With fan votes only counting for 10% and the other 90% being decided by the voting jury I have basically lost all interest in caring for the Game awards. Especially seeing the list of who makes up that jury.
They can't cuz there is simply not enough dlc's to warrant a whole category, plus literally what DLC can compete with SoTE? Truth be told, DLC's were always eligible for GOTY, it's just that there hasn't been one that is worthy of that title.
Persona 3 reload def should have also been nominated. I argue its the better game, even tohugh its a remake, the OST has freshness and is super emotional.
@@_gokceada ehh i dunno i would take a new fresh IP every time over another remake, P3 is a great game but it has had its time under the limelight and we should move on.
I mean personally I'm against both remakes/reimagines and DLCs being nominated, but at least Silent Hill 2 is technically a game made from scratch and you already have FFVII.
No. Let's not pretend it'll be anything other than Shadow of the Erdtree. That and Wukong being here are...relatively obvious...cases of Keighley putting his thumb on the scale. He'll crow til the cows come home otherwise, but Phantom Liberty, rightly, only got an ongoing game nomination last year, and the same should have happened for Shadow of the Erdtree. What changed? Keighley, horrified, staring down the barrel of a scenario he would detest. "If I DON'T influence the jury? A JRPG is going to win GOTY! 4 JRPGs are going to be nominated! That just won't do!" And, if it were just Shadow of the Erdtree and the other game he pushed the jury toward was plausibly well reviewed (85 or higher, like Silent Hill 2 or Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown), that'd still be semi-suspicious, but not sloppy in the level of greasiness. And that sloppiness is mostly why I HATE this.
At least Black Myth Wukong got some recognition but Shadow Of The ErdTree getting nominated in GOTY is wild even though it's great still they need to create their category as DOTY ( DLC Of The Year ) hopefully BMW wins it
There are exceptions to that like Xenoblade 2's dlc (Torna: The Golden Country) but yeah, for most cases that is true and I agree it shouldn't be nominated
Exactly why is this not common knowledge, a lot of ER fans are saying it’s deserved and other nominations are jokes are either too short which is a lie either they’re lying to justify their DLC being in the a wrong category or just plain dumb and still didn’t play it, this is making me despise some from soft fans
No Nine Sols for best indie is ridiculous. I dont have any respect for TGA from now on. AND they literally put DS2 for most anticipated and NOT Doom?? That is some criminal sh1t.
Personal take? Yes, there aren't enough distinct DLCs to have a DLC category. But Phantom Liberty in Ongoing Game made sense, and that's the ONLY place where Shadow of the Erdtree should have been, and the only reason it ISN'T is because Geoff would have otherwise been staring down the barrel of a JRPG winning Game of the Year. I know this sounds kinda limiting/soulless, but two rules I would institute at The Game Awards for GOTY and any genre or technical category? 1. An 85 Metacritic Score Minimum for a GOTY nom. 2. A DLC pack released outside the game's original eligibility window is ineligible.
A DLC over fucking Stellar Blade and Silent Hill 2 (and heck even Nine Sols) is absolute bullshit. We already know what GOTY is gonna be just because of that dumb stunt. Screw this event man. I already know neither FFVII nor Black Myth Wukong, my personal faves, are not gonna win because of this either.
How many dlcs get released a year to make an entire category for it every year? Also it doesn't seem like there were that many games snubbed, since one of the other goty nominees is a remake
Because it’s a DLC nominated for Game of The Year….Game of the Year is for brand new games not an already made game with DLC. Should really just be it’s own category. Do I have to break it down any further DR?
Yea, idk. There actually isn't anything about remake better than Rbeirth besides maybe a story because remake takes place in a very solid location (Midgar) while Rebirth is just the middle adventure section of the original and is just about exploring
Charlie didn’t even finish rebirth because it’s was too long or whatever but his brain is probably fried from speedrunning every game he touches but can’t really do that with rebirth
The fact that sonic x shadow generations isnt in best community support or action game is just a fucking joke. Heck, not even game of year. Thats a damn joke. IT ISNT ANYWHERE
That would be so lame if elden ring wins again no matter how good the expansion is. It's an expansion, not a separate game, so it shouldn't be eligible for GAME of the year
@buletincuadelin5690 BMW has no shot. The award ain't gonna go to a game rated 81 on metacritic. Remember, critics are the jury. If it was a popularity contest, totk would've won last year.
Can someone explain to this old fogee what exactly is appealing about caseoh.... like ive gone on his stream a few times and hes just boring as piss, so I feel like Skinner here wondering if its me or the kids that are wrong?
Everyone is so mad about Shadow being nominated but I think it is big enough to effectively be a stand alone game. I think its similar to GTA IV’s Ballad of Gay Tony and The Lost and Damned, yes they were expansion packs but if you’re being honest with yourself those might as well have been stand alone games. And you can’t expect there to be a stand alone DLC category because there are not enough major DLC’s each year to justify it. So, in short, quit complaining, it is what it is
With fan votes only counting for 10% and the other 90% being decided by the voting jury I have basically lost all interest in caring for the Game awards. Especially seeing the list of who makes up that jury.
The Game Awards Nominations situation is crazy
Nobody cares Charlie sucks lmfao
Wish infinite wealth was nominated for GOTY. Absolutely loved that game and I think is my fav RGG game
Concord for the win
DLC being nominated for GOTY is such a joke. Just give DLC it's own category.
they did it with Cyberpunk too
Seems perfectly reasonable to me. Many DLCs are bigger than full games.
Nobody cares Charlie sucks lmfao☠️☠️🙋🏻♂️🍗🇩🇪
@@DR.TheLaw no they didn’t, phantom liberty wasn’t in the running.
They can't cuz there is simply not enough dlc's to warrant a whole category, plus literally what DLC can compete with SoTE?
Truth be told, DLC's were always eligible for GOTY, it's just that there hasn't been one that is worthy of that title.
I'm glad to see Metaphor getting spots like soundtrack and narrative.
Nobody cares lmfao☠️☠️🙋🏻♂️🍗🇩🇪
Persona 3 reload def should have also been nominated. I argue its the better game, even tohugh its a remake, the OST has freshness and is super emotional.
@@_gokceada ehh i dunno i would take a new fresh IP every time over another remake, P3 is a great game but it has had its time under the limelight and we should move on.
Metaphor is good AND it panders, so it will win Goty (or most awards)..
...
which will send a bad signal to other Jrpgs
@@_gokceadanah it has Tartarus so it’s worse
Still a great game tho, and it probably should’ve been nominated for best narrative
Elden Ring DLC got nominated for GOTY but not Silent Hill 2? Who’s in charge of this lol
I mean personally I'm against both remakes/reimagines and DLCs being nominated, but at least Silent Hill 2 is technically a game made from scratch and you already have FFVII.
I say it's either astro bot ,wu Kong, or metaphor
Metaphor hopefully
No. Let's not pretend it'll be anything other than Shadow of the Erdtree. That and Wukong being here are...relatively obvious...cases of Keighley putting his thumb on the scale. He'll crow til the cows come home otherwise, but Phantom Liberty, rightly, only got an ongoing game nomination last year, and the same should have happened for Shadow of the Erdtree. What changed? Keighley, horrified, staring down the barrel of a scenario he would detest. "If I DON'T influence the jury? A JRPG is going to win GOTY! 4 JRPGs are going to be nominated! That just won't do!" And, if it were just Shadow of the Erdtree and the other game he pushed the jury toward was plausibly well reviewed (85 or higher, like Silent Hill 2 or Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown), that'd still be semi-suspicious, but not sloppy in the level of greasiness. And that sloppiness is mostly why I HATE this.
At least Black Myth Wukong got some recognition but Shadow Of The ErdTree getting nominated in GOTY is wild even though it's great still they need to create their category as DOTY ( DLC Of The Year ) hopefully BMW wins it
Nobody cares Charlie sucks lmfao☠️☠️🙋🏻♂️🍗🇩🇪
they did the same with Cyberpunk last year too
Black Myth Wukong got recognition for the same reason as Shadow Of The ErdTree. They are popular but there were better games to include.
Didn't have much games to begin with
Nah elden ring is just goated cope 😂
STELLAR BLADE AND WARHAMMER 40K SPACE MARINE 2 WERE ROBBED
Space marine was mid stop the cap, it's not near game of the year
Especially stellar blade, that game is literally near perfect lol
@@N.Chrysaliastory and writing was ass
@@battlefuta9953 true
Nah, both mid. Stellar Blade is just a downgraded Nier:Automata with better GFX and worse gameplay.
I’m glad to see Stellar Blade getting some recognition
My soul for Metaphor winning as much as possible
I need metaphor to win
I'm just happy it got so many nominations. It's my personal GoTY too
Never heard of it till today
If it doesn't win game of the year it better win best art and music
it’s just another persona reskin
Nobody cares Charlie sucks lmfao
If elden ring dlc is game of the year idk what to say
I mean it’s better than the other options 🤷♂️
It is, but imo GOTY should always go to a fully new product. I don’t know why it wasn’t nominated for best ongoing.
I think it is good enough to be GOTY but that’s just my opinion :)
@@fluffly8935 did you even play any of the others
@@fluffly8935no, its not. And it really looks like you didnt play other nominees.
The picture they used for Caseoh 💀
Sonic getting the soundtrack robbed again
Don't forget black myth wukong there. What a joke
Shadow of the Erdtree being nominated is a joke
A dlc is fundamentally not a game because you cannot play it by itself. If it wins GOTY this award show will lose any remaining credibility.
It should have not gotten nominations in general.
There are exceptions to that like Xenoblade 2's dlc (Torna: The Golden Country) but yeah, for most cases that is true and I agree it shouldn't be nominated
Exactly why is this not common knowledge, a lot of ER fans are saying it’s deserved and other nominations are jokes are either too short which is a lie either they’re lying to justify their DLC being in the a wrong category or just plain dumb and still didn’t play it, this is making me despise some from soft fans
TGA just opened its official account on Chinese social media platform days ago, i guess BMW will win something
No Lethal company mention has me feeling a way
I can’t wait for the VGA orchestra to play the BGM for Balatro 😂
No Nine Sols for best indie is ridiculous. I dont have any respect for TGA from now on. AND they literally put DS2 for most anticipated and NOT Doom?? That is some criminal sh1t.
Between Metroid and GTA I don’t think Doom would get close to winning even if it was nominated.
@@paulbrown9328 GTA, yes. Metroid? no. Doom have always been bigger than Metroid both production and the fanbase wise.
Not to mention, SilkSong not being anticipated.
@@joutakujo9773silksong has been there for YEARS I think they made a intentional decision to leave it out this time
P3R, palworld and shadow gens not getting anything is kinda crazy
Personal take?
Yes, there aren't enough distinct DLCs to have a DLC category. But Phantom Liberty in Ongoing Game made sense, and that's the ONLY place where Shadow of the Erdtree should have been, and the only reason it ISN'T is because Geoff would have otherwise been staring down the barrel of a JRPG winning Game of the Year. I know this sounds kinda limiting/soulless, but two rules I would institute at The Game Awards for GOTY and any genre or technical category? 1. An 85 Metacritic Score Minimum for a GOTY nom. 2. A DLC pack released outside the game's original eligibility window is ineligible.
A DLC over fucking Stellar Blade and Silent Hill 2 (and heck even Nine Sols) is absolute bullshit. We already know what GOTY is gonna be just because of that dumb stunt. Screw this event man. I already know neither FFVII nor Black Myth Wukong, my personal faves, are not gonna win because of this either.
STALKER 2
Astro bot is going to sweep. I'm just being realistic.
At this point they should just nominate a console to win GOTY
Dragon age is win EVERY SINGLE award.
It's fixed
It's rigid
I didn’t see it in any of the nominations
Nin Sols hasnt even come out on console yet, I bet that affects it
Idk why they don't just have dlc in its own category. So many good games snubbed just to put in elden ring.
How many dlcs get released a year to make an entire category for it every year? Also it doesn't seem like there were that many games snubbed, since one of the other goty nominees is a remake
They do it's called best ongoing game phantom liberty won that category last year I think
@@kei7540 I think that should for games that receive constant content updates, not for a game that got a dlc 2 years later
@@cowhale2488doesn’t matter it’s a fucking DLC which should be in DLC category regardless
The day warframe gets a “best ongoing” nomination over destiny is the day I can finally die a happy man
DLC should not be up there, you can't play DLC without getting the base/actual game itself.
God let SoTE win Game of the year, It will be so fucking funny.
Wtf Balatro GOTY nominee. If it wins it'd be the funniest shit ever.
Palworld was mid
This one finna be tough💀
So which game won? The trash or the garbage?
Charlie voting for a game he hasnt played lol
Elden Ring even being up for nomination is such bullshit. It isn’t a full game, the other games don’t deserve to be up against it
So true brother I love that DLC and game but it’s not right
Only dlc that should’ve been nominated was I guess iceborne or old hunters due to how quality that was but otherwise I don’t think sote deserves a win
You can't play Shadow without playing ER ... Geoff getting pocketed by fromsoft now?
Caseoh and UFO 50 are the only W nominations here. I would replace Destiny 2 with World of Warcraft for the best ongoing game
If the Japanese hear about the Game awards Pekora could win CCOTY She is MASSIVE in Japan.
Why isn't Concord nominated for game of the year?
Until Dawn Remake should've been nominated for something. That game was peak.
The scratching noises at the start were lowkey pissin me off
I'm really hoping metaphor can take it home and win it all personally
I dont understand why people are surprised DLC's are in the nominees, they did the same year last year with Cyberpunk lol
@@DR.TheLaw they did not lol
Expansion and DLC's are different. I still dont think they should count as well.
People just do won't a dlc in the goty category
Because it’s a DLC nominated for Game of The Year….Game of the Year is for brand new games not an already made game with DLC. Should really just be it’s own category. Do I have to break it down any further DR?
Elden ring sweep 🔥
Elden ring is definitely not going to sweep.
@@paulbrown9328let’s see
Hellblade 2, Space Marine 2, Hades 2, Helldivers 2 !!?!?!?
Saying Remake is better than Rebirth is crazy
They did that with last of us last year at best soundtrack if im correct
Yea, idk. There actually isn't anything about remake better than Rbeirth besides maybe a story because remake takes place in a very solid location (Midgar) while Rebirth is just the middle adventure section of the original and is just about exploring
@@samsunggamer6661there’s less padding in remake and u can make and u can make an argument that the combat was better balanced
Charlie didn’t even finish rebirth because it’s was too long or whatever but his brain is probably fried from speedrunning every game he touches but can’t really do that with rebirth
Silent Hill 2 got robbed
Of what category?
Wukong gives me hope for a Asuras Wrath remake.
Auras wrath doesn’t need a remake just play the OG.
Their 'pannel' is a joke. Corporations that hate gamers get 90% of the vote. Viewers vote total to 10%.
Viewer percentage needs to be way higher
Lol bro is itchy in the morning 😮
Starwars outlaws made it but SxS Generations didn’t cant believe that
Pretty balanced nominees unlike last year 😂
Idk last year was definitely much stronger for gaming imo
DLC being a "game of this year" at all is ludicrous
How did Star Wars outlaws get any categories 😭😂
No mouthwashing? Well, it's been nice knowing you lads
The fact that sonic x shadow generations isnt in best community support or action game is just a fucking joke. Heck, not even game of year. Thats a damn joke. IT ISNT ANYWHERE
Bro where was i at when this happen
Timestamp because I am constructive on the Internet.
1:04:21
I’m voting for Wuthering Waves
The Quarry was a bad ass game!!
That would be so lame if elden ring wins again no matter how good the expansion is. It's an expansion, not a separate game, so it shouldn't be eligible for GAME of the year
Concord shortest game of the year
Also Did Charlie even beat Black Myth Wukong's secret boss??
For those who know who the secret boss is, don't spoil it though. You don't wanna break the surprise there
Rebirth has got to win. It’s too good for it not to win
Astro bot is winning GOTY mark my words
I don’t get why Astrobot wasn’t in best family game
1:10:21
It literally was though
It was
Absolutely ridiculous that Helldivers 2 didn't get goty nomination
Its to manly for them
it fell off toward the latter half of the year, if they managed to keep the momenteum post release then the nomination could have been justified
GTA 6 is gonna win game awards before GTA 6 comes out
Remakes being nominated for best narrative kind of whack ngl
They did it, vanguard is not goty
rebirth rebirth rebirth rebirth rebirth rebirth rebirth
Does anyone want astro bot to win other then me ??
maybe by next year you will learn to balance sound...damn payful most times
Guess we'll be back in 2026 since we already know gta 6 will win goty 2025
Wait no CONCORD!?!
Sad bill clinton guy didn’t make it this time
Might as well make history and vote for elden ring again , be the craziest thing ever
What’s with the crazy disrespect to rebirth from you. Amazing game
Pekora jumpscare
You know this show isn't for gamers right? Its for gaming journos. It should be avoided like its radioactive.
Will astrobot be Playstation's mascot?
Nine Sols got robbed
dragon dogma 2? hello?
At least its in rpg, but it could take outlaws' spot in Action adventure, or maybe find a spot in Music
That game was so mid
LETS GOOO REBIRTHHH
If 1 percent of the Chinese audience vote, BMW wins easily
Until Then was robbed.
most i could hear is your voice and keyboard/mouse....video sound barely there
Theres no warhammer 40k the new one
I know Charlie doesn't want to hear this but Wukong has no chance of winning GOTY lol i think it'll go to either Metaphor or SOTE
ill be honest, I love metaphor to hell and back, but being real, its either BMW or SOTE
@@buletincuadelin5690 FF7 and astro bot have a strong chance too
Highly doubt this. Especially if the Chinese community vote. Which they will.
Dragon Age is going to win lmao. Did people forget about the TLAU2 fiasco?
@buletincuadelin5690 BMW has no shot. The award ain't gonna go to a game rated 81 on metacritic. Remember, critics are the jury. If it was a popularity contest, totk would've won last year.
No persona 3 reload?!
REBIRTH REBIRTH
This game awards is truely a shit show
Can someone explain to this old fogee what exactly is appealing about caseoh.... like ive gone on his stream a few times and hes just boring as piss, so I feel like Skinner here wondering if its me or the kids that are wrong?
Everyone is so mad about Shadow being nominated but I think it is big enough to effectively be a stand alone game. I think its similar to GTA IV’s Ballad of Gay Tony and The Lost and Damned, yes they were expansion packs but if you’re being honest with yourself those might as well have been stand alone games. And you can’t expect there to be a stand alone DLC category because there are not enough major DLC’s each year to justify it. So, in short, quit complaining, it is what it is
I disagree there are lots of DLC it doesn’t have to be for a major game just ones semi relevant. Plus more if you count more than just story DLC.
Why is this shit not loading properly?
Everyone is on it