on corruption, no vote!!! Welcome to Bangladesh 🤝🥀🥲
What the rubbish Debabrati is saying?
She is also lying.
She is a paid agent.
@@dystopian_1 nah indian agent
She is from India so surely she was paid by the awami league
She has been misled
@@taifurrahmanbitto6822 she knows what she is doing
By creating the movement, some dishonest politicians who do Jamaat-BNP politics have harmed Bangladesh.
Debarati completely changed the narrative by bringing third party involvement, she said she met Arafat the minister, seems she has been bought. And the government and Arafat is a downright liar. DW should be more careful whom they bring for interview.
Debarati Guha is not telling truth. She is trying to support the government side technically. Almost everyone rejected the national mourning day instead everyone was changing their facebook profile as whole red. Please make sure your representatives are transparent enough to uphold the truth.
Shame ....Alos I heard KHALED MOHIUDDIN quited ?!!
Ms. Guha clearly failed to fathom the actual scenerio here in Bangladesh puting her professional sincerity into question.
For example,
1. She overlooked the fact that general public also took part in the demonstrations.
2. She didn't mention that the mass population, specially students, rejected the declaration of the national mourning day by the government because the killers are now mourning - crocodile's tear. They showed red card against it. And Facebook platform turned red today with people changing their DPs and Cover Pictures to colour red. University teachers, Supreme Court lawyers, celebrities also came in solidarity.
3. She also seemed more focused on the loss of real assets than the loss of lives. This is exactly all the beneficiaries of the govt. are doing currently.
4. Even after the presenter asked her about the accountability of the govt., she didn't mentioned the fact that the govt. is not even acknowledging the killngs perpetrated by the law enforcement agencies- let alone taking responsibilities. The govt. is still puting the responsibilities on their political opposition party despite clear evidences of most of the killings were done by Police and BGB shooting demonstrators to death.
5. Many of the student leaders (Including Nahid Islam & Asif Mahmud) have been detained and tortured severly under police custody. If leaders like them who got such extensive media coverage are tortured in such brutal manner, then what can be happened to general students is a matter of grave concern. A 17 year old boy has been put into 7 days of remand despite being a minor shows how aggressive they can be.
@dwnews
She is biased.
Ms Guha reached Dhaka on the 20th. She did not witness any of the clashes but there were enough video evidence. Without any verification she claimed there is a 3rd party involved. How do we know that 3rd party is not chatra league, or shromik league? There are reports and cc camera report showing faces of Shromic league leader burning govt buses and properties. Who were those individuals wearing civilian dress with arms and weapons along side with the police shooting at the students. Why were the police and government forces working with them? Sorry to say but This is a sub par reporting at best from Ms Guha and put her integrity in question.
Please save the people and students of Bangladesh from🇧🇩 this Sairachari government😢😢
Debrati Guha had the opportunity to speak out against the government's wrongdoings, but it seems she chose to play it safe and refrained from criticizing them. It's evident that she is protecting the government with her nonsense.
Absolutely right
she is from neighboring country!!! u have to understand her stand for our government!
May be she is sponsored by Indian Modi Government!
exactly, she’s tiptoeing around the main problem or diluting the extent of the horrible things the government has done
Devrati Indian product - so u can understand it
Bangladeshi students were peacefully protesting against quota, but the Bangladesh Student League (BSL), an organization of the government, along with Police protection launched attacks on us and are continuously doing so. Nearly three hundred students are already injured and many were killed in the attacks. A student was shot by the police on his chest, and achieved martyrdom. At this point, we need you very much because the journalists of our country are with the government. savebangladesh
Right
900+ Dead Students
10,000+ Injured
50,000+ Arrest
There's no room for apology. No one needs it anymore.
This government has to go.
It's totally genocide in Bangladesh
Agreed
Please rather than believing a minister’s speech, talk to general people and students to get the real picture. There is a list of almost 300 dead people in hand with names and identities! Many are unknown and unidentified. Thousands of students are getting arrested. We seek international investigation and support to save our country and people.
Exactly, the current situation is much more dangerous😓
True comment 🥺
This channel is reporting based on Arafat speech and also an indian girl....The indian girl is a fan of Modi...They invite neither BD Students nor BD PPL here
Govt is massacring and arresting students, please help.🙏🇧🇩😭
I think Debarati Guha didn't talk from a journalist prespective. You should not trust her. 🟡
You are 100% Right and she is also a liar like MA Arafat.
Debrati Guha spoke like spineless Bangladeshi journalists. And that information minister is a complete liar. It is not the first time this guy lied.
She is Indian Bengali
In Bangladesh Third party is also our Government. They killed our brothers and blame on the third party.
Unnecessary gunshot even killed children. This was provocative and aggressive to unarmed protesters.
Debrati’s stand is partial, and diplomatic. She did not mention killing of children by law enforcers. She also escaped the ambush made by Army.
This is called True Journalism. The journalist was not afraid to ask tough questions or confront the responsible Bangladeshi government minister. shame on Bangladesh Govt
Yet he didn't have guts to anwser.
@@SwapnosGalleryCanada yes
Speaking as a Bangladeshi, the Newscaster did a Phenomenal job by asking Tough yet Important Questions to the Minister and for pressing on issues he tried to avoid. However, Debarati Guha, from DW's Asia Department is at best, willfully ignorant and at worst Biased towards the Bangladeshi Government. Next time Please DON'T Invite Indian Journalists to talk about Bangladesh - they Will Have a Conflict of Interest. That's because the Current Prime Minister of Bangladesh - Sheikh Hasina, is well known inside the country to be an Authoritarian leader who has been accused of holding onto Power Primarily with the help of the Indian Government for the past 15 years. She also supports Indian Policies which are detrimental to her own country - Bangladesh and to her own countrymen.
For an Accurate portrayal of the situation on Ground you can invite Bangladeshis, especially, University Student Protesters who can explain the situation the Best, or even Researchers from Amnesty International who know the track record of the Human Rights Abuse of the Current Government towards both the country's Civilians and Political Dissidents.
Exactly
Exactly
Yes, I couldn't agree more.
He is a liar..
Please save us.. 952 students died, not 200
Our government & police killed innocent students 😭😭😭😭🇧🇩🇧🇩
They won't. They can but they don't want to.
None can save us , we have to fight back ..
Right
it was 972
Why didn’t they just say Bangladesh’s Tyrant killed close to or more than 1000 students including pre-school kids ?
Why playing with words?
As a Bangladeshi, I can say that what the current government is saying about the protest is nothing but a lie.
Talk to the student leader, not the minister.
Mr. Arafat is a bad liar. Every word he said is lie. One example, he said- Court accept student demands for quota dated 18 July. But it happened on 22 July instead of date 11 August, after government genocide. Shame on you Arafat.
I am Bangladeshi, i hate this liar minister, police and government party members attacked students by a strong declaration of top government minister.
They killed students and people who had no weapons in hand😢😢😢
It is a genocide
Debarati isn’t the correct person for people of Bangladesh, she is serving India and dictator Hasina , she isn’t a fair journalist or honest journalist
This reporter did biased in interview. Because she favours Indian Government . She did not speak about truth and actual situation at Dhaka. Even she did not mention about law enforcement involvement in student murder. This Debi Rati is an indian agent. DW shouldn’t assign her at Bangladeshi news cover.
Please let another Reporter to Dhaka
I,m a Bangladesh Students.🇧🇩 20000+injured 30000+ arrest more then 2000+ students have been killed by Bangladesh police, BGB,RAB,ARM & ruling party Awami League. Please help us International community Help Bangladeshi people
The reporter saw what the government wanted her to see and heard what the government wanted her to hear.
Exactly!!
yes
There is no 3rd party.
3rd party is the Government.
Debarati Guha completely mislead the information.
Right
Right
Shame on dw
There are almost 1000+ death
10,000+ injured
50,000+ Arrest(students)
We the students and the people just want the resign of the government.
How is it possible that even a DW reporter is lying? Unbelievable!
To save their own job..
Not their fault
Why do you have to criticize everyone with a neutral narrative? She was absolutely right in stating everything. She criticizes the government and maintains neutrality by highlighting all the facts. You dislike her because of your simplified view.
Because they're not free
Look what they say about Palestine and Israeli backed genocide of Palestinians people and now after posting this might be removed soon this is the freedom rest you can check it in bd situation.
Debarati Guha either doesn't understand the reality of Bangladesh as an outsider or is super biased towards Awami League. Multiple political parties have been demanding Hasinas resignation for the past 10 years after 2 sham elections, including the BNP. Where is she getting her info?
ikr
Agreed
She understands everything but serves the BAL. At the end She intentionally said that 3rd party Jamat-Sibir ke today ban kora hobe as if Ato students death er jnno orai dayi
More then 1500 people killed by govt. For their power
please also consider interviewing/inviting people outside of politics as well who is in the country, there is teachers of our top universities, advocates, maybe some student willing to risk their safety to say the real picture of what happening.
Let me get this clear. Ms. Guha visited Dhaka to investigate this difficult and complicated situation. She spoke with government officials, visited the destruction sites, and then thought, "Oh, I have seen enough; I'll learn the rest from the TV," and came back! She didn’t bother to talk to at least one family member of the 200 people who were officially reported as killed, nor did she speak to any organizers of the movement. All she saw was chaos! She merely stated some of the government’s statements that Mr. Arafat forgot to mention. Is this really the work DW pays her for? Or someone else does the payment?
Agreed
Right
Yea
Totally aligned with you!
So true. She’s incompetent
Did Ms Guha actually speak to any protestors or she just sat with ministers?
Mrs Debabrati Guha didn't give the right information. 1)BNP and other parties called for the resignation of pm. 2) Today govt. declared the national day of mouring. But the people of Bangladesh totally rejected it. You can see that everyone change their facebook profile picture into Red to reject this mourning.
Please give appropriate information
I am speaking as a common citizen of Bangladesh. Bangladesh has now become unlivable due to the oppression of the present government. The student quota movement is centered around. These tyrannical governments are firing from helicopters. 😓 Many adults including 3 year old children have been killed in their own homes due to firing. Apart from this 1000+ students have been shot dead indiscriminately by this government. Thousands of students are now missing. Here is another reason why these brutal murders have been used. UN authorized helicopters and equipment. So is the United Nations behind this murder?? But the Bangladesh government has shut down the internet to keep this information secret. So that the international media does not get the correct information. In this situation our wish for the intervention of the United Nations. At the same time, I call on the international media to present the correct information to the United Nations🙏
I want to repeat:
I don't know whether Ms. Guha made unintended mistake, or she intentionally lied. But it's clear that her reporting doesn't represent the true picture of the situation here in Bangladesh. If she didn't lie, which I hope is the case, then I'm 100% sure that she didn't do her job sincerely. This kind of reporting is disgrace to journalism, especially when it comes from a well-reputed international media outlet like DW. I'd request DW to put more hard-working and realistic people on the field who take their responsibilities more seriously rather than relying on someone who chooses shortcut ways to do the investigation. We all know, there are no rooms for shortcut in investigative journalism.
To get transparent & true report DW shouldn't appoint any Indian Civilian Journalist here in BD. They will never expose anything of this BAL Govt. like genocide on 18th, 19th & 20th July 2024. DW should rethink
I didn't expect such yellow journalism from DW... UnSubscribe
👌👍
100% agreed
Right
Under Sheikh Hasina, the dictator of South East Asia, people of Bangladesh lost freedom of speech, rights to vote, and all human rights.