The F@llen of World W@r II | REACTION
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Our reaction to The F@llen of World W@r II
Original Video: • The Fallen of World Wa...
➤Leave Your video request here: bit.ly/2OFp78J
➤PayPal Donations To Help Support The Channel: bit.ly/2DFNC4G
➤By clicking this link a
If you click on this links and make a purchase I’ll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos.➤ amzn.to/2rhIcV... Video:
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links and make a purchase I’ll receive a small commission. This helps support the channel and allows us to continue to make videos like this. Thank your for the support
Almost every single person in Russia has a relative that died in WW2.
@Dragana Milosavljevic Not just parental.
For example, my great-great-uncle died, but not my grandfather.
People should understand what you mentioned is the reason why the Soviets were like they were during the Cold War.
My great uncle was in the Soviet air Force in ww2 and survived somehow
Good for him!
(It all depends on the type of aircraft he had to fly on, but his chances weren't awfully bad after the initial phase of the Great Patriotic?)
@@stefanradev7034 he did later in the war but it's still scary to go against Nazi planes since they were like he's compared to ours
Stefan Radev my great grandfather was a ball turret gunner of a Canadian bomber (British bombers design)
@@josephkush1032 Well, the soviet planes weren't bad but the soviets lacked time to train their pilots (because most of them never survived long enough to get a better pilot) while the german air force had an unbelievable amount of very well trained and experienced pilots in it's ranks. It's comparable to a professional football player having a match with a complete amateur who barely played any football in his life. It's not fair at all but war never is.
For a soviet pilot shooting down a german plane was a great success. And the few soviet aces faced unbelievable odds in the heights of the sky.
But in the end germany's air force was spread out thin, also because of the lack of ressources, which made planes rare.
When the germans fought with constant air superiority against the soviets until 1944 (not in numbers but in efficiency) they lost this air superiority when the allies landed in normandy. From this point on many skirmishes were fought without any air support at all.
Only the bigger battles (and for the german command more important battles) had air support.
In the end many german aces survived the war because they went out of battle-ready vehicles and couldn't continue the fight in the sky.
Otherwise many of them would have died.
WE gotta start pillaging some stuff
The confrontation of the USSR with the German Empire, its allies and satellites, is one of the most important episodes of the Second World War, characterized by extremely tough opposition of the parties.
Germany initially considered the campaign against the USSR as an episode of the fight against England, counting on 6-8 weeks of hostilities, according to the Barbarossa plan. It was planned that before the onset of winter, the Wehrmacht would reach the goals set by going to the Volga River, on the Arkhangelsk-Astrakhan line, destroying the army of the opposing enemy and neutralizing the potential of the industrial potential of the Soviet Union, up to the Urals.
The beginning of the Great Patriotic War is characterized by great losses of the Red Army during the battles, regular retreats from the lines of defense and troops encircled as a result of successful enemy actions. Already in the winter of 1941, it became clear that the Barbarossa plan had failed: the Wehrmacht was stopped near Leningrad (the city’s tragedy has no analogues, the city was in a ring, the supply was interrupted, and the blockade lasted until January 1944) and Moscow.
In the south of the country, near Rostov-on-Don, German troops had to go on the defensive. The Nazis advanced up to 1,200 kilometers deep into the territory of the USSR, raw materials and industrial centers were captured, the country lost millions of its compatriots for a long time, but the aggressor, having lost 730,000 people, could no longer count on a quick end to the campaign.
As a result of the counterattack of the Soviet army near Moscow (winter of 1941-1942), the enemy was thrown back from the capital, the threat of seizing the largest transport hub was removed. Attempts to break the blockade of Leningrad and the liberation of the Crimea were repulsed.
The first two years of the Great Patriotic War were the hardest for the Soviet Union, the enormous losses of both the territory and the population of the country posed a threat of defeat, but by the summer of 1942 the economy was firmly on the "war rails". The production of tanks, airplanes, guns and small arms by enterprises evacuated to Siberia and the Far East has grown in multiples, retooling on new types of equipment and armaments was taking place rapidly.
The turning point in the Great Patriotic War came only with the encirclement and destruction of the enemy grouping at Stalingrad (winter of 1942-1943), the strategic initiative passed to the USSR, and the fighting began to shift to the west. Began a slow and difficult liberation of the country from invaders.
By June 1944, the territory of the Soviet Union was practically liberated, the Soviet armies were fighting in the territory of Poland, Czechoslovakia. By the beginning of 1945, Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania, Finland had left the alliance with Germany, but the main battle was still ahead.
In April 1945, three fronts immediately launched the Berlin offensive, the city had by that time been turned into an impregnable citadel, and the approaches to it were surrounded by defensive lines. By May 8, 1945 the city was taken.
The Great Patriotic War ended in victory over the Nazi invaders and unconditional surrender, signed by the leadership of Germany. 1418 days were fighting. The losses of the armies of the USSR and the Axis countries (Germany and its satellites) were estimated in the millions.
The USSR, as part of the anti-Hitler coalition, shackling the huge forces of the enemy, grinding them, won a victory over Nazi Germany. From 70% to 75% of the German armed forces participated in the conflict on the Eastern Front, more than 600 enemy divisions were captured, defeated or destroyed.
The Great Patriotic War turned out to be ruinous for the Soviet Union: cities in ruins after air raids and artillery shelling, huge loss of life, destroyed factories, but independence was defended. At the cost of incredible efforts, Nazism was defeated, and the country reaffirmed its right to be a world superpower. At the Potsdam Conference, the leaders of the USSR, Great Britain and the USA determined the post-war reconstruction of Europe.
This brings tears to my eyes. evreytime is see footage of this dark period. :-(
Lets remember the fallen. The fallen Russians, the fallen Polish, the fallen Germans and all the others around the globe. Lets remember all the missguided people who suffered from the period between 1914 and 1945. Let us learn from it. We all are responsible for the happenings around us. For the words we choose, for the ideas we follow and the leaders we vote for.
Lets make better decisions in future.
Kind greetings to all of you, from a german
Same here. Thinking about behind each figure is thousands of people and family, just like mine, tearing apart. But the last minute of the video gave a good hope for humanity. That's what makes it special.
Maxel Foly I honestly respect ✊🏼 that
There are no bad soldiers. Germans were forced to follow orders or elsethey'll be seen as a Failure infront of their society
@@OsnoloVrach Germans were forced to follow orders ruclips.net/video/rCwlnU8I1Uo/видео.html
So say we all....
I’m starting to develop a bigger ear respect for Russia
You should. Russia took on and drew off the German military to allow the Americans & others to come into it w/o such resistance. It's not popular but I do like Putin. From watching him (when its translated) is impressive. He just tells it like it is. A lot of people died in Russia. Then they got screwed over Berlin when the Allies were dividing up Germany & Scientists. I wish people would stay awake in History classes. They might learn something that would make a difference.
@@Hurricaneintheroom Well lot's of countries got screwed over in the end of the war, but that is a different story for another day. :)
In my opinion Russia played the biggest part in conquering Germany (Nazis) love from the uk huge respect🇬🇧 🇷🇺 love to our 🇩🇪🇺🇸 brothers too
It was a war that never had to happen😕
@@yingyang3769 🤜🤛
soviet union isnt only russia
Soviet Union isn't only Russia!!! Don't forget about other republics like Ukraine, Kazakhstan,Belorus, Azerbaijan,Armenia and etc.
Aaand Bulgaria
as far as i am aware they are considered CIS. (Commonwealth of independant states)
it includes russia
@@OsnoloVrach Bulgarian didn't fought nazis
@@OneManStartup i know, but im pretty sure they got to be a part of the USSR at the end of WW2
@@OsnoloVrach Bulgaria was in axis powers alliance. In 1946 it became communist satellite state, but was never included in Soviet Union. It's easy verifiable in wikipedia
Такое чувство, что они живут где-то в мире пони.
А ведь в России у каждого человека в семье кто то воевал, в каждой семье предки участвовали в войне...
@@jonidou8329 да... К сожалению, это так(
Не знаю как так получается, но без слёз будучи 19 летним подростком, я не могу.
100%...вот у меня из 4-х прадедов, только 1 вернулся живым с этой войны
@@evgeniy_dmitriev У тебя 4 прадедов было? эт как?
My grandfather fougth for the few hours denmark was in war with germany he knew he wasnt gonna win but his king gave him orders to figth so he fougth what followed was 5 years of german occupstion he got 2 medals he keeps them in a box locked away becouse he doesnt like showing his medals becouse he feel guilt about the occupstion even though he destroyed a panzer tank with his devision he still didnt like his defeat he later became an officer and retired
none cares
@@BananaRama1312 well you cared since you looked at it and commented
@@BananaRama1312 Weird guy
7:11 remember watching this, the silence is so eerie
its what germany and the soviet union gets for invading poland...thats 5 million+ possibly 6-7 killed more than 20% of their total population most of any nations population killed in camps...working to expand their nations dying in labor camps or gas chambers..insanity
@@razkable How can the civilians help what the leaders do? They are innocent with no intent of harming. Every dot of a person is 1000 people with families, feelings, fear, love, happiness, tragedies and everything you have and they got wiped out without a thought how can you possibly defend that?
Так кто победил Гитлера? А то носятся со своей победой.Увидели какая разница между американскими жертвами и советскими? Огромная.
1.5 millions of Leningrad citizens were evacueted during blockade in terrible conditions taking enourmous efforts, but anyway its much easier to say how Stalin was cruel and bloodthirsty.
east propaganda against soviets
I dont like how he keeps saying Nazis half a million nazis were killed in stalingrad most of the german people werent nazis!
Allied forces still considered all German soldiers Nazis even though wehrmacht army wasn't consider a Nazis army but for all Germans that fought for their country and for Hitler we're still considered Nazis to those they invaded
@@ZugZugMahogny good
Don't take it seriously. I know what u feel coz the case "germans=nazis" is similar to "soviets=commies". It's like every people till the last child are nazis/commies and honestly share this ideology :) This is bs.
Only 10% of Germany FULLY supported the Nazis. But history will label them all as Nazis forever
Most of them weren't even German. Hungarian Austrian Italian Estonian Spanish Croatian Lithuanians Ukrainians
here in eastern Slovakia we got memorials in honor to red army for liberation on the places and forests where the battles were
The monuments were not demolished? Our monuments are being demolished all over Eastern Europe
26 milion russians died :'(
28-30 * russians is the greatest peoples
not only russian, but soviet
And other nations in soviet
@@BlackZaporozhian there are no "greatest people" there are great people, and bad people, Russians are great people, I have a few Russian friends. But saying stuff like that is what started WW2
Here I am bawling my eyes out still, although I have watched this video before and many of the sorts.... Never again. The only thing they really still have to change in their video is saying "Nazi Soldiers" since only a fraction of the German military was actually politically aligned with the NSDAP.
I agree, the video made me cry pretty hard.
Un1c0rnOfL0v3 true!
This should be shown in history lessons around the world
the capture of stalingrad is actually debatable, since the germans didnt spend a single day without house 2 house fighting, sometimes even spending days to conquer a single building
house to house? .... They were fighting for single rooms in buildings... there were messages comming to gemrman HQ that they captured kitchen or bedroom.
@@honzavasicek and that was for the basement XD
yeah lol just read pavlovs house
soviets defended that house in stalingrad for 60 days
60 days germans could not take a god damm house
Vasily Chuikov, commanding general of the Soviet forces in Stalingrad, later joked that the Germans lost more men trying to take Pavlov's House than they did taking Paris
@Der Lümmel No it's a historical fact and has nothing to do with who won
"Winners write history" is used by countries that deny war crimes
The figure of 8.7 million total Red Army dead is disputed heavily by independent historians both in and outside of Russia, with recent (viable) estimates suggesting anywhere between 10-14 million deceased or missing personnel
The numbers are so incredibly important imo.
I'm currently having my final night in Vietnam(I'm from Belgium). And I see construction works everywhere.
Every guide I had when visiting. From the people in the bigger cities to the minority groups in the farm lands reports the same thing.
Things aren't perfect.
But they're getting better. They can see it getting better.
Things become more equal between genders, education becomes more accessible, opportunities more plentiful.
And the same applies to most of Africa and other poor regions around the world.
As of now, first of January 2019, we have people preparing for some of the biggest vaccination actions of all time.
Things are looking up, for everybody.
Londronable Lets just hope it stays this way...
I was very surprised by this reaction. Why? You are not told about the war at school? In Russia, every student knows the number of losses. In each!!!! the family has the dead in the war. I am very surprised by the reaction of adults to the facts. Maybe the silence of history is a special policy?
@Der Lümmel Americans did indeed win the war. Sure, the battle already tipped to the side of the Allies when key battles were won like the Battle of Britain and the win over the Eastern Front, but America's inclusion alone quickened the rate of victory in a otherwise slow and sluggish European battle or the ever changing colonial battles in Africa and the slow onslaught in Asia like China, Burma, Philippines, etc. They were the key in the last stages of the war.
@@ashishhembrom3905 NAZIS IN THE USA:
Documents declassified in 2014 show that the FBI director Edgar Hoover not only authorized the use of ex-Nazis as spies for the United States, but also denounced the evidence of their war crimes as "fake Soviet propaganda."
Shocking numbers were reported in the 2015 New York Times: in the post-war decades, not less than 133 established Nazi criminals were paid $ 20.2 million of pension contributions from the US government. Moreover, $ 5.6 million was paid to former Nazis, who were subsequently deported from the United States.
The Nazi collaborator Alexandras Lileykis, the police chief of Vilnius, who had the blood of tens of thousands of murdered Jews, went to Germany after the war, and then in 1955 to the USA, where he received American citizenship and lived in Norwood, Massachusetts. Lileykis in 1952 was hired by the Central Intelligence Agency. The CIA knew about the involvement of Lileikis in the genocide of the Jews, however, he was helped to enter the United States.
Of the personnel of the same concentration camp was Oscar Gröning - “the accountant of Auschwitz”, who in 1947, together with three hundred other employees of the concentration camp, was acquitted of war crimes charges. It later became known that he had avoided prosecution due to interference by the US intelligence agencies who wanted to use the former Nazis to build West Germany during the Cold War with the USSR.
The cynical campaign by the US secret services was evidence that the CIA did not have any remorse about working with persons whose hands were stained with human blood. Another well-known character whose name was cited in the report is Arthur Rudolph, the former director of the Nazi military factory Mittelwerk. During the war years, this company actively used the work of prisoners, prisoners of concentration camps, Arthur Rudolph was engaged in the organization of forced labor. This did not prevent him from becoming a prominent NASA functionary in the United States and gaining world renown as the father of the Saturn 5 launch vehicle. Naturally, American intelligence officers knew about this man’s past, but preferred not to take action.
@@ashishhembrom3905 List of countries in which the United States invaded -
1950 Korea
1954- Guatemala
1958- Lebanon
1961- Cuba
1964- Laos
1964- Vietnam
1965- Dominican Republic
1965- Cambodia
1980 Iran
1983- Lebanon
1983- Grenada
1986- Libya
1989- Panama
1992-1998 Iraq
1992- Somalia
1994- Haiti
1999- Yugoslavia
2001- Afghanistan
2003- Iraq
2004- Haiti
2004- Somalia
2011- Libya
2014- Syria, Iraq
2015- Yemen
No one expects the United States or any other mode on your "long list" to invade the neighboring country?
@@ashishhembrom3905 USA - terrorist number 1. has 800 military bases across the globe, staged ''arab spring'', tried to overthrow Assad and put ISIS in power in Syria, destroyed Yugoslavia, Iraq, Libya, Vietnam, Nicaragua, occupies Germany and japan and staged a Nazi coup in Ukraine in 2014 and put missiles on the Russia's border
American Schools only focus on The U.S participation/Western front. Only time they teach about the eastern front is Stalingrad and you really only learn that it was the turning point for the war.
*27 Million Soviets*
*20 Million Chinese*
*7.4 Million Nazis*
*6 Million Jews*
*4 Million Dutch east Indies*
*3.1 Million Japanese*
*2.5 Million Indian Soldiers(under British Army)*
*3 Million all others combined*
I am crying. Can't handle it. Greetings from Germany. Never again 😘
@Mike Morbuk We're human not humane.
It’s a shame this stuff wasn’t and isn’t taught in school
SSSR death 27 millions
And this is only the official number
Создатель ролика видимо не обладал достоверной информацией. Есть явные ошибки, но в целом не плохо.
Трудно оценивать. Военные потери, например. Сравнивают потери СССР и Германии, не учитывая коллаборантов, партизан, потери союзников Гитлера Европе, часть потерь СССР в войне с Японией. При таком анализе и получается, что СССР завалил советскими трупами нацистов. А когда анализируешь численность конкретных частей на восточном для Германии фронте и соответственно советских на западном и потери там. Потери становятся вполне соизмеримыми. Цифры то вполне правильные, небольшая манипуляция и вуаля выводы не соответствующие действительности. С Ленинградом и Берлином вообще враньё откровенное.
Главное то про ГУЛАГ пиздануть, про "кровавого" Сталина. Все остальное не так важно.
@@evilfurryfromnowhere4100 похоже на то. От свидетелей тех времен мало слышал плохого о Сталине.
@@user-dy2mx2ub4u На какие источники опираетесь с расчётах
? И в какую сторону учитывааете колаборационистов?
@@StalkerY ну а я вот слышал
Is that only me who thinks he looks like Kobe?
RiP
The world has never been better than today.
Though we still have a long way to go, progress made truly is great.
@@bremc666 Yes I know but progress is natural. We're living in historic times where the world and humankind will change drastically in the course of the next century. Our future is bright and achievements of unconparable scale will be accomplished soon. Healing long reigning diseases like cancer and hiv, genetically modified humans, frequent space travel, colonization of the moon and Mars, and probably the most important is the emergence of artifical intelligence. Iam glad to be living in such great times and will do my part to help humanity advance more.
The world sucks today. Countless countries are at war and are killing innocent people the only difference is the media isn't reporting on it like they use to. France is possibly on the brink of civil war, hell all of Europe could be by 2020. Worlds about to blow up and we're about to join these fallen people either in heaven or hell
@@henrichvonruben9114 Calm down dude. You're exaggerating the situation.
@@Ulas_Aldag have you not been paying attention to the world for the last decade?
Edit almost two decades now
Sorry but this is basic history about the most important thing that happened ever. Not to know is amazing
Ok
The interactive (you guys didn't do it) hits so much harder at the end.
That zoom into the timeline at the end, is a zoom into your current date and time and counts as you watch the clock tick
You can't on a RUclips video
with that much death around you as soldier you cant forget that kind of stuff in our mind.
The fleeing from eastern prussia was one of the greates humanitarian catastrophes.. almost all from eastern prussia where fleeing from the rage of the soviets... and the pity was... it was one of the coldest winters at this time...sinc the last decade...
how many Franklin's, Tesla's, and Hawking's and what ever their brilliant minds could have come up with were lost in just 6 years in the mid 1900's
But also more Hitlers,Stalins and Maos, maybe.
@@Konleb Falsche denkweise ist ganz einfach zieht keiner in den Krieg gibts kein. Sind nur die Leute die es immernoch nicht verstehen. Da sieht man das 80% der Menschheit noch primitiv sind.
I wish the commentator would stop saying 'Nazi' when he means 'National Socialist'. We don't describe Soviet soldiers as 'commies'.
I agree, it dehumanises the German soldiers fighting for their country, not the extermination of Jews.
@@paddystrongjaw9995 And ... it distorts history. The National Socialists were, by their own admission, SOCIALISTS. The stuff they did they did in the name of socialism. Calling them "Nazis" kind of let's socialists off the hook for all the appalling crap they are complicit in. National Socialism and other fascist ideologies are a form of socialism just slightly to the right of Marxism. China today is far more fascist than it is communist. Of course, no one says a thing!
@Alex Woodward Really; you think I'm naïve? Tell me, how would you describe a political philosophy based around central planning, direct state control of the economy and the collectivization of the people, because, racial policies aside; that is the basis of National Socialism. Let's try this another way, why don't you list some 'right wing' National Socialist policies. Well?
Alex, you out there? I'm still waiting on your list of 'right-wing' National Socialist policies. Remember; I'm "so wrong it hurts" so how hard can this be?
@@haroldgodwinson832 You are right in some respects however the Nazis are definitely right of centre at least during their time. Socialism was extremely trendy during the Weimar era and so virtually all parties barring the DNVP embraced some aspects of socialism. The best way to evaluate Nazi policy is to look at Hitler’s 25 point manifesto. Indeed many policies are socialist such as industrial companies sharing their profits with their workers. However, the promotion of imperialism is extremely antithetical to socialism, as well as its nationalist ideas (considering the core tenant of socialism is internationalism). Overall it is wise to look at Hitler’s policies as centrists economically (at least for the time), right wing socially/culturally and authoritarian overall. A manifesto is one thing though and actions are another. By 1938 privatisation of national companies made up 1.4 percent of all government income, a very substantial amount. No one in their right mind can call these policies socialist. Furthermore, Hitler wrote about and then committed to imprisoning or executing all socialists in Germany. The first concentration camp (Dachau) was almost exclusively for socialists and was set up just two months into his term beginning in 1933. Hitler named his party this way and added some socialist policies in order to try and entice the working class (who were overwhelmingly socialist) who he needed to win elections.
In conclusion, I am inclined to agree with Alex although there much more to it. The Nazis were definitely NOT socialists, however, they were far from free market capitalists. The left right spectrum is too simplistic to describe many ideologies but if we must then I would put the Nazis centre right. Authoritarianism is the main hallmark of Nazi Germany not its left right policies
So yeah Nazis not socialists feel free to argue I’m only doing a degree in German history :)
Respect all soviet warrior, they save the world!
Lol save the world?
@@demjan96no we dont. Yours capetalist propaganda fool of you
@@luchko3936 from nazi, yes.
@@vadimzavorotov8853 soviet are just same evil like nazy
@@luchko3936 you are nazy
I think if you look at this alongside the countries population, it makes you realize the scale of it
people think its just russia..soviet union is a bunch of nations...even back then...so when they say soviet union it means like allies lost totals which means many countries....big difference than just one country..china lost the most for one country technically if we count the events before world war 2 started in 1937-1938 vs japan ..I believe right ahead of russia then germany not too far behind them...its closer than people make it out to be..germany lost so many its insane.....of course the germans took most of the union until they got into the heart of russia where soldiers stopped retreating and help came these are small countries with russians running away because theres not as many of them and its not their home so thy gave up a bunch ..
@@razkable If that's true (which funnily enough, the Soviets have argued before on founding the UN), then the US is also 50 separate nations united under an "alliance". An American "union", if you will.
of the 27 million Soviet people who died during World War II-10 million military and 17 million civilians, women, children, and the elderly. They were bombed , shot, burned alive, starved. Many died in the rear working for Victory, from hunger, from cold, from stress. Americans who have not suffered civilian casualties will not understand the grief of the Soviet people, all of us, even 75 years later .
When losing a 1 family member hurts.. imagine losing over 70 million brothers & sisters :/
"The irretrievable losses of the troops and forces of the army and navy amounted to almost 12 million servicemen. 4.5 million people went missing and were captured, 1.8 million returned home from captivity. 5.3 million people were forcibly taken to work from the occupied Soviet territories, 2.2 million of them died."
"The total irretrievable human losses of the country - military personnel and civilians - amounted to 26.6 million people."
y'all know "kamikaze" is Japanese not Chinese, right?
World war 1-1914 to 1918
World war 2-1939 to 1945
Fathers went to war and if they survived their sons went to war. Crazy
Великая Отечественная война 22.06.1941 - 09.05.1945 г.г. (29 000 000 погибших граждан СССР)
Sergey Siberian sorry no speak Chinese
@@datboidego The great Patriotic war 22.06.1941 - 09.05.1945 (29 000 000 dead citizens of the USSR)
P.S. I do not speak Arabic, there is a on line translator
German Volksturm fought in both wars in
@@sergeysiberian9571 and you can use that online translator too or?
This video should be mandatory in schools
In this case Americans and Europeans can learn about the role of the Soviet Union in world war II ruclips.net/video/-TfpjTjOb-M/видео.html
This brings me to tears my grandfather got stabbed by banzai attack but didnt die he got a big scar after surgery but died early I barely got to see him
Not every German was a Nazi, its like saying every American soldier was a racist segregationist.
Good, sensible reaction ^^
As for the vid- that's why History should be learnt
тогда зачем в этом видео ложь???
@@user-Prost-69
Who lies/ what's the lie itself?
@@stefanradev7034 лгут о роли Сталина в войне. ложь это не правда (поясню, ну если ты не знал конечно)))
@@user-Prost-69
There are several inconsistencies in the video, but they hardly hamper the main point- to visually show a glimpse to the unimaginable loss of life. And this is a REACTION video of NEil Halloran's video.
(What did bother you in particular?)
@@stefanradev7034 для чего создано это видео? ответ вроде бы прост... конечно показать как много людей умирают на войне и как это плохо. но в этом видео есть фраза о том, что Сталин специально не эвакуировал людей из городов, чтобы затруднить продвижение немцев (видимо этим пытаются объяснить огромное количество погибшего мирного населения в СССР. и вот тут становится понятно для чего сделано это видео. мирное население погибало от рук немецких солдат. а цель авторов показать. что немецкие солдаты не были виноваты в смертях гражданских людей, получается это Сталин виноват!!! автор лжец! дьявол как всегда кроется в деталях!
the thing is the figure of 8.7 million Soviet military casualties is not accurate, when including the 4 million missing in action the total rises to at least 12 million
total is 10 milion with missing in action
Deaths, not casualties.
@@alalalala57 yep thats what I meant. Injured is 18 million or something insane like that
probably gonna have a big one in next 10-15 years
Big? Nah, It'll be done in a couple of days.
@@stefanradev7034
War going nuclear is incredibly unlikely. I would say the next big war is going to be longest ever and might already be ongoing. It's the history that defines what was one single war.
@@TealJosh My guess is that the WW3 will go on for the longest out of all the wars in history, and end because of nuclear weapons being used. I also believe that will be the last war humanity will ever see.
@@TealJosh It would never happen out of fear of usage of nuclear weapons.
Not Russia, but Soviet Union. Belorussia and Ukraine republics suffered the most, and a lot of other republics with whole variety of ethnic groups, russians are not the only one.
Да что вы вообще знаете о Сталине, чтоб говорить о нем плохо?! Сталин был величайшим правителем в истории России, это факт! Почему на западе о России говорят только плохо или ничего?! Да Сталин был очень не простой, но он спас страну от гибели и сделал из нее сверхдержаву, и все это в условиях самой кровопролитной из войн! Россия после первой мировой воны, гражданской воны и революции была в гораздо худшем положении чем Германия после первой и второй мировых войн! А рост экономики при Сталине составлял 60% в год, это рекорд не побитый никем и никогда!
Так а в СНГ не так? Пропаганда в СНГ сделала не меньше, а то и больше для поливания грязью чем вся западная вместе взятая. В конце концов на западе наконец смогли показать пальцем на СНГ и сказать "смотрите, даже они говорят что он плохой, а значит то что мы говорили правда".
Так говорят малолетние ушлепки . Если родители воспитают детей а не забивают на них, то все нормально будет. А эти отморозки , которые за идею либерастов продать все , чтобы хорошо жить ничего из себя не представляют. Душка у них нет , не за что им стоять кроме конфетки).
We were not ready for war. Stalin was not an idiot, he tried by all means not to enter the war. Signed treaties with Hitler to avoid war. Nothing happened then. We could not avoid the war .... The Nazis attacked suddenly, several of our armies were immediately surrounded. This is called the cauldron, many of our soldiers surrendered to captivity, but they were killed in concentration camps. More preferred to die without giving up. Therefore, the losses are so terrible. We practically had no experienced soldiers and army. The Soviet Union was a state of workers and peasants, we did not know how to fight then, but we were taught. And the small losses of the Nazi army are due to the fact that they surrendered to captivity, and we did not kill many.
Stalin ignored warnings from his military and intelligence services about the Germans planning to invade.He forbid any preparations for invasion under penalty of death.
@@jamesricker3997 ЧТО?
*german army*
Signed a treaty to avoid the war, but somehow forgot to leave the countries after war. Typical Russian propaganda
@@jamesricker3997 Not true. The information was too conflicting, the difference in time was in months.
In defense of the Soviet Union I will say - 1) The Soviet Union would be in a weak state at the start of the 2nd World War. Before the war, the Soviet Union had a revolution of 1917 and a civil war from 1917 to 1923. These events greatly damaged the people, the economy and the opportunities. I won’t talk about World War I. 2) On an early Sunday morning, June 22, 1941, Germany declared war on the Soviet Union. Between 2:30 a.m. and 3:00 a.m. German troops deliver a powerful surprise strike across the western Soviet border with three army groups: the North, the Center, and the South. On the first day, a significant part of Soviet ammunition, fuel and military equipment was destroyed or captured; destroyed about 1,200 aircraft. Germany already had a plan of attack on the Soviet Union. He was fast, sudden, trained, and powerful. 3) - The first nuclear bomb appeared in America. The Manhattan project began its implementation on September 17, 1943. Many prominent physicists were attracted to him, many of whom were refugees from Europe. By the summer of 1945, the Americans managed to build 3 atomic bombs, 2 of which were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Which is terrible. And in the Soviet Union, the bomb appeared only in 1949. 4) Operation "The Unthinkable" is the code name for two plans (offensive, then defensive) in the event of a military conflict between, on the one hand, the British Empire and the United States, and, on the other hand, the USSR, developed in the spring and summer of 1945. Both plans were developed on the instructions of Prime Minister Winston Churchill by the Joint Planning Headquarters of the British War Cabinet, in the deepest secrecy, even from other headquarters. The British government categorically denied the existence of such plans until 1998. Documents related to these plans are currently stored in the UK National Archives. And not the fact that England and the United States simply started such a plan for the sake of conventional defense. 5) And in the Gulag there were not just some innocent people. Most of them were a threat there. Someone was a terrorist, someone was preparing another coup, revolution, assassination, espionage and so on. And at the expense of Stalin - to judge after all the events is very easy. And what would you do in his place. When there are a lot of people ready to betray, spy and arrange riots. Also 1st World War, Civil War. There is no economy, devastation, domestic agents from Europe and the United States are persuading them to overthrow the government. So also, Stalin assumed that there would be another war. And that the 1st World War is a rehearsal for another war.
Thank you, I really wanted to write something same, but I am too busy
Really thought provoking...all those people must never be forgotten, that is the only way future world wars can be avoided...
For what darkness lurks in the hearts of Man.
A handful of American civilians were killed in WWII, though not enough to make one of their stick figures. Most were killed by Japanese balloon bombs that flew all the way over the Pacific.
за общими фактами все равно вставляют ложь ...
Уважение из России, город мурманск.
WW2 over simplified.
One of the most important facts to put it into perspective is the 1 day Omaha beach landing 2,500 in one day more that total 13 years of the Afghanistan war. Seems like most see that US 400,000 dead we can’t wrap our head around it, no idea how that compares to say the war on terror but as we see 13 years 2,500 US soldiery in Afghanistan , 400,000 in ww2 it’s so much more catastrophically aedsful.
Привет из Ленинграда.
Americans be like BuTwe WoN ThE WaR SoViEt UnIoN DiD NoThInG MURICA
They fought for their survival. No one in the Western world can understand this. Even now, being in Syria, the Russians destroyed Igil, and no one before them did it, Americans only need money and it was always like that ... Even for transit, the Soviets demanded money and they I had to pay in gold ... I am writing from Google translator, sorry for the mistakes.
It's not really understandable. But what you think what would America do if Russia was having similar conflicts with Canada or Mexico, you think they would stand aside waiting for Russian government to place their guy there which would give them control over that country ?
@@hmm-.- completely Chu Chu, ?
Надеюсь, что хоть после этого видео, они поймут, почему мы празднуем этот День... День Победы...
Хотя на самом деле должны скорбить о великой потере, а не победобесить как долбанутые. Ветеранам за нас стыдно.
@@ravioliconsumer3772 победа это праздник, скорбим мы о великой потере 22 июня , а такие как ты только "пбедобесятся")))
@@ravioliconsumer3772конечно праздник. если бы проиграли погибло в разы больше. План ОСТ. Это Праздник со слезами на глазах
@@RAShu1 Да, но и многих потеряли зря. Во всём мире день скорби, почему именно мы особенные? Победа пришла с огромной ценой, и любой, кто застал то время, вспоминает это с ужасом или грустью.
@@ravioliconsumer3772 вы этот фильм смотрели? Из него По-моему предельно понятно почему мы особенные. Но если непонятно, поясню. Особенными нас делает то, что мы "рассово неприемлимые", и мы не с Германией воевали, а с "рассово приемлимыми". Единственными кто достойно сопротивлялся на Западе - это Сербы. Посмотрите сколько было Бельгийских, Французских, Испанских, Скандинавских и пр. Дивизий было на восточном фронте. Мы воевали не за территории или ресурсы, мы воевали за выживание. И если бы мы проиграли, нас бы просто не стало. Так же как не стало коренных североамериканцев, южноамериканцев, австралийцев. Поэтому - просто Огромное спасибо дедам - они Герои. Они могли не праздновать потому что прошли через АД. А для нас это огромный праздник. Праздник жизни. Поэтому не надо смотреть на других, эти другие придумали Евгенику и рассовую гигиену, а нацисты лишь их последователи. Поэтому празднуйте окончание геноцида советских людей, не стесняйтесь. Окончание кошмара - это хорошо.
This is the TED Talk of RUclips
When at the the end that said I hope it would be more peaceful I saw a video with a thumbnail of the president of South Korea and Kim Jin un shaking hands
8.6 Russians died in pow camps and 5.3 died in action. About 19 mil soviet civilians died. I think with injured the German took 5.3 mil casualties. Only Japan used kamikaze
80 million died in a world of 2 billion. That 80 of 2000 million. That's not a 1/4, that 4% not 25% lol.
It is sad and the average age of US soldiers were 23. In Vietnam it was even younger. This is a great statistical show talking about how many people died from all over in WWII. I find it shocking that people don't know some of this stuff. Were they sleeping in History class like they do nowadays and learn nothing? Will they, personally, have to experience it to get it. I watch some videos on science people who go out and locate fallen soldiers (Russian, German, others) and dig them up. They look for ID dog tags, medical issues, buttons, bullets, etc. to try to identify who they were or where they came from. After trying to identify them they are sent back to the countries they fought for and re-interred. I think Crocodile Tears is one group who does this. Time for them to return home to whoever is left to remember them. I hate the fact that students today could careless about everything in school. It seems it's too much work for them to learn anything. Then they wonder why their lives are so bad.
10:56 - Bullshit. USSR (and Stalin) smply had no means to evacuate Leningrad. None, that wouldn't lead USSR into a deadly trap i mean, which is a resault nazies are very hoped for, that Stalin would lose his temper, and send his, at that time very scarse reserves to try to break that seige.
As for evac - Germans have tightly surrounded Leningrad from all directions from land and sea, and they had a complete air superiority. Any attempt to leave Leningrad became suicidal.
I hate that he refers to all german soldiers (wermacht or ss) as nazis, they were soldiers not politicians, dont project their leaders views on every common man.
The guy who made the video has stated that he regrets referring to all German soldiers as Nazis
Wehrmacht soldiers are not Nazis. You mean these people
ruclips.net/video/rCwlnU8I1Uo/видео.html
Why is Finland not included? Or did I miss something? We were co-belligerents with the Axis. Meaning we had the same enemy but were not in theory part of the alliance. That being said Finnish jews were 100% protected during the war. They were treated just like anyone else and they did fight the Soviets ALONGSIDE Germans. Pretty funny. Our command made sure that the Germans were not allowed to harass Finnish citizens jewish or otherwise.
I like how all the German soldiers that died are labeled as “nazis.” Other then that, it’s a great video
It's because its soldiers voluntarily or involuntarily fought/died under the Nazi banner.
ashish hembrom nope not true. They died under a German war banner called Reichskriegsflagge. Nazis were a political party that didn’t represent majority of those soldiers who died.
@@debbes9517 so under the German war banner that is under the Nazi regime? So basically involuntarily/voluntarily die/fight for the Nazi?
ashish hembrom the majority of those soldiers that died labeled as nazis were in fact not nazis. Is that hard to understand? He even corrects himself on the original video under comments
@@debbes9517 that's what I replied German soldiers voluntarily/involuntarily fought/died under the German war banner under the Nazi regime. Is that hard for you to understand???
Современные иностранцы должны знать блогадарья кому мир живёт сейчас
Весь мир живёт благодаря США
@@Легендарный-Выродок да конечно🤣🤣
@@Легендарный-Выродок ну так то да, ЕСЛИ ЭТИ ДАУНЫ НЕ НАЖМУТ КРАСНУЮ КНОПОЧКУ ТО ВЫЖИВЕМ (ХОТЯ В РАШКЕ НА ЭТО МАЛО ШАНСОВ , А В ДРУГИХ ЗАВЕДЕНИЯХ НАС НЕ ЖДУТ, ПОЛУЧИТСЯ ЗАВЕДОМО ПРОИГРЫШ )
@@Легендарный-Выродок особенно хорошо живёт Украина, самая бедная страна в Европе)))
Only Japan ever used Kamikazes (basically meaning "gods wind") , I they even build special zero planes with explosives implanted in the planes front end. Most Kamikazes were used for sea attacks, also though Kamikaze planes were most common ones there are reports of Kamikaze boats filled with explosives and also Kamikaze torpedo's guided by human hand.
my grandpa was in the D-Day invasion. he saw horrible things there. Death Camps mostly
Теперь Вы видите какой ценой была Победа..
да не хрена они не видят. в этом видео ещё говорится как русские изнасиловали миллионы немок.
Sorry but without my homeland, Russia, the western front would not have won, you're welcome America, France and England
I agree there were so many deaths in many of these countries who were involved/fought in this war.
But why around 3- 5 million Indians died due to deliberately induced famines by British simultaneously during this war?
The narrator don't know anything about this ? They mentioned about China and other Asian nations.
Do a research and comment. I know this is not tought in your English History.
Do not forget 1/6 th of the British who fought during this war were Indian Soldiers too.
Why would Britain starve India deliberately? Especially if it was such a vital source of manpower?
Вам надо это в школах показывать, а то заврались совсем.
"Nazi Soldiers" really bro? is that word not a bit closeminded ?
my grandfather was a Wehrmacht soldier and he wasnt a Nazi he was not a volunter
excuse my bad english
If you go on the original video page, the author wrote that he regret using that word.
Same here. My grandfather never fought for the political ideologies of the Nazi party. He didn't want to fight at all. You also don't call the soviets communists or the americans democrats. Or the japanese imperials. Germany also was called germany back then and not Naziland. Therefore their citizens were called germans and not Nazis.
Yes finally
allied didn't fight for you two definetly
Germany didn't start ww2 in '39. Japan started ww2 when they pushed into Mongolia in 1931. Homework people, homework.
But there is no war if America didn't push Japan to Open their country. So America is at fault too because if they didn't do that then Japan might not decide to conquer the World too.
James Smith Negative. I would say most actual historians would say '31.
Manchuria not Mongolia
Sea Sniper 7 Correct. Northeast China. I sometimes think of it as Mongolia because it was the Mongolian army with help from the Soviets that ousted the puppet state in '45 and is home to a moderately large populace of Mongols to this day.
A love nicol
Please. The world owes Germany an apology. WW2 was started at the end of WW1 when the delegation that went to Paris, made The Versailles Treaty law. The terms were absolutely impossible. Please view "Benjamin Freedman 1961 speech".
I think that you have a brain cancer...
What you think happens when you lose a war ?
As in thousands of wars up to this day, if you attack someone and you lose you have to deal with the consequences.
In my opinion allies should've acted once Hitler raised his military above signed limit.
But they did nothing, then he took Austria, then half of Czechoslovakia, and they finally did something when he attacked Poland.
End of the world war one could've ended far worse for Germany, some countries in history were completely gone after such a defeat.
@@hmm-.- Both of you are right and wrong. The Allies certainly do not owe Germany an apology, the National Socialist Party and their supporters commited attrocities that are not excusable in any way. However, the Treaty of Versaille certainly was a major factor in Hitler's rise to power and thus should never be ignored when talking about the reasons for the breakout of World War II
@@hmm-.- To make a country pay reparations you know it can't even come close to reaching was not very reasonably of the Allies (especially France)
@@hmm-.- Lastly (sorry for spamming) I would recommend not calling someone mentally challenged when stating your side of the argument, that might not get your point across to him :D
@@hmm-.- I understand you probably have been raised in America, under the indoctrination of the false history. With all due respect when someone suggests a different point of view I listen to their reasons. Do you not question why the American education system never tells Germany's side of the story. It will eventually come out anyway. If you would like, I could share some videos. I had to wake up also.
Про Сталина - ложь!!!
Canadians?
Про Ленинград полная ложь. Город был окружен и из - за постоянных обстрелов, в том числе и "дороги жизни" жители умирали от голода. Факты извратили полностью
Nice Reaction
And the Pacific war front was much harder and cruel then the western war front because of more diseases, mosquitoes and constant island hopping and right when you land it's a another d day basically
Yeah. With that, World War II is the worst thing America had that.
@@thepoet9253 not just America it's the worse the world had especially Russia
Yeah. China suffered very much from Japan
@@vladimirt.3627 China lost millions.
@Richard Kim Yes. And it is very sad. China is second in loss of people at World War 2, if I remember correctly.
There were no winners in this war
чо вы тут рисуйте картинки свои, у германии это все военные потери, на поле боя практически все потери были. у СССР же из 27 млн убитых, военные потери примерно такие же как и у германии, 15 млн примерно это фашисты уничтожили мирное население,геноцид был,сжигали в печах,опыты ставили и т.д, а сколько пленных безоружных миллионов было загублено еще, если и их вычесть,то у СССР меньше будет потерь на войне именно. фашисты уничтожали лишь безоружных,очень хорошо получалось у них,а на поле боя наваляли им.
Where is the mention of the Indians the Indians sent the most amount of soliders besides the Soviet Union.
I Miss u kobe
Stalin coined the phrase "One death is a tragedy, 1 million deaths is a statistic".
the price tag for being number 1 is not in money but in innocent lives. human lives. Just beacouce the enemy is a asshole it dos not mean you can be a bigger asshole the him.
The soviets sacrifice a whole generation
And they MURDERED a whole generation of Poles.
Wonder if these statistics include the deaths on U Boats.
together with Hitler, the whole of Europe went to war with the Soviet Union. The whole country of Europe fought on the Russian front with Hitler against the USSR - and we in Russia remember and will not forget when
It wasnt the whole of europe. It was Germany, Italy, Hungary and Romania, some spanish "volunteers" and a couple foreign SS Division from actual volunteers.
And I'll never forget, what Russia did to occupied territories - way before ww1 and long after ww2.
70 million isnt quartering the world population. Not even close... I mean its absolutely devestating but it didnt even quarter the population in europe alone or any european country. World population was like 2.5 billion back then. So roughly 3% of the world population died during the war. But I guess its not the best way to look at it. Locally it was absolutely devestating of course as entire cities were literally wiped out. Poland lost roughly 17% of its population, Soviet Union 16%, Germany 12%, Japan 4%, China 4%, and since the US were hardly really involved (in any big battles) they lost about 0.3% of their population.
She said it must have quartered the world population, thats why I said it. No idea what you are on about but enjoy.
Niles-After my comment to him,I have no doubt he'll have many more idiotic,bitter comments to make as well.
@@IcePrincess751-kb9bq What idiotic comment? He is right. Just like the original video portrays it at the end. This was medium at best in terms of deaths / total population ratio. There were faaaar worse wars waaaay back in the day.
@@nilesmarcko7996 i think you misunderstood. he's saying no European country lost a quarter of their population. he's obviously not implying that there are like 300 million people in every European country.
No it wasn't 2.5 billion back then. In the early to mid 60's it was some 2 billion people in the world, more than 15 years after the end of WW2
Hey guys you should really check out Hat Films - Subscribe to Pewdiepie Song
ruclips.net/video/zy5E-LFswhs/видео.html
Слава товарищу Сталину. Величайший правитель России. Хватит врать и клеватать на его личность.
О боже, что у тебя в голове вообще? Сталин худший правитель России. Убил миллионы людей, в том числе моих родственников. Что за высер ты вообще высрал ты понимаешь?
@@igorsenin Ссылку на документики, пожалуйста, что Сталин убил миллионы людей. Иначе балабол.
Видео дудя смотри про колыму за 1938-1939 сталин уничтожил 2 милиона. А всего за свое правление не во время войны больше 10 милионов.
@@ememdems94 дудю надо почитать немного документы. Хотя бы немного.
@@ememdems94 ссылочку на документики и исторические исследования, пожалуйста. Где указана цифра "более 10 миллионов"