Colts manual states to remove spring tension first , reassembling the pistol is much easier when you're not fighting the spring tension and accidentally scratching the frame.
My Grandfather was a WW2 vet and taught me how to field strip the 1911. The Spring comes out first and goes back in last. If you don't you are fighting the spring the whole time.
If you release the recoil spring first like Colt designed the thing, you don't risk the accurately named Idiot Scratch that comes from trying to fight the spring unnecessarily
I was taught a much different sequence of disassembly and re-assembley. I press in the plug first, rotate the Barrel bushing, carefully release the recoil spring plug, to ensure it doesn't fly to the other side of the room, THEN, push the slide back and then press/remove the slide stop and then you can push the slide forward and off, rotate the barrel bushing, and slide the barrel out. BTW, not a single one of my 4, 1911's have the idiot scratch. ALSO, All of my 1911's have a full length recoil spring guide. I find my weapons run much smoother than with small guides. It's also easier to take down and put back together. I believe you would call it the "Traditional method".
I can truthfully say I've never disassembled a 1911 in that order. If the spring tension is removed first, everything else is effortless. Manipulation and removal of the slide stop is also very easy when not fighting the recoil spring tension. To each their own. Thanks for the video and demonstrating your version of 1911 disassembly. It was very interesting!
It seems to me that the easier and safer way to field strip the 1911 is to remove the barrel bushing first, thus relieving all of the spring tension on the barrel and slide. Then you don't have to keep a gorilla grip on the barrel assembly while you line up the pin hole in the frame with the hole in the barrel. But, like you said, whatever works best for you.
Holding the spring and guide rod as you disassemble the gun deprives you of the exquisite joy of tracking down your rod and spring, especially if you do so in the kitchen!
I always take the mag out before checking the chamber, it's just an extra precaution for a ridiculous and rare situation where a round can be unseen in the mag and get pushed up right before dropping the slide forward. This is much more important with a Glock though because you need to pull the trigger before disassembly. Thanks for the heads up! I hope I never messed up my dad's Kimber like that! I'm sure we'd have noticed... It's a matt finish too.
Thanks for the clear and methodical demonstration! One thing you didn't mention, though, was an explanation of what exactly the "idiot scratch" is and why your method prevents it from happening. I'm still wondering what that's about.
I've always released the spring tension on the recoil spring by rotating the barrel bushing... but if your aim is to launch your guide rod across the room and have to spend the next half hour on your hands and knees looking under the furniture to try and find it, or possibly shatter any glass you might have in the room then this is exactly what you want to do lol😂
That is the hardest way to disassemble and reassemble a 1911 I have ever seen WOW
Colts manual states to remove spring tension first , reassembling the pistol is much easier when you're not fighting the spring tension and accidentally scratching the frame.
My Grandfather was a WW2 vet and taught me how to field strip the 1911. The Spring comes out first and goes back in last. If you don't you are fighting the spring the whole time.
If you release the recoil spring first like Colt designed the thing, you don't risk the accurately named Idiot Scratch that comes from trying to fight the spring unnecessarily
I was taught a much different sequence of disassembly and re-assembley. I press in the plug first, rotate the Barrel bushing, carefully release the recoil spring plug, to ensure it doesn't fly to the other side of the room, THEN, push the slide back and then press/remove the slide stop and then you can push the slide forward and off, rotate the barrel bushing, and slide the barrel out. BTW, not a single one of my 4, 1911's have the idiot scratch. ALSO, All of my 1911's have a full length recoil spring guide. I find my weapons run much smoother than with small guides. It's also easier to take down and put back together. I believe you would call it the "Traditional method".
I think you should release the recoil spring tension first.
I can truthfully say I've never disassembled a 1911 in that order. If the spring tension is removed first, everything else is effortless. Manipulation and removal of the slide stop is also very easy when not fighting the recoil spring tension. To each their own. Thanks for the video and demonstrating your version of 1911 disassembly. It was very interesting!
The most complicated way to disassemble and reassemble a 1911 I have ever seen.
It seems to me that the easier and safer way to field strip the 1911 is to remove the barrel bushing first, thus relieving all of the spring tension on the barrel and slide. Then you don't have to keep a gorilla grip on the barrel assembly while you line up the pin hole in the frame with the hole in the barrel. But, like you said, whatever works best for you.
I don’t think this guy realizes you can remove the recoil spring before you can remove the slide.
Dude makes a job much harder than what it’s supposed to be I can only imagine him at his workplace
When I learned to field strip a 1911A1 in the Navy, I was taught to remove the recoil spring plug first.
A detailed video on how to do it the hard way. I'm with the commenters who suggest releasing the spring tension first.
Holding the spring and guide rod as you disassemble the gun deprives you of the exquisite joy of tracking down your rod and spring, especially if you do so in the kitchen!
I always take the mag out before checking the chamber, it's just an extra precaution for a ridiculous and rare situation where a round can be unseen in the mag and get pushed up right before dropping the slide forward. This is much more important with a Glock though because you need to pull the trigger before disassembly. Thanks for the heads up! I hope I never messed up my dad's Kimber like that! I'm sure we'd have noticed... It's a matt finish too.
I always start by removing the barrel bushing plug and spring first I learned that in the Army in 1966
Or you can do it the correct way by removing the spring plug first.
Thanks for the clear and methodical demonstration! One thing you didn't mention, though, was an explanation of what exactly the "idiot scratch" is and why your method prevents it from happening. I'm still wondering what that's about.
I've always released the spring tension on the recoil spring by rotating the barrel bushing... but if your aim is to launch your guide rod across the room and have to spend the next half hour on your hands and knees looking under the furniture to try and find it, or possibly shatter any glass you might have in the room then this is exactly what you want to do lol😂
Well. I always remove the plug and recoil spring first. Easier when not fighting spring tension but to each his own.