-Rosie Summer- lel my bad.. cuz i usually see people in the comments from other videos saying they split up in 2014 so i believed it. :/ also i think I've seen you before
I am everywhere lol. They split in 2009, each were blaming the other over the split. It was pretty bad, they were both bitching about each other to the media. They did do reunion performances but it was for contract reasons, such as 2012 Romania's The Voice (I commented on that video too), Eurovision when Russia was the host that year and Sochii Winter Olympic Games. They both pretty much are solo artists now. You just need to watch Romania's The Voice performance to see how they were forcing themselves to perform together such as holding hands. Yulia wanted to share that warm chemistry such as a hug or a simple touch. Lena was very cold to Yulia, and tried to out perform Yulia which was out of character. There is a video showing footage back at Yulia's hotel where she is upset by how Lena had treated her.
i think that there is something that yulia wants but lena couldn't give her ..so yulia had a guy who become her BF or husband..but i guest yulia's heart beats for lena and it's obvious that both side were deeply hurt..
Lena said:I think we will be together forever. She loves you Yulia!Stard realize...pls... T_T You belong together! Nobody on in this world can be the perfect one for you,because....its Lena. t.A.T.u 4 ever
Lena siempre tuvo frases lindas y fue la que mas hablo de sus sentimientos pero al final a demostrado todo lo contrario y Julia que NO tuvo tantas frases sobre ella la busco despues de tatu pero lena la evito siempre y era notorio el rechazo hasta en el escenario ahhhh pero luego le dedica cancioncitas que si nunca tr olvidare que si Posle Nas...
my opinion is that lena really did love yulia, and yulia did love lena but yulia has always been the more outgoing/daring/flirty one, i love them both but yulia got knocked up twice and lena probably felt like yulia was cheating on her even though lena is supposedly straight, and she was probably getting upset because yulia got pregnant again. so lena probably got a little bit embarrased/hurt. i love them both, and i like their songs, but i will always think they were perfect together.
Don't be ridiculous. There has never been any hint that Lena is bisexual or would be hurt by Yulia having babies. On the other hand Yulia has openly admitted to being bisexual and having relationships with women as well as a witness and hints over the years.
Lena always said "She's my partner" or "Yulia is unic" but Yulia never said something like that. I think Lena always love Yulia,but Yulia never felt the same.
I noticed in earlier videos, like 2000 - 2001ish, it looked mutual as fuck. Like, they were both really into it. And then a time came (2003ish) where Lena looked more distant and Yulia looked even more into it. And then later videos, it mostly started looking friendly, but moments show up where they BOTH look really into each other. They're really cute, to be honest.
MMasonable I can see what you mean. Especially in the early concerts they were pretty hands on with each other. I don't know if there was romantic love or platonic love but they did care for each other to a point. It seemed they were together a lot in the early years. I don't know why they split as a group Lena was blaming Yulia and Yulia was blaming Lena.
I think the same way too guys, look how Lena always look at Yulia in each video, you can see love. Even tho Yulia part is to act like a boy, and Lena as a girl at that time, but honestly on all the video Yulia are more to women side,even with her outfit, meanwhile Lena always look calm and quiet but she is more like a man in every video and outfit to me. Sometimes in their video when Yulia take her cloth off, Lena kind of mad at her. And i do think Lena feel betrayal when Yulia dating men and women, and get pregnant. I think Yulia know Lena feeling too. But Yulia never accept Lena feeling. Perhaps that some of the reason the break up, even become perfect enemy now. And look at Lena Never Forget video, match it with Yulia All Because Of You video. I seems something happen there. But, i do love to see them both together. They are so match together. I just hope they can be nice to each other again. And be friend like they used to be. I miss tATu :)
Is this a radio interview? That's why there's no video? THIS IS PROOF ENOUGH. Yup, they do love each other. HA. Okay, but I'm not gonna give up waiting for their own voices saying, "Yes, I was in love."
es cierto se amaban la una ala otra y estaban muy bienen su relacion antes del segundo embarazode yulia, Lena ya no aguanto mas compartir a Yulia ademas parvis se encargo de separarlas estaba celoso de Lena y hacia todo para alejarlas , en mi opinion ese distanciamiento fue lo que acabo con TATU
Sera? Bueno yo si creo que el distanciamiento entre ellas acabo con todo... Porque ellas era el eje del grupo la magia la ponian ellas dos, ellas podian tocar con otros musicos y seguirian siendo tatu pero sin ellas todo acabo...
I belive before lena very loved her.but whats happened now?i think she hates her a lot now.its hurt.i just thinking that everybody loves julia.coz julia is perfect..
Yeah, in reality, Lena really loved Yulia. But... when there's too much hurt involved, a great love can turn to a great deal of hate too. We just don't know the process of it.
Donna Danish it hurts to lena that knowing the moment when julia told lena that shes pregnant..it shocks lena and hurts her.when lena living in L.A shes doing here own solo album shes doing it to fight her feelings and when they meet again in 2013 to do the guesting in the voice lena is not prepared to face julia coz she did not forget yet the past..but at this time she move on ready...coz she released her new album..and shes happy with her life a lot of people will saw it.more blessing for lena and julia i still love them both..they live in my heart forever..the important now is lena and julia stil friends and they are both happy in each other.
@fevah hey!!! Which interview is the one where she's asked if she's in love with yulia and she says: private question. And also where did you get the pic from 1:55 !? I've been looking for that photoshoot forever!!! when was it? :S
@tatufevah I'm on that site right now:) uhh,I'm feeling very happy,Know why..just because u replied!! Im still new to the whole youtube account thingy,so it means a lot to me dat uve considered to answer my question.hehe.
I think originally it was a set up, but there was some feelings there. Perhaps platonic. They spent a lot of time together just the two of them in those early years. They were pretty close, just have to watch a few of their live videos such as AOL sessions. Or their documentary clips. However they both dated men, Yulia has openly admitted to being bisexual, though she dated a lot of men many who were unattractive. Lena seemed to have kept her dating life private. Not sure why they both went their separate ways but there is an interview where Lena said she hated Yulia. Honestly who knows what went on behind the scenes.
That's not all that strange, haven't you ever felt you'd be forever with someone only to find out later down the line it just wouldn't work? Almost everyone goes through something like that, they just happened to be in the spotlight the whole time.
lena le cuenta a la entrevistadora acerca de la primera vez que ella y julia vieron su video en la televisión, cómo viven juntos, sus peleas tontas, y cómo lena piensa que siempre estarán juntos, ya que julia es una gran parte de su vida
Развлечения
2:19 'I think we will be together forever" -Lena Katina
''in 2014 group splits up''
Actually in 2009 they split up.
-Rosie Summer- lel my bad.. cuz i usually see people in the comments from other videos saying they split up in 2014 so i believed it. :/ also i think I've seen you before
I am everywhere lol. They split in 2009, each were blaming the other over the split. It was pretty bad, they were both bitching about each other to the media. They did do reunion performances but it was for contract reasons, such as 2012 Romania's The Voice (I commented on that video too), Eurovision when Russia was the host that year and Sochii Winter Olympic Games. They both pretty much are solo artists now. You just need to watch Romania's The Voice performance to see how they were forcing themselves to perform together such as holding hands. Yulia wanted to share that warm chemistry such as a hug or a simple touch. Lena was very cold to Yulia, and tried to out perform Yulia which was out of character. There is a video showing footage back at Yulia's hotel where she is upset by how Lena had treated her.
That's sad
@@rosiesummer2711 They officially split in 2011.
i think that there is something that yulia wants but lena couldn't give her ..so yulia had a guy who become her BF or husband..but i guest yulia's heart beats for lena and it's obvious that both side were deeply hurt..
Lena said:I think we will be together forever.
She loves you Yulia!Stard realize...pls... T_T
You belong together!
Nobody on in this world can be the perfect one for you,because....its Lena.
t.A.T.u 4 ever
Lena siempre tuvo frases lindas y fue la que mas hablo de sus sentimientos pero al final a demostrado todo lo contrario y Julia que NO tuvo tantas frases sobre ella la busco despues de tatu pero lena la evito siempre y era notorio el rechazo hasta en el escenario ahhhh pero luego le dedica cancioncitas que si nunca tr olvidare que si Posle Nas...
"Julia It's a part of my life" no parece ahora Lena -.-
Marcia Gaytan Supongo que la lastimó tanto mucho y todos tienen su límite
my opinion is that lena really did love yulia, and yulia did love lena but yulia has always been the more outgoing/daring/flirty one, i love them both but yulia got knocked up twice and lena probably felt like yulia was cheating on her even though lena is supposedly straight, and she was probably getting upset because yulia got pregnant again. so lena probably got a little bit embarrased/hurt. i love them both, and i like their songs, but i will always think they were perfect together.
i agree with you
Don't be ridiculous. There has never been any hint that Lena is bisexual or would be hurt by Yulia having babies. On the other hand Yulia has openly admitted to being bisexual and having relationships with women as well as a witness and hints over the years.
Lena always said "She's my partner" or "Yulia is unic" but Yulia never said something like that.
I think Lena always love Yulia,but Yulia never felt the same.
Anima55
Well, Julia was always very affectionate with Lena, but who was more to say she loved Julia and such was the Lena ... I think ....
Anima55
I miss these two
I noticed in earlier videos, like 2000 - 2001ish, it looked mutual as fuck. Like, they were both really into it. And then a time came (2003ish) where Lena looked more distant and Yulia looked even more into it. And then later videos, it mostly started looking friendly, but moments show up where they BOTH look really into each other. They're really cute, to be honest.
MMasonable I can see what you mean. Especially in the early concerts they were pretty hands on with each other. I don't know if there was romantic love or platonic love but they did care for each other to a point. It seemed they were together a lot in the early years. I don't know why they split as a group Lena was blaming Yulia and Yulia was blaming Lena.
PANDA Panda thats right. So Sad
I think the same way too guys, look how Lena always look at Yulia in each video, you can see love. Even tho Yulia part is to act like a boy, and Lena as a girl at that time, but honestly on all the video Yulia are more to women side,even with her outfit, meanwhile Lena always look calm and quiet but she is more like a man in every video and outfit to me. Sometimes in their video when Yulia take her cloth off, Lena kind of mad at her. And i do think Lena feel betrayal when Yulia dating men and women, and get pregnant. I think Yulia know Lena feeling too. But Yulia never accept Lena feeling. Perhaps that some of the reason the break up, even become perfect enemy now. And look at Lena Never Forget video, match it with Yulia All Because Of You video. I seems something happen there. But, i do love to see them both together. They are so match together. I just hope they can be nice to each other again. And be friend like they used to be. I miss tATu :)
Is this a radio interview? That's why there's no video? THIS IS PROOF ENOUGH. Yup, they do love each other. HA. Okay, but I'm not gonna give up waiting for their own voices saying, "Yes, I was in love."
es cierto se amaban la una ala otra y estaban muy bienen su relacion antes del segundo embarazode yulia, Lena ya no aguanto mas compartir a Yulia ademas parvis se encargo de separarlas estaba celoso de Lena y hacia todo para alejarlas , en mi opinion ese distanciamiento fue lo que acabo con TATU
katyfan21 yes
Sera? Bueno yo si creo que el distanciamiento entre ellas acabo con todo... Porque ellas era el eje del grupo la magia la ponian ellas dos, ellas podian tocar con otros musicos y seguirian siendo tatu pero sin ellas todo acabo...
its so sweet aaaawwwww makes me wanna cry :D i love it when she say 'eeeerrrrr.... privet question hahaha
I love their LOVE
I do think that they did LOVE each other like the real love it just hurts cuz i know there not together no more :(
Todavia se aman ms mas que nunca
the beginning, she probably wanted to say yes haha
t.A.T.u forever! they really did love eachother
That's right Julia and Lena are Married Couple
Юлия и Лена ето супружеская пара
lol we wish “ “
Did anyone hear yulia laugh in the background of 1:20 its sooo cute 3
what's hard when someone treats you SPECIAL?
It's when you get used to it of course you EXPECT
and expectations only leads to FRUSTRATION...ouch:(
I can't believe it was just a act
❤
Una pregunta la foto del minuto 1:54? Donde puedo ver las demas donde ellas usaban esos atuendos de boda?
I love those pics.I've got some of them on my pc,however i do want to know where you got them.Could you plz tell me?thnx
I belive before lena very loved her.but whats happened now?i think she hates her a lot now.its hurt.i just thinking that everybody loves julia.coz julia is perfect..
Yeah, in reality, Lena really loved Yulia. But... when there's too much hurt involved, a great love can turn to a great deal of hate too. We just don't know the process of it.
Donna Danish it hurts to lena that knowing the moment when julia told lena that shes pregnant..it shocks lena and hurts her.when lena living in L.A shes doing here own solo album shes doing it to fight her feelings and when they meet again in 2013 to do the guesting in the voice lena is not prepared to face julia coz she did not forget yet the past..but at this time she move on ready...coz she released her new album..and shes happy with her life a lot of people will saw it.more blessing for lena and julia i still love them both..they live in my heart forever..the important now is lena and julia stil friends and they are both happy in each other.
Caroline Caroline So Sad
Lol, I have seen u under other videos🤔
2018 anyone else???
@fevah hey!!! Which interview is the one where she's asked if she's in love with yulia and she says: private question. And also where did you get the pic from 1:55 !? I've been looking for that photoshoot forever!!! when was it? :S
@tatufevah I'm on that site right now:) uhh,I'm feeling very happy,Know why..just because u replied!! Im still new to the whole youtube account thingy,so it means a lot to me dat uve considered to answer my question.hehe.
@TheVikusikas i think that's from korea.. :)
podriian traducir lo ke estan diciendo'!?
Los latinos no entendemos mucho el ingles!!
wawawawa! Graciias
Alejadra Cruz dice que la ama mucho :v
i think she did love yuila otherwise she would said so
@dk2death a lot of tem are from tatu.ru :)))
where i can find this interviews? plzz
Can you please be a little more specific? I need to see that concert / moment!
It was a very well set up fake thing that people fell for for a little while but they could not keep it up anymore cause it was not real
I think originally it was a set up, but there was some feelings there. Perhaps platonic. They spent a lot of time together just the two of them in those early years. They were pretty close, just have to watch a few of their live videos such as AOL sessions. Or their documentary clips. However they both dated men, Yulia has openly admitted to being bisexual, though she dated a lot of men many who were unattractive. Lena seemed to have kept her dating life private. Not sure why they both went their separate ways but there is an interview where Lena said she hated Yulia. Honestly who knows what went on behind the scenes.
@@rosiesummer2711 i really agree with what you said! :)
could someone translate this please ?
Into what language?
That's not all that strange, haven't you ever felt you'd be forever with someone only to find out later down the line it just wouldn't work? Almost everyone goes through something like that, they just happened to be in the spotlight the whole time.
Alguien podría decirme q dicen ?? Por fa🙏🙏🙏
lena le cuenta a la entrevistadora acerca de la primera vez que ella y julia vieron su video en la televisión, cómo viven juntos, sus peleas tontas, y cómo lena piensa que siempre estarán juntos, ya que julia es una gran parte de su vida
Valoro la musica de Lena pero Aveces me parexe mas hipocrita que Julia Volkova...
Whats the first interview ?
👎👎👎👎👎
I love their LOVE