Is Mawlid Permitted? | Panel Discussion | Islam Answers
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- A panel discussion on Mawlid with Shaykh Noorud-deen Rashid, Shaykh Mohammed Jamili, Dr. Abdul Wahid, Shaykh Omar Hajjaj, and Mowlana Thaqib Mahmood.
🌐 islamanswers.c...
📧 info@islamanswers.co.uk
🪣 Support the Dawah:
islamanswers.c...
Timestamp:
Related Answers:
📱Follow Islam Answers:
▸ Facebook: / islamanswers20
▸ Instagram: / islamanswers.co.uk
▸ TikTok: / islamanswers1
▸ Twitter: / islamanswers20
This is what true unity looks. Respecting difference of opinion amd focussing on the Prophet peace be upon him
Brelvis will call it sula kulli and continue tp defend blasphemy against the Prophet peace be upon him.
Molana Thaqib Mahmood made 100% sense in his open statement
Mawlid Mubarak to all the Ashiq e Rasul
Great panel discussion.
Masha Allaah, we need this brotherhood and respect. Jasaaka Allaah khayr
I celebrate Mawlid but Molana Thaqib's opening statement was absolutely spot on when talking about we should celebrate Mawlid daily by keeping to the sunnah!
Great idea we need more comming together of different groups like this
lies
@@MBeats27I dealt with you in another video comments.
You brelvi deal with the blasphemy of the brelvis before you speak about this
Your hero Asrar Rashid is silent about blasphemy and running away from sh Nurudin
@@navoxford8406 deal with your mum
@@MBeats27there you go the teachings of Asrar Rashid are being shown
What expect from brelvis.
This guy started his comments pretending to be concerned about the Prophet peace be upon him
Didn't take long for him to take off his mask
@@navoxford8406 your mum taught me
The most important celebration is following the sunnah no doubt. However that IS NOT A PROOF against the mawlid.
The best way to celebrate the birth of the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam is to fast on a Monday.
If we were to spend the 12th of Rabi al Awwal in remembering the death, we would be sad all the time and resemble shia people.
Whoever says "You must do the mawlid" is doing a bid'a.
Very good discussion
The first 3 generations didn't celebrate the birthday that's the benchmark
Who has set that benchmark
@@hasibkhan4451 the Prophet SAW,
yep جزاك الله خيرا
Abdullah ibn Mas’ud reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The best people are those of my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them. Then, there will come people after them whose testimony precedes their oaths and their oaths precede their testimony.”
You cannot argue with Zionists!
Alhamdulillah the prophet peace be upon him was not disrespected that's what is the most important
Brelvis are forced to have such low standards. If they watch a video without blasphemy they are happy.
This is because their teachers inult the Prophet peace be upon him
@@navoxford8406 the whole video was about not disrespecting the prophet and loving him that is the highest standard. You wahabis have the lowest standard because you can't go a day without disrespecting him
@@navoxford8406 no people are sick of salafi's disrespecting the prophet every chance they get
@@MBeats27it is not the Wahabis who praised insults against the Prophet peace be upon him
It was Asrar Rashids student. And when sh Nurudin asked Asrar to meet to discuss it he cancelled his class and ran away
@@MBeats27Brelvis are even worse than wahabis
Hasan the brelvi insults the Prophet peace be upon him and all brelvis are silent.
Including their lion Asrar Rashid who is busy running away from sh Nurudin
More unity talks please we need to get rid of all these sects especially brelvis and madkhalis. These two are the worst ones
What an idiot
@@activemeasures6251yes the Madkhalis and Brelvis are idiots. Why would you want to divide the Ummah like they do.
The Prophet sallaAllahu alayhi wa sallam himself did not celebrate, Sahaba did not celebrate, the rightly guided khalifs did not celebrate, the four imams did not celebrate. What if some Ulama have permitted? There also other Ulama who said it's not permitted. An alim should express his opinion/ijtidad with proofs from Quran and Sunnah otherwise we can not say that this ijtihad/opiion is a proof by itself. And yes, Mawlid is not a simple gathering, it's like and Eid but in Islam we have only two eids. That's it. Prophet used to fast every Monday and Thursday. This is the Sunnah.
Mawlid is harm none of the sahaba celebrated it. It's a intervention introduced by Shia sect
Harm😅
While the discourse presented was insightful, it neglected a pivotal aspect underpinning the concept of bid'ah (innovation) in Islamic jurisprudence. It is crucial to discern that not all forms of bid'ah are deemed impermissible; a nuanced understanding is required. The reliance on a hadith whose matn (text) generically employs the term "every" should not be hastily categorised as Qat'i (definitive evidence), given its Dhanni (speculative) nature. Such evidential classification matters profoundly within Sharia, where differentiation in rulings is commonplace. If this distinction were acknowledged, the nature of the discussion would fundamentally shift. The panel, along with a significant portion of the Muslim audience who adhere to a stringent interpretation of Hukum (laws) in Sharia, appears to overlook this critical nuance. This collective oversight propagates the misleading assertion that all bid'ah is unequivocally unacceptable, which starkly diverges from a more considered theological analysis.
Incorporating the critical analysis of evidentiary decisiveness, we must consider two integral aspects:
Qata’iyy ath-Thabut (Decisiveness of Establishment): This refers to evidence that is definitively established, such as the Qur’an and Mutawatir traditions, which are beyond any doubt due to their absolute authenticity and universal acceptance. These sources are devoid of any potential errors, weaknesses, or falsehoods. In stark contrast stands Dhanniyy ath-Thubut, which includes evidence that may be prone to errors or inaccuracies, such as weak narrations.
Qata’iyy ad-Dalalah (Decisiveness of Indication): For evidence to be deemed decisive in this regard, it must conclusively address the topic under discussion, leaving no room for valid alternative interpretations that could negate the derived ruling. An exemplar of such decisive indication is the evidentiary basis for Wudhu (ablution) being a commanded practice within Shari’ah and the understanding that lying about the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) constitutes a graver sin than falsehoods concerning others. Conversely, Dhanniyy ad-Dalalah encompasses evidence that, despite being based on reliable sources, does not conclusively settle an issue due to the presence of various interpretative possibilities or textual variances. A pertinent example of this can be observed in the debate over the method of ablution-specifically the act of wiping over the feet. While the Shi’ah perspective might cite a Qur'anic verse as definitive, the Sunnah adherents favour Hadiths that explicitly advocate for washing the feet, deemed both Qat’iyy ath-Thabut and Qat’iyy ad-Dalalah, thereby reflecting a higher standard of scriptural decisiveness and relevance.
Incorporating these distinctions into our theological discourse not only enriches the debate but also ensures a more rigorous and holistic approach to interpreting Islamic jurisprudence, highlighting the necessity of differentiating between types of evidential certainty in our understanding of bid'ah and broader Shariah laws.
When talking about the origins of Biddah (innovation) is Islam, Imam as al-Sanusi r.a mentioned in his book 'Al Muqaddimat', that one of the main origins of innovation and being misguided is “ignorance in both the rules of logic and the Arabic language”
Are you trying to open up the doors of biddah
Would like to see Shaykh Riyadh Ul Haq and Abu Taymiyyah and others.
I was going to mention this abu Taymiyyah the panel
@@MotorWorld-v8yHe won't do it. He thinks these sheikhs at Ahle biddah
They won't join they are too sectarian
Fea Allah brothers.
Mawlid is considered an act of worship that draws someone closer to Allah by the ones that do it, the sahaba or Rasolullah sallalahu alahi wa salam never celebrated mawlid, innovating an act of worship that wasnt done by the sahaba or Rasolullah sallalahu alahi wa salam is a bidah, therefore celebrating mawlid is a bidah.
The evilest matters in religion are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”
Source: Sunan al-Nasā’ī 1578
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
What are your credentials?
@@ejazkhanahmed908 Why does that mattet akhi?
gaalkacyo
You claim that celebrating the Mawlid is bidah .
My question to you is this:Who gave you the authority for declaring every bidah as haram? You don't even know the basic in Islam and you are giving fatwas.
I suggest you study on the subject of bidah when do do you will learn that a bidah is to introduce something new in Islam that goes against the Quran and Sunnah but who introduce a good practice in Islam earns the reward of it.
I can give you many examples of new innovations in Islam that the Ummah is benefitting from.
Hypocrites who celebrate their own birthdays with such importance but oppose the Mawlid.
@@farookdinaully8029 don't waste your time. The qiyaas and majority agree upon this matter of fiqh so Alhamdu Lillah.
Allahamdollilah many mawlids happening in Luton every week throughout the year. Not just in rabi al awal as one of the brothers implied
Yeah probably by Sufis who fabricate Hadith. What kind of love is that. They lie against the Prophet
Yeah by Sufis who also insult the Prophet peace be upon him. What is the point of such mawlids
Assalamo Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuh Scholars and Sheikhs, is it really necessary to focus on topics that lead to debates and divisions within the Muslim Ummah, instead of uniting us? Given the current state of the world, where our brothers and sisters are oppressed, our disunity and inaction only contribute to their suffering. For the sake Allah and His messenger please stop this non sense and work towards uniting Ummah and prepare us well for the day to come ...😢
You obviously have not listened to the video. Why comment if you don't know what it is about
@@TrueSunni I agreed and apologized that didn't listen the video but commented seeing the caption or topic of the video. Brother several videos on this topic available in RUclips but very limited people talk about how to tackle Islamophobia, oppression and injustice happening all around 🙄
@@protestagainst-injustice-lieThis channel has done all of that
Only the ones that have love will celebrate the coming of the one loves. Period. Do halal celebrations. Today the Ummah needs this day more than before.
Wrong the brelvis celebrate mawlid but they also defend blasphemy against the Prophet
Mawlid alone is not enough
Shamshi destroyed this man in speakers corner , but still stuborn
"Destroyed this man" and then proceeded to run off?
Cope is real 😂
@@manbetterunderstand when you explain somone something clear based on the quran and sunnah and they only want to create doubts make the doubts clear and obstain from further conversation with that person
@@monirbumanjal2868 explain something clear? More like got agitated and started shouting and then called it being a "real man". He couldn't handle the heat so he left. Then he went home and started making videos about it and saying he had a bad back and was being pushed. Get a grip.
Madkhalis can't stop lying. Shamsi ran away and then refused to have a real debate afterwards.
If Shamsi ever had a real debate or discussion with someone then his ignorance and misguidance would be shown, that's why he does not do it.
You Shamsi fans have been copin since that day
@@monirbumanjal2868clear based on Quran and Sunnah? What a joke he accused the Sahabi Ibn Abbas of being misguided and then ran away.
That's why he will never debate sh Nurudin properly.
Shamsi fans are deluded