Is Karlos Nasar's Snatch Technique Really That Bad?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 44

  • @franciscovencedor1785
    @franciscovencedor1785 2 дня назад +90

    Needs to go back to the PVC pipe.

  • @DredFulProductions
    @DredFulProductions 2 дня назад +15

    I adore the lock out Karlos has. Even when he has to fight to stabilize the bar overhead the shoulder and elbow position is ROCK SOLID.

  • @Daniel-ie3vq
    @Daniel-ie3vq 20 часов назад +3

    As uncle Abadjev would've said "my lifter's a champion, his technique is fine."

    • @tfwwhennofitlitgf3300
      @tfwwhennofitlitgf3300 17 часов назад

      he probably would've yapped for 2 hours straight before getting there, though

  • @HannibalBarcaRTW
    @HannibalBarcaRTW 2 дня назад +11

    New world record and bad technique in same sentence

  • @Yupppi
    @Yupppi 2 дня назад

    It's been a fascination to me to watch Karlos lift. You at times see how he's jumping forward or unstable in the bottom of the catch, but at times he looks like his technique is so on point. Makes it difficult to assess as a noob when people say his technique has noticeable issues. This however cleared it up. Somehow he makes even the rough snatches look pretty good.
    Also thanks for these videos, the last few months of these technique videos (and talk about the importance of mobility exercise even when you don't have pains or big range issues) have caused me to catch the barbell at the bottom of the squat without odd leg angles and positions, as well as arms comfortably around the shoulder position (far enough in the back) and the barbell flipping there instead of being pressed. And the arms being much more stable base in the catch. The weights haven't improved, the training hasn't been olympic lifting focused, but I've got stronger, more powerful and more stable and I feel like the snatches are more aesthetic than they were. In short just seeing these videos shifts technique towards better.

  • @lordgunzerker6901
    @lordgunzerker6901 2 дня назад +8

    He hyperextends behind quite a bit, literally looking at the ceiling, yet he jumps forward. Interesting man, yet he wins everything lol

    • @bcobesi44
      @bcobesi44 2 дня назад +2

      Well, 89k vs 180k that's the answer

    • @markkatz4247
      @markkatz4247 2 дня назад +1

      He jumps forward because he hyper extends so much that bar is far away from him when he is at the peak of his hyper extension. So when he uses the bar the pull himself under at the third pull he pulls himself forward because the bar is far forward away from him because of his extreme hyper extension.
      Rhamaet is riziki is the same way. I think that might be the new revolutionary technique to pull a lot of weight.

    • @MarkoAssi_pokervlogger
      @MarkoAssi_pokervlogger 2 дня назад +3

      He tries to pull the weight towards him but the weight is just very heavy. So it will pull him.
      For lower weights he won't have this issue.

    • @bigguy4u989
      @bigguy4u989 20 часов назад

      @@MarkoAssi_pokervloggerhe jumps forward when snatching 50kg

  • @valkarcy
    @valkarcy 2 дня назад +5

    Ask anton about it. He says how goofy his tech is but that he has the strength of farm animal.

    • @sikastrength
      @sikastrength  2 дня назад +2

      I don't want to upset Anton 🤣

  • @benjamingrunberg7807
    @benjamingrunberg7807 2 дня назад

    Very unusual and unique technique, especially for eastern european lifter. The biggest difference is that he keeps the bar in contact with the body all the way, like the chinese. You see (hear the friction) how he scrapes his shins, knees and thighs. His first pull is very slow and second pull even slower but then because he holds the bar so close he releases stored energy and uses his back and arms and powerfully and aggressively pulls himself under the bar. Not the classic soviet technique like Lasha, accelerating the bar, makes powerful contact, the bar flies and he goes under it. Then the fact that he jumps forward a little is not so bad. Dmitry Lapikov used to jump forward a little and he said it's not so bad.

  • @pannonianfit1582
    @pannonianfit1582 22 часа назад

    starting of the pull looks like his back is way stronger then his legs so the hips starts rising early combining knees caving in makes his technique not ideal but of course he makes up for it in other parts of the lift, also his pulling techniques is one of the reason his body goes into non ideal position maybe he would have better pull if his hips are higher and he starts from a static position

  • @fabriciusbjerre
    @fabriciusbjerre 2 дня назад

    Where did the latest Q&A go?

  • @synapsy9291
    @synapsy9291 2 дня назад +2

    In my opinion maybe he bends his arms a little bit too much? So he must transition the barbell early and a bit more in front?

    • @synapsy9291
      @synapsy9291 2 дня назад

      I don t know I m asking

    • @sikastrength
      @sikastrength  2 дня назад +3

      Yeah definitely would consider it an issue BUT I think jump forward takes precedent as his major issue. The arm would be an issue usually in terms of bar speed slow down but in his case that doesn't seem to happen too much.

    • @ix_9_ix
      @ix_9_ix 2 дня назад

      @@sikastrength however dont you agree that (whether he intentionally means to or not idk) he autocorrects by how close the bar path is kept, like if you watch his cleans especially now you will see a minimal bar crash and amazing receiving height of his clean, similarly in the snatch his bar path is def wonky but because he jumps forward it helps him somewhat correct it no?

    • @synapsy9291
      @synapsy9291 2 дня назад

      @@sikastrength thanks for the answer, sorry for my english i m italian. i said it because it s the first thing I noticed, is like the fact that he engages so much his forearms the transition at the hand seems not so smooth, this is the thing i noticed that seemed odd also compared to the older lifters which arms don t engage that much in the lift. The other thing i thought is that because his form in my opinion is a lot back focus, he doesn t use the legs a lot, he also pulls very aggressively so his center of mass must be more in front than if he tried to be as upright as possible and using a more quad dominant pull so maybe he is thinking too much on driving the bar up then diving under it so (?) i m guessing honestly

    • @synapsy9291
      @synapsy9291 2 дня назад

      ​@@ix_9_ix in my opinion this reinforces the fact he has less technique in fact the clean is a more strenght movement, which is strange because in my opinion he has a structure more suitable to the snatch ( in fact he does 180 kg ). For what i saw personally the bar isn t close especially in the first pull so he maybe BRINGS himself closer jumping forward but the issue is in the first pull ( my opinion ) edit : i m not sure the second sentence i wrote makes sense😂 maybe he would jump behind in that case i m confused rethinking about it

  • @Yyyyyyyyyyyy86
    @Yyyyyyyyyyyy86 2 дня назад

    I wonder what Girth thinks the cause for the jump forward is

    • @sikastrength
      @sikastrength  2 дня назад

      Basically his knees don't move back enough and as a result he brings his hips into the bar too soon

  • @Arbfor
    @Arbfor 2 дня назад +2

    Chaste and snatch-pilled.
    Karlos obviously doesn't have a squat plug to keep his foot position grounded.

  • @Jay-bo1gs
    @Jay-bo1gs 2 дня назад +3

    It's the correct technique for his proportions and where he can catch it without the bar moving too far forward or backward. Doesn't matter where he lands if the bar goes straight up and down.

  • @fabiobonetta5454
    @fabiobonetta5454 2 дня назад

    Maybe.. you know when you're as strong as Achilles It don't matter

  • @ThatOnlyAsianGuy
    @ThatOnlyAsianGuy 2 дня назад +1

    Damn karlos needs to go back to 60kg 😅

  • @steffanofumo
    @steffanofumo 2 дня назад

    I can’t stand the… but he’s winning argument, that’s not the point, the point is he could perform even better if he fixed his technique, and yes at that level it’s incredibly hard to implement technique changes but still.

    • @tf2andtalk897
      @tf2andtalk897 2 дня назад +2

      Your body has a finite lifespan and you're currently performing as top of your class. If winning is the point, then what's the point in chasing technique changes that aren't needed? Making major adjustments could exhaust your important time.

  • @charlesthomas6608
    @charlesthomas6608 2 дня назад

    Bro i its clear he uses brute force and speed under the bar , just imagine if this guy had technique like gabriel sincrian .

    • @sikastrength
      @sikastrength  2 дня назад +8

      Maybe Gabriel's training block will show us in a few months 🤔

  • @LatimusChadimus
    @LatimusChadimus 2 дня назад

    🏋

  • @itsprestonjones
    @itsprestonjones 2 дня назад +2

    If Karlos jumps forward then so can I… I don’t care what my coach says

  • @wiperiser1
    @wiperiser1 День назад +1

    You are talking about inconsistencies in technique about the world champion. I can't care less what newtonian physics say about energy preservation. If it works, it works! To analyse flaws in the top athlete instead of analyse what can be learnt from him is borderline stupid, no matter how many master degrees one has.

    • @sikastrength
      @sikastrength  День назад

      Didn't watch the whole video did you?

    • @clintiacuone1703
      @clintiacuone1703 День назад

      @@sikastrengththe old classic case of read the title, get emotional and make baseless assertions without actually watching the video😂

  • @ianlewis5910
    @ianlewis5910 2 дня назад

    Second comment